The fetal cleft palate: II. Scarless healing after in utero repair of a congenital model.

The role of fetal surgery in the treatment of non-life-threatening congenital anomalies remains a source of much debate. Before such undertakings can be justified, models must be established that closely resemble the respective human anomalies, and the feasibility and safety of these in utero procedures must be demonstrated. The authors recently described and characterized a congenital model of cleft palate in the goat. The present work demonstrates the methodology they developed to successfully repair these congenital cleft palates in utero, and it shows palatal healing and development after repair. A surgically created cleft model was developed for comparative purposes. Palatal shelf closure normally occurs at approximately day 38 of gestation in the caprine species. Six pregnant goats were gavaged twice daily during gestational days 32 to 41 (term, 145 days) with a plant slurry of Nicotiana glauca containing the piperidine alkaloid anabasine; the 12 fetuses had complete congenital clefts of the secondary palate. Repair of the congenital clefts was performed at 85 days of gestation using a modified von Langenbeck technique employing lateral relaxing incisions with elevation and midline approximation of full-thickness, bilateral, mucoperiosteal palatal flaps followed by single-layer closure. Six congenitally clefted fetuses underwent in utero repair, six remained as unrepaired controls. Twelve normal fetuses underwent surgical cleft creation by excision of a 20 x 3 mm full-thickness midline section of the secondary palate extending from the alveolus to the uvula, at 85 days of gestation. Six surgically clefted fetuses underwent concurrent repair of the cleft at that time; six clefted fetuses remained as unrepaired controls. At 2 weeks of age, no congenitally or surgically created clefts repaired in utero demonstrated gross or histologic evidence of scar formation. A slight indentation at the site of repair was the only remaining evidence of a cleft. At 6 months of age, normal palatal architecture, including that of mucosal, muscular, and glandular elements, was seen grossly and histologically. Cross-section through the mid-portion of the repaired congenitally clefted palates demonstrated reconstitution of a bilaminar palate, with distinct oral and nasal mucosal layers, after single-layer repair. In utero cleft palate repair is technically feasible and results in scarless healing of the mucoperiosteum and velum. The present work represents the first in utero repair of a congenital cleft palate model in any species. The use of a congenital cleft palate model that can be consistently reproduced with high predictability and little variation represents the ideal experimental situation. It provides an opportunity to manipulate specific variables, assess the influence of each change on the outcome and, subsequently, extrapolate such findings to the clinical arena with a greater degree of relevance.     

A long-term, controlled-outcome analysis of in utero versus neonatal cleft lip repair using an ovine model.

Successful open repair of a cleft lip in utero has the advantage of scarless wound healing in the fetus. Unfortunately, no long-term outcome studies have been performed to evaluate the efficacy of these repairs. Moreover, no study to date has compared the long-term results of an in utero cleft lip repair to a similar, control-matched, newborn cleft repair. This study was performed to evaluate the 9-month outcome of in utero cleft lip surgery compared with an identical cleft lip repair performed on infant lambs. In utero epithelialized cleft lips were created through an open hysterotomy in sixteen 65-day-old fetal lambs (term = 140 days) using methods described by Longaker et al. Eight of 16 animals underwent subsequent in utero repair of these clefts at 90 days gestational age. The repair of the remaining eight animals was delayed until 1 week postpartum. At 9 months, the animals were analyzed for changes in lip contour and for the degree of scarring by hematoxylin and eosin and Masson's trichrome collagen staining. Two animals in each group died from preterm labor. Of the animals that survived to term, all repaired lips had some degree of abnormality postoperatively. One of six lips repaired in utero dehisced before delivery. Three of six neonatal repairs dehisced in the first postoperative month. In the remaining animals with intact lip repairs, the vertical lip height on the repaired side was an average of 9 to 12 mm shorter than the normal lip in both the in utero and neonatally repaired animals. Phenotypically, the postnatally repaired animals had more lip distortion and visible notching. Histologically, the in utero repair was scarless and the neonatal repairs had scar throughout the entire vertical height of the lip with an associated loss of hair in this region. Maxillary growth was also evaluated. There was no inhibition of maxillary growth in the animals that underwent in utero cleft lip repair. However, in the neonatal repair group, significant maxillary retrusion was evident. Compared with the cleft side of the maxilla, horizontal growth was decreased by 11 percent (p = 0.01). Compared with the intrauterine repair group, there was a 17-percent decrease in horizontal maxillary width (p = 0.01). Straight-line in utero repair of a cleft lip produces a better long-term result in terms of maxillary growth than a similar repair performed postnatally in the ovine model. There was no diminution in maxillary growth in the animals treated in utero. Histologically, in utero repair of clefts was indeed scarless. However, both lip repairs produced lips that were significantly shorter than their contralateral noncleft sides. This degree of lip shortening would require a secondary lip revision, thereby defeating the purpose of performing an intrauterine repair. Comparisons now need to be made between in utero and neonatal repairs using a Millard-type rotation advancement technique before intrauterine treatment can be considered to be more beneficial than our current treatment modalities.     

The influence of lip repair with and without soft-tissue undermining on facial growth in beagles

The present study was designed to test the hypothesis that undermining of the soft tissues on the surface of the maxilla at the time of lip repair in unilateral cleft lip, alveolus, and palate results in more severe craniofacial growth aberrations than lip repair alone. Sixty-seven purebred beagles were used in this experiment. The animals were divided into four groups: two control groups (unoperated and unrepaired) and two experimental groups (lip repair without undermining and lip repair with undermining). Lip pressures were monitored in all groups. Significantly higher lip pressures were observed in animals with soft-tissue undermining. Cephalometric measurements were analyzed using univariate and multivariate techniques. The results of this study indicate that lip repair performed with soft-tissue undermining results in more severe craniofacial growth aberrations than lip repair performed alone.     

In utero cleft lip repair in A/J mice

Reconstructive in utero microsurgery for repair of unilateral cleft lips has been technically achieved in the A/J mouse fetus. The period of gestation was undisturbed, and following birth, the gross and histologic appearance of the lips was nearly normal with no evidence of scar formation. The absence of a lip scar after human cheiloplasty may require the as yet undefined advantages of fetal wound healing.     

The fetal cleft palate: III. Ultrastructural and functional analysis of palatal development following in utero repair of the congenital model

The role of fetal surgery in the management of congenital anomalies and intrauterine abnormalities is appropriately restricted on the basis of feasibility and risk-to-benefit analyses of intrauterine intervention. Recently, the authors demonstrated that in utero cleft palate repair of the congenital caprine model is technically feasible and results in scarless healing of the mucoperiosteum and velum, with subsequent development of a potentially functional bilaminar palate with distinct oral and nasal mucosal layers, following single-layer repair of the fetal mucoperiosteal flaps. A slight indentation at the site of repair was the only remaining evidence of a cleft. At 6 months of age, normal palatal architecture, including that of mucosal, muscular, and glandular elements, was seen grossly and histologically. The present work investigated the ultrastructural and functional aspects of the palate following in utero cleft repair to determine what benefits might be derived from fetal intervention. Six goats pregnant with twins were gavaged twice daily for 10 days (gestational days 32 to 41; term, 145 days) with dry, ground Nicotiana glauca plant delivering between 2.4 and 14 mg/kg per day of anabasine, doses that were adjusted in response to mater-nal toxicity. At 85 days' gestation, six fetuses underwent in utero palatoplasty using a modified von Langenbeck technique with elevation of bilateral mucoperiosteal flaps and lateral relaxing incisions. A single-layer repair of the mucoperiosteal flaps was performed using interrupted 6-0 Vicryl sutures. Six fetuses remained as unrepaired clefted controls. Six months after in utero palatoplasty, each group of goats underwent nasoendoscopy to evaluate palatal function; two unclefted 6-month-old goats served as controls. Subsequently, soft palate muscle was harvested from each of the goats and was evaluated by light and electron microscopy. Velar muscle was also harvested from the unclefted control goats and was similarly studied. Nasoendoscopy demonstrated functional palates capable of dynamic velopharyngeal closure following in utero cleft repair; this motion was similar to that observed in unclefted animals. Unrepaired clefted goats did not demonstrate any evidence of velar motion or velopharyngeal closure. Soft palate muscle from this group demonstrated evidence of myofibril degeneration, atrophy, and loss compared with unclefted control velar muscle. Ultrastructural changes included sarcomere "scalloping, " partial Z-line degeneration and loss, and progressive I-band degeneration and loss. Repaired clefted soft palate muscle was remarkably similar to unclefted control muscle. Significantly less myofibril, Z-line, and I-band degeneration and loss were observed with minimal evidence of sarcomere scalloping. In utero cleft palate repair results in a functional soft palate with restoration of ultrastructural architecture of the velum. These findings were attributed to reconstitution of the velar muscular sling, which is disrupted during the clefting process and remains abnormally inserted into the posterior edge of the palatal bone and along the bony cleft. Although repaired velar muscle does demonstrate some evidence of ultrastructural change compared with control muscle, these findings are significantly less pronounced than those observed in the unrepaired clefted muscle.     

A comparative analysis of healing of surgical cleft lip corrected in utero and neonates.

We studied the healing process in surgically created cleft lips in fetal mice and compared it with that in newborn mice with cleft lips. Our purpose was to determine the time for optimal healing, defined as minimal scarring, for a repaired cleft lip. Full-thickness paramedian lip incisions were made in NMRI mice in utero, in 2- and 4-day-old neonates, and in adults (n = 10 in each experimental and control group). The healing process was studied by biochemical analysis of hyaluronic acid and hydroxyproline content in the repaired cleft tissue. We found that the production of hyaluronic acid remained stable during the healing period and was similar in all experimental groups. However, there was an unexplained but consistent depression in the hyaluronic acid content of fetal tissue 2 days after repair. Hydroxyproline was present in the fetal healing tissue, but in a low concentration, starting 4 days after surgical incision of the lip. The production of hydroxyproline in 2-day-old neonates was similar to that in the fetuses throughout the healing period (p less than 0.0005). However, the production of hydroxyproline increased in 4-day-old neonatal and adult tissues. In conclusion, we found an optimal healing period for mice with minimal collagen production in the late fetal stage, and this lasted 2 days after birth.     

Lip pressure changes following lip repair in infants with unilateral clefts of the lip and palate

The present study was designed to quantitatively assess lip pressure changes following cleft lip repair in infants with unilateral cleft lip, alveolus, and palate. Lip pressure measurements were taken using an electronic transducer system developed especially for this study. Lip pressure was monitored from 3 months (preoperatively) through 2 years of age in cleft and normal control children. Findings from the present study confirm the hypothesis that lip repair in infants with unilateral cleft lip and palate significantly increases lip pressure and that increased lip pressure remains significantly higher than in normal control children for the 2-year duration of the study. Thus increased lip pressure when the palate is unrepaired has to be considered as a factor modulating subsequent craniofacial growth.     

Analysis of the lengthening effect of the muscle repair in functional cleft lip repair

In 14 patients undergoing functional cleft lip repair, changes in the lengths of the key lip segments were measured preoperatively, after the muscle layer was repaired, and after the skin was repaired using pieces of wire bent to follow the curves of the lip in three dimensions. The cleft side of the lip was shorter than the normal side in the vertical and horizontal dimensions. Freeing the muscle from its dermal insertions, splitting it, and advancing it into the medial side of the cleft lengthened the cleft side of the lip vertically and horizontally. The Z-plasty skin repair further lengthened the cleft side of the lip in the vertical dimension. The lengthening effect of the muscle repair appears to be the result of the loose skin redraping over the dissected muscle and further explains elimination of the orbicularis bulge and superior scar formation in the functional cleft lip repair.     

In utero cleft lip repair in the mouse without an incision

In utero cleft lip repairs were done by full-thickness approximation of the cleft edges by 11-0 sutures in the A/J mouse on day 17 of gestation after Dilantin was administered on day 10. On day 20, a cesarean section was performed, the repair inspected, and the lip sectioned for histologic study. One-thousand one-hundred and thirty-nine mice were bred, and surgery was performed on 48. At least one fetus was present that had a cleft lip in 21 mice, and repairs were done on 16 fetuses. Ultimately, 9 viable fetuses were studied. In all cases, lip continuity was present where the suture had coapted the edges. There was little or no evidence of the lip repair despite no incision being performed. Histologic examination revealed epithelial and mesenchymal continuity with an occasional notch noted in the epithelium and soft-tissue asymmetry in complete clefts. The implications of these findings are discussed.     

Confocal microscopic analysis of scarless repair in the fetal rat: defining the transition.

Fetal wounds pass from scarless repair to healing with scar formation during gestation. This transition depends on both the size of the wound and the gestational age of the fetus. This study defines the transition period in the fetal rat model and provides new insight into scarless collagen wound architecture by using confocal microscopy. A total of 16 pregnant Sprague-Dawley rats were operated on. Open full-thickness wounds, 2 mm in diameter, were created on fetal rats at gestational ages 14.5 days (E14; n = 10), 16.5 days (E16; n = 42), and 18.5 days (E18; n = 42) (term = 21.5 days). Wounds were harvested at 24 (n = 18 per gestational age) and 72 hours (n = 24 per gestational age). Skin at identical gestational ages to wound harvest was used for controls. The wounds were fixed and stained with hematoxylin and eosin, antibody to type I collagen, and Sirius red for confocal microscopic evaluation. No E14 rat fetuses survived to wound harvest. Wounds created on E16 fetal rats healed completely and without scarring. E16 fetal rat hair follicle formation and collagen architecture was similar to that of normal, nonwounded skin. Wounds created on E18 fetal rats demonstrated slower healing; only 50 percent were completely healed at 72 hours compared with 100 percent of the E16 fetal rat wounds at 72 hours. Furthermore, the E18 wounds healed with collagen scar formation and without hair follicle formation. Confocal microscopy demonstrated that the collagen fibers were thin and arranged in a wispy pattern in E16 fetal rat wounds and in nonwounded dermis. E18 fetal rat wounds had thickened collagen fibers with large interfiber distances. Two-millimeter excisional E16 fetal rat wounds heal without scar formation and with regeneration of normal dermal and epidermal appendage architecture. E18 fetal rat wounds heal in a pattern similar to that of adult cutaneous wounds, with scar formation and absence of epidermal appendages. Confocal microscopy more clearly defined the dermal architecture in normal skin, scarless wounds, and scars. These data further define the transition period in the fetal rat wound model, which promises to be an effective system for the study of in vivo scarless wound healing.     

妊娠晚期胎羊宫内外科手术的实验研究

目的　以妊娠晚期孕羊为研究对象 ,探讨宫内外科手术的可行性 ,为开展胎儿外科研究建立动物实验模型。方法　通过对妊娠 12 0d左右的 4只双胎孕羊进行宫腔手术 ,切除双胎中 1只胎羊的脚趾或唇部皮肤 ,观察妊娠结果。并取分娩后羔羊脑组织及手术切除部位皮肤作组织形态学观察和评价。结果　妊娠羊经阴道足月分娩后羔羊均成活 ,脚趾及唇部切除处未见疤痕形成 ,皮肤组织形态学观察对照组与实验组未见明显差异 ;脑组织形态学检查仅有 1例实验组羔羊有轻度病理学变化 ,与对照羔羊有差异 ,其余 3例实验羔羊与对照羔羊脑组织结构均正常 ,未见有明显的病理学改变。结论　妊娠羊经宫内胎羊外科手术后能够持续妊娠状态并经阴道自然分娩 ,产出羔羊的精神状态及病理组织学观察结果表明 ,利用妊娠晚期孕羊进行胎儿外科动物实验研究是可行的 ,为进一步开展人类先天性畸形胎儿的早期治疗奠定了动物实验基础     

Untreated cleft lip in an aged patient

An unusual case of unrepaired bilateral incomplete cleft lip in a 66-year-old female patient is presented. Since the cleft had been untreated for such a long time, the local anatomy was severely altered. For this reason, the situation was faced as an ordinary gap and was successfully repaired by advancement of the lateral segments of the lip and excision of the Bürow triangles from the perialar region. Since there was no skeletal involvement, cephalometric findings were absent, so the interest of the case focuses on the age of the patient and the method of repair.     

Simultaneous cleft lip and palate repair: an experimental study in beagles

This study was designed to test the hypothesis that simultaneous lip and palate repair results in more severe craniofacial growth aberrations than lip repair or palate repair performed separately. Seventy-six purebred beagles were divided into five groups. Two of these groups were controls (unoperated and unrepaired animals); the three remaining groups were experimental (in one group only the lip was repaired, in another only the palate was repaired, and in the last the lip and palate were repaired simultaneously). Cephalometric measurements were analyzed using univariate and multivariate statistical techniques. In multivariate analysis, stepwise multiple regression and discrimination were applied to precisely assess the effects of the various surgical procedures. The results of this study indicate that simultaneous lip and palate repair results in more severe craniofacial growth aberrations than lip repair or palate repair performed separately.     

Nasal expansion in the fetal lamb: a first step toward management of cleft nasal deformity in utero

The cleft nasal deformity, a combination of malpositioned cartilage and tissue and postrepair scarring, is a difficult problem to correct. To harness the potential of scarless fetal wound healing, in utero repair of cleft lip and palate deformities has been studied but the fetal cleft nose deformity has not been addressed. The purpose of this study was to manipulate the fetal nasal shape in utero as a first step toward restoration of normal nasal form in cleft nasal deformities. To do this, preformed hypertonic sponges were placed into the right nostril of eight fetal lambs during the second trimester (when scarless cutaneous wound repair is known to occur). Then, the size and shape of fetal nasal structures were analyzed after selected time periods (1, 2, and 6 weeks) with measurements, routine histologic examination, and three-dimensional computed tomographic scans of the experimentally expanded noses compared with the control nonexpanded noses of the birth twins or age-matched specimens. Results showed that experimentally expanded nasal structures had markedly increased in septal length measurement, in nostril area (doubled), and in intranasal volume (more than doubled). Histology showed normal cellular elements without scarring in the tissue sections from the expanded nasal areas. In conclusion, the shape of nasal tissue can be manipulated without scarring in second-trimester fetal lambs after placement of a nasal expansion device. This study is an experimental first step toward restoring normal nasal form by repositioning alar cartilages and soft tissue during fetal cleft repair.     

Upper lip measurements at the time of surgery and follow-up after modified rotation-advancement flap repair in unilateral cleft lip patients

The purpose of this prospective study was to determine whether unilateral cleft lip repaired by the rotation-advancement flap will grow short on the repaired side. This study involved 56 patients with nonsyndromic unilateral cleft lip (31 with complete and 25 with incomplete cleft lip) who underwent a rotation-advancement flap repair by a single surgeon between 1989 and 1997. Eleven patients were lost to follow-up. Forty-five patients have been followed for a varying period of between 8 and 84 months (mean = 37 months). The upper lip was measured immediately after the lip repair and follow-up using calipers. The growth ratios of vertical, horizontal, and nostril sill dimensions were compared between the cleft side and the noncleft side of the same face. Statistical analysis was performed to compare the growths between the cleft and noncleft sides. There was not a significant difference in the growth ratios of vertical (Wilcoxon signed rank test, p = 0.85) and horizontal dimensions (Student's t test, p = 0.18) between the cleft and noncleft sides. There was, however, a statistically significant difference in the growth ratios of nostril sill width between the cleft and noncleft sides (Student's t test, p = 0.02). Our findings indicated that a repaired unilateral cleft retained the vertical and horizontal dimensions determined at the time of the initial repair.     

Immunohistochemical localization of growth factors in fetal wound healing

Fetal wound healing occurs rapidly, in a regenerative fashion, and without scar formation, by contrast with adult wound healing, where tissue repair results in scar formation which limits tissue function and growth. The extracellular matrix deposited in fetal wounds contains essentially the same structural components as that in the adult wound but there are distinct differences in the spatial and temporal distribution of these components. In particular the organization of collagen in the healed fetal wound is indistinguishable from the normal surrounding tissue. Rapidity of healing, lack of an inflammatory response, and an absence of neovascularization also distinguish fetal from adult wound healing. The mechanisms controlling these differing processes are undefined but growth factors may play a critical role. The distribution of growth factors in healing fetal wounds is unknown. We have studied, by immunohistochemistry, the localization of platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF), transforming growth factor beta (TGF beta), and basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF), in fetal, neonatal, and adult mouse lip wounds. TGF beta and bFGF were present in neonatal and adult wounds, but were not detected in the fetal wounds, while PDGF was present in fetal, neonatal, and adult wounds. This pattern correlates with the known effects in vitro of these factors, the absence of an inflammatory response and neovascularization in the fetal wound, and the patterns of collagen deposition in both fetal and adult wounds. The results suggest that it may be possible to manipulate the adult wound to produce more fetal-like, scarless, wound healing.     

Scarless skin wound repair in the fetus.

The ability of a fetus to heal without scar formation depends on its gestational age at the time of injury and the size of the wound defect. In general, linear incisions heal without scar until late in gestation whereas excisional wounds heal with scar at an earlier gestational age. The profiles of fetal proteoglycans, collagens, and growth factors are different from those in adult wounds. The less-differentiated state of fetal skin is probably an important characteristic responsible for scarless repair. There is minimal inflammation in fetal wounds. Fetal wounds are characterized by high levels of hyaluronic acid and its stimulator(s) with more rapid, highly organized collagen deposition. The roles of peptide growth factors such as transforming growth factor-beta and basic fibroblast growth factor are less prominent in fetal than in adult wound healing. Platelet-derived growth factor has been detected in scarless fetal skin wounds, but its role is unknown. An understanding of scarless tissue repair has possible clinical application in the modulation of adult fibrotic diseases and abnormal scar-forming conditions.     

One-stage closure of the entire primary palate

Timing of the closure of the anterior palate and alveolus is a subject of debate. Late repair of this defect is complicated by high fistula formation and subjects the patient to the problems of palate fistula for extended periods of time. We have utilized a single procedure performed when the child is 3 months of age that completely closes the anterior hard palate and alveolus along with the cleft lip. Our series consisted of 61 consecutive patients with unilateral clefts of the primary and secondary palate. Mucosal turnover flaps from the vomer along with lateral nasal mucosal flaps provide the nasal lining. A buccal sulcus flap with a Veau flap completes the oral repair. Ninety-five percent (58 of 61) of the patients had complete and stable closure of their anterior palate and alveolus after 1 year. The incidence of fistula formation in our series (3 of 61) is much lower than that reported with the utilization of other protocols. Excellent exposure of the anterior palate and alveolar defect during lip repair, early restoration of anatomic relationships, establishment of a good nostril floor and sill, and very low fistula formation are among the benefits of this procedure. The increase in operative time is considered minimal in light of aforementioned advantages.     

Nerve dependency in scarless fetal wound healing

The human fetus is capable of healing cutaneous wounds without scar up to the third trimester of development This process of tissue repair is more akin to newt limb regeneration than classic adult scar forming wound repair. Regeneration of the newt limb is dependent on neural input in its early stages. This study was an attempt to determine whether a similar dependence on neural input exists for mammalian fetal wounds to heal without scar. The left hind limb of six fetal lambs was denervated during the early second trimester of development (day 55; term = 145 days). Two weeks after denervation, the animals were again exposed to create bilateral incisional and 6-mm-diameter excisional wounds on their innervated right and denervated left lower extremities. Five days after creation of these defects, the wounds were examined for alterations in repair. Four fetal lambs survived, and three were suitable for evaluation. There were marked alterations in wound healing seen after denervation. Excisional wounds on the innervated side contracted and decreased their surface area by 14 percent. In contrast, the denervated wounds not only failed to contract, but increased in size by 60 percent. Changes in the incisional wounds were equally distinctive. Innervated incisional wounds healed completely without scar and had a wound breaking strength comparable to that of normal skin (Table I). In contrast, two of the three denervated incisional wounds dehisced and failed to heal, even in the regions where the skin was approximated by suture. The third denervated incisional wound did heal but with a significant amount of scar. Electron microscopy confirmed this finding by clearly demonstrating thickened and irregular collagen deposition in the extracellular matrix of all the denervated incisional specimens. In summary, like the regenerating newt limb, scarless fetal skin wound repair requires neural stimulation for tissue regeneration to occur. Therefore, in the mammal, the primary regulator for this unique type of tissue repair may have a central neural, rather than a local, tissue origin.     

Experience with the functional cleft lip repair

The first 12 functional cleft lip repairs performed on unselected consecutive patients immediately following the completion of training by the author are presented. Previous reports on this cleft lip repair have shown excellent results but have always been based on patients operated on by the originator of the procedure. This report gives credence to the ease with which a cleft lip repair that gives reproducible good results can be taught and learned even by plastic surgeons with limited experience. It reviews the technical steps of the procedure, which emphasizes wide undermining and release of the orbicularis oris muscle on the lateral side of the cleft to allow redraping and lengthening of the lip skin, step-by-step layered closure of the mucosa, muscle, and skin, and further vertical lengthening of the lip with a Z-plasty skin closure. Three elements that are difficult to achieve or restore with cleft lip revision are evaluated: (1) achievement of a good skin scar, (2) maintenance of the alar-facial groove, and (3) achievement of adequate lip height without sacrificing horizontal lip length. Ten of the 12 patients had a satisfactory scar, 9 patients had a good alar-facial groove, and all patients had a normal-appearing horizontal lip length. Nine patients required secondary surgery; however, in six patients, this included correction of the nasal deformity that was not corrected at the time of cleft lip repair.