Dynamics of ribosomal RNA structure

The structural dynamics of ribosomal 5S RNAs have been investigated by probing single strandedness through enzymatic cleavage and chemical modification. This comparative study includes 5S rRNAs from E. coli, B. stearothermophilus, T. thermophilus, H. cutirubrum, spinach chloroplast, spinach cytomplasm, and Artemia salina. The structural studies support a unique tertiary interaction in eubacterial 5S rRNAs, involving nucleotides around positions 43 and 75. In addition long range structural effects are demonstrated in E. coli 5S rRNA due to the conversion of C to U at position 92.     

In vitro incorporation of eubacterial, archaebacterial and eukaryotic 5S rRNAs into large ribosomal subunits of Bacillus stearothermophilus.

Bacillus stearothermophilus large ribosomal subunits were reconstituted in the presence of 5S rRNAs from different origins and tested for their biological activities. The results obtained have shown that eubacterial and archaebacterial 5S rRNAs can easily substitute for B. stearothermophilus 5S rRNA in the reconstitution, while eukaryotic 5S rRNAs yield ribosomal subunits with reduced biological activities. From our results we propose an interaction between nucleotides 42-47 of 5S rRNA and nucleotides 2603-2608 of 23S rRNA during the assembly of the 50S ribosomal subunit. Other experiments with eukaryotic 5.8S rRNAs reveal, if at all, a very low incorporation of these RNA species into the reconstituted ribosomes.     

Structural analysis of 5S rRNA, 5S rRNA-protein complexes and ribosomes employing RNase H and d(GTTCGG)

The hybridization of d(GTTCGG) to eubacterial 5S rRNAs, 5S rRNA-protein complexes, 70S ribosomes and 50S and 30S ribosomal subunits was investigated. This oligonucleotide, which may be considered to be an analogue of the T psi CG loop of tRNAs, was chosen in order to investigate a possible interaction between tRNAs with ribosomal components during protein synthesis. The hybridization was analysed by RNase H hydrolysis studies and, in the case of the ribosomes and ribosomal subunits, in addition with the radioactively labelled oligodeoxyribonucleotide in binding studies. The results obtained lead to the conclusion that nucleotides in loop c, i.e. positions 42-47, are available for oligonucleotide interaction in free Escherichia coli and Bacillus stearothermophilus 5S rRNAs and not available in the corresponding 5S rRNA-protein complexes. The 70S ribosomes and ribosomal subunits did not interact with the oligonucleotide. Under the assumption that d(GTTCGG) is an analogue of the T psi CG loop of tRNAs and in view of the results obtained, we conclude that in the unprogrammed ribosomes the T psi CG loop of tRNAs does not interact via standard Watson-Crick base pairs with the ribosomal 5S, 16S or 23S RNAs.     

Electron microscopy of the secondary structure in partially denatured rRNAs of Escherichia coli and Bacillus stearothermophilus.

Partially denatured 16S and 23S rRNAs from the thermophile Bacillus stearothermophilus show characteristic loop patterns when observed by electron microscopy. The patterns are very similar to those seen in rRNAs from Escherichia coli. At least 2 of 4 most stable interactions in 16S rRNA and 8 of 12 interactions in 23S rRNA are in common for the two species. These interactions correspond well to features of secondary structure in models inferred for rRNA from phylogenetic sequence comparisons and chemical modification studies. However, two additional large loops, enclosing large portions of the 23S rRNA, have been detected in B. stearothermophilus for the first time, and even though other loops are similar, their relative frequencies vary in the two species. Much of the variation is consistent with relative delta G degree values for putative base-paired stems at the base of different loops; but the 5'-terminal loops in 23S rRNA, for example, are unaccountably far less stable in B. stearothermophilus. Also, in general, structural features are not differentially stabilized in B. stearothermophilus; the relative stability of secondary structure in its ribosomes at elevated growth temperatures must involve interactions with ribosomal proteins or other cellular components.     

Detailed analysis of RNA-protein interactions within the bacterial ribosomal protein L5/5S rRNA complex

The crystal structure of ribosomal protein L5 from Thermus thermophilus complexed with a 34-nt fragment comprising helix III and loop C of Escherichia coli 5S rRNA has been determined at 2.5 A resolution. The protein specifically interacts with the bulged nucleotides at the top of loop C of 5S rRNA. The rRNA and protein contact surfaces are strongly stabilized by intramolecular interactions. Charged and polar atoms forming the network of conserved intermolecular hydrogen bonds are located in two narrow planar parallel layers belonging to the protein and rRNA, respectively. The regions, including these atoms conserved in Bacteria and Archaea, can be considered an RNA-protein recognition module. Comparison of the T. thermophilus L5 structure in the RNA-bound form with the isolated Bacillus stearothermophilus L5 structure shows that the RNA-recognition module on the protein surface does not undergo significant changes upon RNA binding. In the crystal of the complex, the protein interacts with another RNA molecule in the asymmetric unit through the beta-sheet concave surface. This protein/RNA interface simulates the interaction of L5 with 23S rRNA observed in the Haloarcula marismortui 50S ribosomal subunit.     

Three-dimensional model of Escherichia coli ribosomal 5 S RNA as deduced from structure probing in solution and computer modeling.

The conformation of Escherichia coli 5 S rRNA was investigated using chemical and enzymatic probes. The four bases were monitored at one of their Watson-Crick positions with dimethylsulfate (at C(N-3) and A(N-1], with a carbodiimide derivative (at G(N-1) and U(N-3] and with kethoxal (at G(N-1, N-2]. Position N-7 of purine was probed with diethylpyrocarbonate (at A(N-7] and dimethylsulfate (at G(N-7]. Double-stranded or stacked regions were tested with RNase V1 and unpaired guanine residues with RNase T1. We also used lead(II) that has a preferential affinity for interhelical and loop regions and a high sensitivity for flexible regions. Particular care was taken to use uniform conditions of salt, magnesium, pH and temperature for the different enzymatic chemical probes. Derived from these experimental data, a three dimensional model of the 5 S rRNA was built using computer modeling which integrates stereochemical constraints and phylogenetic data. The three domains of 5 S rRNA secondary structure fold into a Y-shaped structure that does not accommodate long-range tertiary interactions between domains. The three domains have distinct structural and dynamic features as revealed by the chemical reactivity and the lead(II)-induced hydrolysis: domain 2 (loop B/helix III/loop C) displays a rather weak structure and possesses dynamic properties while domain 3 (helix V/region E/helix IV/loop D) adopts a highly structured and overall helical conformation. Conserved nucleotides are not crucial for the tertiary folding but maintain an intrinsic structure in the loop regions, especially via non-canonical pairing (A.G, G.U, G.G, A.C, C.C), which can close the loops in a highly specific fashion. In particular, nucleotides in the large external loop C fold into an organized conformation leading to the formation of a five-membered loop motif. Finally, nucleotides at the hinge region of the Y-shape are involved in a precise array of hydrogen bonds based on a triple interaction between U14, G69 and G107 stabilizing the quasi-colinearity of helices II and V. The proposed tertiary model is consistent with the localization of the ribosomal protein binding sites and possesses strong analogy with the model proposed for Xenopus laevis 5 S rRNA, indicating that the Y-shape model can be generalized to all 5 S rRNAs.     

Different conformational forms of Escherichia coli and rat liver 5S rRNA revealed by Pb(II)-induced hydrolysis.

Different stable forms of Escherichia coli and rat liver 5S rRNA have been probed by Pb(II)-induced hydrolysis. In the native A forms of 5S rRNA, Pb2+ reveal single-stranded RNA stretches and regions of increased conformational flexibility or distorted by the presence of bulged nucleotides. Hydrolysis of urea/EDTA-treated E. coli 5S rRNA (B form) shows the presence of two strong helical domains; helix A retained from the A form and a helix composed of RNA regions G33-C42 and G79-C88. Other RNA regions resistant to hydrolysis may be involved in alternative base pairing, causing conformational heterogeneity of that form. Pb(II)-induced hydrolysis distinguishes two different forms of rat liver 5S rRNA; the native A form and the form obtained by renaturation of 5S rRNA in the presence of EDTA. Pb(II)-hydrolysis data suggest that both forms are highly structured. In the latter form, the orientation of the bulged C66 is changed with respect to helix B. At the same time, a new helical segment is possibly formed, composed of nucleotides from helix C and loop c on one side and from helix E and loop d' on the other.     

Dynamics of Ribosomal RNA Structure

Abstract

The structural dynamics of ribosomal 5S RNAs have been investigated by probing single strandedness through enzymatic cleavage and chemical modification. This comparative study includes 5S rRNAs from E. coli, B. stearothermophilus, T. thermophilics, H. cutirubrum, spinach chloroplast, spinach cytomplasm, and Artemia salina. The structural studies support a unique tertiary interaction in eubacterial 5S rRNAs, involving nucleotides around positions 43 and 75. In addition long range structural effects are demonstrated in E. coli 5S rRNA due to the conversion of C to U at position 92.     

Structural analysis of three prokaryotic 5S rRNA species and selected 5S rRNA--ribosomal-protein complexes by means of Pb(II)-induced hydrolysis.

Lead ions have been applied to the structural analysis of 5S rRNA from Thermus thermophilus, Bacillus stearothermophilus and Escherichia coli. Based on the distribution of Pb(II)-induced cleavages, some minor modifications of the consensus secondary structure model of 5S rRNA are proposed. They include the possible base pairing between nucleotides at positions 11 and 109, as well as changes in secondary interactions within the helix B region. The 'prokaryotic arm' region is completely resistant to hydrolysis in the three RNA species, suggesting that it is a relatively stable, highly ordered structure. Hydrolysis of E. coli 5S rRNA complexed with ribosomal protein L18 shows, besides the shielding effect of the bound protein, a highly enhanced cleavage between A108 and A109. It supports the concept that the major L18-induced conformational change involves the junction of helices A, B and D.     

Improved procedure for the isolation of a double-strand-specific ribonuclease and its application to structural analysis of various 5S rRNAs and tRNAs

An improved method for the isolation of a double-strand-specific RNase from snake venom is presented. This RNase, called CSV, was used to cleave yeast tRNAPhe and tRNA2Glu and tRNAfMet from Escherichia coli. In addition these RNAs and E. coli tRNAPhe were examined with the single-strand-specific nuclease S1. The results are discussed in terms of the specificity of CSV RNase and the structure of tRNAs. S1 nuclease digestions at increasing temperatures allowed the melting of tertiary and secondary structure to be monitored. 5S rRNA from E. coli, Thermoplasma acidophilum and the chloroplasts of Spinacia oleracea were digested with CSV and S1. The information these results give on the secondary-structural differences between different classes of 5S rRNA are discussed. Supporting evidence is found for tertiary interactions between hairpin loop c and internal loop d of eubacterial 5S rRNA.     

The lonepair triloop: a new motif in RNA structure

The lonepair triloop (LPTL) is an RNA structural motif that contains a single ("lone") base-pair capped by a hairpin loop containing three nucleotides. The two nucleotides immediately outside of this motif (5' and 3' to the lonepair) are not base-paired to one another, restricting the length of this helix to a single base-pair. Four examples of this motif, along with three tentative examples, were initially identified in the 16S and 23S rRNAs with covariation analysis. An evaluation of the recently determined crystal structures of the Thermus thermophilus 30S and Haloarcula marismortui 50S ribosomal subunits revealed the authenticity for all of these proposed interactions and identified 16 more LPTLs in the 5S, 16S and 23S rRNAs. This motif is found in the T loop in the tRNA crystal structures. The lonepairs are positioned, in nearly all examples, immediately 3' to a regular secondary structure helix and are stabilized by coaxial stacking onto this flanking helix. In all but two cases, the nucleotides in the triloop are involved in a tertiary interaction with another section of the rRNA, establishing an overall three-dimensional function for this motif. Of these 24 examples, 14 occur in multi-stem loops, seven in hairpin loops and three in internal loops. While the most common lonepair, U:A, occurs in ten of the 24 LPTLs, the remaining 14 LPTLs contain seven different base-pair types. Only a few of these lonepairs adopt the standard Watson-Crick base-pair conformations, while the majority of the base-pairs have non-standard conformations. While the general three-dimensional conformation is similar for all examples of this motif, characteristic differences lead to several subtypes present in different structural environments. At least one triloop nucleotide in 22 of the 24 LPTLs in the rRNAs and tRNAs forms a tertiary interaction with another part of the RNA. When a LPTL containing the GNR or UYR triloop sequence forms a tertiary interaction with the first (and second) triloop nucleotide, it recruits a fourth nucleotide to mediate stacking and mimic the tetraloop conformation. Approximately half of the LPTL motifs are in close association with proteins. The majority of these LPTLs are positioned at sites in rRNAs that are conserved in the three phylogenetic domains; a few of these occur in regions of the rRNA associated with ribosomal function, including the presumed site of peptidyl transferase activity in the 23S rRNA.     

Comparative Surface Structure of 16S Ribosomal Ribonucleic Acid of 30S Ribosomes of Procaryotic Cells

Ribonuclease T(1) treatment of 30S ribosomes of Escherichia coli converts a large region at the 3' OH end of 16S ribosomal ribonucleic acid (rRNA) to low-molecular-weight RNA. The final 25 nucleotides at the 3' terminus of the molecule emerge relatively intact, whereas most of the region "upstream," for about 150 nucleotides, is converted to oligonucleotides. Identical enzyme treatment generates a fragment of about 60 nucleotides from the middle of 16S rRNA (section D'). To determine whether there are similar sequences in other bacteria, which occupy similar accessible surface locations, we treated 30S ribosomes from Azotobacter vinelandii and Bacillus stearothermophilus with RNase T(1). In each case, a fragment of RNA about 25 nucleotides in length containing the 3' OH end of 16S rRNA and a fragment of about 60 nucleotides in length similar, but not identical, in oligonucleotide composition to section D' of E. coli 16S rRNA were obtained from nuclease-treated 30S ribosomes. These data indicate that, although the primary structure at the 3' end and the middle (section D') of the various 16S rRNA's is not completely conserved, their respective conformations are conserved. A number of identical oligonucleotides were found in the low-molecular-weight fraction obtained from RNase T(1)-treated E. coli, A. vinelandii, and B. stearothermophilus 30S ribosomes. These results show that identical RNase T(1)-sensitive sequences are present in all three bacteria. Hydrolysis of these regions leads to the production of the fragments 25 and 60 nucleotides in length.     

Structural changes in the 530 loop of Escherichia coli 16S rRNA in mutants with impaired translational fidelity.

The higher order structure of the functionally important 530 loop in Escherichia coli 16S rRNA was studied in mutants with single base changes at position 517, which significantly impair translational fidelity. The 530 loop has been proposed to interact with the EF-Tu-GTP-aatRNA ternary complex during decoding. The reactivity at G530, U531 and A532 to the chemical probes kethoxal, CMCT and DMS respectively was increased in the mutant 16S rRNA compared with the wild-type, suggesting a more open 530 loop structure in the mutant ribosomes. This was supported by oligonucleotide binding experiments in which probes complementary to positions 520-526 and 527-533, but not control probes, showed increased binding to the 517C mutant 70S ribosomes compared with the non-mutant control. Furthermore, enzymatic digestion of 70S ribosomes with RNase T1, specific for single-stranded RNA, substantially cleaved both wild-type and mutant rRNAs between G524 and C525, two of the nucleotides involved in the 530 loop pseudoknot. This site was also cleaved in the 517C mutant, but not wild-type rRNA, by RNase V1. Such a result is still consistent with a more open 530 loop structure in the mutant ribosomes, since RNase V1 can cut at appropriately stacked single-stranded regions of RNA. Together these data indicate that the 517C mutant rRNA has a rather extensively unfolded 530 loop structure. Less extensive structural changes were found in mutants 517A and 517U, which caused less misreading. A correlation between the structural changes in the 530 loop and impaired translational accuracy is proposed.     

The 3''-terminal region of bacterial 23S ribosomal RNA: structure and homology with the 3''-terminal region of eukaryotic 28S rRNA and with chloroplast 4.5s rRNA.

The sequence of the 110 nucleotide fragment located at the 3'-end of E.coli, P.vulgaris and A.punctata 23S rRNAs has been determined. The homology between the E.coli and P.vulgaris fragments is 90%, whereas that between the E.coli and A.punctate fragments is only 60%. The three rRNA fragments have sequences compatible with a secondary structure consisting of two hairpins. Using chemical and enzymatic methods recently developed for the study of the secondary structure of RNA, we demonstrated that one of these hairpins and part of the other are actually present in the three 3'-terminal fragments in solution. This supports the existence of these two hairpins in the intact molecule. Indeed, results obtained upon limited digestion of intact 23S RNA with T1 RNase were in good agreement with the existence of these two hairpins. We observed that the primary structures of the 3'-terminal regions of yeast 26S rRNA and X.laevis 28S rRNA are both compatible with a secondary structure similar to that found at the 3'-end of bacterial 23S rRNAs. Furthermore, both tobacco and wheat chloroplast 4.5S rRNAs can also be folded in a similar way as the 3'-terminal region of bacterial 23S rRNA, the 3'-end of chloroplast 4.5S rRNAs being complementary to the 5'-end of chloroplast 23S rRNA. This strongly reinforces the hypothesis that chloroplast 4.5S rRNA originates from the 3'-end of bacterial 23S rRNA and suggests that this rRNA may be base-paired with the 5'-end of chloroplast 23S rRNA. Invariant oligonucleotides are present at identical positions in the homologous secondary structures of E.coli 23S, yeast 26S, X.laevis 28S and wheat and tobacco 4.5S rRNAs. Surprisingly, the sequences of these oligonucleotides are not all conserved in the 3'-terminal regions of A.punctata or even P.vulgaris 23S rRNAs. Results obtained upon mild methylation of E.coli 50S subunits with dimethylsulfate strongly suggest that these invariant oligonucleotides are involved in RNA tertiary structure or in RNA-protein interactions.     

The kink-turn: a new RNA secondary structure motif

Analysis of the Haloarcula marismortui large ribosomal subunit has revealed a common RNA structure that we call the kink-turn, or K-turn. The six K-turns in H.marismortui 23S rRNA superimpose with an r.m.s.d. of 1.7 A. There are two K-turns in the structure of Thermus thermophilus 16S rRNA, and the structures of U4 snRNA and L30e mRNA fragments form K-turns. The structure has a kink in the phosphodiester backbone that causes a sharp turn in the RNA helix. Its asymmetric internal loop is flanked by C-G base pairs on one side and sheared G-A base pairs on the other, with an A-minor interaction between these two helical stems. A derived consensus secondary structure for the K-turn includes 10 consensus nucleotides out of 15, and predicts its presence in the 5'-UTR of L10 mRNA, helix 78 in Escherichia coli 23S rRNA and human RNase MRP. Five K-turns in 23S rRNA interact with nine proteins. While the observed K-turns interact with proteins of unrelated structures in different ways, they interact with L7Ae and two homologous proteins in the same way.     

The secondary structure of the protein L1 binding region of ribosomal 23S RNA. Homologies with putative secondary structures of the L11 mRNA and of a region of mitochondrial 16S rRNA.

An heterologous complex was formed between E. coli protein L1 and P. vulgaris 23S RNA. We determined the primary structure of the RNA region which remained associated with protein L1 after RNase digestion of this complex. We also identified the loci of this RNA region which are highly susceptible to T1, S1 and Naja oxiana nuclease digestions respectively. By comparison of these results with those previously obtained with the homologous regions of E. coli and B. stearothermophilus 23S RNAs, we postulate a general structure for the protein L1 binding region of bacterial 23S RNA. Both mouse and human mit 16S rRNAs and Xenopus laevis and Tetrahymena 28S rRNAs contain a sequence similar to the E. coli 23s RNS region preceding the L1 binding site. The region of mit 16S rRNA which follows this sequence has a potential secondary structure bearing common features with the L1-associated region of bacterial 23S rRNA. The 5'-end region of the L11 mRNA also has several sequence potential secondary structures displaying striking homologies with the protein L1 binding region of 23S rRNA and this probably explains how protein L1 functions as a translational repressor. One of the L11 mRNA putative structures bears the features common to both the L1-associated region of bacterial 23S rRNA and the corresponding region of mit 16S rRNA.     

A comparison of the solution structures and conformational properties of the somatic and oocyte 5S rRNAs of Xenopus laevis

The secondary and tertiary structures of Xenopus oocyte and somatic 5S rRNAs were investigated using chemical and enzymatic probes. The accessibility of both RNAs towards single-strand specific nucleases (T1, T2, A and S1) and a helix-specific ribonuclease from cobra venom (RNase V1) was determined. The reactivity of nucleobase N7, N3 and N1 positions towards chemical probes was investigated under native (5 mM MgCl2, 100 mM KCl, 20 degrees C) and semi-denaturing (1 mM EDTA, 20 degrees C) conditions. Ethylnitrosourea was used to identify phosphates not reactive towards alkylation under native conditions. The results obtained confirm the presence of the five helical stems predicted by the consensus secondary structure model of 5S rRNA. The chemical reactivity data indicate that loops C and D are involved in a number of tertiary interactions, and loop E folds into an unusual secondary structure. A comparison of the data obtained for the two types of Xenopus 5S rRNA indicates that the conformations of the oocyte and somatic 5S rRNAs are very similar. However, the data obtained with nucleases under native conditions, and chemical probes under semi-denaturing conditions, reveal that helices III and IV in the somatic 5S rRNA are less stable than the same structures in oocyte 5S rRNA. Using chimeric 5S rRNAs, it was possible to demonstrate that the relative resistance of oocyte 5S rRNA to partial denaturation in 4 M urea is conferred by the five oocyte-specific nucleotide substitutions in loop B/helix III. In contrast, the superior stability of oocyte 5S rRNA in the presence of EDTA is related to a single C substitution at position 79.     

A new model for the tertiary structure of 5S ribonucleic acid in plants

Chemical, enzymatic and physicochemical methods of a structural analysis of 5S rRNAs in lupine, wheat germ, and other plants led us to propose a new three-dimensional model of these molecules The main features of the model are tertiary interactions between the β- and γ-domains of the molecule, specifically nucleotides (34)CCCA(37) in loop C and nucleotides (85)GGGU(88) in loop D. In addition we propose tertiary base-pairing in A100-U53 between loops B and E. We have confirmed this model by NMR spectroscopy and by chemical modification with diethylpyrocarbonate. Our results are consistent with the proposed model and are also applicable to all eukaryotic 5S rRNAs. Our model is clearly differentiated from others by intramolecular tertiary hydrogen bonds between the two domains.     

Base-pairing between 23S rRNA and tRNA in the ribosomal A site

The aminoacyl (A site) tRNA analog 4-thio-dT-p-C-p-puromycin (s4TCPm) photochemically cross-links with high efficiency and specificity to G2553 of 23S rRNA and is peptidyl transferase reactive in its cross-linked state, establishing proximity between the highly conserved 2555 loop in domain V of 23S rRNA and the universally conserved CCA end of tRNA. To test for base-pairing interactions between 23S rRNA and aminoacyl tRNA, site-directed mutations were made at the universally conserved nucleotides U2552 and G2553 of 23S rRNA in both E. coli and B. stearothermophilus ribosomal RNA and incorporated into ribosomes. Mutations at G2553 resulted in dominant growth defects in E. coli and in decreased levels of peptidyl transferase activity in vitro. Genetic analysis in vitro of U2552 and G2553 mutant ribosomes and CCA end mutant tRNA substrates identified a base-pairing interaction between C75 of aminoacyl tRNA and G2553 of 23S rRNA.