Purified mouse mammary tumor and lymphoid cells in immune assays

Summary Tumor and lymphoid cell components from primary mammary adenocarcinomas of C3H/He mice were isolated simultaneously by velocity gradients. Viable tumor cells were obtained in sufficient numbers to test their in vivo and in vitro growth. Isolated tumor cells grew in 97% of inoculated syngeneic animals. In six assays with different tumors the effects of tumor-associated lymphoid cells (TAL) on in vivo tumor growth varied, enhancing in three and delaying in two experiments. Isolated tumor cells from animals with enhancing TAL grew faster in nonirradiated mice, whereas tumor cells from animals with inhibitory TAL grew better in irradiated animals. Isolated tumor cells also proliferated in cell culture, where they averaged 35% primary plating efficiency. Separated tumor cells were used in short-term ⁵¹Cr-release assays with TAL, tumor-bearer lymph node and spleen effectors. Cytotoxicity was detected in only five of 25 assays. In no case was there killing by lymphocyte populations from normal animals. In the present report we describe a technique for the isolation of viable tumor and lymphoid cells from murine adenocarcinomas that allows study of interactions between these populations from the original tumor-bearing host.Postdoctoral fellow of the Fogarty International Foundation. Present address: Department of Surgery, Harvard Medical School and Brigham & Women's Hospital, Boston, MA 02215, USA     

Adherent cells in tumor immunity

The present studies explored the role of adherent cells in tumor immunity. Lymph node cells from mice bearing large tumors appeared to be maximally stimulated in vivo and incapable of further stimulation by cells of the same tumor in vitro. Removal of the adherent cell population resulted in a marked decrease in the spontaneous background activity of the remaining nonadherent cells and allowed these cells to undergo stimulation when cultured in the presence of mitomycin-blocked tumor cells. The role of the adherent cell in the maintenance of a state of continuous stimulation was further elucidated by experiments in which lymph node cell populations were reconstituted from the adherent and nonadherent subpopulations. It was also shown that adherent lymphoid cells from tumor-bearing mice, but not from normal mice, were capable of stimulating tumor-immune lymphocytes in a manner similar to intact mitomycin-blocked tumor cells.     

Lymphocyte function in experimental African trypanosomiasis. III. Loss of lymph node cell responsiveness

The relationship between immunosuppression and suppressor cell activity in the lymphoid organs of animals with experimental African trypanosomiasis has been examined further. In the present study we measure the primary in vitro PFC response to SRBC by spleen and lymph node cells from Trypanosoma rhodesiense infected or drug-cured C57BL/6 mice. Passive transfer experiments with this culture system tested for the presence or absence of suppressor cells. We demonstrate that infected mice exhibit immunosuppression in the spleen cell population several weeks before becoming suppressed at the level of the lymph node cell populations. Although suppressor cells are present in immunosuppressed spleen cell populations, suppression of lymph node cell responsiveness was not attributable to suppressor cells detectable withi, lymph nodes. After Berenil treatment of terminally infected mice immunocompetence was restored gradually, first to the lymph node cells and subsequently to the spleen cell population. Recovery of spleen cell responsiveness was attributable to the loss of detectable suppressor cell activity within spleens. These results demonstrate that there is anatomical restriction of the suppressor cell population to trypanosome-infected mouse spleen and that loss of immunocompetence in the lymph nodes may be due to factors unrelated to suppressor cell effects.     

Augmentation of immune response to syngeneic fibrosarcoma T241 with in vivo protection

Summary Lewis T241 fibrosarcoma, a syngeneic tumor in C57 BL/6J mice, was found to be poorly immunogenic. When tumor-bearing animals (TBA) were challenged with tumor cells either concomitantly or after excision of a growing tumor no protection was observed. In vivo (Winn) neutralization assays also showed a lack of tumor immunogenicity. However, in vitro studies showed that a significant proliferative response could be elicited from the spleen cells of TBA when these cells were cultured with either mitomycin-C-treated tumor cells or KCl tumor extract. Similarly, macrophage migration inhibition factor (MIF) was produced by TBA spleen cells upon incubation with KCl tumor extract, but no cell-mediated cytotoxicity to T241 target cells was observed with various lymphoid cell populations at any stage of tumor growth. Immunization of syngeneic animals with Vibrio cholerae neuraminidase(VCN)-treated, irradiated tumor cells alone or admixed with Freund's complete adjuvant (FCA) resulted in decreased tumor growth and fewer pulmonary metastases following challenge with 10⁶ tumor cells. No complete tumor rejection was observed. In contrast, 13 of 16 animals immunized with irradiated tumor cells admixed with FCA rejected 10⁵ tumor cells. Animals that grew tumors had significantly reduced tumor growths and pulmonary metastases. Lymph node and peritoneal exudate cells (PEC) of immunized animals showed significant cytotoxicity to T241 cells.     

Nonspecific inhibition of tumor growth in vivo by admixed allogeneic tumor-sensitized lymphoid cells and identical inactivated allogeneic tumor cells.

With the in vivo tumor neutralization test (Winn test), growth of a transplanted (KMT-17) from Wistar-King-Aptekman rats was inhibited by allogeneic tumor (AH-66 from Donryu rats)-sensitized syngeneic lymphoid cells admixed with mitomycin C (MMC)-treated AH-66 cells. The observed tumor inhibition may be immunologically nonspecific, since no cross-antigens were detected by membrane immunofluorescence on the surfaces of KMT-17 and AH-66 cells. Close contact among KMT-17, AH-66-sensitized lymphoid cells and MMC-treated AH-66 cells was required for the inhibition of KMT-17 growth. AH-66 cells pretreated with formalin or ultrasonication lost tumor inhibitory activity when they were admixed with AH-66-sensitized lymphoid cells, and only MMC-treatment effectively preserved the tumor inhibitory activity of AH-66 cells. The sensitized spleen cells, draining lymph node, or peripheral blood cells inhibited tumor growth when they were admixed with MMC-treated AH-66 cells, whereas nucleated cells from bone marrow, thymus, or distal lymph node did not. Growths of KMT-17 were inhibited by admixed sensitized spleen cells and MMC-treated AH-66 even when pre-irradiated rats were used as recipients.     

Mechanisms of tumor-induced immunosuppression: evidence for contact-dependent T cell suppression by monocytes.

BACKGROUND: The progressive growth of tumors in mice is accompanied by down-regulation of specific T cell responses. The factors involved in this suppression are not completely understood. Here, we have developed a model to examine the role of host immune effector cells in the inhibition of T cell function. In this model, progressive growth of a colon carcinoma line, CT26, is accompanied by loss of T cell response to alloantigens in both cytolytic and proliferation assays. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The CT26 tumor was inoculated into BALB/c syngeneic mice. Tumor growth, cytolytic T cell responses, lymphocyte proliferation, and flow cytometric analysis was performed in tumor-bearing animals 7 or 28 days after tumor inoculation. RESULTS: Spleen cells from tumor-bearing mice were found to suppress the proliferative response of spleen cells from normal mice to alloantigens. Examination of the spleen cell population by FACS analysis revealed an increase in the percentage of monocytes as defined by expression of CD11b, the Mac-1 antigen. Removal of the Mac-1-positive cells from the tumor-bearing hosts spleen relieved suppression of the tumor-bearing mouse spleen cell proliferative response to alloantigens, and addition of the Mac-1-positive enriched cells suppressed proliferation of normal T cells in response to alloantigens. Cell contact was required for this inhibition. CONCLUSIONS: Tumor induction of suppressive monocytes plays an important role in the general immunosuppression noted in animals bearing CT26 tumors. Identification of the mechanisms responsible for this effect and reversal of tumor-induced macrophage suppression may facilitate efforts to develop effective immunotherapy for malignancy.     

Effect of tumor immunity on the distribution of labeled lymphoid cells in tumor-challenged mice

The distribution of ⁵¹Cr-labeled lymphoid cells from normal mice and mice immunized against a tumor were compared after intravenous inoculation of the labeled cells into normal syngeneic recipients. Spleen cell preparations from immune donors contained increased percentages of spleen and bone marrow-seeking cells, thus suggesting expansion of these cell populations when immunity to a tumor exists. Homing of labeled normal cells in tumor cell-injected normal animals was somewhat different from that seen in tumor cell-inoculated mice that were immunized against the tumor. In the latter case, accumulations of lymph node and spleen cells in recipient lymph nodes and bone marrow were consistently lower. In contrast, lymphoid cells from animals immunized against the tumor were found to accumulate in virtually the same percentages in lymphoid organs of normal and immune recipients. The behavior of lymphoid cell populations from thymus or bone marrow that consist mainly of precursor cells was unaffected by presence of malignancy and/or tumor immunity.     

Characterization of bovine mononuclear cell populations with natural cytolytic activity against bovine herpesvirus 1-infected cells

Freshly isolated or overnight cultured peripheral blood mononuclear cells from immune or nonimmune animals had natural cytolytic activity against bovine herpesvirus 1 (BHV-1)-infected tumor target cells. No lysis was demonstrated against tumor target cells alone. This natural cytolytic activity was present in mononuclear cells from the spleen, lymph node, and peripheral blood but little or no cytolytic activity was detected in bone marrow or thymus cells. When monoclonal antibodies and complement to deplete bovine mononuclear cell subpopulations from the nonadherent cells were used, results indicated the effector cell was not a T cell, B cell, or activated monocyte. From nonadherent populations separated on density gradients, it was determined that the effector cells were large, low density mononuclear cells. These results indicate the nonadherent effector cells mediating lysis of BHV-1-infected xenogeneic adherent target cells were large null lymphocytes and/or immature monocytes.     

Modulation of the immune response to tumors by a novel synthetic compound, (4R)-3-benzoyl-N-[(1R)-1-phenylethyl]-4-thiazolidinecarboxamide (RS-0481)

Summary RS-0481, (4R)-3-benzoyl-N-[(1R)-phenylethyl]-4-thiazolidinecarboxamide, is a compound that can re-establish the function of certain lymphoid cell populations impaired by the presence of a growing tumor in an animal. The compound markedly augmented the tumorspecific cytotoxic T lymphocytes,Tdth (delayed-type hypersensitivity T cells), and the nonspecific lymphokine-activated-killer-cell-like cell responses. It also enhanced the tumor-inhibitory effect of macrophages in tumor-bearing mice, but not in normal mice, indicating that it enhances the antitumor immune responses. Lymphocytes from RS-0481-treated tumor-bearing mice released significantly higher amounts of macrophage-activating factor(s) (MAF) and interleukin-2(IL-2)-like factors in culture compared with lymphocytes from untreated animals. Also, sera from treated tumor bearers showed elevated colony-stimulating factor (CSF) activity. Although the compound did not influence the factor-producing activity in mice without tumor, it enhanced the responsiveness of their bone marrow cells, T cells, and macrophages to CSF, IL-2, and MAF. It seems therefore possible that the compound enhances the responsiveness of immunocompetent cells to cytokines, resulting in a marked augmentation of antitumor T cell responses in tumor-bearing mice. Consistently it inhibited the development of lymph node metastasis of transplanted X5563 plasmacytoma, and we showed that T cells play a decisive role in this inhibition. The compound also counteracted the development of suppressor T cell activity in the spleen of tumor-bearing mice.     

In situ lymphoid cells of mouse mammary tumors. IV. Comparison of functional activity of lymphoid cells separated from mammary tumors to that of spleen and lymph node cells of tumor-sensitized mice.

Lymphoid cells isolated form several types of mouse mammary tumors are capable of stimulating tumor cell growth or survival in MCT assays. Lymph node and spleen cells of mice bearing such a tumor are specifically cytotoxic to the tumor cells. Surgical removal of the tumor is followed in 4 to 7 days by the appearance of stimulatory capacity in spleens and lymph nodes. By day 10, cytotoxic cells specific for the sensitizing tumor are again detected. These reach a peak on day 13. By day 17 no reactivity is detectable. The functional distribution of tumor-reactive lymphoid cells is different between tumor masses and peripheral lymphoid organs.     

Incomplete differentiation of antigen-specific CD8 T cells in tumor-draining lymph nodes

CD8 T cells lacking effector activity have been recovered from lymphoid organs of mice and patients with progressing tumors. We explored the basis for lack of effector activity in tumor-bearing mice by evaluating Ag presentation and CD8 T cell function in lymphoid organs over the course of tumor outgrowth. Early after tumor injection, cross-presentation by bone marrow-derived APC was necessary for T cell activation, inducing proliferation and differentiation into IFN-gamma-producing, cytolytic effectors. At later stages of outgrowth, tumor metastasized to draining lymph nodes. Both cross- and direct presentation occurred, but T cell differentiation induced by either modality was incomplete (proliferation without cytokine production). T cells within tumor-infiltrated nodes differentiated appropriately if Ag was presented by activated, exogenous dendritic cells. Thus, activated T cells lacking effector function develop through incomplete differentiation in the lymph nodes of late-stage tumor-bearing mice, rather than through suppression of previously differentiated cells.     

Immunosuppression in a murine B cell leukemia (BCL1): role of an adherent cell in the suppression of primary in vitro antibody responses

The ability of lymph node cells from mice bearing the BCL1 tumor to respond in vitro to mitogens, allogeneic cells, and both TI and TD antigens was investigated. The lymph nodes of such mice are not invaded with tumor cells and contain normal numbers of T and B cells. Nevertheless, at the peak of tumor burden in the spleen and blood (approximately 8 to 12 wk after injection with tumor cells), the lymph node cells from the tumor-bearing mice display markedly decreased responsiveness both to allogeneic cells and to antigens. In addition, small numbers of lymph node cells from the tumor-bearing mice suppress primary antibody responses of normal lymph node cells. This nonspecific suppression of antibody responses is mediated by a G-10 Sephadex adherent, non-T, non-B cell present in the nodes of the tumor-bearing mice. Since the BCL1 tumor model is in many respects similar to the prolymphocytic type of human chronic lymphocytic leukemia, the present results may be helpful in elucidating the mechanisms underlying the in vivo immunosuppression associated with lymphocytic neoplasms in humans.     

The effect of indomethacin on the activation and effector function of suppressor cells from tumor-bearing mice

Summary The spleens of mice with large M-1 fibrosarcomas contain two populations of suppressor cells with the properties of macrophages and T cells. In this study, we tested the effect of indomethacin on suppressor cell activation and effector function. Neither the activation nor the effector function of the suppressor macrophages was inhibited by indomethacin, and the activity of suppressor macrophages correlated with the tumor size. In contrast, the treatment of tumor-bearing mice with indomethacin from the day of injection of tumor cells completely blocked the in vivo activation of suppressor T cells. Indomethacin did not, however, depress suppressor T cell activity if mice were treated only during the third week of tumor growth. The effector function of the suppressor T cells, as assessed in mixing assays, was partially blocked by indomethacin, while selective suppression by low-molecular-weight factors was completely blocked if indomethacin was present in the cultures. Furthermore, the in vitro activation of suppressor cells by soluble factors secreted by tumor-bearer spleen cells was completely blocked by indomethacin, and this inhibition was reversed by prostaglandin E₁. These data are consistent with the hypothesis that prostaglandins are involved in the activation, but not the effector function, of tumor-activated suppressor T cells.     

The antimetastatic function of concomitant antitumor immunity. II. Evidence that the generation of Ly-1+2+ effector T cells temporarily causes the destruction of already disseminated tumor cells

Progressive growth of the P815 mastocytoma in an immunocompetent host evokes the generation of an antitumor immune response that can be measured in terms of the production of cytolytic Ly-1+2+ T cells in the draining lymph node and spleen. This immunity, designated concomitant immunity, is present on day 6 of tumor growth, peaks on day 9, and decays progressively thereafter. It fails to develop in mice made T cell deficient by thymectomy and lethal whole-body gamma-radiation, and reconstituted with syngeneic bone marrow cells (TXB mice). Employment of a mouse survival assay, capable of enumerating metastatic P815 cells in cell suspensions, showed that the P815 tumor metastasizes to the draining lymph node and spleen at the same rate in normal and TXB mice for the first 6 days of growth of an intradermal P815 tumor. By day 6 of tumor growth there were approximately 10(3) P815 cells in the draining lymph node in both types of mice. However, during the generation of concomitant immunity between days 6 and 9, the number of metastatic P815 cells in the draining lymph nodes and spleens of normal tumor-bearing mice declined by nearly 90%. After day 12, however, the number of tumor cells in the nodes and spleens increased concordantly with the decay of concomitant immunity. These findings, together with the demonstration that T cell-deficient mice failed to restrain the number of metastatic P815 cells in the draining lymph node and spleen, suggest that concomitant immunity is an important defense mechanism against the development of systemic disease. Additional evidence consistent with this interpretation was provided by studies which showed that adoptive immunization with spleen cells from concomitant immune donors significantly prolonged the median survival time of TXB tumor-bearing mice by destroying a substantial proportion of P815 tumor cells already seeded in the draining lymph node. Adoptive immunization also delayed the appearance of metastatic tumor cells in the spleen.     

Locoregional therapy with polyethylene-glycol-modified interleukin-2 of an intradermally growing hepatocellular carcinoma in the guinea pig induces T-cell-mediated antitumor activity

Therapy with repeated intratumoral and perilymphatic administration of relatively low doses of polyethylene-glycol(PEG)-modified interleukin-2 (IL-2) in the syngeneic guinea pig line 10 (L10) hepatocarcinoma results in significant local tumor growth inhibition and a delay in development of regional lymph node metastases of more than 3 weeks when compared to controls. Occasionally animals are cured of tumor. The mechanism of this antitumor activity was studied. The antitumor activity of locoregionally administered PEG-IL-2 was abrogated by pretreatment with polyclonal anti-thymocyte serum, indicating that the observed tumor growth inhibition was a T-cell-mediated phenomenon. Besides the locoregional tumor growth inhibition, a systemic effect was recorded as the growth of a second tumor cell inoculum at the contralateral side was inhibited as well. Furthermore, those animals cured after PEG-IL-2 therapy developed specific immunity against the L10 tumor and this immunity could be transferred to naive animals by spleen cells. Immunohistological observations of the tumor site revealed a slight increase of helper and cytotoxic T cell subpopulations after PEG-IL-2 therapy. More pronounced, however, was the rise in number of eosinophilic granulocytes present in the stroma surrounding the tumor cells. Involvement of cytotoxic cells in the antitumor effects of PEG-IL-2 could not be demonstrated: regional lymph node cells and spleen cells obtained immediately after therapy (day 15) or on day 21 showed no cytotoxic activity in vitro against L10, K562, Daudi and line 1 (L1) target cells.In conclusion, locoregional therapy with PEG-IL-2 induced a systemic T-cell-mediated antitumor response. As no cytotoxic T cell activity was measured, however, the underlying mechanism is most likely a T-helper response. Eosinophils at the tumor site may be tumoricidal but further experiments must reveal the role of these cells in the PEG-IL-2-induced tumor regression.     

The antimetastatic function of concomitant antitumor immunity. I. Host Ly-1+2+ effector T cells prevent the enumeration of metastatic tumor cells in a biological assay

A mouse survival assay was evaluated for its suitability to enumerate metastatic P815 tumor cells in the draining lymph node and spleen of a B6D2 F1 (H-2b X H-2d) host bearing a primary intradermal P815 tumor. The mouse survival assay is based on the linear relationship between the log10 number of P815 tumor cells (H-2d) injected i.p. into mice and their mean survival time. It was found that the assay is capable of quantifying as few as 10 tumor cells in lymph node and spleen, but only if cell suspensions of these organs are treated with anti-H-2b serum and complement, in order to selectively destroy H-2bd host cells. This was necessary because host cells from the lymph node and spleen of a tumor-bearing host possessed antitumor functions, in that they were capable of destroying the H-2d P815 tumor cells when admixed with the tumor cells and injected i.p. into 800-rad irradiated test recipients. The kinetics of acquisition and loss of host cells with antitumor function and the Ly phenotype of these host cells suggest that they are the same cells that give the tumor-bearing host the capacity to express concomitant immunity against a tumor implant.     

Regulation by adherent cells of macromolecular synthesis in lymphocyte populations.

The role of adherent cells in the regulation of lymphocyte DNA, RNA, and protein synthesis was investigated. Splenic adherent cells suppressed DNA synthesis of spleen cells. The reverse was true of lymph node adherent cells, i.e., DNA synthesis was less in the absence of adherent cells. Histocompatibility was not required for interaction between adherent and nonadherent cells. The regulatory adherent cell in either case was not θ positive. Removal of splenic adherent cells decreased RNA and protein synthesis of nonadherent spleen cells. RNA synthesis by lymph node cells increased when adherent cells were removed, but protein synthesis was lower. Autoradiographic analysis revealed that removal of adherent spleen cells allowed a greater number of nonadherent cells to respond to the presence of mitogen. Adherent cells were observed to regulate DNA synthesis of B lymphocytes also. Lymph node adherent cells amplified DNA synthesis in both nonadherent spleen and lymph node cells, while splenic adherent cells suppressed splenic nonadherent cells but stimulated nonadherent lymph node cells. We feel the data are compatible with the idea that at least two functionally distinct adherent cell populations exist. A mechanism is suggested to explain the data.     

Spontaneous helper factor production by nonadherent rabbit lymphoid cells and its feedback regulation by adherent cells

Normal, unstimulated rabbit lymphoid cells, when depleted of adherent cells, produced soluble helper factor activity that augmented antibody formation by rabbit spleen cells primed against sheep red blood cells (SRBC). Adherent cells inhibited the production of the helper factor by nonadherent cells via a soluble product. Thus unseparated (adherent cell-containing) appendix, lymph node, and spleen cell cultures did not produce the helper factor. On the other hand, the activity of the helper factor required the presence of adherent cells in the assay cultures. Peritoneal exudate cells, predominantly esterase positive, also inhibited the production of the helper factor if they were first exposed to the helper factor-containing culture supernatant. These results imply that a helper factor may participate in the feedback regulation of its own production via an adherent cell population.     

Cross presentation of antigen on MHC class II via the draining lymph node after corneal transplantation in mice

We investigated Ag trafficking from the cornea and T effector cell activation in secondary lymphoid tissue after corneal transplantation. In preliminary experiments, the central cornea was shown to contain a population of CD45(+), CD11b(+), CD11c- cells, with a few MHC class II(+) cells, and F4/80(+) cells. However, MHC class II(+) passenger leukocytes in donor cornea after allografting did not traffic to the draining lymph node. Instead, Ag (plasmid) delivered to the eye via the donor cornea during allograft was detected in host CD11c(+) and F4/80(+) APC in the draining lymph nodes and spleen. The earliest detection of APC-associated Ag was at 6 h in the draining lymph node and 24 h in the spleen. After 48 h Ag was not detected in the draining lymph node but was still present in the spleen. Ag applied to the donor corneal epithelium before allografting induced Ag-specific T cell activation and expansion in the draining lymph node with a peak response at 4-6 days, indicating that cross-presentation of Ag had occurred. We conclude therefore, that Ag is transported from the donor cornea within host APC and that this event occurs within hours after grafting. Ag is cross-presented to host CD4(+) T cells on MHC class II and leads to the activation of Ag-specific effector T cells and clonal expansion in the draining lymph node.     

T and B lymphocyte migration into syngeneic tumors.

The migration of splenic T and B lymphocytes into syngeneic tumors undergoing immunologic rejection was investigates. Spleen cells were obtained from normal BALC/c mice or BALB/c mice bearing tumors induced by murine sarcoma virus (MSV). Either whole spleen cells or immunoabsorbent purified T and B cells were radiolabeled with sodium chromate-51 and injected i.v. into normal or MSV inducted-tumor bearing syngeneic recipients. Twenty-four hours later the recipient mice were sacrificed and radioactivity was assessed for tumor, contralateral normal muscle, the lymph nodes draining the tumor and contralateral draining lymph nodes, peripheral lymph nodes, spleen, and liver. Both T and B lymphocytes from either normal or MSV tumor-bearing animals show greatly increased migration into the tumor when compared with normal muscle. Migration of T cells from both normal and MSV tumor bearers was 30 times that of migration to normal muscle. B cells from tumor-bearing mice, on the other hand, localized in the tumor itself only 50% as frequently as did B cells from normal animals. In addition, T cells from MSV tumor bearers were found in the highest proportion in the lymph node draining the tumor site. We conclude that T and B lymphocytes from either normal or tumor-bearing mice migrate to a syngeneic tumor undergoing immunologic rejection. In contrast, the migration of both T and B cells from tumor-bearing animals was decreased to the peripheral lymph nodes at the time of maximum tumor growth.