Plant transformation by coinoculation with a disarmed Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain and an Escherichia coli strain carrying mobilizable transgenes

Transformation of Nicotiana tabacum leaf explants was attempted with Escherichia coli as a DNA donor either alone or in combination with Agrobacterium tumefaciens. We constructed E. coli donor strains harboring either the promiscuous IncP-type or IncN-type conjugal transfer system and second plasmids containing the respective origins of transfer and plant-selectable markers. Neither of these conjugation systems was able to stably transform plant cells at detectable levels, even when VirE2 was expressed in the donor cells. However, when an E. coli strain expressing the IncN-type conjugation system was coinoculated with a disarmed A. tumefaciens strain, plant tumors arose at high frequencies. This was caused by a two-step process in which the IncN transfer system mobilized the entire shuttle plasmid from E. coli to the disarmed A. tumefaciens strain, which in turn processed the T-DNA and transferred it to recipient plant cells. The mobilizable plasmid does not require a broad-host-range replication origin for this process to occur, thus reducing its size and genetic complexity. Tumorigenesis efficiency was further enhanced by incubation of the bacterial strains on medium optimized for bacterial conjugation prior to inoculation of leaf explants. These techniques circumvent the need to construct A. tumefaciens strains containing binary vectors and could simplify the creation of transgenic plants.     

Agrobacterium tumefaciens transfers extremely long T-DNAs by a unidirectional mechanism.

During crown gall tumorigenesis, part of the Agrobacterium tumefaciens tumor-inducing (Ti) plasmid, the T-DNA, integrates into plant DNA. Direct repeats define the left and right ends of the T-DNA, but tumorigenesis requires only the right-hand repeat. Virulence (vir) genes act in trans to mobilize the T-DNA into plant cells. Transfer of T-DNA begins when the VirD endonuclease cleaves within the right-hand border repeat. Although the T-DNA right-border repeat promotes T-DNA transmission best in its normal orientation, an inverted right border exhibits reduced but significant activity. Two models may account for this diminished tumorigenesis. The right border may function bidirectionally, with strong activity only in its wild-type orientation, or it may promote T-DNA transfer in a unidirectional manner such that, with an inverted right border, transfer proceeds around the entire Ti plasmid before reaching the T-DNA. To determine whether a substantial portion of the Ti plasmid is transferred to plant cells, as predicted by the unidirectional-transfer hypothesis, we examined T-DNAs in tumors induced by strains containing a Ti plasmid with a right border inverted with respect to the T-DNA oncogenes. These tumors contained extremely long T-DNAs corresponding to most or all of the Ti plasmid. To test whether the right border can function bidirectionally, we inserted T-DNAs with either a properly oriented or an inverted right border into a specific site in the A. tumefaciens chromosome. A border situated to transfer the oncogenes first directed T-DNA transfer even from the bacterial chromosome, whereas a border in the opposite (inverted) orientation did not transfer the oncogenes to plant cells. Our results indicate that the right-border repeat functions in a unidirectional manner.     

Modification of T-DNA of nopaline Ti plasmid by intermediary vector and utilization of agrocin 84 sensitivity as simple criterion of conjugation transfer of modified Ti plasmid

The chloramphenicol resistance gene from pSa was introduced into T-DNA of pTi T37 of Agrobacterium tumefaciens by cointegration with intermediary plasmid based on pBR322. The resulting intermediary vector was mobilized to A. tumefaciens T37 by conjugative plasmid pRK2. The RK2 plasmid also forms contegrates with pTi due to the Tn3 transposon which was used for the mobilization of modified pTi into plasmid-less A. tumefaciens strain. Transconjugants were selected on the basis of their antibiotic resistance markers and tested for agrocin sensitivity as proof of Ti plasmid transfer. Agrocin sensitivity of tranconjugants together with chloramphenicol resistance was shown to be a sufficient and simple criterion of transfer of modified Ti plasmids. Agrobacterium strains with modified Ti plasmids showed decreased virulence in consequence of the presence of additional borderline sequence inside their T-DNA.     

A plasmid cloning system utilizing replication and packaging functions of the filamentous bacteriophage fd

DNA cloning vectors were developed which utilize the replication origin (ori) of bacteriophage fd for their propagation. These vectors depend on the expression of viral gene 2 that was inserted into phage lambda, which in turn was integrated into the host genome. The constitutive expression of gene 2 in the host cells is sufficient for the propagation of at least 100 pfd plasmids per cell. In addition to the fd ori, the pfd vectors carry various antibiotic-resistance genes and unique restriction sites. Some of these vectors have no homologies to commonly used pBR plasmids or to lambda DNA. The nucleotide sequence of the vectors can be deduced from published sequences. Large DNA inserts can be stably propagated in pfd vectors; these are more stable than similar DNA fragments cloned in intact genomes of filamentous bacteriophage. Inclusion of phage sequences required for efficient phage packaging and infection with a helper phage resulted in formation of phage particles containing single-stranded plasmid genomes. Growth at 42 degrees C without selective pressure results in loss of pfd plasmids.     

Intergeneric transfer and exchange recombination of restriction fragments cloned in pBR322: a novel strategy for the reversed genetics of the Ti plasmids of Agrobacterium tumefaciens

Transmission of ColE1/pMB1-derived plasmids, such as pBR322, from Escherichia coli donor strains was shown to be an efficient way to introduce these plasmids into Agrobacterium. This was accomplished by using E. coli carrying the helper plasmids pGJ28 and R64drd11 which provide the ColE1 mob functions and tra functions, respectively. For example, the broad host-range replication plasmid, pGV1150, a co-integrate plasmid between pBR322 and the W-type mini-Sa plasmid, pGV1106, was transmitted from E. coli to A. tumefaciens with a transfer frequency of 4.5 x 10(-3). As pBR322 clones containing pTiC58 fragments were unable to replicate in Agrobacterium, these clones were found in Agrobacterium only if the acceptor carried a Ti plasmid, thus allowing a co-integration of the pBR322 clones with the Ti plasmid by homology recombination. These observations were used to develop an efficient method for site-specific mutagenesis of the Ti plasmids. pTiC58 fragnents, cloned in pBR322, were mutagenized in vitro and transformed into E. coli. The mutant clones were transmitted from an E. coli donor strain containing pGJ28 and R64drd11 to an Agrobacterium containing a target Ti plasmid. Selecting for stable transfer of the mutant clone utilizing its antibiotic resistance marker(s) gave exconjugants that already contained a co-integrate plasmid between the mutant clone and the Ti plasmid. A second recombination can dissociate the co-integrate plasmid into the desired mutant Ti plasmid and a non-replicating plasmid formed by the vector plasmid pBR322 and the target Ti fragment. These second recombinants lose the second plasmid and they are identified by screening for the appropriate marker combination.     

A novel plasmid curing method using incompatibility of plant pathogenic Ti plasmids in Agrobacterium tumefaciens

Ti (Tumor inducing) plasmids in Agrobacterium tumefaciens can transfer their T-DNA region into dicotyledonous plants, in which the expression of T-DNA genes causes plant tumors and the production of bacterial nutrients, e.g., opines such as nopaline. Naturally occurring Ti plasmids (pTi) are difficult to cure by conventional curing methods because of their high stability. Here, we developed a novel curing method based on plasmid incompatibility. For this, a curing plasmid, pMGTrep1, was newly constructed and subsequently introduced into A. tumefaciens strains harboring pTi by conjugation with Escherichia coli harboring pMGTrep1. The conjugation yielded 32-99% nopaline non-utilizing agrobacterial transconjugants in which pMGTrep1 replaced pTi due to incompatibility. Then, pMGTrep1-less derivatives of the transconjugants are easily selected in the presence of sucrose because pMGTrep1 contains a sucrose-sensitive sacB gene. This efficient method is directly applicable for curing plasmids with the same incompatibility group and shoud also applicable to other types of plasmids in Agrobacterium groups, including A. rhizogenes, by replacing the rep gene region of the curing plasmid with that of the corresponding incompatibility.     

Trans-kingdom T-DNA transfer from Agrobacterium tumefaciens to Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

Agrobacterium tumefaciens transfers part of its tumour-inducing (Ti) plasmid, the transferred or T-DNA, to plants during tumourigenesis. This represents the only example of naturally occurring trans-kingdom transfer of genetic material. Here we report that A.tumefaciens can transfer its T-DNA not only to plant cells, but also to another eukaryote, namely the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The Ti plasmid virulence (vir) genes that mediate T-DNA transfer to plants were found to be essential for transfer to yeast as well. Transgenic S.cerevisiae strains were analysed for their T-DNA content. Results showed that T-DNA circles were formed in yeast with precise fusions between the left and right borders. Such T-DNA circles were stably maintained by the yeast if the replicator from the yeast 2 mu plasmid was present in the T-DNA. Integration of T-DNA in the S.cerevisiae genome was found to occur via homologous recombination. This contrasts with integration in the plant genome, where T-DNA integrates preferentially via illegitimate recombination. Our results thus suggest that the process of T-DNA integration is predominantly determined by host factors.     

Ti plasmid type affects T-DNA processing in Agrobacterium tumefaciens

Agrobacterium tumefaciens can transfer the T-DNA region of a Ti plasmid to a recipient plant cell. An accepted model that describes the T-DNA transfer mechanism proposes that single-stranded T-complexes are transferred to a recipient plant via a conjugation-like mechanism. This model has been based on examination of a limited number of Ti plasmids. In this study, the type of processed T-DNA molecule created from multiple Ti plasmids was determined. The form of the processed T-DNA was found to vary and was correlated with whether the T-DNA region was organized as a single continuous region or two adjacent regions.     

Limited-host-range plasmid of Agrobacterium tumefaciens: molecular and genetic analyses of transferred DNA.

A tumor-inducing (Ti) plasmid from a strain of Agrobacterium tumefaciens that induces tumors on only a limited range of plants was characterized and compared with the Ti plasmids from strains that induce tumors on a wide range of plants. Whereas all wide-host-range Ti plasmids characterized to date contain closely linked oncogenic loci within a single transferred DNA (T-DNA) region, homology to these loci is divided into two widely separated T-DNA regions on the limited-host-range plasmid. These two plasmid regions, TA-DNA and TB-DNA, are separated by approximately 25 kilobases of DNA which is not maintained in the tumor. The TA-DNA region resembles a deleted form of the wide-host-range TL-DNA and contains a region homologous to the cytokinin biosynthetic gene. However, a region homologous to the two auxin biosynthetic loci of the wide-host-range plasmid mapped within the TB-DNA region. These latter genes play an important role in tumor formation because mutations in these loci result in a loss of virulence on Nicotiana plants. Furthermore, the TB-DNA region alone conferred tumorigenicity onto strains with an intact set of vir genes. Our results suggest that factors within both the T-DNA and the vir regions contribute to the expression of host range in Agrobacterium species. There was a tremendous variation among plants in susceptibility to tumor formation by various A. tumefaciens strains. This variation occurred not only among different plant species, but also among different varieties of plants within the same genus.     

Genetic analysis of integration mediated by single T-DNA borders.

Transformation of plant cells by the T-DNA of the Ti plasmid of Agrobacterium tumefaciens depends in part upon a sequence adjacent to the right T-DNA end. When this sequence is absent, the T-DNA is almost avirulent; when it is present, DNA between it and the left T-DNA border region becomes integrated in plants. To investigate further this process of DNA transfer and integration, we introduced the right border region and the nopaline synthase (nos) gene of plasmid pTiC58 into a variety of new positions around Ti plasmids. The border region functioned when separated from the remainder of the T-DNA by almost 50 kilobases. It also worked when placed outside of the T-DNA region where there were no known left-border sequences with which to interact. Indeed, the nos gene could be transferred to plants even when no other Ti plasmid sequences were present on the same plasmid. These results may indicate that the sequence requirements for the left borders are not as stringent as those for the right borders. In addition, mutants with an extra copy of the right border region within their T-DNA were found to transfer or integrate only parts of the bacterial T-DNA region. It is possible that abnormally placed T-DNA borders interfere with the normal process of DNA transfer, integration, or both.     

The virD operon of Agrobacterium tumefaciens encodes a site-specific endonuclease

Tumor formation by Agrobacterium tumefaciens involves the transfer and integration of a defined segment (T-DNA) of tumor-inducing (Ti) plasmid DNA into the plant nuclear genome. A set of plasmid genes outside the T-DNA, the vir genes, are thought to mediate the transfer process. We report here that the virD operon encodes a site-specific endonuclease that cleaves at a unique site within each of the 24 bp direct repeats that flank the T-DNA. The endonuclease function was further localized to the 5' end of this operon by demonstrating that cleavage does not occur in virD mutant strains of Agrobacterium and that the 5' end of the virD operon is sufficient to direct cleavage in E. coli. Analysis of nucleotide sequence and protein data indicate that two proteins of 16.2 and 47.4 kd are involved.     

T-DNA fragments of hairy root plasmid pRi8196 are distantly related to octopine and nopaline Ti plasmid T-DNA

Agrobacterium Ti (tumor-inducing) and Ri (root-inducing) plasmids transform dicot plant cells by insertion of a specific plasmid sector called T-DNA (transferred DNA) into host plant nuclear DNA. The mannopine-type Ri plasmid pRi8196 contains four BamHI fragments that encompass core T-DNA. We report Southern hybridization studies that show that these four fragments have no strong homology to octopine-, nopaline-, or agropine-type Ti plasmids. We detected and mapped very weak homology regions, most of which are assignable to opine synthase or opine catabolic functions on the Ti plasmid. We found no homology between Ri T-DNA and the region of Ti T-DNA that encodes tumor morphology functions.     

Structure and function of root-inducing (Ri) plasmids and their relation to tumor-inducing (Ti) plasmids

The abilities of Agrobacterium tumefaciens and A. rhizogenes to transform dicotyle-dons and cause crown gall and hairy root disease are caused by the presence of tumor inducing (Ti) and root inducing (Ri) plasmids. During transformation plasmid T-DNA (transferred DNA) is inserted into the plant genome. The T-region is flanked by 25 bp direct repeats, which are essential for transfer. The T-regions contain oncogenes that are expressed in the plants. Some of these code for enzymes that synthesize auxin or cytokinin. Another type, present in Ri plasmids only, appears to impose a high hormone sensitivity on the infected tissue. The T-DNA also contains genes for enzymes synthesizing opines, which the bacteria catabolize. The T-DNA transfer is initiated by the induction of genes in the virulence (vir) region of the plasmid by phenolic compounds secreted by wounded tissue. The products of the vir -genes and of chromosomal genes mediate transfer of T-DNA to the plant cells. Crown gall disease is caused by production of auxin and cytokinin by the transferred T-DNA. The T-DNA of Ri plasmids codes for at least three genes that each can induce root formation, and that together cause hairy root formation from plant tissue. Current results indicate that the products of these genes induce a potential for increased auxin sensitivity that is expressed when the transformed cells are subjected to a certain level of auxin. After this stage the transformed roots can be grown in culture without exogenous supply of hormones.     

Expression of Agrobacterium nopaline-specific VirD1, VirD2, and VirC1 proteins and their requirement for T-strand production in E. coli

Induction of Ti plasmid virulence (vir) genes during early stages of the genetic transformation of plant cells by Agrobacterium tumefaciens results in several molecular events that are involved in generating a transferable T-DNA copy. These events include site-specific nicking at the T-DNA borders and synthesis of free, unipolar, linear, single-stranded copies of the T-DNA (T-strands). Here E. coli was used as a heterologous cell to assay the requirements for T-strand synthesis. Cells of E. coli harbored two compatible plasmids, one containing coding sequences overlapping the virC and virD regions of the nopaline Ti plasmid, and a second plasmid containing a T-DNA region. The amount of vir proteins produced was varied by placing their expression under the control of either native Agrobacterium, tac, or T7 promoters. The data show that VirD1 and VirD2 proteins are absolutely essential for T-strand production in E. coli, and the relative amounts of these polypeptides produced correlate with the amounts of T-strand observed. When VirD1 and VirD2 products are limiting, the VirC1 protein increases T-strand production. The yield of T-strands also varies as a function of the plasmid vector used to clone the T-DNA region substrate; the same T-DNA cloned into pLAFR1 produces more T-strands than that cloned into the higher copy number plasmid pACYC184. In summary, VirD1 and VirD2 proteins are the minimal requirements for T-strand production; however, other factors such as VirC1, the relative concentration of VirD1, VirD2, and the T-DNA substrate, and possibly additional functions (e.g., those specified by pLAFR1) influence the efficiency of T-strand production. Additional results regarding the requirements for expression of VirD1 and VirD2 polypeptides are presented.     

vir-induced recombination in Agrobacterium. Physical characterization of precise and imprecise T-circle formation

Induction of Ti plasmid virulence (vir) gene expression during the early stages of plant cell transformation by Agrobacterium tumefaciens initiates the generation of several T-DNA-associated molecular events: (1) site-specific nicks at T-DNA border sequences (border nicks); (2) free, unipolar, linear, single-stranded T-DNA copies (T-strands); and (3) double-stranded, circular T-DNA molecules (T-circles). The first two T-DNA products have been detected in A. tumefaciens, while T-circles have only been detected following Escherichia coli transformation or transduction. The relationship between the three events has not been evaluated since the genesis of T-circles in A. tumefaciens has not been clarified. Evidence is presented here that T-circles are not an artefact of E. coli transformation, but are present as free, double-stranded molecules in A. tumefaciens resulting from site-specific reciprocal recombination between the left and right 25-base-pair border sequences that flank the T-DNA. Furthermore, the frequency of T-circle formation correlates with the frequency of formation of its reciprocal product, the Ti plasmid deleted in the T-DNA region. Several types of recombinant T-DNA circles arise after activation of vir gene expression, a major class representing precise site-specific recombination between both T-DNA borders, and a minor class representing recombination events either utilizing only one T-DNA border sequence and other Ti plasmid sequences, or utilizing only Ti plasmid sequences (i.e. no T-DNA borders). Nucleotide sequence analyses show that when one (nicked) border recombines with other Ti plasmid sequences, a small stretch (16 to 17 base-pairs) of local homology suffices to allow crossing over.     

Characterization of conjugal transfer functions of Agrobacterium tumefaciens Ti plasmid pTiC58.

Physical characterization of 13 transposon Tn5 insertions within the agrocinopine-independent, transfer-constitutive Ti plasmid pTiC58Trac identified three separate loci essential for conjugation of this nopaline/agrocinopine A + B-type Ti plasmid. Complementation analysis with relevant subcloned DNAs indicated that the three physically separated blocks of conjugal genes constitute distinct complementation groups. Two independent Tn5 insertions within the wild-type, agrocinopine-dependent, repressed pTiC58 plasmid resulted in constitutive expression of conjugal transfer. These two insertions were physically indistinguishable and could not be complemented in trans. However, the Trac phenotype resulted when the Tn5-mutated fragment cointegrated into the wild-type Ti plasmid. While the spontaneous Trac mutant Ti plasmids were also derepressed for agrocinopine catabolism, those generated by Tn5 insertions remained inducible, indicating that this apparent cis-acting site is different from that affected in the spontaneous mutants. No chromosomal Tn5 insertion mutations were obtained that affected conjugal transfer. An octopine-type Ti plasmid, resident in different Agrobacterium tumefaciens chvB mutants, transferred at normal frequencies, demonstrating that this virulence locus affecting plant cell binding is not required for Ti plasmid conjugation. None of our conjugal mutants limited tumor development on Kalanchoe diagremontiana. Known lesions in pTiC58 vir loci had no effect on conjugal transfer of this Ti plasmid. These results show that pTiC58 Ti plasmid conjugal transfer occurs by functions independent of those required for transfer of DNA to plant cells.     

The hypervirulence of Agrobacterium tumefaciens A281 is encoded in a region of pTiBo542 outside of T-DNA.

We used a binary-vector strategy to study the hypervirulence of Agrobacterium tumefaciens A281, an L,L-succinamopine strain. Strain A281 is hypervirulent on several solanaceous plants. We constructed plasmids (pCS65 and pCS277) carrying either the transferred DNA (T-DNA) or the remainder of the tumor-inducing (Ti) plasmid (pEHA101) from this strain and tested each of these constructs in trans with complementary regions from heterologous Ti plasmids. Hypervirulence on tobacco could be reconstructed in a bipartite strain with the L,L-succinamopine T-DNA and the vir region on separate plasmids. pEHA101 was able to complement octopine T-DNA to hypervirulence on tobacco and tomato plants. Nopaline T-DNA was complemented better on tomato plants by pEHA101 than it was by its own nopaline vir region, but not to hypervirulence. L,L-Succinamopine T-DNA could not be complemented to hypervirulence on tobacco and tomato plants with either heterologous vir region. From these results we suggest that the hypervirulence of strain A281 is due to non-T-DNA sequences on the Ti plasmid.     

Conjugation in Agrobacterium tumefaciens in the absence of plant tissue.

A general, reliable conjugation system for Agrobacterium tumefaciens in the absence of plant tissue is described in which A. tumefaciens can serve either as the donor or recipient of plasmid deoxyribonucleic acid with reasonable efficiency. Plasmid RP4 was transferred from Escherichia coli to A. tumefaciens and from strain of A. tumefaciens. Both RP4 and the A. tumefaciens virulence-associated plasmids were detected by alkaline sucrose gradients in A. tumefaciens strains A6 and C58 after mating with E. coli J53(RP4). The pathogenicity (tumor foramtion) of strains A6 and C58 and the sensitivity of strain C58 to bacteriocin 84 were unaffected by the acquistion of RP4 by the Agrobacterium strains. Plasmid R1drd-19 was not transferred to A. tumefaciens. Transformation experiments with plasmid deoxyribonucleic acid were unsuccessful, even though, in the case of RP4, conjugation studies showed taht the deoxyribonucleic acid was compatible with that of the recipient strains.     

TraG from RP4 and TraG and VirD4 from Ti plasmids confer relaxosome specificity to the conjugal transfer system of pTiC58

Plasmid conjugation systems are composed of two components, the DNA transfer and replication system, or Dtr, and the mating pair formation system, or Mpf. During conjugal transfer an essential factor, called the coupling protein, is thought to interface the Dtr, in the form of the relaxosome, with the Mpf, in the form of the mating bridge. These proteins, such as TraG from the IncP1 plasmid RP4 (TraG(RP4)) and TraG and VirD4 from the conjugal transfer and T-DNA transfer systems of Ti plasmids, are believed to dictate specificity of the interactions that can occur between different Dtr and Mpf components. The Ti plasmids of Agrobacterium tumefaciens do not mobilize vectors containing the oriT of RP4, but these IncP1 plasmid derivatives lack the trans-acting Dtr functions and TraG(RP4). A. tumefaciens donors transferred a chimeric plasmid that contains the oriT and Dtr genes of RP4 and the Mpf genes of pTiC58, indicating that the Ti plasmid mating bridge can interact with the RP4 relaxosome. However, the Ti plasmid did not mobilize transfer from an IncQ relaxosome. The Ti plasmid did mobilize such plasmids if TraG(RP4) was expressed in the donors. Mutations in traG(RP4) with defined effects on the RP4 transfer system exhibited similar phenotypes for Ti plasmid-mediated mobilization of the IncQ vector. When provided with VirD4, the tra system of pTiC58 mobilized plasmids from the IncQ relaxosome. However, neither TraG(RP4) nor VirD4 restored transfer to a traG mutant of the Ti plasmid. VirD4 also failed to complement a traG(RP4) mutant for transfer from the RP4 relaxosome or for RP4-mediated mobilization from the IncQ relaxosome. TraG(RP4)-mediated mobilization of the IncQ plasmid by pTiC58 did not inhibit Ti plasmid transfer, suggesting that the relaxosomes of the two plasmids do not compete for the same mating bridge. We conclude that TraG(RP4) and VirD4 couples the IncQ but not the Ti plasmid relaxosome to the Ti plasmid mating bridge. However, VirD4 cannot couple the IncP1 or the IncQ relaxosome to the RP4 mating bridge. These results support a model in which the coupling proteins specify the interactions between Dtr and Mpf components of mating systems.