Strategies for optimizing DNA hybridization on surfaces

Specific and predictable hybridization of the polynucleotide sequences to their complementary counterparts plays a fundamental role in the rational design of new nucleic acid nanodevices. Generally, nucleic acid hybridization can be performed using two major strategies, namely hybridization of DNA or RNA targets to surface-tethered oligonucleotide probes (solid-phase hybridization) and hybridization of the target nucleic acids to randomly distributed probes in solution (solution-phase hybridization). Investigations into thermodynamic and kinetic parameters of these two strategies showed that hybridization on surfaces is less favorable than that of the same sequence in solution. Indeed, the efficiency of DNA hybridization on surfaces suffers from three constraints: (1) electrostatic repulsion between DNA strands on the surface, (2) steric hindrance between tethered DNA probes, and (3) nonspecific adsorption of the attached oligonucleotides to the solid surface. During recent years, several strategies have been developed to overcome the problems associated with DNA hybridization on surfaces. Optimizing the probe surface density, application of a linker between the solid surface and the DNA-recognizing sequence, optimizing the pH of DNA hybridization solutions, application of thiol reagents, and incorporation of a polyadenine block into the terminal end of the recognizing sequence are among the most important strategies for enhancing DNA hybridization on surfaces.     

Hybridization of single-stranded DNA targets to immobilized complementary DNA probes: comparison of hairpin versus linear capture probes

A microtiter-based assay system is described in which DNA hairpin probes with dangling ends and single-stranded, linear DNA probes were immobilized and compared based on their ability to capture single-strand target DNA. Hairpin probes consisted of a 16 bp duplex stem, linked by a T₂-biotin·dT-T₂ loop. The third base was a biotinylated uracil (U_B) necessary for coupling to avidin coated microtiter wells. The capture region of the hairpin was a 3′ dangling end composed of either 16 or 32 bases. Fundamental parameters of the system, such as probe density and avidin adsorption capacity of the plates were characterized. The target DNA consisted of 65 bases whose 3′ end was complementary to the dangling end of the hairpin or to the linear probe sequence. The assay system was employed to measure the time dependence and thermodynamic stability of target hybridization with hairpin and linear probes. Target molecules were labeled with either a 5′-FITC, or radiolabeled with [γ-³³P]ATP and captured by either linear or hairpin probes affixed to the solid support. Over the range of target concentrations from 10 to 640 pmol hybridization rates increased with increasing target concentration, but varied for the different probes examined. Hairpin probes displayed higher rates of hybridization and larger equilibrium amounts of captured targets than linear probes. At 25 and 45°C, rates of hybridization were better than twice as great for the hairpin compared with the linear capture probes. Hairpin–target complexes were also more thermodynamically stable. Binding free energies were evaluated from the observed equilibrium constants for complex formation. Results showed the order of stability of the probes to be: hairpins with 32 base dangling ends > hairpin probes with l6 base dangling ends > 16 base linear probes > 32 base linear probes. The physical characteristics of hairpins could offer substantial advantages as nucleic acid capture moieties in solid support based hybridization systems.     

Computer simulation study of molecular recognition in model DNA microarrays

DNA microarrays have been widely adopted by the scientific community for a variety of applications. To improve the performance of microarrays there is a need for a fundamental understanding of the interplay between the various factors that affect microarray sensitivity and specificity. We use lattice Monte Carlo simulations to study the thermodynamics and kinetics of hybridization of single-stranded target genes in solution with complementary probe DNA molecules immobilized on a microarray surface. The target molecules in our system contain 48 segments and the probes tethered on a hard surface contain 8-24 segments. The segments on the probe and target are distinct and each segment represents a sequence of nucleotides ( approximately 11 nucleotides). Each probe segment interacts exclusively with its unique complementary target segment with a single hybridization energy; all other interactions are zero. We examine how the probe length, temperature, or hybridization energy, and the stretch along the target that the probe segments complement, affect the extent of hybridization. For systems containing single probe and single target molecules, we observe that as the probe length increases, the probability of binding all probe segments to the target decreases, implying that the specificity decreases. We observe that probes 12-16 segments ( approximately 132-176 nucleotides) long gave the highest specificity and sensitivity. This agrees with the experimental results obtained by another research group, who found an optimal probe length of 150 nucleotides. As the hybridization energy increases, the longer probes are able to bind all their segments to the target, thus improving their specificity. The hybridization kinetics reveals that the segments at the ends of the probe are most likely to start the hybridization. The segments toward the center of the probe remain bound to the target for a longer time than the segments at the ends of the probe.     

Dramatic increase in the signal and sensitivity of detection <Emphasis Type="Italic">via</Emphasis> self-assembly of branched DNA

In molecular testing using PCR, the target DNA is amplified via PCR and the sequence of interest is investigated via hybridization with short oligonucleotide capture probes that are either in a solution or immobilized on solid supports such as beads or glass slides. In this report, we report the discovery of assembly of DNA complex(es) between a capture probe and multiple strands of the PCR product. The DNA complex most likely has branched structure. The assembly of branched DNA was facilitated by the product of asymmetric PCR. The amount of branched DNA assembled was increased five fold when the asymmetric PCR product was denatured and hybridized with a capture probe all in the same PCR reaction mixture. The major branched DNA species appeared to contain three reverse strands (the strand complementary to the capture probe) and two forward strands. The DNA was sensitive to S1 nuclease suggesting that it had single-stranded gaps. Branched DNA also appeared to be assembled with the capture probes immobilized on the surface of solid support when the product of asymmetric PCR was hybridized. Assembly of the branched DNA was also increased when hybridization was performed in complete PCR reaction mixture suggesting the requirement of DNA synthesis. Integration of asymmetric PCR, heat denaturation and hybridization in the same PCR reaction mixture with the capture probes immobilized on the surface of solid support achieved dramatic increase in the signal and sensitivity of detection of DNA. Such a system should be advantageously applied for development of automated process for detection of DNA.     

Competitive reporter monitored amplification (CMA)--quantification of molecular targets by real time monitoring of competitive reporter hybridization

Background

State of the art molecular diagnostic tests are based on the sensitive detection and quantification of nucleic acids. However, currently established diagnostic tests are characterized by elaborate and expensive technical solutions hindering the development of simple, affordable and compact point-of-care molecular tests.

Methodology and Principal Findings

The described competitive reporter monitored amplification allows the simultaneous amplification and quantification of multiple nucleic acid targets by polymerase chain reaction. Target quantification is accomplished by real-time detection of amplified nucleic acids utilizing a capture probe array and specific reporter probes. The reporter probes are fluorescently labeled oligonucleotides that are complementary to the respective capture probes on the array and to the respective sites of the target nucleic acids in solution. Capture probes and amplified target compete for reporter probes. Increasing amplicon concentration leads to decreased fluorescence signal at the respective capture probe position on the array which is measured after each cycle of amplification. In order to observe reporter probe hybridization in real-time without any additional washing steps, we have developed a mechanical fluorescence background displacement technique.

Conclusions and Significance

The system presented in this paper enables simultaneous detection and quantification of multiple targets. Moreover, the presented fluorescence background displacement technique provides a generic solution for real time monitoring of binding events of fluorescently labelled ligands to surface immobilized probes. With the model assay for the detection of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 and 2 (HIV 1/2), we have been able to observe the amplification kinetics of five targets simultaneously and accommodate two additional hybridization controls with a simple instrument set-up. The ability to accommodate multiple controls and targets into a single assay and to perform the assay on simple and robust instrumentation is a prerequisite for the development of novel molecular point of care tests.     

Direct probing: covalent attachment of probe DNA to double-stranded target DNA.

We report a novel procedure, which can be applied to probing of specific DNA, for covalently attaching probe DNA to complementary sequences in double-stranded target DNA. Employing hairpin-like oligonucleotide probes in combination with successive use of recA protein and DNA ligase, probes can be attached directly to target DNA molecules without dissociation of the DNA. The hairpin-like structure of the probes was designed so that the terminus of the probe oligonucleotide can be brought into close stereochemical proximity to the terminus of the complementary strand of target DNA for ligation. Because of the elimination of the DNA dissociation and subsequent hybridization (and washing) steps in the currently employed method, the probing process has become greatly simplified and more efficient and may lead to development of fully automated probing systems.     

Shielding effect of monovalent and divalent cations on solid-phase DNA hybridization: surface plasmon resonance biosensor study

Solid-phase hybridization, i.e. the process of recognition between DNA probes immobilized on a solid surface and complementary targets in a solution is a central process in DNA microarray and biosensor technologies. In this work, we investigate the simultaneous effect of monovalent and divalent cations on the hybridization of fully complementary or partly mismatched DNA targets to DNA probes immobilized on the surface of a surface plasmon resonance sensor. Our results demonstrate that the hybridization process is substantially influenced by the cation shielding effect and that this effect differs substantially for solid-phase hybridization, due to the high surface density of negatively charged probes, and hybridization in a solution. In our study divalent magnesium is found to be much more efficient in duplex stabilization than monovalent sodium (15 mM Mg²⁺ in buffer led to significantly higher hybridization than even 1 M Na⁺). This trend is opposite to that established for oligonucleotides in a solution. It is also shown that solid-phase duplex destabilization substantially increases with the length of the involved oligonucleotides. Moreover, it is demonstrated that the use of a buffer with the appropriate cation composition can improve the discrimination of complementary and point mismatched DNA targets.     

Effect of unlabeled helper probes on detection of an RNA target by bead-based sandwich hybridization

Unlabeled helper oligonucleotides assisting a bead-based sandwich hybridization assay were tested for the optimal placement of the capture and detection probes. The target used was a full-length in vitro synthesized mRNA molecule. Helper probes complementary to regions adjacent to the binding site of the 5' end attached capture probe were found much more effective than helper probes targeting positions adjacent to the detection probe binding site. The difference is believed to be caused by a disruption of the RNA secondary structure in the area where the capture probe binds, thereby reducing structural interference from the bead. The use of additional helpers showed an additive effect. Using helpers at both sides of the capture and detection probes showed a 15- to 40-fold increase in hybridization efficiency depending on the target, thereby increasing the sensitivity of the hybridization assays. Using an electrical chip linked to the detection probe for the detection of p-aminophenol, which is produced by alkaline phosphatase, a detection limit of 2 x 10(-13) M mRNA molecules was reached without the use of a nucleic acid amplification step.     

Disposable DNA electrochemical sensor for hybridization detection

A disposable electrochemical sensor for the detection of short DNA sequences is described. Synthetic single-stranded oligonucleotides have been immobilized onto graphite screen printed electrodes with two procedures, the first involving the binding of avidinbiotinylated oligonucleotide and the second adsorption at a controlled potential. The probes were hybridized with different concentrations of complementary sequences. The formed hybrids on the electrode surface were evaluated by differential pulse voltammetry and chronopotentiometric stripping analysis using daunomycin hydrochloride as indicator of hybridization reaction. The probe immobilization step, the hybridization event and the indicator detection, have been optimized. The DNA sensor obtained by adsorption at a controlled potential was able to detect 1 microgram/ml of target sequence in the buffer solution using chronopotentiometric stripping analysis.     

Magnetic bead-based solid phase for selective extraction of genomic DNA

Magnetic bead-based solid phases are widely used for the separation of nucleic acids from complex mixtures. The challenge to selectively separate specific DNA molecules (via complementary hybridization) in a single step is the selection of a linker between the capture probe and the solid support that can be exposed to high temperatures in the presence of a high salt media. This article presents a general platform for the fabrication of a magnetic bead-based selective solid phase that can be used for subtractive hybridization or sequence capture applications. Phosphorus dendrimers are used for the first time as linkers in a magnetic bead-based selective solid phase for capture of genomic DNA. Aside from providing a high loading capacity, they render a stable bond between the capture probe and the surface under the high temperature and salt conditions required for denaturation and capture to proceed in a single step. The thermal stability of the solid phase under these conditions is first demonstrated by hybridizing a Cy3-labeled target. The selective capture of DNA targets in a single step is then demonstrated by subtractive hybridization of fragmented human genomic DNA. The specificity and selectivity of the solid phase are demonstrated by the recovery of adenovirus serotype 4 DNA spiked into the human DNA target. The effect of steric and electrostatic constraints was also investigated by using dendrimers of different generations that vary in their size and the number of branches. The results demonstrate that this platform can be used for single-step subtractive hybridization applications with better performance over the conventional two-step method using streptavidin-coated magnetic beads.     

Affinity capture and recovery of DNA at femtomolar concentrations with peptide nucleic acid probes

The efficacy of PNA vs DNA oligomers for the recovery of femtomolar concentrations of 16S rDNA targets was determined with solution- and mixed-phase hybridization formats and limiting dilution quantitative PCR. Several results contradict existing perceptions of expected PNA behavior deduced from hybridization studies with oligonucleotide targets at high concentration. For example, DNA probes in the solution hybridization format performed as well as or better than PNA probes under high- or low-salt conditions, regardless of hybridization time or target size. In the mixed-phase hybridization format, however, PNA probes showed certain advantages, with more rapid and efficient binding/recovery of target nucleic acids regardless of target size. Recovery of target DNA with PNA probes was always more efficient in low-salt (20 mM in Na(+)) than high-salt (400 mM in Na(+-)) phosphate buffer. Recovery of target DNA by PNA probes was enhanced in the presence of excess, nontarget DNA, and differences in PNA efficacy under low- or high-salt conditions vanquished. In contrast, DNA probe performance was unaffected by the presence or absence of exogenous DNA in both solution- and mixed-phase hybridization formats. The absolute recovery and detection limit of the affinity purification method with either DNA or PNA probes was approximately 10(2) input target molecules at zeptamolar concentrations.     

A sensitive nonisotopic hybridization assay for HIV-1 DNA

We have developed a microtiter-based sandwich hybridization assay for the detection of low copy number HIV-1 sequences. The assay employs a capture DNA sequence covalently coupled to microtiter wells through linker arms. The detection probe is a biotin-labeled DNA fragment derived from sequences adjacent to the capture sequence. After hybridization in the presence of sample nucleic acid, the detection probe remains bound only if the sample contained complementary sequences spanning the junction between capture and detection probes. The amount of detection probe bound is quantified by incubation with a peroxidase-streptavidin conjugate and a colorimetric peroxidase substrate. This assay has been combined with enzymatic target amplification to achieve sensitive detection of HIV-1 in patient samples. Following amplification of HIV-1 DNA using the polymerase chain reaction technique, a 190-bp product is produced. This product is easily and specifically quantified using the sandwich hybridization assay. The resulting test can detect one HIV-1-infected cell in 10(5) cells or about 30 molecules of HIV-1 DNA.     

Solution-phase detection of polynucleotides using interacting fluorescent labels and competitive hybridization

DNA was assayed in a homogeneous format using DNA probes containing hybridization-sensitive labels. The DNA probes were prepared from complementary DNA strands in which one strand was covalently labeled on the 5'-terminus with fluorescein and the complementary strand was covalently labeled on the 3'-terminus with a quencher of fluorescein emission, either pyrenebutyrate or sulforhodamine 101. Probes prepared in this manner were able to detect unlabeled target DNA by competitive hybridization producing fluorescence signals which increased with increasing target DNA concentration. A single pair of complementary probes detected target DNA at a concentration of approximately 0.1 nM in 10 min or about 10 pM in 20-30 min. Detection of a 4 pM concentration of target DNA was demonstrated in 6 h using multiple probe pairs. The major limiting factors were background fluorescence and hybridization rates. Continuous monitoring of fluorescence during competitive hybridization allowed correction for variable sample backgrounds at probe concentrations down to 20 pM; however, the time required for complete hybridization increased to greater than 1 h at probe concentrations below 0.1 nM. A promising application for this technology is the rapid detection of amplified polynucleotides. Detection of 96,000 target DNA molecules in a 50-microliters sample was demonstrated following in vitro amplification using the polymerase chain reaction technique.     

Electrochemical measurement of DNA hybridization using nanosilver as label and horseradish peroxidase as enhancer

A simple and sensitive electrochemical DNA biosensor based on in situ DNA amplification with nanosilver as label and horseradish peroxide (HRP) as enhancer has been designed. The thiolated oligomer single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) was initially directly immobilized on a gold electrode, and quartz crystal microbalance (QCM) gave the specific amount of ssDNA adsorption of 6.3 ± 0.1 ng/cm². With a competitive format, hybridization reaction was carried out via immersing the DNA biosensor into a stirred hybridization solution containing different concentrations of the complementary ssDNA and constant concentration of nanosilver-labeled ssDNA, and then further binding with HRP. The adsorbed HRP amount on the probe surface decreased with the increment of the target ssDNA in the sample. The hybridization events were monitored by using differential pulse voltammetry (DPV) with the adsorbed HRP toward the reduction of H₂O₂. The reduction current from the enzyme-generated product was related to the number of target ssDNA molecules in the sample. A detection of 15 pmol/L for target ssDNA was obtained with the electrochemical DNA biosensor. Additionally, the developed approach can effectively discriminate complementary from non-complementary DNA sequence, suggesting that the similar enzyme-labeled DNA assay method hold great promises for sensitive electrochemical biosensor applications.     

Microgravimetric DNA sensor based on quartz crystal microbalance: comparison of oligonucleotide immobilization methods and the application in genetic diagnosis

We report on the study of immobilization DNA probes onto quartz crystal oscillators by self-assembly technique to form variety types of mono- and multi-layered sensing films towards the realization of DNA diagnostic devices. A 18-mer DNA probe complementary to the site of genetic beta-thalassaemia mutations was immobilized on the electrodes of QCM by covalent bonding or electrostatic adsorption on polyelectrolyte films to form mono- or multi-layered sensing films by self-assembled process. Hybridization was induced by exposure of the QCMs immobilized with DNA probe to a test solution containing the target nucleic acid sequences. The kinetics of DNA probe immobilization and hybridization with the fabricated DNA sensors were studied via in-situ frequency changes. The characteristics of QCM sensors containing mono- or multi-layered DNA probe constructed by direct chemical bonding, avidin-biotin interaction or electrostatic adsorption on polyelectrolyte films were compared. Results indicated that the DNA sensing films fabricated by immobilization of biotinylated DNA probe to avidin provide fast sensor response and high hybridization efficiencies. The effects of ionic strength of the buffer solution and the concentration of target nucleic acid used in hybridization were also studied. The fabricated DNA biosensor was used to detect a set of real samples. We conclude that the microgravimetric DNA sensor with its direct detection of amplified products provide a rapid, low cost and convenient diagnostic method for genetic disease.     

Time-resolved detection probe for homogeneous nucleic acid analyses in one-step format

We report here an extension of homogeneous assays based on fluorescence intensity and lifetime measuring on DNA hybridization. A novel decay probe that allows simple one-step nucleic acid detection with subnanomolar sensitivity, and is suitable for closed-tube applications, is introduced. The decay probe uses fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) between a europium chelate donor and an organic fluorophore acceptor. The substantial change in the acceptor emission decay time on hybridization with the target sequence allows the direct separation of the hybridized and unhybridized probe populations in a time-resolved measurement. No additional sample manipulation or self-hybridization of the probes is required. The wavelength and decay time of a decay probe can be adjusted according to the selection of probe length and acceptor fluorophore, thereby making the probes applicable to multiplexed assays. Here we demonstrate the decay probe principle and decay probe-based, one-step, dual DNA assay using celiac disease-related target oligonucleotides (single-nucleotide polymorphisms [SNPs]) as model analytes. Decay probes showed specific response for their complementary DNA target and allowed good signal deconvolution based on simultaneous optical and temporal filtering. This technique potentially could be used to further increase the number of simultaneously detected DNA targets in a simple one-step homogeneous assay.     

The effect of surface probe density on DNA hybridization

The hybridization of complementary strands of DNA is the underlying principle of all microarray-based techniques for the analysis of DNA variation. In this paper, we study how probe immobilization at surfaces, specifically probe density, influences the kinetics of target capture using surface plasmon resonance (SPR) spectroscopy, an in situ label-free optical method. Probe density is controlled by varying immobilization conditions, including solution ionic strength, interfacial electrostatic potential and whether duplex or single stranded oligonucleotides are used. Independent of which probe immobilization strategy is used, we find that DNA films of equal probe density exhibit reproducible efficiencies and reproducible kinetics for probe/target hybridization. However, hybridization depends strongly on probe density in both the efficiency of duplex formation and the kinetics of target capture. We propose that probe density effects may account for the observed variation in target-capture rates, which have previously been attributed to thermodynamic effects.     

Fast quantification of nucleic acid hybrids by affinity-based hybrid collection.

A hybridization technique for the quantification of nucleic acids is described. In the method a probe pair is allowed to form hybrids with the target nucleic acid in solution. One of the probes has been modified with an affinity label, by which the formed hybrids can be isolated after the reaction. Streptavidin-agarose was used to capture hybrids containing biotinylated DNA. The hybrids were measured using radioiodine as label on the second probe. The rate of the hybridization reaction in solution is fast, allowing the whole procedure to be carried out in 3 h. The method is quantitative with a detection limit of 4 X 10(5) molecules (0.67 attomoles) target DNA. The test is insensitive to impurities in biological samples, which are analyzed without purification of the target DNA. Non-isotopic measurement of the hybrids can also be applied. In this case the hybrids are bound to microtitration wells and detected spectrophotometrically by peroxidase-catalyzed colour development.     

Target concentration dependence of DNA melting temperature on oligonucleotide microarrays

The design of microarrays is currently based on studies focusing on DNA hybridization reaction in bulk solution. However, the presence of a surface to which the probe strand is attached can make the solution‐based approximations invalid, resulting in sub‐optimum hybridization conditions. To determine the effect of surfaces on DNA duplex formation, the authors studied the dependence of DNA melting temperature (T_m) on target concentration. An automated system was developed to capture the melting profiles of a 25‐mer perfect‐match probe–target pair initially hybridized at 23°C. Target concentrations ranged from 0.0165 to 15 nM with different probe amounts (0.03–0.82 pmol on a surface area of 10¹⁸ Ų), a constant probe density (5 × 10¹² molecules/cm²) and spacer length (15 dT). The authors found that T_m for duplexes anchored to a surface is lower than in‐solution, and this difference increases with increasing target concentration. In a representative set, a target concentration increase from 0.5 to 15 nM with 0.82 pmol of probe on the surface resulted in a T_m decrease of 6°C when compared with a 4°C increase in solution. At very low target concentrations, a multi‐melting process was observed in low temperature domains of the curves. This was attributed to the presence of truncated or mismatch probes. © 2012 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 2012