Comparison of SYTO9 and SYBR Green I for real-time polymerase chain reaction and investigation of the effect of dye concentration on amplification and DNA melting curve analysis

Following the initial report of the use of SYBR Green I for real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) in 1997, little attention has been given to the development of alternative intercalating dyes for this application. This is surprising considering the reported limitations of SYBR Green I, which include limited dye stability, dye-dependent PCR inhibition, and selective detection of amplicons during DNA melting curve analysis of multiplex PCRs. We have tested an alternative to SYBR Green I and report the first detailed evaluation of the intercalating dye SYTO9. Our findings demonstrate that SYTO9 produces highly reproducible DNA melting curves over a broader range of dye concentrations than does SYBR Green I, is far less inhibitory to PCR than SYBR Green I, and does not appear to selectively detect particular amplicons. The low inhibition and high melting curve reproducibility of SYTO9 means that it can be readily incorporated into a conventional PCR at a broad range of concentrations, allowing closed tube analysis by DNA melting curve analysis. These features simplify the use of intercalating dyes in real-time PCR and the improved reproducibility of DNA melting curve analysis will make SYTO9 useful in a diagnostic context.     

Comparison of multiple DNA dyes for real-time PCR: effects of dye concentration and sequence composition on DNA amplification and melting temperature

The importance of real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) has increased steadily in clinical applications over the last decade. Many applications utilize SYBR Green I dye to follow the accumulation of amplicons in real time. SYBR Green I has, however, a number of limitations that include the inhibition of PCR, preferential binding to GC-rich sequences and effects on melting curve analysis. Although a few alternative dyes without some of these limitations have been recently proposed, no large-scale investigation into the properties of intercalating dyes has been performed. In this study, we investigate 15 different intercalating DNA dyes for their inhibitory effects on PCR, effects on DNA melting temperature and possible preferential binding to GC-rich sequences. Our results demonstrated that in contrast to the results of SYBR Green I, two intercalating dyes SYTO-13 and SYTO-82 do not inhibit PCR, show no preferential binding to GC rich sequences and do not influence melting temperature, T_m, even at high concentrations. In addition, SYTO-82 demonstrated a 50-fold lower detection limit in a dilution series assay. In conclusion, the properties of SYTO-82 and SYTO-13 will simplify the development of multiplex assays and increase the sensitivity of real-time PCR.     

A New Organic Dye-Based Staining for The Detection of Plant DNA in Agarose Gels

Ethidium bromide (EtBr) is used to stain DNA in agarose gel electrophoresis, but this dye is mutagenic and carcinogenic. We investigated N-719, which is a visible, reliable and organic Ruthenium-based dye, and five fluorescent alternatives for staining plant DNA. For prestaining and poststaining, N-719, GelRed, and SYBR Safe stained both DNA and PCR product bands as clearly as EtBr. SYBR Green I, methylene blue, and crystal violet were effective for poststaining only. The organic dye N-719 stained DNA bands as sensitively and as clearly as EtBr. Consequently, organic dyes can be used as alternatives to EtBr in plant biotechnology studies.     

In situ monitoring of polymerase extension rate and adaptive feedback control of PCR by using fluorescence measurements

Real time PCR detection systems based on fluorescence detection from intercalating dyes (such as SYBR Green I) typically take only single point measurements during every cycle to quantify the amplification. In this process key information about enzymatic kinetics is lost. In this work we measure SYBR Green I fluorescence intensity every 0.5 s within a cycle during PCR in polypropylene tubes. We observe that the intensity during the extension cycle increases while the template is being extended. Results obtained for different lengths are used to estimate an in vitro polymerase activity rate of Thermus aquaticus and Thermus brockianus. An important practical consequence of this result is that the extension time of each PCR cycle can be individually optimized while the reaction is in progress. We demonstrate this idea of adaptive feedback control and show that the total number of cycles and total time required to reach maximum fluorescence is reduced as compared to conventional PCR.     

Ethidium bromide and SYBR Green I enhance the genotoxicity of UV-irradiation and chemical mutagens in E. coli

Ethidium bromide (EtBr) and SYBR Green I are nucleic acid gel stains and used commonly in combination with UV-illumination. EtBr preferentially induces frameshift mutations but only in the presence of an exogenous metabolic activation system, while SYBR Green I is a very weak mutagen that induces frameshift mutations. We found that EtBr and SYBR Green I, without an added metabolic activation system, strongly potentiated the base-substitution mutations induced by UV-irradiation in E. coli B/r WP2 cells. Each DNA stain alone showed no mutagenicity to the strain. Base-substitutions induced by 3-chloro-4-(dichloromethyl)-5-hydroxy-2(5H)-furanone (MX) and 4-nitroquinoline-1-oxide were similarly potentiated by EtBr and SYBR Green I. SYBR Green I had a much greater effect. No enhancing effects were observed on mutations induced by mitomycin C, cisplatin, transplatin, cumene hydroperoxide, base analogs, and alkylating agents. Another DNA stain, acridine orange, showed similar enhancing effects on UV- and MX-mutagenicity, but no effect was observed for 4',6-diamidino-2-phenylindole (DAPI). UV- and MX-induced mutations in E. coli WP2s (uvrA), which is defective in nucleotide excision repair activity, were not potentiated by the addition of EtBr, SYBR Green I, or acridine orange. Those nucleic acid stains might inhibit the nucleotide excision repair of DNA damaged by UV and MX treatment.     

Use of fluorescent DNA-intercalating dyes in the analysis of DNA via ion-pair reversed-phase denaturing high-performance liquid chromatography

SYBR Green 1 is an asymmetrical cyanine DNA-binding dye that provides an opportunity for increasing the sensitivity of nucleic acid detection when used in conjunction with gel electrophoresis. In this paper, we summarize the general properties and specific uses of SYBR green 1 in ion-pair reversed-phase denaturing high-performance liquid chromatography (IP DHPLC). We describe several applications for the WAVE DHPLC platform that illustrate the generic potential of such intercalating dyes in mutation detection and gene expression profiling. We show that SYBR Green 1 obviates the need to use end-labeled oligodeoxynucleotides for the sensitive detection of nucleic acids during chromatography. Moreover the incorporation of SYBR Green 1 into samples and elution buffers does not impair resolution and has no significant effect on the retention times of DNA fragments compared with dye-free DHPLC.     

Molecular diagnostic methods for detection of Thelohania contejeani (Microsporidia), the causative agent of porcelain disease in crayfish

Diagnosis of Thelohania contejeani in the crayfish Astacus astacus is currently based on observation of gross clinical signs--opaque appearance of the abdomen and whitish colouration of the musculature--and confirmed by microscopic examination of histological sections of muscle. We have developed 2 molecular diagnostic methods for sensitive and rapid detection of porcelain disease in its early stages: PCR and loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP). The PCR test utilises a primer based on the T. contejeani small subunit ssu ribosomal RNA (ssu rRNA) gene and amplified parasite DNA with high specificity and a detection limit of 10(-5) dilution. The LAMP assay involves incubation of the target DNA with a set of 6 primers and Bst DNA polymerase for 60 min at 65 degrees C in a water bath or heating block, followed by visualisation of the reaction products with the SYBR Green I stain; sensitivity of visual detection with SYBR Green I is equivalent to that with agarose gel electrophoresis. The LAMP assay can detect T. contejeani DNA to a dilution of 10(-7). The LAMP assay is 100 times more sensitive than the PCR test and is the method we recommend as an alternative to traditional means of diagnosing T. contejeani.     

A new minor groove binding asymmetric cyanine reporter dye for real-time PCR

The minor groove binding asymmetric cyanine dye 4-[(3-methyl-6-(benzothiazol-2-yl)-2,3-dihydro- (benzo-1,3-thiazole)-2-methylidene)]-1-methyl-pyridin ium iodide (BEBO) is tested as sequence non- specific label in real-time PCR. The fluorescence intensity of BEBO increases upon binding to double-stranded DNA allowing emission to be measured at the end of the elongation phase in the PCR cycle. BEBO concentrations between 0.1 and 0.4 µM generated sufficient fluorescence signal without inhibiting the PCR. A comparison with the commonly used reporter dye SYBR Green I shows that the two dyes behave similarly in all important aspects.     

Characterization of the PCR inhibitory effect of bile to optimize real-time PCR detection of Helicobacter species

The inhibitory effect of human and porcine bile samples to detect Helicobacter DNA was studied by adding different concentrations of bile samples to PCR mixtures of six thermostable DNA polymerases containing cagA specific primers and Helicobacter pylori DNA. PCR products were amplified by using the Rotorgene system and SYBR Green I. Among the six DNA polymerases tested, rTth had the lowest sensitivity to bile inhibitors, whereas Taq and Tfl had the highest sensitivity. Bile proteins did not inhibit AmpliTaq DNA polymerase, whereas the fraction containing mainly bile acids and their salts inhibited the amplification capacity of AmpliTaq. Heating human bile at 98 degrees C and adding casein and formamide to the reaction mixture reduced the PCR inhibitory effect of bile. Therefore, a pre-PCR treatment based on dilution and heating of bile, adding casein and formamide to the reaction mixture of rTth DNA polymerase was found efficient to amplify DNA directly in bile.     

Evaluation of quantification methods for real-time PCR minor groove binding hybridization probe assays

Real-time PCR data analysis for quantification has been the subject of many studies aimed at the identification of new and improved quantification methods. Several analysis methods have been proposed as superior alternatives to the common variations of the threshold crossing method. Notably, sigmoidal and exponential curve fit methods have been proposed. However, these studies have primarily analyzed real-time PCR with intercalating dyes such as SYBR Green. Clinical real-time PCR assays, in contrast, often employ fluorescent probes whose real-time amplification fluorescence curves differ from those of intercalating dyes. In the current study, we compared four analysis methods related to recent literature: two versions of the threshold crossing method, a second derivative maximum method, and a sigmoidal curve fit method. These methods were applied to a clinically relevant real-time human herpes virus type 6 (HHV6) PCR assay that used a minor groove binding (MGB) Eclipse hybridization probe as well as an Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) PCR assay that used an MGB Pleiades hybridization probe. We found that the crossing threshold method yielded more precise results when analyzing the HHV6 assay, which was characterized by lower signal/noise and less developed amplification curve plateaus. In contrast, the EBV assay, characterized by greater signal/noise and amplification curves with plateau regions similar to those observed with intercalating dyes, gave results with statistically similar precision by all four analysis methods.     

Ethidium bromide stimulated hyper laccase production from bird's nest fungus Cyathus bulleri

AIMS: Effect of ethidium bromide, a DNA intercalating agent, on laccase production from Cyathus bulleri was studied. METHODS AND RESULTS: The bird's nest fungus, Cyathus bulleri was grown on 2% (w/v) malt extract agar (MEA) supplemented with 1.5 microg ml(-1) of the phenanthridine dye ethidium bromide (EtBr) for 7 d and when grown subsequently in malt extract broth (MEB), produced a 4.2-fold increase in laccase production as compared to the untreated fungus. The fungal cultures following a single EtBr treatment, when regrown on MEA devoid of EtBr, produced a sixfold increase in laccase in MEB. However, on subsequent culturing on MEA in the absence of EtBr, only a 2.5-fold increase in laccase production could be maintained. In another attempt, the initial EtBr-treated cultures, when subjected to a second EtBr treatment (1.5 microg ml(-1)) on MEA for 7 d, produced a 1.4-fold increase in laccase production in MEB. CONCLUSIONS: The white-rot fungus Cyathus bulleri, when treated with EtBr at a concentration of 1.5 microg ml(-1) and regrown on MEA devoid of EtBr, produced a sixfold increase in laccase production in MEB. SIGNIFICANCE AND THE IMPACT OF THE STUDY: The variable form of C. bulleri capable of hyper laccase production can improve the economic feasibility of environmentally benign processes involving use of fungal laccases in cosmetics (including hair dyes), food and beverages, clinical diagnostics, pulp and paper industry, industrial effluent treatment, animal biotechnology and biotransformations.     

基于SYBR Green I的双链DNA定量方法

摘要 基于SYBR Green I荧光染料与双链DNA（dsDNA）结合产生荧光的原理,建立一种高精度、高通量的双链DNA 定量方法。将梯度稀释后的基因组DNA及已知浓度的?DNA与等体积的SYBR Green I（4×）充分混合后,利用荧光定量PCR仪采集荧光信号,以ROX（1×）作为校正染料进行定量分析;同时利用紫外分光光度计对样品进行平行测定,比较该方法与紫外分光光度法的检测限与准确度。紫外分光光度法的检测限为2 ng/?l,而SYBR Green I荧光定量法的检测限可达到0.015 ng/?l,并且在0.015~2 ng/?l范围内,SYBR Green I荧光强度与?DNA浓度呈线性关系（R2=0.9999）,比紫外分光光度法灵敏100倍以上,并可准确定量低纯度的DNA样品。此方法具有重复性好、高通量的特点,仅需少量的生物样本即可满足定量要求,为分子生物学研究及临床检验等多个领域提供了一种可靠的dsDNA定量方法。     

Demonstration of preferential binding of SYBR Green I to specific DNA fragments in real-time multiplex PCR

SYBR Green I (SG) is widely used in real-time PCR applications as an intercalating dye and is included in many commercially available kits at undisclosed concentrations. Binding of SG to double-stranded DNA is non-specific and additional testing, such as DNA melting curve analysis, is required to confirm the generation of a specific amplicon. The use of melt curve analysis eliminates the necessity for agarose gel electrophoresis because the melting temperature (T_m) of the specific amplicon is analogous to the detection of an electrophoretic band. When using SG for real-time PCR multiplex reactions, discrimination of amplicons should be possible, provided the T_m values are sufficiently different. Real-time multiplex assays for Vibrio cholerae and Legionella pneumophila using commercially available kits and in-house SG mastermixes have highlighted variability in performance characteristics, in particular the detection of only a single product as assessed by T_m analysis but multiple products as assessed by agarose gel electrophoresis. The detected T_m corresponds to the amplicon with the higher G+C% and larger size, suggesting preferential binding of SG during PCR and resulting in the failure to detect multiple amplicons in multiplex reactions when the amount of SG present is limiting. This has implications for the design and routine application of diagnostic real-time PCR assays employing SG.     

Plasmodium falciparum: Development and validation of a measure of intraerythrocytic growth using SYBR Green I in a flow cytometer

Reliable analytical techniques to test growth-promoting and antimalarial efficacy on plasmodia are very important. Flow cytometry (FCM) offers the possibility to study developmental stages of intraerythrocytic growth of malaria parasites using nucleic acid staining. To analyze the growth of Plasmodium falciparum SYBR Green I was introduced as an intercalating dye with FCM for the 488 nm line of an argon laser. Procedures employing FCM, including fixatives, dye concentrations, dilution buffer, and staining period, were optimized to simplify the method. FCM as described here allows parasitemia and parasites of different stages to be quantified according to the DNA content. The proportion of parasitized erythrocytes estimated by FCM and the Giemsa method agreed with determination by parasite lactate dehydrogenase. The protocol was extended to merozoite counting as a sensitive assay of growth inhibition of the parasite.     

Detection of the Escherichia coli pathogenic gene eae with three real-time polymerase chain reaction methods

Several real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) methods are currently available to rapidly detect the presence of a specific DNA sequence. When used for detection of pathogenic organisms, the turnaround time for PCR-based methods is much lower than for traditional culture techniques. This study compared the sensitivity of three real-time PCR methods when detecting the Escherichia coli pathogenic gene eae to determine which method is most effective in identifying very low levels of the organism. The three methods were used to detect the eae gene over a range of DNA concentrations. The differences in sensitivity were statistically significant (p<0.05), and SYBR Green I PCR was found to have the lowest detection limit of the three; LUX primers had the highest detection limit. Therefore, using a defined DNA concentration for detecting the eae gene, SYBR Green I is the best alternative.     

Tetraalkylammonium derivatives as real-time PCR enhancers and stabilizers of the qPCR mixtures containing SYBR Green I

Tetraalkylammonium (TAA) derivatives have been reported to serve as stabilizers of asymmetrical cyanine dyes in aqueous solutions and to increase the yield and efficiency of polymerase chain reaction (PCR) detected by end-point analysis. In this study, we compared the ability of various TAA derivatives (with alkyl chain ranging from 1 to 5 carbons) and some other compounds to serve as enhancers of real-time PCR based on fluorescence detection from intercalating dye SYBR Green I (SGI). Our data indicate that TAA chlorides and some other TAA derivatives serve as potent enhancers of SGI-monitored real-time PCR. Optimal results were obtained with 10-16 mM tetrapropylammonium chloride. The effect of TAA compounds was dependent on the nature of counter ions present and composition of the reaction mixtures used. Based on measurements of SGI-generated fluorescence signal in the presence of PCR-amplified DNA fragments, oligonucleotide primers and/or various additives, we propose that TAA-derivatives reduce the binding of SGI to oligonucleotide primers and thus enhance primer-template interactions during annealing phase. Furthermore, these compounds serve as stabilizers of SGI-containing PCR mixtures. The combined data indicate that TAA derivatives might be a new class of additives contributing to robustness of real-time PCR monitored by asymmetrical cyanine dye SGI.     

Evaluation of DNA extraction methods for use in combination with SYBR green I real-time PCR to detect Salmonella enterica serotype enteritidis in poultry

The objective of this study was to develop a rapid, reproducible, and robust method for detecting Salmonella enterica serotype Enteritidis in poultry samples. First, for the extraction and purification of DNA from the preenrichment culture, four methods (boiling, alkaline lysis, Nucleospin, and Dynabeads DNA Direct System I) were compared. The most effective method was then combined with a real-time PCR method based on the double-stranded DNA binding dye SYBR Green I used with the ABI Prism 7700 system. The specificity of the reaction was determined by the melting temperature (T(m)) of the amplicon obtained. The experiments were conducted both on samples of chicken experimentally contaminated with serotype Enteritidis and on commercially available poultry samples, which were also used for comparisons with the standard cultural method (i.e., ISO 6579/2001). The results of comparisons among the four DNA extraction methods showed significant differences except for the results from the boiling and Nucleospin methods (the two methods that produced the lowest threshold cycles). Boiling was selected as the preferred extraction method because it is the simplest and most rapid. This method was then combined with SYBR Green I real-time PCR, using primers SEFA-1 and SEFA-2. The specificity of the reaction was confirmed by the T(m), which was consistently specific for the amplicon obtained; the mean peak T(m) obtained with curves specific for serotype Enteritidis was 82.56 +/- 0.22 degrees C. The standard curve constructed using the mean threshold cycle and various concentrations of serotype Enteritidis (ranging from 10(3) to 10(8) CFU/ml) showed good linearity (R(2) = 0.9767) and a sensitivity limit of less than 10(3) CFU/ml. The results of this study demonstrate that the SYBR Green I real-time PCR constitutes an effective and easy-to-perform method for detecting serotype Enteritidis in poultry samples.     

Comparison of the SYBR Green and the hybridization probe format for real-time PCR detection of HHV-6

A comparative study was conducted of a novel real-time quantitative PCR test (LightCycler System) with FastStart DNA Master(PLUS) SYBR Green I dye to detect DNA of human herpes virus 6 (HHV-6). Results were compared with those of a real-time quantitative PCR with hybridization probe (HP) formats using the fluorescence resonance energy transfer method, and with those of a single qualitative PCR test. The detection limit of the test with SYBR Green I dye was 20 copies of the virus, similar to that of the other two tests. The reproducibility was satisfactory. The new test has the same advantages as real-time PCR with HP formats and offers a greater versatility at lower cost.