Molecular Basis of Bacterial Outer Membrane Permeability Revisited

Gram-negative bacteria characteristically are surrounded by an additional membrane layer, the outer membrane. Although outer membrane components often play important roles in the interaction of symbiotic or pathogenic bacteria with their host organisms, the major role of this membrane must usually be to serve as a permeability barrier to prevent the entry of noxious compounds and at the same time to allow the influx of nutrient molecules. This review summarizes the development in the field since our previous review (H. Nikaido and M. Vaara, Microbiol. Rev. 49:1-32, 1985) was published. With the discovery of protein channels, structural knowledge enables us to understand in molecular detail how porins, specific channels, TonB-linked receptors, and other proteins function. We are now beginning to see how the export of large proteins occurs across the outer membrane. With our knowledge of the lipopolysaccharide-phospholipid asymmetric bilayer of the outer membrane, we are finally beginning to understand how this bilayer can retard the entry of lipophilic compounds, owing to our increasing knowledge about the chemistry of lipopolysaccharide from diverse organisms and the way in which lipopolysaccharide structure is modified by environmental conditions.     

Leptospira: a spirochaete with a hybrid outer membrane

Leptospira is a genus of spirochaetes that includes organisms with a variety of lifestyles ranging from aquatic saprophytes to invasive pathogens. Adaptation to a wide variety of environmental conditions has required leptospires to acquire a large genome and a complex outer membrane with features that are unique among bacteria. The most abundant surface‐exposed outer membrane proteins are lipoproteins that are integrated into the lipid bilayer by amino‐terminal fatty acids. In contrast to many spirochaetes, the leptospiral outer membrane also includes lipopolysaccharide and many homologues of well‐known beta‐barrel transmembrane outer membrane proteins. Research on leptospiral transmembrane outer membrane proteins has lagged behind studies of lipoproteins because of their aberrant behaviour by Triton X‐114 detergent fractionation. For this reason, transmembrane outer membrane proteins are best characterized by assessing membrane integration and surface exposure. Not surprisingly, some outer membrane proteins that mediate host–pathogen interactions are strongly regulated by conditions found in mammalian host tissues. For example, the leptospiral immunoglobulin‐like (Lig) repeat proteins are dramatically induced by osmolarity and mediate interactions with host extracellular matrix proteins. Development of molecular genetic tools are making it possible to finally understand the roles of these and other outer membrane proteins in mechanisms of leptospiral pathogenesis.     

Lipid trafficking to the outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria

The envelope of Gram-negative bacteria is composed of two distinct lipid membranes: an inner membrane and outer membrane. The outer membrane is an asymmetric bilayer with an inner leaflet of phospholipids and an outer leaflet of lipopolysaccharide. Most of the steps of lipid synthesis occur within the cytoplasmic compartment of the cell. Lipids must then be transported across the inner membrane and delivered to the outer membrane. These topological features combined with the ability to apply the tools of biochemistry and genetics make the Gram-negative envelope a fascinating model for the study of lipid trafficking. In addition, as lipopolysaccharide is essential for growth of most strains and is a potent inducer of the mammalian innate immune response via activation of Toll-like receptors, Gram-negative lipid transport is also a promising target for the development of novel antibacterial and anti-inflammatory compounds. This review focuses on recent developments in our understanding of lipid transport across the inner membrane and to the outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria.     

Lipopolysaccharide biogenesis and transport at the outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria

The outer membrane (OM) of Gram-negative bacteria is an asymmetric lipid bilayer containing a unique glycolipid, lipopolysaccharide (LPS) in its outer leaflet. LPS molecules confer to the OM peculiar permeability barrier properties enabling Gram-negative bacteria to exclude many toxic compounds, including clinically useful antibiotics, and to survive harsh environments. Transport of LPS poses several problems to the cells due to the amphipatic nature of this molecule. In this review we summarize the current knowledge on the LPS transport machinery, discuss the challenges associated with this process and present the solutions that bacterial cells have evolved to address the problem of LPS transport and assembly at the cell surface. Finally, we discuss how knowledge on LPS biogenesis can be translated for the development of novel antimicrobial therapies. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Bacterial Lipids edited by Russell E. Bishop.     

Transport of outer membrane lipids in mycobacteria

The complex organization of the mycobacterial cell wall poses unique challenges for the study of its assembly. Although mycobacteria are classified evolutionarily as Gram-positive bacteria, their cell wall architecture more closely resembles that of Gram-negative organisms. They possess not only an inner cytoplasmic membrane, but also a bilayer outer membrane that encloses an aqueous periplasm and includes diverse lipids that are required for the survival and virulence of pathogenic species. Questions surrounding how mycobacterial outer membrane lipids are transported from where they are made in the cytoplasm to where they function at the cell exterior are thus similar, and similarly compelling, to those that have driven the study of Gram-negative outer membrane transport pathways. However, little is understood about these processes in mycobacteria. Here we contextualize these questions by comparing our current knowledge of mycobacteria with better-defined systems in other organisms. Based on this analysis, we propose possible models and highlight continuing challenges to improving our understanding of outer membrane assembly in these medically and environmentally important bacteria. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Bacterial Lipids edited by Russell E. Bishop.     

Significance of composition and structure of the enterobacterial outer membrane to the transport of desired and undesired substances and its inhibition

The enterobacterial outer membrane forms a bilayer. Its outer monolyer consists of lipopolysaccharides and proteins, its inner monolayer of phospholipids and proteins. It thus represents an efficient penetration barrier against hydrophobic and anionic compounds (such as detergents or hydrophobic antibiotics) and against higher molecular substances (such as proteolytic, lipolytic, and murolylic enzymes). Some of the proteins (“porins”) form channels through the outer membrane through which neutral and cationic hydrophylic compounds up to a molecular weight of about 800 can pass. Besides the porins additional transport systems have been described. They play an important part in providing the bacteria with substances necessary for their growth, i.e., phosphate, iron ions, and others. Organic polycations are able to generate more or less severe disorganizations in the outer membrane through which they can pass the bilayer (“self-promoted pathway”). Some of these polycations represent efficient antibiotics (polymyxin B, nourseothricin). Bacteria are able to protect themselves against the harmful action of these substances by changing the composition of the outer membrane.     

Making a beta-barrel: assembly of outer membrane proteins in Gram-negative bacteria

The outer membrane (OM) of Gram-negative bacteria is an essential organelle that serves as a selective permeability barrier by keeping toxic compounds out of the cell while allowing vital nutrients in. How the OM and its constituent lipid and protein components are assembled remains an area of active research. In this review, we describe our current understanding of how outer membrane proteins (OMPs) are delivered to and then assembled in the OM of the model Gram-negative organism Escherichia coli.     

A tetrameric porin limits the cell wall permeability of Mycobacterium smegmatis

Mycobacteria protect themselves with an outer lipid bilayer, which is the thickest biological membrane hitherto known and has an exceptionally low permeability rendering mycobacteria intrinsically resistant against many antibiotics. Pore proteins mediate the diffusion of hydrophilic nutrients across this membrane. Electron microscopy revealed that the outer membrane of Mycobacterium smegmatis contained about 1000 protein pores per microm(2), which are about 50-fold fewer pores per microm(2) than in Gram-negative bacteria. The projection structure of the major porin MspA of M. smegmatis was determined at 17 A resolution. MspA forms a cone-like tetrameric complex of 10 nm in length with a single central pore. Thus, MspA is drastically different from the trimeric porins of Gram-negative bacteria and represents a new class of channel proteins. The formation of MspA micelles indicated that the ends of MspA have different hydrophobicities. Oriented insertion of MspA into membranes was demonstrated in lipid bilayer experiments, which revealed a strongly asymmetrical voltage gating of MspA channels at -30 mV. The length of MspA is sufficient to span the outer membrane and contributes in combination with the tapering end of the pore and the low number of pores to the low permeability of the cell wall of M. smegmatis for hydrophilic compounds.     

Mutational analyses define helix organization and key residues of a bacterial membrane energy-transducing complex

In Gram-negative bacteria, many biological processes are coupled to inner membrane ion gradients. Ions transit at the interface of helices of integral membrane proteins, generating mechanical energy to drive energetic processes. To better understand how ions transit through these channels, we used a model system involved in two different processes, one of which depends on inner membrane energy. The Tol machinery of the Escherichia coli cell envelope is dedicated to maintaining outer membrane stability, a process driven by the proton-motive force. The Tol system is parasitized by bacterial toxins called colicins, which are imported through the outer membrane using an energy-independent process. Herein, we mutated TolQ and TolR transmembrane residues, and we analyzed the mutants for outer membrane stability, colicin import and protein complex formation. We identified residues involved in the assembly of the complex, and a new class of discriminative mutations that conferred outer membrane destabilization identical to a tol deletion mutant, but which remained fully sensitive to colicins. Further genetic approaches revealed transmembrane helix interactions and organization in the bilayer, and suggested that most of the discriminative residues are located in a putative aqueous ion channel. We discuss a model for the function of related bacterial molecular motors.     

Pore formation and function of phosphoporin PhoE of Escherichia coli are determined by the core sugar moiety of lipopolysaccharide

The lipid matrix of the outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria is an asymmetric bilayer composed of a phospholipid inner leaflet and a lipopolysaccharide outer leaflet. Incorporated into this lipid matrix are, among other macromolecules, the porins, which have a sieve-like function for the transport or exclusion of hydrophilic substances. It is known that a reduced amount of porins is found in the outer membrane of rough mutants as compared with wild-type bacteria. This observation was discussed to be caused by a reduced number of insertion sites in the former. We performed electrical measurements on reconstituted planar bilayers composed of lipopolysaccharide on one side and a phospholipid mixture on the other side using lipopolysaccharide from various rough mutant strains of Salmonella enterica serovar Minnesota. We found that pore formation by PhoE trimers that were added to the phospholipid side of the bilayers increased with the increasing length of the lipopolysaccharide core sugar moiety. These results allow us to conclude that the length of the sugar moiety of lipopolysaccharide is the parameter governing pore formation and that no particular insertion sites are required. Furthermore, we found that the voltage gating of the porin channels is strongly dependent on the composition of the lipid matrix.     

Effects of membrane lipids on ion channel structure and function

Biologic membranes are not simply inert physical barriers, but complex and dynamic environments that affect membrane protein structure and function. Residing within these environments, ion channels control the flux of ions across the membrane through conformational changes that allow transient ion flux through a central pore. These conformational changes may be modulated by changes in transmembrane electrochemical potential, the binding of small ligands or other proteins, or changes in the local lipid environment. Ion channels play fundamental roles in cellular function and, in higher eukaryotes, are the primary means of intercellular signaling, especially between excitable cells such as neurons. The focus of this review is to examine how the composition of the bilayer affects ion channel structure and function. This is an important consideration because the bilayer composition varies greatly in different cell types and in different organellar membranes. Even within a membrane, the lipid composition differs between the inner and outer leaflets, and the composition within a given leaflet is both heterogeneous and highly dynamic. Differential packing of lipids (and proteins) leads to the formation of microdomains, and lateral diffusion of these microdomains or "lipid rafts" serve as mobile platforms for the clustering and organization of bilayer constituents including ion channels. The structure and function of these channels are sensitive to specific chemical interactions with neighboring components of the membrane and also to the biophysical properties of their membrane microenvironment (e.g., fluidity, lateral pressure profile, and bilayer thickness). As specific examples, we have focused on the K+ ion channels and the ligand-gated nicotinicoid receptors, two classes of ion channels that have been well-characterized structurally and functionally. The responsiveness of these ion channels to changes in the lipid environment illustrate how ion channels, and more generally, any membrane protein, may be regulated via cellular control of membrane composition.     

Protein translocation across membranes.

Cellular membranes act as semipermeable barriers to ions and macromolecules. Specialized mechanisms of transport of proteins across membranes have been developed during evolution. There are common mechanistic themes among protein translocation systems in bacteria and in eukaryotic cells. Here we review current understanding of mechanisms of protein transport across the bacterial plasma membrane as well as across several organelle membranes of yeast and mammalian cells. We consider a variety of organelles including the endoplasmic reticulum, outer and inner membranes of mitochondria, outer, inner, and thylakoid membranes of chloroplasts, peroxisomes, and lysosomes. Several common principles are evident: (a) multiple pathways of protein translocation across membranes exist, (b) molecular chaperones are required in the cytosol, inside the organelle, and often within the organelle membrane, (c) ATP and/or GTP hydrolysis is required, (d) a proton-motive force across the membrane is often required, and (e) protein translocation occurs through gated, aqueous channels. There are exceptions to each of these common principles indicating that our knowledge of how proteins translocate across membranes is not yet complete.     

The porin and the permeating antibiotic: a selective diffusion barrier in Gram-negative bacteria

Gram-negative bacteria are responsible for a large proportion of antibiotic-resistant bacterial diseases. These bacteria have a complex cell envelope that comprises an outer membrane and an inner membrane that delimit the periplasm. The outer membrane contains various protein channels, called porins, which are involved in the influx of various compounds, including several classes of antibiotics. Bacterial adaptation to reduce influx through porins is an increasing problem worldwide that contributes, together with efflux systems, to the emergence and dissemination of antibiotic resistance. An exciting challenge is to decipher the genetic and molecular basis of membrane impermeability as a bacterial resistance mechanism. This Review outlines the bacterial response towards antibiotic stress on altered membrane permeability and discusses recent advances in molecular approaches that are improving our knowledge of the physico-chemical parameters that govern the translocation of antibiotics through porin channels.     

Bcl-2 proteins and mitochondria--specificity in membrane targeting for death

The localization and control of Bcl-2 proteins on mitochondria is essential for the intrinsic pathway of apoptosis. Anti-apoptotic Bcl-2 proteins reside on the outer mitochondrial membrane (OMM) and prevent apoptosis by inhibiting the activation of the pro-apoptotic family members Bax and Bak. The Bcl-2 subfamily of BH3-only proteins can either inhibit the anti-apoptotic proteins or directly activate Bax or Bak. How these proteins interact with each other, the mitochondrial surface and within the OMM are complex processes we are only beginning to understand. However, these interactions are fundamental for the transduction of apoptotic signals to mitochondria and the subsequent release of caspase activating factors into the cytosol. In this review we will discuss our knowledge of how Bcl-2 proteins are directed to mitochondria in the first place, a crucial but poorly understood aspect of their regulation. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled Mitochondria: the deadly organelle.     

Bcl-2 proteins and mitochondria—Specificity in membrane targeting for death

The localization and control of Bcl-2 proteins on mitochondria is essential for the intrinsic pathway of apoptosis. Anti-apoptotic Bcl-2 proteins reside on the outer mitochondrial membrane (OMM) and prevent apoptosis by inhibiting the activation of the pro-apoptotic family members Bax and Bak. The Bcl-2 subfamily of BH3-only proteins can either inhibit the anti-apoptotic proteins or directly activate Bax or Bak. How these proteins interact with each other, the mitochondrial surface and within the OMM are complex processes we are only beginning to understand. However, these interactions are fundamental for the transduction of apoptotic signals to mitochondria and the subsequent release of caspase activating factors into the cytosol. In this review we will discuss our knowledge of how Bcl-2 proteins are directed to mitochondria in the first place, a crucial but poorly understood aspect of their regulation. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled Mitochondria: the deadly organelle.     

Transport across the bacterial outer membrane

Diffusion of small molecules across the outer membrane of gram-negative bacteria may occur through protein channels and through lipid bilayer domains. Among protein channels, many examples of trimeric porins, which produce water-filled diffusion channels, are known. Although the channels are nonspecific, the diffusion rates of solutes are often drastically affected by their gross physicochemical properties, such as size, charge, or lipophilicity, because the channel has a dimension not too different from that of the diffusing solutes. In the last few years, the structures of three such porins have been solved by X-ray crystallography. It is now known that a monomer unit traverses the membrane 16 times as -strands, and one of the external loop folds back into the channel to produce a narrow constriction. Most of the static properties of the channel, such as the pore size and the position of the amino acids that produce the constriction, can now be explained by the three-dimensional structure. Controversy, however, still surrounds the issue of whether there are dynamic modulation of the channel properties in response to pH, ionic strength, or membrane potential, and of whether such responses are physiological. More recently, two examples of monomeric porins have been identified. These porins allow a very slow diffusion of solutes, but the reason for this low permeability is still unclear. Finally, channels with specific binding sites facilitate the diffusion of specific classes of nutrients, often those compounds that are too large to penetrate rapidly through the porin channels. Lipid bilayers in the outer membrane were shown to be perhaps 50- to 100-fold less permeable to uncharged, lipophilic molecules in comparison with the bilayers made of the usual glycerophospholipids. This is caused by the presence of a lipopolysaccharide leaflet in the bilayer, and more specifically, by the presence of a larger number of fatty acids in each lipid molecule, and by the absence of unsaturated fatty acids in the lipopolysaccharide structure.     

Characterization of interactions between LPS transport proteins of the Lpt system

The lipopolysaccharide transport system (Lpt) in Gram-negative bacteria is responsible for transporting lipopolysaccharide (LPS) from the cytoplasmic surface of the inner membrane, where it is assembled, across the inner membrane, periplasm and outer membrane, to the surface where it is then inserted in the outer leaflet of the asymmetric lipid bilayer. The Lpt system consists of seven known LPS transport proteins (LptA-G) spanning from the cytoplasm to the cell surface. We have shown that the periplasmic component, LptA is able to form a stable complex with the inner membrane anchored LptC but does not interact with the outer membrane anchored LptE. This suggests that the LptC component of the LptBFGC complex may act as a dock for LptA, allowing it to bind LPS after it has been assembled at the inner membrane. That no interaction between LptA and LptE has been observed supports the theory that LptA binds LptD in the LptDE homodimeric complex at the outer membrane.     

Breaching the Barrier: Quantifying Antibiotic Permeability across Gram-negative Bacterial Membranes

The double-membrane cell envelope of Gram-negative bacteria is a sophisticated barrier that facilitates the uptake of nutrients and protects the organism from toxic compounds. An antibiotic molecule must find its way through the negatively charged lipopolysaccharide layer on the outer surface, pass through either a porin or the hydrophobic layer of the outer membrane, then traverse the hydrophilic peptidoglycan layer only to find another hydrophobic lipid bilayer before it finally enters the cytoplasm, where it typically finds its target. This complex uptake pathway with very different physico-chemical properties is one reason that Gram-negative are intrinsically protected against multiple classes of antibiotic-like molecules, and is likely the main reason that in vitro target-based screening programs have failed to deliver novel antibiotics for these organisms. Due to the lack of general methods available for quantifying the flux of drugs into the cell, little is known about permeation rates, transport pathways and accumulation at the target sites for particular molecules. Here we summarize the current tools available for measuring antibiotic uptake across the different compartments of Gram-negative bacteria.     

Mechanisms of outer membrane vesicle entry into host cells

Bacterial outer membrane vesicles (OMVs) are nano‐sized compartments consisting of a lipid bilayer that encapsulates periplasm‐derived, luminal content. OMVs, which pinch off of Gram‐negative bacteria, are now recognized as a generalized secretion pathway which provides a means to transfer cargo to other bacterial cells as well as eukaryotic cells. Compared with other secretion systems, OMVs can transfer a chemically extremely diverse range of cargo, including small molecules, nucleic acids, proteins, and lipids to proximal cells. Although it is well recognized that OMVs can enter and release cargo inside host cells during infection, the mechanisms of host association and uptake are not well understood. This review highlights existing studies focusing on OMV‐host cell interactions and entry mechanisms, and how these entry routes affect cargo processing within the host. It further compares the wide range of methods currently used to dissect uptake mechanisms, and discusses potential sources of discrepancy regarding the mechanism of OMV uptake across different studies.     

Preventing drug access to targets: cell surface permeability barriers and active efflux in bacteria.

Bacteria, being unicellular, are constantly exposed to toxic compounds in their environment. Gram-negative bacteria and mycobacteria are unusually successful in surviving in the presence of toxic compounds because they combine two mechanisms of resistance. They produce effective permeability barriers, comprising the outer membrane and the mycolate-containing cell wall, on the cell surface. Further, they actively pump out drug molecules that trickle through the barrier, often utilizing multidrug efflux pumps. In Gram-negative bacteria, multidrug pumps of exceptionally wide specificity frequently interact with outer membrane channels and accessory proteins, forming multisubunit complexes that extrude drug molecules directly into the medium, bypassing the outer membrane barrier.