Cytotoxicity and mutagenicity of alkylating agents in cultured mammalian cells (CHO/HGPRT system): mutagen treatment in the presence or absence of serum

Cytotoxicity and mutation induction at the hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyl transferase locus in Chinese hamster ovary cells (CHO/HGPRT system) were measured for a range of concentrations of 6 alkylating agents [methyl and ethyl methanesulfonate (MMS, EMS), N-methyl- and N-ethyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG, ENNG), and methyl- and ethyl-nitrosourea (MNU, ENU)] to determine the effect of the presence or absence of serum during the time of mutagen treatment. Cultures were treated with the mutagens for 5 h, a time period which results in no growth inhibition in the absence of serum, to estimate the potential decrease in effective mutagen dose to the cells which might result from reactivity with the serum proteins. With all 6 agents, identical results were found for cytotoxicity and for mutagenicity regardless of the presence or absence of serum during treatment. This finding demonstrates that the use of serum in cell-culture medium does not present any problems in apparent dosimetry studies, at least with these alkylating agents.     

Inactivation and mutation of coliphage T4 by aliphatic nitrosamides and methanesulphonates: in vitro recovery of infectivity of T4 inactivated by isopropyl methanesulphonate.

The inactivation and mutation (to r phenotype) of extracellular coliphage T4 wild-type by the monofunctional alkylating agents N-methyl- and N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea and isopropyl methanesulphonate were investigated. The rate and extent of change in phage infectivity observed during the post-treatment period were found to correlate with what is known of the mechanisms by which these agents react in vitro. Loss of phage infectivity was found to occur during the period following treatment with these agents, but that resulting from treatment with isopropyl methanesulphonate was preceded, in the first 24 to 48 h, by a recovery of infectivity. This suggested that changes in phage infectivity occurring after treatment with monofunctional alkylating agents are resultant of various processes which diversely promote loss and recovery of infectivity. The mutagenicity of N-methyl-N-nitrosourea was similar to that of its ethyl homologue at a level of phage survival of 4 x 10-3, but less than that of isopropyl methanesulphonate. At a level of survival of 3 x 10-2 ethyl methanesulphonate was a mutagenic as its isopropyl homologue, but methyl methanesulphonate was only slightly if at all mutagenic. These results could not be correlated with the compounds' reaction mechanisms. The efficiency of isopropyl methanesulphonate (compared with its toxicity to phage) was found to decrease as the severity of the dose was increased.     

Dependency of the yield of sister-chromatid exchanges induced by alkylating agents on fixation time. Possible involvement of secondary lesions in sister-chromatid exchange induction

Chinese hamster V79 cells were pulse-treated (for 60 min) with various mutagens three, two or one cell cycles before fixation (treatment variants A, B and C, respectively) and the frequencies of induced SCEs were analysed and compared. The degree of increase in frequency of SCEs with dose in the treatment variants depended on the mutagen used. For the methylating agents MNU, MNNG and DMPNU, high yields of SCEs were obtained in the treatment variants A and B, and there was no difference in the efficiency with which these agents induced SCEs in these treatment variants. In the treatment variant C, however, no SCEs were induced with mutagen doses yielding a linear increase in SCE frequency in treatment variants A and B. A slight increase in SCE frequency in treatment variant C was observed only when relatively high doses of MNU or MNNG were applied. Like the above agents, EMS, ENU and MMS induced more SCEs in treatment variants A and B than in C, but for these agents treatment variant B was most effective and SCEs were induced over the entire dose range, also in treatment variant C. As opposed to the methylating and ethylating agents, MMC induced SCEs with high efficiency when treatment occurred one or two generations prior to fixation. There was no difference in SCE frequency between these treatment variants. MMC was completely ineffective for the induction of SCEs when treatment occurred three generations before fixation. The unexpectedly low SCE frequencies induced by the methylating and ethylating agents when treatment occurred one generation before fixation were not due to the exposure of cells to BrdU prior to mutagen treatment. From the results obtained, it is concluded that DNA methylation and ethylation lesions give rise to SCEs only with very low probability during the replication cycle after the lesion's induction, and that subsequent lesions produced during or after replication of the methylated or ethylated template (secondary lesions) are of prime importance for SCE formation after alkylation. For MMC, however, primary lesions seem to be most important for SCE induction.     

The inactivation of bacteriophage R17 by ethylating agents: the lethal lesions.

The biological inactivation of bacteriophage R17 by ethyl methanesulphonate (EMS) and N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea (ENUA) has been studied. At the mean lethal dose for the first compound 8 moles ethyl are bound/mole RNA and with the nitroso compound 3.5 moles ethyl are bound. Analysis of the amounts of the different ethylated derivatives formed shows that the toxicity of the sulphonate can be accounted for by the formation of 3-ethylcytosine, O6-ethylguanine, 1-ethyladenine and chain breaks produced on the hydrolysis of ethyl phosphotriesters. With the nitroso derivative on the other hand, the sum of chain breaks and of bases alkylated on a position involved in specific hydrogen bonding between base pairs only accounts for 65% of the observed toxicity. The possibility that 3-ethyladenine may constitute a lethal lesion is discussed.     

Alkylation of cytosine and 5-hydroxymethyl-cytosine by methyl methanesulphonate and N-methyl-N-nitrosourea: its relevance to mutagenesis.

The reaction of cytosine and 5-hydroxymethyl-cytosine (OHMeCyt) with a variety of monofunctional alkylating agents has been investigated to evaluate further the possible role of cytosine alkylation in mutagenesis and the possibility that the immunity of T-even phages to mutation by methyl methanesulphonate (MMS) was due to the unreactivity of OHMeCyt towards this agent. Both cytosine and OHMeCyt reacted equally well with the methylating agents MMS and N-methyl-N-nitrosourea (MNU) affording 6% and less than 1% respectively of the 3-substituted derivative. No product was isolated following subjection of the bases to reaction with ethyl methane-sulphonate (EMS), N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea (ENU) or iso-propyl methane-sulphonate (iPMS).     

Mutagenicity of methyl-, ethyl-, propyl- and butylnitrosourea towards Escherichia coli WP2 strains with varying DNA repair capabilities.

Methyl- (MNUA), ethyl- (ENUA), propyl- (PNUA) and butylnitrosourea (BNUA) have been tested for toxicity and mutation in a liquid suspension assay towards Escherichia coli WP2 and some of its repair deficient derivatives. A comparison of survival rates after nitrosourea exposure between WP2 and WP2 uvrA showed no difference between the two strains but a consistent difference in potency between the various nitrosoureas studied. Toxicity increased in the order MNUA less than PNUA less than ENUA less than BNUA. ENUA and PNUA induced a greater number of trp+ revertants in both strains than did MNUA and BNUA, particularly at low survival rates. None of these differences in biological potency could be accounted for by differences in rates of hydrolysis. ENUA, PNUA and BNUA were non-mutagenic towards WP2 lexA, WP2 recA and WP2 uvrA lexA, whereas MNUA did induce mutations. Ethyl methanesulphonate (EMS) was able to mutate WP2 lexA. These results are discussed in the light of current theories regarding the mechanism of action of these compounds.     

Heritable translocation test and dominant-lethal assay in mice with methyl methanesulfonate.

A dominant-lethal test and a heritable translocation test were performed with methyl methanesulphonate (MMS) at 40 mg/kg by treating the sensitive periods of post-meiotic spermatogenesis i.e. spermatozoa and spermatids. In the dominant-lethal test 25 to 60% dominant-lethal mutations were obtained depending on the mating intervals. In the heritable translocation test 11% sterile and partially sterile F1 males were observed in 250 offspring of the MMS group. All of the 14 partially sterile and 6 of the 14 sterile F1 males were demonstrated to be translocation carriers. Fertility of the partial steriles was about 40% of normal fertility. The translocation frequencies in the primary spermatocytes of the partially sterile F1 males varied between 2 and 99%. Transmission of partial sterility and translocations was confirmed in the F2 generation. There were no partially sterile or sterile males among the 245 controls.     

Hypersensitivity of ataxia telangiectasia skin fibroblasts to DNA alkylating agents

3 ataxia telangiectasia (AT) fibroblast cell strains, AT4BI, AT5BI and AT2BE (CRL1343) were studied for their colony-forming ability after treatment with various concentrations of 4 different DNA alkylating agents. The results were compared to the response of fibroblast strains from 3 normal individuals. None of the AT strains were abnormally sensitive to N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine. 1 strain (AT5BI) was significantly more sensitive to treatment with methyl methanesulfonate (MMS) based on a survival curve D0 value of 0.29 mM vs. the normal average D0 of 0.38 mM (P less than 0.02) and a D10 value of 0.85 mM vs. the normal average D10 of 1.2 mM (P less than 0.025). Strain AT4BI was also significantly more sensitive to MMS treatment when D10 values were compared (0.73 mM, P less than 0.01). All 3 AT cell strains were significantly more sensitive to treatment with ethyl methanesulfonate when D10 values were the criterion of sensitivity, AT4BI 16 mM, AT5BI 13 mM and AT2BE 15 mM vs. the normal human fibroblast average D10 value of 28 mM (P less than 0.01 for all 3 AT strains). 2 of the 3 AT cell strains (AT4BI and AT2BE) were abnormally sensitive to treatment with 4-nitroquinoline-1-oxide; the D0 values were 0.045 microM and 0.05 microM, respectively, vs. the normal average D0 value of 0.11 microM (P less than 0.01 for both AT strains). The corresponding D10 values were 0.08 microM and 0.11 microM, respectively, vs. the normal average D10 value of 0.27 microM (P less than 0.01 for AT4BI and P less than 0.025 for AT2BE). These results indicate that there is a heterogeneity in the response of AT fibroblast cell strains to treatment with DNA alkylating agents, except possibly in the case of ethylating compounds.     

Radiation equivalent of genotoxic chemicals: Validation in cultured mammalian cell lines

Published data on mutations induced by ionizing radiation and 6 monofunctional alkylating agents, namely EMS, MMS, ENNG, MNNG, ENU and MNU, in different cell lines (Chinese hamster ovary, Chinese hamster lung V79, mouse lymphoma L5178 and human cells) were analysed so that radiation-equivalent chemical (REC) values could be calculated.REC values thus obtained for a given alkylating agent with different cell lines fall within a narrow range suggesting its validation in cultured mammalian cell systems including human.     

Relative mutagenicity of antineoplastic drugs and other alkylating agents in V79 chinese hamster cells,independence of cytotoxic and mutagenic responses

The mutagenic and cytotoxic effects of 4 antineoplastic drugs, vinblastine, vincristine, adriamycin and nitrogen mustard and of several monofunctional alkylating agents have been assayed in V79 Chinese hamster cells. Vincristine, vinblastine and nitrogen mustard did not significantly increase the frequency of TG^RHGPRT^? mutants but were all highly cytotoxic. Adriamycin and the monofunctional alkylating agents were all significantly mutagenic even at the lowest doses tested (approx. 70 % survival level). Induced mutant frequency increased linearly with increasing dose whereas dose-response curves for cytotoxicity for these effective mutagens invariably showed a shoulder followed by an exponential decline. At equitoxic doses the relative mutagenic effectiveness was MNU ENU EMS MMS ? DMS. MNU was approx. 20 times more effective than MMS and DMS.Measurement of the total amount of alkylation and the relative amounts of reaction with individual DNA bases at approx. equitoxic doses of MNU and DMS indicated a significantly higher O⁶/N⁷ ratio after MNU (0.15) than after DMS (0.005). However, approx. equal numbers of mutants/10⁵ cells/μM O⁶-Meguanine were induced by these 2 agents. These results support previous conclusions, that mutagenic and cytotoxic responses are independent in V79 cells.     

Assay of cytotoxicity and mutagenicity of alkylating agents by using Neurospora spheroplasts

A system relying on the use of Neurospora crassa spheroplasts has been developed for the assay of cytotoxicity and mutagenicity of chemical compounds. Mutagenicity was assayed by using reversion of alleles in the am gene selected to recognize certain specified transitions and also undefined point mutations. Cytotoxicity was quantified by measuring a 'cytotoxicity parameter', m, which appears in the exponential function that fits the survival/dose curve for each compound (under standard incubation conditions). Of the compounds tested, nitrogen mustard (Cl(CH2)2 NMe(CH2)2Cl) was cytotoxic and non-mutagenic, and ethyl nitrosourea was highly mutagenic but not cytotoxic. Of the remaining compounds tested, methyl nitrosourea, butadiene diepoxide, and cis platin (cis diammonia platinum II chloride) all showed comparable mutagenicity per survivor, although the values of m covered a wide range. Differences were found between the different compounds in the effects of the uvs-2 allele on survival and on the preponderance of G to A transitions.     

A comparison of mutation induction by 14 MeV fast neutrons and 137 Cs -rays in meiotic spermatocytes in the silkworm

Barley seeds were treated with methyl methanesulphonate (MMS) and ethyl methanesulphonate (EMS), stored at 15% water content and washed for 16–24 h. These treatments resulted in an increase of toxic and genetic effects. In teh DNA of embryos of such stored MMS- and EMS-treated seeds, a strong enhancement of the amount of single-strand breaks and/or alkali-labile sites took place. In contrast, the amount of alkylated sites, particularly of 7-methylguanine, was somewhat lower. It can be that the depurination and/or backbone breakage, which proceeds during the storage period, is responsible for the enhancement of toxic and genetic effects, whereas the influence of the alkylation of DNA during the storage period by the unreacted residual mutagen is negligible.     

Effect of N-nitroso-N-methylurea on viability and mutagenic response of repair-deficient strains of Escherichia coli

Various E. coli mutants, deficient in DNA repair, differed in their response to increasing concentrations of N-nitroso-N-methylurea (NMU).Loss of viability due to exposure to NMU was greatest in those strains with a reduced capacity for repair of single-strand breaks. Viability of wild-type and uvrA^? strains was not affected by NMU concentrations up to 3.0 mM. Some loss of viability occurred, at the higher NMU concentrations, in both strains carrying exrA^? while strains carrying uvrA^?polA^? or recA^? were the most sensitive. The results support the hypothesis that the lethal effect of NMU on repair-deficient E. coli was due to its ability to induce single-strand breaks.Induction of mutations by NMU was observed in all the strains used and the results suggested that NMU damage per se was the major mutational event. The dose response curve for induction of revertants by NMU was, however, influenced by the repair system(s) present. The number of revertants scored at the higher NMU concentrations was greater in those strains lacking the recA and polA dependent repair functions than in the wild-type strain. However, at NMU concentrations below 2.0 mM the numbers of revertants induced in exrA^? carrying strains, prossessing accurate rec-dependent repair, were lower than the comparable wild-type values. The evidence suggests that the uvrA gene product also acts on some, possibly non-mutagenic, types of NMU damage and that error-prone repair of these lesions increases the number of potential revertants.     

Synergistic effect of an Escherichia coli mutator gene on mutagenesis by ultraviolet radiation and by alkylating agents

E. coli strains differing in a gene responsible for high spontaneous mutability (mut HI) were compared for their mutability by UV radiation and by the alkylating agents ethyl methanesulfonate and methyl methanesulfonate. All three exogenous mutagenic agents induced significantly higher frequencies of mutants with impaired carbohydrate-fermenting ability when the mutator allele rather than the wild-type allele was present. Thus the mut HI gene product possibly increases the probability of replication error due to alterations in the structure of the template strand of DNA. An attempt to detect an synergistic effect for UV-induced suppressor mutations was unsuccessful. The failure may have been due to the particular method used for scoring this type of mutation.     

Factors affecting the quantitation of dose-response curves for mutation induction in V79 Chinese hamster cells after exposure to chemical and physical mutagens.

Using four common mutagens, ethyl methanesulphonate (EMS), methyl methanesulphonate (mms), uv, and X-irradiation, the relationship between dose of mutagen, cellular lethality and frequency of 8-azaguanine resistant colonies in V79 Chinese hamster cells has been examined. Several factors affecting the recovery of mutants including inter and intra-clone metabolic co-operation have been quantitated and their influence on survival response curves examined. Induced mutant frequencies were assayed by two methods in situ, and after replating. After exposure to X-rays, MMS and UV a significantly higher frequency of mutants was observed in replated experiments as compared with the in situ situation, at all survival levels assayed. With EMS, an increment on replating was observed only at high survival levels. The replating data suggest that two types of azgr colonies are produced, i.e. those which contain only azgr cells and those which, due to damage segregation, contain a mixture of azgr and azg8 cells. These mixed colonies appear to be lost by metabolic co-operation when mutation frequencies are assayed in silu. The proportion of mixed to homogeneous colonies differs with different mutagens. Taking into account such factors, EMS and UV irradiation were similarly mutagenic at a given survival level, but at equitoxic doses, fewer mutants were recovered after exposure of V79 cells to MMS and X-rays.     

Post-treatment with caffeine and the induction of gene mutations by ultraviolet irradiation and ethyl methanesulphonate in V-79 Chinese hamster cells in culture.

The effect of caffeine on V-79 Chinese hamster cells after ultraviolet irradiation or treated with ethyl methanesulphonate was investigated. Caffeine strongly potentiated the killing of both agents, but it had no effect on the induction of mutations at the hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyl transferase locus. The results are consistent with the notion that caffeine slows down an error-prone post-replicative repair mechanism without changing the mutation frequency.     

The induction of thymidine- and IUdR-resistant variants in P388 mouse lymphoma cells by x-rays, UV and mono- and bi-functional alkylating agents

Dose-response curves for “mutation” to resistance to 5-iodo-2-deoxyuridine (IUdR) and excess thymidine (TdR) in P388 mouse lymphoma cells have been established after exposure of these cells to six chemical mutagens, UV |and| ionising radiations. The dose-response curves for all mutagens in both selective system show considerable similarities when induced mutation frequencies are plotted against survival. Expression time for both types of variants, IUdR^r and TdR^r, are similar, i.e. maximum frequencies are reached by 48 h and there is no fall in variant frequency at late expression times up to 144 h. Over the range of survival levels studied there appears to be little or no dependence of expression time on dose of mutagen. Some loss of mutants after high doses (i.e. at low survival levels) was observed due to the fact that a significant proportion of both TdR^r and IUdR^r clones were more sensitive to the mutagens than the wild-type population. The similarities in induced dose-response curves for different mutagens suggest that the mutants have a common origin, probably an error in repair, but it seems unlikely that errors in “cut and patch” repair are responsible. A comparison of spontaneous frequencies of IUdR^r and TdR^r variants suggests that IUdR is mutagenic in P388 cells.