Stability mutants of staphylococcal nuclease: large compensating enthalpy-entropy changes for the reversible denaturation reaction

By use of intrinsic fluorescence to determine the apparent equilibrium constant Kapp as a function of temperature, the midpoint temperature Tm and apparent enthalpy change delta Happ on reversible thermal denaturation have been determined over a range of pH values for wild-type staphylococcal nuclease and six mutant forms. For wild-type nuclease at pH 7.0, a Tm of 53.3 +/- 0.2 degrees C and a delta Happ of 86.8 +/- 1.4 kcal/mol were obtained, in reasonable agreement with values determined calorimetrically, 52.8 degrees C and 96 +/- 2 kcal/mol. The heat capacity change on denaturation delta Cp was estimated at 1.8 kcal/(mol K) versus the calorimetric value of 2.2 kcal/(mol K). When values of delta Happ and delta Sapp for a series of mutant nucleases that exhibit markedly altered denaturation behavior with guanidine hydrochloride and urea were compared at the same temperature, compensating changes in enthalpy and entropy were observed that greatly reduce the overall effect of the mutations on the free energy of denaturation. In addition, a correlation was found between the estimated delta Cp for the mutant proteins and the d(delta Gapp)/dC for guanidine hydrochloride denaturation. It is proposed that both the enthalpy/entropy compensation and this correlation between two seemingly unrelated denaturation parameters are consequences of large changes in the solvation of the denatured state that result from the mutant amino acid substitutions.     

Mutant forms of staphylococcal nuclease with altered patterns of guanidine hydrochloride and urea denaturation

Eleven mutant forms of staphylococcal nuclease with one or more defined amino acid substitutions have been analyzed by solvent denaturation by using intrinsic fluorescence to follow the denaturation reaction. On the basis of patterns observed in the value of m--the rate of change of log Kapp (the apparent equilibrium constant between the native and denatured states) with denaturant concentration--these proteins can be grouped into two classes. For class I mutants, the value of m with guanidine hydrochloride is less than the wild-type value and is either constant or increases slightly with increasing denaturant; the value of m with urea is also less than wild type but shows a marked increase with increasing denaturant concentration, often approaching but never exceeding the wild-type value. For class II mutants, m is constant and is greater than wild type in both denaturants, with the increase being consistently larger in guanidine hydrochloride than in urea. When double or triple mutants are constructed from members of the same mutant class, the change in m is usually the sum of the changes produced by each mutation in isolation. One plausible explanation for these altered patterns of denaturation is that chain-chain or chain-solvent interactions in the denatured state have been modified--interactions which appear to involve hydrophobic groups.     

Reshaping the folding energy landscape by chloride salt: impact on molten-globule formation and aggregation behavior of carbonic anhydrase

During chemical denaturation different intermediate states are populated or suppressed due to the nature of the denaturant used. Chemical denaturation by guanidine-HCl (GuHCl) of human carbonic anhydrase II (HCA II) leads to a three-state unfolding process (Cm,NI=1.0 and Cm,IU=1.9 M GuHCl) with formation of an equilibrium molten-globule intermediate that is stable at moderate concentrations of the denaturant (1-2 M) with a maximum at 1.5 M GuHCl. On the contrary, urea denaturation gives rise to an apparent two-state unfolding transition (Cm=4.4 M urea). However, 8-anilino-1-naphthalene sulfonate (ANS) binding and decreased refolding capacity revealed the presence of the molten globule in the middle of the unfolding transition zone, although to a lesser extent than in GuHCl. Cross-linking studies showed the formation of moderate oligomer sized (300 kDa) and large soluble aggregates (>1000 kDa). Inclusion of 1.5 M NaCl to the urea denaturant to mimic the ionic character of GuHCl leads to a three-state unfolding behavior (Cm,NI=3.0 and Cm,IU=6.4 M urea) with a significantly stabilized molten-globule intermediate by the chloride salt. Comparisons between NaCl and LiCl of the impact on the stability of the various states of HCA II in urea showed that the effects followed what could be expected from the Hofmeister series, where Li+ is a chaotropic ion leading to decreased stability of the native state. Salt addition to the completely urea unfolded HCA II also led to an aggregation prone unfolded state, that has not been observed before for carbonic anhydrase. Refolding from this state only provided low recoveries of native enzyme.     

Apparent Debye-Huckel electrostatic effects in the folding of a simple, single domain protein

We have monitored the effects of salts and denaturants on the folding of the simple, two-state protein FynSH3. As predicted by Debye-Huckel limiting law, both the stability and (log) folding rate of FynSH3 increase nearly perfectly linearly (r(2)> 0.99) with the square root of ionic strength upon increasing concentrations of the relatively nonchaotropic salt sodium chloride. The stability of FynSH3 is also linear in square root ionic strength when the relatively nonchaotropic salts sodium bromide, potassium bromide, and potassium chloride are employed. Comparison of the kinetic and equilibrium effects of sodium chloride suggests that the electrostatic interactions formed in the folding transition state are approximately 50% as destabilizing as those formed in the native state, presumably reflecting the more compact nature of the latter. In contrast, the relationship between concentration and folding kinetics is more complex when the highly chaotropic salt guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl) is employed. At moderate to high GuHCl concentrations the net effect of the linear, presumably chaotrope-induced deceleration and the presumed, square root-dependent ionic strength-induced acceleration is well approximated as linear, thus accounting for the observation of "chevron behavior" (log folding rate linear in denaturant concentration) typically reported for the folding of single domain proteins. At very low GuHCl concentrations, however, significant kinetic rollover is observed. This rollover is reasonably well fitted as a sum of a linear, presumably chaotropic effect and a square root-dependent, presumably electrostatic effect. These results thus not only provide insight into the nature of the folding transition state but also suggest that caution is in order when extrapolating GuHCl-based chevrons to estimate folding rates in the absence of denaturant and in interpreting deviations from chevron linearity as evidence for non-two-state kinetics.     

Sequential conformation change and activation of chicken liver dihydrofolate reductase in low concentration of guanidine hydrochloride

The conformation changes of dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) from chicken liver in guanidine hy-drochloride were monitored by protein intrinsic fluorescence, hydrophobic fluorescence probe TNS and limited proteol-ysis by proteinase K. The kinetics of the enzyme denaturation were also studied and compared with its activity changes. It was indicated by the enhanced fluorescence of 2-p-toluidinylnaphthalene (TNS) that a subtle conforma-tional change of the enzyme in dilute GuHCl parallels GuHCl-induced activation. At GuHCl concentration higher than 0.75 mol/L, the conformational change can be detected by increased susceptibility of the enzyme to proteinase K, but no significant gross conformational change of the enzyme molecule is observed by intrinsic fluorescence up to a GuHCl concentration of 1.2 mol/L. The results suggest that the denaturation of DHFR by GuHCl does not follow strictly the two-state model. The enzyme seems to open up sequentially with increasing concentrations of denaturants, mainly at th     

Surface point mutations that significantly alter the structure and stability of a protein's denatured state.

Significantly different m values (1.9-2.7 kcal mol-1 M-1) were observed for point mutations at a single, solvent-exposed site (T53) in a variant of the B1 domain of streptococcal Protein G using guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl) as a denaturant. This report focuses on elucidating the energetic and structural implications of these m-value differences in two Protein G mutants, containing Ala and Thr at position 53. These two proteins are representative of the high (m+) and low (m-) m-value mutants studied. Differential scanning calorimetry revealed no evidence of equilibrium intermediates. A comparison of GuHCl denaturation monitored by fluorescence and circular dichroism showed that secondary and tertiary structure denatured concomitantly. The rates of folding (286 S-1 for the m+ mutant and 952 S-1 for the m- mutant) and the rates of unfolding (11 S-1 for m+ mutant and 3 S-1 for the m- mutant) were significantly different, as determined by stopped-flow fluorescence. The relative solvation free energies of the transition states were identical for the two proteins (alpha ++ = 0.3). Small-angle X-ray scattering showed that the radius of gyration of the denatured state (Rgd) of the m+ mutant did not change with increasing denaturant concentrations (Rgd approximately 23 A); whereas, the Rgd of the m- mutant increased from approximately 17 A to 23 A with increasing denaturant concentration. The results indicate that the mutations exert significant effects in both the native and GuHCl-induced denatured state of these two proteins.     

Thermodynamics of unfolding for turkey ovomucoid third domain: thermal and chemical denaturation.

We have used thermal and chemical denaturation to characterize the thermodynamics of unfolding for turkey ovomucoid third domain (OMTKY3). Thermal denaturation was monitored spectroscopically at a number of wave-lengths and data were subjected to van't Hoff analysis; at pH 2.0, the midpoint of denaturation (Tm) occurs at 58.6 +/- 0.4 degrees C and the enthalpy of unfolding at this temperature (delta Hm) is 40.8 +/- 0.3 kcal/mol. When Tm was perturbed by varying pH and denaturant concentration, the resulting plots of delta Hm versus Tm yield a mean value of 590 +/- 120 cal/(mol.K) for the change in heat capacity upon unfolding (delta Cp). A global fit of the same data to an equation that includes the temperature dependence for the enthalpy of unfolding yielded a value of 640 +/- 110 cal/(mol.K). We also performed a variation of the linear extrapolation method described by Pace and Laurents, which is an independent method for determining delta Cp (Pace, C.N. & Laurents, D., 1989, Biochemistry 28, 2520-2525). First, OMTKY3 was thermally denatured in the presence of a variety of denaturant concentrations. Linear extrapolations were then made from isothermal slices through the transition region of the denaturation curves. When extrapolated free energies of unfolding (delta Gu) were plotted versus temperature, the resulting curve appeared linear; therefore, delta Cp could not be determined. However, the data for delta Gu versus denaturant concentration are linear over an extraordinarily wide range of concentrations. Moreover, extrapolated values of delta Gu in urea are identical to values measured directly.     

Equilibrium denaturation of recombinant porcine growth hormone.

Equilibrium denaturation of recombinant porcine growth hormone (pGH) derived from Escherichia coli using the denaturant guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl) was followed by ultraviolet absorption spectroscopy, intrinsic fluorescence, far-ultraviolet circular dichroism, and size-exclusion chromatography. The normalized denaturation transition curves for each of the above methods were not coincident; denaturation resulted in an initial disruption of the tertiary structure, whereas secondary structure and degree of compactness were disrupted at higher concentrations of denaturant. Size-exclusion chromatography also detected an associated form of pGH at intermediate GuHCl concentrations. These findings conclusively show that pGH does not follow a simple two-state folding mechanism but are consistent with the framework model of folding. Stable intermediates observed were similar to those seen in other nonhuman growth hormones and are characterized as compact and largely alpha-helical yet lacking nativelike tertiary structure.     

Reversible denaturation of oligomeric human chaperonin 10: denatured state depends on chemical denaturant

Chaperonins cpn60/cpn10 (GroEL/GroES in Escherichia coli) assist folding of nonnative polypeptides. Folding of the chaperonins themselves is distinct in that it entails assembly of a sevenfold symmetrical structure. We have characterized denaturation and renaturation of the recombinant human chaperonin 10 (cpn10), which forms a heptamer. Denaturation induced by chemical denaturants urea and guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl) as well as by heat was monitored by tyrosine fluorescence, far-ultraviolet circular dichroism, and cross-linking; all denaturation reactions were reversible. GuHCl-induced denaturation was found to be cpn10 concentration dependent, in accord with a native heptamer to denatured monomer transition. In contrast, urea-induced denaturation was not cpn10 concentration dependent, suggesting that under these conditions cpn10 heptamers denature without dissociation. There were no indications of equilibrium intermediates, such as folded monomers, in either denaturant. The different cpn10 denatured states observed in high [GuHCl] and high [urea] were supported by cross-linking experiments. Thermal denaturation revealed that monomer and heptamer reactions display the same enthalpy change (per monomer), whereas the entropy-increase is significantly larger for the heptamer. A thermodynamic cycle for oligomeric cpn10, combining chemical denaturation with the dissociation constant in absence of denaturant, shows that dissociated monomers are only marginally stable (3 kJ/mol). The thermodynamics for co-chaperonin stability appears conserved; therefore, instability of the monomer could be necessary to specify the native heptameric structure.     

Solvent denaturation and stabilization of globular proteins

Statistical thermodynamic theory has recently been developed to account for the stabilities of globular proteins. Here we extend that work to predict the effects of solvents on protein stability. Folding is assumed to be driven by solvophobic interactions and opposed by conformational entropy. The solvent dependence of the solvophobic interactions is taken from transfer experiments of Nozaki and Tanford on amino acids into aqueous solutions of urea or guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl). On the basis of the assumption of two pathways involving collapse and formation of a core, the theory predicts that increasing denaturant should lead to a two-state denaturation transition (i.e., there is a stable state along each path separated by a free energy barrier). The denaturation midpoint is predicted to occur at higher concentrations of urea than of GuHCl. At neutral pH, the radius of the solvent-denatured state should be much smaller than for a random-flight chain and increase with either denaturant concentration or number of polar residues in the chain. A question of interest is whether free energies of folding should depend linearly on denaturant, as is often assumed. The free energy is predicted to be linear for urea but to have some small curvature for GuHCl. Predicted slopes and exposed areas of the unfolded states are found to be in generally good agreement with experiments. We also discuss stabilizing solvents and compare thermal with solvent denaturation.     

A test of the linear extrapolation of unfolding free energy changes over an extended denaturant concentration range.

Guanidine hydrochloride (GdnHCl) and thermally induced unfolding measurements on the oxidized form of Escherichia coli thioredoxin at pH 7 were combined for the purpose of assessing the functional dependence of unfolding free energy changes on denaturant concentration over an extended GdnHCl concentration range. Conventional analysis of GdnHCl unfolding exhibits a linear plot of unfolding delta G vs [GdnHCl] in the transition zone. In order to extend unfolding delta G measurements outside of that narrow concentration range, thermal unfolding measurements were performed using differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) in the presence of low to moderate concentrations of GdnHCl. The unfolding delta G values from the DSC measurements were corrected to 25 degrees C using the Gibbs-Helmholtz equation and mapped onto the delta G vs [GdnHCl] plot. The dependence of unfolding delta G on [GdnHCl] was found to be linear over the full denaturant concentration range, provided that the chloride ion concentration was kept at a threshold of greater than or equal to 1.5 M. In the DSC experiments performed in the presence of GdnHCl, chloride concentrations were maintained at 1.5 M by addition of appropriate amounts of NaCl. The linear extrapolation method (LEM) gives an unfolding free energy change in the absence of denaturant (delta G degrees N-U) in excellent agreement with the delta G determined by DSC measurement in 1.5 M NaCl. The various methods give a consensus unfolding delta G value of 8.0 kcal/mol at 25 degrees C in the absence of denaturant.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

NMR studies on the induced denaturation of lysozyme by guanidine hydrochloride in the presence of the inhibitor (NAG)3

The stabilization of the folded conformation of lysozyme, arising from the binding of the inhibitor (NAG)3 against induced denaturation, is demonstrated from the 1H-nmr spectra of the enzyme. The nmr spectra reveal that the binding of the denaturant (GuHCl) to the enzyme is associated with changes in the conformation of the enzyme. The binding site of the inhibitor site C also serves as one of the binding sites of GuHCl. The observation that higher denaturant concentrations are required in the unfolding of Lys-(NAG)3 as compared to free Lys can be explained partly in terms of the existence of a competitive binding to the enzyme involving the (NAG)3 and GuHCl molecules.     

The pH dependence of the reversible unfolding of ovalbumin A1 by guanidine hydrochloride.

The pH dependence of the reversible guanidine hydrochloride denaturation of the major fraction of ovalbumin (ovalbumin A1) was studied by a viscometric method in the pH range 1-7, at 25 degrees C and at six different denaturant concentrations (1.5-2.6 M). At any denaturant concentrationa reduction in pH favoured the transition from the native to the denatured state. The latter was essentially 'structureless', as revealed by the fact that the reduced viscosity of the acid and guanidine hydrochloride denatured state of ovalbumin A1 (obtained at different denaturant concentrations in acidic solutions) was measured (at a protein concentration of 3.8 mg/ml) to be 29.2 ml/g which is identical to that found in 6 M guanidine hydrochloride wherein the protein behaves as a cross-linked random coil. A quantitative analysis of the results on the pH dependence of the equilibrium constant for the denaturation process showed that on denaturation the intrinsic pK of two carboxyl groups in ovalbumin A1 went up from 3.1 in the native state to 4.4 in the denatured state of the protein.     

Counteracting osmolyte trimethylamine N-oxide destabilizes proteins at pH below its pKa. Measurements of thermodynamic parameters of proteins in the presence and absence of trimethylamine N-oxide

Earlier studies have reported that trimethylamine N-oxide (TMAO), a naturally occurring osmolyte, is a universal stabilizer of proteins because it folds unstructured proteins and counteracts the deleterious effects of urea and salts on the structure and function of proteins. This conclusion has been reached from the studies of the effect of TMAO on proteins in the pH range 6.0-8.0. In this pH range TMAO is almost neutral (zwitterionic form), for it has a pK(a) of 4.66 +/- 0.10. We have asked the question of whether the effect of TMAO on protein stability is pH-dependent. To answer this question we have carried out thermal denaturation studies of lysozyme, ribonuclease-A, and apo-alpha-lactalbumin in the presence of various TMAO concentrations at different pH values above and below the pK(a) of TMAO. The main conclusion of this study is that near room temperature TMAO destabilizes proteins at pH values below its pK(a), whereas it stabilizes proteins at pH values above its pK(a). This conclusion was reached by determining the T(m) (midpoint of denaturation), delta H(m) (denaturational enthalpy change at T(m)), delta C(p) (constant pressure heat capacity change), and delta G(D) degrees (denaturational Gibbs energy change at 25 degrees C) of proteins in the presence of different TMAO concentrations. Other conclusions of this study are that T(m) and delta G(D) degrees depend on TMAO concentration at each pH value and that delta H(m) and the delta C(p) are not significantly changed in presence of TMAO.     

Kinetics of Denaturation of Rabbit Skeletal Muscle Glycogen Phosphorylase b by Guanidine Hydrochloride

The kinetics of denaturation and aggregation of rabbit muscle glycogen phosphorylase b in the presence of guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl) have been studied. The curve of inactivation of phosphorylase b in time includes a region of the fast decline in the enzymatic activity,an intermediate plateau,and a part with subsequent decrease in the enzymatic activity. The fact that the shape of the inactivation curves is dependent on the enzyme concentration testifies to the dissociative mechanism of inactivation. The dissociation of phosphorylase b dimers into monomers in the presence of GuHCl is supported by sedimentation data. The rate of phosphorylase b aggregation in the presence of GuHCl rises as the denaturant concentration increases to 1.12 M; at higher concentration of GuHCl, suppression of aggregation occurs. At rather low concentration of the protein (0.25 mg/ml), the terminal phase of aggregation follows the kinetics of a monomolecular reaction (the reaction rate constant is equal to 0.082 min^–1;1 M GuHCl, 25°C). At higher concentration of phosphorylase b (0.75 mg/ml), aggregation proceeds as a trimolecular reaction.     

Does beta-lactoglobulin denaturation occur via an intermediate state?

The denaturation of beta-lactoglobulin (BLG) in the presence of urea and GuHCl has been investigated at different pH values with various spectroscopic techniques. The equilibrium denaturation free energy values, obtained by linearly extrapolating the data to vanishing denaturant (DeltaG(D)(H2O)), are compared and discussed. The fit of the spectroscopic data monitoring the denaturation of BLG has been approached, at first, with a two-state model that describes the protein transition from the folded state (at each pH and in the absence of denaturant) to the denatured state, but in particular, along the GuHCl denaturation pathway some evidence is found of the presence of an intermediate state. Time-resolved fluorescence experiments performed on the BLG-ANS (1-anilino-8-naphthalenesulfonate) complex help to understand the results. Fluorescence polarization anisotropy (FPA) measurements accompanying the denaturation process show the presence of a fast rotational diffusion of the ANS probe, and the data are interpreted in terms of local fluctuations of a still structured tract of the denatured protein where the probe is bound.     

Temperature- and denaturant-induced unfolding of two thermophilic esterases.

We studied the temperature- and denaturant-induced denaturation of two thermophilic esterases, AFEST from Archeoglobus fulgidus and EST2 from Alicyclobacillus acidocaldarius, by means of circular dichroism measurements. Both enzymes showed a very high denaturation temperature: 99 degrees C for AFEST and 91 degrees C for EST2. They also showed a remarkable resistance against urea; at half-completion of the transition the urea concentration was 7.1 M for AFEST and 5.9 M for EST2. On the contrary, both enzymes showed a weak resistance against GuHCl; at half-completion of the transition the GuHCl concentration was 2.0 M for AFEST and 1.9 M for EST2. The thermodynamic parameters characterizing urea- and GuHCl-induced denaturation of the studied enzymes have been obtained by both the linear extrapolation model and the denaturant binding model. The dependence of the thermal stability on NaCl concentration for both esterases has also been determined. A careful analysis of the data, coupled with available structural information, has allowed the proposal of a reliable interpretation.     

Kietics of thermal unfolding and refolding of thermostable phosphoglycerate kinase.

The kinetics of denaturation by guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl) of a thermostable phosphoglycerate kinase (PGK) extracted from Thermus thermophilus and of yeast PGK at neutral pH were studied by circular dichroism. Denaturation by GuHCl proceeded as a first-order reaction. The activation free energy of the denaturation reactions (delta Gf not identical to ) in the absence of GuHCl was estimated to be 32.7 kcal/mol for T. thermophilus PGK and 27.9 kcal/mol for yeast PGK (at 25 degrees C). Measurements of the rate constants at various temperatures indicated that delta Gf not identical to has maximum values at 29 degrees C for T. thermophilus PGK and at 20 degrees C for yeast PGK, and that the temperature dependences of delta Gf not identical to, delta Hf not identical to, and delta Sf not identical to for T. thermophilus PGK are smaller than those of yeast PGK. Values of delta Sf not identical to for thermal denaturation for both PGK's are approximately 200 e.u.