A comparative study of seven grabs used for sampling benthic macroinvertebrates in rivers

SUMMARY. After considering the large number of grabs described in the literature, seven grabs of weight < 25 kg were chosen for manual operation from a small boat: Van-Veen grab, weighted and unweighted Ponar grabs, Friedinger version of the Petersen grab, Dietz-La Fond mud-snapper, pole-operated Birge-Ekman grab and pole-operated Allan grab. Random samples (number of sampling units n= 10) were taken in a large tank with a known number of 2-mm cylindrical plastic pellets amongst stones of uniform size. Separate experiments were performed with four sizes of stones (model ranges: 2–4 mm, 8–16 mm, 16–32 mm, 32–64 mm). Stratified random samples (n= 10) were taken in rivers and the modal particle sizes at four sites were 0.004–0.06 mm, 0.5–2 mm, 16–64 mm and 64–128 mm. All grabs usually took a representative sample of the substratum at each site with no strong bias towards a particular particle size. The general performance of the Friedinger, Dietz-La Fond and Allan grabs was poor, except on a muddy bottom, with frequent failure to operate, small samples of substratum and a mean depth of penetration < 3 cm in all substrata except mud for the Dietz-La Fond and Allan grabs. The Van-Veen and Birge-Ekman grabs sampled to a mean depth < 3 cm in mud and fine gravel (2–4 mm), but the Birge-Ekman jammed frequently in fine gravel. Both Ponar grabs operated well and sampled to a mean depth ≥ 5 cm in mud and fine gravel, > 3 cm when small stones (8–16 mm) were present and 2 cm (weighted Ponar only) when larger stones (> 16 mm) were present in a gravel bottom. The mean depth was <0.8 cm for all grabs when larger stones (>16 mm) were predominant on the bottom. In the tank experiments with pellets, the efficiencies for the total catches of the Friedinger, Dietz-La Fond and Allan grabs were low with values <45% for fine gravel (2–4 mm), < 22% for small stones (8–16 mm) and <5% for a substratum of larger stones (>16 mm). If 50% is the minimum acceptable efficiency, then the Ponar, Van-Veen and Birge-Ekman grabs were adequate for fine gravel, only the two Ponar grabs were adequate for small stones and no grabs were adequate for sampling a substratum of larger stones (>16 mm). In field trials, the relative abundances of major taxa were similar for most grabs at each site; Friedinger and Dietz-La Fond grabs were the major exceptions. In terms of both mean number of taxa and mean number of invertebrates m^?2 the Ponar, Birge-Ekman and Allan grabs performed well on the predominantly muddy substratum at site 1, but only the weighted Ponar grab performed adequately on the predominantly gravel bottom with some large stones (>16 mm) at site 2. All grabs performed badly when larger stones (>16 mm) were predominant on the bottom (sites 3, 4). The relationship between the variances and means of the samples taken with each grab followed a power law for the catches of pellets in tank experiments, and for major taxa and total numbers at each site in field trials. Values of exponents in the power law lay within the range 1.14–2.34. The coefficient of variation was also frequently related to the sample mean and was an unreliable statistic for comparing the precision of grabs.     

Revisiting the effect of PCR replication and sequencing depth on biodiversity metrics in environmental DNA metabarcoding

Environmental DNA (eDNA) metabarcoding is an increasingly popular tool for measuring and cataloguing biodiversity. Because the environments and substrates in which DNA is preserved differ considerably, eDNA research often requires bespoke approaches to generating eDNA data. Here, we explore how two experimental choices in eDNA study design—the number of PCR replicates and the depth of sequencing of PCR replicates—influence the composition and consistency of taxa recovered from eDNA extracts. We perform 24 PCR replicates from each of six soil samples using two of the most common metabarcodes for Fungi and Viridiplantae (ITS1 and ITS2), and sequence each replicate to an average depth of ~84,000 reads. We find that PCR replicates are broadly consistent in composition and relative abundance of dominant taxa, but that low abundance taxa are often unique to one or a few PCR replicates. Taxa observed in one out of 24 PCR replicates make up 21–29% of the total taxa detected. We also observe that sequencing depth or rarefaction influences alpha diversity and beta diversity estimates. Read sampling depth influences local contribution to beta diversity, placement in ordinations, and beta dispersion in ordinations. Our results suggest that, because common taxa drive some alpha diversity estimates, few PCR replicates and low read sampling depths may be sufficient for many biological applications of eDNA metabarcoding. However, because rare taxa are recovered stochastically, eDNA metabarcoding may never fully recover the true amplifiable alpha diversity in an eDNA extract. Rare taxa drive PCR replicate outliers of alpha and beta diversity and lead to dispersion differences at different read sampling depths. We conclude that researchers should consider the complexity and unevenness of a community when choosing analytical approaches, read sampling depths, and filtering thresholds to arrive at stable estimates.     

A comparative study of three air-lift samplers used for sampling benthic macro-invertebrates in rivers

SUMMARY. From 16 air-lift samplers described in the literature, three were selected for operation from a small boat: Mackey, Pearson et al. and Verollet & Tachet samplers. Random samples (number of sampling units n= 10) were taken in a large tank with a known number of dried peas, representing invertebrates, amongst stones of uniform size. Separate experiments were performed with three sizes of stones (modal sizes 2–4, 16–20 and 32–36 mm). Stratified-random samples (usually n= 10) were taken in rivers at lour sites with modal particle sizes of < 0.1 2–4. 32–128 and 64–128 mm. The samplers were compared with a Ponar grab in the tank experiments and the field, and with a Naturalist's dredge in the field. Rates of pumping at different air-flows were established for each sampler. Water-How increased with increasing air-How and increasing submergence of the riser-pipe. The Mackey sampler achieved the highest water-flow and lifted more substratum and larger stones (64–128 mm) than the other samplers. The Verollet & Tachet sampler had the lowest pumping rate and failed to lift stones > 8 mm long, whilst the Pearson et al. sampler, with an intermediate performance, lifted mud and stones < 32 mm long. In the tank experiments, the area from which the Mackey and Pearson et al. samplers collected peas varied with air-flow, operating time and type of substratum. The Maekey sampler over-sampled and the Pearson et al. sampler usually under-sampled their respective sampling areas, except the latter sampler at high air-flows gave approximately quantitative results comparable to those of the Ponar grab for peas on the surface of stones 16–20 mm. No sampler collected much at a depth of 3 cm on larger stones (32–36 mm), and the Verollet & Tachet sampler failed completely on all substrata. In field trials, the Mackey and Pearson et al. samplers provided good qualitative samples except on large stones (32–128mm). The Verollet & Tachet sampler lifted little material. The relative abundance of taxa often differed between samplers. Estimates of the number of invertebrates per m² differed widely between samplers except for the Pearson et al. and Ponar grab which gave similar quantitative results at three sites. Values were very low for the Verollet & Tachet sampler and Naturalist's dredge and always very high for the Mackey sampler which often grossly over-sampled its sampling area. Therefore, these three samplers cannot be considered as quantitative. The relationship between the variances and the means of samples of peas in the tank and most invertebrates in the field followed a power law with values of the exponent b in the range 1.13–2.51. The present study completes the evaluation of 14 samplers used to sample benthic macro-invertebrates in deep rivers, and the more important conclusions from the comparative studies of seven grabs, four dredges and three air-lift samplers are summarized in a table.     

Effects of biotic factors on depth selection by salt marsh nekton

Biotic factors such as interactions among co-occurring taxa are frequently cited as important in determining how nekton use habitat, yet their effects have rarely been tested experimentally. We investigated the general hypothesis that depth distributions of five taxa common in salt marsh intertidal creeks are affected by the presence of other taxa. Two experiments were conducted in a pair of large (15 m³), multi-level (20, 40, and 60 cm water depth) flow-through tanks under fairly stable environmental conditions. During the first experiment, when grass shrimp (Palaemonetes spp.), mummichog (Fundulus heteroclitus), white mullet (Mugil curema), spot (Leiostomus xanthurus), and pinfish (Lagodon rhomboides) were each tested alone, the highest proportions of individuals occupied the intermediate and deepest depths. When all taxa were tested together, the distributions of resident creek taxa, mummichog and grass shrimp, shifted to shallower depths, but the distributions of the seasonal transient taxa, white mullet, spot, and pinfish, did not change. A second experiment was conducted to test the effect of predator presence on grass shrimp depth selection. Neither predatory pinfish nor non-predatory white mullet had a strong influence on grass shrimp depth distribution when tested separately, but grass shrimp shifted to shallower depths in the combined presence of both fish. This suggests that a multiple-taxa effect such as increased disturbance or higher encounter frequency influenced the depth selection of grass shrimp. Our results demonstrate that biotic factors are important in shaping distributions of grass shrimp and mummichog in shallow water habitat.     

On the reliability of Ponar grab samples for the quantitative study of benthic invertebrates in ponds

We present observations on the variability of sediment penetration depth by the Ponar grab sampler, which lead us to question the reliability of grab samples in the quantitative study of freshwater benthos. Penetration depth of the Petite Ponar grab depends on substrate type, and correlates with the amount of organic carbon, the water content and the granulometry of the sediment. Since these factors can also influence faunal composition and vertical distribution in the sediment, it is important to study the performance of the sampler before a biological explanation for the observed pattern is given. At the site studied, a case study was performed, in which variable grab penetration did not influence biological interpretation because the penetration depth of the grab followed that of the organisms under study.Research Assistant of the Belgian National Fund for Scientific Research (N.F.W.O.)Research Assistant of the Belgian National Fund for Scientific Research (N.F.W.O.)     

Meiofauna of silty sediments in the coastal area of the North Adriatic,with special reference to sampling methods

At five coastal silty sediment stations ranging in depth from 8 to 30 m, the abundance and composition of meiofauna were investigated. Three methods of sampling were used, i.e. Pfleger corer, Van Veen grab and SCUBA divers. Four samples per station were taken. The mean density of total meiofauna was 660 ± 109 ind. 10 cm². The main meiofauna group was Nematoda, the second abundant was Copepoda, and third was Kinorhyncha. Statistical tests showed significant differences in meiofaunal abundance between corer and grab samples, and between corer and divers samples.Differences in meiofauna abundance between stations were found.     

Chironomid pupal exuviae and larvae of two storage reservoirs in The Netherlands

For three years chironomid larvae were collected bimonthly with a grab sampler in two deep storage reservoirs in The Netherlands. Chironomid pupal exuviae were collected monthly, from April to November, with a handnet. Net samples yielded more taxa than grab samples. The taxa found in net samples originated from more habitats, than taxa found in grab samples. The relative contribution of Orthocladiinae was much larger in net samples. Based on the results obtained in the two reservoirs, some advantages and disadvantages of both sampling methods are discussed.     

A Feasibility Study to Monitor the Macroinvertebrate Diversity of the River Nile Using Three Sampling Methods

The River Nile is one of the world’s major rivers. Its’ catchment in Egypt has a population of 75,000,000. River flow is highly regulated and there are known discharges of pollutants. 1035 km of the river downstream of the Aswan high dam was studied to test the hypothesis that representative qualitative samples can be used to estimate macroinvertebrate biodiversity. Benthic macroinvertebrates are difficult to sample in large rivers and a reliable sampling strategy is required to evaluate their ecological status. Three methods for sampling have been investigated. Ekman Grab, macrophyte sweep netting and Artificial Substrate Samplers (ASS) were used to sample 15 sites from Aswan to Cairo between September 2001 and June 2002. Organisms were identified to species level where possible. Taxon accretion curves indicated that the all taxa present at a site should be collected using either 15 grab samples, 10 macrophyte samples or 5 ASS. The best time to sample was May–June. The biodiversity of macroinvertebrates in the Nile was recorded as 50 taxa with values of 7–31 at individual bank-side sites. Mid-stream biodiversity was much lower (0–19). Lowest biodiversity occurred at sites with known pollution inputs whilst highest occurred at sites with high levels of sedimentation. A regular programme for biomonitoring is recommended which will allow current status to be confirmed and future changes detected.     

A new quantitative air-lift sampler for collecting macroinvertebrates on stony bottoms in deep rivers

SUMMARY. 1. As three previous comparative studies of deep-water samplers for benthic macroinvertebrates in rivers highlighted the need for a quantitative sampler for use on stony substrata, a new air-lift sampler was developed. It can be operated from a small boat by two people, weighs 13.5–20.0 kg, depending on the length of riser used, and extends the maximum range of substrata that may be sampled quantitatively from 16–32 mm to 128—256 mm. The sampling area is isolated by forcing a collecting cylinder into the substratum, and rapid evacuation of the contents is assisted by a vibrator.
2. All the major specifications of the sampler were determined experimentally in a large tank using three sizes of substrata and plastic pellets to represent invertebrates. The sampler performed accurately to a depth of at least 8 cm on substrata ranging from gravel (2–4 mm) to large stones (32–36 mm long).
3. The performance of the sampler was compared with that of a Ponar grab and Pearson el at. air-lift sampler at two sites on a large river and also with a Naturalist's dredge and a diver-operated Hess-Waters sampler at one of the sites where there were large stones up to 280 mm long. In terms of both mean taxa per sample and mean numbers m⁻², samples taken using the new air-lift sampler provided estimates comparable to or belter than those obtained with the other samplers.     

Cost/benefit and the effect of sample preservation procedures on quantitative patterns in benthic ecology

Some benthic assemblages studies have tested the effects of different preservation procedures on biomass, but their influence on quantitative patterns (number of species and abundance) is still unclear. We evaluated the influence of two sample preservation procedures on quantitative patterns in benthic ecology. Ten sampling points were systematically interspersed on two types of sediment (sandy and muddy). At each sediment type, samples from five sampling points were fixed in 10% formalin, and the other five points were preserved in 70% ethanol (without previous fixation). Three replicates were collected at each sampling point, and samples were washed in 0.5 mesh size and sorted in laboratory. A cost/benefit analysis was performed considering the washing time in laboratory and the costs of substances. A total of 1970 individuals were collected (muddy sediment: 132; sandy sediment: 1838), belonging to 121 taxa (muddy: 49; sandy: 83). Assemblages preserved in ethanol were composed of 795 individuals and 80 taxa, while those fixed with formalin had 1173 individuals and 94 taxa. Polychaeta predominated as the most abundant group for both preservation procedures. For the whole benthic community, significant differences occurred only between sediment types. Significant differences in the number of individuals of polychaetes were observed for the different preservation procedures in sandy sediment. Ethanol has the best cost/benefit ratio in both sediment types due to additional costs to attend safety requirements for formalin-fixed samples. Further studies should evaluate how quantitative patterns are affected by exposure time of preservation, anesthesia interaction, and morphological deformations (e.g. impossibility of identification).     

Sample pooling obscures diversity patterns in intertidal ciliate community composition and structure

The aim of this study was to assess the effect of sample pooling on the portrayal of ciliate community structure and composition in intertidal sediment samples. Molecular ciliate community profiles were obtained from nine biological replicates distributed in three discrete sampling plots and from samples that were pooled prior to RNA extraction using terminal restriction fragment polymorphism (T-RFLP) analyses of SSU rRNA. Comparing the individual replicates of one sampling plot with each other, we found a differential variability among the individual biological replicates. T-RFLP profiles of pooled samples displayed a significantly different community composition compared with the cumulative individual biological replicate samples. We conclude that sample pooling obscures diversity patterns in ciliate and possibly also other microbial eukaryote studies. However, differences between pooled samples and replicates were less pronounced when community structure was analyzed. We found that the most abundant T-RFLP peaks were generally shared between biological replicates and pooled samples. Assuming that the most abundant taxa in an ecosystem under study are also the ones driving ecosystem processes, sample pooling may still be effective for the analyses of ecological key players.     

Distribution and habitat of Nitellopsis obtusa (Characeae) in the Laurentian Great Lakes

Nitellopsis obtusa, a macroalga (Characeae) native to Europe and Asia, was found in U.S. waters of the St. Clair-Detroit River system in 1983, thus extending the range of this taxon into the Laurentian Great Lakes about 850 km from the St. Lawrence River where it was first discovered in North America in 1978. Its occurrence only in water frequented by commercial shipping vessels suggests that it is distributed via this mechanism. In the St. Clair-Detroit River system, N. obtusa was collected with a Ponar grab at four locations, and with a grapnel at one additional location. It was the ninth most frequently found macrophyte and it was most abundant at Belle Isle in the Detroit River, where the mean dry-weight biomass in Ponar samples was 0 g m^-2 in June, 37 g m^-2 in August, and 32 g m⁻² in September. Maximum biomass of this taxon in one Ponar grab at this location was 289 g m^-2 in September. The alga occurred primarily in water of relatively low current velocity (11.3 cm s⁻¹) and in association with Vallisneria americana, Myriophyllum spicatum, Potamogeton richardsonii, Najas flexilis, and Elodea canadensis. Contribution 654, Great Lakes Fishery Laboratory, Ann Arbor, MI 48105, USA Contribution 654, Great Lakes Fishery Laboratory, Ann Arbor, MI 48105, USA     

Optimization of sampling procedures for DNA‐based diagnosis of wood decay fungi in standing trees

Aims: To develop fast and reliable sampling procedures for DNA‐based diagnosis of wood decay fungi in standing trees. Methods and Results: A total of 250 trees were tested for the presence of a suite of wood decay fungi by collecting wood frass obtained by drilling each tree once with a 4‐mm‐diameter, 43‐cm‐long bit. We identified at least one of 11 target wood decay fungi in 56 trees through multiplex PCR assays. The presence of target wood decay taxa was further investigated in these 56 trees, by analysing independently wood from each of six drillings. Results were then compared with those obtained using sampling schemes differing in terms of number and position of drillings. Samples of 1–4 drillings were either analysed separately, and the results were combined, or pooled together before analysis was performed. In comparison with taxa identified by the analysis of six drillings, diagnostic efficiency ranged from 56·6% for the scheme based on a single drill to 96·8% for the scheme based on four drillings analysed separately. Both schemes significantly differ (P < 0·05) from those based on two and three drillings, whose efficiency was 72·6% and 83·9%, respectively. Diagnostic efficiency of pooled samples was comparable to that of samples analysed separately. Conclusions: Highest diagnostic efficiency was obtained by analysing wood from four drillings. It is advisable to pool samples deriving from different drillings to reduce laboratory costs. Significance and Impact of the Study: Fast and reliable sampling procedures make DNA‐based diagnosis more suitable for tree inspection procedures.     

Modelling habitat associations with fingernail clam (Family: Sphaeriidae) counts at multiple spatial scales using hierarchical count models

1. Macroinvertebrate count data often exhibit nested or hierarchical structure. Examples include multiple measurements along each of a set of streams, and multiple synoptic measurements from each of a set of ponds. With data exhibiting hierarchical structure, outcomes at both sampling (e.g. within stream) and aggregated (e.g. stream) scales are often of interest. Unfortunately, methods for modelling hierarchical count data have received little attention in the ecological literature. 2. We demonstrate the use of hierarchical count models using fingernail clam (Family: Sphaeriidae) count data and habitat predictors derived from sampling and aggregated spatial scales. The sampling scale corresponded to that of a standard Ponar grab (0.052 m²) and the aggregated scale to impounded and backwater regions within 38–197 km reaches of the Upper Mississippi River. Impounded and backwater regions were resampled annually for 10 years. Consequently, measurements on clams were nested within years. Counts were treated as negative binomial random variates, and means from each resampling event as random departures from the impounded and backwater region grand means. 3. Clam models were improved by the addition of covariates that varied at both the sampling and regional scales. Substrate composition varied at the sampling scale and was associated with model improvements, and reductions (for a given mean) in variance at the sampling scale. Inorganic suspended solids (ISS) levels, measured in the summer preceding sampling, also yielded model improvements and were associated with reductions in variances at the regional rather than sampling scales. ISS levels were negatively associated with mean clam counts. 4. Hierarchical models allow hierarchically structured data to be modelled without ignoring information specific to levels of the hierarchy. In addition, information at each hierarchical level may be modelled as functions of covariates that themselves vary by and within levels. As a result, hierarchical models provide researchers and resource managers with a method for modelling hierarchical data that explicitly recognises both the sampling design and the information contained in the corresponding data.     

Effects of dredge material placement on benthic macroinvertebrates of the Illinois River

Since the 1930s, dredge material has been removed from the Illinois River and placed along the main channel border in shallow depths to maintain a 2.7 m deep main channel for commercial navigation. Placement of this material changes the sediment composition from primarily silt/clay to primarily sand, and it buries pre-existing benthic invertebrates. During 1997 and 1998, the benthos of an 125 km reach of the middle Illinois River (La Grange Reach) was studied by extracting 1065 Ponar samples from randomly-selected sites which had never received dredge material, received dredge material one year previous, or received dredge material during the current year. Although total numbers of macroinvertebrates collected was lower in 1998 than in 1997, relative abundances of eight targeted taxa were highly similar between years. Chironimidae were most abundant and comprised >66% of all macroinvertebrates collected both years. Differences in densities of Chironomidae, Ephemeroptera, Sphaeriidae, Corbicula fluminea (Muller, 1774), Dreissena polymorpha (Pallas, 1771), Odonata, and Gastropoda among the three classes of dredge material placement were all significant (P< 0.05). For all taxa, densities were highest at sites that had never received dredge material; and, for all taxa except Chironimidae, densities were lowest at sites that received dredge material during the current year. No significant recovery by macroinvertebrates was noticed on dredge areas of this reach after one year (P>0.05). Future operations to maintain a channel for navigation should consider preexisting densities of macroinvertebrate taxa. Because benthic macroinvertebrates are an important component of the food web and shifting sand does not support diverse macroinvertebrate communities, strategic placement of dredge material by avoiding islands or other areas of high macroinvertebrate diversity could improve overall system productivity and biotic integrity of large river-floodplains.     

Assessment of Stream Restoration: Sources of Variation in Macroinvertebrate Recovery throughout an 11‐Year Study of Coal Mine Drainage Treatment

Stream restoration researchers have a complex array of alternative assessment methodologies using macroinvertebrates. We examined sources of variation among three field sampling methods and five metrics in three networked streams impacted by a circumneutral coal mine discharge treated midway through an 11‐year study. Constructed wetlands captured the primary stressor, 700 kg iron/day. Before pollution abatement, copious iron hydroxide smothered downstream sites for decades. Two second‐order streams and one fourth‐order receiving stream, each with matching locations upstream and downstream, were monitored midsummer from 1994 to 2004. We compared taxa density (TD) (number/sample), abundance, expected taxa richness (ETR), U.S. regional pollution tolerance values (RTV), and community similarity (CS) indices from 3 to 11 replicate samples/site using grab samples (i.e. D‐nets, rock washes) and incubated leaf packs. Variation due to sampling method, metric, location, and year significantly influenced outcomes when analyzed using regression and analysis of variance. TD, RTV, and CS indicated biological recovery lagged 6 years behind chemical improvement; ETR and abundance showed more severe, persistent impairment in the two, highly impacted second‐order streams compared to the fourth‐order stream. Incubated leaf packs offered a preview of stream recovery in downstream sites, providing clean food (leaves) and substrate (mesh) and attracted more taxa and abundance than grab samples. In light of the worldwide distribution of coal mining often accompanied by metal hydroxide deposits into streams, we suggest restoration project managers use a variety of sampling methods, metrics, and models to evaluate remediation of physical as well as chemical impairment from mining.     

Prediction of total fecal output in sheep fed silage using the Captec chrome controlled-release capsule

Six Finnish wethers (average weight, 52.3 kg) were used to determine the effectiveness of a controlled-release Cr₂O₃ bolus and the internal marker acid insoluble ash (AIA) for predicting fecal output. Wethers were fed grass silage for ad libitum intake. Each wether was dosed orally with one continuous-release Cr₂O₃ bolus (CRC) on the first day of the experiment. Chronology of the trial was as follows: Day 0 to 14, marker adaptation period; Day 15 to 21, total fecal collection; Day 22 to 23, fecal grab sampling every 4 h; Day 25 to 35, once-daily fecal grab sampling. Accuracy of marker-estimated fecal output derived from each method was compared within a marker with total fecal collection values using a paired t-test. Concentrations of AIA and Cr varied (P < 0.10) between sampling times. Accuracy of fecal output estimates was better with the controlled-release Cr₂O₃ bolus (r = 0.97; P = 0.03) than with AIA (r = −0.08; P = 0.89). Grab samples taken once produced reliable (r = 0.96; P = 0.02) estimates of fecal output of silage-fed wethers using the controlled-release Cr₂O₃ bolus. The controlled-release Cr₂O₃ bolus is a better marker than acid-insoluble ash for predicting fecal output of silage-fed wethers.     

Sweeping beauty: is grassland arthropod community composition effectively estimated by sweep netting?

Arthropods are critical ecosystem components due to their high diversity and sensitivity to perturbation. Furthermore, due to their ease of capture they are often the focus of environmental health surveys. There is much debate regarding the best sampling method to use in these surveys. Sweep netting and pan trapping are two sampling methods commonly used in agricultural arthropod surveys, but have not been contrasted in natural grassland systems at the community level. The purpose of this study was to determine whether sweep netting was effective at estimating arthropod diversity at the community level in grasslands or if supplemental pan trapping was needed. Arthropods were collected from grassland sites in Montana, USA, in the summer of 2011. The following three standardized evaluation criteria (consistency, reliability, and precision) were developed to assess the efficacy of sweep netting and pan trapping, based on analyses of variations in arthropod abundances, species richness, evenness, capture frequency, and community composition. Neither sampling method was sufficient in any criteria to be used alone for community‐level arthropod surveys. On a taxa‐specific basis, however, sweep netting was consistent, reliable, and precise for Thysanoptera, infrequently collected (i.e., rare) insects, and Arachnida, whereas pan trapping was consistent, reliable, and precise for Collembola and bees, which is especially significant given current threats to the latter's populations worldwide. Species‐level identifications increase the detected dissimilarity between sweep netting and pan trapping. We recommend that community‐level arthropod surveys use both sampling methods concurrently, at least in grasslands, but likely in most nonagricultural systems. Target surveys, such as monitoring bee communities in fragmented grassland habitat or where detailed information on behavior of the target arthropod groups is available can in some instances employ singular methods. As a general ecological principle, consistency, reliability, and precision are appropriate criteria to evaluate the applicability of a given sampling method for both community‐level and taxa‐specific arthropod surveys in any ecosystem.     

Invertebrate Sampling in the Substratum of an Experimental Recirculating Stream

In order to determine the efficacy of sampling benthic invertebrates to a depth of 100 mm as compared with 200 mm, the gravel substratum of an experimental recirculating stream was sampled to both depths. Except for 6 taxa which were significantly more numerous in the shallower samplers, there was no significant difference between the densities determined from the two depths.     

The structure and long-term dynamics of the communities of Arctica islandica (Bivalavia) in Rugozerskaya Guba of the White Sea

The age structure of a dense settlement of Arctica islandica (Bivalvia) near Vysokii Island (Rugozerskaya Guba (bay)) of the White Sea is described. The data collected by trawling in 2003, 2006–2007 and grab sampling in 2009–2011 are summarized. The A. islandica community in the Rugozerskaya Guba was first described in 1953–1959, but to date, no reliable quantitative estimates have been obtained and the community’s size structure was not studied. The size structure of this community was stable over the last eight years; the main part of the community was represented by individuals with a body weight of 3–10 g. It was revealed that the distribution of different A. islandica classes depends on the depth. The majority of the largest individuals were found in the shallowest parts of the study area (9–11 m); middle-size individuals were registered at depths of 9–14 m; and the smallest ones, at depths of 12–17 m.