Mirror image stereoisomers of the major benzo[a]pyrene N2-dG adduct are bypassed by different lesion-bypass DNA polymerases in E. coli

The potent mutagen/carcinogen benzo[a]pyrene (B[a]P) is metabolically activated to (+)-anti-B[a]PDE, which induces a full spectrum of mutations (e.g., G-to-T, G-to-A, -1 frameshifts, etc.) via its major adduct [+ta]-B[a]P-N2-dG. We recently showed that the dominant G-to-T mutation depends on DNA polymerase V (DNAP V), but not DNAPs IV or II, when studied in a 5'-TG sequence in E. coli. Herein we investigate what DNAPs are responsible for non-mutagenic bypass with [+ta]-B[a]P-N2-dG, along with its mirror image adduct [-ta]-B[a]P-N2-dG. Each adduct is built into a 5'-TG sequence in a single stranded M13 phage vector, which is then transformed into eight different E. coli strains containing all combinations of proficiency and deficiency in the three lesion-bypass DNAPs II, IV and V. Based on M13 progeny output, non-mutagenic bypass with [-ta]-B[a]P-N2-dG depends on DNAP IV. In contrast, non-mutagenic bypass with [+ta]-B[a]P-N2-dG depends on both DNAPs IV and V, where arguments suggest that DNAP IV is involved in dCTP insertion, while DNAP V is involved in extension of the adduct-G:C base pair. Numerous findings indicate that DNAP II has a slight inhibitory effect on the bypass of [+ta]- and [-ta]-B[a]P-N2-dG in the case of both DNAPs IV and V. In conclusion, for efficient non-mutagenic bypass (dCTP insertion) in E. coli, [+ta]-B[a]P-N2-dG requires DNAPs IV and V, [-ta]-B[a]P-N2-dG requires only DNAP IV, while DNAP II is inhibitory to both, and experiments to investigate these differences should provide insights into the mechanism and purpose of these lesion-bypass DNAPs.     

Toward an understanding of the role of DNA adduct conformation in defining mutagenic mechanism based on studies of the major adduct (formed at N(2)-dG) of the potent environmental carcinogen, benzo[a]pyrene

The process of carcinogenesis is initiated by mutagenesis, which often involves replication past damaged DNA. One question - what exactly is a DNA polymerase seeing when it incorrectly copies a damaged DNA base (e.g., inserting dATP opposite a dG adduct)? - has not been answered in any case. Herein, we reflect on this question, principally by considering the mutagenicity of one activated form of benzo[a]pyrene, (+)-anti-B[a]PDE, and its major adduct [+ta]-B[a]P-N(2)-dG. In previous work, [+ta]-B[a]P-N(2)-dG was shown to be capable of inducing>95% G-->T mutations in one sequence context (5'-TGC), and approximately 95% G-->A mutations in another (5'-AGA). This raises the question - how can a single chemical entity induce different mutations depending upon DNA sequence context? Our current working hypothesis is that adduct conformational complexity causes adduct mutational complexity, where DNA sequence context can affect the former, thereby influencing the latter. Evidence supporting this hypothesis was discussed recently (Seo et al., Mutation Res. [in press]). Assuming this hypothesis is correct (at least in some cases), one goal is to consider what these mutagenic conformations might be. Based on molecular modeling studies, 16 possible conformations for [+ta]-B[a]P-N(2)-dG are proposed. A correlation between molecular modeling and mutagenesis work suggests a hypothesis (Hypothesis 3): a base displaced conformation with the dG moiety of the adduct in the major vs. minor groove gives G-->T vs. G-->A mutations, respectively. (Hypothesis 4, which is a generalized version of Hypothesis 3, is also proposed, and can potentially rationalize aspects of both [+ta]-B[a]P-N(2)-dG and AP-site mutagenesis, as well as the so-called "A-rule".) Finally, there is a discussion of how conformational complexity might explain some unusual mutagenesis results that suggest [+ta]-B[a]P-N(2)-dG can become trapped in different conformations, and why we think it makes sense to interpret adduct mutagenesis results by modeling ds-DNA (at least in some cases), even though the mutagenic event must occur at a ss/ds-DNA junction in the presence of a DNA polymerase.     

Factors that influence the mutagenic patterns of DNA adducts from chemical carcinogens

Carcinogens are generally mutagens, which is understandable given that tumor cells grow uncontrollably because they have mutations in critical genes involved in growth control. Carcinogens often induce a complex pattern of mutations (e.g., GC-->TA, GC-->AT, etc.). These mutations are thought to be initiated when a DNA polymerase encounters a carcinogen-DNA adduct during replication. In principle, mutational complexity could be due to either a collection of different adducts each inducing a single kind of mutation (Hypothesis 1a), or a single adduct inducing different kinds of mutations (Hypothesis 1b). Examples of each are discussed. Regarding Hypothesis 1b, structural factors (e.g., DNA sequence context) and biological factors (e.g., differing DNA polymerases) that can affect the pattern of adduct mutagenesis are discussed. This raises the question: how do structural and biological factors influence the pattern of adduct mutagenesis. For structural factors, three possibilities are considered: (Hypothesis 2a) a single conformation of an adduct giving rise to multiple mutations -- dNTP insertion by DNA polymerase being influenced by (e.g.) the surrounding DNA sequence context; (Hypothesis 2b) a variation on this ("dislocation mutagenesis"); or (Hypothesis 2c) a single adduct adopting multiple conformations, each capable of giving a different pattern of mutations. Hypotheses 2a, 2b and 2c can each in principle rationalize many mutational results, including how the pattern of adduct mutagenesis might be influenced by factors, such as DNA sequence context. Five lines of evidence are discussed suggesting that Hypothesis 2c can be correct for base substitution mutagenesis. For example, previous work from our laboratory was interpreted to indicate that [+ta]-B[a]P-N(2)-dG in a 5'-CGG sequence context (G115) could be trapped in a conformation giving predominantly G-->T mutations, but heating caused the adduct to equilibrate to its thermodynamic mixture of conformations, leading to a decrease in the fraction of G-->T mutations. New work is described suggesting that [+ta]-B[a]P-N(2)-dG at G115 can also be trapped predominantly in the G-->A mutational conformation, from which equilibration can also occur, leading to an increase in the fraction of G-->T mutations. Evidence is also presented that the fraction of G-->T mutations is higher when [+ta]-B[a]P-N(2)-dG at G115 is in ss-DNA ( approximately 89%) vs. ds-DNA ( approximately 66%), a finding that can be rationalized if the mixture of adduct conformations is different in ss- and ds-DNA. In summary, the factors affecting adduct mutagenesis are reviewed and five lines of evidence that support one hypothesis (2c: adduct conformational complexity can cause adduct mutational complexity) are discussed.     

Toward an understanding of the role of DNA adduct conformation in defining mutagenic mechanism based on studies of the major adduct (formed at N-dG) of the potent environmental carcinogen, benzo[a]pyrene

The process of carcinogenesis is initiated by mutagenesis, which often involves replication past damaged DNA. One question — what exactly is a DNA polymerase seeing when it incorrectly copies a damaged DNA base (e.g., inserting dATP opposite a dG adduct)? — has not been answered in any case. Herein, we reflect on this question, principally by considering the mutagenicity of one activated form of benzo[a]pyrene, (+)-anti-B[a]PDE, and its major adduct [+ta]-B[a]P-N²-dG. In previous work, [+ta]-B[a]P-N²-dG was shown to be capable of inducing>95% G→T mutations in one sequence context (5′-T C), and 95% G→A mutations in another (5′-A A). This raises the question — how can a single chemical entity induce different mutations depending upon DNA sequence context? Our current working hypothesis is that adduct conformational complexity causes adduct mutational complexity, where DNA sequence context can affect the former, thereby influencing the latter. Evidence supporting this hypothesis was discussed recently (Seo et al., Mutation Res. [in press]). Assuming this hypothesis is correct (at least in some cases), one goal is to consider what these mutagenic conformations might be. Based on molecular modeling studies, 16 possible conformations for [+ta]-B[a]P-N²-dG are proposed. A correlation between molecular modeling and mutagenesis work suggests a hypothesis (Hypothesis 3): a base displaced conformation with the dG moiety of the adduct in the major vs. minor groove gives G→T vs. G→A mutations, respectively. (Hypothesis 4, which is a generalized version of Hypothesis 3, is also proposed, and can potentially rationalize aspects of both [+ta]-B[a]P-N²-dG and AP-site mutagenesis, as well as the so-called “A-rule”.) Finally, there is a discussion of how conformational complexity might explain some unusual mutagenesis results that suggest [+ta]-B[a]P-N²-dG can become trapped in different conformations, and why we think it makes sense to interpret adduct mutagenesis results by modeling ds-DNA (at least in some cases), even though the mutagenic event must occur at a ss/ds-DNA junction in the presence of a DNA polymerase.     

Molecular modeling of the major benzo[a]pyrene N2-dG adduct in cases where mutagenesis results are known in double stranded DNA

The potent mutagen/carcinogen benzo[a]pyrene (B[a]P) is metabolically activated to (+)-anti-B[a]PDE, which induces a full spectrum of mutations (e.g. GC-->TA, GC-->AT, etc.). One hypothesis for this complexity is that different mutations are induced by different conformations of its major adduct [+ta]-B[a]P-N2-dG when bypassed during DNA replication (probably by different DNA polymerases). Previous molecular modeling studies suggested that B[a]P-N2-dG adducts can in principle adopt at least 16 potential conformational classes in ds-DNA. Herein we report on molecular modeling studies with the eight conformations most likely to be relevant to base substitution mutagenesis in 10 cases where mutagenesis has been studied in ds-DNA plasmids in E. coli with B[a]P-N2-dG adducts of differing stereoisomers and DNA sequence contexts, as well as in five cases where the conformation is known by NMR. Of the approximately 11,000 structures generated in this study, the computed lowest energy structures are reported for 120 cases (i.e. eight conformations and 15 examples), and their conformations compared. Of the eight conformations, four are virtually always computed to be high in energy. The remaining four lower energy conformations include two with the BP moiety in the minor groove (designated: BPmi5 and BPmi3), and two base-displaced conformations, one with the dG moiety in the major groove (designated: Gma5) and one with the dG in the minor groove (designated: Gmi3). Interestingly, these four are the only conformations that have been observed for B[a]P-N2-dG adducts in NMR studies. Independent of sequence contexts and adduct stereochemistry, BPmi5 structures tend to look reasonably similar, as do BPmi3 structures, while the base-displaced structures Gma5 and BPmi3 tend to show greater variability in structure. A correlation was sought between modeling and mutagenesis results in the case of the low energy conformations BPmi5, BPmi3, Gma5 and Gma3. Plots of log[(G-->T)/(G-->A)] versus energy[(conformation X)-(conformation Y)] were constructed for all six pairwise combinations of these four conformations, and the only plot giving a straight line involved Gma5 and Gmi3. While this finding is striking, its significance is unclear (as discussed).     

In vitro replication of primer-templates containing benzo[a]pyrene adducts by exonuclease-deficient Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I (Klenow fragment): effect of sequence context on lesion bypass

The presence of benzo[a]pyrene diol epoxide (B[a]PDE) adducts in DNA is known to interfere with DNA replication. Kinetic studies of nucleotide insertion by exonuclease-deficient E. coli DNA polymerase I (Klenow fragment) across from either the (+)-trans- or the (+)-cis-B[a]P-N(2)-dG adduct in the 5'-CGT-3' sequence context indicated that the rate of nucleotide incorporation followed the order: dAMP > dGMP > dTMP > dCMP, which did not correlate with the mutational spectrum observed for these adducts in this sequence in E. coli (mostly G-->A transitions). Interestingly, a kinetic analysis of extension past the adduct showed that, unlike other sequences studied, the primer-template was extended best when dT was positioned at the 3'-terminus of the primer across from either a (+)-trans- or a (+)-cis-B[a]P-N(2)-dG adduct. In contrast, when the (+)-trans-B[a]P-N(2)-dG adduct was positioned in the 5'-TGC-3' sequence context, which gives predominantly G-->T mutations in E. coli, extension was detectable only when dA was positioned across from the adduct. These data provide the first in vitro evidence that may explain why G-->A transitions, rather than the G-->T transversions found in other sequences, are preferred in the 5'-CGT-3' sequence in vivo.     

The processing of a Benzo(a)pyrene adduct into a frameshift or a base substitution mutation requires a different set of genes in Escherichia coli

Replication through a single DNA lesion may give rise to a panel of translesion synthesis (TLS) events, which comprise error-free TLS, base substitutions and frameshift mutations. In order to determine the genetic control of the various TLS events induced by a single lesion, we have chosen the major N2-dG adduct of (+)-anti-Benzo(a)pyrene diol epoxide [(+)-anti-BPDE] adduct located within a short run of guanines as a model lesion. Within this sequence context, in addition to the major event, i.e. error-free TLS, the adduct also induces base substitutions (mostly G --> T transversions) and -1 frameshift mutations. The pathway leading to G --> T base substitution mutagenesis appears to be SOS independent, suggesting that TLS is most probably performed by the replicative Pol III holoenzyme itself. In contrast, both error-free and frameshift TLS pathways are dependent upon SOS-encoded functions that belong to the pool of inducible DNA polymerases specialized in TLS (translesional DNA polymerases), namely umuDC (Pol V) and dinB (Pol IV). It is likely that, given the diversity of conformations that can be adopted by lesion-containing replication intermediates, cells use one or several translesional DNA polymerases to achieve TLS.     

Amino Acid Architecture That Influences dNTP Insertion Efficiency in Y-Family DNA Polymerase V of E. coli

Y-family DNA polymerases (DNAPs) are often required in cells to synthesize past DNA-containing lesions, such as [+ ta]-B[a]P-N²-dG, which is the major adduct of the potent mutagen/carcinogen benzo[a]pyrene. The current model for the non-mutagenic pathway in Escherichia coli involves DNAP IV inserting deoxycytidine triphosphate opposite [+ ta]-B[a]P-N²-dG and DNAP V doing the next step(s), extension. We are investigating what structural differences in these related Y-family DNAPs dictate their functional differences. X-ray structures of Y-family DNAPs reveal a number of interesting features in the vicinity of the active site, including (1) the “roof-amino acid” (roof-aa), which is the amino acid that lies above the nucleobase of the deoxynucleotide triphosphate (dNTP) and is expected to play a role in dNTP insertion efficiency, and (2) a cluster of three amino acids, including the roof-aa, which anchors the base of a loop, whose detailed structure dictates several important mechanistic functions. Since no X-ray structures existed for UmuC (the polymerase subunit of DNAP V) or DNAP IV, we previously built molecular models. Herein, we test the accuracy of our UmuC(V) model by investigating how amino acid replacement mutants affect lesion bypass efficiency. A ssM13 vector containing a single [+ ta]-B[a]P-N²-dG is transformed into E. coli carrying mutations at I38, which is the roof-aa in our UmuC(V) model, and output progeny vector yield is monitored as a measure of the relative efficiency of the non-mutagenic pathway. Findings show that (1) the roof-aa is almost certainly I38, whose β-carbon branching R-group is key for optimal activity, and (2) I38/A39/V29 form a hydrophobic cluster that anchors an important mechanistic loop, aa29-39. In addition, bypass efficiency is significantly lower both for the I38A mutation of the roof-aa and for the adjacent A39T mutation; however, the I38A/A39T double mutant is almost as active as wild-type UmuC(V), which probably reflects the following. Y-family DNAPs fall into several classes with respect to the [roof-aa/next amino acid]: one class has [isoleucine/alanine] and includes UmuC(V) and DNAP η (from many species), while the second class has [alanine (or serine)/threonine] and includes DNAP IV, DNAP κ (from many species), and Dpo4. Thus, the high activity of the I38A/A39T double mutant probably arises because UmuC(V) was converted from the V/η class to the IV/κ class with respect to the [roof-aa/next amino acid]. Structural and mechanistic aspects of these two classes of Y-family DNAPs are discussed.     

The spacious active site of a Y-family DNA polymerase facilitates promiscuous nucleotide incorporation opposite a bulky carcinogen-DNA adduct: elucidating the structure-function relationship through experimental and computational approaches

Y-family DNA polymerases lack some of the mechanisms that replicative DNA polymerases employ to ensure fidelity, resulting in higher error rates during replication of undamaged DNA templates and the ability to bypass certain aberrant bases, such as those produced by exposure to carcinogens, including benzo[a]pyrene (BP). A tumorigenic metabolite of BP, (+)-anti-benzo-[a]pyrene diol epoxide, attacks DNA to form the major 10S (+)-trans-anti-[BP]-N(2)-dG adduct, which has been shown to be mutagenic in a number of prokaryotic and eukaryotic systems. The 10S (+)-trans-anti-[BP]-N(2)-dG adduct can cause all three base substitution mutations, and the SOS response in Escherichia coli increases bypass of bulky adducts, suggesting that Y-family DNA polymerases are involved in the bypass of such lesions. Dpo4 belongs to the DinB branch of the Y-family, which also includes E. coli pol IV and eukaryotic pol kappa. We carried out primer extension assays in conjunction with molecular modeling and molecular dynamics studies in order to elucidate the structure-function relationship involved in nucleotide incorporation opposite the bulky 10S (+)-trans-anti-[BP]-N(2)-dG adduct by Dpo4. Dpo4 is able to bypass the 10S (+)-trans-anti-[BP]-N(2)-dG adduct, albeit to a lesser extent than unmodified guanine, and the V(max) values for insertion of all four nucleotides opposite the adduct by Dpo4 are similar. Computational studies suggest that 10S (+)-trans-anti-[BP]-N(2)-dG can be accommodated in the active site of Dpo4 in either the anti or syn conformation due to the limited protein-DNA contacts and the open nature of both the minor and major groove sides of the nascent base pair, which can contribute to the promiscuous nucleotide incorporation opposite this lesion.     

Phenylalanine 171 is a molecular brake for translesion synthesis across benzo[a]pyrene-guanine adducts by human DNA polymerase kappa

Human cells possess multiple specialized DNA polymerases (Pols) that bypass a variety of DNA lesions which otherwise would block chromosome replication. Human polymerase kappa (Pol κ) bypasses benzo[a]pyrene diolepoxide-N(2)-deoxyguanine (BPDE-N(2)-dG) DNA adducts in an almost error-free manner. To better understand the relationship between the structural features in the active site and lesion bypass by Pol κ, we mutated codons corresponding to amino acids appearing close to the adducts in the active site, and compared bypass efficiencies. Remarkably, the substitution of alanine for phenylalanine 171 (F171), an amino acid conserved between Pol κ and its bacterial counterpart Escherichia coli DinB, enhanced the efficiencies of dCMP incorporation opposite (-)- and (+)-trans-anti-BPDE-N(2)-dG 18-fold. This substitution affected neither the fidelity of TLS nor the efficiency of dCMP incorporation opposite normal guanine. This amino acid change also enhanced the binding affinity of Pol κ to template/primer DNA containing (-)-trans-anti-BPDE-N(2)-dG. These results suggest that F171 functions as a molecular brake for TLS across BPDE-N(2)-dG by Pol κ and that the F171A derivative of Pol κ bypasses these DNA lesions more actively than does the wild-type enzyme.     

Genetic effects of oxidative DNA damages: comparative mutagenesis of the imidazole ring-opened formamidopyrimidines (Fapy lesions) and 8-oxo-purines in simian kidney cells

Fapy.dG and 8-oxo-7,8-dihydro-2'-deoxyguanosine (8-oxo-dG) are formed in DNA by hydroxyl radical damage. In order to study replication past these lesions in cells, we constructed a single-stranded shuttle vector containing the lesion in 5'-TGT and 5'-TGA sequence contexts. Replication of the modified vector in simian kidney (COS-7) cells showed that Fapy.dG is mutagenic inducing primarily targeted Fapy.G-->T transversions. In the 5'-TGT sequence mutational frequency of Fapy.dG was approximately 30%, whereas in the 5'-TGA sequence it was approximately 8%. In parallel studies 8-oxo-dG was found to be slightly less mutagenic than Fapy.dG, though it also exhibited a similar context effect: 4-fold G-->T transversions (24% versus 6%) occurred in the 5'-TGT sequence relative to 5'-TGA. To investigate a possible structural basis for the higher G-->T mutations induced by both lesions when their 3' neighbor was T, we carried out a molecular modeling investigation in the active site of DNA polymerase beta, which is known to incorporate both dCTP (no mutation) and dATP (G-->T substitution) opposite 8-oxo-G. In pol beta, the syn-8-oxo-G:dATP pair showed greater stacking with the 3'-T:A base pair in the 5'-TGT sequence compared with the 3'-A:T in the 5'-TGA sequence, whereas stacking for the anti-8-oxo-G:dCTP pair was similar in both 5'-TGT and 5'-TGA sequences. Similarly, syn-Fapy.G:dATP pairing showed greater stacking in the 5'-TGT sequence compared with the 5'-TGA sequence, while stacking for anti-Fapy.G:dCTP pairs was similar in the two sequences. Thus, for both lesions less efficient base stacking between the lesion:dATP pair and the 3'-A:T base pair in the 5'-TGA sequence might cause lower G-->T mutational frequencies in the 5'-TGA sequence compared to 5'-TGT. The corresponding lesions derived from 2'-deoxyadenosine, Fapy.dA and 8-oxo-dA, were not detectably mutagenic in the 5'-TAT sequence, and were only weakly mutagenic (<1%) in the 5'-TAA sequence context, where both lesions induced targeted A-->C transversions. To our knowledge this is the first investigation using extrachromosomal probes containing a Fapy.dG or Fapy.dA site-specifically incorporated, which showed unequivocally that in simian kidney cells Fapy.G-->T substitutions occur at a higher frequency than 8-oxo-G-->T and that Fapy.dA is very weakly mutagenic, as is 8-oxo-dA.     

Mutagenesis of benzo[a]pyrene diol epoxide in yeast: requirement for DNA polymerase zeta and involvement of DNA polymerase eta

Benzo[a]pyrene is a potent environmental carcinogen, which can be metabolized in cells to the DNA damaging agent anti-benzo[a]pyrene-7,8-dihydrodiol-9,10-epoxide (anti-BPDE). We hypothesize that mutations induced by BPDE DNA adducts are mainly generated through an error-prone translesion synthesis that requires a specialized DNA polymerase (Pol). Using an in vivo mutagenesis assay in the yeast model system, we have examined the potential roles of Pol(zeta) and Pol(eta) in (+/-)-anti-BPDE-induced mutagenesis. In cells proficient in mutagenesis, (+/-)-anti-BPDE induced 85% base substitutions with predominant G --> C followed by G --> T transversions, 9% deletions of 1-3 nucleotides, and 6% insertions of 1-3 nucleotides. In rad30 mutant cells lacking Pol(eta), (+/-)-anti-BPDE-induced mutagenesis was reduced and accompanied by a moderate decrease in base substitutions and more significant decrease in deletions and insertions of 1-3 nucleotides. In rev3 mutant cells lacking Pol(zeta), (+/-)-anti-BPDE-induced mutagenesis was mostly abolished, leading to a great decrease in both base substitutions and deletions/insertions of 1-3 nucleotides. In contrast, large deletions/insertions were significantly increased in cells lacking Pol(zeta). Consistent with the in vivo results, purified yeast Pol(zeta) performed limited translesion synthesis opposite (+)- and (-)-trans-anti-BPDE-N(2)-dG DNA adducts with predominant G incorporation opposite the lesion. These results show that (+/-)-anti-BPDE-induced mutagenesis in yeast requires Pol(zeta) and partially involves Pol(eta) and suggest that Pol(zeta) directly participates in nucleotide insertions opposite the lesion, while Pol(eta) significantly contributes to deletions and insertions of 1-3 nucleotides.     

Saturation of DNA mismatch repair and error catastrophe by a base analogue in Escherichia coli

Deoxyribosyl-dihydropyrimido[4,5-c][1,2]oxazin-7-one (dP) is a potent mutagenic deoxycytidine-derived base analogue capable of pairing with both A and G, thereby causing G. C --> A. T and A. T --> G. C transition mutations. We have found that the Escherichia coli DNA mismatch-repair system can protect cells against this mutagenic action. At a low dose, dP is much more mutagenic in mismatch-repair-defective mutH, mutL, and mutS strains than in a wild-type strain. At higher doses, the difference between the wild-type and the mutator strains becomes small, indicative of saturation of mismatch repair. Introduction of a plasmid containing the E. coli mutL(+) gene significantly reduces dP-induced mutagenesis. Together, the results indicate that the mismatch-repair system can remove dP-induced replication errors, but that its capacity to remove dP-containing mismatches can readily be saturated. When cells are cultured at high dP concentration, mutant frequencies reach exceptionally high levels and viable cell counts are reduced. The observations are consistent with a hypothesis in which dP-induced cell killing and growth impairment result from excess mutations (error catastrophe), as previously observed spontaneously in proofreading-deficient mutD (dnaQ) strains.     

Evidence for a Rad18-independent frameshift mutagenesis pathway in human cell-free extracts

Bypass of replication blocks by specialized DNA polymerases is crucial for cell survival but may promote mutagenesis and genome instability. To gain insight into mutagenic sub-pathways that coexist in mammalian cells, we examined N-2-acetylaminofluorene (AAF)-induced frameshift mutagenesis by means of SV40-based shuttle vectors containing a single adduct. We found that in mammalian cells, as previously observed in E. coli, modification of the third guanine of two target sequences, 5'-GGG-3' (3G) and 5'-GGCGCC-3' (NarI site), induces -1 and -2 frameshift mutations, respectively. Using an in vitro assay for translesion synthesis, we investigated the biochemical control of these events. We showed that Pol eta, but neither Pol iota nor Pol zeta, plays a major role in the frameshift bypass of the AAF adduct located in the 3G sequence. By complementing PCNA-depleted extracts with either a wild-type or a non-ubiquitinatable form of PCNA, we found that this Pol eta-mediated pathway requires Rad18 and ubiquitination of PCNA. In contrast, when the AAF adduct is located within the NarI site, TLS is only partially dependent upon Pol eta and Rad18, unravelling the existence of alternative pathways that concurrently bypass this lesion.     

Role of damage-specific DNA polymerases in M13 phage mutagenesis induced by a major lipid peroxidation product trans-4-hydroxy-2-nonenal

One of the major lipid peroxidation products trans-4-hydroxy-2-nonenal (HNE), forms cyclic propano- or ethenoadducts bearing six- or seven-carbon atom side chains to G > C ? A > T. To specify the role of SOS DNA polymerases in HNE-induced mutations, we tested survival and mutation spectra in the lacZα gene of M13mp18 phage, whose DNA was treated in vitro with HNE, and which was grown in uvrA^? Escherichia coli strains, carrying one, two or all three SOS DNA polymerases. When Pol IV was the only DNA SOS polymerase in the bacterial host, survival of HNE-treated M13 DNA was similar to, but mutation frequency was lower than in the strain containing all SOS DNA polymerases. When only Pol II or Pol V were present in host bacteria, phage survival decreased dramatically. Simultaneously, mutation frequency was substantially increased, but exclusively in the strain carrying only Pol V, suggesting that induction of mutations by HNE is mainly dependent on Pol V. To determine the role of Pol II and Pol IV in HNE induced mutagenesis, Pol II or Pol IV were expressed together with Pol V. This resulted in decrease of mutation frequency, suggesting that both enzymes can compete with Pol V, and bypass HNE-DNA adducts in an error-free manner. However, HNE-DNA adducts were easily bypassed by Pol IV and only infrequently by Pol II.Mutation spectrum established for strains expressing only Pol V, showed that in uvrA^? bacteria the frequency of base substitutions and recombination increased in relation to NER proficient strains, particularly mutations at adenine sites. Among base substitutions A:T → C:G, A:T → G:C, G:C → A:T and G:C → T:A prevailed.The results suggest that Pol V can infrequently bypass HNE-DNA adducts inducing mutations at G, C and A sites, while bypass by Pol IV and Pol II is error-free, but for Pol II infrequent.     

Mutagenic properties of estrogen quinone-derived DNA adducts in simian kidney cells

DNA damage caused by catechol estrogens has been shown to play an etiologic role in tumor formation. Catechol estrogens are reactive to DNA and form several DNA adducts via their quinone forms. To explore the mutagenic properties of 2-hydroxyestrogen-derived DNA adducts in mammalian cells, N(2)-(2-hydroxyestrogen-6-yl)-2'-deoxyguanosine and N(6)-(2-hydroxyestrogen-6-yl)-2'-deoxyadenosine adducts induced by quinones of 2-hydroxyestrone, 2-hydroxyestradiol, or 2-hydroxyestriol were incorporated site-specifically into the oligodeoxynucleotides ((5)(')TCCTCCTCXCCTCTC, where X is dG, dA, 2-OHE-N(2)-dG, or 2-OHE-N(6)-dA). The modified oligodeoxynucleotides were inserted into single-stranded phagemid vectors followed by transfection into simian kidney (COS-7) cells. Preferential incorporation of dCMP, the correct base, was observed opposite all 2-OHE-N(2)-dG adducts. Only targeted G --> T transversions were detected; the highest mutation frequency (18.2%) was observed opposite the 2-OHE(2)-N(2)-dG adduct, followed by 2-OHE(1)-N(2)-dG (4.4%) and 2-OHE(3)-N(2)-dG (1.3%). When 2-OHE-N(6)-dA adducts were used, preferential incorporation of dTMP, the correct base, was observed. Targeted mutations representing A --> T transversions were detected, accompanied by small numbers of A --> G transitions. The highest mutation frequencies were observed with 2-OHE(1)-N(6)-dA and 2-OHE(3)-N(6)-dA (14.5 and 14.1%, respectively), while 2-OHE(2)-N(6)-dA exhibited a mutation frequency of only 6.0%. No mutations were detected with vectors containing unmodified oligodeoxynucleotides. Thus, 2-OHE quinone-derived DNA adducts are mutagenic, generating primarily G --> T and A --> T mutations in mammalian cells. The mutational frequency varied depending on the nature of the 2-OHE moiety.     

In vivo evidence that phenylalanine 171 acts as a molecular brake for translesion DNA synthesis across benzo[a]pyrene DNA adducts by human DNA polymerase κ

Humans possess multiple specialized DNA polymerases that continue DNA replication beyond a variety of DNA lesions. DNA polymerase kappa (Pol κ) bypasses benzo[a]pyrene diolepoxide-N²-deoxyguanine (BPDE-N²-dG) DNA adducts in an almost error-free manner. In the previous work, we changed the amino acids close to the adducts in the active site and examined the bypass efficiency. The substitution of alanine for phenylalanine 171 (F171A) enhanced by 18-fold in vitro, the efficiencies of dCMP incorporation opposite (−)- and (+)-trans-anti-BPDE-N²-dG. In the present study, we established human cell lines that express wild-type Pol κ (POLK+/−), F171A (POLK F171A/−) or lack expression of Pol κ (POLK−/−) to examine the in vivo significance. These cell lines were generated with Nalm-6, a human pre-B acute lymphoblastic leukemia cell line, which has high efficiency for gene targeting. Mutations were analyzed with shuttle vectors having (−)- or (+)-trans-anti-BPDE-N²-dG in the supF gene. The frequencies of mutations were in the order of POLK−/− > POLK+/− > POLK F171A/− both in (−)- and (+)-trans-anti-BPDE-N²-dG. These results suggest that F171 may function as a molecular brake for bypass across BPDE-N²-dG by Pol κ and raise the possibility that the cognate substrates for Pol κ are not BP adducts in DNA but may be lesions in DNA induced by endogenous mutagens.     

Somatic hypermutation of immunoglobulin genes: lessons from proliferating cell nuclear antigenK164R mutant mice

Proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) encircles DNA as a ring-shaped homotrimer and, by tethering DNA polymerases to their template, PCNA serves as a critical replication factor. In contrast to high-fidelity DNA polymerases, the activation of low-fidelity translesion synthesis (TLS) DNA polymerases seems to require damage-inducible monoubiquitylation (Ub) of PCNA at lysine residue 164 (PCNA-Ub). TLS polymerases can tolerate DNA damage, i.e. they can replicate across DNA lesions. The lack of proofreading activity, however, renders TLS highly mutagenic. The advantage is that B cells use mutagenic TLS to introduce somatic mutations in immunoglobulin (Ig) genes to generate high-affinity antibodies. Given the critical role of PCNA-Ub in activating TLS and the role of TLS in establishing somatic mutations in immunoglobulin genes, we analysed the mutation spectrum of somatically mutated immunoglobulin genes in B cells from PCNA^K164R knock-in mice. A 10-fold reduction in A/T mutations is associated with a compensatory increase in G/C mutations—a phenotype similar to Polη and mismatch repair-deficient B cells. Mismatch recognition, PCNA-Ub and Polη probably act within one pathway to establish the majority of mutations at template A/T. Equally relevant, the G/C mutator(s) seems largely independent of PCNA^K164 modification.     

Replication of 2-hydroxyadenine-containing DNA and recognition by human MutSalpha

2-Hydroxyadenine (2-OH-A), a product of DNA oxidation, is a potential source of mutations. We investigated how representative DNA polymerases from the A, B and Y families dealt with 2-OH-A in primer extension experiments. A template 2-OH-A reduced the rate of incorporation by DNA polymerase alpha (Pol alpha) and Klenow fragment (Kf(exo-)). Two Y family DNA polymerases, human polymerase eta (Pol eta) and the archeal Dpo4 polymerase were affected differently. Bypass by Pol eta was very inefficient whereas Dpo4 efficiently replicated 2-OH-A. Replication of a template 2-OH-A by both enzymes was mutagenic and caused base substitutions. Dpo4 additionally introduced single base deletions. Thermodynamic analysis showed that 2-OH-A forms stable base pairs with T, C and G, and to a lesser extent with A. Oligonucleotides containing 2-OH-A base pairs, including the preferred 2-OH-A:T, were recognized by the human MutSalpha mismatch repair (MMR). MutSalpha also recognized 2-OH-A located in a repeat sequence that mimics a frameshift intermediate.     

Activities of human DNA polymerase kappa in response to the major benzo[a]pyrene DNA adduct: error-free lesion bypass and extension synthesis from opposite the lesion

In cells, the major benzo[a]pyrene DNA adduct is the highly mutagenic (+)-trans-anti-BPDE-N(2)-dG. In eukaryotes, little is known about lesion bypass of this DNA adduct during replication. Here, we show that purified human Polkappa can effectively bypass a template (+)-trans-anti-BPDE-N(2)-dG adduct in an error-free manner. Kinetic parameters indicate that Polkappa bypass of the (-)-trans-anti-BPDE-N(2)-dG adduct was approximately 41-fold more efficient compared to the (+)-trans-anti-BPDE-N(2)-dG adduct. Furthermore, we have found another activity of human Polkappa in response to the (+)- and (-)-trans-anti-BPDE-N(2)-dG adducts: extension synthesis from mispaired primer 3' ends opposite the lesion. In contrast, the two adducts strongly blocked DNA synthesis by the purified human Polbeta and the purified catalytic subunits of yeast Polalpha, Poldelta, and Pol epsilon right before the lesion. Extension by human Polkappa from the primer 3' G opposite the (+)- and (-)-trans-anti-BPDE-N(2)-dG adducts was mediated by a -1 deletion mechanism, probably resulting from re-aligning the primer G to pair with the next template C by Polkappa prior to DNA synthesis. Thus, sequence contexts 5' to the lesion strongly affect the fidelity and mechanism of the Polkappa-catalyzed extension synthesis. These results support a dual-function model of human Polkappa in bypass of BPDE DNA adducts: it may function both as an error-free bypass polymerase alone and an extension synthesis polymerase in combination with another polymerase.