Identity and ecophysiology of filamentous bacteria in activated sludge

Excessive growth of filamentous bacteria in activated sludge wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) can cause serious operational problems. With some filaments there may be the problem of bulking, where inadequate flocculation and settling of the biomass in the secondary clarifier results in a carryover of solids with the final treated liquid effluent. Their proliferation often encourages the development of stable foams on the surface of the reactors, and these foams may impact negatively on plant performance and operation. The availability of culture-independent molecular methods now allows us to identify many of the more common filamentous organisms encountered in WWTPs, which are phylogenetically diverse, affiliating to seven separate bacterial phyla. Furthermore, the extensive data published in the past decade on their in situ behaviour from the application of these culture-independent methods have not been summarized or reviewed critically. Hence, here, we attempt to discuss what we now know about their identity, ecophysiology and ecological niches and its practical value in better managing activated sludge processes. Some of this knowledge is already being applied to control and manage full-scale WWTPs better, and the hope is that this review will contribute towards further developments in this field of environmental microbiology.     

Clarifying the roles of kinetics and diffusion in activated sludge filamentous bulking

We hypothesized that the growth rates of filaments and floc formers in activated sludge are affected by the combination of kinetic selection (Lou and de los Reyes, Biotechnol Bioeng 92(6): 729-739, 2005b) and substrate diffusion limitation (Martins et al., Water Res 37:2555-2570, 2003). To clarify the influence of these factors in explaining filamentous bulking, a conceptual framework was developed in this study. The framework suggests the existence of three different regions corresponding to bulking, non-bulking, and intermediate regions, based on substrate concentration. In the bulking and non-bulking regions, kinetic growth differences control the competition process, and filaments or floc formers dominate, respectively. In the intermediate region, substrate diffusion limitation, determined by the floc size, plays the major role in causing bulking. To test this framework, sequencing batch reactors (SBRs) were operated with influent COD of 100, 300, 600, and 1,000 mg/L, and the sludge settleability was measured at various floc size distributions that were developed using different mixing strengths. The experimental data in the bulking and intermediate regions supported the proposed framework. A model integrating the two factors was developed to simulate the substrate concentrations at different depths and floc sizes under intermittently feeding conditions. The modeling results confirmed that substrate diffusion limitation occurs inside the flocs at a certain range of activated sludge floc sizes over the operation cycle, and provided additional support for the proposed framework.     

Multiple approaches to assess filamentous bacterial growth in activated sludge under different carbon source conditions

Aims:  To compare molecular and microscopic approaches in determining which filamentous bacteria grow in activated sludge reactors when different carbon sources and different activated sludge mixed liquor inocula are used.
Methods and Results:  Microscopic and molecular (Denaturing Gradient Gel Electrophoresis and Fluorescent In Situ Hybridization) techniques were used to determine which filamentous bacteria became dominant in lab scale reactors treating wastewater composed of different carbon sources. Molecular analysis indicated the presence of Sphaerotilus natans and Thiothrix -related organisms . Microscopy indicated the presence of Nostocoida limicola in some reactors. Sludge volume index increased as filament abundance increased. The detection level of DGGE analysis increased when the abundance levels of the filaments were high.
Conclusions:  Simultaneous application of traditional and molecular methods was effective, and highlighted the advantages and limitations of each method. Readily biodegradable substances favoured the growth of specific filaments in a mixed liquor environment. The origin of inoculum influenced which specific filamentous bacteria grew.
Significance and Impact of the Study:  The study shows the potential problems when using particular techniques, and highlights the need for multiple approaches when studying filaments. The study also provides more information on which filaments will grow under different carbon source conditions for a given inoculum.     

城市污水处理厂活性污泥生物泡沫研究进展

城市污水处理厂运行过程中一旦发生活性污泥生物泡沫,就会影响污泥沉降和处理厂运行效能,对出水水质、作业安全和公共健康带来一系列挑战。生物泡沫是自活性污泥法诞生以来长期困扰污水处理厂运行的难题。生物泡沫的形成需要气泡、表面活性物质和疏水物质等3点基本的要素,在其中主要富集了诺卡氏型丝状细菌(Nocardioformfilamentousbacteria)和微丝菌(Candidatus Microthrix parvicella)这两种类型微生物。多种环境和运行因素包括温度、溶解氧、pH、污泥龄、特别是营养物质种类和浓度等均会对这些丝状微生物的生长产生影响。抑制丝状细菌生长的常用控制策略包括选择器、生长动力学控制、投加化学药剂以及噬菌体等方法,通过降低两类丝状细菌在生化池中的浓度以期消除生物泡沫现象。本文总结了生物泡沫的类型、成因、表征生物泡沫程度的指标、影响生物泡沫的环境因素以及常用的调控策略的原理及优缺点等,尽可能全面地介绍活性污泥生物泡沫的研究现状,并探讨未来研究方向和控制策略,期望能够为今后研究活性污泥微生物和污水处理厂运行调控提供有价值的参考。     

Ecophysiology of abundant denitrifying bacteria in activated sludge

The abundance of potential denitrifiers in full-scale wastewater treatment plants with biological nitrogen and phosphorus removal was investigated by FISH and various oligonucleotide probes. The potential denitrifiers were characterized as probe-defined populations that were able to consume radiolabelled substrate with oxygen, nitrate and nitrite as electron acceptor as determined by microautoradiography. The most abundant potential denitrifiers were related to the genera Aquaspirillum, Azoarcus, Thauera and Rhodocyclus, all within the Betaproteobacteria. They made up 20-49% of all bacteria in most of the 17 nitrogen removal plants investigated and were hardly present in four plants without denitrification. The ecophysiology of Aquaspirillum, Azoarcus and Thauera-related bacteria was consistent within each probe-defined group in the plants investigated. These three groups showed distinct physiological differences, with the Aquaspirillum-related bacteria appearing as the most specialized one, consuming only amino acids among the substrates tested, and Thauera as the most versatile consuming some volatile fatty acids, ethanol and amino acids. The coexistence of Aquaspirillum, Azoarcus and Thauera-related bacteria in a range of treatment plants with differences in wastewater, design and operation suggest that the populations ensure a functional stability of the plants by occupying different ecological niches related to the carbon transformation.     

454 Pyrosequencing reveals bacterial diversity of activated sludge from 14 sewage treatment plants

Activated sludge (AS) contains highly complex microbial communities. In this study, PCR-based 454 pyrosequencing was applied to investigate the bacterial communities of AS samples from 14 sewage treatment plants of Asia (mainland China, Hong Kong, and Singapore), and North America (Canada and the United States). A total of 259 K effective sequences of 16S rRNA gene V4 region were obtained from these AS samples. These sequences revealed huge amount of operational taxonomic units (OTUs) in AS, that is, 1183–3567 OTUs in a sludge sample, at 3% cutoff level and sequencing depth of 16 489 sequences. Clear geographical differences among the AS samples from Asia and North America were revealed by (1) cluster analyses based on abundances of OTUs or the genus/family/order assigned by Ribosomal Database Project (RDP) and (2) the principal coordinate analyses based on OTUs abundances, RDP taxa abundances and UniFrac of OTUs and their distances. In addition to certain unique bacterial populations in each AS sample, some genera were dominant, and core populations shared by multiple samples, including two commonly reported genera of Zoogloea and Dechloromonas, three genera not frequently reported (i.e., Prosthecobacter, Caldilinea and Tricoccus) and three genera not well described so far (i.e., Gp4 and Gp6 in Acidobacteria and Subdivision3 genera incertae sedis of Verrucomicrobia). Pyrosequencing analyses of multiple AS samples in this study also revealed the minority populations that are hard to be explored by traditional molecular methods and showed that a large proportion of sequences could not be assigned to taxonomic affiliations even at the phylum/class levels.     

Quantification of Microthrix parvicella in activated sludge bacterial communities by real-time PCR

AIMS: This study was to develop a simple and reliable method for quantifying Microthrix parvicella 16S rRNA gene copies and its application to activated sludge samples collected from wastewater treatment plants (WWTP) with and without foaming problems. METHODS AND RESULTS: The relative frequency of M. parvicella was determined by combining real-time PCR assays for quantification of total bacterial 16S rRNA gene copies and M. parvicella 16S rRNA gene copies. The developed method was applied to analyse 32 activated sludge samples obtained from German WWTP. The level of M. parvicella 16S rRNA gene copies in the 18 nonfoaming samples was below 3% of the total number of 16S rRNA gene copies and in the range of 0-18% for the 14 foaming samples. CONCLUSIONS: The described method allows reliable monitoring of the amount of M. parvicella in activated sludge samples. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: The described method may become an important component of a warning system for forthcoming bulking and foaming episodes.     

A quantitative method for measuring the mass concentration of the filamentous bacterium Type 021N in activated sludge using fluorescence in situ hybridization

AIMS: This study aimed to develop a quantitative method for measuring mass concentrations of Type 021N, a bacterium causing bulking in activated sludge. METHODS AND RESULTS: Fluorescence in situ hybridization was used to determine the relationship between the concentration ratio of the mass of the bacterium Type 021N to mass of activated sludge, and the proportion of fluorescence area imparted by probe G123T specific for Type 021N to that obtained with probe EUB338 for bacteria. A linear relationship existed between the cube root of the mass concentration ratio and square root of this area proportion. CONCLUSIONS: A standard curve was obtained for quantifying Type 021N in activated sludge. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: This method may allow the determination of growth rate constant of filamentous bacteria in activated sludge, information that will help in understanding their ecology.     

Ecophysiology of mycolic acid-containing Actinobacteria (Mycolata) in activated sludge foams

Increasing incidences of activated sludge foaming have been reported in the last decade in Danish plants treating both municipal and industrial wastewaters. In most cases, foaming is caused by the presence of Actinobacteria; branched mycolic acid-containing filaments (the Mycolata) and the unbranched Candidatus'Microthix parvicella'. Surveys from wastewater treatment plants revealed that the Mycolata were the dominant filamentous bacteria in the foam. Gordonia amarae-like organisms and those with the morphology of Skermania piniformis were frequently observed, and they often coexisted. Their identity was confirmed by FISH, using a new permeabilization procedure. It was not possible to identify all abundant Mycolata using existing FISH probes, which suggests the presence of currently undetectable and potentially undescribed populations. Furthermore, some Mycolata failed to give any FISH signal, although substrate uptake experiments with microautoradiography revealed that they were physiologically active. Ecophysiological studies were performed on the Mycolata identified by their morphology or FISH in both foams and mixed liquors. Large differences were seen among the Mycolata in levels of substrate assimilation and substrate uptake abilities in the presence of different electron acceptors. These differences were ascribed mainly to the presence of currently undescribed Mycolata species and/or differences in foam age.     

Gram-staining characterisation of activated sludge filamentous bacteria by automated colour analysis

An automated image analysis method has been developed for the monitoring of the Gram-staining characteristics of filamentous bacteria in activated sludge. The binary method of pixel classification agreed with manual estimation (level of correlation of 0.9 for Gram-positive bacteria). Its robustness has been assessed by repeatability tests. Population shifts in terms of Gram-staining characteristics have been monitored in laboratory-scale experiments with two feeding schedules using this technique.Revisions requested 22 September 2004; Revisions received 11 October 2004     

京津冀区域市政污水厂活性污泥种群结构的多样性及差异

【背景】活性污泥中微生物的种群结构影响着污水生物处理的高效性及稳定性,是有效保证污水处理效果的关键。【目的】研究活性污泥中细菌的群落结构组成及多样性,并分析相应菌群的主要功能,旨在更好地发挥细菌的净化作用、保持污水处理过程的稳定及提高污水的处理效率。【方法】以京津冀区域内典型市政污水厂活性污泥为研究对象,通过IlluminaMiSeq高通量测序及实时定量PCR技术,对5个污水厂活性污泥的微生物种群结构特征进行了详细解析,研究不同工艺参数下活性污泥中优势种群及脱氮菌群丰度的差异。【结果】5个污水厂活性污泥种群结构具有一定差异,其中Hengshui (HS)厂污泥的群落结构受温度的影响最大,而Shahe (SH)、Daoxianghu (DXH)、Nangong(NG)厂活性污泥群落结构则受总氮、总磷与氨氮的共同影响,氨氮对SH厂活性污泥种群结构影响最大。DXH、NG和HS厂污泥中优势菌均为Anaerolineaceae,而SH和Hejian (HJ)厂的优势菌则为Saprospiraceae与Lactobacillus。活性污泥中反硝化菌丰度最高的为HJ厂,丰度最低的为HS厂,反硝化功能基因nirS比nirK分布更为广泛。【结论】对于不同污水厂,影响其活性污泥群落结构组成的环境因素也是不同的,并且特殊的进水水质也会对污泥菌群组成和生物多样性产生影响。     

Comparison of bacteriophage and enteric virus removal in pilot scale activated sludge plants

AIMS: The aim of this experimental study was to determine comparatively the removal of two types of bacteriophages, a somatic coliphage and an F-specific RNA phage and of three types of enteric viruses, hepatitis A virus (HAV), poliovirus and rotavirus during sewage treatment by activated sludge using laboratory pilot plants. METHODS AND RESULTS: The cultivable simian rotavirus SA11, the HAV HM 175/18f cytopathic strain and poliovirus were quantified by cell culture. The bacteriophages were quantified by plaque formation on the host bacterium in agar medium. In each experiment, two pilots simulating full-scale activated sludge plants were inoculated with viruses at known concentrations, and mixed liquor and effluent samples were analysed regularly. In the mixed liquor, liquid and solid fractions were analysed separately. The viral behaviour in both the liquid and solid phases was similar between pilots of each experiment. Viral concentrations decreased rapidly following viral injection in the pilots. Ten minutes after the injections, viral concentrations in the liquid phase had decreased from 1.0 +/- 0.4 log to 2.2 +/- 0.3 log. Poliovirus and HAV were predominantly adsorbed on the solid matters of the mixed liquor while rotavirus was not detectable in the solid phase. In our model, the estimated mean log viral reductions after 3-day experiment were 9.2 +/- 0.4 for rotavirus, 6.6 +/- 2.4 for poliovirus, 5.9 +/- 3.5 for HAV, 3.2 +/- 1.2 for MS2 and 2.3 +/- 0.5 for PhiX174. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: This study demonstrates that the pilots are useful models to assess the removal of infectious enteric viruses and bacteriophages by activated sludge treatment. Our results show the efficacy of the activated sludge treatment on the five viruses and suggest that coliphages could be an acceptable indicator of viral removal in this treatment system.     

Actinomycete diversity associated with foaming in activated sludge plants

Large numbers of mycolic acid-containing actinomycetes were isolated from foam and scum samples taken from three activated-sludge sewage-treatment plants using several selective isolation media. Organisms presumptively identified as gordonae formed the dominant population in all of the samples. A representative set of these strains have chemical properties consistent with their classification in the genusGordona. Forty-eight of theGordona strains were compared through 165 unit characters with the type strains of validly described species ofGordona. The resultant data were examined using the Jaccard and simple matching coefficients and clustering achieved using the unweighted pair group method with arithmetic averages algorithm. The numerical classification was only marginally affected by the statistics used or by test error, estimated as 3.92%. The isolates were assigned to five multi-membered and 28 single-membered clusters defined by the simple matching coefficient at the 89% similarity level. With few exceptions, the isolates were sharply separated from theGordona marker strains. Essentially the same classification was obtained when the test strains were examined using a Curie-point pyrolysis mass spectrometric procedure. It can be concluded that the gordonae form a heterogeneous taxonomic group, the members of which can be distinguished from representatives of validly described species ofGordona.     

Characterization of PHB storage in activated sludge extended filamentous bacteria by automated colour image analysis

The storage of poly-β-hydroxybutyrate (PHB) in extended filamentous bacteria from activated sludge was monitored by Sudan Black staining: PHB granules were blue in the reddish filaments counterstained by safranin. By quantitative image analysis of colour images grabbed on an optical microscope, the distribution of the PHB loading of the extended filaments was estimated by determination of the proportion of blue pixels of their skeleton. The method was applied for different feed compositions to demonstrate its ability to monitor the PHB synthesis and storage capacity of filamentous bacteria in mixed cultures. Fast PHB storage, within a few hours, could be observed with acetate-based feeding solutions but the storage rate decreased with more complex feeds (meat extract based feed, wastewater).     

Communities of ammonia-oxidizing bacteria in activated sludge of various sewage treatment plants in Tokyo

We investigated ammonia-oxidizing bacteria in activated sludge collected from 12 sewage treatment systems, whose ammonia removal and treatment processes differed, during three different seasons. We used real-time PCR quantification to reveal total bacterial numbers and total ammonia oxidizer numbers, and used specific PCR followed by denaturing gel gradient electrophoresis, cloning, and sequencing of 16S rRNA genes to analyze ammonia-oxidizing bacterial communities. Total bacterial numbers and total ammonia oxidizer numbers were in the range of 1.6 x 10(12) - 2.4 x 10(13) and 1.0 x 10(9) - 9.2 x 10(10)cellsl(-1), respectively. Seasonal variation was observed in the total ammonia oxidizer numbers, but not in the ammonia-oxidizing bacterial communities. Members of the Nitrosomonas oligotropha cluster were found in all samples, and most sequences within this cluster grouped within two of the four sequence types identified. Members of the clusters of Nitrosomonas europaea-Nitrosococcus mobilis, Nitrosomonas cryotolerans, and unknown Nitrosomonas, occurred solely in one anaerobic/anoxic/aerobic (A2O) system. Members of the Nitrosomonas communis cluster occurred almost exclusively in association with A2O and anaerobic/aerobic systems. Solid residence time mainly influenced the total numbers of ammonia-oxidizing bacteria, whereas dissolved oxygen concentration primarily affected the ammonia-oxidizing activity per ammonia oxidizer cell.     

Intergeneric coaggregations among Oligotropha carboxidovorans and Acinetobacter species present in activated sludge

The coaggregation traits of two pairs of sewage sludge bacteria were tested and characterized. Oligotropha carboxidovorans S23 coaggregated with two strains of the genus Acinetobacter viz. Acinetobacter junii S33 (56%) and Acinetobacter johnsonii S35 (99%). Coaggregates of O. carboxidovorans S23 and A. junii S33 were small (20-40 microm), weak and susceptible to EDTA and a commercial protease (Actinase E). Actinase/periodate pretreatment of the partners prior to coaggregation revealed that interaction in this case was mediated by protein surface components. Coaggregates of O. carboxidovorans S23 and A. johnsonii S35 were large (above 100 microm), strong and not deflocculated by EDTA or Actinase E. Only periodate pretreatment of A. johnsonii S35 prevented this coaggregation indicating a role for a carbohydrate-containing moiety without the involvement of protein components. The potential mechanisms and strength of bacterial coaggregations seem to be pair dependent.     

活性污泥丝状膨胀的模拟试验与控制对策研究

以新鲜的生活污水作为水样,采用同步培菌法,在培养活性污泥的基础上,模拟一定的条件促进丝状菌生长直至形成丝状膨胀,并探索消除丝状膨胀的控制措施,同时通过对丝状菌进行分析鉴定及生活特性显微观察,确定产生丝状膨胀的丝状菌的种类。因为实验能够较好地接近污水厂的实际情况,其结论对污水厂曝气池的正常运行具有实际指导作用。     

Enhancement of the activated sludge process by activated carbon produced from surplus biological sludge

Surplus biological sludge from wastewater treatment operations was converted into activated carbon and then added to the aerated vessel of an activated sludge process treating phenol and glucose. The addition of activated carbon, either sludge-based or commercial, enhanced phenol removal from 58 to 98.7% and from 87 to 93% for COD with feed concentrations of 100 mg phenol l^–1 and 2500 mg COD l^–1. No differences were found between the activated sludge-activated carbon bench scale continuous reactors operating with either commercial or sludge-based activated carbon in spite of the higher adsorption capacity of the former.     

Occurrence of ammonia-oxidizing Archaea in activated sludges of a laboratory scale reactor and two wastewater treatment plants

Aims:  Characterization of the ammonia-oxidizing archaea (AOA) community in activated sludge from a nitrogen removal bioreactor and wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs).
Methods and Results:  Three primer sets specific for ammonia mono-oxygenase α -subunit ( amoA ) were used to construct clone libraries for activated sludge sample from a nitrogen removal bioreactor. One primer set resulted in strong nonspecific PCR products. The other two clone libraries retrieved both shared and unique AOA amoA sequences. One primer set was chosen to study the AOA communities of activated sludge samples from Shatin and Stanley WWTPs. In total, 18 AOA amoA sequences were recovered and compared to the previous reported sequences. A phylogenetic analysis indicated that sequences found in this study fell into three clusters.
Conclusions:  Different primers resulted in varied AOA communities from the same sample. The AOA found from Hong Kong WWTPs were closely similar to those from sediment and soil, but distinct from those from activated sludge in other places. A comparison of clone libraries between Shatin WWTP and bioreactor indicated the AOA community significantly shifted only after 30-day enrichment.
Significance and Impact of the Study:  This study confirmed the occurrence of AOA in a laboratory scale nitrogen removal bioreactor and Hong Kong WWTPs treating saline or freshwater wastewater. AOA communities found in this study were significantly different from those found in other places. To retrieve diverse AOA communities from environmental samples, a combination of different primers for the amoA gene is needed.