Hermaphroditism and gonochorism. a new hypothesis on the evolution of sexuality in crustacea

Most crustaceans are gonochoristic but hermaphroditism occurs in primitive classes as well as in different orders of higher Crustacea. Though studies have been carried out in plants and animals on the advantages of these two types of sexuality, it is not known how hermaphroditism can change into gonochorism and vice versa. The new hypothesis we report here is based on recent results on biased sex ratio in Crustacea. We suggest that ancestral sexuality was a simultaneous hermaphroditism as it exists still today in primitive groups. Gonochorism may have appeared following integration in the host genome of a parasitic xenogenous DNA inhibiting expression of ‘male genes’. Female sex would be anterior to male sex, and male heterogamety can be seen as a by-product of an intragenomic conflict in a species with an ancestral female heterogamety. Sequential hermaphroditism in higher Crustacea would be a secondary hermaphroditism resulting from other genetic conflicts between host genes and repressing heterochromosomic genes (parasitic DNA from xenogenous origin?)     

Hermaphroditism in fishes: an annotated list of species,phylogeny, and mating system

Fewer than 1% of vertebrate species are hermaphroditic, and essentially all of these are fishes. Four types of hermaphroditism are known in fishes: simultaneous (or synchronous) hermaphroditism (SH), protandry (male-to-female sex change; PA), protogyny (female-to-male sex change; PG), and bidirectional sex change (BS or reversed sex change in protogynous species). Here we present an annotated list of hermaphroditic fish species from a comprehensive review and careful re-examination of all primary literature. We confirmed functional hermaphroditism in more than 450 species in 41 families of 17 teleost orders. PG is the most abundant type (305 species of 20 families), and the others are much less abundant, BS in 66 species of seven families, SH in 55 species of 13 families, and PA in 54 species of 14 families. The recently proposed phylogenetic tree indicated that SH and PA have evolved several times in not-closely related lineages of Teleostei but that PG (and BS) has evolved only in four lineages of Percomorpha. Examination of the relation between hermaphroditism type and mating system in each species mostly supported the size-advantage model that predicts the evolution of sequential hermaphroditism. Finally, intraspecific variations in sexual pattern are discussed in relation to population density, which may cause variation in mating system.

     

A rare presentation of true hermaphroditism: an abnormal inguinoscrotal mass

This study examined the differential diagnosis of inguinoscrotal masses and true hermaphroditism as well as incarcerated inguinal hernia in the differential diagnosis of abnormal inguinoscrotal masses. Inguinoscrotal masses are a rare presentation of true hermaphroditism. A child with an inguinoscrotal mass of the right groin and penoscrotal hypospadias was diagnosed. Our case suggested that abnormal inguinoscrotal masses occur in true hermaphroditism as well as incarcerated inguinal hernia. These congenital anomalies should be considered in the differential diagnosis of inguinoscrotal masses of the groin.     

Hermaphroditism in molluscs

The functional significance of hermaphroditism is, as yet, not well understood. This study attempts to examine the relevance of some theories on this topic to reality, by reviewing the literature on hermaphroditism among molluscs. The study reveals that about 40% of the 5600 mollusc genera are either simultaneous or sequential hermaphrodites. Hermaphroditism occurs in 100% of the Solenogastres, 99% of the Opisthobranchia, 100% of the Pulmonata, 3% of the Prosobranchia and 9% of the Bivalvia. Sequential hermaphroditism, whatever its theoretical advantages over gonochorism, is not common among molluscs. Simultaneous hermaphroditism is common among the Euthyneura. Over 80% of the hermaphroditic genera belong to the Euthyneura (about 2000 recent genera), and over 99% of the Euthyneura are hermaphrodites. The almost ubiquitous occurrence of hermaphroditism throughout the Euthyneurans, coupled with this group's very widespread dispersal in marine, terrestrial and freshwater habitats (and corresponding exposure to a very wide range of predators, competitors or parasites); and also its wide range of population densities, suggests that in this group hermaphroditism is not an adaptive response to selective forces of the environment and it may well be a phylogenetic constraint. A few stylommatophorans have broken this constraint by possessing genitalia in which the male system is absent (aphally) or extremely reduced (hemiphally). They reproduce by self-fertilization. In theory this is advantageous in that these species save the cost of developing two sets of reproductive apparatus. In reality there is no record of aphally occurring throughout an entire species, as one may expect if this saving of cost were so overwhelmingly advantageous. There is also no record of stylommatophoran individuals developing only the male system, as one may expect if there was any evolutionary trend from hermaphroditism towards gonochorism. Simultaneous hermaphroditism offers a (theoretical) option to selling. Selfing by self-fertilization is widespread among freshwater basommatophorans, amphibious stylommatophorans and freshwater bivalves. Selfing by parthenogenesis is widespread among freshwater prosobranchs. Altogether, of 48 genera which self, 60% are dwellers of freshwater. Certain freshwater habitats may perhaps be less stable than most marine or terrestrial ones are. Beyond the Euthyneura, hermaphroditism is common among parasitic, deep sea and Cnidaria-eating molluscs. Perhaps these three associations should be slightly rearranged and combined into a single generalization: that hermaphroditism (beyond the Euthyneura) is widespread among molluscs that live in a close and permanent intimacy with live marine invertebrates, whether as parasites, commensals or predators. Gonochorism but with dwarf males is common among the Eulimoidea, which are parasites, and Galeommatoidea, which are commensals. This situation of gonochorism, in which there is a very close association between members of the two sexes, is functionally a hermaphroditic type. Animals that can manipulate the physiology and endocrinology of their hosts may also have the tendency and ability to manipulate the size of their own males. It may well be that the female not only determines the size of the male but also his sex, in which case dwarf males should be considered as a case of environmental sex determination. The theoretical possibility that hermaphroditism may evolve in brooding animals was examined in gastropods. Among the (predominantly gonochoric) prosobranchs brooding is recorded in 85 genera (4%), only two of which are hermaphrodites. Among the (predominantly hermaphrodite) heterobranchs it is recorded in only 95 odd genera (4%). When all gastropod genera are considered together, the frequency of hermaphroditism among the brooders is only very slightly and insignificantly higher than in the non-brooders. When only the prosobranchs are considered, the frequency of hermaphroditism among the brooders is actually lower than among non-brooders. The theory that hermaphroditism evolves in brooding animals thus appears not to be relevant to the vast majority of gastropods. Brooding is widespread among freshwater prosobranchs (48% of the brooding genera). In this habitat, brooding may perhaps be an adaptation to protect the developing embryo against osmotic stresses.     

Direct reciprocity stabilizes simultaneous hermaphroditism at high mating rates: A model of sex allocation with egg trading

Simultaneous hermaphroditism is predicted to be unstable at high mating rates given an associated increase in sperm competition. The existence of reciprocal egg trading, which requires both hermaphroditism and high mating rates to evolve, is consequently hard to explain. We show using mathematical models that the presence of a trading economy creates an additional fitness benefit to egg production, which selects for traders to bias their sex allocation toward the female function. This female‐biased sex allocation prevents pure females from invading a trading population, thereby allowing simultaneous hermaphroditism to persist stably at much higher levels of sperm competition than would otherwise be expected. More generally, our model highlights that simultaneous hermaphroditism can persist stably when mating opportunities are abundant, as long as sperm competition remains low. It also predicts that reciprocity will select for heavier investment in the traded resource.     

Hermaphroditism in the dash‐and‐dot goatfish Parupeneus barberinus

Presence of bisexual individuals and a sex‐specific bimodal size distribution are suggestive of protogyny in the dash‐and‐dot goatfish Parupeneus barberinus, but the most parsimonious interpretation of histological analysis is juvenile hermaphroditism. This is the first report of hermaphroditism in the Mullidae.     

Simultaneous hermaphroditism; cost and benefit

Current theories explain simultaneous hermaphroditism by the advantage it gives to organisms which are widely dispersed or sluggish, resulting in a low frequency of reproductive contacts. It is difficult to see why hermaphroditism is not more widespread unless there is some counterbalancing disadvantage.It is suggested that hermaphrodites suffer an energetic cost because they maintain two reproductive systems and a cost due to the reduced number or viability of offspring which may result from accidental self-fertilization. These costs will result in a disadvantage to hermaphroditism (compared to gonochorism) when reproductive contacts are frequent. However, even in widely dispersed or sluggish organisms behavioural mechanisms may exist which increase the frequency of reproductive contacts, favouring gonochorism instead of hermaphroditism.It is argued that externally fertilizing species should as a rule be gonochoric and that species which brood their young may often be hermaphroditic. Hermaphroditism in species which form permanent male/female pairs in the breeding season could result in more zygotes being produced. However, where parental care of the young is important, it is suggested that gonochorism and sexual dimorphism may result in more progeny being reared.     

Familial true hermaphroditism (apropos of 2 families)

The authors report the cases of two new families of true hermaphroditism (4 cases) defined by the coexistence of both testicular and ovarian tissues. Exceptionally the disease presents a familial recurrence: only 8 families have been reported in the literature. When the study is done HY antigen is always increased in patients with true hermaphroditism and sometimes slightly increased in their mothers who are phenotypically normal.     

The Evolution of Hermaphroditism from Dioecy in Crustaceans: Selfing Hermaphroditism Described in a Fourth Spinicaudatan Genus

The evolution of reproductive systems has intrigued evolutionary biologists for well over a century. Recent empirical and theoretical work has elucidated the evolution of dioecy (separate males and females) from hermaphroditism in many plant species. The reverse transition, evolving hermaphroditism from dioecy, has occurred many times in animals, and yet is poorly studied relative to its reverse analog in plants. Crustaceans in the sub-order Spinicaudata have evolved hermaphroditism from dioecy three separate times, in some cases forming all-hermaphroditic species and in others forming androdioecious (males + hermaphrodites) species. Herein we report evidence of hermaphroditism in a fourth spinicaudatan genus: the newly described Calalimnadia. We present sex ratio and anatomical evidence that Calalimnadia mahei comprises selfing hermaphrodites, with no males being found in over 10,000 offspring reared. We combine these reproductive results with those of other Spinicaudata to estimate the evolution of hermaphroditism in this crustacean sub-order. We use these genetic data combined with anatomical evidence to suggest that C. mahei represents a fourth, independent derivation of hermaphroditism from dioecy in these reproductively labile crustaceans.     

Sustainability of dioecious and hermaphrodite populations on a lattice

Sexual reproduction may be divided into two main categories: hermaphroditism and dioecy (Botany)/gonochorism (Zoology). Simultaneous hermaphrodites can function in both male and female roles whereas a dioecious/gonochorist population consists of distinct male and female individuals. Mean-field calculations, which ignore spatial aspects, suggest that self-incompatible hermaphrodites should have a twofold advantage over dioecious population when reproduction is limited by mating encounters. By use of stochastic spatial simulations we demonstrate that hermaphroditism has an even greater advantage when local interactions are considered. This result provides further support for the observation that hermaphroditism is associated with sedentary species, such as plants and animals with poor mate search efficiency. We also investigate the finite size effects associated with the well-known quadratic contact process.     

Evolution of breeding systems and fruits in New World Galium and relatives (Rubiaceae)

? Premise of the study: Dioecy occurs in only about 6% of angiosperms, yet it has evolved many times from hermaphroditism. Polygamy is an even more uncommon condition within angiosperms, in which both unisexual and bisexual flowers occur within a species. Polygamy, dioecy, and hermaphroditism all occur within a New World clade of Galium (Rubiaceae), in which dioecy is hypothesized to have evolved from hermaphroditism via polygamy. At least five sections of Galium as traditionally defined by fruit morphology occur within this group. We tested the monophyly of sections defined by fruit morphology and sought to determine origins and pathways of breeding systems within this group. ? Methods: We obtained chloroplast (rpoB-trnC, trnC-psbM, trnL-ndhJ) and nuclear ribosomal (external transcribed spacer) DNA sequences for 89 taxa from the Cruciata-Galium-Valantia (CGV) clade to estimate the phylogeny. Ancestral states for breeding systems, fruit types, and fruit hairs were reconstructed using parsimony and likelihood analyses. ? Key results: We identified nine well-supported lineages of New World Galium taxa. However, none of the sections traditionally defined by fruit morphology are monophyletic. Dioecy is inferred to have arisen at least three times from hermaphroditism; polygamy is inferred to have arisen at least twice from dioecy and at least six times from hermaphroditism. ? Conclusions: Polygamy appears to be a terminal condition in the CGV clade and not a pathway to dioecy. Fruit characters traditionally used in the taxonomy of this group have arisen multiple times within this clade of Galium and are not reliable indicators of shared evolutionary history.     

Sexual pattern ofNeocirrhites armatus (Cirrhitidae) with notes on other hawkish species

Synopsis We examined the gonads of eight species in five genera of hawkfishes. Histological preparations of ovaries and testes produced evidence for protogynous hermaphroditism inNeocirrhites armatus and suggested that hermaphroditism may also be expressed inCirrhitichthys oxycephalus, C. aprinus andC. falco, and possibly also by other species. Sexual patterns in hawkfishes are discussed in relation to environmental and ecological factors which influence mobility and length of spawning season.     

Hermaphroditism: What's not to like?

Hermaphroditism is rare and phylogenically in decline among animal species. The evolutionary basis for this development is not well understood. This paper focusses on self-incompatible simultaneous hermaphroditism in animals. It proposes that such hermaphroditism is not stable in sufficiently heterogeneous populations, suggesting a possible reason for why hermaphroditism is rare among evolved animal species. The argument turns on the Bateman principle, namely that male reproductive success (RS) is limited by partner availability, while female RS is not. We show that: low-quality individuals do better if female; secondary sexual differentiation may be important for understanding the existence of males; and that hermaphroditic mating is reciprocal. Reciprocity may be key to understanding promiscuity and attendant phenomena such as cryptic female choice, sperm competition and love darts-common features of hermaphroditic mating. We also argue that hermaphrodites are especially vulnerable to male violence, suggesting a reason for the rarity of trioecy. Finally, we propose that external fertilization, and the scope for streaking, may be one reason fish are the only simultaneously hermaphroditic vertebrates.     

RECURRENT EVOLUTION OF DIOECY IN BRYOPHYTES

The origin and maintenance of separate sexes (dioecy) is an enduring evolutionary puzzle. Although both hermaphroditism and dioecy occur in many diverse clades, we know little about the long‐term evolutionary consequences of changing sexual system. Here we find evidence for at least 133 transitions between sexual systems in mosses, representing an almost unparalleled lability in the evolution of their sexual systems. Furthermore, in contrast to predictions, the transition rate from hermaphroditism to dioecy was approximately twice as high as the reverse transition. Our results also suggest that hermaphrodites may have higher rates of diversification than dioecious mosses. These results illustrate the utility of mosses for understanding the genomic and macroevolutionary consequences of hermaphroditism and dioecy.     

Bateman's Principle and Simultaneous Hermaphrodites: A Paradox

Bateman's principle states that reproductive success is limiteda) in females by the resources available for egg production;and b) in males, only by access to females and/or eggs. Theprinciple has been used to generate predictions for two aspectsof hermaphroditism; a) the advantage of hermaphroditism andb) sexual conflict. Comparing these predictions to the empiricaldata offers tests of Bateman's principle. Charnov's predictionthat hermaphroditism would occur under circumstances where Bateman'sprinciple does not apply is found to be largely correct. However,the prediction as to the association of hermaphroditism andlow fixed costs is inconsistent with the data. Alternative explanationsthat predict that hermaphroditism is a strategy for reducingvariance in reproductive success may better explain the data.Probability theory demonstrates that where two strategies haveequal mean fitness, which must be the case for male and femalefunction, the strategy with the lower variance in reproductivesuccess must have higher fitness (Gillespie's principle). Bateman'sprinciple predicts that this will be the female role in hermaphrodites.However, Charnov, assuming Bateman's principle, predicted thatsexual conflict stemming from a preference for the male rolewould be important in hermaphrodite mating systems, creatinga paradox. Many hermaphrodite mating systems are based on conditionalreciprocity with a preferred sexual role indicating sexual conflict.The data demonstrate that the preferred role varies among taxa,contrary to the predictions of Bateman's principle. It has beensuggested that Bateman's principle can explain cases in whichthe female role is preferred (sperm-trading) as involving energyrather than gamete trading. However, energetic considerationssuggest that energy trading would only be adaptive if Bateman'sprinciple does not apply, paradoxically. The gamete tradingmodel, based on the prediction that the role that offers controlof fertilization will be preferred, is more consistent withthe data. Application of Bateman's principle to hermaphroditesleads to contradictory predictions and does not offer the basisfor a coherent theory of sexual selection, as Bateman proposed.     

Pollination biology and outcrossing rates in hermaphroditic Schiedea lydgatei (Caryophyllaceae)

The influence of outcrossing and pollination biology on the maintenance of hermaphroditism was studied for Schiedea lydgatei (Caryophyllaceae: Alsinoideae), a species endemic to Moloka`i in the Hawaiian Islands. Schiedea lydgatei is the only hermaphroditic species in an otherwise dimorphic clade and hermaphroditism is likely the result of a reversal from a gynodioecious ancestor. Both wind and native moths in the family Pyralidae are responsible for pollination in S. lydgatei. Outcrossing rates were generally high (0.80), especially in years when the greatest number of plants were flowering. The combination of high outcrossing rates and substantial inbreeding depression indicates that at present females would not be favored in the population. Pollination by both wind and insects is consistent with the hypothesis that hermaphroditism is the result of a relatively recent reversal, as the ancestor of S. lydgatei was probably wind pollinated and gynodioecious with few females in the populations. A shift from wind to predominately insect pollination on Moloka`i may have resulted in increased outcrossing rates and prevented the expression of high inbreeding depression among progeny of hermaphrodites, a condition that would select against females and favor a reversal to hermaphroditism. Because few females were likely to have been present in ancestral populations that colonized Moloka`i, founder effect is another potential explanation for loss of females. In either case, current high levels of outcrossing prevent re-establishment of females in populations of S. lydgatei.     

True hermaphroditism: a new case with complex mosaicism

True hermaphroditism is a very rare disorder of human sexual differentiation. In the medical literature, more than 450 cases are described, and about 250 true hermaphrodites have been subjected to chromosome studies. A 21-year-old "man" was examined because of genital and phenotypic abnormalities: clinical, surgical and laboratory investigations showed a true hermaphroditism, with a quadruple mosaicism 45,X/46,XX/46,XY/47,XXY. We believe that this is the first case in which this peculiar type of multiple mosaicism has been documented.     

Hermaphroditism as a reproductive strategy for metazoans; some correlated benefits

Abstract

The concept of hermaphroditism is examined, the terminology is reviewed, and several new terms are proposed: EUHERMAPHRODITISM for the occurrence together of eggs and sperm in the individual that produced them; TEMPORARY HERMAPHRODITISM for the few instances where euhermaphroditism is a brief transitional phase between sexes in protandry and protogyny, and opsiautogamy to designate the condition where sperm saved from an early male phase are used to fertilise eggs produced in a later female phase. An animal that functions successively in the different sex roles is considered to be quite distinct from one that functions as both male and female simultaneously. Further, the circumstances in which these different sexual modes are appropriate and the advantages that accrue from them are quite different. For this reason protandry, protogyny, and consecutive sexuality are not considered to be part of hermaphroditism, but rather aspects of labile gonochorism.

A major idea advanced in this paper is that hermaphroditism is of primary importance as a reproductive strategy of very small metazoans. In such animals, whose eggs are so disproportionately large that very few can be produced, hermaphroditism ensures that through having the maximal number of females the maximal number of eggs are produced and fertilised economically. For very small hermaphrodites the mate-finding difficulties associated with small size and limited motility are reduced by converting each meeting into a potential mating. Further, in hermaphroditism not only is the frequency of mating maximised. but through sperm storage the effects of matings last for a long time. and through multiple reciprocal copulations genetically diverse progenies are produced. The effective size of the gene pool is maximised, and the risk of genetic drift in sex ratio in small populations is avoided. Very small animals do not have the energetic resources to produce large numbers of large, yolky eggs, nor do they have the space in which to store them before release. Thus tiny hermaphrodites tend to produce a few eggs at a time, but over extended or continuous breeding seasons. The effects of their reduced fecundity may be further offset by precise methods of fertilisation, brooding, and commonly the suppression of pelagic phases, thus minimising losses from larval predation and overdispersal.

It is also argued that hermaphroditism may have been advantageous because of features often associated with it. Copulation with protected sperm transfer may have been especially important, not only because of economies in gamete production and use, but also in the exploitation of new habitats. In freshwater hermanhrodites copulatory or spermatophore exchange habits protect sperm from osmotic death: in endoparasites copulation protects sperm from digestive enzymes and osmotic stress in the host’s gut, and from antibodies and phagocytosis in the bloodstream.     

The relationship between mating system and simultaneous hermaphroditism in the coral reef fish, Hypoplectrus nigricans (Serranidae)

The behaviour and reproductive ecology of the simultaneously hermaphroditic coral reef fish, Hypoplectrus nigricans (Serranidae), the black hamlet, was investigated in an effort to elucidate the relationship between simultaneous hermaphroditism and mating behaviour. The major features of the mating system are as follows. (1) Hamlets spawn only in pairs, one partner releasing eggs and the other fertilizing them. There is no selfing. (2) Eggs are planktonic. There is no parental care. (3) The major courtship display serves to advertise that an individual has ripe eggs. (4) A clutch is not released in a single spawn but is parcelled over several, usually with the same partner. (5) Partners generally alternate sex roles with each spawn: that is, they take turns giving up parcels to be fertilized. This active reciprocation of release of eggs, called egg trading, means that reproductive success as a male depends upon the ability to reproduce as a female. Since most of the reproductive effort of an individual is spent on female functions, egg trading provides a fecundity advantage to hermaphroditism, making it evolutionarily stable relative to dioecy (separate sexes). The advantage is analogous to that which parthenogenetic organisms have over sexual ones. The fecundity advantage under egg trading can account for the maintenance, but not the origin of simultaneous hermaphroditism, since hermaphroditism must be established before egg trading can evolve.     

Evolutionary transitions among dioecy,androdioecy and hermaphroditism in limnadiid clam shrimp (Branchiopoda: Spinicaudata)

Examinations of breeding system transitions have primarily concentrated on the transition from hermaphroditism to dioecy, likely because of the preponderance of this transition within flowering plants. Fewer studies have considered the reverse transition: dioecy to hermaphroditism. A fruitful approach to studying this latter transition can be sought by studying clades in which transitions between dioecy and hermaphroditism have occurred multiple times. Freshwater crustaceans in the family Limnadiidae comprise dioecious, hermaphroditic and androdioecious (males + hermaphrodites) species, and thus this family represents an excellent model system for the assessment of the evolutionary transitions between these related breeding systems. Herein we report a phylogenetic assessment of breeding system transitions within the family using a total evidence comparative approach. We find that dioecy is the ancestral breeding system for the Limnadiidae and that a minimum of two independent transitions from dioecy to hermaphroditism occurred within this family, leading to (1) a Holarctic, all‐hermaphrodite species, Limnadia lenticularis and (2) mixtures of hermaphrodites and males in the genus Eulimnadia. Both hermaphroditic derivatives are essentially females with only a small amount of energy allocated to male function. Within Eulimnadia, we find several all‐hermaphrodite populations/species that have been independently derived at least twice from androdioecious progenitors within this genus. We discuss two adaptive (based on the notion of ‘reproductive assurance’) and one nonadaptive explanations for the derivation of all‐hermaphroditism from androdioecy. We propose that L. lenticularis likely represents an all‐hermaphrodite species that was derived from an androdioecious ancestor, much like the all‐hermaphrodite populations derived from androdioecy currently observed within the Eulimnadia. Finally, we note that the proposed hypotheses for the dioecy to hermaphroditism transition are unable to explain the derivation of a fully functional, outcrossing hermaphroditic species from a dioecious progenitor.