Optical studies of complexes of quinacrine with DNA and chromatin: implications for the fluorescence of cytological chromosome preparations

The fluorescence and circular dichroism of quinacrine complexed with nucleic acids and chromatin were measured to estimate the relative magnitudes of factors influencing the fluorescence banding patterns of chromosomes stained with quinacrine or quinacrine mustard. DNA base composition can influence quinacrine fluorescence in at least two ways. The major effect, evident at low ratios of quinacrine to DNA, is a quenching of dye fluorescence, correlating with G-C composition. This may occur largely prior to relaxation of excited dye molecules. At higher dye/DNA saturations, which might exist in cytological chromosome preparations stained with high concentrations of quinacrine, energy transfer between dye molecules converts dyes bound near G-C base pairs into energy sinks. In contrast to its influence on quinacrine fluorescence, DNA base composition has very little effect on either quinacrine binding affinity or the circular dichroism of bound quinacrine molecules. The synthetic polynucleotides poly(dA-dT) and poly(dA)-poly(dT) have a similar effect on quinacrine fluorescence, but differ markedly in their affinity for quinacrine and in the circular dichroism changes associated with quinacrine binding. Quinacrine fluorescence intensity and lifetime are slightly less when bound to calf thymus chromatin than when bound to calf thymus DNA, and minor differences in circular dichroism between these complexes are observed. Chromosomal proteins probably affect the fluorescence of chromosomes stained with quinacrine, although this effect appears to be much less than that due to variations in DNA base composition. The fluorescence of cytological chromosome preparations may also be influenced by fixation effects and macroscopic variations in chromosome coiling.     

Mechanisms of chromosome banding

The binding of methylene blue to DNA and chromatin treated in various ways was examined by equilibrium dialysis. The maximum r value (moles of bound dye/mole of nucleotide) was 1.0 for DNA, 0.6 for unfixed chromatin, and 0.83 for chromatin fixed in methanol-acetic acid. When fixed chromatin was treated with saline-citrate at 60° C for 3 hours, as used for G-banding chromosomes, the r value decreased from 0.83 to 0.55. When unfixed chromatin was treated as for R-banding the r values also dropped. Equilibrium dialysis indicated there was no disproportionate increase of dye binding as the concentration of DNA increased. — These results, and others, suggest that some of the Giemsa negative regions of G- and R-banded chromosomes are due to the denaturation of non-histone proteins so that they more effectively cover the DNA and prevent side binding of the thiazin dyes.     

Calorimetry of DNA-dye interactions in aqueous solution: I. Proflavine and ethidium bromide

The results of an investigation on the interaction of proflavine and of ethidium bromide with DNA (calf thymus) in dilute aqueous solution are reported. The binding of the two dyes by DNA has been studied by means of microcalorimetric and of equilibrium dialysis measurements. Data on the thermodynamics of dimerization of both proflavine and ethidium bromide in aqueous solution obtained on the basis of spectroscopic and/or calorimetric experiments are also reported.The enthalpy data show that dye-dimerization and dye “strong” interaction with DNA are energetically favourable and quite similar while only in the latter case the phenomenon is also entropy driven. This is taken as further evidence in support of the concept that “strong” interaction-of both proflavine and ethidium bromide with DNA means dye molecules intercalation into the native, double helical structure of the biopolymer.     

Photodynamic activity of dyes with different DNA binding properties I. free-radical induction in DNA.

The photosensitizing efficiencies of eight dyes have been compared; two acridines, two xanthene derivatives, one sulphur-containing dye and three chemotherapeutic agents. The analysed reaction was the photosensitized induction of free radicals in calf-thymus DNA at low temperature. The binding of these dyes to DNA was first measured. Both strong (process I) and weak (process II) binding, with different intensities, either alone or together, were observed as mode of fixation. Whatever the nature of their binding, all the dyes used revealed a photosensitizing power as inducers of peroxide radicals in DNA. Their relative efficiencies, expressed as a function of the amount of dye molecules bound to DNA, were found to be very different. Intercalation, however, appeared to favour the free-radical induction as the first strongly bound molecules were more efficient.     

Structural transitions of chromatin at low salt concentrations: a flow linear dichroism study

We have studied the structure of nuclease-solubilized chromatin from Ehrlich ascites cells by flow linear dichroism (LD) using the anisotropic absorption of the DNA bases and of two intercalated dyes, ethidium bromide and methylene blue. It is confirmed that intercalation occurs preferentially in the linker part of the chromatin fiber, at binding ratios (dye/base) below 0.020. Using this information, we determined the orientation of the linker in relation to the average DNA organization in chromatin. The LD measurements indicate that the conformation of chromatin is considerably changed in the ionic strength interval 0.1-10 mM NaCl: with increasing salt concentration, the LD of the intrinsic DNA base absorption changes signs, from negative to positive, at approximately 2.5 mM NaCl. The LD of the intercalated dyes also changes signs, however, at a somewhat higher salt concentration. The results are analyzed in terms of possible allowed combinations of tilt angles of nucleosomes and pitch or tilt angles of linker DNA sections relative to the fiber axis, at different salt concentrations in the interval 0.1-10 mM NaCl. Two models for the salt-induced structural change of chromatin are discussed.     

DNA stainability in aneuploid breast tumors: comparison of four DNA fluorochromes differing in binding properties.

The aim of this study was to evaluate whether or not the differences in chromatin structure between diploid stromal cells or lymphocytes, which are often used as DNA ploidy standard, and aneuploid breast tumor cells can significantly affect the estimates of the DNA index of these tumors. To this end, the DNA content estimates of 34 aneuploid breast tumors, differing in size, degree of differentiation, and presence or absence of estrogen and progesterone receptors and metastases, were compared using four common DNA fluorochromes: DAPI, Hoechst 33342, propidium iodide, and acridine orange. These dyes differ in their mode of interaction with DNA (binding to minor groove or intercalation) and for each of them binding to DNA is restricted to a different degree by nuclear proteins. It was expected, therefore, that if differences in chromatin structure play a role in DNA content estimates, the DNA index of the measured tumors may vary depending on the dye. The cell nuclei were isolated from the tumors using a detergent-based procedure and stained with each of the dyes and the DNA index was estimated using peripheral blood lymphocytes as a DNA content standard. For each of the tumors, the DNA index estimates with all four dyes correlated very well. When the results obtained with individual dyes were compared in pairs, the correlation coefficients (r) of DNA indices were all above 0.96 (correlation at p less than 0.001). The best concordance was seen between specimens stained with Hoechst 33342 and DAPI (r = 0.99), and the least between those stained with Hoechst 33342 and propidium iodide (r = 0.96). The data indicate that DNA content analysis of unfixed nuclei, utilizing the above fluorochromes, is not significantly biased by differences in chromatin structure of the measured cells.     

Comparative evaluation of several DNA binding dyes in the detection of apoptosis-associated chromatin degradation by flow cytometry.

Mouse thymocytes readily undergo apoptosis-associated DNA degradation upon exposure to glucocorticoids or ionizing radiation. It has been previously shown that flow cytometric cell cycle analysis of propidium iodide-stained apoptotic thymocytes results in the appearance of a distinct cell cycle region (the A0 region) below the G0/G1 region. Cells in this region were shown to be undergoing apoptosis, and determination of apoptosis by flow cytometric analysis was proposed as a superior method for evaluating thymocyte apoptosis. In this study, a variety of DNA binding dyes with diverse primary binding mechanisms were evaluated for their ability to detect glucocorticoid and ionizing radiation-induced apoptosis in mouse thymocytes. Apoptotic thymocytes stained with DNA binding dyes from the phenanthridinium, acridine, actinomycin, chromomycinone, anthracycline, and bisbenzimidazole groups all demonstrated clearly defined A0 regions with percentages comparable to those obtained for propidium iodide. These results indicate that the appearance of the A0 region is not dependent on a particular dye binding characteristic and may be the consequence of extensive changes in chromatin structure resulting in a significant degree of dye exclusion.     

Incorporation and replication of foreign metaphase chromosomes in cultured mammalian cells

It is shown that the dyes used to produce banding patterns on chromosomes, quinacrine and Giemsa, are bound to DNA, and not to non-histone protein, the other chromosomal component remaining after acetic acid fixation. Studies on fixed nuclei and on extracted DNA in gelatine films show that the amount of dye bound is not affected by whether the DNA is native or denatured, and is not directly related to the amount of DNA present. Quinacrine is bound to the DNA ionically. With Giemsa, a new magenta compound is formed in situ, consisting of two molecules of methylene blue and one of eosin; this compound is attached to the chromosome by hydrogen bonds. Both quinacrine and the magenta compound formed from Giemsa appear to be attached to DNA molecules at two separate points, and the available evidence suggests that the amount of dye bound is related to the concentration of the DNA. It is suggested that the dye molecules bridge longitudinally separated sites brought into close proximity by folding of the DNA, and that the spatial arrangement of sites in the chromosome is influenced by non-histone proteins. It is concluded that chromosome banding is thus a consequence of the reduction of dye binding in those regions where the DNA chains become sufficiently dispersed to prevent bridging by the dye molecules. Possible indirect effects of base composition and repetition on dye binding at certain chromosomal sites are discussed.     

Apoptotic cell nuclei favour aggregation and fluorescence quenching of DNA dyes

 Apoptotic cell nuclei are known to stain hyperchromatically with absorption dyes and dimly with many DNA fluorochromes. We hypothesised that both optical phenomena have the same cause - the ability of apoptotic chromatin to aggregate cationic dyes. This hypothesis was tested using prednisolone-primed rat thymus, which is known to contain apoptotic cells. The apoptotic cells were classified as early and late, based on their morphology, in thin and semithin sections and in thymus imprints on slides. Direct reaction for DNA strand breaks (TUNEL) indicated the presence of breaks in both categories of cells, with more intense labelling in late apoptosis. The chromatin ultrastructure of early apoptotic cells initially retained the supranucleosomal order of packaging which characterises control cells, whereas the dense chromatin of late apoptotic cells possessed the degraded structure. Absorption spectra of the toluidine blue-stained early apoptotic cell chromatin revealed a metachromatic shift, indicating a change of DNA conformation and polymerisation of the dye. When the staining was performed by acridine orange (preceded by a short acid treatment), a paradoxical several-fold increase of fluorescence intensity at a several-fold dilution of the dye was found. The simultaneous reduction of the ratio of red to green components of fluorescence confirmed that the concentration-dependent fluorescence quenching was due to aggregation of the dye. The results suggest that the enhanced affinity of the chromatin of early apoptotic cells for cationic dyes is associated with conformational relaxation rather than degradation of DNA. In late apoptotic cells, the very dense packaging of degraded DNA promotes further aggregation of dyes. The results suggest alternative methods for detection and discrimination of early and late apoptotic cells. Accepted: 12 February 1997     

Fluorescence characteristics of DNA complexes with dyes of the bis-benzimidazole series

Fluorescence characteristics of DNA-specific dyes of bis-benzimidazole type in a wide range of pH and r = C/P were investigated. Fluorescence spectra of DNA complexes with bis-benzimidazoles have elements of a structure, which may result from a superposition of the spectra of dye molecules in different protonization group states that form different types of complexes with DNA. Experimental data do not contradict the idea of bis-benzimidazole dye binding into the minor groove of DNA. Bis-benzimide molecules in the deprotonization state have a major affinity to DNA.     

Effect of chemical structures of acridine and triphenylmethane dyes on the induced optical activity of DNA-dye complexes

Fifteen symmetrically substituted acridine dyes, all of which are interrelated by their chemical structures, each belonging to a C_2v symmetry, and three triphenylmethane dyes with amino or dimethylamino substituents are utilized to study necessary conditions for the appearance of extrinsic Cotton effects upon their binding to native and heat-denatured deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA). Three different kinds of the DNA–dye complexes, i.e., (1) dye added to native DNA, (2) heat-denatured DNA–dye complex, and (3) dye added to preheated DNA, were examined for each dye at a fixed P/D value of about 4. Optical activity was always observed for the compelexes of type (1) in each absorption band of the dyes in the visible and near-ultraviolet region. Two exceptions are 9-acetamido- and 9-hydroxyacridine, both being nonionic in aqueous solution at a pH range of 6. Acridinium chloride was unable to exhibit any definite extrinsic Cotton effect for complexes (2) and (3). Thus, the monocationic form of a dye due to the protonation or quaternization of the ring nitrogen in acridines or exonuclear amino nitrogen in triphenylmethane dyes is concluded to be an essential factor for extrinsic Cotton effect to appear. Changes in the absorption spectra upon complex formation are also related to the structure of dyes. Hypochromism and bathochromism are associated with the induced optical activity in all cases in the presence of native and denatured DNA.     

Development of a mechanism-based, DNA staining protocol using SYTOX orange nucleic acid stain and DNA fragment sizing flow cytometry

Accurate measurement of single DNA fragments by DNA fragment sizing flow cytometry (FSFC) depends upon precise, stoichiometric DNA staining by the intercalating dye molecules. In this study, we determined the binding characteristics of a commercially available 532 nm wavelength-excitable dye and used this information to develop a universal DNA staining protocol for DNA FSFC using a compact frequency-doubled Nd:YAG laser excitation source. Among twelve 532 nm wavelength-excitable nucleic acid staining dyes tested, SYTOX Orange stain showed the highest fluorescence intensity along with a large fluorescence enhancement upon binding to double-stranded DNA ( approximately 450-fold). Furthermore, using SYTOX Orange stain, accurate fragment-size-distribution histograms were consistently obtained without regard to the staining dye to base pair (dye/bp) ratio. A model describing two binding modes, intercalation (primary, yielding fluorescence) and external binding (secondary, involving fluorescence quenching), was proposed to interpret the performance of the dyes under different dye/bp ratios. The secondary equilibrium dissociation constant was found to be the most critical parameter in determining the sensitivity of each fluorophore to the staining dye/bp ratio. The measurements of both equilibrium dissociation constants provided us with a theoretical framework for developing a universal protocol which was successfully demonstrated over a wide range of DNA concentrations on a compact flow cytometer equipped with a frequency-doubled, diode-pumped, solid-state Nd:YAG laser for rapid and sensitive DNA fragment sizing.     

Induced circular dichroism of DNA-dye complexes

The binding of methylene blue, proflavine, and ethidium bromide with DNA has been studied by spectrophotometric titration. Methylene blue and proflavine or methylene blue and ethidium bromide were simultaneously titrated by DNA. The results indicate that all of these dyes compete for the same bindine sites. The binding properties are discussed in terms of symmetry. The optical properties of the dye–DNA complexes have been studied as a function of DNA/dye ratio. The induced circular dichriosm due to dye–dye interaction was measured at low dye/DNA ratios for cases involving both the same dye and different dyes. A positive Cotton effect for DNA–proflavine complex may be induced at 465 mμ by eithr proflavine or ethidium bromide, whereas a netgative Cotton effect at 465 mμ may be induced by methylene blue. The limiting circular dichroism, with no dye–dye interaction, and the induced circular dichroism spectra are discussed in terms of symmetry rules.     

Determination of the drug-DNA binding modes using fluorescence-based assays

Therapeutic drugs and environmental pollutants may exhibit high reactivity toward DNA bases and backbone. Understanding the mechanisms of drug-DNA binding is crucial for predicting their potential genotoxicity. We developed a fluorescence analytical method for the determination of the preferential binding mode for drug-DNA interactions. Two nucleic acid dyes were employed in the method: TO-PRO-3 iodide (TP3) and 4',6-diamidino-2-phenylindole (DAPI). TP3 binds DNA by intercalation, whereas DAPI exhibits minor groove binding. Both dyes exhibit significant fluorescence magnification on binding to DNA. We evaluated the DNA binding constant, K(b), for each dye. We also performed fluorescence quenching experiments with 11 molecules of various structures and measured a C(50) value for each compound. We determined preferential binding modes for the aforementioned molecules and found that they bound to DNA consistently, as indicated by other studies. The values of the likelihood of DNA intercalation were correlated with the partition coefficients of the molecules. In addition, we performed nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) studies of the interactions with calf thymus DNA for the three molecules. The results were consistent with the fluorescence method described above. Thus, we conclude that the fluorescence method we developed provides a reliable determination of the likelihoods of the two different DNA binding modes.     

Groove-binding unsymmetrical cyanine dyes for staining of DNA: syntheses and characterization of the DNA-binding

Two new crescent-shaped unsymmetrical cyanine dyes have been synthesised and their interactions with DNA have been investigated by different spectroscopic methods. These dyes are analogues to a minor groove binding unsymmetrical cyanine dye, BEBO, recently reported by us. In this dye, the structure of the known intercalating cyanine dye BO was extended with a benzothiazole substituent. To investigate how the identity of the extending heterocycle affects the binding to DNA, the new dyes BETO and BOXTO have a benzothiazole group and a benzoxazole moiety, respectively. Whereas BEBO showed a heterogeneous binding to calf thymus DNA, linear and circular dichroism studies of BOXTO indicate a high preference for minor groove binding. BETO also binds in the minor groove to mixed sequence DNA but has a contribution of non-ordered and non-emissive species present. A non-intercalative binding mode of the new dyes, as well as for BEBO, is further supported by electrophoresis unwinding assays. These dyes, having comparable spectral properties as the intercalating cyanine dyes, but bind in the minor groove instead, might be useful complements for staining of DNA. In particular, the benzoxazole substituted dye BOXTO has attractive fluorescence properties with a quantum yield of 0.52 when bound to mixed sequence DNA and a 300-fold increase in fluorescence intensity upon binding.     

Syntheses and DNA-binding studies of a series of unsymmetrical cyanine dyes: structural influence on the degree of minor groove binding to natural DNA

Twelve crescent-shaped unsymmetrical dyes have been synthesized and their interactions with DNA have been investigated by spectroscopic methods. A new facile synthetic route to this type of cyanine dyes has been developed, involving the preparation of 6-substituted 2-thiomethyl-benzothiazoles in good yields. The new dyes are analogues to the minor groove binding unsymmetrical cyanine dye, BEBO, recently reported by us. In this dye, the structure of the known intercalating cyanine dye BO was extended with a 6-methylbenzothiazole substituent. Herein we further investigate the role of the extending benzazole heterocycle, as well as of the pyridine or quinoline moiety of the cyanine chromophore, for the binding mode of these crescent-shaped dyes to calf thymus DNA. Flow LD and CD studies of the 12 dyes show that the extent of minor groove binding to mixed sequence DNA varies significantly between the dyes. We find that hydrophobicity and size are the crucial parameters for recognition of the minor groove. The relatively high fluorescence quantum yield of many of these cyanines bound to DNA, combined with their absorption at long wavelengths, may render them useful in biological applications. In particular, two of the benzoxazole containing dyes BOXTO and 2-BOXTO show a high degree of minor groove binding and quantum yields of 0.52 and 0.32, respectively, when bound to DNA.     

Photo-bleaching and photon saturation in flow cytometry.

In flow cytometry, small particles travel at a high speed through a bright light spot. The high light intensity at the point of measurement causes measurable photon saturation. This observation indicates that the rate at which individual dye molecules emit photons is close to the maximum emission rate. Despite the short exposure time, individual molecules may go through a few hundred excitation cycles while they are in the light beam. The absorbed light dose causes significant dye destruction. This article presents experimental procedures to determine the extent of photon saturation and photo-bleaching of dyes bound to cell nuclei in a flow cytometer. Measurements of Hoechst and propidium iodide bound to chromatin show that the amount of dye bleached per emitted photon is the same at low and high illumination intensities. This finding indicates that photon emission and dye destruction are both the result of the absorption of single excitation photons. The experimental observations allow rough estimates of the lifetime of the excited state and the lifetime of the molecule. The lifetime of the Hoechst 33258 bound to DNA is estimated to be 100 excitation-relaxation cycles. The average propidium iodide molecule lasts approximately 200 excitation-relaxation cycles. The theoretical considerations show that the optimal illumination conditions are different for bleaching and nonbleaching dyes. An optical arrangement for high precision measurements of bleaching dyes is presented.     

Compaction of 2-chain DNA as a method of procedure in determining its binding constant with antibiotics]

The binding of antibiotics and dyes with a compact form of DNA produced in water-salt solutions containing polyethylenglycol (PEG) presents a possibility of studying antibiotic interaction with DNA molecules contained in biological objects, such as viruses and chromosomes, since the compact form of DNA reflects some DNA properties in vivo. Possibly the use of the compact and not the "open" or linear form of DNA in chemical reactions will provide data on the efficiency of the compound "action" under conditions close to intracellular ones. The results well be useful in screening substances with "optimal" pharmacological effect. The paper presents a method for determination of the constant of antibiotic or dye binding with DNA and two-chain synthetic polynucleotides in water-salt solutions containing PEG. The method is based on "elimination" of the DNA molecules in the form of compact particles bound in a complex with an antibiotic or a dye. Comparison of the data with the results of estimation of the constants of antibiotic binding with DNA by the routine methods showed close conformity of the binding constants determined by different methods. It was found that the value of the binding constant of the antibiotics studied slightly depended on the structural state of DNA. The value was practically the same for the linear and the compact forms of DNA.     

Dielectric behavior of DNA--dye complex. II

The dielectric relaxation of native DNA and the effect of aminoacridine dyes, such as acridine orange (AO), proflavine (PF), and ethidium bromide (EB) have been investigated at different molar DNA phosphate (P) to dye (D) ratios in the frequency range 100 Hz–100 kHz. The static dielectric constant was observed to decrease with increasing binding of aminoacridines. This was interpreted as arising from the neutralization of the surface changes of the DNA molecules as a result of dye binding. At any P/D ratio the extent of charge neutralization was greatest for AO and least for the EB–DNA complex. The relaxation time (τ) for dye-bound DNA was greater compared to that for native DNA. This increase in τ was ascribed to the increase in the length of the dye-bound DNA. The maximum value of τ occurred at P/D = 20, 10, and 2 for AO-, PF-, and EB-treated DNA, respectively. The variation of τ at various levels of binding gave a qualitative idea about the conformational changes of DNA due to its binding with the dyes.     

A contribution to the theory of biological staining based on the principles for structural organization of biological macromolecules

Biological staining is to a large degree explainable based on the principles governing folding and aggregation of macromolecules in aqueous solution. Most macromolecules are polyions, which, except for heteropolysaccharides, have a large proportion of nonpolar or only slightly polar residues. Because they are amphiphilic, they react in water by a complex set of hydrophobic interactions involving charged residues, nonpolar residues and water molecules. The hydrophobic interactions lead to complex folding systems or micelle-like structures. Dyes are amphiphilic molecules with a tendency to form micelles, but with limitations due to geometric constraints and charge repulsion. Macromolecules and dyes react with each other in aqueous solution following the same principles as for the structural organization of macromolecules, as in protein folding for example. Dye binding requires near contact between nonpolar groups in both the dye and macromolecule, and this is accomplished by choosing a pH at which the dye and macromolecule have opposite net charges. Charge attraction is insufficient for binding in most cases, but it is directive because it determines which macromolecules a given dye ion is able to contact. These considerations apply to the staining of globular (cytoplasmic) proteins and to nucleic acid staining. The staining mechanism is by hydrophobic interactions. Above approximately pH 3.5, DNA may also bind dyes by hydrophobic intercalation between the bases of the double helix; at lower pH the double helix opens and dye binding is as for RNA and globular proteins. Heteroglycans (mucins) have virtually no nonpolar groups, so nonpolar interactions are restricted to the dye molecules. Metachromatic staining of heteroglycans is due to hydrophobic bonding or micelle formation between the monovalent planar dye molecules aided by charge neutralization by the negatively charged heteroglycans. Alternatively, as the charge attraction increases with the number of closely placed charges, acidic heteroglycans may be stained by a polycation such as alcian blue or colloidal iron. For elastic fiber and collagen staining, actual hydrophobic interactions are less important and hydrogen bonding and simple nonpolar interactions play a major role. These macromolecules may therefore be stained using a nonaqueous alcoholic solution.