Responsiveness of Thymus Cells to Syngeneic and Allogeneic Lymphoid Cells

THE thymus is necessary for the normal development of cell-mediated immunity in mice as shown by the immunological defects after neonatal thymectomy¹. Thymus cells themselves can be stimulated by allogeneic lymphoid cells in mixed leucocyte reaction (MLR)² and become killer cells or cytotoxic lymphocytes after stimulation with allogeneic spleen cells in vitro (H. Wagner and M. Feldmann, unpublished work) and in vivo^3,4. This suggests that the thymus as well as peripheral lymphoid tissues contain T cells which can be stimulated by foreign histocompatibility antigen to divide and differentiate into the cytotoxic lymphocytes which mediate cellular immunity. There have been suggestions that thymus cells might be stimulated to divide by “self” antigen, as well as foreign cells: incorporation of ³H-thymidine above background levels has been found in cultures with syngeneic spleen and thymus cells of adult rats⁵, although the experiments do not determine whether thymus or spleen cells have been stimulated. In contrast to these experiments, Howe et al. reported that only thymus cells of neonatal CBA mice reacted to allogeneic and syngeneic spleen cells of adult animals in “one way” MLR cultures^6,7. Whether the reaction of neonatal thymus cells to syngeneic adult spleen cells is recognition of “self” antigens is uncertain, since spleens of adult mice could carry antigens which do not occur in neonatal animals and are therefore “unknown” for neonatal thymus cells. We demonstrate here that neonatal thymus cells do not react to 4-day-old CBA spleen cells, but adult thymus cells do react against both allogeneic and syngeneic adult spleen cells.     

The specificity of the syngeneic mixed leukocyte response, a primary anti-I region T cell proliferative response, is determined intrathymically

In previous studies, the syngeneic MLR of peripheral T cells was shown to be predominantly an I region-restricted function. In this report we show that adult thymocytes are also capable of responding to syngeneic irradiated stimulator cells in a syngeneic MLR, provided that TCGF is added to the culture system. Using this assay, it was possible for the first time to examine the pattern of I region restriction within the thymus itself. Analysis of the thymocyte syngeneic MLR in thymuses from radiation-induced bone marrow chimeras demonstrated that the MHC preference seen in the peripheral T cell population also existed in cells resident within the thymus. Experiments utilizing congenitally athymic mice transplanted with allogeneic thymic grafts demonstrated that both peripheral T cells and thymocytes from such animals displayed a strong preferential proliferation toward stimulator cells bearing thymic-type MHC determinants. The results in the nude model thus demonstrate that the thymus by itself is sufficient to impart such restriction specificity on a developing T cell repertoire. These results are consistent with the notion that the thymus exerts selective pressure on maturing T cell populations that results in a skewing of the T cell repertoire toward the recognition of thymic-type I region products, and that this MHC preference exists before expansion of T cells in the periphery.     

Response of human fetal lymphocytes in xenogeneic mixed leukocyte culture: Phylogenetic and ontogenetic aspects

Cells from liver, thymus, and spleen of human fetuses at different stages of development were capable of a proliferation response against xenogeneic and allogeneic lymphocytes. The kinetics of fetal responses against rat lymphocytes were identical to those of fetal and adult responses against allogeneic cells. With all of the cell types studied, including adult lymphocytes, allogeneic responses were stronger than xenogeneic. Xenogeneic responses against lymphocytes from rat, mouse, or sheep were stronger than those against lymphocytes from rabbit, chicken, snake, or frog. These results are interpreted to indicate that recognition of foreign lymphocytes by human lymphocytes depends on the phylogenetic position of the species used as a source of stimulating cells. The degree of recognition decreases as the phylogenetic distance increases. Specific elimination of responding cells and restimulation with another cell population was used to study the specificity of proliferation responses against mouse and rat lymphocytes. Responses by prethymic liver cells from human fetuses were not due to the existence of specifically recognizing subpopulations. Thymus and spleen at 16 weeks' gestation contained specific subpopulations capable of differentiating between xenogeneic and allogeneic cells, as well as between xenogeneic cells with different intraspecies histocompatibility patterns. Generation of receptor diversity on T lymphocytes is discussed briefly in the light of these findings.     

Alloantigen-induced T helper activity. I. Minimal genetic differences necessary to induce a positive allogeneic effect.

Addition of histoincompatible lymphocytes can influence the course of ongoing immune responses. Such allogeneic effects may either augment or diminish immune responses. We describe here the minimal genetic differences necessary to generate positive allogeneic effects (allohelp) in a humoral immune response. The antibody response to sheep erythrocytes of T cell-depleted mouse spleen cells was reconstituted by addition of syngeneic or allogeneic nylon wool column-passaged spleen T cells. T cells were pretreated with mitomycin C before culture to prevent development of allo-suppression and cytotoxic lymphocytes. Positive allogeneic effects were operationally defined as superior helper effects (to generate greater antibody forming cell responses) with T cells allogeneic rather than syngeneic to the responding B cells. Thus, addition of allogeneic T cells resulted in many more antibody forming cells than did equal numbers of syngeneic T cells, and fewer allogeneic than syngeneic T cells were necessary to generate comparable responses. With congenic, recombinant, and mutant mouse lines, genetic differences in the H-2 complex and those associated with Mls were each sufficient to provide positive allogeneic effects. With intra-H-2 recombinants, differences at either I or D were sufficient. A disparity at H-2K alone, as provided by the H-2 mutant B6.C-H-2ba against the parental line C57BL/6By, also induced helper effects. The significance of these results is discussed.     

Syngeneic mixed lymphocyte reaction in mice: strain distribution, kinetics, participating cells, and absence in NZB mice.

Co-culture of mouse spleen nonadherent (T-enriched cells with mitomycin C-treated unfractionated syngeneic spleen cells resulted in increased DNA synthesis in the responding T cells. The kinetics of this syngeneic mixed lymphocyte reaction (SMLR) showed that peak DNA synthesis occurred on day 5 of culture compared to day 4 for conventional mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR). Anti-T cell antiserum plus complement treatment of the responding cell population abolished the reaction, and similar treatment of the stimulator population enhanced SMLR. These studies indicate that SMLR represents the response of T cells to non-T cells. Studies on the generation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) in parallel cultures of T cells activated by syngeneic or allogeneic spleen cells showed no cytotoxicity of SMLR-activated cells for either PHA- or LPS-induced blasts but did show a good CTL response of allo-activated cells to both targets. Studies on the strain distribution of SMLR revealed that NZB mice manifested poor or no stimulation in SMLR whereas all other strains tested exhibited strong SMLR. This defect in NZB mice may be pathogenetically related to the autoimmune disease that develops in these mice.     

Induction of allospecific suppressor T cells in vitro.

Incubation of mouse thymic lymphocytes with irradiated allogeneic spleen cells gave rise to suppressor cells. The suppressor activity was assayed by adding the incubated cell mixture to a mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) in which the responder cells were syngeneic with the sensitized thymocytes and the stimulator cells were syngeneic with the sensitizing spleen cells. Such addition suppressed significantly thymidine incorporation in the mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR). The suppressor cells were found to carry the θ antigen and to function allospecifically, as shown by cross-testing in three allogeneic combinations. Our data suggest that these cells may originate from immature cortisone-sensitive thymic lymphocytes and also provide some preliminary information concerning their mode of action.     

Specificity of allogeneic and xenogeneic cell recognition in the fetal lamb.

Cells prepared from liver, thymus, and spleen of fetal lambs at different stages if gestation were confronted with allogeneic and xenogeneic cells in MLC. Specific elimination of the responding cells with BUdR and UV light together with a subsequent restimulation was used to study the specificity of the reaction. The response of fetal liver cells was not based on the existence of specifically recognizing cellular subpopulations; the response was concluded to be due either to stimulatory products released by the stimulating cells or to the multipotentiality of the responding cells. Specifically recognizing cells first appeared in the thymus at 58 days postconception and in the spleen at 70 days. In the response of sheep lymphocytes against allogeneic and xenogeneic (mouse, human) cells, a cross-reactivity occurred. Fetal lamb lymphocytes were also capable of recognizing intraspecies differences on the xenogeneic cells. This capacity developed simultaneously with the specific recognition of allogeneic cells. No clear difference was observed in the reactivity of fetal thymus cells and spleen cells when compared to that of adult peripheral blood lymphocytes. These findings indicate that immunologically specific recognition of foreign cells is created in the sheep during the early intrauterine development.     

Soluble suppressor of T cell proliferation in primary in vitro response to murine minor histocompatibility antigens

Normal mouse lymphocytes are not capable of mounting a primary cytotoxic T cell response to Mls encoded, non H-2, allodeterminants, although a strong lymphoproliferative response is observed in primary MLR between Mls incompatible cells. In this study it is reported that in the supernatant of primary cultures between AKR macrophages and CBA/H lymphocytes (H-2 identical, incompatible for Mls and other minor antigens) a suppressor of T cell proliferation in MLR is detected. By contrast, a suppressor is not detected in supernatants from primary cultures between BALB/C macrophages and CBA/H lymphocytes (H-2 incompatible, Mls identical), B10.BR macrophages and CBA/H macrophages and CBA/H lymphocytes (syngeneic) suggesting that the production of the suppressor factor occurs only when an Mls incompatibility exists. The suppressive activity of the Mls incompatible culture supernatant upon MLR between incompatible macrophages and lymphocytes is neither antigen specific nor Mls or H-2 restricted, nor is it due to an irreversible toxic effect on T lymphocytes or macrophages. The inhibition of T cell proliferation could be explained by inhibition of IL 2 production, by blocking its union to T cells or by a combination of both effects. Our findings could help explain previous observations that lymphocytes from mice preimmunized with Mls incompatible cells have a depressed proliferative response as well as depressed cytotoxicity against alloantigens.     

Biological characterization of T and B lymphocytes separated from normal mouse spleen by a physical adherence column method

The capacity of spleen cell populations enriched for T and B lymphocytes by a physical adherence column method to respond in vitro to phytomitogens and allogeneic lymphocytes was determined. Column filtrate cells (T lymphocytes) responded well to phytohaemagglutinin- and mitomycin-C-treated allogeneic spleen cells, but poorly to pokeweed mitogen. Adherent cell populations from the column (B and some T lymphocytes) responded well to pokeweed mitogen, but poorly to phytohaemagglutinin- and mitomycin-C-treated allogeneic cells.Purified peripheral T lymphocytes prepared from normal mouse spleen by the column method reconstituted the depleted in vitro antibody response to the thymic-dependent SRBC antigen of all B lymphocyte sources tested, namely, spleen cells from congenitally athymic mice, neonatally thymectomized mice, and adult thymectomized mice which had been reconstituted with bone marrow, and a lymphocyte population prepared by incubating spleen cells with anti-θ serum and complement. When transferred with sheep erythrocytes to congenitally athymic mice, purified peripheral T cells restored the in vivo IgM and IgG responses of these animals. These results confirm that the column filtrate is a thymus derived subpopulation of cells capable of cell-mediated immunity and cooperation with B lymphocytes in humoral immunity both in vitro and in vivo.     

T lymphocyte heterogeneity in the rat. III. Autoreactive T cells are activated by B cells

Evidence has been presented to show that CD4+ autoreactive T cell lines (ATs)2 in the rat require periodic stimulation with syngeneic spleen cells for in vitro proliferation. This proliferation can be blocked by treatment of the stimulator (spleen) cells with mAb to Ia antigens. Although ATs are Ia+ and can activate the allogeneic MLR, they fail to be autostimulatory. Fractionation of the spleen cells revealed that ATs can be stimulated with B cells and not by macrophages, although the latter were efficient in several accessory cell functions, including antigen presentation, lectin-dependent T cell activation and allogenic MLR response. Moreover, B cells proliferated and differentiated in response to AT cells. These data are compatible with a model in which ATs respond to hitherto undetermined B cell membrane antigen(s) in association with MHC class II antigens. These results may have important implications in understanding autoimmune responses.     

The differentiation of suppressor cell populations as revealed by studies of the effects of mitogens on the mixed lymphocyte reaction and on the generation of cytotoxic lymphocytes.

The regulation by concanavalin A (Con A) and bacterial lipoloysaccharide (LPS) of the mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) and of the generation of cytotoxic lymphocytes (CL) was studied in congenic resistant mice using cortisone resistant thymocytes as the responding cells. LPS enhances the generation of CL selectively when suboptimal numbers of allogeneic cells are present in mixed lymphocyte cultures and also results in the augmentation of the MLR. Mitogenic concentrations of Con A on the other hand suppress the generation of CL regardless of alloantigen dose. The mechanism of suppression cannot be ascribed to the presence of suppressor T cells, since the addition to the cultures of syngeneic cortisone resistant thymocytes activated by Con A does not change the immune response. However, prospective suppressor cells that can be activated by Con A are located in secondary lymphoid organs such as spleen and lymph node. Suppressor activity by those cells is abolished by anti θ plus complement. Con A activated spleen cells suppress the MLR, whereas Con A activated thymocytes amplify the proliferation of responding cells.     

In Vitro Reconstitution of Anti-Sheep Erythrocyte Antibody Response of T Cell-Depleted Spleen Cells by Allogeneic T Cells or by Factors Derived from Them

Restoration of the impaired antibody response to sheep erythrocytes (SRBC) in cultures of mouse spleen cells, which were deprived of thymus-derived lymphocytes (T cells) by treatment with anti-mouse brain-associated θ (BAθ) antiserum and complement, was studied by adding a small portion of syngeneic or allogeneic normal spleen cells in vitro. Allogeneic spleen cells had a far greater effect than syngeneic spleen cells on the restoration, as far as the normal spleen cells added were able to recognize the alloantigens on the anti-BAθ serum-treated spleen cells (bone marrow-derived lymphocytes). Treatment of the allogeneic spleen cells with mitomycin C did not affect their activity in the restoration of the impaired antibody response. The possibility that the role of T cells in the antibody response to SRBC may be replaced by a nonspecific mediator derived from T cells reacting with allogeneic cells was proven by the finding that supernatant of the mixed allogeneic spleen cell cultures restored the impaired anti-SRBC antibody response of the T cell-depleted spleen cells. The effect of such culture supernatant on the restoration of the antibody response was greatest when it was added to the T cell-depleted spleen cell cultures one day after cultivation with SRBC, suggesting that the effectiveness may result from triggering of the proliferation and differentiation of antibody-forming cell precursors, which have already reacted with the antigen, to antibody-forming cells.     

A partial characterization of suppressor cells in rat fetal liver cells

Rat fetal liver cells (FLC) obtained at 18–20 days gestation suppressed mixed lymphocyte reactions(MLR) of adult lymph node cells. The suppression was not strain specific: both syngeneic and allogeneic FLC were capable of suppressing the MLR. The same suppressor activity was observed with fetal spleen cells but not with fetal thymus cells. Removal of phagocytic cells from FLC failed to inhibit the suppressor activity. The suppressor cells were separated into two different types by BSA density gradient: one is radiosensitive, the other radioresistant. A stronger suppressor activity was observed in radiosensitive cells. The suppressor cells belonged to the fraction agglutinated with peanut agglutinin. The data suggest that the suppressor cells in rat FLC may be a proliferating blastoid-type cell rather than mature lymphocytes or mature macrophages.     

Recognition of protozoan parasites by murine T lymphocytes. II. Role of the H-2 gene complex in interactions between antigen-presenting macrophages and Leishmania-immune T lymphocytes

The proliferative response of nylon wool purified, primed lymph node cells to L. tropica parasites in vitro was found to be restored by the addition of either syngeneic or allogeneic adherent spleen cells as a putative source of macrophages. These results suggested a lack of H-2 restriction in Leishmania-specific T cell responses. However, when T cell blasts generated in vitro in response to the parasite were separated on Percoll density gradients and subsequently maintained for 4 days in the presence of TCGF, their response to L. tropica was found to be strictly dependent on the presence of syngeneic spleen cells. Further studies using congenic recombinant mice demonstrated that proliferation of a parasite-specific blasts required the presence of spleen cells compatible with the responding cells in the I-A region of the MHC. This requirement for I-A compatible adherent cells in the spleen cell populations was further confirmed by a lack of proliferative responses in the presence of spleen cells treated with monoclonal anti-la antibodies and complement. Leishmania-immune F1 blasts responding to the parasite in the context of either parental la-bearing accessory cell could be obtained by positive selection from a F1 hybrid responding cell population. Using flow microfluorometry, the T cell phenotype of the L. tropica-specific blasts was determined to be Thy-1+, lyt-1+, and Lyt-2-.     

Regulatory T cell subpopulations in pregnancy. I. Evidence for suppressive activity of the early phase of MLR.

Previous in vivo experiments have provided evidence of suppressive activity induced by multiple allogeneic pregnancies. The reactivity of maternal spleen cells toward paternal strain alloantigens was investigated by use of MLR microculture technique. A study of the kinetics of the MLR showed an early peak of reactivity (48-hr culture) followed by a decline leading to a decreased reactivity by 96 hr when spleen cells from allogeneically pregnant mice were compared to those of virgin or even isogeneically pregnant mice, suggesting the possible action of MLR regulatory cells. A strong suppression of a H-2k (CBA) anti-H-2a (A/J) or anti-H-2d (C57BL/Ks) MLR was observed when mitomycin-treated spleen cells from CBA mice multiparous by A/J or C57BL/Ks (but not CBA) males were added to the culture. This suppression was abolished by treating the regulatory cell population with anti-theta serum plus complement or replacing the 1% normal mouse serum in the medium by a proper antiidiotypic mouse serum.     

A vaccine based on exosomes secreted by a dendritic cell line confers protection against T. gondii infection in syngeneic and allogeneic mice

Our results show that exosomes secreted by SRDC pulsed in vitro with Toxoplasma gondii-derived antigens (Exo-TAg) induced protective responses against infection with the parasite in both syngeneic and allogeneic mice. After oral infection, syngeneic CBA/J mice exhibited significantly fewer cysts in their brains and allogeneic C57BL/6 mice survived. This protection was associated with strong humoral responses in vivo in serum from both CBA/J and C57BL/6 mice, and with high levels of anti-TAg IgA antibodies in intestinal secretions from CBA/J mice alone. Furthermore, strong cellular responses in vivo were observed in both mouse models. Cellular proliferation was associated with cytokines production by spleen and mesenteric lymph node cells. The results presented here show that exosomes are nucleic acid free vesicles that are able to induce immune responses correlated with protection against parasitic infections in both syngeneic and allogeneic mice. They could constitute an efficient tool for use in vaccination and antitumor strategies based on exosomes.     

Fractionation of lymphocyte subpopulations which regulate mixed lymphocyte reactions.

Four days after injection of allogeneic lymphocytes BALB/c splenic T cells suppress proliferation of syngeneic cells in mixed lymphocyte reactions (MLR). Conversely, lymph node cells from the same mice amplify MLR responses. To further characterize these functional subpopulations, alloantigen-primed lymphocyte suspensions from both organs were fractionated by velocity sedimentation at unit-gravity. After fractionation MLR suppressor cells from spleens localized exclusively in rapidlly sedimenting fractions of large cells. MLR suppressor activity of cells from these fractions, as well as that of unfractionated spleen cell suspensions, was abolished by treatment with anti-Thy-1.2 serum and complement. Spleen cell fractions of similar sedimentation velocity also secreted a soluble MLR suppressor into culture supernatants. Although inhibitory of MLR, spleen cells of rapid sedimentation velocity did not suppress responses to T cell mitogens. In marked contrast with the effects of spleen cells, large 4-day-alloantigen-primed lymph node cells had no suppressive activity in MLR. MLR amplifier cells of uncertain derivation were found in fractions of medium sedimentation velocity from both spleens and lymph nodes. Fractionation of alloantigen-primed lymph node cell suspensions did reveal, however, a subpopulation of small cells with MLR suppressor acitivty which was unaffected by treatment with anti-Thy-1 serum and complement. The data thus indicate that large alloantigen-activated lymphocytes are not intrinsically suppressive nor are cells which suppress MLR necessarily large. We consequently conclude that regulation of MLR responses by alloantigen-primed lymphocytes involves a complex interaction between distinct functional subpopulations of cells which are separable both by physical and biologic properties.     

Phytohemagglutinin-induced proliferation of guinea pig thymus-derived lymphocytes. I. Accessory cell dependence.

The accessory cell requirement for mitogen-induced T lymphocyte proliferation has been investigated by using a population of guinea pig lymph node lymphocytes enriched in T cells and markedly depleted of macrophages and B lymphocytes. We have found that effective phytohemagglutinin-induced proliferation of T cells is dependent on the participation of accessory cells. Augmentation of PHA responsiveness was noted when cultural conditions were manipulated to increase cell density, suggesting that physical proximity between T cell and accessory cell is required for efficient triggering. Both syngeneic and allogeneic macrophages, as well as syngeneic fibroblasts, serve as accessory cells in this response whereas polymorphonuclear leukocytes or thymocytes do not. Thus, although PHA-induced T lymphocyte proliferation requires accessory cells, the specificity of these cells is strikingly less stringent than for antigen-mediated triggering of immune guinea pig T cells, a response which is dependent upon participation of syngeneic macrophages.     

Regulation of cytotoxic lymphocyte precursors: I. Interactions between concanavalin A and T cell growth factors

The induction of cytotoxic T lymphocytes by concanavalin A has been analyzed under conditions of limit dilution. The dose-response curves deviate from linearity in a way that has been interpreted as revealing successive zones of suppression as the cell concentration was increased. The magnitude of suppression was influenced by both the concentration of concanavalin A and the amount of T cell growth factors added to the culture. These regulatory events involve the cytotoxic T cell clones produced by (CBA X DBA)F1 spleen cells which are detected by DBA mastocytoma (P815) targets at a maximum detectable frequency of 1 in 2000 cells. Similar multiphase dose-response data were also obtained with syngeneic and allogeneic combinations with the same target cell. It is suggested that the successive zones of suppression and activation are a consequence of the relative frequencies of CTL-P, suppressive and helper cells, and the ease with which the cells are activated in limit dilution cultures. The experimental approach illustrates how CTL production can be manipulated to study the balance of signals required to control effector cell production.     

Existence of T cells manifesting self-reactivity indistinguishable from alloreactivity

The studies reported here were designed to analyze the phenotypic characteristics of self-reactive T lymphocytes induced in culture by allogeneic effect factor (AEF), as well as the control of their functional activities by the major histocompatibility complex (MHC). Unprimed T cells cultured with AEF in the absence of exogenous stimulating target cells become activated against self-antigens, as evidenced by their ability to manifest two distinct activities. First, such cells could lyse syngeneic target cells. This cytolytic activity was directed against H-2K antigens and was mediated by Lyt-2+ T cells. Second, the AEF-activated T cells could be stimulated in a secondary culture to high levels of proliferative activity by irradiated syngeneic spleen cells. The stimulator cells in this syngeneic mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) were found to be Thy-1-negative, Ia-positive splenic adherent cells. Stimulation in the secondary syngeneic MLR was provided by I-region specificities, and the majority of the proliferating cells were Lyt-1+ cells. Finally, AEF-induced T cells were effective in serving as effectors of graft-vs-host reactions in vivo in syngeneic recipients. These results prove that, under appropriate conditions, murine T lymphocytes can display aggressive patterns of self-reactivity that are similar in both quantity and quality to the classical patterns of alloreactivity and may have great significance for our understanding of MHC recognition processes.