Estrogen receptor interaction with immobilized metals: differential molecular recognition of Zn2+, Cu2+ and Ni2+ and separation of receptor isoforms

We have utilized iminodiacetate (IDA) gels with immobilized Zn2+, Cu2+ and Ni2+ ions to evaluate the metal binding properties of uterine estrogen receptor proteins. Soluble (cytosol) receptors labeled with [3H]estradiol were analyzed by immobilized metal affinity chromatography (IMAC) before as well as after (1) 3 M urea-induced transformation to the DNA-binding form, and (2) limited trypsin digestion to separate the steroid- and DNA-binding domains. Imidazole (2-200 mM) affinity elution and pH-dependent (pH 7-3.6) elution techniques were both evaluated and found to resolve several receptor isoforms differentially in both the presence and absence of 3 M urea. Individual receptor forms exhibited various affinities for immobilized Zn2+, Cu2+ and Ni2+ ions, but all intact receptor forms were strongly adsorbed to each of the immobilized metals (Ni2+ greater than Cu2+ much greater than Zn2+) at neutral pH. Generally, similar results were obtained with IDA-Cu2+ and IDA-Ni2+ in the absence of urea. Receptors were tightly bound and not eluted before 100 mM imidazole or pH 3.6. Different results were obtained using IDA-Zn2+; at least four receptor isoforms were resolved on IDA-Zn2+. Receptor-metal interaction heterogeneity and affinity for IDA-Zn2+ and IDA-Cu2+, but not IDA-Ni2+, were substantially decreased in the presence of 3 M urea. The receptor isoforms identified and separated by IDA-Zn2+ chromatography were not separable using high-performance size-exclusion chromatography, density gradient centrifugation, chromatofocusing or DNA-affinity chromatography. The affinity of trypsin-generated (mero)receptor forms for each of the immobilized metals was decreased relative to that of intact receptor. High-affinity metal-binding sites were mapped to the DNA-binding domain, but at least one of the metal-binding sites is located on the steroid-binding domain. Recovery of all receptor forms from the immobilized metal ion columns was routinely above 90%. These results demonstrate the differential utility of various immobilized metals to characterize and separate individual receptor isoforms and domain structures. Receptor-metal interactions warrant further investigation to establish their effects on receptor structure/function relationships. In addition to the biological implications, recognition of estrogen receptor proteins as metal-binding proteins suggests new and potentially powerful receptor immobilization and purification regimes previously unexplored by those in this field.     

Evaluation of the interaction of peptides with Cu(II), Ni(II), and Zn(II) by high-performance immobilized metal ion affinity chromatography

High-performance immobilized metal ion affinity chromatography was utilized to evaluate the adsorption properties of 67 synthetic, biologically active, peptides ranging in size from 5 to 42 residues. The metal ions, Cu(II), Ni(II) and Zn(II), were immobilized by iminodiacetic acid (IDA) coupled to TSK gel 5PW (10 microns). Two types of gradient elution (imidazole and pH) were used to evaluate peptide retention by the metal ions. A decreasing pH gradient and an increasing imidazole gradient eluted the peptides in similar order. IDA-Cu(II) and IDA-Zn(II) showed very similar selectivities for the peptides analyzed; however, IDA-Zn(II) displayed a weaker affinity for the peptides. IDA-Ni(II) showed a slightly different pattern of selectivity. Peptide adsorption effects contributed by the metal-free gel matrix were found to be relatively minor. The concentration and type of salt included in the mobile phase could affect the relative affinities of the peptides for the immobilized metal ions. Retention coefficients were assigned to individual amino acid residues by multiple linear regression analysis. Histidine showed the largest positive correlation with retention, followed by aromatic amino acid residues. Modified N-terminal residues resulted in negative contributions to retention. Analyses of peptide amino acid composition alone allowed prediction of peptide retention behavior on immobilized metal ion affinity columns.     

Purification of recombinant enhanced green fluorescent protein expressed in Escherichia coli with new immobilized metal ion affinity magnetic absorbents

A new immobilized metal ion affinity (IMA) adsorbent containing superparamagnetic nanoparticles and coated with hydrophilic resins are proposed here to improve the purification of His-tagged proteins. The magnetic chelating resin was prepared by radical polymerization of magnetite (Fe3O4), styrene, divinyl benzene (DVB) and glycidyl methacrylate-iminodiacetic acid (GMA-IDA) in ethanol/water medium. IDA is immobilized on magnetite as a ligand and pre-charged Cu2+, Zn2+ and Ni2+ as metal ions. To identify the GMA-IDA magnetic particles easily, we named these particles MPGI. The MPGI adsorbent was used to test their suitability for the direct recovery of an intracellular, polyhistidine-tagged protein, enhanced green fluorescent protein [EGFP-(His)(6)], from Escherichia coli lysates in a single step. Parameters influencing the purification efficiencies such as pH, ionic strength and imidazole concentration were optimized to achieve improved separation. The optimal selectively was observed in binding buffer (0.2M NaCl, 0.02M imidazole), washing buffer (0.4M NaCl, 0.03 M imidazole) and elution buffer (0.50M imidazole). The Cu2+-charged MPGI adsorbent had the highest yield and purification factor at 70.4% and 12.3, respectively. The calculated isotherm parameters (Q(m)=53.5 mg/g, K(d)=5.84 mg/mL and Q(m)/K(d)=9.2 mL/g) indicated that the MPGI adsorbent could be used as a suitable adsorbent for EGFP from an aqueous solution.     

High-performance immobilized metal ion affinity chromatography of peptides: analytical separation of biologically active synthetic peptides

The separation of more than 30 biologically active synthetic peptides and their analogs on a high-performance immobilized metal ion affinity chromatography column is described. The metal chelating gel (TSK gel chelate-5PW) contains iminodiacetic acid (IDA) covalently coupled to a hydrophilic, resin-based matrix with a bead diameter of 10 micron. The retention of the peptides on Cu(II), Ni(II), and Zn(II) ions immobilized on the chelating gel showed that some of them can be separated by isocratic elution while the majority of them are retained and are separated into distinct fractions by elution with a linear imidazole gradient or with a continuously decreasing pH gradient. Of the three immobilized metal ions investigated here, the IDA-Cu(II) chelate column gave the best resolution irrespective of the type of gradient used. This is amply illustrated by the resolution of angiotensins I and II and their seven synthetic analogs. The results obtained here serve as guidelines for the future exploitation of this separation method for the efficient fractionation of a wide variety of peptides on an analytical or preparative scale.     

A single-step chromatographic method for the purification of proteins devoid of exposed histidine residues

The principle of the immobilized metal affinity chromatography (IMAC) is based on the differences in the affinity of proteins for metal ions bound in a 1:1 complex of iminodiacetic acid (IDA) immobilized on a chromatographic support. A single step purification was carried out for luteinizing hormone (LH) on Cu2+, Zn2+, Ni2+, and Co2+ IDA Sepharose affinity columns. Highly purified LH was obtained with a Cu2+ IDA Sepharose column. SDS-PAGE and Western blot analysis were done to confirm the purity of the hormone. Biological activity has been evaluated by radio-immunoassay. This method was found economically viable and suitable for the recovery of biologically active hormone.     

Design of affinity tags for one-step protein purification from immobilized zinc columns

Affinity tags are often used to accomplish recombinant protein purification using immobilized metal affinity chromatography. Success of the tag depends on the chelated metal used and the elution profile of the host cell proteins. Zn(II)-iminodiacetic acid (Zn(II)-IDA) may prove to be superior to either immobilized copper or nickel as a result of its relatively low binding affinity for cellular proteins. For example, almost all Escherichia coli proteins elute from Zn(II)-IDA columns between pH 7.5 and 7.0 with very little cellular protein emerging at pH values lower than 7.0. Thus, a large portion of the Zn(II)-IDA elution profile may be free of contaminant proteins, which can be exploited for one-step purification of a target protein from raw cell extract. In this paper we have identified several fusion tags that can direct the elution of the target protein to the low background region of the Zn(II)-IDA elution profile. These tags allow targeting of proteins to different regions of the elution profile, facilitating purification under mild conditions.     

Resolution of three forms of superoxide dismutase by immobilised metal affinity chromatography

A new method for separation of three forms of superoxide dismutase (SOD) using immobilised metal affinity chromatography (IMAC) is reported. Fe-, Mn- and Cu/Zn-SODs were eluted sequentially from Cu²⁺-IMAC column with an increasing gradient of a counter ion (NH⁺₄) run in combination with an increasing pH gradient (6.8–7.8). The combined gradient elution method resulted in separation of SODs with high resolution, the three proteins being eluted in electrophoretically homogeneous forms. Similar preparation could not be achieved by either increasing gradient of a counter ion or decreasing pH gradients used separately. The described methodology has been successfully applied for separation of three SODs from a protozoan parasite, indicating that this combined gradient elution system for IMAC offers new possibilities for the high-resolution separation of proteins exhibiting only minor differences in their amino acid composition and structure.     

Protein interactions with immobilized transition metal ions: quantitative evaluations of variations in affinity and binding capacity

The interaction of proteins with immobilized transition-metal ions proceeds via mechanisms influenced by metal type and degree of coordination, variations in mobile phase constituents, and protein surface architecture at or near the metal binding site(s). The contributions each of these variables make toward the affinity of protein surfaces for immobilized metal ions remain empirical. We have used equilibrium binding analyses to evaluate the influence of pH and competitive binding reagents on the apparent equilibrium dissociation constant (Kd) and binding capacity of immobilized Cu(II) and Ni(II) ions for several model proteins of known three-dimensional structure. Linear Scatchard plots suggested that 8/13 of the proteins evaluated interacted with immobilized metal ions via a single class of operational (Kd = 10-700 microM) binding sites. Those proteins with the highest affinities for the immobilized Cu(II) ions (5/13) showed evidence of multiple, non-identical or nonindependent binding sites. The effects of altered metal type, pH, and concentration of competitive affinity reagents (e.g., imidazole, free metal ions) on the apparent Kd and binding capacity varied in magnitude for individual proteins. The presence of free Cu(II) ions did not detectably alter either the affinity or binding capacity of the proteins for immobilized Cu(II) ions. The expected relationship between the relative chromatographic elution sequence and calculated affinity constants was not entirely evident by evaluation under only one set of conditions. Our results demonstrate the utility of nonchromatographic equilibrium binding analyses for the quantitative evaluation of experimental variables affecting the relative affinity and capacity of immobilized metal ions for proteins. This approach affords the opportunity to improve understanding and to vary the contribution of interaction mechanisms involved.     

Interaction of metal ions with lupin seed conglutin gamma

Various metal ions were capable of aggregating and precipitating conglutin gamma, an oligomeric glycoprotein purified from Lupinus albus seeds, at neutral pH values. The most effective metal ions, at 60-fold molar excess to the protein, were Zn2+, Hg2+ and Cu2+; a lower influence on the physical status of conglutin gamma was observed with Cr3+, Fe3+, Co2+, Ni2+, Cd2+, Sn2+, and Pb2+, while Mg2+, Ca2+ and Mn2+ had no effect at all. The insolubilisation of the protein with Zn2+, which is fully reversible, strictly depended on both metal concentration and pH. with middle points of the sharp transitions at three-fold molar excess and pH 6.5, respectively. Conglutin gamma is also fully retained on a metal affinity chromatography column at which Zn2+ and Ni2+ were complexed. A drop of pH below 6.0 and the use of chelating agents, such as EDTA and imidazole, fully desorbed the protein. A slightly lower binding to immobilised Cu2+ and Co2+ and no binding with Mg2+, Cd2+ and Mn2+ were observed. The role of the numerous histidine residues of conglutin gamma in the binding of Zn2+ is discussed.     

重组人Fab金属螯合层析法纯化条件的研究

在重组人Fab(rh Fab)表达载体的羧基端插入六个组氨酸, 使其对金属螯合层析介质产生特异性吸附, 可用金属螯合亲和层析法进行分离纯化. 采用自制金属(铜、锌金属离子)螯合层析介质, 以pH和咪唑两种洗脱方法,对rh Fab段的纯化效果进行了探讨. 结果显示: 铜离子螯合层析介质比锌离子螯合层析介质对rh Fab的亲和能力更强; pH洗脱方法的重复性优于咪唑法; 金属铜离子螯合层析法对rh Fab进行一步纯化可得到纯度大于95%的rh Fab产品.     

Dye-ligand and immobilized metal ion interaction chromatography for the purification of enzymes of prenyl pyrophosphate metabolism.

Dye-ligand and immobilized metal ion interaction chromatography were shown to be efficient techniques for the rapid batchwise fractionation, from crude plant extracts, of a series of enzymes of prenyl pyrophosphate metabolism. Isopentenyl pyrophosphate isomerase, two prenyltransferases, and a number of terpene cyclases (synthases) were readily adsorbed to Matrex Gel Red A (a dimeric triazine dye coupled to cross-linked agarose beads), and desorbed in good yield with relatively high concentrations of KCl and increasing pH. Although all of these enzymes exhibit the common feature of employing a pyrophosphorylated substrate, selective elution could not be achieved with substrate or substrate analogues bearing a pyrophosphate function. Nor could the strong binding of these enzymes to triazine dyes be attributed solely to metal ion interactions or to hydrophobic effects. In a similar way, the isomerase, the prenyltransferases, and all of the terpene cyclases bound to a column of iminodiacetate-immobilized Ni(II) and were desorbed in relatively high fold purity with 15 mM imidazole. Although all of these enzymes bear accessible histidine residues, the interactions with the chelated metal ion were not sufficiently different to permit selective enzyme desorbtion by imidazole gradient elution. However, the use of columns charged with Zn(II) or Co(II) did allow some separation of the different cyclase and transferase types. While empirical in nature, these techniques offer simple, effective, and high-capacity methods for the preliminary concentration and purification of a group of enzymes that utilize prenyl pyrophosphate intermediates of isoprenoid biosynthesis.     

Chelating peptide-immobilized metal ion affinity chromatography. A new concept in affinity chromatography for recombinant proteins

We report our experimental results supporting the hypothesis that a specific metal-chelating peptide (CP) on the NH2 terminus of a protein can be used to purify that protein using immobilized metal ion affinity chromatography (IMAC). The potential utility of this approach resides with recombinant proteins since the nucleotide sequence that codes for the protein can be extended to include codons for the chelating peptide and thereby generate the gene for a chimeric CP-protein that can be cloned, expressed, and affinity-purified with immobilized metal ions. The chelating peptide purification handle could then be removed chemically or enzymatically after purification has been achieved to generate a protein with the natural amino acid sequence. The feasibility of using a chelating peptide as a purification handle has been demonstrated using a leuteinizing hormone-releasing hormone (LHRH) analog, 2-10 LHRH, which contains the previously identified chelating peptide, His-Trp, on the NH2 terminus. 2-10 LHRH had a high affinity for a Ni(II) IMAC column due to the NH2-terminal dipeptide sequence His-Trp, forming a coordination complex with Ni(II), whereas the controls, 3-10 LHRH and 4-10 LHRH, lacking the CP sequence, did not bind. Furthermore, 2-10 LHRH could be purified from a mixture of histidine-containing peptides on a Ni(II) IMAC column in one step. His-Trp proinsulin was used as a model of a recombinant CP-protein. The S-sulfonates of His-Trp-proinsulin and proinsulin were isolated from Escherichia coli engineered to overproduce these proteins as trpLE' fusion proteins. His-Trp-proinsulin(SSO3-)6 had a higher affinity for immobilized Ni(II) than proinsulin (SSO3-)6. Both proteins were eluted by decreasing the pH or by introducing a displacing ligand into the buffer. Ni(II) eluted from the column with much higher concentrations of displacing ligand than the proteins.     

Metal chelate affinity chromatography of Zn2+-inhibited protein Tyr(P) phosphatases

Metal chelate affinity chromatography using Zn2+-iminodiacetate agarose is shown to provide quantitative recoveries of Zn2+-inhibited protein Tyr(P) phosphatases. To elute adsorbed enzymes from immobilized Zn2+ three methods were compared: (1) removal of Zn2+ with chelators such as EDTA, (2) introduction of ligands to compete with enzyme for Zn2+ and (3) lowering pH to protonate sidechains in the enzyme that serve as ligands to Zn2+. Results show highest yields but poor purification for method 1, high purification but poor yields of active enzyme for method 3. It is concluded that gradients of competing Zn2+ ligands, such as imidazole, provide the best strategy for the purification of enzymes with retention of activity using metal chelate affinity chromatography.     

Chromatographic separations of serum proteins on immobilized metal ion stationary phases

The separation of proteins on stationary phases consisting of a bound organic chelator and a chelated divalent transition metal has been studied as a function of (A) metal ion species; (B) mobile phase composition and pH; and (C) anion and cation concentration. Optimum separation was observed at alkaline pH on chelated nickel stationary phases. Ammonium and Tris salts reduced the affinity of the metal chelate packing for serum proteins. Halide ions caused the proteins to be more strongly bound to the stationary phase. High salt concentrations had only a small effect on the binding of serum proteins in the absence of amine containing buffers or salts. It was also observed that the ease of elution and the recovery of protein were dependent on pH and upon the presence of halides. The general order of elution of serum proteins, based on isoelectric focusing, was independent of metal ion species and elution conditions, suggesting that a single mechanism or a unique sequence of mechanisms was operative. The results suggest that ligand exchange is the major mechanism of separation under basic conditions and that hydrophobic effects are the result of the competition of nonnitrogen ions with ammonium ions or amines for ligand binding sites modifying or participating in protein binding. Protein binding studies under weak acidic conditions are also presented although the mechanism responsible for protein binding is unclear.     

Affinity purification of Csk protein tyrosine kinase based on its catalytic requirement for divalent metal cations

Protein tyrosine kinase Csk requires two Mg2+ ions for activity: one magnesium is part of the ATP-Mg complex, and the second free Mg2+ ion is required as an essential activator. Zn2+ can bind to this site to replace Mg2+, which inhibits Csk kinase activity. The binding is reversible and removal of Zn2+ results in an active Csk apoenzyme. In this communication, we report that this tight binding can be used as a mechanism for affinity purification of Csk. When bacterial cell lysate containing overexpressed GST-Csk was applied to a column of Zn2+-iminodiacetic acid immobilized to agarose, Csk was specifically retained by the column. Since the binding of Csk to Zn2+ is not affected by up to 200 mM NaCl, high ionic strength conditions were used in the purification procedure, minimizing nonspecific binding due to ionic interactions. Washing the column with 200 mM NaCl and 50 mM imidazole removed virtually all other proteins from the column while Csk remained bound. The retained Csk enzyme was eluted with 1 M imidazole. The 1 M imidazole-eluted fraction contained pure Csk that had a specific activity similar to the enzyme purified by a glutathione-agarose affinity column.     

Protein selectivity in immobilized metal affinity chromatography based on the surface accessibility of aspartic and glutamic acid residues

The interaction of different species variants of cytochrome c and myoglobin, as well as hen egg white lysozyme, with the hard Lewis metal ions Al³⁺, Ca²⁺, Fe³⁺, and Yb³⁺ and the borderline metal ion Cu²⁺, immobilized to iminodiacetic acid (IDA)-Sepharose CL-4B, has been investigated over the rangepH 5.5–8.0. With appropriately chosen buffer and metal ion conditions, these proteins can be bound to the immobilized M ⁿ +-IDA adsorbents via negatively charged amino acid residues accessible on the protein surface. For example, tuna heart cytochrome c, which lacks surface-accessible histidine residues, readily bound to the Fe³⁺-IDA adsorbent, while the other proteins also showed affinity toward immobilized Fe³⁺-IDA adsorbents when buffers containing 30 mM of imidazole were used. These studies document that protein selectivity can be achieved with hard-metalion immobilized metal ion affinity chromatography (IMAC) systems through the interaction of surfaceexposed aspartic and glutamic acid residues on the protein with the immobilized M ⁿ +-IDA complex. These investigations have also documented that the so-called soft or borderline immobilized metal ions such as the Cu²⁺-IDA adsorbent can also interact with surface-accessible aspartic and glutamic acid residues in a protein-dependent manner. A relationship is evident between the number and extent of clustering of the surfaceaccessible aspartic and glutamic acid residues and protein selectivity with these IMAC systems. The use of elution buffers which contain organic compound modifiers which replicate the carboxyl group moieties of these amino acids on the surface of proteins is also described.Abbreviations IDA iminodiacetic acid - IDA-Mⁿ⁺ iminodiacetic acid chelated to metal ion - IMAC immobilized metal affinity chromatography - DHCC dog heart cytochrome c - HHCC horse heart cytochrome c, THCC, tuna heart cytochrome c - HMYO horse skeletal muscle myoglobin - SMYO sheep skeletal muscle myoglobin - HEWL hen egg white lysozyme     

Vector engineering anomalies: impact on fusion protein purification performance

Recombinant protein purification using IMAC is often carried out by protein fusion to affinity tags. We have identified several tags useful for protein purification on Zn(II)-IDA columns. These tags were fused to the green fluorescent protein (rGFPuv) using the vector pGFPuv distributed by Clontech Lab (Palo Alto, CA) and analyzed for purification on Zn(II)-IDA. Each fusion protein exhibited elution heterogeneity (elution in two distinct pHs) from Zn(II)-IDA columns This led us to believe that two populations of fluorescent proteins were being expressed: one without the tag coeluting with Escherichia coli proteins at pH 7.5 and one bearing the tag eluting at a pH lower than pH 7.5. Assessment of the constructs revealed the possibility of a ribosomal binding site and start codon between the fusion tag and the rGFPuv sequence which might be used as a secondary translation start site. This hypothesis was confirmed by changing the second ATG (methionine) codon to an ACG (threonine) codon. The protein produced from this new construct eluted in a single fraction from a Zn(II)-IDA column. Thus, vector irregularities (along with other possibilities) should be examined when searching for the cause of elution heterogeneity of a target protein.     

Immobilized metal ion affinity chromatography of serum albumins.

The interaction of several serum albumins with chelated (iminodiacetate, IDA) and immobilized (agarose-IDA) metal ions, Co2+, Ni2+, Cu2+ and Zn2+, was studied. There was no retention of human, bovine, porcine, murine and avian albumins on IDA-Zn(II) and IDA-Co(II) columns. However, all albumins studied, i.e., those of: man, cow, pig, dog, rabbit, rat, mouse, chicken and pigeon were retained on IDA-Cu(II) columns, and all except dog albumin were retained also on IDA-Ni(II). The recognition of albumins by chelated and immobilized transition metals seems to be related to an affinity for the imidazole side chains. It is postulated that one to three imidazoles is involved in this interaction, under the employed experimental conditions (pH 7.0; 1 M sodium chloride). There is no evidence for any significant contribution of tryptophan or cysteine (Cys 34) residues to the chromatographic event. The retention of defatted albumin and albumin oligomers (human), on IDA-Cu(II) columns was not significantly different from that of non-defatted albumin or albumin monomer, respectively.     

High-performance liquid chromatography with concanavalin A immobilized by metal interactions on the stationary phase

Concanavalin A (Con A) was immobilized via metal interactions on macroporous, microparticulate silica support having covalently bound iminodiacetic acid functions (IDA-silica) chelated with Cu(II) at the surface. The amount of copper and of Con A in the column could readily be controlled by the conditions used for chelating the metal by IDA-silica and for immobilization of the lectin. The retention behavior of columns packed with the stationary phase did not change under a wide range of elution conditions, indicating no loss of immobilized lectin. However, the Con A proper could readily be removed from the column at pH 3.0 or together with Cu(II) by perfusion with EDTA at neutral pH. Columns containing Con A immobilized by this technique exhibited dual retention behavior for proteins, glycoproteins, and carbohydrates according to the pertinent glycan-lectin or protein-metal interactions. The glycoproteins, peroxidase and alpha 1-acid glycoprotein, were retained by the Con A moiety and eluted with eluents containing competing sugars, whereas the proteins, beta-lactoglobulin, alpha-chymotrypsinogen A, and ribonuclease A and B were retained by the chelated copper and were eluted and separated with eluents containing sodium chloride or borate. Binding constants of glycosides on the immobilized Con A were evaluated chromatographically and found to be one-third to two-thirds those reported in the literature on the basis of experiments in free solution.