Molecular Genetics of Submergence Tolerance in Rice: QTL Analysis of Key Traits

Flash flooding of young rice plants is a common problem forrice farmers in south and south-east Asia. It severely reducesgrain yield and increases the unpredictability of cropping.The inheritance and expression of traits associated with submergencestress tolerance at the seedling stage are physiologically andgenetically complex. We exploited naturally occurring differencesbetween certain rice lines in their tolerance to submergenceand used quantitative trait loci (QTL) mapping to improve understandingof the genetic and physiological basis of submergence tolerance.Three rice populations, each derived from a single cross betweentwo cultivars differing in their response to submergence, wereused to identify QTL associated with plant survival and variouslinked traits. These included total shoot elongation under water,the extent of stimulation of shoot elongation caused by submergence,a visual submergence tolerance score, and leaf senescence underdifferent field conditions, locations and years. Several majorQTL determining plant survival, plant height, stimulation ofshoot elongation, visual tolerance score and leaf senescenceeach mapped to the same locus on chromosome 9. These QTL weredetected consistently in experiments across all years and inthe genetic backgrounds of all three mapping populations. SecondaryQTL influencing tolerance were also identified and located onchromosomes 1, 2, 5, 7, 10 and 11. These QTL were specific toparticular traits, environments, or genetic backgrounds. Allidentified QTL contributed to increased submergence tolerancethrough their effects on decreased underwater shoot elongationor increased maintenance of chlorophyll levels, or on both.These findings establish the foundations of a marker-assistedscheme for introducing submergence tolerance into agriculturallydesirable cultivars of rice.     

水稻的耐淹性状及其Sub1基因

近4年来, 水稻(Oryza sativa L.)耐淹性状及其分子机理的研究取得了长足的进展。水稻植株的耐淹性状主要由Submergence-1 (Sub1) 基因控制。Sub1通过调节乙烯和赤霉素介导的反应, 抑制淹水期间的伸长生长和减缓碳水化合物消耗来控制耐淹性状。文章介绍了水稻应对淹涝胁迫的两种策略, 影响耐淹性状的主要生理因素, Sub1基因定位以及它控制耐淹性状的机理; 阐述了Sub1基因在我国杂交水稻生产方面的应用前景。     

Physiological and Molecular Basis of Susceptibility and Tolerance of Rice Plants to Complete Submergence

Rice plants are much damaged by several days of total submergence.The effect can be a serious problem for rice farmers in therainfed lowlands of Asia, and runs contrary to a widespreadbelief amongst plant biologists that rice is highly tolerantof submergence. This article assesses the characteristics ofthe underwater environment that may damage rice plants, examinesvarious physiological mechanisms of injury, and reviews recentprogress achieved using linkage mapping to locate quantitativetraits loci (QTL) for tolerance inherited from a submergence-tolerantcultivar FR13A. Progress towards identifying the gene(s) involvedthrough physical mapping of a dominant tolerance locus on chromosome9 is also summarized. Available physiological evidence pointsaway from responses to oxygen shortage as being inextricablyinvolved in submergence injury. An imbalance between productionand consumption of assimilates is seen as being especially harmful,and is exacerbated by strongly accelerated leaf extension andleaf senescence that are ethylene-mediated and largely absentfrom FR13A and related cultivars. DNA markers for a major QTLfor tolerance are shown to be potentially useful in breedingprogrammes designed to improve submergence tolerance.     

The beneficial effect of reduced elongation growth on submergence tolerance of rice

Adverse effects of elongation growth on tolerance to completesubmergence for up to 14 d were evaluated in rice seedlingsof cultivars which differed in submergence tolerance. Thereis a good negative correlation between per cent survival andelongation growth of genotypes during complete submergence (r= – 0.81). When elongation growth underwater is minimizedby application of a gibberellin biosynthesis inhibitor, percent survival increases by as much as 50 times for one cultivar.These effects are likely related to elongation growth since(i) addition of gibberellin had the opposite effect by reducingsurvival, and (ii) when the elongation inhibitor and gibberellinwere added together, there was no effect on elongation growthand the per cent survival did not change. A GA-deficient mutantof rice which had little elongation ability during submergenceshowed a high level of submergence tolerance when plants weresubmerged at equal initial dry weights and carbohydrate levelsrelative to a submergence-tolerant cultivar. These results areconsistent with the hypothesis that elongation growth competeswith maintenance processes for energy and hence reduces survivalduring submergence. The impact of these findings is that inenvironments where elongation ability is not required, thereis a potential to increase submergence tolerance of agriculturallyimportant cultivars by selecting for least elongation, at leastduring periods of complete submergence. Furthermore, this trade-offbetween stimulated elongation growth and submergence tolerancewill have important ecological consequences for the distributionof plant species in different flood-prone environments. Key words: Gibberellin, growth, Oryza sativa, rice, submergence     

Genes/QTLs affecting flood tolerance in rice

The adaptation of deepwater rice to flooding is attributed to two mechanisms, submergence tolerance and plant elongation. Using a QTL mapping study with replicated phenotyping under two contrasting (water qualities) submergence treatments and AFLP markers, we were able to identify several genes/QTLs that control plant elongation and submergence tolerance in a recombinant inbred rice population. Our results indicate that segregation of rice plants in their responses to different flooding stress conditions is largely due to the differential expression of a few key elongation and submergence tolerance genes. The most important gene was QIne1 mapped near sd-1 on chromosome 1. The Jalmagna (the deepwater parent) allele at this locus had a very large effect on internal elongation and contributed significantly to submergence tolerance under flooding. The second locus was a major gene, sub1(t), mapped to chromosome 9, which contributed to submergence tolerance only. The third one was a QTL, QIne4, mapped to chromosome 4. The IR74 (non-elongating parent) allele at this locus had a large effect for internal elongation. An additional locus that interacted strongly with both QIne1 and QIne4 appeared near RG403 on chromosome 5, suggesting a complex epistatic relationship among the three loci. Several QTLs with relatively small effects on plant elongation and submergence tolerance were also identified. The genetic aspects of these flooding tolerance QTLs with respect to patterns of differential expression of elongation and submergence tolerance genes under flooding are discussed. Received: 13 December 1999 / Accepted: 14 March 2000<@head-com-p1a.lf>Communicated by G. Wenzel     

Flooding and Plant Growth

This Special Issue is based on the 7th Conference of the InternationalSociety for Plant Anaerobiosis (ISPA), held in Nijmegen, TheNetherlands, 12–16 June 2001. The papers describe andanalyse many of the responses that plants display when subjectedto waterlogging of the soil or deeper submergence. These responsesmay be injurious or adaptive, and are discussed at various levelsof organizational complexity ranging from ecosystem processes,through individual plants to single cells. The research incorporatesmolecular biology and genetics, cell physiology, biochemistry,hormone physiology, whole plant physiology, plant demographyand ecology. The study of the damage to young rice plants causedby submergence, especially as experienced in the rainfed lowlandsof Asia, is comprehensively addressed. This work integratesvarious specialized approaches ranging from agronomy to moleculargenetics, and demonstrates how plant biology can be harnessedto improve stress tolerance in an important crop species whilesimultaneously improving basic understanding of tolerance mechanismsand plant processes.     

Chlorophyll fluorescence parameters,CO2 photosynthetic rate and regeneration capacity as a result of complete submergence and subsequent re-emergence in rice (Oryza sativa L.)

Regeneration capacity of submerged rice (Oryza sativa) seedlings in terms of CO₂ photosynthetic rate, chlorophyll a fluorescence and chlorophyll and carbohydrate content were investigated in three Indica rice cultivars namely FR 13A, Kalaputia and IR 42 that differed in submergence tolerance. Twenty-one day old plants were completely submerged under water for 8 days. Subsequently, plants were kept under normal conditions with 5–10 cm of stagnant water above soil surface for a further period of 15 days. After complete submergence, all genotypes showed inhibition of CO₂ photosynthetic rate. Submergence treatment resulted in a significant reduction of Rubisco activity. Maximal photochemical efficiency (F_v/F_m) of PS II and area above the fluorescence curve between F_o and F_m decreased more under submergence especially in susceptible cultivar IR 42. When re-aerated, the plants recovered to various degrees. The carbohydrate content of plants was found to be significantly and positively associated with submergence tolerance and regeneration growth. The tolerant cultivar (FR 13A) could survive submergence apparently because it possessed 1.9–2.0 and 3.2–3.7-fold more non-structural carbohydrate content before and after submergence compared to the susceptible cultivar (IR 42) and it had a better capability to restore its photosynthetic capacity during post-submergence periods.     

Induction of mitochondrial aldehyde dehydrogenase by submergence facilitates oxidation of acetaldehyde during re-aeration in rice

Post-hypoxic injuries in plants are primarily caused by bursts of reactive oxygen species and acetaldehyde. In agreement with previous studies, we found accumulations of acetaldehyde in rice during re-aeration following submergence. During re-aeration, acetaldehyde-oxidizing aldehyde dehydrogenase (ALDH) activity increased, thereby causing the acetaldehyde content to decrease in rice. Interestingly, re-aerated rice plants showed an intense mitochondrial ALDH2a protein induction, even though ALDH2a mRNA was submergence induced and declined upon re-aeration. This suggests that rice ALDH2a mRNA is accumulated in order to quickly metabolize acetaldehyde that is produced upon re-aeration.     

Short-Term Complete Submergence of Rice at the Tillering Stage Increases Yield

Flooding is a major threat to agricultural production. Most studies have focused on the lower water storage limit in rice fields, whereas few studies have examined the upper water storage limit. This study aimed to explore the effect of waterlogging at the rice tillering stage on rice growth and yield. The early-ripening late japonica variety Yangjing 4227 was selected for this study. The treatments included different submergence depths (submergence depth/plant height: 1/2 (waist submergence), 2/3 (neck submergence), and 1/1 (complete submergence)) and durations (1, 3, and 5 d). The control group was treated with the conventional alternation of drying and wetting. The effects of waterlogging at the tillering stage on root characteristics, dry matter production, nitrogen and phosphorus accumulation, yield, yield components, and 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid synthase (ACS) gene expression were explored. Compared with the control group, the 1/1 group showed significant increases in yield, seed-setting rate, photosynthetically efficient leaf area, and OS-ACS3 gene expression after 1 d of submergence. The grain number per panicle, dry weight of the aboveground and belowground parts, and number of adventitious roots also increased. Correlation analysis revealed a significant positive correlation between the panicle number and nitrogen content; however, no significant correlation was found for phosphorus content. If a decrease in rice yield of less than 10% is acceptable, half, 2/3, and complete submergence of the plants can be performed at the tillering stage for 1-3 d; this treatment will increase the space available for rice field water management/control and will improve rainfall resource utilization.     

Introgression of dual abiotic stress tolerance QTLs (Saltol QTL and Sub1 gene) into Rice (Oryza sativa L.) variety Aiswarya through marker assisted backcross breeding

Salinity and submergence are two very prominent abiotic stress conditions affecting rice yield adversely in the coastal agro ecosystem. Marker Assisted Backcross Breeding (MABB) is an efficient and fast track molecular tool to incorporate a desired stress tolerant QTL/gene into an improved cultivar. The present study was carried out for the introgression of Saltol QTL responsible for salinity tolerance and Sub1 gene responsible for submergence tolerance into the high yielding rice variety Aiswarya independently through MABB. Final objective of the study is to develop dual stress tolerant (tolerance to salinity and submergence) Aiswarya rice variety by pyramiding the both target QTLs introgressed BC₂F₂ progenies having maximum background homozygosity. The donors of Saltol QTL and Sub1 gene used in the present study were FL478 and Swarna Sub1, respectively. Based on the background genome analysis of the introgressed plants, the plants with > 85–90% background similarity were selected for pyramiding of Saltol QTL and Sub1 gene into the elite background of rice variety Aiswarya. Those selected introgressed lines with Saltol QTL and Sub1 gene will be again crossed to pyramid both Saltol QTL and Sub1 gene into the rice variety Aiswarya. Such a mega rice variety pyramided with dual stress tolerant QTLs is the expected outcome of this study and can be recommended for cultivation in the flood prone saline coastal agroecosystem.     

The role of ethylene in the growth response of submerged deep water rice

We investigated the effect of partial submergence on internode elongation in a Bangladesh variety of floating or deep water rice (Oryza sativa L., cv. Habiganj Aman II). In plants which were at least 21 days old, 7 days of submergence led to a 3- to 5-fold increase in internodal length. During submergence, the ethylene concentration in the internodes increased from about 0.02 to 1 microliters per liter. Treatment of nonsubmerged plants with ethylene also stimulated internode elongation. When ethylene synthesis in partially submerged plants was blocked with aminooxyacetic acid and aminoethoxyvinylglycine, internode elongation was inhibited. This growth inhibition was reversed when ethylene biosynthesis was restored with 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC). Radio-labeling studies showed that ethylene in floating rice was synthesized from methionine via ACC. Internodal tissue from submerged plants had a much higher capacity to form ethylene than did internodal tissue from nonsubmerged plants. This increase in ethylene synthesis appeared to be due to enhanced ACC formation rather than to increased conversion of ACC to ethylene. Our results indicate that ethylene produced during submergence is required for the stimulation of growth in submerged floating rice plants.     

Responses of rice (Oryza sativa L.) genotypes to different levels of submergence

The study aims at identifying some submergence-tolerant rice genotypes through morphological and molecular characterization and their genetic variability analysis. Ten rice genotypes including two submergence-tolerant checks, two susceptible varieties and six advanced lines were evaluated for submergence tolerance in the laboratory and in the field during January–December 2015. The experiment was conducted in the field following randomized complete block design in a two-factor arrangement using five replications. Ten characters, viz. days to flowering, plant height, tiller number plant^?1, effective tiller plant^?1, and yield plant^?1 etc. were studied for four treatments. A significant genotype × environment interaction was observed for all traits studied in this experiment. The yield was reduced for all genotypes at a different level of submergence stress compared to control. Binadhan-11, Binadhan-12, RC 249 and RC 251 showed tolerance, whereas RC 192, RC 193 and RC 225 showed moderate tolerance in submerged condition. The phenotypic coefficient of variance (PCV) was higher than the genotypic coefficient of variance (GCV) in all the studies traits. High heritability (75–97%) was found for all traits. High heritability along with high genetic advance was found for days to flowering (45.55) and plant height (40.05). Molecular characterization of the used genotypes was done with three SSR markers viz. RM 24, and submergence specific SC3 and SUB1. SC3 was found reliable for detection of submergence tolerant genotypes due to the highest gene diversity (0.840) compared to others. The banding pattern of the submergence specific markers SC3 and SUB1 identified in Binadhan-11, Binadhan-12, RC 192, RC 193, RC 225, RC 227, RC 249, and RC 251, which possess the SUB1 gene. Finally, clustering also separates the tolerant genotypes from the susceptible by dividing them into different clusters. The identified genotypes might be useful for the breeding programme for the development of submergence tolerant as well as resistant rice variety in Bangladesh.     

Morphological and physiological responses of rice seedlings to complete submergence (flash flooding)

Background and Aims

Reducing damage to rice seedlings caused by flash flooding will improve the productivity of rainfed lowland rice in West Africa. Accordingly, the morphological and physiological responses of different forms of rice to complete submergence were examined in field and pot experiments to identify primary causes of damage.

Methods

To characterize the physiological responses, seedlings from a wide genetic base including Oryza sativa, O. glaberrima and interspecific hybrids were compared using principle component analysis.

Key Results

Important factors linked to flash-flood tolerance included minimal shoot elongation underwater, increase in dry matter weight during submergence and post-submergence resistance to lodging. In particular, fast shoot elongation during submergence negatively affected plant growth after de-submergence. Also shoot-elongating cultivars showed a strong negative correlation between dry matter weight of the leaves that developed before submergence and leaves developing during submergence.

Conclusions

Enhancement of shoot elongation during submergence in water that is too deep to permit re-emergence by small seedlings represents a futile escape strategy that takes place at the expense of existing dry matter in circumstances where underwater photosynthetic carbon fixation is negligible. Consequently, it compromises survival or recovery growth once flood water levels recede and plants are re-exposed to the aerial environment. Tolerance is greater in cultivars where acceleration of elongation caused by submergence is minimal.Key words: Africa, flash floods, Oryza glaberrima, rainfed lowland, rice, shoot elongation, stress tolerance, submergence     

水稻耐淹涝性状的遗传分析和SSR标记的研究

淹涝胁迫对水稻生产造成了严重影响, 发掘可应用于耐淹涝辅助选择的分子标记(MAS), 将有助于水稻耐淹涝性状的遗传改良。应用耐淹涝材料FR13A和淹涝敏感材料IR39595-503-2-1-2为亲本做正反交获得F₁和F₂代群体。对正反交的F₁群体的耐淹涝性状进行遗传分析, 发现正反交的F₁代群体在耐淹涝性状上没有显著差异, 说明耐淹涝性状是核基因控制。从两次淹涝处理中F₂代群体的分离情况来看, 来源于FR13A的耐淹特性表现出数量-质量性状遗传的特点。当淹涝胁迫压力比较轻时表现为数量性状遗传, 具有微效多基因的作用。当淹涝胁迫压力增大时, 表现为主效基因控制的质量性状。在SSR分析中, 187对SSR引物中有73对引物在两亲本间有明显的差异, 差异率为39%。用这73对差异引物, 对F2群体进行多态筛选, 结果筛选到一个与耐淹涝性状连锁的标记RM219, 验证了耐淹涝性状确实由主效基因Sub1控制, 因此, RM219在水稻耐淹涝育种中具有利用价值。     

Molecular and Physiological Mechanisms of Flooding Avoidance and Tolerance in Rice

Submergence is one of the major constraints in rice production. The main factor limiting rice survival during submergence is oxygen deprivation. To cope with flooding conditions, rice has developed two survival strategies: either rapid elongation of the submerged tissues to keep up with the rising water level or no elongation to save carbohydrate resources for maintenance of energy production under submerged and concomitant hypoxic conditions. The survival strategies used by rice have been studied quite extensively and the role of several phytohormones in the elongation response has been established. The mechanisms of submergence tolerance include metabolic changes, for instance, the shift to an ethanolic fermentation pathway, reduced elongation growth to save carbohydrates and energy for maintenance processes, and protective antioxidant systems. Current molecular technology can provide tools for the understanding of mechanisms developed by rice to survive submergence. In addition, cloning of genes related to submergence tolerance might open new ways to genetic improvement of this crop.