Cold hardiness of Lymantria monacha and L. dispar (Lepidoptera: Erebidae) eggs to extreme winter temperatures: implications for predicting climate change impacts

1. It has been predicted that temperature increases of 3.6–5.8 °C would shift the northern distribution limit of Lymantria monacha (Linnaeus) and Lymantria dispar (Linnaeus) by 500–700 km, but these predictions ignore the effects of minimum winter temperatures. It was hypothesised that winter cold can limit range expansion due to high egg mortality in cold temperatures. 2. The present study determined the supercooling points of overwintering eggs of these forest pests, and compared these with recent minimum winter temperatures in the areas of origin of three populations. Eggs from one L. monacha and one L. dispar population from the species' core distribution area in Germany were included, as well as L. monacha eggs from Finland, near the northern border of the species' distribution. 3. The median supercooling points of both species were more than 10 °C lower than the median minimum winter temperatures of their areas of origin, and the median supercooling points of Finnish and German L. monacha eggs did not differ significantly. The median supercooling point of German L. monacha eggs differed from that of German L. dispar eggs. 4. Previous literature on the topic is referenced, and translations of the old German and Russian sources are given. Based on these results, it is argued that the frequent claim that L. monacha eggs can survive cold down to ?40 °C is unsupported, with a value near ?30 °C being a more likely limit. 5. Winter cold alone can limit the predicted range shifts of these species to 200–300 km under 3.6–5.8 °C increase scenarios, which is less than half the value of earlier estimates.     

Divergent strategies in low temperature environment for the sibling species Drosophila melanogaster and D. simulans: overwintering in extension border areas of France and comparison with African populations

The two sibling species D. /melanogaster and D. simulans adopt different overwintering strategies in northern border areas situated in France. If the winter is mild, both species reappear in early spring to refound the population. If the winter is cold, with several weeks of temperatures below 0 °C, D. melanogaster leave their shelters in April whereas D. simulans, which do not use shelters, reappear in late June, probably after returning from further south. Here, we tried to identify life-history characteristics responsible for this difference. For this, we studied developmental duration, viability, fecundity, fertility and longevity, and compared the abilities of French and African populations to survive when food supplies were inadequate, at different temperatures (14, 11, 7 °C). These temperatures are lower than those commonly used in the laboratory but closer to real conditions encountered in the wild. When the temperature was mild (14 or 11 °C) and the food supply was adequate, D. simulans performed better than D. melanogaster: it had a higher fecundity, a longer life expectancy and the males remained fertile, allowing outdoor reproduction late in winter. However, D. simulans was less resistant in more extreme conditions. At 7 °C D. simulans survived shorter on normal medium and its ability to survive when food supplies were inadequate was insufficient to allow outdoor overwintering. In contrast, D. melanogaster could not reproduce during winter: its fecundity was low and males were sterile at 11 °C. Nevertheless, if only protein-deficient resources were available, temperate D. melanogaster could survive for longer than D. simulans at all the temperatures tested. This greater resistance to underfeeding allows the species to survive until spring, in shelters for several months. A comparison of French and African population performances showed differences in the evolution of the two species during the colonization of more northern areas. African D. simulans, which are efficient at mild temperatures, underwent few modifications. In contrast, the viability of D. melanogaster improved at low developmental temperatures. This species also displayed higher fecundity, longer survival and higher underfeeding resistance at low temperatures. The relationship between the long retention genotype and underfeeding resistance or survival ability observed in French D. melanogaster populations may not exist in African populations.     

The Japanese tree frog (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Hyla japonica</Emphasis>), one of the most cold-resistant species of amphibians

The Japanese tree frog, a representative of the Manchurian fauna, is characterized by an outstanding cold resistance among the anuran amphibian species studied so far. Almost 70% of the specimens from the population inhabiting the middle Amur River withstand the cooling down to–30°C; some animals, down to–35°C. This exceeds more than twofold the cold hardiness of the wood frog (Lithobates sylvaticus LeConte, 1825), which has been considered earlier to be the most cold-resistant species. The ability of H. japonica to survive for four months in the frozen state at low temperatures makes this species independent of the temperature overwintering conditions.     

Effect of temperature on the in vitro reproductive fitness of Pratylenchus coffeae populations from Vietnam

The in vitro reproductive fitness on carrot discs of 10 Pratylenchus coffeae populations collected from different agricultural crops in different agro-ecological regions in Vietnam was studied and compared with the reproductive fitness of a P. coffeae population from Ghana. Few major differences in in vitro reproductive fitness on carrot discs among the 10 P. coffeae populations from Vietnam examined (with the exception of one population originally isolated from the roots of an unidentified ornamental tree and one population originally isolated from banana), and between these populations and the P. coffeae population originally isolated from banana in Ghana were observed. Our observations indicate that although the optimum temperature for reproduction of three P. coffeae populations from Vietnam examined is 25?°C to, at least, 30?°C, these populations are also tolerant to low temperatures (15–20?°C) enabling them to survive the low temperatures which occur during the winter in the northern and central parts of Vietnam.     

Temperature requirements for the growth and maturation of the gametophytes of Undaria pinnatifida and U. undarioides (Laminariales, Phaeophyceae)

Gametophytes of two Undaria species, U. pinnatifida and U. undarioides (Laminariales, Phaeophyceae), were studied to determine their water temperature requirements in order to understand their different distributions in Mie Prefecture, Japan. The optimal temperature for growth was 20°C for gametophytes of both species, and the upper critical temperature for growth was also the same for both species at 28°C. Therefore, the optimal and critical temperatures for growth of the gametophytes are not the main factors determining distribution. The optimal temperature for maturation of U. pinnatifida was approximately 10–15°C, whereas it was closer to 20–21°C for U. undarioides, a difference between these species of at least 5°C. In autumn and early winter, the seawater temperature at the mouth of Ise Bay, where U. pinnatifida is distributed, ranges from 21.6°C (October) to 12.7°C (December), and off Hamajima, where U. undarioides is found, the range is from 22.7°C (October) to 19.1°C (December). The seawater temperatures from October to December, which is the maturation season for the gametophytes, agreed well with the optimal temperature requirements for maturation of the gametophytes of both species. Thus the difference in the maturation temperature range of the gametophytes is a major factor determining distribution of these Undaria species along the Japanese coast.     

Temperatures lethal for citrus blackfly parasites,Encarsia opulenta andE. Smithi [Hym.: Aphelinidae]

Seasonally acclimatized adult and immature parasites of the citrus blackfly (CBF),Aleurocanthus woglumi Ashby, were exposed to high or low temperature extremes for 3 h periods. Death of all summer adults ofEncarsia opulenta Silvestri andE. smithi Silvestri occurred between 35° and 40°C. Within CBF hosts,E. opulenta were not able to emerge when temperatures reached between 45° and 50°C. In winter experiments adults of bothEncarsia species succumbed between −5° and −10°C. In a comparison of the 2 seasonal tests, a higher percentage ofE. smithi adults were able to survive both higher and lower temperatures thanE. opulenta, but the main interspecific difference was the ability ofE. opulenta within CBF to survive −10° to − 15°C whileE. smithi did not. Limited data forAmitus hesperidum Silvestri [Hym.: Platygasteridae] indicated that the immatures survived better at low, and not as well at high, temperatures as either species ofEncarsia. Florida Agricultural Experiment Station Journal Series # 5549.     

Cold in the common garden: comparative low-temperature tolerance of boreal and temperate conifer foliage

Because they maintain green foliage throughout the winter season, evergreen conifers may face special physiological challenges in a warming world. We assessed the midwinter low-temperature (LT) tolerance of foliage from eight temperate and boreal species in each of the genera Abies, Picea, and Pinus growing in an arboretum in Trondheim, Norway, using relative electrolyte leakage (REL) as an index of cell injury. Relatively LT sensitive species came from temperate coastal and Mediterranean environments and displayed a well-defined sigmoidal response to LT stress, with LT₅₀ ranging from −27 to −38°C. Species originating from boreal regions were not lethally stressed by slow freezing to temperatures as low as −80°C, while species from temperate mountains and continental interiors displayed intermediate responses, with LT50s ranging from −33 to −44°C. Further evaluation of one sensitive and one insensitive species in each genus showed that boreal species can survive quenching in liquid nitrogen at −196°C provided they are first slowly cooled to −30°C or lower. Quantitative image analysis of color changes resulting from LT stress followed by exposure to light showed that foliage from nonlethally stressed boreal species developed mild to moderate chlorosis while more sensitive species developed a mixture of chlorosis and necrosis, with significant necrosis occurring mainly at temperatures resulting in REL of 50% or more. Sensitive and insensitive trees differed significantly in total raffinose, sucrose, and total sugar concentrations, and raffinose and sucrose correlated significantly with LT₅₀ within the sensitive group. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Effects of salinity and cyclic temperature on survival of two sympatric species of grass shrimp (Palaemonetes), and their relationship to natural distributions

Survival and respiration of the grass shrimp Palaemonetes pugio Holthuis and P. vulgaris (Say) from the Newport River estuary were measured after exposure to cyclic and constant winter temperatures, to rapid decreases in temperature, and to various temperature-salinity combinations. Both species were subjected to nine temperature-salinity combinations including temperature regimes of cyclic 7–13°C, constant 7° and 10°C, and salinities of 5, 20, and 35%.. Based on the laboratory and field results, the differences in physiological tolerance to winter temperatures and salinities were examined in relation to habitat partitioning by these sympatric species.Survival after continuous exposure to cyclic temperature regimes at medium to high salinities was similar to that observed for comparable constant temperatures; however, at low salinities mortality was significantly lower under the cyclic regime than under either constant regime. This suggests that cyclic temperatures may be detrimental in combination with some other stress. A rapid, transient decrease in temperature from either 7° or 10°C to 2°C had no measurable effect on survival or rate of oxygen consumption at any temperature-salinity acclimation. Neither salinity (except in areas intermittently subjected to salinities below 3 %.) nor winter temperatures appear to affect habitat partitioning in grass shrimp.     

Winter cold tolerance and the geographic range separation of Bromus tectorum and Bromus rubens,two severe invasive species in North America

The invasive grasses Bromus rubens and Bromus tectorum are responsible for widespread damage to semiarid biomes of western North America. Bromus. tectorum dominates higher and more northern landscapes than its sister species B. rubens, which is a severe invader in the Mojave desert region of the American Southwest. To assess climate thresholds controlling their distinct geographic ranges, we evaluated the winter cold tolerance of B. tectorum and B. rubens. Freezing tolerance thresholds were determined using electrolyte leakage and whole‐plant mortality. The responses of the two species to winter cold and artificial freezing treatments were similar in 2007–2008 and 2009–2010. When grown at minimum temperatures of 10 °C, plants of both species had cold tolerance thresholds near ?10 °C, while plants acclimated to a daily minimum of ?10 to ?30 °C survived temperatures down to ?31 °C. In the winter of 2010–2011, a sudden severe cold event on December 9, 2010 killed all B. rubens populations, while B. tectorum was not harmed; all tested plants were 7–8 weeks old. Controlled acclimation experiments demonstrated that 8‐week‐old plants of B. rubens had a slower acclimation rate to subzero temperatures than B. tectorum and could not survive a rapid temperature drop from 1 to ?14 °C. Four‐month‐old B. rubens populations were as cold tolerant as B. tectorum. Our results show that severe and sudden freeze events in late autumn can kill young plants of B. rubens but not B. tectorum. Such events could exclude B. rubens from the relatively cold, Intermountain steppe biome of western North America where B. tectorum predominates.     

Cold-hardiness of the phoretic mites Anoetus myrmicarum (Acariformes,Anoetidae) from the ants Formica lemani (Hymenoptera,Formicidae) in the Kolyma Highland

In the sparse larch forests of the upper Kolyma River, hypopi of the mite Anoetus myrmicarum (Scheucher, 1957) were found in several nests of the ant Formica lemani Bondroit, 1917. These mites were not found in hundreds of nests of the other 10 ant species examined in northeastern Asia. A possible ecological and physiological conditionality of the restricted distribution of phoretic mites was analyzed. For this purpose, coldhardiness of mites and their ant hosts, the biotopic distribution and the structure of nests, and the temperature conditions of overwintering were examined. At the stage of hypopus, the mites overwintered on ants in the overcooled stage; their mean supercooling temperatures (SCP) varied from ?25.8 ± 0.3°C to ?27.7 ± 0.4°C (min ?32.2°C, n = 157). These values were by 0.1 to 7.0°C lower than the mean SCP of the ants from 8 tested nests of F. lemani (?20.7 ± 0.5°C to ?25.7 ± 0.8°C). The soil temperatures at the level of winter chambers varied from ?12°C to ?15°C. Scarcity of findings of Anoetus myrmicarum in the Kolyma Highland is not associated with the limited cold-hardiness of the examined stages, but is most probably determined by interrelations between mites and ants.     

Low-temperature tolerance of juvenile tarpon <Emphasis Type="Italic">Megalops atlanticus</Emphasis>

The tarpon Megalops atlanticus is a tropical to subtropical species whose pole-ward distribution is thought to be limited by low water temperatures. In the western north Atlantic Ocean juvenile tarpon occur in estuaries of the South Atlantic Bight (SAB) north of Florida near the northern limit of its distribution, but it is currently unknown whether these individuals can survive winter, grow to maturity, and contribute to the adult population. As a first step to determine whether juvenile tarpon can survive winter conditions in the SAB, we conducted laboratory experiments to estimate minimum lethal temperatures of tarpon exposed to 1) ambient fluctuating winter water conditions and 2) a constant rate of temperature decline. Juvenile tarpon exposed to ambient winter water conditions had a mean ± standard deviation (SD) minimum lethal temperature of 13.7 ± 3.4 °C. When exposed to a constant rate of temperature decline (2 °C day^?1), mean ± SD minimum lethal temperature (9.2 ± 0.8 °C) was lower than when tarpon were exposed to ambient fluctuating conditions. A combination of our results with all published data on the cold tolerance of juvenile tarpon resulted in an overall mean ± SD minimum lethal temperature of 12.0 ± 2.8 °C. Based on available long-term temperature records from SAB estuaries, overwinter survival of juvenile tarpon is unlikely in most aquatic habitats (e.g., tidal creeks, flats, open water). Similar to other estuarine transient fishes, juvenile tarpon likely exploit seasonably favorable nursery habitats and then migrate to other locations to overwinter.     

Factors affecting cold hardiness in the small striped flea beetle, Phyllotreta undulata

The striped flea beetle, Phyllotreta undulata Kutschera (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae), is a pest of cruciferous crops. It overwinters as an adult. During winter in northern European countries, such as Estonia, it is subject to sometimes severe temperatures that may fluctuate daily, over the season, and between seasons. The objective of this study was to investigate factors that affect its cold hardiness. In a series of five experiments, the effects of food plant, starvation, and acclimatization on the beetles’ ability to supercool and survive exposure to sub‐zero temperatures was investigated. The supercooling points (SCP) of overwintered beetles field‐collected from white mustard and Indian mustard differed from those caught from white cabbage and oilseed rape, but these differences disappeared after a 4‐day period of starvation at room temperature, indicating that gut content probably influences the potential to supercool. The duration and temperature of acclimation affected SCP in overwintered beetles. The decrease in SCP was more rapid at 22 °C than at 0 °C, probably because of faster dehydration and gut evacuation at the higher temperature. Acclimation at 0 °C for a week increased the ability of overwintered beetles to survive sub‐zero temperatures, lowering both SCP and lower lethal temperature (LLT₅₀). Some pre‐freeze mortality occurred; SCP and LLT₅₀ were correlated but the latter was a constant 3 °C higher than the former. The SCP of field‐collected pre‐winter beetles decreased gradually during the autumn. It also decreased when field‐collected pre‐winter beetles were acclimated at 0 °C in the laboratory, attaining its lowest level after 18 days. Phyllotreta undulata is well‐adapted to unstable and sometimes severe winter conditions; its high potential to supercool enhances its cold hardiness and ability to survive short periods at sub‐zero temperatures although it cannot survive freezing of its body fluids.     

Thermal habitat of adult Atlantic salmon Salmo salar in a warming ocean

The year-round thermal habitat at sea for adult Atlantic salmon Salmo salar (n = 49) from northern Norway was investigated using archival tags over a 10 year study period. During their ocean feeding migration, the fish spent 90% of the time in waters with temperatures from 1.6–8.4°C. Daily mean temperatures ranged from −0.5 to 12.9°C, with daily temperature variation up to 9.6°C. Fish experienced the coldest water during winter (November–March) and the greatest thermal range during the first summer at sea (July–August). Trends in sea-surface temperatures influenced the thermal habitat of salmon during late summer and autumn (August–October), with fish experiencing warmer temperatures in warmer years. This pattern was absent during winter (November–March), when daily mean temperatures ranged from 3.4–5.0°C, in both colder and warmer years. The observations of a constant thermal habitat during winter in both warmer and colder years, may suggest that the ocean distribution of salmon is flexible and that individual migration routes could shift as a response to spatiotemporal alterations of favourable prey fields and ocean temperatures.     

Life on the edge: thermal optima for aerobic scope of equatorial reef fishes are close to current day temperatures

Equatorial populations of marine species are predicted to be most impacted by global warming because they could be adapted to a narrow range of temperatures in their local environment. We investigated the thermal range at which aerobic metabolic performance is optimum in equatorial populations of coral reef fish in northern Papua New Guinea. Four species of damselfishes and two species of cardinal fishes were held for 14 days at 29, 31, 33, and 34 °C, which incorporated their existing thermal range (29–31 °C) as well as projected increases in ocean surface temperatures of up to 3 °C by the end of this century. Resting and maximum oxygen consumption rates were measured for each species at each temperature and used to calculate the thermal reaction norm of aerobic scope. Our results indicate that one of the six species, Chromis atripectoralis, is already living above its thermal optimum of 29 °C. The other five species appeared to be living close to their thermal optima (ca. 31 °C). Aerobic scope was significantly reduced in all species, and approached zero for two species at 3 °C above current‐day temperatures. One species was unable to survive even short‐term exposure to 34 °C. Our results indicate that low‐latitude reef fish populations are living close to their thermal optima and may be more sensitive to ocean warming than higher‐latitude populations. Even relatively small temperature increases (2–3 °C) could result in population declines and potentially redistribution of equatorial species to higher latitudes if adaptation cannot keep pace.     

Emerging climate‐driven disturbance processes: widespread mortality associated with snow‐to‐rain transitions across 10° of latitude and half the range of a climate‐threatened conifer

Climate change is causing rapid changes to forest disturbance regimes worldwide. While the consequences of climate change for existing disturbance processes, like fires, are relatively well studied, emerging drivers of disturbance such as snow loss and subsequent mortality are much less documented. As the climate warms, a transition from winter snow to rain in high latitudes will cause significant changes in environmental conditions such as soil temperatures, historically buffered by snow cover. The Pacific coast of North America is an excellent test case, as mean winter temperatures are currently at the snow–rain threshold and have been warming for approximately 100 years post‐Little Ice Age. Increased mortality in a widespread tree species in the region has been linked to warmer winters and snow loss. Here, we present the first high‐resolution range map of this climate‐sensitive species, Callitropsis nootkatensis (yellow‐cedar), and document the magnitude and location of observed mortality across Canada and the United States. Snow cover loss related mortality spans approximately 10° latitude (half the native range of the species) and 7% of the overall species range and appears linked to this snow–rain transition across its range. Mortality is commonly >70% of basal area in affected areas, and more common where mean winter temperatures is at or above the snow–rain threshold (>0 °C mean winter temperature). Approximately 50% of areas with a currently suitable climate for the species (相似文献   

Survival of Heleomyza borealis (Diptera, Heleomyzidae) larvae down to − 60°C

Heleomyza borealis Boh. (Diptera, Heleomyzidae) overwinters as larvae in Arctic habitats, where they may experience winter temperatures below ? 15°C. The larvae freeze at c.? 7°C but in acclimation experiments 80% survived when exposed to ? 60°C. Of the larvae exposed to between ? 4 and ? 15°C, only 3% pupated. However, when cooled to ? 20°C this increased to 44%, with 4% emerging as adults. Larvae maintained at 5°C contained low levels of glycerol, sorbitol and trehalose, which did not increase with acclimation to low temperatures. However, levels of fructose increased from 6.1 μg mg^?1 fw in control animals to 17 μg mg^?1 fw when exposed to ? 2°C for 1 week. Larval body water (2.2 ± 0.1 g/g dw, mean ± SD, n = 100) and lipid content (0.22 ± 0.002 g/g fw, mean ± SE) showed no significant change during acclimation to low temperatures. Larvae maintained at a constant 5°C survived for over 18 months with little loss of body mass (from 7.5 ± 1.2 to 7.0 ± 1.2 mg fw, mean ± SD, n = 20), but none pupated. Heleomyza borealis larvae appear to feed and grow until they reach a body mass of about 7.5 mg and then become dormant. They remain in this state until they experience a low temperature stimulus (< ? 15°C) followed by a warm period (≈ 5°C). This ensures that the larvae pupate and adults emerge in early summer, allowing the maximum growing period before the following winter. Heleomyza borealis are adapted to survive long winters in a dormant larval state. They have a low metabolic rate, can conserve body water even at subzero temperatures but do not synthesize large quantities of cryoprotectants.     

Development,survival and reproduction of Orius niger (Hemiptera:Anthocoridae) under different photoperiod and temperature regimes

The successful use of the predatory bug Orius spp. (Hemiptera:Anthocoridae) for the biological control of pests, namely western flower thrips Frankliniella occidentalis (Pergande), in greenhouses during winter depends on overcoming the obstacles of short photoperiods and low temperatures which limit the efficacy of the predators through diapause induction, slowed development, reduced survival and reproduction. Thus, research has focused on determining the insect species least vulnerable to these problems. This study investigated the effect of varying day-lengths (9, 11, 13 and 16 h) at 26°C as well as constant (18, 22, 26 and 30°C) and fluctuating (10/22°C) temperatures on biological characteristics of Orius niger (Wolff). Photoperiod did not induce reproductive diapause and did not significantly affect development, survival of eggs and nymphs, longevity, fecundity or sex ratio; with the exception of the 16 h day-length which led to a shorter duration of nymphal development. Fluctuating temperatures and a constant temperature of 18°C increased the incubation period, duration of nymphal development, total developmental time, generation time and longevity, compared to the constant temperatures of 22, 26 and 30°C, but decreased fecundity compared to 22 and 26°C. On the other hand, sex ratio was not influenced by 10/22 and 18°C. Egg hatch rate and nymph survival differed significantly between temperature regimes, being lower at 18 and 10/22°C. These results suggest that O. niger would be able to survive and reproduce under winter conditions in unheated Mediterranean greenhouses and is a candidate for use in the biological control of pests.     

A thermal time model for predicting time to aerial shoot elongation in Variegated Solomon's Seal

Aerial shoot development in Variegated Solomon's Seal (Polygonatum odoratum‘Variegatum’) was studied under warm (mean 18°C) conditions after dormant rhizomes had been stored at a range of temperatures. After chilling at 0.8–5.5°C for 21–77 days, all rhizomes produced elongated aerial shoots, with mean lengths from 33 cm to 44 cm. Exposure of rhizomes to 15°C or 20°C for 21–77 days resulted in 17% to 50% of buds emerging as shoots, but these either aborted or failed to extend beyond a rosette. The earliest aerial shoot elongation was observed after 7–13 days at 18°C in rhizomes that had been chilled at 0.8–2°C treatments for 59–72 days. The base, optimum and maximum temperatures during pre‐planting storage for subsequent aerial shoot elongation were derived respectively as ?1.5°C, 1.9°C and 15.8°C. A thermal time of storage was calculated from these cardinal temperatures and the rate of progress to normal aerial shoot clongation was shown to increase linearly with increasing thermal time to c. 150°Cd. The thermal time procedure for predicting time to aerial shoot elongation constructed from growth room/chamber data was validated using rhizomes that had been exposed to varying temperatures in shadehouse conditions during the winter in Taiwan.     

Change in overwintering mechanism of the Cucujid beetle, Cucujus clavipes

Overwintering larvae of the Cucujid beetle, Cucujus clavipes, were freeze tolerant, able to survive the freezing of their extracellular body fluids, during the winter of 1978–1979. These larvae had high levels of polyols (glycerol and sorbitol), thermal hysteresis proteins and haemolymph ice nucleators that prevented extensive supercooling (the supercooling points of the larvae were ? 10°C), thus preventing lethal intracellular ice formation. In contrast, C. clavipes larvae were freeze suspectible, died if frozen, during the winter of 1982–1983, but supercooled to ～ ? 30°C. The absence of the ice nucleators in the 1982–1983 larvae, obviously essential in the now freeze-susceptible insects, was the major detected difference in the larvae from the 2 years. However, experiments in which the larvae were artifically seeded at ? 10°C (the temperature at which the natural haemolymph ice nucleators produced spontaneous nucleation in the 1978–1979 freeze tolerant larvae) demonstrated that the absence of the ice nucleators was not the critical factor, or at least not the only critical factor, responsible for the loss of freeze tolerance in the 1982–1983 larvae. The lower lethal temperatures for the larvae were approximately the same during the 2 winters in spite of the change in overwintering strategy.