Na+-driven flagellar motors of an alkalophilic Bacillus strain YN-1

Flagellar motors of some alkalophilic Bacillus strains have been suggested to be powered by the electrochemical potential gradient of Na+, namely the (formula: see text) (Hirota, N., Kitada, M., and Imae, Y. (1981) FEBS Lett. 132, 278-280). In the present study, we quantitatively measured the (formula: see text) and motility of one of the strains, YN-1. Swimming speed of YN-1 cells increased linearly with a logarithmic increase of Na+ concentration in the medium up to 100 mM. The intracellular Na+ concentration and the membrane potential of the cell were about 30 mM and -170 mV, respectively, and stayed constant irrespective of Na+ concentration in the medium. Thus, the swimming speed changed as a function of the chemical potential difference of Na+ across the cell membrane. When the membrane potential of YN-1 cells was decreased by a combination of valinomycin and various concentrations of K+ in the medium, the swimming speed of the cells decreased linearly and reached zero at around -90 mV. Under the condition, the intracellular Na+ concentration stayed constant. Thus, the membrane potential was also a determinant of the swimming speed. Furthermore, the chemical potential of Na+ and the membrane potential were found to be equivalent as the energy source for motility. Therefore, it is concluded that the (formula: see text) is the energy source for the flagellar motors of YN-1 cells. Threshold value of the (formula: see text) for motility was about -100 mV.     

Na+-driven bacterial flagellar motors

Bacterial flagellar motors are the reversible rotary engine which propels the cell by rotating a helical flagellar filament as a screw propeller. The motors are embedded in the cytoplasmic membrane, and the energy for rotation is supplied by the electrochemical potential of specific ions across the membrane. Thus, the analysis of motor rotation at the molecular level is linked to an understanding of how the living system converts chemical energy into mechanical work. Based on the coupling ions, the motors are divided into two types; one is the H⁺-driven type found in neutrophiles such asBacillus subtilis andEscherichia coli and the other is the Na⁺-driven type found in alkalophilicBacillus and marineVibrio. In this review, we summarize the current status of research on the rotation mechanism of the Na⁺-driven flagellar motors, which introduces several new aspects in the analysis.     

Ion-coupling determinants of Na+-driven and H+-driven flagellar motors

The bacterial flagellar motor is a tiny molecular machine that uses a transmembrane flux of H(+) or Na(+) ions to drive flagellar rotation. In proton-driven motors, the membrane proteins MotA and MotB interact via their transmembrane regions to form a proton channel. The sodium-driven motors that power the polar flagellum of Vibrio species contain homologs of MotA and MotB, called PomA and PomB. They require the unique proteins MotX and MotY. In this study, we investigated how ion selectivity is determined in proton and sodium motors. We found that Escherichia coli MotA/B restore motility in DeltapomAB Vibrio alginolyticus. Most hypermotile segregants isolated from this weakly motile strain contain mutations in motB. We constructed proteins in which segments of MotB were fused to complementary portions of PomB. A chimera joining the N terminus of PomB to the periplasmic C terminus of MotB (PotB7(E)) functioned with PomA as the stator of a sodium motor, with or without MotX/Y. This stator (PomA/PotB7(E)) supported sodium-driven motility in motA or motB E.coli cells, and the swimming speed was even higher than with the original stator of E.coli MotA/B. We conclude that the cytoplasmic and transmembrane domains of PomA/B are sufficient for sodium-driven motility. However, MotA expressed with a B subunit containing the N terminus of MotB fused to the periplasmic domain of PomB (MomB7(E)) supported sodium-driven motility in a MotX/Y-dependent fashion. Thus, although the periplasmic domain of PomB is not necessary for sodium-driven motility in a PomA/B motor, it can convert a MotA/B proton motor into a sodium motor.     

Specific inhibition of the Na(+)-driven flagellar motors of alkalophilic Bacillus strains by the amiloride analog phenamil.

Amiloride, a specific inhibitor for the Na(+)-driven flagellar motors of alkalophilic Bacillus strains, was found to cause growth inhibition; therefore, the use of amiloride for the isolation of motility mutants was difficult. On the other hand, phenamil, an amiloride analog, inhibited motor rotation without affecting cell growth. A concentration of 50 microM phenamil completely inhibited the motility of strain RA-1 but showed no effect on the membrane potential, the intracellular pH, or Na(+)-coupled amino acid transport, which was consistent with the fact that there was no effect on cell growth. Kinetic analysis of the inhibition of motility by phenamil indicated that the inhibition was noncompetitive with Na+ in the medium. A motility mutant was isolated as a swarmer on a swarm agar plate containing 50 microM phenamil. The motility of the mutant showed an increased resistance to phenamil but normal sensitivity to amiloride. These results suggest that phenamil and amiloride interact at different sites on the motor. By examining various bacterial species, phenamil was found to be a specific and potent inhibitor for the Na(+)-driven flaggellar motors not only in various strains of alkalophilic Bacillus spp. but also in a marine Vibrio sp.     

Torque-speed relationships of Na+-driven chimeric flagellar motors in Escherichia coli

The bacterial flagellar motor is a rotary motor in the cell envelope of bacteria that couples ion flow across the cytoplasmic membrane to torque generation by independent stators anchored to the cell wall. The recent observation of stepwise rotation of a Na⁺-driven chimeric motor in Escherichia coli promises to reveal the mechanism of the motor in unprecedented detail. We measured torque-speed relationships of this chimeric motor using back focal plane interferometry of polystyrene beads attached to flagellar filaments in the presence of high sodium-motive force (85 mM Na⁺). With full expression of stator proteins the torque-speed curve had the same shape as those of wild-type E. coli and Vibrio alginolyticus motors: the torque is approximately constant (at ∼ 2200 pN nm) from stall up to a “knee” speed of ∼ 420 Hz, and then falls linearly with speed, extrapolating to zero torque at ∼ 910 Hz. Motors containing one to five stators generated ∼ 200 pN nm per stator at speeds up to ∼ 100 Hz/stator; the knee speed in 4- and 5-stator motors is not significantly slower than in the fully induced motor. This is consistent with the hypothesis that the absolute torque depends on stator number, but the speed dependence does not. In motors with point mutations in either of two critical conserved charged residues in the cytoplasmic domain of PomA, R88A and R232E, the zero-torque speed was reduced to ∼ 400 Hz. The torque at low speed was unchanged by mutation R88A but was reduced to ∼ 1500 pN nm by R232E. These results, interpreted using a simple kinetic model, indicate that the basic mechanism of torque generation is the same regardless of stator type and coupling ion and that the electrostatic interaction between stator and rotor proteins is related to the torque-speed relationship.     

Amiloride at pH 7.0 inhibits the Na(+)-driven flagellar motors of Vibrio alginolyticus but allows cell growth.

Amiloride, a specific inhibitor for the Na(+)-driven flagellar motors of alkalophilic Bacillus, is known to inhibit secondarily the growth of alkalophiles. The motility of a marine Vibrio, V. alginolyticus, was almost completely inhibited by 2 mM amiloride either at pH 7.0 or 8.5. We found that this concentration of amiloride inhibited the cell growth completely at pH 8.5 but only slightly at pH 7.0. Kinetic analysis of the inhibition of motility by amiloride at pH 7.0 showed that the inhibition was competitive with Na+ in the medium. Thus, amiloride at pH 7.0 is really a specific and useful tool for the analysis of the Na(+)-driven flagellar motors of Vibrio.     

Intracellular Na+ kinetically interferes with the rotation of the Na(+)-driven flagellar motors of Vibrio alginolyticus

To understand the mechanism of Na+ movement through the force-generating units of the Na(+)-driven flagellar motors of Vibrio alginolyticus, the effect of intracellular Na+ concentration on motor rotation was investigated. Control cells containing about 50 mM Na+ showed good motility even at 10 mM Na+ in the medium, i.e. in the absence of an inwardly directed Na+ gradient. In contrast, Na(+)-loaded cells containing about 400 mM Na+ showed very poor motility at 500 mM Na+ in the medium, i.e. even in the presence of an inwardly directed Na+ gradient. The membrane potential of the cells, which is a major driving force for the motor under these conditions, was not detectably altered, and consistently with this, Na(+)-coupled sucrose transport was only partly reduced in the Na(+)-loaded cells. Motility of the Na(+)-loaded cells was restored by decreasing the intracellular Na+ concentration, and the rate of restoration of motility correlated with the rate of the Na+ decrease. These results indicate that the absolute concentration of the intracellular Na+ is a determinant of the rotation rate of the Na(+)-driven flagellar motors of V. alginolyticus. A simple explanation for this phenomenon is that the force-generating unit of the motor has an intracellular Na(+)-binding site, at which the intracellular Na+ kinetically interferes with the rate of Na+ influx for motor rotation.     

Relationship between Na+-dependent cytoplasmic pH homeostasis and Na+-dependent flagellar rotation and amino acid transport in alkalophilic Bacillus

The cytoplasmic pH homeostasis of alkalophilic Bacillus strains required the presence of Na+ in the medium, and Li+ was found to be equivalently substitutable for Na+. Flagellar rotation and amino acid transport of these bacteria also required Na+ but Li+ was not substitutable for Na+. Na+ concentration of about 1 mM was enough for the cytoplasmic pH homeostasis, while more than 10 mM Na+ was required for the full activities of flagellar rotation and amino acid transport. The addition of 150 mM ethanolamine to the cells at pH 9.6 disrupted the pH homeostasis and increased the cytoplasmic pH close to the external pH. Under this condition, however, flagellar rotation and amino acid transport were not so much affected. Thus, it is clear that flagellar rotation and amino acid transport themselves require the presence of Na+ in the medium, independent of the Na+-dependent cytoplasmic pH homeostasis.     

Roles of charged residues of rotor and stator in flagellar rotation: comparative study using H+-driven and Na+-driven motors in Escherichia coli

In Escherichia coli, rotation of the flagellar motor has been shown to depend upon electrostatic interactions between charged residues of the stator protein MotA and the rotor protein FliG. These charged residues are conserved in the Na+-driven polar flagellum of Vibrio alginolyticus, but mutational studies in V. alginolyticus suggested that they are relatively unimportant for motor rotation. The electrostatic interactions detected in E. coli therefore might not be a general feature of flagellar motors, or, alternatively, the V. alginolyticus motor might rely on similar interactions but incorporate additional features that make it more robust against mutation. Here, we have carried out a comparative study of chimeric motors that were resident in E. coli but engineered to use V. alginolyticus stator components, rotor components, or both. Charged residues in the V. alginolyticus rotor and stator proteins were found to be essential for motor rotation when the proteins functioned in the setting of the E. coli motor. Patterns of synergism and suppression in rotor/stator double mutants indicate that the V. alginolyticus proteins interact in essentially the same way as their counterparts in E. coli. The robustness of the rotor-stator interface in V. alginolyticus is in part due to the presence of additional charged residues in PomA but appears mainly due to other factors, because an E. coli motor using both rotor and stator components from V. alginolyticus remained sensitive to mutation. Motor function in V. alginolyticus may be enhanced by the proteins MotX and MotY.     

Torque-speed relationship of the Na+-driven flagellar motor of Vibrio alginolyticus

The torque-speed relationship of the Na(+)-driven flagellar motor of Vibrio alginolyticus was investigated. The rotation rate of the motor was measured by following the position of a bead, attached to a flagellar filament, using optical nanometry. In the presence of 50mM NaCl, the generated torque was relatively constant ( approximately 3800pNnm) at lower speeds (speeds up to approximately 300Hz) and then decreased steeply, similar to the H(+)-driven flagellar motor of Escherichia coli. When the external NaCl concentration was varied, the generated torque of the flagellar motor was changed over a wide range of speeds. This result could be reproduced using a simple kinetic model, which takes into consideration the association and dissociation of Na(+) onto the motor. These results imply that for a complete understanding of the mechanism of flagellar rotation it is essential to consider both the electrochemical gradient and the absolute concentration of the coupling ion.     

Forced rotation of Na+-driven flagellar motor in a coupling ion-free environment

Rotational characteristics of Na+-driven flagellar motor in the presence and absence of coupling ion were analyzed by electrorotation method. The motor rotated spontaneously in the presence of Na+, and the rotation accelerated or decelerated following the direction of the applied external torque. The spontaneous motor rotation was inhibited by removal of external Na+, however, the motor could be forcibly rotated by relatively small external torque applied by the electrorotation apparatus. The observed characteristic of the motor was completely different from that of ATP-driven motor systems, which form rigor bond when their energy source, ATP, is absent. The internal resistance of the flagellar motor increased significantly when the coupling ion could not access the inside of the motor, suggesting that the interaction between the rotor and the stator is changed by the binding of the coupling ion to the internal sites of the motor.     

Na(+)-driven flagellar motor of Vibrio

Bacterial flagellar motors are molecular machines powered by the electrochemical potential gradient of specific ions across the membrane. Bacteria move using rotating helical flagellar filaments. The flagellar motor is located at the base of the filament and is buried in the cytoplasmic membrane. Flagellar motors are classified into two types according to the coupling ion: namely the H(+)-driven motor and the Na(+)-driven motor. Analysis of the flagellar motor at the molecular level is far more advanced in the H(+)-driven motor than in the Na(+)-driven motor. Recently, the genes of the Na(+)-driven motor have been cloned from a marine bacterium of Vibrio sp. and some of the motor proteins have been purified and characterized. In this review, we summarize recent studies of the Na(+)-driven flagellar motor.     

Multimeric structure of PomA, a component of the Na+-driven polar flagellar motor of vibrio alginolyticus

Four integral membrane proteins, PomA, PomB, MotX, and MotY, are thought to be directly involved in torque generation of the Na(+)-driven polar flagellar motor of Vibrio alginolyticus. Our previous study showed that PomA and PomB form a complex, which catalyzes sodium influx in response to a potassium diffusion potential. PomA forms a stable dimer when expressed in a PomB null mutant. To explore the possible functional dependence of PomA domains in adjacent subunits, we prepared a series of PomA dimer fusions containing different combinations of wild-type or mutant subunits. Introduction of the mutation P199L, which completely inactivates flagellar rotation, into either the first or the second half of the dimer abolished motility. The P199L mutation in monomeric PomA also altered the PomA-PomB interaction. PomA dimer with the P199L mutation even in one subunit also had no ability to interact with PomB, indicating that the both subunits in the dimer are required for the functional interaction between PomA and PomB. Flagellar rotation by wild-type PomA dimer was completely inactivated by phenamil, a sodium channel blocker. However, activity was retained in the presence of phenamil when either half of the dimer was replaced with a phenamil-resistant subunit, indicating that both subunits must bind phenamil for motility to be fully inhibited. These observations demonstrate that both halves of the PomA dimer function together to generate the torque for flagellar rotation.     

Characterization of the periplasmic region of PomB, a Na+-driven flagellar stator protein in Vibrio alginolyticus

The stator proteins PomA and PomB form a complex that couples Na⁺ influx to torque generation in the polar flagellar motor of Vibrio alginolyticus. This stator complex is anchored to an appropriate place around the rotor through a putative peptidoglycan-binding (PGB) domain in the periplasmic region of PomB (PomB_C). To investigate the function of PomB_C, a series of N-terminally-truncated and in-frame mutants with deletions between the transmembrane (TM) segment and the PGB domain of PomB was constructed. A PomB_C fragment consisting of residues 135 to 315 (PomB_C5) formed a stable homodimer and significantly inhibited the motility of wild-type cells when overexpressed in the periplasm. A fragment with an in-frame deletion (PomB_ΔL) of up to 80 residues retained function, and its overexpression with PomA impaired cell growth. This inhibitory effect was suppressed by a mutation at the functionally critical Asp (D24N) in the TM segment of PomB, suggesting that a high level of Na⁺ influx through the mutant stator causes the growth impairment. The overproduction of functional PomA/PomB_ΔL stators also reduced the motile fractions of the cells. That effect could be slightly relieved by a mutation (L168P) in the putative N-terminal α-helix that connects to the PGB domain without affecting the growth inhibition, suggesting that a conformational change of the region including the PGB domain affects stator assembly. Our results reveal common features of the periplasmic region of PomB/MotB and demonstrate that a flexible linker that contains a “plug” segment is important for the control of Na⁺ influx through the stator complex as well as for stator assembly.     

Na+ modulates the K+ permeability and the membrane potential of alkalophilic Bacillus

In the absence of Na+ in the medium, the membrane potential of obligately alkalophilic Bacillus cells was found to be decreased by the addition of K+ to the medium, whereas K+ addition in the presence of Na+ had no effect. Rb+ showed essentially the same effect as K+. The decreased membrane potential was quickly restored by lowering the K+ concentration in the medium or by adding Na+ or Li+ to the medium. Thus, in the absence of Na+, the membrane potential of alkalophilic Bacillus seems to be affected by the concentration difference of K+ between inside and outside of the cell, and Na+ or Li+ in the medium suppresses the K+ effect. An exchange between extracellular Rb+ and intracellular K+ was observed in the absence of Na+. However, the exchange was greatly suppressed by the addition of Na+ or Li+ to the medium, indicating that Na+ in the medium modulates the K+ permeability of the alkalophilic Bacillus cell membrane. The K+-induced decrease in the membrane potential of alkalophilic Bacillus in the absence of Na+ is accounted for by the increased K+-permeability of the cell membrane.     

Assembly of motor proteins, PomA and PomB, in the Na+-driven stator of the flagellar motor

PomA and PomB are transmembrane proteins that form the stator complex in the sodium-driven flagellar motor of Vibrio alginolyticus and are believed to surround the rotor part of the flagellar motor. We constructed and observed green fluorescent protein (GFP) fusions of the stator proteins PomA and PomB in living cells to clarify how stator proteins are assembled and installed into the flagellar motor. We were able to demonstrate that GFP-PomA and GFP-PomB localized to a cell pole dependent on the presence of the polar flagellum. Localization of the GFP-fused stator proteins required their partner subunit, PomA or PomB, and the C-terminal domain of PomB, which has a peptidoglycan-binding motif. Each of the GFP-fused stator proteins was co-isolated with its partner subunit from detergent-solubilized membrane. From these lines of evidence, we have demonstrated that the stator proteins are incorporated into the flagellar motor as a PomA/PomB complex and are fixed to the cell wall via the C-terminal domain of PomB.     

The conserved charged residues of the C-terminal region of FliG, a rotor component of the Na+-driven flagellar motor

FliG is an essential component of the flagellar motor and functions in flagellar assembly, torque generation and regulation of the direction of flagellar rotation. The five charged residues important for the rotation of the flagellar motor were identified in Escherichiacoli FliG (FliG(E)). These residues are clustered in the C terminus and are all conserved in FliG(V) of the Na(+)-driven motor of Vibrioalginolyticus (Lys284, Arg301, Asp308, Asp309 and Arg317). To investigate the roles of these charged residues in the Na(+)-driven motor, we cloned the VibriofliG gene and introduced single or multiple substitutions into the corresponding positions in FliG(V). FliG(V) with double Ala replacements in all possible combinations at these five conserved positions still retained significant motile ability, although some of the mutations completely eliminated the function of FliG(E). All of the triple mutants constructed in this study also remained motile. These results suggest that the important charged residues may be located in different places and the conserved charged residues are not so important for the Na(+)-driven flagellar motor of Vibrio. The chimeric FliG protein (FliG(VE)), composed of the N-terminal domain from V.alginolyticus and the C-terminal domain from E.coli, functions in Vibrio cells. The mutations of the charge residues of the C-terminal region in FliG(VE) affected swarming ability as in E.coli. Both the FliG(V) and the FliG(VE) proteins with the triple mutation were more susceptible to proteolysis than proteins without the mutation, suggesting that their conformations were altered.     

Roles of charged residues in the C-terminal region of PomA, a stator component of the Na+-driven flagellar motor

Bacterial flagellar motors use specific ion gradients to drive their rotation. It has been suggested that the electrostatic interactions between charged residues of the stator and rotor proteins are important for rotation in Escherichia coli. Mutational studies have indicated that the Na(+)-driven motor of Vibrio alginolyticus may incorporate interactions similar to those of the E. coli motor, but the other electrostatic interactions between the rotor and stator proteins may occur in the Na(+)-driven motor. Thus, we investigated the C-terminal charged residues of the stator protein, PomA, in the Na(+)-driven motor. Three of eight charge-reversing mutations, PomA(K203E), PomA(R215E), and PomA(D220K), did not confer motility either with the motor of V. alginolyticus or with the Na(+)-driven chimeric motor of E. coli. Overproduction of the R215E and D220K mutant proteins but not overproduction of the K203E mutant protein impaired the motility of wild-type V. alginolyticus. The R207E mutant conferred motility with the motor of V. alginolyticus but not with the chimeric motor of E. coli. The motility with the E211K and R232E mutants was similar to that with wild-type PomA in V. alginolyticus but was greatly reduced in E. coli. Suppressor analysis suggested that R215 may participate in PomA-PomA interactions or PomA intramolecular interactions to form the stator complex.     

Arginine inhibits Na-driven flagellar motors of alkaliphilic Bacillus

L-arginine has attracted a great deal of attention as an agent for refolding denatured proteins, and the mildness of its effects offer hope for a wide range of potential applications for this substance, including medicines with few side effects. We report that both L- and D-arginine inhibits Na+-driven flagellar motors of alkaliphilic Bacillus by competing with Na+, which we take as evidence that arginine specifically binds to a molecular target.