Optical monitoring of synaptic vesicle trafficking in ribbon synapses

Synaptic transmission constitutes the major basis of communication among nerve cells. Upon nerve terminal depolarisation, calcium influx triggers the exocytosis of synaptic vesicles at active zones. Vesicles are then retrieved by endocytosis, recycled and refilled with neurotransmitter. Fluorescent styryl dyes have proven very useful as tools for studying several aspects of the synaptic vesicle cycle. Here, we review recent imaging studies using styryl FM dyes and bipolar cells of goldfish retina, which have a giant synaptic terminal containing ribbon-type active zones. Optical techniques applied to this unique synaptic terminal have provided novel insights into the trafficking of synaptic vesicles during and following strong stimulation.     

Normal biogenesis and cycling of empty synaptic vesicles in dopamine neurons of vesicular monoamine transporter 2 knockout mice

The neuronal isoform of vesicular monoamine transporter, VMAT2, is responsible for packaging dopamine and other monoamines into synaptic vesicles and thereby plays an essential role in dopamine neurotransmission. Dopamine neurons in mice lacking VMAT2 are unable to store or release dopamine from their synaptic vesicles. To determine how VMAT2-mediated filling influences synaptic vesicle morphology and function, we examined dopamine terminals from VMAT2 knockout mice. In contrast to the abnormalities reported in glutamatergic terminals of mice lacking VGLUT1, the corresponding vesicular transporter for glutamate, we found that the ultrastructure of dopamine terminals and synaptic vesicles in VMAT2 knockout mice were indistinguishable from wild type. Using the activity-dependent dyes FM1-43 and FM2-10, we also found that synaptic vesicles in dopamine neurons lacking VMAT2 undergo endocytosis and exocytosis with kinetics identical to those seen in wild-type neurons. Together, these results demonstrate that dopamine synaptic vesicle biogenesis and cycling are independent of vesicle filling with transmitter. By demonstrating that such empty synaptic vesicles can cycle at the nerve terminal, our study suggests that physiological changes in VMAT2 levels or trafficking at the synapse may regulate dopamine release by altering the ratio of fillable-to-empty synaptic vesicles, as both continue to cycle in response to neural activity.     

Measuring exocytosis in neurons using FM labeling

The ability to measure the kinetics of vesicle release can help provide insight into some of the basics of neurotransmission. Here we used real-time imaging of vesicles labeled with FM dye to monitor the rate of presynaptic vesicle release. FM4-64 is a red fluorescent amphiphilic styryl dye that embeds into the membranes of synaptic vesicles as endocytosis is stimulated. Lipophilic interactions cause the dye to greatly increase in fluorescence, thus emitting a bright signal when associated with vesicles and a nominal one when in the extracellular fluid. After a wash step is used to help remove external dye within the plasma membrane, the remaining FM is concentrated within the vesicles and is then expelled when exocytosis is induced by another round of electrical stimulation. The rate of vesicles release is measured from the resulting decrease in fluorescence. Since FM dye can be applied external and transiently, it is a useful tool for determining rates of exocytosis in neuronal cultures, especially when comparing the rates between transfected synapses and neighboring control boutons.     

Mechanisms of synaptic vesicle recycling illuminated by fluorescent dyes

The recycling of synaptic vesicles in nerve terminals involves multiple steps, underlies all aspects of synaptic transmission, and is a key to understanding the basis of synaptic plasticity. The development of styryl dyes as fluorescent molecules that label recycling synaptic vesicles has revolutionized the way in which synaptic vesicle recycling can be investigated, by allowing an examination of processes in neurons that have long been inaccessible. In this review, we evaluate the major aspects of synaptic vesicle recycling that have been revealed and advanced by studies with styryl dyes, focussing upon synaptic vesicle fusion, retrieval, and trafficking. The greatest impact of styryl dyes has been to allow the routine visualization of endocytosis in central nerve terminals for the first time. This has revealed the kinetics of endocytosis, its underlying sequential steps, and its regulation by Ca2+. In studies of exocytosis, styryl dyes have helped distinguish between different modes of vesicle fusion, provided direct support for the quantal nature of exocytosis and endocytosis, and revealed how the probability of exocytosis varies enormously from one nerve terminal to another. Synaptic vesicle labelling with styryl dyes has helped our understanding of vesicle trafficking by allowing better understanding of different synaptic vesicle pools within the nerve terminal, vesicle intermixing, and vesicle clustering at release sites. Finally, the dyes are now being used in innovative ways to reveal further insights into synaptic plasticity.     

Vesicle dynamics: how synaptic proteins regulate different modes of neurotransmission

Central synapses operate neurotransmission in several modes: synchronous/fast neurotransmission (neurotransmitters release is tightly coupled to action potentials and fast), asynchronous neurotransmission (neurotransmitter release is slower and longer lasting), and spontaneous neurotransmission (where small amounts of neurotransmitter are released without being evoked by an action potential). A substantial body of evidence from the past two decades suggests that seemingly identical synaptic vesicles possess distinct propensities to fuse, thus selectively serving different modes of neurotransmission. In efforts to better understand the mechanism(s) underlying the different modes of synaptic transmission, many research groups found that synaptic vesicles used in different modes of neurotransmission differ by a number of synaptic proteins. Synchronous transmission with higher temporal fidelity to stimulation seems to require synaptotagmin 1 and complexin for its Ca²⁺ sensitivity, RIM proteins for closer location of synaptic vesicles (SV) to the voltage operated calcium channels (VGCC), and dynamin for SV retrieval. Asynchronous release does not seem to require functional synaptotagmin 1 as a calcium sensor or complexins, but the activity of dynamin is indispensible for its maintenance. On the other hand, the control of spontaneous neurotransmission remains less clear as deleting a number of essential synaptic proteins does not abolish this type of synaptic vesicle fusion. VGCC distance from the SV seems to have little control on spontaneous transmission, while there is an involvement of functional synaptic proteins including synaptotagmins and complexin. Recently, presynaptic deficits have been proposed to contribute to a number of pathological conditions including cognitive and mental disorders. In this review, we evaluate recent advances in understanding the regulatory mechanisms of synaptic vesicle dynamics and in understanding how different molecular substrates maintain selective modes of neurotransmission. We also highlight the implications of these studies in understanding pathological conditions.     

Modulation of Synaptic Vesicle Exocytosis in Muscle-Dependent Long-Term Depression at the Amphibian Neuromuscular Junction

We have labeled recycling synaptic vesicles at the somatic Bufo marinus neuromuscular junction with the styryl dye FM2-10 and provide direct evidence for refractoriness of exocytosis associated with a muscle activity-dependent form of long-term depression (LTD) at this synapse. FM2-10 dye unloading experiments demonstrated that the rate of vesicle exocytosis from the release ready pool (RRP) of vesicles was more than halved in the LTD (induced by 20 min of low frequency stimulation). Recovery from LTD, observed as a partial recovery of nerve-evoked muscle twitch amplitude, was accompanied by partial recovery of the refractoriness of RRP exocytosis. Unexpectedly, paired pulse plasticity, another routinely used indicator of presynaptic forms of synaptic plasticity, was unchanged in the LTD. We conclude that the LTD induces refractoriness of the neuromuscular vesicle release machinery downstream of presynaptic calcium entry.     

Properties of fast endocytosis at hippocampal synapses

Regulation of synaptic transmission is a widespread means for dynamic alterations in nervous system function. In several cases, this regulation targets vesicular recycling in presynaptic terminals and may result in substantial changes in efficiency of synaptic transmission. Traditionally, experimental accessibility of the synaptic vesicle cycle in central neuronal synapses has been largely limited to the exocytotic side, which can be monitored with electrophysiological responses to neurotransmitter release. Recently, physiological measurements on the endocytotic portion of the cycle have been made possible by the introduction of styryl dyes such as FM1-43 as fluorescent markers for recycling synaptic vesicles. Here we demonstrate the existence of fast endocytosis in hippocampal nerve terminals and derive its kinetics from fluorescence measurements using dyes with varying rates of membrane departitioning. The rapid mode of vesicular retrieval was greatly speeded by exposure to staurosporine or elevated extracellular calcium. The effective time-constant for retrieval can be < 2 seconds under appropriate conditions. Thus, hippocampal synapses capitalize on efficient mechanisms for endocytosis and their vesicular retrieval is subject to modulatory control.     

Visualization of synaptic activity in hippocampal slices with FM1-43 enabled by fluorescence quenching

Fluorescence imaging of presynaptic uptake and release of styryl dyes such as FM1-43 has provided valuable insights into synaptic function. However, in studies of CNS neurons, the utility of these dyes has been severely limited by nonsynaptic background fluorescence. This has thwarted the use of FM dyes in systems more intact than dissociated neuronal cultures. Here, we describe an approach to selectively reduce undesired fluorescence through quenching of the surface-bound FM1-43 signal. The introduction of sulforhodamine, a fluorophore that is not taken up by synaptic vesicles, selectively reduced the nonsynaptic fluorescence in FM1-43-labeled hippocampal cultures. When applied to rat hippocampal slices, this procedure allowed us to observe activity-dependent staining and destaining of functional synapses. Extending the usefulness of styryl dyes to slice preparations may help make functional synaptic networks amenable to optical measurements.     

The Cytoplasmic Domain of Rat Synaptotagmin I Enhances Synaptic Transmission

Synaptotagmin, an integral membrane protein of synaptic vesicles, functions as a calcium sensor in the temporal control of neurotransmitter release. Although synaptotagmin facilitates lipid membrane fusion in biochemical experiments, overexpression of synaptotagmin inhibits neurotransmission. A facilitatory effect of synaptotagmin on synaptic transmission was never observed. To determine whether synaptotagmin may accelerate synaptic transmission in vivo, we injected the cytoplasmic domain of rat synaptotagmin I (CD-syt) into crayfish motor axons and tested the effect of CD-syt on synaptic response. We confirmed that CD-syt accelerates neuromuscular transmission. The injected preparation had larger synaptic potentials with shorter rise time. Experiments with varying calcium concentrations showed that CD-syt increased the maximum synaptic response of the neuromuscular synapses. Further tests on short-term plasticity of neuromuscular synapses revealed that CD-syt increases the release probability of the release-ready vesicles.     

Studying Synaptic Vesicle Pools using Photoconversion of Styryl Dyes

The fusion of synaptic vesicles with the plasma membrane (exocytosis) is a required step in neurotransmitter release and neuronal communication. The vesicles are then retrieved from the plasma membrane (endocytosis) and grouped together with the general pool of vesicles within the nerve terminal, until they undergo a new exo- and endocytosis cycle (vesicle recycling). These processes have been studied using a variety of techniques such as electron microscopy, electrophysiology recordings, amperometry and capacitance measurements. Importantly, during the last two decades a number of fluorescently labeled markers emerged, allowing optical techniques to track vesicles in their recycling dynamics. One of the most commonly used markers is the styryl or FM dye ¹; structurally, all FM dyes contain a hydrophilic head and a lipophilic tail connected through an aromatic ring and one or more double bonds (Fig. 1B). A classical FM dye experiment to label a pool of vesicles consists in bathing the preparation (Fig. 1Ai) with the dye during the stimulation of the nerve (electrically or with high K⁺). This induces vesicle recycling and the subsequent loading of the dye into recently endocytosed vesicles (Fig. 1A_i-iii). After loading the vesicles with dye, a second round of stimulation in a dye-free bath would trigger the FM release through exocytosis (Fig. 1A_iv-v), process that can be followed by monitoring the fluorescence intensity decrease (destaining). Although FM dyes have contributed greatly to the field of vesicle recycling, it is not possible to determine the exact localization or morphology of individual vesicles by using conventional fluorescence microscopy. For that reason, we explain here how FM dyes can also be used as endocytic markers using electron microscopy, through photoconversion. The photoconversion technique exploits the property of fluorescent dyes to generate reactive oxygen species under intense illumination. Fluorescently labeled preparations are submerged in a solution containing diaminobenzidine (DAB) and illuminated. Reactive species generated by the dye molecules oxidize the DAB, which forms a stable, insoluble precipitate that has a dark appearance and can be easily distinguished in electron microscopy ^2,3. As DAB is only oxidized in the immediate vicinity of fluorescent molecules (as the reactive oxygen species are short-lived), the technique ensures that only fluorescently labeled structures are going to contain the electron-dense precipitate. The technique thus allows the study of the exact location and morphology of actively recycling organelles.Open in a separate windowClick here to view.^{(49M, flv)}     

Experimental and modeling investigation of the mechanism of synaptic vesicles recycling

Under the condition of microelectrode recording and fluorescence microscopy with dye FM 1-43 the research of exo-/endocytosis of synaptic vesicles in motor nerve terminals (NT) of frog cutaneous pectoris and white mice diaphragm muscles during high frequency stimulation (20 imp/s) was carried out. A mathematical modeling allowed us to conclude that the obtained experimental data can be explained in the following framework. Three pools of synaptic vesicles are involved in neurotransmitter release in the frog motor NT. Recovery of these pools is provided by endocytosis of two types: fast endocytosis with limited capacity and slow endocytosis. Fast-reconstructing vesicles refill the mobilization pool and slow endocytosis recovers the reserve pool. Our modeling investigation has revealed in frog NT independent recruiting of reserve and mobilization pools to the neurotransmitter secretion, i.e. this pools work concurrently. Experimental data, obtained on mice preparations, are well described with the framework of two-pools model including single type of endocytosis (fast endocytosis).     

Motorneurons require cysteine string protein-α to maintain the readily releasable vesicular pool and synaptic vesicle recycling

Cysteine string protein-α (CSP-α) is a synaptic vesicle protein that prevents activity-dependent neurodegeneration by poorly understood mechanisms. We have studied the synaptic vesicle cycle at the motor nerve terminals of CSP-α knock-out mice expressing the synaptopHluorin transgene. Mutant nerve terminals fail to sustain prolonged release and the number of vesicles available to be released decreases. Strikingly, the SNARE protein SNAP-25 is dramatically reduced. In addition, endocytosis during the stimulus fails to maintain the size of the recycling synaptic vesicle pool during prolonged stimulation. Upon depolarization, the styryl dye FM?2-10 becomes trapped and poorly releasable. Consistently with the functional results, electron microscopy analysis revealed characteristic features of impaired synaptic vesicle recycling. The unexpected defect in vesicle recycling in CSP-α knock-out mice provides insights into understanding molecular mechanisms of degeneration in motor nerve terminals.     

Direct monitoring of vesicular release and uptake in brain slices by multiphoton excitation of the styryl FM 1-43

Fluorescence imaging using FM 1-43 and related styryl dyes has provided invaluable insights into presynaptic function of synapses in culture preparations, but has been limited in use for studying central synapses in vivo or in brain slices, because of excessive fluorescence background due to nonspecific membrane binding of dye. We demonstrate here that focal excitation of FM dyes using two-photon laser-scanning microscopy (TPLSM) provides high resolution of FM 1-43-labeled nerve terminals in brain slices by suppressing out-of-focus background and that a readily releasable pool of vesicles can be selectively and stably labeled by hypertonic shock despite slice diffusion barriers. We find direct TPLSM of FM 1-43-labeled nerve terminals to be superior to treatment of slices with either the fluorescent quencher sulforhodamine 101 or dye scavenger ADVASEP-7 in resolving nerve terminal against background fluorescence, enabling continuous monitoring of vesicular uptake, and release of styryl dyes from individual nerve terminals in brain slices.     

An isolated pool of vesicles recycles at rest and drives spontaneous neurotransmission

Spontaneous synaptic vesicle fusion is a common property of all synapses. To trace the origin of spontaneously fused vesicles in hippocampal synapses, we tagged vesicles with fluorescent styryl dyes, antibodies against synaptotagmin-1, or horseradish peroxidase. We could show that synaptic vesicles recycle at rest, and after spontaneous exo-endocytosis, they populate a reluctantly releasable pool of limited size. Interestingly, vesicles in this spontaneously labeled pool were more likely to re-fuse spontaneously compared to vesicles labeled with activity. We found that blocking vesicle refilling at rest selectively depleted neurotransmitter from spontaneously fusing vesicles without significantly altering evoked transmission. Furthermore, in the absence of the vesicle SNARE protein synaptobrevin (VAMP), activity-dependent and spontaneously recycling vesicles could mix, suggesting a role for synaptobrevin in the separation of the two pools. Taken together these results suggest that spontaneously recycling vesicles and activity-dependent recycling vesicles originate from distinct pools with limited cross-talk with each other.     

A minimal domain responsible for Munc13 activity

Munc13 proteins are essential in neurotransmitter release, controlling the priming of synaptic vesicles to a release-ready state. The sequences responsible for this priming activity are unknown. Here we identify a large alpha-helical domain of mammalian Munc13-1 that is autonomously folded and is sufficient to rescue the total arrest in neurotransmitter release observed in hippocampal neurons lacking Munc13s.     

Loss of Usp14 results in reduced levels of ubiquitin in ataxia mice

The ataxia (ax(J)) mutation is a spontaneous recessive mutation that results in reduced expression of ubiquitin-specific protease 14, Usp14. Mice homozygous for the ax(J) mutation are retarded for growth and exhibit several behavioral disorders, including a resting tremor and hindlimb paralysis. Although pathological defects appear to be limited to the central nervous system, reduction of Usp14 expression was widespread in the ax(J) mice. Usp14 co-fractionated with proteasomes isolated from livers and brains of wild-type mice. Proteasomes isolated from the ax(J) brains still possessed deubiquitinating activity and were functionally competent to hydrolyze 20S proteasomal substrates in vitro. However, the levels of monomeric ubiquitin were reduced approximately 35% in most of the ax(J) tissues examined. These results indicate that Usp14 functions to maintain the cellular levels of monomeric ubiquitin in mammalian cells, and that alterations in the levels of ubiquitin may contribute to neurological disease.     

Effectiveness of extracellular lactate/pyruvate for sustaining synaptic vesicle proton gradient generation and vesicular accumulation of GABA

The effects of extracellular monocarboxylates pyruvate and lactate on membrane potentials, acidification and neurotransmitter filling of synaptic vesicles were investigated in experiments with rat brain synaptosomes using [(3)H]GABA and fluorescent dyes, potential-sensitive rhodamine 6G and pH-sensitive acridine orange. In experiments investigating accumulation of acridine orange in synaptic vesicles within the synaptosomes, monocarboxylates, similarly to glucose, ensured generation of the vesicle proton gradient by available and recycled vesicles, and pyruvate demonstrated the highest efficacy. An increase in the level of proton gradient correlated with enhanced accumulation of [(3)H]GABA in synaptic vesicles and resulted in enlarged exocytosis and attenuated the transporter-mediated [(3)H]GABA release. Pyruvate added to glucose-contained medium caused more active binding of rhodamine 6G by synaptosomes that reflected mitochondrial membrane hyperpolarization, and this intensification of nerve terminal energy metabolism resulted in an increase in total ATP content by approximately 25%. Pyruvate also prolonged the state of metabolic competence of nerve terminal preparations, keeping the mitochondrial potential and synaptic vesicle proton gradient at steady levels over a long period of time. Thus, besides glucose, the extracellular monocarboxylates pyruvate and lactate can provide sufficient support of energy-dependent processes in isolated nerve terminals, allowing effective functioning of neurotransmitter release and reuptake systems.     

Probing rotational viscosity in synaptic vesicles

The synaptic vesicle (SV) is a central organelle in neurotransmission, and previous studies have suggested that SV protein 2 (SV2) may be responsible for forming a gel-like matrix within the vesicle. Here we measured the steady-state rotational anisotropy of the fluorescent dye, Oregon Green, within individual SVs. By also measuring the fluorescence lifetime of Oregon Green in SVs, we determined the mean rotational viscosity to be 16.49 ± 0.12 cP for wild-type (WT) empty mice vesicles (i.e., with no neurotransmitters), 11.21 ± 0.12 cP for empty vesicles from SV2 knock-out mice, and 11.40 ± 0.65 cP for WT mice vesicles loaded with the neurotransmitter glutamate (Glu). This measurement shows that SV2 is an important determinant of viscosity within the vesicle lumen, and that the viscosity decreases when the vesicles are filled with Glu. The viscosities of both empty SV2 knock-out vesicles and Glu-loaded WT vesicles were significantly different from that of empty WT SVs (p < 0.05). This measurement represents the smallest enclosed volume in which rotational viscosity has been measured thus far.     

Calcium regulates the mode of exocytosis induced by hypotonic shock in isolated neuronal presynaptic endings

A decrease in the osmolarity of incubation medium is accompanied by calcium influx in neuronal presynaptic endings. We studied the influence of Ca2+ on exocytosis induced by hypotonic shock using the hydrophilic fluorescent dye acridine orange and the hydrophobic fluorescent dye FM2-10. It was shown using acridine orange that lowering of osmolarity to 230 mOsm/l induces exocytosis both in calcium-containing and calcium-free medium. By contrast, we were able to demonstrate calcium-dependence of exocytosis using styryl dye FM2-10. Lowering of osmolarity leads to increase of [3H]D-aspartate and [3H]GABA release in calcium-free medium. Addition of calcium inhibits hypotonic-induced neurotransmitter release. Decreasing of NaCl concentration to 92 mM in isotonic medium is able to induce d-aspartate and GABA release. Thus, our data suggest that hypotonic swelling induces calcium-independent exocytosis possibly by a "kiss and run" mechanism. Calcium influx mediated by stretch channels is able to provoke full fusion between plasma membrane and synaptic vesicles. [3H]D-aspartate and [3H]GABA released by hypotonic shock is determined by sodium lowering rather than by osmolarity decreasing itself.     

Endocytosis and Exocytosis Events Regulate Vesicle Traffic in Endothelial Cells

We used water-soluble styryl pyridinium dyes that fluoresce at the membrane-water interface to study vesicle traffic in endothelial cells. Cultured endothelial cells derived from bovine and human pulmonary microvessels were incubated in styryl probes, washed to remove dye from the plasmalemmal outer face, and observed by digital fluorescence microscopy. Vesicles that derived from plasmalemma by endocytosis were filled with the styryl dye. These vesicles were distributed throughout the cytosol as numerous particles of heterogeneous diameter and brightness. Vesicle formation was activated 2-fold following addition of extracellular albumin whereas a control protein, immunoglobulin G, had no effect. Dye uptake was abrogated by labeling at low temperatures and inhibitors of phosphoinositide-3-kinase (PI 3-kinase). Tyrosine kinase inhibitors (genistein and herbimycin A) prevented the albumin-induced vesicle formation. Cytochalasin B prevented vesicle redistribution indicating involvement of actin filaments in translocation of endosomes away from sites of vesicle formation. Styryl dye was lost from cells by exocytosis as evident by the disappearance of discrete fluorescent particles. N-ethylmaleimide and botulinum toxin types A and B caused cells to accumulate increased number of vesicles suggesting that exocytosis was regulated by NSF-dependent SNARE mechanism. The results suggest that phosphoinositide metabolism regulates endocytosis in endothelial cells and that extracellular albumin activates endocytosis by a mechanism involving tyrosine phosphorylation, whereas exocytosis is a distinct process regulated by the SNARE machinery. The results support the hypothesis that albumin regulates its internalization and release in vascular endothelial cells via activation of specific endocytic and exocytic pathways.