Operation Everest II: pulmonary gas exchange during a simulated ascent of Mt. Everest

Eight normal subjects were decompressed to barometric pressure (PB) = 240 Torr over 40 days. The ventilation-perfusion (VA/Q) distribution was estimated at rest and during exercise [up to 80-90% maximal O2 uptake (VO2 max)] by the multiple inert gas elimination technique at sea level and PB = 428, 347, 282, and 240 Torr. The dispersion of the blood flow distribution increased by 64% from rest to 281 W, at both sea level and at PB = 428 Torr (heaviest exercise 215 W). At PB = 347 Torr, the increase was 79% (rest to 159 W); at PB = 282 Torr, the increase was 112% (108 W); and at PB = 240 Torr, the increase was 9% (60 W). There was no significant correlation between the dispersion and cardiac output, ventilation, or pulmonary arterial wedge pressure, but there was a correlation between the dispersion and mean pulmonary arterial pressure (r = 0.49, P = 0.02). When abnormal, the VA/Q pattern generally had perfusion in lung units of zero or near zero VA/Q combined with units of normal VA/Q. Alveolar-end-capillary diffusion limitation of O2 uptake (VO2) was observed at VO2 greater than 3 l/min at sea level, greater than 1-2 l/min VO2 at PB = 428 and 347 Torr, and at higher altitudes, at VO2 less than or equal to 1 l/min. These results show variable but increasing VA/Q mismatch with long-term exposure to both altitude and exercise. The VA/Q pattern and relationship to pulmonary arterial pressure are both compatible with alveolar interstitial edema as the primary cause of inequality.     

A graphic analysis of respiratory heat exchange

A new graphic representation of respiratory heat exchange is proposed using the concept of equivalent temperatures directly related to enthalpy values. On such a diagram it is possible to 1) compute the value of the heat exchange (delta H) knowing the inspired temperature (TI) and the partial pressure of water vapor (PIH2O) [or the relative humidity (rhI)] of inspired gas; 2) estimate the variation in delta H following a given variation in TI and PIH2O or, inversely, to choose the variation in TI and PIH2O necessary to obtain a given variation in delta H; 3) dissociate inspiratory and expiratory exchanges and to evaluate the efficiency of the respiratory heat exchange process in different environmental situations; and 4) easily compare the results of different studies published on respiratory heat exchanges in humans or other animal species.     

Pulmonary gas exchange in humans during normobaric hypoxic exercise

Previous studies (J. Appl. Physiol. 58: 978-988 and 989-995, 1985) have shown both worsening ventilation-perfusion (VA/Q) relationships and the development of diffusion limitation during heavy exercise at sea level and during hypobaric hypoxia in a chamber [fractional inspired O2 concentration (FIO2) = 0.21, minimum barometric pressure (PB) = 429 Torr, inspired O2 partial pressure (PIO2) = 80 Torr]. We used the multiple inert gas elimination technique to compare gas exchange during exercise under normobaric hypoxia (FIO2 = 0.11, PB = 760 Torr, PIO2 = 80 Torr) with earlier hypobaric measurements. Mixed expired and arterial respiratory and inert gas tensions, cardiac output, heart rate (HR), minute ventilation, respiratory rate (RR), and blood temperature were recorded at rest and during steady-state exercise in 10 normal subjects in the following order: rest, air; rest, 11% O2; light exercise (75 W), 11% O2; intermediate exercise (150 W), 11% O2; heavy exercise (greater than 200 W), 11% O2; heavy exercise, 100% O2 and then air; and rest 20 minutes postexercise, air. VA/Q inequality increased significantly during hypoxic exercise [mean log standard deviation of perfusion (logSDQ) = 0.42 +/- 0.03 (rest) and 0.67 +/- 0.09 (at 2.3 l/min O2 consumption), P less than 0.01]. VA/Q inequality was improved by relief of hypoxia (logSDQ = 0.51 +/- 0.04 and 0.48 +/- 0.02 for 100% O2 and air breathing, respectively). Diffusion limitation for O2 was evident at all exercise levels while breathing 11% O2.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Exercise breathing pattern during chronic altitude exposure

Breathing pattern in response to maximal exercise was examined in four subjects during a 7-day acclimatisation to a simulated altitude of 4247 m (barometric pressure, PB = 59.5 kPa). Graded exercise tests to exhaustion were performed during normoxia (day 0), and on days 2 and 7 of hypoxia, respectively. Ventilation was significantly augmented in the hypoxic environment, as were both the mean inspiratory flow (VT/TI) and inspiratory duty cycle (TI/TTOT) components of it. VI/TI was increased due to a significant increase in tidal volume (VT) and a corresponding decrease in inspiratory time duration (TI). Throughout a range of exercise ventilation, TI/TTOT was increased due to an apparently greater decrease in expiratory time duration (TE) with respect to TI. In all cases, the relation between VT and TI displayed a typical range 2 behaviour, with evidence of a range 3 occurring at very high ventilatory rates. There was essentially no difference observed in the VT-TI relation during exercise between the normoxic and hypoxic conditions. No significant changes were observed in the breathing pattern in response to exercise within the exposure period (from day 2 to day 7), although there was a discernible tendency to a higher stage 3 plateau by day 7 of altitude exposure.     

Control of respiratory pattern in conscious dog: effects of heat and CO2

We measured tidal volume (VT) and inspiratory (TI) and expiratory (TE) durations in five conscious tracheostomized dogs breathing air or 5% CO2 in air either at normal (20 degrees C) or elevated (30 degrees C) ambient temperatures. Respiratory frequency ranged between 16 and 333/min due to changes in both TI and TE. During panting TI exceeded TE. During air inhalation instantaneous ventilation (V) spontaneously ranged from 100 to 1,600 ml . kg-1 . min-1. Hypercapnia, heat stress, or both, increased this range of V by increasing maximum V, primarily due to increases in mean inspiratory flow. Under these conditions, changes in TI accounted for more of the spontaneous changes in breath duration. During inhalation of air and 5% CO2, a positive correlation between VT and TI was obtained for TI between 0.13 and 1.05 s; above 1.05 s VT decreased. Heat stress increased VT at a given TI. We suggest that either the decay rate or position of the inspiratory off-switch threshold curve (Clark and von Euler, J. Physiol. London 222: 267, 1972) varies in conscious dogs. Shifts in either the reset (onset) value or decay rate of the curve yield a positive correlation between VT and TI. This modification to the Clark-von Euler model implies that the primary effect of anesthesia on respiratory control is fixation of the inspiratory off-switch threshold curve.     

Life-long consequences of postnatal normoxia exposure in rats raised at high altitude

We tested the hypothesis that exposure of high-altitude (HA) rats to a period of postnatal normoxia has long-term consequences on the ventilatory and hematological acclimatization in adults. Male and female HA rats (3,600 m, Po(2) ? 100 Torr; La Paz, Bolivia) were exposed to normal room air [HA control (HACont)] or enriched oxygen (32% O(2); Po(2) ? 160 Torr) from 1 day before to 15 days after birth [HA postnatal normoxia (HApNorm)]. Hematocrit and hemoglobin values were assessed at 2, 12, and 32 wk of age. Cardiac and lung morphology were assessed at 12 wk by measuring right ventricular hypertrophy (pulmonary hypertension index) and lung air space-to-tissue ratio (indicative of alveolarization). Respiratory parameters under baseline conditions and in response to 32% O(2) for 10 min (relieving the ambient hypoxic stimulus) were measured by whole body plethysmography at 12 wk. Finally, we performed a survival analysis up to 600 days of age. Compared with HACont, HApNorm rats had reduced hematocrit and hemoglobin levels at all ages (both sexes); reduced right ventricular hypertrophy (both sexes); lower air space-to-tissue ratio in the lungs (males only); reduced CO(2) production rate, but higher oxygen uptake (males only); and similar respiratory frequency, tidal volume, and minute ventilation. When breathing 32% O(2), HApNorm male rats had a stronger decrease of minute ventilation than HACont. HApNorm rats had a marked tendency toward longer survival throughout the study. We conclude that exposure to ambient hypoxia during postnatal development in HA rats has deleterious consequences on acclimatization to hypoxia as adults.     

Effect of CO₂ on the ventilatory sensitivity to rising body temperature during exercise

We examined the degree to which ventilatory sensitivity to rising body temperature (the slope of the regression line relating ventilation and body temperature) is altered by restoration of arterial PCO(2) to the eucapnic level during prolonged exercise in the heat. Thirteen subjects exercised for ~60 min on a cycle ergometer at 50% of peak O(2) uptake with and without inhalation of CO(2)-enriched air. Subjects began breathing CO(2)-enriched air at the point that end-tidal Pco(2) started to decline. Esophageal temperature (T(es)), minute ventilation (V(E)), tidal volume (V(T)), respiratory frequency (f(R)), respiratory gases, middle cerebral artery blood velocity, and arterial blood pressure were recorded continuously. When V(E), V(T), f(R), and ventilatory equivalents for O(2) uptake (V(E)/VO(2)) and CO(2) output (V(E)/VCO(2)) were plotted against changes in T(es) from the start of the CO(2)-enriched air inhalation (ΔT(es)), the slopes of the regression lines relating V(E), V(T), V(E)/VO(2), and V(E)/VCO(2) to ΔT(es) (ventilatory sensitivity to rising body temperature) were significantly greater when subjects breathed CO(2)-enriched air than when they breathed room air (V(E): 19.8 ± 10.3 vs. 8.9 ± 6.7 l·min(-1)·°C(-1), V(T): 18 ± 120 vs. -81 ± 92 ml/°C; V(E)/VO(2): 7.4 ± 5.5 vs. 2.6 ± 2.3 units/°C, and V(E)/VCO(2): 7.6 ± 6.6 vs. 3.4 ± 2.8 units/°C). The increase in Ve was accompanied by increases in V(T) and f(R). These results suggest that restoration of arterial PCO(2) to nearly eucapnic levels increases ventilatory sensitivity to rising body temperature by around threefold.     

Interaction between upper airway negative pressure pulses and CO2 on breathing pattern

The interaction between CO2 and negative pressure pulses on breathing pattern was investigated in 10 anesthetized, spontaneously breathing rabbits. The upper airway was functionally isolated into a closed system. A servo-respirator triggered by the inspiratory activity of the diaphragm was used to apply pressure pulses of -15 cmH2O to the isolated upper airway in early inspiration while the animal was breathing room air, 100% O2, 6% CO2 in O2, or 9% CO2 in O2. The negative pressure pulses produced a reversible inhibition of inspiration in most trials with resultant increase in inspiratory duration (TI); no change was observed in peak diaphragmatic electromyogram (Dia EMG) or expiratory duration, whereas a decrease was seen in mean inspiratory drive (peak Dia EMG/TI). This prolongation of inspiratory duration and decrease in mean inspiratory drive with negative pressure pulses persisted at higher levels of CO2; the slopes of the test breaths were not significantly different from that of control breaths. These results suggest that upper airway negative pressure pulses are equally effective in altering the breathing pattern at all levels of CO2.     

Effects of almitrine on respiration in unanesthetized newborn rabbits

We previously demonstrated that almitrine, a peripheral chemoreceptor stimulant, increased tidal volume (VT), expired minute ventilation (VE), and respiratory frequency (f) and decreased inspiratory (TI) and expiratory time (TE) in sleeping adult cats. We now hypothesized that almitrine would induce an increase in ventilation in a young animal model. Respiration was studied by the barometric method in 11 unanesthetized New Zealand White rabbit pups between 3 and 6 days of age. Recordings were made in 0.21 FIO2 at base line and after cumulative intraperitoneal infusions of almitrine (2.5, 5.0, and 7.5 mg/kg). The chamber pressure deflection (proportional to VT after appropriate calculation) was computer sampled at 200 Hz. At least 100 breaths for each dose in each animal were analyzed. We found that a 7.5-mg/kg intraperitoneal dose of almitrine increased f to 135 +/- 9% (SE) of base line and decreased TE and TI to 72 +/- 8% and 79 +/- 8% of base line, respectively. Changes in VE, VT/TI, and VT were not significant. Recognizing that apnea is associated with inadequate ventilation and a prolonged TE (failure of the "inspiratory on-switch"), these results, particularly the increase in f and decrease in TE, suggest that almitrine might be useful in treating apnea in preterm infants.     

Operation Everest II: elevated high-altitude pulmonary resistance unresponsive to oxygen

High altitude increases pulmonary arterial pressure (PAP), but no measurements have been made in humans above 4,500 m. Eight male athletic volunteers were decompressed in a hypobaric chamber for 40 days to a barometric pressure (PB) of 240 Torr, equivalent to the summit of Mt. Everest. Serial hemodynamic measurements were made at PB 760 (sea level), 347 (6,100 m), and 282/240 Torr (7,620/8,840 m). Resting PAP and pulmonary vascular resistance (PVR) increased from sea level to maximal values at PB 282 Torr from 15 +/- 0.9 to 34 +/- 3.0 mmHg and from 1.2 +/- 0.1 to 4.3 +/- 0.3 mmHg.l-1 X min, respectively. During near maximal exercise PAP increased from 33 +/- 1 mmHg at sea level to 54 +/- 2 mmHg at PB 282 Torr. Right atrial and wedge pressures were not increased with altitude. Acute 100% O2 breathing lowered cardiac output and PAP but not PVR. Systemic arterial pressure and resistance did not rise with altitude but did increase with O2 breathing, indicating systemic control differed from the lung circulation. We concluded that severe chronic hypoxia caused elevated pulmonary resistance not accompanied by right heart failure nor immediately reversed by O2 breathing.     

Brain stem NO modulates ventilatory acclimatization to hypoxia in mice.

The objective of our study was to assess the role of neuronal nitric oxide synthase (nNOS) in the ventilatory acclimatization to hypoxia. We measured the ventilation in acclimatized Bl6/CBA mice breathing 21% and 8% oxygen, used a nNOS inhibitor, and assessed the expression of N-methyl-d-aspartate (NMDA) glutamate receptor and nNOS (mRNA and protein). Two groups of Bl6/CBA mice (n = 60) were exposed during 2 wk either to hypoxia [barometric pressure (PB) = 420 mmHg] or normoxia (PB = 760 mmHg). At the end of exposure the medulla was removed to measure the concentration of nitric oxide (NO) metabolites, the expression of NMDA-NR1 receptor, and nNOS by real-time RT-PCR and Western blot. We also measured the ventilatory response [fraction of inspired O(2) (Fi(O(2))) = 0.21 and 0.08] before and after S-methyl-l-thiocitrulline treatment (SMTC, nNOS inhibitor, 10 mg/kg ip). Chronic hypoxia caused an increase in ventilation that was reduced after SMTC treatment mainly through a decrease in tidal volume (Vt) in normoxia and in acute hypoxia. However, the difference observed in the magnitude of acute hypoxic ventilatory response [minute ventilation (Ve) 8% - Ve 21%] in acclimatized mice was not different. Acclimatization to hypoxia induced a rise in NMDA receptor as well as in nNOS and NO production. In conclusion, our study provides evidence that activation of nNOS is involved in the ventilatory acclimatization to hypoxia in mice but not in the hypoxic ventilatory response (HVR) while the increased expression of NMDA receptor expression in the medulla of chronically hypoxic mice plays a role in acute HVR. These results are therefore consistent with central nervous system plasticity, partially involved in ventilatory acclimatization to hypoxia through nNOS.     

Periodic breathing in the mouse.

The hypothesis was that unstable breathing might be triggered by a brief hypoxia challenge in C57BL/6J (B6) mice, which in contrast to A/J mice are known not to exhibit short-term potentiation; as a consequence, instability of ventilatory behavior could be inherited through genetic mechanisms. Recordings of ventilatory behavior by the plethsmography method were made when unanesthetized B6 or A/J animals were reoxygenated with 100% O(2) or air after exposure to 8% O(2) or 3% CO(2)-10% O(2) gas mixtures. Second, we examined the ventilatory behavior after termination of poikilocapnic hypoxia stimuli in recombinant inbred strains derived from B6 and A/J animals. Periodic breathing (PB) was defined as clustered breathing with either waxing and waning of ventilation or recurrent end-expiratory pauses (apnea) of > or = 2 average breath durations, each pattern being repeated with a cycle number > or = 3. With the abrupt return to room air from 8% O(2), 100% of the 10 B6 mice exhibited PB. Among them, five showed breathing oscillations with apnea, but none of the 10 A/J mice exhibited cyclic oscillations of breathing. When the animals were reoxygenated after 3% CO(2)-10% O(2) challenge, no PB was observed in A/J mice, whereas conditions still induced PB in B6 mice. (During 100% O(2) reoxygenation, all 10 B6 mice had PB with apnea.) Expression of PB occurred in some but not all recombinant mice and was not associated with the pattern of breathing at rest. We conclude that differences in expression of PB between these strains indicate that genetic influences strongly affect the stability of ventilation in the mouse.     

Importance of vagal afferents in determining ventilation in newborn rats

We studied the effect of acute bilateral vagotomy on ventilation and ventilatory pattern in rats. In 1- to 6-day-old unanesthetized rats, vagotomy resulted in a substantial decrease (38%) in ventilation during air breathing. After vagotomy there was a threefold increase in tidal volume (VT), inspiratory time (TI) doubled, and expiratory time (TE) was six times longer. When studied under isoflurane anesthesia, newborn rats showed decreases in ventilation similar to that observed without anesthesia, whereas anesthetized adult rats had no consistent changes in ventilation. Adult and newborn rats had nearly identical proportionate increases in VT and TI after vagotomy, but TE lengthened to a greater extent in the newborns. Additionally, we demonstrated a significant decrease in ventilation when 100% O2 rather than air was supplied to nonvagotomized unanesthetized newborn rats. Ventilation decreased by 19% after vagotomy under hyperoxic conditions. We conclude that vagal afferent input, probably of pulmonary mechanoreceptor origin, provides positive feedback to respiration in newborn rats and that newborn rats greater than 24 h old also have a degree of peripheral chemoreceptor drive during air breathing.     

Postnatal maturation of ventilation and breathing pattern in kittens: influence of sleep

Ventilation and breathing pattern were studied in kittens at 1, 2, 3, 4, and 8 wk of life during quiet wakefulness (W), quiet sleep (QS), and active sleep (AS) with the barometric method. Tidal volume (VT), respiratory frequency (f), ventilation (VE), inspiratory time (TI), expiratory time (TE), mean inspiratory flow (VT/TI), and respiratory "duty cycle" (TI/TT) were measured. VT, VE, TI, TE, and VT/TI increased; f decreased and TI/TT remained constant during postnatal development in wakefulness and in both sleep states. No significant difference was observed between AS and QS for all the ventilatory parameters except TI/TT, which was greater in QS than in AS at 2 wk. VE was larger in W than in both AS and QS at all ages. This was mainly due to a greater f, TI/TT remaining constant. VT/TI, which represents an index of the central inspiratory activity, was larger in W than in sleep, VT not being significantly different whatever the stage of consciousness. The results of this study show that in the kitten 1) unlike in the adult cat, ventilation and breathing pattern are similar in QS and in AS; 2) in sleep, the central inspiratory drive appears to be independent of the type of sleep; and 3) in wakefulness, the increase of the central inspiratory activity could be related to important excitatory inputs.     

Metabolic consequences of reduced frequency breathing during submaximal exercise at moderate altitude

The intention of this study was to determine the metabolic consequences of reduced frequency breathing (RFB) at total lung capacity (TLC) in competitive cyclists during submaximal exercise at moderate altitude (1520 m; barometric pressure, PB = 84.6 kPa; 635 mm Hg). Nine trained males performed an RFB exercise test (10 breaths.min-1) and a normal breathing exercise test at 75-85% of the ventilatory threshold intensity for 6 min on separate days. RFB exercise induced significant (P less than 0.05) decreases in ventilation (VE), carbon dioxide production (VCO2), respiratory exchange ratio (RER), ventilatory equivalent for O2 consumption (VE/VO2), arterial O2 saturation and increases in heart rate and venous lactate concentration, while maintaining a similar O2 consumption (VO2). During recovery from RFB exercise (spontaneous breathing) a significant (P less than 0.05) decreases in blood pH was detected along with increases in VE, VO2, VCO2, RER, and venous partial pressure of carbon dioxide. The results indicate that voluntary hypoventilation at TLC, during submaximal cycling exercise at moderate altitude, elicits systemic hypercapnia, arterial hypoxemia, tissue hypoxia and acidosis. These data suggest that RFB exercise at moderate altitude causes an increase in energy production from glycolytic pathways above that which occurs with normal breathing.     

Analysis of the mechanisms of expiratory asynchrony in pressure support ventilation: a mathematical approach.

A mathematical model was developed to analyze the mechanisms of expiratory asynchrony during pressure support ventilation (PSV). Solving the model revealed several results. 1) Ratio of the flow at the end of patient neural inspiration to peak inspiratory flow (VTI/V(peak)) during PSV is determined by the ratio of time constant of the respiratory system (tau) to patient neural inspiratory time (TI) and the ratio of the set pressure support (Pps) level to maximal inspiratory muscle pressure (Pmus max). 2) VTI/V(peak) is affected more by tau/TI than by Pps/Pmus max. VTI/V(peak) increases in a sigmoidal relationship to tau/TI. An increase in Pps/Pmus max slightly shifts the VTI/V(peak)-tau/TI curve to the right, i.e., VTI/V(peak) becomes lower as Pps/Pmus max increases at the same tau/TI. 3) Under the selected adult respiratory mechanics, VTI/V(peak) ranges from 1 to 85% and has an excellent linear correlation with tau/TI. 4) In mechanical ventilators, single fixed levels of the flow termination criterion will always have chances of both synchronized termination and asynchronized termination, depending on patient mechanics. An increase in tau/TI causes more delayed and less premature termination opportunities. An increase in Pps/Pmus max narrows the synchronized zone, making inspiratory termination predisposed to be in asynchrony. Increasing the expiratory trigger sensitivity of a ventilator shifts the synchronized zone to the right, causing less delayed and more premature termination. Automation of expiratory trigger sensitivity in future mechanical ventilators may also be possible. In conclusion, our model provides a useful tool to analyze the mechanisms of expiratory asynchrony in PSV.     

Effect of heat acclimation on heat shock protein 72 and interleukin-10 in humans.

Heat acclimation (HA) results in whole body adaptations that increase heat tolerance, and in addition, HA may also result in protective cellular adaptations. We hypothesized that, after HA, basal intracellular heat shock protein (HSP) 72 and extracellular IL-10 levels would increase, while extracellular HSP72 levels decrease. Ten male and two female subjects completed a 10-day exercise/HA protocol (100-min exercise bout at 56% of maximum O(2) uptake in a 42.5 degrees C DB, 27.9% RH environment); subjects exhibited classic adaptations that accompany HA. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) were isolated before and after each acclimation session on days 1, 6, and 10; plasma and serum were collected before and after exercise on the 1st and 10th day of HA. SDS-PAGE was used to determine PBMC HSP72 levels during HA, and ELISA was used to measure plasma IL-10 and serum HSP72 concentrations. The increase in PBMC HSP72 from pre- to postexercise on the 1st day of HA was not significant (mean +/- SD, 1.0 +/- 0 vs. 1.6 +/- 0.6 density units). Preexercise HSP72 levels on day 1 were significantly lower compared with the pre- and postexercise samples on days 6 and 10 (mean +/- SD, day 6: 2.1 +/- 1.0 and 2.2 +/- 1.0, day 10: 2.0 +/- 1.3 and 2.2 +/- 1.0 density units, respectively, P < 0.05). There were no differences in plasma IL-10 and serum HSP72 postexercise or after 10 days of HA. The sustained elevation of HSP72 from days 6 to 10 may be evidence of a cellular adaptation to HA that contributes to improved heat tolerance and reduced heat illness risk.     

Metabolic effects of exposure to hypoxia plus cold at rest and during exercise in humans

To determine effects on metabolic responses, subjects were exposed to four environmental conditions for 90 min at rest followed by 30 min of exercise: breathing room air with an ambient temperature of 25 degrees C (NN); breathing room air with an ambient temperature of 8 degrees C (NC); hypoxia (induced by breathing 12% O2 in N2) with a neutral temperature (HN); and hypoxia in the cold (HC). Hypoxia increased heart rate (HR), systolic blood pressure (SBP), pulmonary ventilation (VE), respiratory exchange ratio (R), blood lactate, and perceived exertion during exercise while depressing rectal temperature (Tre) and O2 uptake (VO2). Cold exposure elevated SBP, diastolic blood pressure (DBP), VE, VO2, blood glucose, and blood glycerol but decreased HR, Tre, and R. Shivering and DBP were higher and Tre was lower in HC compared with NC. HR, SBP, VE, R, and lactate tended to be higher in HC compared with NC, whereas VO2 and blood glycerol tended to be depressed. These results suggest that cold exposure during hypoxia results in an increased reliance on shivering for thermogenesis at rest whereas, during exercise, heat loss is accelerated.