Paradoxical changes in SCE frequencies persistently elevated in vivo, on exposure to a mutagen in vitro

Lymphocyte cultures from 4 individuals with persistently significantly elevated frequencies of sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) were examined with no treatment, and with 2 concentrations of mitomycin C. In each of the 4 cases, the mean level of SCEs in the untreated lymphocytes exhibited a paradoxical reduction in SCE frequency when exposed to the lower (0.005 microgram/ml) of the two doses of mitomycin C. At the second higher dose of mitomycin C (0.025 microgram/ml) the mean level of SCE/cell exceeded the untreated mean. When the distributions of SCE/cell were examined it appeared that the untreated cultures had two or more populations of cells; one was in the normal SCE frequency range, while the second population was in an elevated SCE frequency range. The paradoxical reduction in SCE frequency was apparently due to elimination of, or mitotic inhibition of cells in the highest range of SCE frequency, while a small elevation in SCEs was initiated in the cells with a normal SCE frequency. Thus, mean levels of SCE/cell can be misleading. This data suggests that new exposure to the same or a different genotoxic agent might possibly result in a misleading lowering of the mean SCE frequency.     

Effects of theophylline on chromosomal breakage and sister-chromatid exchange

Frequencies of both sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) and chromosomal breakage (CB) were studied in the lymphocytes of normal individuals (10 and 7 individuals respectively). The cells were exposed in vitro to 3 different concentrations of theophylline (1, 10 and 100 micrograms/ml). A significant concentration effect of the drug was demonstrated for both SCEs and CB. Utilizing a Dunnett's test for individual comparisons, the 10 and 100 micrograms/ml concentrations both demonstrated a significant elevation of SCEs and CB compared to the untreated control cultures. This study suggests that in vitro concentrations of theophylline equal to or greater than 10 micrograms/ml, corresponding to serum levels attained during therapy, increase the frequency of SCEs and chromosome breakage in human lymphocytes.     

Determination of the baseline sister chromatid exchange frequency in human and mouse peripheral lymphocytes using monoclonal antibodies and very low doses of bromodeoxyuridine

We measured the frequency of sister chromatid exchanges (SCEs) in human and mouse peripheral lymphocytes using doses of bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) ranging from 30 nM to 100 microM (human) and from 10 nM to 10 microM (mouse). Heparinized peripheral blood was obtained from five healthy nonsmokers and from six C57B1/6 male mice. The blood was stimulated with PHA (human) or lipopolysaccharide (LPS, mouse) and grown for the first of two cell cycles in BrdU. Metaphase chromosomes were denatured and exposed to a monoclonal antibody reactive to single-stranded DNA containing BrdU. A second antibody was used to label the first antibody with fluorescein, and propidium iodide was used as a counterstain. Second-division metaphases were thus differentially stained red to indicate DNA content and yellow-green to indicate the presence of BrdU. The results indicate that the baseline SCE frequency in human and mouse peripheral lymphocytes is 3.6 and 2.4 SCEs per cell per generation, and that in the human these frequencies are invariant at the lowest BrdU levels. This suggests that SCEs are an integral part of DNA replication, even in the absence of agents known to induce SCEs. The distribution of SCEs per chromosome was analyzed and found to be Poisson-distributed in all 24 murine cultures and in 25 of 36 human cultures. The distribution of SCEs per chromosome may be due to either species-specific chromosome packaging or to karyotypic differences between the species.     

Reduced frequency of baseline sister chromatid exchanges in lymphocytes grown in antibiotics and serum-excluded culture medium

Peripheral venous blood from man, muntjac, and cattle were grown in medium (1) containing different serum (human AB+/FCS/autologous), (2) without serum or antibiotics (penicillin and streptomycin), or (3) without both serum and antibiotics to investigate to what extent certain essential culture components used in in vitro mammalian cell cultures affect the incidence of spontaneous sister chromatid exchanges (SCEs). The observation that exclusion of only serum from culture medium enhanced the frequency of SCEs whereas exclusion of both serum and antibiotics, which influence the cell cycle kinetics to a great extent, exhibited the lowest frequency of SCEs reported so far for lymphocyte cultures, indicates that the frequency of so-called spontaneous SCEs usually observed in normal lymphocyte cultures grown in medium supplemented with serum and antibiotics is in fact an elevated frequency.     

Variation in the frequency of sister chromatid exchanges in repeated human lymphocyte cultures

Summary Repeated blood samples from two healthy donors were taken over a period of about one year to determine the temporal variation in human lymphocyte baseline sister chromatid exchange (SCE)-frequencies. The investigations were performed on whole blood cultures and purified lymphocyte cultures using a standardized protocol for blood collection and cultures. Significant differences in the frequencies of SCEs were found between the two cultivation systems and the two blood donors but also between repeated cultures of the same individual. There was no systematic relationship between the proliferation of the cultures and the basal SCE values. The results indicate the necessity of concurrent controls and repeated blood samples whenever SCEs are used as a test for monitoring human exposure to potential mutagens. Temporal variation in human lymphocyte baseline SCE frequencies is a limiting factor for the detection of minor effects of genotoxic agents.     

As to the clastogenic-, sister-chromatid exchange inducing-and cytotoxic activity of inosine triphosphate in cultures of human peripheral lymphocytes

The influence of commercial inosine triphosphate (ITP) on the chromosome aberration rate, the mitotic rate, sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) frequency, and the proportion of first (X1), second (X2) and third (X3) division metaphases was investigated in 72h cultures of human peripheral lymphocytes. The blood donors had mild inactive arthrosis and a normal health check-up. All cultures of each volunteer were set-up simultaneously. In contrast to a previous report [Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 278 (1990) 238-244], it was demonstrated in two preliminary studies (number of subjects, n=5 each) that ITP at a final concentration of 100 microM does not induce chromosomal aberrations and, furthermore, that not ITP concentrations higher than 100 microM but ITP doses higher than 3.8mM prohibit culture growth.Based on these results, cultures with a final ITP concentration of 3.6mM (max.) and 1.8mM (max./2) were compared with control cultures (number of subjects n=10; three males and seven females, mean age x=57.6 years). Whereas no increase in the chromosomal breakage rate was observed in cultures with an ITP concentration of 1.8mM and only a marginally significant one (P=0.048) for 3.6mM ITP cultures, a highly significant induction of SCEs, not only at an ITP concentration of 3.6mM (P<0.0001) but also at 1.8mM (P<0.0001) was seen. The increase in the SCE frequency was not linear, but steeper from 0 to 1.8mM than from 1.8 to 3.6mM. Nevertheless, the difference between 1.8 and 3.6mM cultures was significant (P=0.027). The distribution of the number of SCEs per metaphase as well as the distribution of SCEs per chromosome correspond to the expected Poisson values. The investigation of the cytotoxic effect of the studied ITP concentrations revealed a highly significant reduction of the mitotic rate from 0 to 1.8mM as well as from 1.8 to 3.6mM in the aberration studies (all P values are equal to smallest possible one for a sample size of 10, namely, 0.002), and in the SCE studies there is a significant decrease in the X3 frequency when ITP is increased (0-1.8mM: P=0.0061 and 1.8-3.6mM: P<0.0001). The proportion of X1 within all X1 and X2 metaphases changes significantly only at the second dose step (0-1.8mM ITP: P=0.22 and 1.8-3.6mM ITP: P<0.0001). The results are discussed.     

Erythrocytes modulate the baseline frequency of sister-chromatid exchanges and the kinetics of lymphocyte division in culture

The baseline sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) frequencies of human plasma lymphocyte cultures (PLC), but not pig PLC, were nearly twice as high as those of whole-blood cultures (WBC). Addition of human red blood cells (RBCs) to human PLC decreased the SCE frequency in proportion to the RBC-leukocyte co-incubation interval. When the period of RBC-leukocyte co-incubation was equivalent to the total length of the culture period (72 h), the SCE frequency was similar to that observed in WBC. Shorter co-incubation periods yielded SCE frequencies intermediate between those of PLC and WBC. Regardless of the species, cell proliferation was slower in PLC than in WBC. Experiments where RBCs were added to PLC showed that the time sequence of RBC incorporation also affects the cell-cycle progression of human and pig lymphocytes. When either human or pig RBCs were added immediately after PLC stimulation, the cell-cycle kinetics was similar to that of WBC. Shorter co-incubation periods made cell-cycle progression intermediate between PLC and WBC values. Thus, PBCs modulate the baseline frequency of SCEs in human PLC and the cell-cycle progression of both human and pig lymphocytes in a time-dependent manner. Two possible hypotheses for the heightened frequency of SCEs of human lymphocytes in RBC-free cultures were assessed. The loss of RBC-to-lymphocyte cellular contact in PLC did not influence the SCE frequencies of lymphocytes. Finally, the increase of SCEs in human PLC could not be related to differences in the generation time of lymphocytes in culture.     

Chromosome studies on lymphocytes of patients under cytostatic therapy

Summary Lymphocyte cultures from the peripheral blood of 38 patients undergoing a cytostatic interval therapy with a regimen of methyl-CCNU (1-[2-chloroethyl-3-(4-methyl-cyclohexyl)]-1-nitrosourea), 5-fluorouracil, and vincristine (each 5-day course of therapy was followed by a therapy interval of 4 weeks) were supplied with 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BUDR) for the whole culture time to determine the sister chromatid labelling pattern. From a total of 92 individual blood samples sister chromatid exchange (SCE) studies were performed including analyses before the start of the therapy, and immediately and 4 weeks after each course of therapy. In addition, the frequency of first, second, and third metaphases in the 72-h cultures was estimated using the characteristic labelling patterns.A distinct increase of SCE frequency over the control level (i.e., lymphocyte cultures of patients before the start of therapy) was observed at all phases of therapy. It was clearly correlated with the number of courses of therapy up to course 7, later on the SCE rate remained more or less at the level reached. The influence of the composition of each drug regimen on the SCE rate was less pronounced than it was on the breakage rate. Moreover, although a clear correlation existed between the individual rates of breakage and SCE, the formation of the latter appeared to reflect a long-term effect of the therapy rather than did the formation of break aberrations. In addition, as the intercellular variability of the number of SCEs per cell was much higher than that of breaks, the interindividual variability (variation of the mean values for each patient) was small compared to the respective variability of breakage rates.The proportion of first, second, and third metaphases present in 72-h cultures evidently was influenced by single courses of therapy. The observed delay of proliferation was also reflected in different amounts of chromosome damage. Although the BUDR treatment enhanced the cytostatic effect of the therapy on the lymphocytes in culture rendering SCE analysis rather difficult in several cases, the other data of this study and in particular the experiences with the long-term effect make it imperative to include BUDR-labelling in further cytogenetic studies in subjects with exceptional exposure to chemicals. However, the SCE method can by no means, replace the classic cytogenetic analysis.     

Increased SCE inducibility by low doses of methylcholanthrene in lymphocytes obtained from patients with Down's disease

The inducibility of sister-chromatid exchanges (SCEs) following 3-methylcholanthrene (MC) treatment of normal human peripheral blood lymphocytes and of in vitro cultured normal human embryo fibroblasts, as well as peripheral blood lymphocytes of patients with Down's disease and of fibroblasts of an embryo with trisomy 21 has been investigated. 10(-6) M MC treatment increased the frequency of SCEs by 2.5 in the case of Down lymphocytes when compared to the healthy control. The fibroblasts with trisomy 21, however, did not show an increased sensitivity to MC treatment when compared with normal fibroblasts, expressed in the number of SCEs per nucleus found in the cells.     

Chromosomal radiosensitivity of pig leucocytes in relation to sampling time

Pig blood cultures were used to analyse the sensitivity to X-rays (measured as frequency of induced dicentrics) of lymphocytes sampled at variable times. By using the BrdU-Giemsa method it was possible to identify the lymphocytes that were performing their first division at early (less than 30% of cells in second division), intermediate (30–50% of cells in second or subsequent divisions) and late stages (more than 50% of cells in second or subsequent divisions). No difference was found in the radiosensitivity of these 3 varieties of lymphocyte. It was also observed that: (a) the combination of radiation followed by BrdU treatment did not increase the clastogenic action of X-rays, (b) X-rays in the dose used in our cultures did not increase the frequency of SCEs, and (c) minor changes in culture conditions probably influence the basal frequency of SCEs.     

Analysis of bromodeoxyuridine-induced single and twin sister chromatid exchanges in tetraploid Chinese hamster ovary cells

Culture of cells in high exogenous levels (>10^–4 M) of bromodeoxyuridine (BrdUrd) or thymidine will increase the baseline sister chromatid exchange (SCE) frequency. The effect is thought to be related to the balance of the DNA precursors thymidine and deoxycytidine. Exogenous addition of deoxycytidine will reverse this effect. Single and twin SCEs were analysed in Colcemid-induced tetraploid Chinese hamster ovary cells exposed to different concentrations of BrdUrd to determine at what stage SCEs are induced by high levels of BrdUrd. In cells exposed to low concentrations of BrdUrd (10^–5 M), equal numbers of SCEs were induced in each of the two cell cycles. With increasing concentrations of BrdUrd (10^–4 to 2×10^–4 M), SCE frequency increased in both cell cycles, but far more SCEs were induced in the second cell cycle. Deoxycytidine (2×10^–4 M) reduced the frequency of SCEs primarily by reducing the frequency of SCEs induced in the second cell cycle. Treatment with 3-aminobenzamide (3AB), a potent inhibitor of poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase, produced effects similar to exposure to high levels of BrdUrd including inducing SCEs in the second replication cycle. This suggests a similar mechanism of action. Deoxycytidine had no effect on 3AB-induced SCEs, however, and there was no interaction between 3AB and high exogenous levels of BrdUrd in SCE induction. Thus these two agents probably act through different mechanisms.     

Chromosomal analysis in vinyl chloride exposed workers: Comparison of the standard technique with the sister-chromatid exchange technique

A group of 21 workers occupationally exposed to vinyl chloride and 6 controls were examined for the presence of chromosomal aberrations or sisterchromatid exchanges in their peripheral lymphocytes. These people comprised a second sampling from a group of exposed workers and controls first examined 18 months earlier. The vinyl chloride exposed workers showed levels of chromosomal aberrations elevated above those of the controls, but there was only a slight increase in sister-chromatid exchanges (per cell or per chromosome) and this increase was not statistically significant. Sister-chromatid exchanges (SCEs) were also examined from in vitro cultures of lymphocytes exposed in G₀/early G₁ and late G₁/early S phase to vinyl chloride, both with and without metabolic activation. There was no increase in SCEs in vitro without metabolic activation but there was a marked increase with metabolic activation and this increase was shown to be independent of cell-cylce phase. It thus was apparent that the small increases of SCEs in workers were not due to the inability of vinyl chloride to induce SCEs in human lymphocytes but were probably because of low exposures and SCE levels could have returned to normal relatively quickly after exposure. The present study suggested that the analysis of longer-living conventional chromosomal aberrations appeared to be a more sensitive monitor of exposure to vinyl chloride in exposed workers than the estimation of SCEs; however, it should be noted that in a 3rd sampling taken 24 months later the exposed workers had chromosomal aberration levels similar to the controls.     

Roles of DNA interstrand crosslinking and its repair in the induction of sister-chromatid exchange and a higher induction in fanconi's anemia cells

The roles of DNA crosslink and its repair in the induction of sister-chromatid exchanges (SCEs) were studied in normal, xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) complementation group A, and Fanconi's anemia (FA) fibroblasts after treatment with mitomycin C (MC) or decarbamoyl mitomycin C (DMC) for 1 h. FA strains were 5—30-fold more sensitive to MC killing than normal cells, but normally responded to DMC killing. XP group-A cells were twice and only slightly more sensitive to DMC and MC killings, respectively, than normal cells. The induction rate of immediate SCEs by MC was 1.7 times higher, despite a normal SCE rate by DMC, in FA strains than that in normal cells. Alternatively, SCE rates by DMC and MC were 6 times and only 1.3 times higher, respectively, in XP cells than in normal cells. In normal cells, the reduction of MC-induced SCEs as a function of repair time followed a biphasic curve of the first rapid (half-life, 2 h) and the second slow (half-life, 14 h) components. Such components corresponded exactly to the first half-excision and the second slow repair processes of molecular crosslink repair. In MC-induced SCEs, FA17JTO cells exhibited only the slow reduction component without the first rapid component and a higher saturation level in the time-dependent reduction in SCEs. This indicates that SCEs are produced by crosslinks remaining unrepaired for long times (24—48 h) after treatment of FA cells. Conversely, XP group-A cells capable of the first half-excision manifested the first rapid reduction in SCEs, although the second component declined at the slowest rate (half-life, 48 h) owing to a defect in the second mono-adduct repair. The reduction in DMC-induced SCEs followed only the slow component. Thus, these results demonstrate that crosslink can be the lesion leading to SCE, and the MC-induced SCE frequency is higher in FA cells than in normal cells. In the FA20JTO strain, such a repair defect seemed to be less than in FA17JTO cells, judged from the survival and SCE characteristics.     

Elevated sister chromatid exchange frequencies in dividing human peripheral blood lymphocytes exposed to 50 Hz magnetic fields

The in vitro cytomolecular technique, sister chromatid exchange (SCE), was applied to test the clastogenic potentiality of extremely low frequency (ELF) electromagnetic fields (EMFs) on human peripheral blood lymphocytes (HPBLs). SCE frequencies were scored in dividing peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBLs) from six healthy male blood donors in two rounds of experiments, R1 and R2, to determine reproducibility. Lymphocyte cultures in the eight experiments conducted in each round were exposed to 50 Hz sinusoidal (continuous or pulsed) or square (continuous or pulsed) MFs at field strengths of 1 microT or 1 mT for 72 h. A significant increase in the number of SCEs/cell in the grouped experimental conditions compared to the controls was observed in both rounds. The highest SCE frequency in R1 was 10.03 for a square continuous field, and 10.39 for a square continuous field was the second highest frequency in R2. DNA crosslinking at the replication fork is proposed as a model which could explain the mechanistic link between ELF EMF exposure and increased SCE frequency.     

Genotype- and age-associated in vivo cytogenetic alterations following mutagenic exposures in mice

We studied mice from eight genetic strains at two ages (young, 10 weeks; and old, more than 80 weeks) for cytogenetic alterations (sister chromatid exchange (SCE), micronuclei, and metaphase indices) following challenges by two known mutagens: N-nitrosoethyl urea (ENU, 17 mg/kg) and cyclophosphamide (CP, 4.5 mg/kg) on bone marrow cells in vivo. The data were used to evaluate the effect of age, genotype, and differential aging patterns of genotypes in relative susceptibility to chromosomal breakage and instability in otherwise normal individuals. The older animals had a higher frequency of micronuclei, reduced metaphase indices, and lower SCE/cell as compared with their younger counterparts. Treatment with both mutagens significantly increased micronuclei and SCEs/cell in almost all strains at both ages but had little effect on the frequency of cells in metaphase. Among individual differences for SCEs/cell at most treatment combinations were not significant. In general, the induced SCEs (treatment-control) are significantly higher in older animals, variable among strains, and relatively higher as a result of CP than the ENU treatment. When the age effect was evaluated as the difference of SCE/cell in old and SCE/cell in young animals of each genotype-treatment combination, an age-dependent pattern was evident. In the presence of a mutagen the pattern in aging response was highly variable and strain (genotype) dependent. This variability may be viewed as subtle inherent genetic predisposition of sensitivity to mutagens that could be evaluated only using sensitive measures (e.g., SCE and not micronuclei) following more than one mutagenic challenges. These subtle differences could become pronounced when these parameters are evaluated at different ages on the same genotype.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Sister-chromatid exchanges are increased in epileptics, but not by sodium valproate.

Sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) frequency has been studied from peripheral blood lymphocyte cultures of 21 patients with epilepsy on sodium valproate, 20 patients who had not started therapy (untreated) and 20 normal healthy controls. Treated and untreated patients with epilepsy were observed to have higher SCE frequencies (mean 9.05 and 9.82 respectively) than healthy controls (mean 4.8; P < 0.001). There was no significant difference in SCE frequency between treated and untreated patients. This suggests that the disease itself may be associated with an increased frequency of SCEs.     

Effects of bleomycin on Down's syndrome lymphocytes in culture

Blood lymphocytes from 3 Down's syndrome (DS) and 3 age- and sex-matched normal probands were studied for the induction of chromosomal aberrations and sister-chromatid exchange (SCEs). Treatment with bleomycin (30 and 60 ng) at the initiation of culture showed a dose-dependent increase in the incidence of dicentric and ring chromosome aberrations. In contrast, the cells which were treated for the last 24 h in culture with bleomycin did not show an increase in chromosome-type aberrations. The proportion of metaphases in M1, M2, and M3 in cultures was not different between DS and normal cells. Sister-chromatid exchange frequency did not show significant changes between DS and normal individuals.     

A family study of spontaneous sister chromatid exchange frequency.

The frequency of spontaneous sister chromatid exchanges (SCEs) was determined in PHA-stimulated peripheral lymphocytes of 52 individuals, comprising 12 complete 2-generation pedigrees. Neither intraindividual variation between replicate cultures established from the same blood sample nor variation among samples from the same individual initiated at different times was significant. However, familial factors affecting mean SCE frequencies were indicated by detection of significant differences among, but not within, families. Although sample sizes were small, a genetic contribution to the SCE frequency was suggested by the observed pattern of familial correlations.     

SCE evaluations in human lymphocytes after G0 exposure to mitomycin C Lack of expression of MMC-induced SCEs in cells that have undergone greater than two in vitro divisions

We conducted a series of experiments designed to determine whether DNA damage induced in G₀ lymphocytes by mitomycin C (MMC) would be expressed as sister-chromatid exchanges during the second and third post-treatment cell cycles. Lymphocytes from normal donors were exposed to MMC for 2 h prior to culture in the presence of phytohemagglutinin. MMC-treated and control cells were subsequently exposed to bromodeoxyuridine (BrdUrd) for the entire culture period (i.e. 48 h or 72 h) or for the terminal 24 h of 72-h cultures. We observed a 3–4-fold increase in SCEs in MII metaphases from lymphocytes treated with MMC and cultured in the presence of BrdUrd for the entire culture period. In contrast, in replicate cultures of MMC-treated lymphocytes that were exposed to BrdUrd for the terminal 24 h only, the SCE frequency in uniformly harlequinized metaphases was not significantly different from that observed in control cultures. We interpret these data as providing evidence that MMC-induced lesions (or alterations) in the DNA of G₀ lymphocytes are probably expressed as SCEs during the first period of mitogeninduced DNA synthesis, and that these lesions do not persist and give rise to SCEs in subsequent cell divisions.     

Analysis of baseline and BrdU-dependent SCEs at different BrdU concentrations

In the present paper we have used a rationale based on the development of theoretical equations that define sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) frequencies as a function of two variables, namely the baseline (BrdU-independent) and the BrdU-dependent SCE frequencies. The experimental design includes the estimation of SCE frequencies in second division chromosomes when both cycles occurred in the presence of BrdU and when BrdU incubation took place only during the first cycle in a wide range of BrdU concentrations. The final SCE yields in second division chromosomes could be separated into three different components: (1) The BrdU-independent, ‘spontaneous’ or baseline SCEs, whose low but biologically significant frequency was calculated to be about 0.06 SCEs per pg of DNA; this figure could be similar for most of the cell types; (2) the BrdU-dependent SCEs whose frequency increases with BrdU dose, probably as a result of BrdU substitution for thymidine; (3) the BrdU-dependent SCEs as a consequence of other cellular factors such as disturbance of nucleotide pool sizes. At high BrdU concentrations (300 μM upward) the three components appear to have a significant value in the final SCE yield, whereas at lower BrdU doses the third component seems to be negligible.