Binding and recognition of GATATC target sequences by the EcoRV restriction endonuclease: a study using fluorescent oligonucleotides and fluorescence polarization

Oligonucleotides labeled with hexachlorofluorescein (hex) have enabled the interaction of the restriction endonuclease EcoRV with DNA to be evaluated using fluorescence anisotropy. The sensitivity of hex allowed measurements at oligonucleotide concentrations as low as 1 nM, enabling K(D) values in the low nanomolar range to be measured. Both direct titration, i.e., addition of increasing amounts of the endonuclease to hex-labeled oligonucleotides, and displacement titration, i.e., addition of unlabeled oligonucleotide to preformed hex-oligonucleotide/EcoRV endonuclease complexes, have been used for K(D) determination. Displacement titration is the method of choice; artifacts due to any direct interaction of the enzyme with the dye are eliminated, and higher fluorescent-labeled oligonucleotide concentrations may be used, improving signal-to-noise ratio. Using this approach (with three different oligonucleotides) we found that the EcoRV restriction endonuclease showed a preference of between 1.5 and 6.5 for its GATATC target sequence at pH 7.5 and 100 mM NaCl, when the divalent cation Ca2+ is absent. As expected, both the presence of Ca2+ and a decrease in pH value stimulated the binding of specific sequences but had much less effect on nonspecific ones.     

Role of magnesium ions in DNA recognition by the EcoRV restriction endonuclease

The restriction endonuclease EcoRV binds two magnesium ions. One of these ions, Mg(A)(2+), binds to the phosphate group where the cleavage occurs and is required for catalysis, but the role of the other ion, Mg(B)(2+) is debated. Here, multiple independent molecular dynamics simulations suggest that Mg(B)(2+) is crucial for achieving a tightly bound protein-DNA complex and stabilizing a conformation that allows cleavage. In the absence of Mg(B)(2+) in all simulations the protein-DNA hydrogen bond network is significantly disrupted and the sharp kink at the central base pair step of the DNA, which is observed in the two-metal complex, is not present. Also, the active site residues rearrange in such a way that the formation of a nucleophile, required for DNA hydrolysis, is unlikely.     

DNA recognition by the EcoRV restriction endonuclease probed using base analogues

The EcoRV restriction endonuclease recognises palindromic GATATC sequences and cuts between the central T and dA bases in a reaction that has an absolute requirement for a divalent metal ion, physiologically Mg(2+). Use has been made of base analogues, which delete hydrogen bonds between the protein and DNA (or hydrophobic interactions in the case of the 5-CH(3) group of thymine), to evaluate the roles of the outer two base-pairs (GATATC) in DNA recognition. Selectivity arises at both the binding steps leading to the formation of the enzyme-DNA-metal ion ternary complex (assayed by measuring the dissociation constant in the presence of the non-reactive metal Ca(2+)) and the catalytic step (evaluated using single-turnover hydrolysis in the presence of Mg(2+)), with each protein-DNA contact contributing to recognition. With the A:T base-pair, binding was reduced by the amount expected for the simple loss of a single contact; much more severe effects were observed with the G:C base-pair, suggesting additional conformational perturbation. Most of the modified bases lowered the rate of hydrolysis; furthermore, the presence of an analogue in one strand of the duplex diminished cutting at the second, unmodified strand, indicative of communication between DNA binding and the active site. The essential metal ion Mg(2+) plays a key role in mediating interactions between the DNA binding site and active centre and in many instances rescue of hydrolysis was seen with Mn(2+). It is suggested that contacts between the GATATC site are required for tight binding and for the correct assembly of metal ions and bound water at the catalytic site, functions important in providing acid/base catalysis and transition state stabilisation.     

EcoRV restriction endonuclease: communication between DNA recognition and catalysis.

A genetic system was constructed for the mutagenesis of the EcoRV restriction endonuclease and for the overproduction of mutant proteins. The system was used to make two mutants of EcoRV, with Ala in place of either Asn185 or Asn188. In the crystal structure of the EcoRV-DNA complex, both Asn185 and Asn188 contact the DNA within the EcoRV recognition sequence. But neither mutation affected the ability of the protein to bind to DNA. In the absence of metal ion cofactors, the mutants bound DNA with almost the same affinity as that of the wild-type enzyme. In the presence of Mg2+, both mutants retained the ability to cleave DNA specifically at the EcoRV recognition sequence, but their activities were severely depressed relative to that of the wild-type. In contrast, with Mn2+ as the cofactor, the mutant enzymes cleaved the EcoRV recognition site with activities that were close to that of the wild-type. When bound to DNA at the EcoRV recognition site, the mutant proteins bound Mn2+ ions readily, but they had much lower affinities for Mg2+ ions than the wild-type enzyme. This was the reason for their low activities with Mg2+ as the cofactor. The arrangement of the DNA recognition functions, at one location in the EcoRV restriction enzyme, are therefore responsible for organizing the catalytic functions at a separate location in the protein.     

Relaxed specificity of the EcoRV restriction endonuclease

The EcoRV restriction endonuclease normally shows a high specificity for its recognition site on DNA, GATATC. In standard reactions, it cleaves DNA at this site several orders of magnitude more readily than at any alternative sequence. But in the presence of dimethyl sulphoxide and at high pH, the EcoRV enzyme cleaves DNA at several sites that differ from its recognition site by one nucleotide. Of the 18 (3 X 6) possible sequences that differ from GATATC by one base, all were cleaved readily except for the following 4 sites: TATATC, CATATC, GATATA and GATATG. However, two of the sites that could be cleaved by EcoRV in the presence of dimethyl sulphoxide, GAGATC and GATCTC, were only cleaved on DNA that lacked dam methylation: both contain the sequence GATC, the recognition site for the dam methylase of Escherichia coli.     

Purification and crystallization of the EcoRV restriction endonuclease

The type II restriction endonuclease EcoRV purified from a genetically engineered, overproducing strain has been crystallized. Four crystal forms all obtained by precipitation with polyethylene glycol 4000 have been characterized. Two of these are suitable for high resolution structure analysis. Both are orthorhombic, have space group P2(1)2(1)2(1) and have similar unit cell dimensions of a = 58.2 A, b = 71.7 A, c = 130.6 A (form A) and a = 59.9 A, b = 74.5 A, c = 121.8 A (form B). They diffract to about 2A resolution and appear to have one dimer of 2 X 29,000 daltons in the asymmetric unit.     

Role of thymidine residues in DNA recognition by the EcoRI and EcoRV restriction endonucleases.

We have synthesized a series of oligonucleotides containing the EcoRI (GAATTC) or EcoRV (GATATC) recognition site within which or adjacent to which thymidine was substituted by uridine or derivatives of uridine. The effects of these substitutions on the rate of the EcoRI and EcoRV catalyzed cleavage reaction were investigated. Our results show that most of the substitutions within the site are quite well tolerated by EcoRI, not, however, by EcoRV. We conclude that the thymin residues most likely are not directly involved in the recognition process of the EcoRI reaction. In contrast, they are major points of contact, between substrate and enzyme in the EcoRV reaction. The effects of substitutions in the position adjacent to the recognition site is also markedly different for EcoRI and EcoRV. Here, EcoRI seems to be considerably more selective than EcoRV.     

EcoRV restriction endonuclease: communication between catalytic metal ions and DNA recognition.

In the absence of magnesium ions, the EcoRV restriction endonuclease binds all DNA sequences with equal affinity but cannot cleave DNA. In the presence of Mg2+, the EcoRV endonuclease cleaves DNA at one particular sequence, GATATC, at least a million times more readily than any other sequence. To elucidate the role of the metal ion, the reactions of the EcoRV restriction enzyme were studied in the presence of MnCl2 instead of MgCl2. The reaction at the EcoRV recognition site was slower with Mn2+. This was caused partly by reduced rates for phosphodiester hydrolysis but also by the translocation of the enzyme along the DNA after cleaving it in one strand. In contrast, alternative sites that differ from the recognition site by one base pair were cleaved faster in the presence of Mn2+ relative to Mg2+. When located at an alternative site on the DNA, the EcoRV enzyme bound Mn2+ ions readily but had a very low affinity for Mg2+. The EcoRV nuclease is thus restrained from cleaving DNA at alternate sites in the presence of Mg2+, but the restraint fails to operate with Mn2+. A discrimination factor, which measures the ratio of the activity of the EcoRV nuclease at its recognition site over that at an alternative site, had values of 3 x 10(5) in MgCl2 and 6 in MnCl2.     

Site-directed mutagenesis studies with EcoRV restriction endonuclease to identify regions involved in recognition and catalysis.

Guided by the X-ray structure analysis of a crystalline EcoRV-d(GGGATATCCC) complex (Winkler, in preparation), we have begun to identify functionally important amino acid residues of EcoRV. We show here that Asn70, Asp74, Ser183, Asn185, Thr186, and Asn188 are most likely involved in the binding and/or cleavage of the DNA, because their conservative substitution leads to mutants of no or strongly reduced activity. In addition, C-terminal amino acid residues of EcoRV seem to be important for its activity, since their deletion inactivates the enzyme. Following the identification of three functionally important regions, we have inspected the sequences of other restriction and modification enzymes for homologous regions. It was found that two restriction enzymes that recognize similar sequences as EcoRV (DpnII and HincII), as well as two modification enzymes (M.DpnII and, in a less apparent form, M.EcoRV), have the sequence motif -SerGlyXXXAsnIleXSer- in common, which in EcoRV contains the essential Ser183 and Asn188 residues. Furthermore, the C-terminal region, shown to be essential for EcoRV, is highly homologous to a similar region in the restriction endonuclease SmaI. On the basis of these findings we propose that these restriction enzymes and to a certain extent also some of their corresponding modification enzymes interact with DNA in a similar manner.     

Modes of DNA cleavage by the EcoRV restriction endonuclease

The mechanism of action of the EcoRV restriction endonuclease at its single recognition site on the plasmid pAT153 was analyzed by kinetic methods. In reactions at pH 7.5, close to the optimum for this enzyme, both strands of the DNA were cut in a single concerted reaction: DNA cut in only one strand of the duplex was neither liberated from the enzyme during the catalytic turnover nor accumulated as a steady-state intermediate. In contrast, reactions at pH 6.0 involved the sequential cutting of the two strands of the DNA. Under these conditions, DNA cut in a single strand was an obligatory intermediate in the reaction pathway and a fraction of the nicked DNA dissociated from the enzyme during the turnover. The different reaction profiles are shown to be consistent with a single mechanism in which the kinetic activity of each subunit of the dimeric protein is governed by its affinity for Mg2+ ions. At pH 7.5, Mg2+ is bound to both subunits of the dimer for virtually the complete period of the catalytic turnover, while at pH 6.0 Mg2+ is bound transiently to one subunit at a time. The kinetics of the EcoRV nuclease were unaffected by DNA supercoiling.     

Interaction of the restriction endonuclease ScaI with its substrates.

The kinetic constants of the site-specific endonuclease, ScaI, for various substrates were determined. We estimated Vmax and Km for octa-, deca-, dodeca-, and hexadecanucleotides and for plasmid pBR322 DNA. Vmax for these substrates were close, but Km were quite different (in decreasing order, octa- greater than deca-, dodeca-, hexadeca- greater than pBR322). The results were discussed with respect to the tertiary structure of substrate.     

Incorporation of a complete set of deoxyadenosine and thymidine analogues suitable for the study of protein nucleic acid interactions into oligodeoxynucleotides. Application to the EcoRV restriction endonuclease and modification methylase

A complete set of dA and T analogues designed for the study of protein DNA interactions has been prepared. These modified bases have been designed by considering the groups on the dA and T bases that are accessible to proteins when these bases are incorporated into double-helical B-DNA [Seeman, N. C., Rosenberg, J. M., & Rich, A. (1976) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 73, 804-808]. Each of the positions on the two bases, having the potential to interact with proteins, have been subject to nondisruptive, conservative change. Typically a particular group (e.g., the 6-NH2 of dA or the 5-CH3 of T) has been replaced with a hydrogen atom. Occasionally keto groups (the 2- and 4-keto oxygen atoms of T) have been replaced with sulfur. The base set has been incorporated into the self-complementary dodecamer d(GACGATATCGTC) at the central d(ATAT) sequence. Melting temperature determination shows that the modified bases do not destabilize the double helix. Additionally, circular dichroism spectroscopy shows that almost all the altered bases have very little effect on overall oligodeoxynucleotide conformation and that most of the modified oligomers have a B-DNA type structure. d(GATATC) is the recognition sequence for the EcoRV restriction modification system. Initial rate measurements (at a single oligodeoxynucleotide concentration of 20 microM) have been carried out with both the EcoRV restriction endonuclease and modification methylase. This has enabled a preliminary identification of the groups of the dA and T bases within the d(GATATC) sequence that make important contacts to both proteins.     

Properties of 2'-fluorothymidine-containing oligonucleotides: interaction with restriction endonuclease EcoRV

2'-Fluorothymidine (Tf) was synthesized via an improved procedure with (diethylamino)sulfur trifluoride. The compatibility of the analogue with DNA synthesis via the phosphoramidite method was demonstrated after complete enzymatic digestion of the oligonucleotides d(Tf11T) and d(Tf3T), the sole products of which were 2'-fluorothymidine and thymidine in the expected ratio. The 2'-fluorothymidine was also incorporated into the EcoRV recognition sequence (underlined), within the complementary oligonucleotides d(CAAACCGATATCGTTGTG) and d(CACAACGATATCGGTTTG). Thermal melting characteristics of these duplexes showed a significant decrease in stability only when both of the thymidine residues in one of the strands were replaced. In contrast, when all of one strand of a duplex contained 2'-fluorothymidine, as in d(Tf11T).d(A12), a substantially higher Tm and cooperativity of melting was observed relative to the unmodified structure. EcoRV cleaved a duplex that contained a 2'-fluorothymidine at the scissile linkage in each strand at two-thirds of the rate obtained for the unmodified structure. A duplex containing two 2'-fluorothymidine residues in one strand and none in the other was cleaved at one-third of the rate in its unsubstituted strand, whereas the cleavage rate was reduced to 22% in its modified strand.     

Solution parameters modulating DNA binding specificity of the restriction endonuclease EcoRV

The DNA binding stringency of restriction endonucleases is crucial for their proper function. The X-ray structures of the specific and non-cognate complexes of the restriction nuclease EcoRV are considerably different suggesting significant differences in the hydration and binding free energies. Nonetheless, the majority of studies performed at pH 7.5, optimal for enzymatic activity, have found a < 10-fold difference between EcoRV binding constants to the specific and nonspecific sequences in the absence of divalent ions. We used a recently developed self-cleavage assay to measure EcoRV-DNA competitive binding and to evaluate the influence of water activity, pH and salt concentration on the binding stringency of the enzyme in the absence of divalent ions. We find the enzyme can readily distinguish specific and nonspecific sequences. The relative specific-nonspecific binding constant increases strongly with increasing neutral solute concentration and with decreasing pH. The difference in number of associated waters between specific and nonspecific DNA-EcoRV complexes is consistent with the differences in the crystal structures. Despite the large pH dependence of the sequence specificity, the osmotic pressure dependence indicates little change in structure with pH. The large osmotic pressure dependence means that measurement of protein-DNA specificity in dilute solution cannot be directly applied to binding in the crowded environment of the cell. In addition to divalent ions, water activity and pH are key parameters that strongly modulate binding specificity of EcoRV.     

Stereochemical outcome of the hydrolysis reaction catalyzed by the EcoRV restriction endonuclease.

The stereochemical course of the reaction catalyzed by the EcoRV restriction endonuclease has been determined. This endonuclease recognizes GATATC sequence and cuts between the central T and dA bases. The Rp isomer of d(GACGATsATCGTC) (this dodecamer contains a phosphorothioate rather than the usual phosphate group between the central T and dA residues, indicated by the s) was a substrate for the endonuclease. Performing this reaction in H2 18O gave [18O]dps(ATCGTC) (a pentamer containing an 18O-labeled 5'-phosphorothioate) which was converted to [18O]dAMPS with nuclease P1. This deoxynucleoside 5'-[18O]phosphorothioate was stereospecifically converted to [18O]dATP alpha S with adenylate kinase and pyruvate kinase [Brody, R. S., & Frey, P. A. (1981) Biochemistry 20, 1245-1251]. Analysis of the position of the 18O in this product by 31P NMR spectroscopy showed that it was in a bridging position between the alpha- and beta-phosphorus atoms. This indicates that the EcoRV hydrolysis proceeds with inversion of configuration at phosphorus. The simplest interpretation is that the mechanism of this endonuclease involves a direct in-line attack at phosphorus by H2O with a trigonal bipyramidal transition state. A covalent enzyme oligodeoxynucleotide species can be discounted as an intermediate. An identical result has been previously observed with the EcoR1 endonuclease [Connolly, B. A., Eckstein, F., & Pingoud, A. (1984) J. Biol. Chem. 259, 10760-10763]. X-ray crystallography has shown that both of these endonucleases contain a conserved array of amino acids at their active sites. Possible mechanistic roles for these conserved amino acids in the light of the stereochemical findings are discussed.     

DNA cleavage by the EcoRV restriction endonuclease: pH dependence and proton transfers in catalysis.

To characterise the pH dependence of phosphodiester hydrolysis by the EcoRV endonuclease in the presence of Mn2+, single turnover reactions on a 12 bp DNA substrate were examined by stopped-flow and quench-flow methods between pH 6.0 and 8.5. At each pH value, the apparent rate constants for phosphodiester hydrolysis increased hyperbolically with the concentration of MnCl2, thus allowing values to be determined for the intrinsic rate constant at saturation with Mn2+ and the equilibrium dissociation constant for Mn2+. The equilibrium constants showed no systematic variation across the pH range tested, while the rate constants increased steeply with increasing pH up to an asymptote above pH 7.5. At low pH conditions, the gradient of a plot of log (rate constant) against pH approached a value of 2. DNA cleavage by EcoRV thus requires the de-protonation of two acidic groups. To determine whether aspartate 36 is one of the groups, mutants of EcoRV were made with other amino acid residues at position 36. Glutamate caused a partial loss of activity, while all other replacements gave near-zero activities. In contrast to wild-type EcoRV, the mutant with glutamate required the de-protonation of only one acidic group for DNA cleavage. A mechanism for EcoRV is proposed in which the water molecule that hydrolyses the phosphodiester bond is de-protonated by two Bronsted bases, probably the ionised forms of aspartate 36 and glutamate 45.     

Fidelity of DNA recognition by the EcoRV restriction/modification system in vivo

The EcoRV restriction/modification system consists of two enzymes that recognize the DNA sequence GATATC. The EcoRV restriction endonuclease cleaves DNA at this site, but the DNA of Escherichia coli carrying the EcoRV system is protected from this reaction by the EcoRV methyltransferase. However, in vitro, the EcoRV nuclease also cleaves DNA at most sites that differ from the recognition sequence by one base pair. Though the reaction of the nuclease at these sites is much slower than that at the cognate site, it still appears to be fast enough to cleave the chromosome of the cell into many fragments. The possibility that the EcoRV methyltransferase also protects the noncognate sites on the chromosome was examined. The modification enzyme methylated alternate sites in vivo, but these were not the same as the alternate sites for the nuclease. The excess methylation was found at GATC sequences, which are also the targets for the dam methyltransferase of E. coli, a protein that is homologous to the EcoRV methyltransferase. Methylation at these sites gave virtually no protection against the EcoRV nuclease: even when the EcoRV methyltransferase had been overproduced, the cellular DNA remained sensitive to the EcoRV nuclease at its noncognate sites. The viability of E. coli carrying the EcoRV restriction/modification system was found instead to depend on the activity of DNA ligase. Ligase appears to proofread the EcoRV R/M system in vivo: DNA, cut initially in one strand at a noncognate site for the nuclease, is presumably repaired by ligase before the scission of the second strand.     

Molecular recognition in the minor groove of the DNA helix. Studies on the synthesis of oligonucleotides and polynucleotides containing 3-deaza-2''-deoxyadenosine. Interaction of the oligonucleotides with the restriction endonuclease EcoRV.

An improved procedure for the preparation of 3-deaza-2'-deoxyadenosine (d3CA) is described which is suitable for the synthesis of gram quantities of this analogue. Using phosphoramidite chemistry d3CA has been incorporated into the Eco RV restiction endonuclease recognition sequence (underlined) present in the self-complementary dodecamer d(GACGATATCGTC). The modified oligonucleotides have been thoroughly characterised by nucleoside composition analysis, circular dichroism and thermal melting studies. Studies with Eco RV show that incorporation of d3CA into either the central or outer dA-dT base-pair results in a substantial reduction in the rate of cleavage. The two-step conversion of d3CA to 3-deaza-2'-deoxyadenosine-5'-O-triphosphate (d3CATP) via the 5'-O-tosylate is also described. d3CATP is not a substrate in the poly[d(AT)].poly[d(AT)] primed polymerisation for either E. coli DNA polymerase I or Micrococcus luteus DNA polymerase. In a more detailed kinetic analysis d3CATP was shown to be a competitive inhibitor of E. coli DNA polymerase I with respect to dATP.     

Synthesis of the oligodeoxyribonucleotide, d(CpTpGpGpApTpCpCpApG), and its substrate activity with the restriction endonuclease, BamHI

The synthesis of the DNA fragment, d(CpTpGpGpApTpCpCpApG), using a long-chain alkylamine-controlled pore glass bead polymer support, crystalline (9-phenyl-9-xanthenyl) nucleosides, and the bifunctional phosphorylating reagent, bis(1-benzotriazolyl)-2-chlorophenyl phosphate is described. For high coupling yields a mixed catalyst (1-methyl-imidazole + diisopropylethylamine) is required. The oligodeoxyribonucleotide shows activity with the DNA restriction endonuclease, BamHI. Kinetic parameters have been determined for the reaction.     

Expression,purification, and crystallization of restriction endonuclease PvuII with DNA containing its recognition site

We have overexpressed the type II restriction endonuclease PvuII (R.PvuII) in E. coli, prepared large amounts of the homogeneous enzyme, and crystallized it with an oligonucleotide carrying a PvuII recognition site. The cocrystals are orthorhombic space group P2₁2₁2₁ with cell constants a = 95.8 Å, b = 86.3 Å, c = 48.5 Å, and diffract X-rays to at least 2.7 Å. There is a complex of two protein subunits and one oligonucleotide duplex in the asymmetric unit. © 1994 Wiley-Liss, Inc.