Nonviral gene delivery: Towards artificial viruses

Several limitations to nonviral gene delivery have been overcome. Small nanometric particles have been obtained by condensation ofDNA with a polymerizable cation followed by DNA template-directed homopolymerization of the vector. Targeting of specific cell types has been achieved by using polyethylenimine (PEI), a cationic polymer, coupled to cell ligands such as galactose or small RGD peptide that allows cell entry by a receptor-mediated endocytosis pathway. Escape of the DNA complexes from the endosomes is favored by the ‘proton sponge’ effect as a consequence of the high buffering capacity of PEI. The last barrier to gene delivery, i.e. the nuclear membrane, can be crossed at the level of the nuclear pore complexes, by using nuclear localization signal DNA molecule conjugates. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Cyclodextrin-modified polyethylenimine polymers for gene delivery

Linear and branched poly(ethylenimines), lPEI and bPEI, respectively, grafted with beta-cyclodextrin are prepared to give CD-lPEI and CD-bPEI, respectively, and are investigated as in vitro and in vivo nonviral gene delivery agents. The in vitro toxicity and transfection efficiency are sensitive to the level of cyclodextrin grafting. The cyclodextrin-containing polycations, when combined with adamantane-poly(ethylene glycol) (AD-PEG) conjugates, form particles that are stable at physiological salt concentrations. PEGylated CD-lPEI-based particles give in vitro gene expression equal to or greater than lPEI as measured by the percentage of EGFP expressing cells. Tail vein injections into mice of 120 microg of plasmid DNA formulated with CD-lPEI and AD-PEG do not reveal observable toxicities, and both nucleic acid accumulation and expression are observed in liver.     

Nonviral gene delivery: techniques and implications for molecular medicine

Medical research continues to illuminate the origins of many human diseases. Gene therapy has been widely proposed as a novel strategy by which this knowledge can be used to deliver new and improved therapies. Viral gene transfer is relatively efficient but there are concerns relating to the use of viral vectors in humans. Conversely, nonviral vectors appear safe but inefficient. Therefore, the development of an efficient nonviral vector remains a highly desirable goal. This review focuses on the numerous challenges preventing efficient nonviral gene transfer in vivo and discusses the many technologies that have been adopted to overcome these problems.     

A degradable polyethylenimine derivative with low toxicity for highly efficient gene delivery

Routine clinical implementation of human gene therapy awaits safe and efficient gene delivery methods. Polymeric vectors hold promise due to the availability of diverse chemistries, potentially providing targeting, low immunogenicity, nontoxicity, and robustness, but lack sufficient gene delivery efficiency. We have synthesized a versatile group of degradable polycations, through addition of 800-Da polyethylenimine (PEI) to small diacrylate cross-linkers. The degradable polymers reported here are similar in structure, size (14-30 kDa), and DNA-binding properties to commercially available 25-kDa PEI, but mediate gene expression two- to 16-fold more efficiently and are essentially nontoxic. These easily synthesized polymers are some of the most efficient polymeric vectors reported to date and provide a versatile platform for investigation of the effects of polymer structure and degradation rate on gene delivery efficiency.     

Nonviral gene carriers based on diblock copolymers of poly(2-ethyl-2-oxazoline) and linear polyethylenimine

Diblock copolymers that consist of poly(2-ethyl-2-oxazoline) (PEOz) and linear polyethylenimine (LPEI) were prepared for use as nonviral gene carriers. The PEOz-b-LPEI copolymers were synthesized by coupling PEOz with LPEI in a thiol-disulfide exchange reaction between the sulfhydryl and pyridyl disulfide terminal groups. A polymer/DNA weight ratio (P/D) of over 12 was required to enable PEOz-b-LPEI to condense DNA completely. The DNA-condensing capability of the diblock copolymers was increased with increasing the hydrolytic degrees of the LPEI segment. The PEOz-b-LPEI polyplexes were stable in 150 mM NaCl aqueous solution and had a mean diameter around 190 nm, whereas BPEI and LPEI polyplexes formed large aggregates in the range 300-500 nm. In addition, these polyplexes exhibited the sensitivity to solution pH and were dissociated in the acidic buffers (pH < or = 5.5). The results of in vitro cell viability and luciferase assay indicated that PEOz-b-LPEI showed not only low cytotoxicity but also high transfection efficiency in gene expression.     

Cross-linked polyethylenimine as potential DNA vector for gene delivery with high efficiency and low cytotoxicity

Polyethylenimine (PEI) has been known as an efficient gene carrier with the highest cationiccharge potential.High transfection efficiency of PEI,along with its cytotoxicity,strongly depends on itsmolecular weight.To enhance its gene delivery efficiency and minimize cytotoxicity,we have synthesizedsmall cross-linked PEI with biodegradable linkages and evaluated their transfection efficiencies in vitro.Inthis study,branched PEI with a molecular weight of 800 Da was cross-linked by small diacrylate[1,4-butanediol diacrylate or ethyleneglycol dimethacrylate (EGDMA)] for 2-6 h.The efficiencies of thecross-linked PEI in in vitro transfection of plasmid DNA containing enhanced green fluorescent protein(EGFP) reporter gene were assessed in melanoma B 16F10 cell line and other cell lines.Flow cytometrywas used to quantify the cellular entry efficiency of plasmid and the transgene expression level.Thecytotoxicities of the cross-linked PEI in these cells were evaluated by MTT assay.EGDMA-PEI 800-4h,atypical cross-linked PEI reported here,mediated a more efficient expression of reporter gene than thecommercially available 25-kDa branched PEI control,and resulted in a 9-fold increase in gene deliveryin B16F10 cells and a 16-fold increase in 293T cells,while no cytotoxicity was found at the optimizedcondition for gene delivery.Furthermore,the transfection activity of polyplexes was preserved in thepresence of serum proteins.     

Optimization of 25 kDa linear polyethylenimine for efficient gene delivery.

A 25-kDa linear polyethylenimine (25 kDa L-PEI) has proven to be efficient and versatile agent for gene delivery. Therefore, we determined the optimal transfection conditions of 25 kDa L-PEI and examined whether it has comparable transfection efficiency with other commercially available reagents, ExGen 500, LipofectAMINE 2000, and Effectene by using EGFP expression vector in different cell lines. Transfection efficiency and cytotoxicity were measured by flow cytometry. First of all, we determined the optimal ratio of nitrogen to phosphorous (N/P) and DNA concentration. With the increase of N/P ratio and DNA amounts, transfection efficiency increased with a slight variation in cell types. The optimal amounts of 25 kDa L-PEI were determined at N/P ratio 40 and DNA concentration varied among the cell types. In addition, 25 kDa L-PEI worked efficiently and was less toxic than other reagents. However, the efficiency and toxicity of all these reagents varied according to cell types as well as the ratio of DNA to reagents and the amounts of DNA. Our finding illustrates the importance of optimal transfection conditions of 25 kDa L-PEI to obtain maximal transgene expression with less cytotoxicity. Importantly, the optimization of those conditions may make possible to perform transfection cost-effectively and efficiently.     

Nonviral vector loaded collagen sponges for sustained gene delivery in vitro and in vivo

Background

Naked DNA and standard vectors have previously been used for gene delivery from implantable carrier matrices with great potential for gene therapeutic assistance of wound healing or tissue engineering. We have previously developed copolymer‐protected gene vectors which are inert towards opsonization. Here we examine their potency in carrier‐mediated gene delivery in comparison to standard vectors using a vector‐loaded collagen sponge model.

Methods

Equine collagen type I sponges were loaded by a lyophilization method with naked DNA, polyethylenimine (PEI)‐DNA, DOTAP/cholesterol‐DNA and copolymer‐protected PEI‐DNA. These preparations were characterized in terms of vector‐release, cell growth on the matrices and reporter gene expression by cells colonizing the sponges in vitro and in vivo. Subcutaneous implantation of sponges in rats served as an in vivo model.

Results

At the chosen low vector dose, the loading efficiency was at least 86%. Naked DNA‐loaded collagen matrices lost 77% of the DNA dose in an initial burst in aqueous buffer in vitro. The other preparations examined displayed a sustained vector release. There was no difference in cell growth and invasion of the sponges between vector‐loaded and untreated collagen grafts. Reporter gene expression from cells colonizing the sponges in vitro was observed for not more than 7 days with naked DNA, whereas the lipoplex and polyplex preparations yielded long‐term expression throughout the experimental period of up to 56 days. The highest expression levels were achieved with the PEI‐DNA‐PROCOP (protective copolymer) formulation. Upon subcutaneous implantation in rats, no luciferase expression was detected with naked DNA preparations. DOTAP/cholesterol‐DNA and PEI‐DNA‐loaded implants lead to reporter gene expression for at least 3 days, but with poor reproducibility. PEI‐DNA‐PROCOP collagen matrices yielded consistently the highest reporter gene expression levels for at least 7 days with good reproducibility.

Conclusions

With the preparation method chosen, lipoplex‐ and polyplex‐loaded collagen sponges are superior in mediating sustained gene delivery in vitro and local transfection in vivo as compared to naked DNA‐loaded sponges. Protective copolymers are particularly advantageous in promoting the tranfection capacity of polyplex‐loaded sponges upon subcutaneous implantation, likely due to their stabilizing and opsonization‐inhibiting properties. Copyright © 2002 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

     

A composite gene delivery system consisting of polyethylenimine and an amphipathic peptide KALA

BACKGROUND: Animal viruses such as enveloped virus carry multi-functional proteins in the virion that can mediate more than two distinct steps of a gene delivery process during the transfer of viral genome into host cells. We tested if the aspects of the viral gene delivery mechanism could be mimicked by forming composite formulae from multi-functional synthetic gene carriers having complementary action modes. METHODS: Polyethylenimine (PEI) was chosen as the component responsible for endosome escape and DNA condensation and KALA for cellular entry and DNA condensation. Compact DNA-carrier particles consisting of the core part where DNA chains were tightly condensed by PEI and the outer layer lined with KALA were formulated, characterized and compared with monolithic cationic formulae in terms of gene delivery efficiency and mechanism. RESULTS: High-level gene expression was observed when C2C12 cells were transfected with DNA that was first partially condensed with PEI and, then, fully with KALA. In these formulae KALA mediated enhanced cellular entry of DNA by facilitating endocytic vesicle formation, while PEI provided an effective endosomolytic capacity. An optimal PEI/KALA formula showed transfection efficiencies better than or comparable to the commercial cationic liposome in various cell types in culture and in vivo. CONCLUSIONS: Gene delivery by combining the membrane-active property of KALA with the endosomolytic activity of PEI can be more efficient than that by either of the properties alone. It appears that, in these formulae, the predominant role of KALA is to facilitate cellular entry of DNA by providing a fusogenic capability, rather than an endosomolytic activity.     

Acetylation of polyethylenimine enhances gene delivery via weakened polymer/DNA interactions

We previously reported that gene delivery efficiency of 25-kDa, branched polyethylenimine (PEI) increased upon acetylation of up to 43% of the primary amines with acetic anhydride. In the present work, we investigated the effects of further increasing the degree of acetylation and elucidated the source of the higher gene delivery efficiency. Despite reduced buffering capacity, gene delivery activity continued to increase (up to 58-fold in HEK293) with acetylation of up to 57% of primary amines but decreased at higher degrees of acetylation. Characterization of polymer-DNA interactions showed that acetylated polymers bind less strongly to DNA. Further, a fluorescence resonance energy transfer assay showed that increasing acetylation causes polyplexes to unpackage inside cells to a higher degree than polyplexes formed with unmodified PEI. Overall, the data suggest that the increased gene delivery activity may be attributable to an appropriate balance between polymer buffering capacity and strength of polymer/DNA interactions.     

PEI-g-chitosan, a novel gene delivery system with transfection efficiency comparable to polyethylenimine in vitro and after liver administration in vivo

Polyethylenimine-graft-chitosan (PEI-g-chitosan) was synthesized by performing cationic polymerization of aziridine in the presence of water-soluble oligo-chitosan (M(n) = 3400). The absolute molecular weight and chemistry of the PEI-g-chitosan obtained were characterized using GPC, 13C and 1H NMR, respectively. The results indicated that all the amines of chitosan were grafted with oligo-PEI, and the average length of the oligo-PEI side chains was determined by the feed molar ratio of aziridne/amine in chitosan. PEI-g-chitosan of M(n) = 7400 with a polydispersity index (PDI) of 1.50, and PEI side chains of M(n) = 206 was prepared for gene delivery. Gel electrophoresis showed that DNA migration was retarded completely at a N/P ratio of 2.5/1, indicating good DNA condensation capability of PEI-g-chitosan. The sizes and the zeta-potentials of the complexes of PEI-g-chitosan/DNA were characterized. The cytotoxicity of PEI-g-chiotsan was evaluated, and the results reflected that PEI-g-chitosan had a lower cytotoxicity than PEI (25 K). Gene transfection efficiency of PEI-g-chitosan in HepG2, HeLa, and primary hepatocytes cells and after administration in the common bile duct of rat liver was determined. Remarkably, PEI-g-chitosan showed a higher transfection efficiency than that of PEI (25 K) both in vitro and in vivo. The systematic distribution and the distribution in liver of the gene expression of the complexes of PEI-chitosan/DNA were determined as well.     

Methodological optimization of polyethylenimine (PEI)-based gene delivery to the lungs of mice via aerosol application

BACKGROUND: Polyethylenimine (PEI) has been successfully used for gene delivery to the lungs of mice via aerosol application using a whole body nebulization device. In this report we optimized the design of such an aerosol device. METHODS: Aerosol devices were constructed as either serial inhalation apparatus or as a whole body nebulization chamber connected to an aerosol spacer placed in a horizontal or vertical position. PEI-based gene vectors were nebulized using a standard jet nebulizer and luciferase gene expression of various tissues was examined. RESULTS: Using a whole body aerosol device resulted in luciferase gene expression in the lungs of mice at the same level as compared with a serial inhalation apparatus. Whereas gene expression was enhanced in the presence of 5% CO(2)-in-air, anesthesia of mice strongly decreased gene expression even when mice were intubated with an intravascular cannula. Reduction of the median mass aerodynamic diameter (MMAD) of the aerosol from 3.4 to 0.27 microm by interposition of an aerosol spacer increased gene expression significantly 3-fold. Drying of the aerosol by silica gel additionally increased gene delivery significantly 3-fold. Reporter gene expression mediated by branched PEI 25 kDa was 9- and 15-fold higher as compared with linear PEIs of 22 and 25 kDa, respectively, and was dependent on the DNA concentration. Gene expression was detectable as soon as 6 h after gene vector application and reached a maximum after 72 h but was still detectable after 14 days. The presence of Zn(2+) did not increase gene expression. CONCLUSION: We propose aerosol drying as a novel and simple method of optimizing PEI-based gene delivery to the lungs.     

Selective gene delivery to cancer cells secreting matrix metalloproteinases using a gelatin/polyethylenimine/DNA complex

We developed a gene delivery strategy targeting metastatic tumors by exploiting the specific matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) secreting properties of metastatic tumor cells. A ternary polyplex has been formed by coating polyethylenimine/DNA (PD) complex with an excessive amount of negatively charged gelatin B (GPDB). We show that GPD-B’s gene delivery activity could be targeted to cancer cells via the MMP-mediated proteolytic process, while GPD-A, made from positively charged gelatin A, was not successful in exhibiting such activity. The 1,10-Phenanthroline, an MMP2 inhibitor, abrogated the MMP-dependent transfection activity of GPD-B. GPD-B carried much less positive surface charges than PD, and thus exhibited significantly reduced interactions with erythrocytes. However, MMP2 elevated the positiveness in GPDB’s surface charge and, thus, its interaction with erythrocytes. These results suggest that the anionic gelatin coating may confer improved stabilities on GPD-B in the surrounding medium, while MMP2-mediated disintegration of the gelatin coat enhances the gene delivery to metastatic cancer cells via increasing the likelihood of local chargemediated interactions between the polyplex and cancer cell membrane.     

A miniaturized nebulization catheter for improved gene delivery to the mouse lung

BACKGROUND: The available methods for administration of gene delivery systems to the lungs of small animals via nebulization have several drawbacks. These include lack of control over the delivered dose and a negative impact on the stability of the formulation. This paper describes a new nebulization catheter device for the administration of plasmid-based gene delivery systems (polyplexes) as aerosols to the mouse lung in vivo. METHODS: The physical stability of naked pDNA and polyplexes formulated with chitosan oligomers and PEI was examined following nebulization with the catheter device. We also examined the in vitro transfection efficiency of the polyplexes recovered after nebulization. Lung distribution and gene expression after administration of the selected gene delivery systems to the mouse lung were also investigated. RESULTS: In contrast to previously described nebulization methods, the structural integrity of the unprotected naked pDNA was maintained following nebulization by the catheter device, which indicates relatively mild nebulization conditions. In addition, the nebulization procedure did not affect the physical stability of the formulated polyplexes. Small volumes of the pDNA aerosol (10-20 microl) were delivered in a highly controlled and reproducible manner. The aerosol droplet size varied with the molecular weight of the polycations. Aerosol delivery via this method resulted in improved lung distribution of pDNA polyplexes and a six-fold increase in the efficiency of gene delivery in vivo over that seen with the commonly used intratracheal instillation method. CONCLUSION: The use of the nebulization catheter device provides a promising alternative for aerosol gene delivery to the mouse lung.     

Controlled delivery of plasmid DNA and siRNA to intracellular targets using ketalized polyethylenimine

A new polyethylenimine (PEI)-derived biodegradable polymer was synthesized as a nonviral gene carrier. Branches of PEI were ketalized, and capabilities of nucleic acid condensation and delivery efficiency of the modified polymers were compared with ones of unketalized PEI. Ketalized PEI was able to efficiently compact both plasmid DNA and siRNA into nucleic acids/ketalized PEI polyplexes with a range of 80-200 nm in diameter. Nucleic acids were efficiently dissociated from the polyplexes made of ketalized PEI upon hydrolysis. In vitro study also demonstrated that ketalization enhanced transfection efficiency of the polyplexes while reducing cytotoxicity, even at high N/ P ratios. Interestingly, transfection efficiency was found to be inversely proportional to molecular weights of ketalized PEI, while RNA interference was observed in the opposite way. This study implies that selective delivery of plasmid DNA and siRNA to the nucleus and the cytoplasm can be achieved by tailoring the structures of polymeric gene carriers.