Positive and negative mutant selection in the human histone hairpin-binding protein using the yeast three-hybrid system

We have used the yeast three-hybrid system in a positive selection for mutants of the human histone hairpin-binding protein (HBP) capable of interacting with non-canonical hairpins and in a negative selection for loss-of-binding mutants. Interestingly, all mutations from the positive selection are located in the N- and C-terminal regions flanking a minimal RNA-binding domain (RBD) previously defined between amino acids 126 and 198. Further, in vitro binding studies demonstrate that the RBD, which shows no obvious similarity to other RNA-binding motifs, has a relaxed sequence specificity compared to full-length HBP, allowing it to bind to mutant hairpin RNAs not normally found in histone genes. These findings indicate that the sequences flanking the RBD are important for restricting binding to the highly conserved histone hairpin structure. Among the loss-of-binding mutations, about half are nonsense mutations distributed throughout the N-terminal part and the RBD whereas the other half are missense mutations restricted to the RBD. Whereas the nonsense mutations permit a more precise definition of the C-terminal border of the RBD, the missense mutations identify critical residues for RNA binding within the RBD.     

Structure of the histone mRNA hairpin required for cell cycle regulation of histone gene expression

Expression of replication-dependent histone genes requires a conserved hairpin RNA element in the 3' untranslated regions of poly(A)-less histone mRNAs. The 3' hairpin element is recognized by the hairpin-binding protein or stem-loop-binding protein (HBP/SLBP). This protein-RNA interaction is important for the endonucleolytic cleavage generating the mature mRNA 3' end. The 3' hairpin and presumably HBP/SLBP are also required for nucleocytoplasmic transport, translation, and stability of histone mRNAs. RNA 3' processing and mRNA stability are both regulated during the cell cycle. Here, we have determined the three-dimensional structure of a 24-mer RNA comprising a mammalian histone RNA hairpin using heteronuclear multidimensional NMR spectroscopy. The hairpin adopts a novel UUUC tetraloop conformation that is stabilized by base stacking involving the first and third loop uridines and a closing U-A base pair, and by hydrogen bonding between the first and third uridines in the tetraloop. The HBP interaction of hairpin RNA variants was analyzed in band shift experiments. Particularly important interactions for HBP recognition are mediated by the closing U-A base pair and the first and third loop uridines, whose Watson-Crick functional groups are exposed towards the major groove of the RNA hairpin. The results obtained provide novel structural insight into the interaction of the histone 3' hairpin with HBP, and thus the regulation of histone mRNA metabolism.     

Critical residues for RNA discrimination of the histone hairpin binding protein (HBP) investigated by the yeast three-hybrid system

The histone hairpin binding protein (HBP, also called SLBP, which stands for stem-loop binding protein) binds specifically to a highly conserved hairpin structure located in the 3' UTR of the cell-cycle-dependent histone mRNAs. HBP consists of a minimal central RNA binding domain (RBD) flanked by an N- and C-terminal domain. The yeast three-hybrid system has been used to investigate the critical residues of the human HBP involved in the binding of its target hairpin structure. By means of negative selections followed by positive selections, we isolated mutant HBP species. Our results indicate tight relationships between the RBD and the N- and C-terminal domains.     

The gene for histone RNA hairpin binding protein is located on human chromosome 4 and encodes a novel type of RNA binding protein.

The hairpin structure at the 3' end of animal histone mRNAs controls histone RNA 3' processing, nucleocytoplasmic transport, translation and stability of histone mRNA. Functionally overlapping, if not identical, proteins binding to the histone RNA hairpin have been identified in nuclear and polysomal extracts. Our own results indicated that these hairpin binding proteins (HBPs) bind their target RNA as monomers and that the resulting ribonucleoprotein complexes are extremely stable. These features prompted us to select for HBP-encoding human cDNAs by RNA-mediated three-hybrid selection in Saccharomyces cerevesiae. Whole cell extract from one selected clone contained a Gal4 fusion protein that interacted with histone hairpin RNA in a sequence- and structure-specific manner similar to a fraction enriched for bovine HBP, indicating that the cDNA encoded HBP. DNA sequence analysis revealed that the coding sequence did not contain any known RNA binding motifs. The HBP gene is composed of eight exons covering 19.5 kb on the short arm of chromosome 4. Translation of the HBP open reading frame in vitro produced a 43 kDa protein with RNA binding specificity identical to murine or bovine HBP. In addition, recombinant HBP expressed in S. cerevisiae was functional in histone pre-mRNA processing, confirming that we have indeed identified the human HBP gene.     

Crosslinking of an iodo-uridine-RNA hairpin to a single site on the human U1A N-terminal RNA binding domain.

The N-terminal RNA binding domain (RBD) of the human U1A snRNP protein binds tightly and specifically to an RNA hairpin that contains a 10-nucleotide loop. The protein is one of a class of RNA binding proteins that adopts a beta alpha beta beta alpha beta global fold, which in turn forms a four-stranded antiparallel beta-sheet. This sheet forms the primary binding surface for the RNA, as shown by the crosslinking results described here, and in more detail by a recently described co-crystal of this RBD with an RNA hairpin (Oubridge C, et al., 1994, Nature 372:432-438). The RNA hairpin sequence used in the crosslinking experiments, containing 5-iodo-uridine, is a variant of the normal U1 snRNA sequence which is able to form a crosslink with the protein, in contrast to the wild-type sequence, which does not. This single uridine substitution in the 10-nucleotide loop is the site of cross-linking to one tyrosine (Tyr 13) in the beta 1 strand of the U1A N-terminal RBD. This same uridine is also crosslinked to a mutant Tyr 13 Phe RBD, at this Phe 13 substitution.     

Defining the orientation of the human U1A RBD1 on its UTR by tethered-EDTA(Fe) cleavage.

The N-terminal RNA binding domain of the human U1A protein (RBD1) specifically binds an RNA hairpin of U1 snRNA as well as two internal loops in the 3' UTR of its own mRNA. Here, a single cysteine has been introduced into Loop 1 of RBD1, which is subsequently used to attach (EDTA-2-aminoethyl) 2-pyridyl disulfide-Fe3+ (EPD-Fe). This EDTA-Fe derivative is used to generate hydroxyl radicals to cleave the proximal RNA sugar-phosphate backbone in the RNA-RBD complexes. RBD1(K20C)-EPD-Fe cleaves the 5' strand of the RNA hairpin stem, centered four base pairs away from the base of the loop, and cleaves the UTR in two places, again centered on the 5' side of the fourth base pair from each internal loop. These data, extrapolated to the position of Lys 20 in RBD1, orient the two proteins bound to the UTR, and provide direct biochemical evidence for the proposed model of the RBD1:UTR complex.     

Stability of single-nucleotide bulge loops embedded in a GAAA RNA hairpin stem

Forty-six RNA hairpins containing combinations of 3' or 5' bulge loops and a 3' or 5' fluorescein label were optically melted in 1 M NaCl, and the thermodynamic parameters ΔH°, ΔS°, ΔG°(37), and T(M) for each hairpin were determined. The bulge loops were of the group I variety, in which the identity of the bulge is known, and the group II variety, in which the bulged nucleotide is identical to one of its nearest neighbors, leading to ambiguity as to the exact position of the bulge. The fluorescein label at either the 3' end or 5' end of the hairpin did not significantly influence the stability of the hairpin. As observed with bulge loops inserted into a duplex motif, the insertion of a bulge loop into the stem of a hairpin loop was destabilizing. The model developed to predict the influence of bulge loops on the stability of duplex formation was extended to predict the influence of bulge loops on hairpin stability. Specifically, the influence of the bulge is related to the stability of the hairpin stem distal from the hairpin loop.     

Sequence dependence of the stability of RNA hairpin molecules with six nucleotide loops

Thermodynamic parameters are reported for hairpin formation in 1 M NaCl by RNA sequence of the types GCGXUAAUYCGC and GGUXUAAUYACC with Watson-Crick loop closure, where XY is the set of 10 possible mismatch base pairs. A nearest-neighbor analysis of the data indicates the free energy of loop formation at 37 degrees C varies from 3.1 to 5.1 kcal/mol. These results agree with the model previously developed [Vecenie, C. J., and Serra, M. J. (2004) Biochemistry 43, 11813] to predict the stability of RNA hairpin loops: DeltaG degrees (37L(n) = DeltaG degrees (37i(n) + DeltaG degrees (37MM) - 0.8 (if first mismatch is GA or UU) - 0.8 (if first mismatch is GG and loop is closed on the 5' side by a purine). Here, DeltaG degrees (37i(n) is the free energy for initiating a loop of n nucleotides, and DeltaG degrees (37MM) is the free energy for the interaction of the first mismatch with the closing base pair. Thermodynamic parameters are also reported for hairpin formation in 1 M NaCl by RNA sequence of the types GACGXUAAUYUGUC and GGUXUAAUYGCC with GU base pair closure, where XY is the set of 10 possible mismatch base pairs. A nearest-neighbor analysis of the data indicates the free energy of loop formation at 37 degrees C varies from 3.6 to 5.3 kcal/mol. These results allow the development of a model for predicting the stability of hairpin loops closed by GU base pairs. DeltaG degrees (37L(n) (kcal/mol) = DeltaG degrees (37i(n) - 0.8 (if the first mismatch is GA) - 0.8 (if the first mismatch is GG and the loop is closed on the 5' side by a purine). Note that for these hairpins, the stability of the loops does not depend on DeltaG degrees (37MM). For hairpin loops closed by GU base pairs, the DeltaG degrees (37i(n) values, when n = 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8, are 4.9, 5.0, 4.6, 5.0, and 4.8 kcal/mol, respectively. The model gives good agreement when tested against six naturally occurring hairpin sequences. Thermodynamic values for terminal mismatches adjacent to GC, GU, and UG base pairs are also reported.     

Mutational definition of RNA-binding and protein-protein interaction domains of heterogeneous nuclear RNP C1

The heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoprotein (hn- RNP) C proteins, among the most abundant pre-mRNA-binding proteins in the eukaryotic nucleus, have a single RNP motif RNA-binding domain. The RNA-binding domain (RBD) is comprised of approximately 80-100 amino acids, and its structure has been determined. However, relatively little is known about the role of specific amino acids of the RBD in the binding to RNA. We have devised a phage display-based screening method for the rapid identification of amino acids in hnRNP C1 that are essential for its binding to RNA. The identified mutants were further tested for binding to poly(U)-Sepharose, a substrate to which wild type hnRNP C1 binds with high affinity. We found both previously predicted, highly conserved residues as well as additional residues in the RBD to be essential for C1 RNA binding. We also identified three mutations in the leucine-rich C1-C1 interaction domain near the carboxyl terminus of the protein that both abolished C1 oligomerization and reduced RNA binding. These results demonstrate that although the RBD is the primary determinant of C1 RNA binding, residues in the C1-C1 interaction domain also influence the RNA binding activity of the protein. The experimental approach we described should be generally applicable for the screening and identification of amino acids that play a role in the binding of proteins to nucleic acid substrates.     

Extra stable 2',5'-linked RNA loops

We prepared hairpins that differ in the connectivity of phosphodiester linkages in the loop (RNA vs 2', 5'-RNA). We find that the stability of the extra stable RNA hairpin 5'-rGGAC(UUCG)GUCC-3' is the same as that observed for the hairpin containing a 2',5'RNA loop, i.e. 5'-rGGAC(UUCG)GUCC-3' (where UUCG = U2'p5'U2'p5' C2'p5'G2'p5'). Also significant is the finding that when the stem is duplex DNA, duplex 2',5'-RNA, or DNA:2',5'-RNA, hairpins with the UUCG loop are more stable than those with UUCG loop.     

A test of the model to predict unusually stable RNA hairpin loop stability

To investigate the accuracy of a model [Giese et al., 1998, Biochemistry37:1094-1100 and Mathews et al., 1999, JMol Biol 288:911-940] that predicts the stability of RNA hairpin loops, optical melting studies were conducted on sets of hairpins previously determined to have unusually stable thermodynamic parameters. Included were the tetraloops GNRA and UNCG (where N is any nucleotide and R is a purine), hexaloops with UU first mismatches, and the hairpin loop of the iron responsive element, CAGUGC. The experimental values for the GNRA loops are in excellent agreement (deltaG degrees 37 within 0.2 kcal/mol and melting temperature (TM) within 4 degrees C) with the values predicted by the model. When the UNCG hairpin loops are treated as tetraloops, and a bonus of 0.8 kcal/mol included in the prediction to account for the extra stable first mismatch (UG), the measured and predicted values are also in good agreement (deltaG degrees 37 within 0.7 kcal/mol and TM within 3 degrees C). Six hairpins with unusually stable UU first mismatches also gave good agreement with the predictions (deltaG degrees 37 within 0.5 kcal/mol and TM within 8 degrees C), except for hairpins closed by wobble base pairs. For these hairpins, exclusion of the additional stabilization term for UU first mismatches improved the prediction (AG degrees 37 within 0.1 kcal/mol and TM within 3 degrees C). Hairpins with the iron-responsive element loop were not predicted well by the model, as measured deltaG degrees 37 values were at least 1 kcal/mol greater than predicted.     

Characterization of RNA hairpin loop stability.

Fifteen RNA hairpins that share the same stem sequence and have homopolymer loops of A, C and U residues which vary in length from three to nine nucleotides were synthesized and their thermal stabilities determined. Tm varies as a function of loop size but is almost independent of loop composition. Loops of four or five nucleotides are found to be the most stable loop size. This is consistent with the observation that four-membered loops are the most prevalent loop size in 16S-like RNAs. The contribution of each loop to hairpin stability was calculated by subtracting the known contribution of the helical stem. These data should be useful for predicting the stability of other hairpins.     

Functional importance of conserved nucleotides at the histone RNA 3' processing site.

Histone pre-mRNA 3' processing is controlled by a hairpin element preceding the processing site that interacts with a hairpin-binding protein (HBP) and a downstream spacer element that serves as anchoring site for the U7 snRNP. In addition, the nucleotides following the hairpin and surrounding the processing site (ACCCA'CA) are conserved among vertebrate histone genes. Single to triple nucleotide mutations of this sequence were tested for their ability to be processed in nuclear extract from animal cells. Changing the first four nucleotides had no qualitative and little if any quantitative effects on histone RNA 3' processing in mouse K21 cell extract, where processing of this gene is virtually independent of the HBP. A gel mobility shift assay revealing HBP interactions and a processing assay in HeLa cell extract (where the contribution of HBP to efficient processing is more important) showed that only one of these mutations, predicted to extend the hairpin by one base pair, affected the interaction with HBP. Mutations in the next three nucleotides affected both the cleavage efficiency and the choice of processing sites. Analysis of these novel sites indicated a preference for the nucleotide 5' of the cleavage site in the order A > C > U > G. Moreover, a guanosine in the 3' position inhibited cleavage. The preference for an A is shared with the cleavage/polyadenylation reaction, but the preference order for the other nucleotides is different [Chen F, MacDonald CC, Wilusz J, 1995, Nucleic Acids Res 23:2614-2620].     

Thermodynamic parameters for loop formation in RNA and DNA hairpin tetraloops.

We determined the melting temperatures (Tm) and thermodynamic parameters of 15 RNA and 19 DNA hairpins at 1 M NaCl, 0.01 M sodium phosphate, 0.1 mM EDTA, at pH 7. All these hairpins have loops of four bases, the most common loop size in 16S and 23S ribosomal RNAs. The RNA hairpins varied in loop sequence, loop-closing base pair (A.U, C.G, or G.C), base sequence of the stem, and stem size (four or five base pairs). The DNA hairpins varied in loop sequence, loop-closing base pair (C.G, or G.C), and base sequence of the four base-pair stem. Thermodynamic properties of a hairpin may be represented by nearest-neighbor interactions of the stem plus contributions from the loop. Thus, we obtained thermodynamic parameters for the formation of RNA and DNA tetraloops. For the tetraloops we studied, a free energy of loop formation (at 37 degrees C) of about +3 kcal/mol is most common for either RNA or DNA. There are extra stable loops with delta G degrees 37 near +1 kcal/mol, but the sequences are not necessarily the same for RNA and DNA. The closing base pair is also important; changing from C.G to G.C lowered the stability of several tetraloops in both RNA and DNA. These values will be useful in predicting RNA and DNA secondary structures.     

Recognition of pre-formed and flexible elements of an RNA stem-loop by nucleolin

Nucleolin is an abundant nucleolar protein which is essential for ribosome biogenesis. The first two of its four tandem RNA-binding domains (RBD12) specifically recognize a stem-loop structure containing a conserved UCCCGA sequence in the loop called the nucleolin-recognition element (NRE). We have determined the structure of the consensus SELEX NRE (sNRE) by NMR spectroscopy. In both the free and bound RNA the top part of the stem forms a loop E (or S-turn) motif. In the absence of protein, the structure of the hairpin loop is not well defined due to conformational heterogeneity, and appears to be in equilibrium between two families of conformations. Titrations of RBD1, RBD2, and RBD12 with the sNRE show that specific binding requires RBD12. In complex with RBD12, the hairpin loop interacts specifically with the protein and adopts a well-defined structure which shares some of the features of the free form. The loop E motif also has specific interactions with the protein. Implications of these findings for the mechanism of recognition of RNA structures by modular proteins are discussed.     

Interactions of hairpin oligo-2'-O-methylribonucleotides containing methylphosphonate linkages with HIV TAR RNA

Methylphosphonate-modified oligo-2'-O-methylribonucleotides 15-20 nucleotides (nt) in length were prepared whose sequences are complementary to the 5' and 3' sides of the upper hairpin of HIV trans-acting response element (TAR) RNA. These anti-TAR oligonucleotides (ODNs) form stable hairpins whose melting temperatures (Tm) range from 55 degrees C to 80 degrees C. Despite their rather high thermal stabilities, the hairpin oligo-2'-O-methylribonucleotides formed very stable complexes with TAR RNA, with dissociation constants in the nanomolar concentration range at 37 degrees C. The affinities of the hairpin oligomers for TAR RNA were influenced by the positions of the methylphosphonate linkages. The binding affinity was reduced approximately 17-fold by the presence of two methylphosphonate linkages in the TAR loop complementary region (TLCR) of the oligomer, whereas methylphosphonate linkages outside this region increased binding affinity approximately 3-fold. The configurations of the methylphosphonate linkages in the TLCR also affected binding affinity, with the RpRp isomer showing significantly higher binding than the SpSp isomer. In addition to serving as probes of the interactions between the oligomer and TAR RNA, the presence of the methylphosphonate linkages in combination with the hairpin structure increases the resistance of these oligomers to degradation by exonucleases found in mammalian serum. The combination of high binding affinity and nuclease resistance of the hairpin ODNs containing methylphosphonate linkages suggests their potential utility as antisense compounds.     

Solution structure of the two N-terminal RNA-binding domains of nucleolin and NMR study of the interaction with its RNA target

Nucleolin is an abundant 70 kDa nucleolar protein involved in many aspects of ribosomal RNA biogenesis. The central region of nucleolin contains four tandem consensus RNA-binding domains (RBD). The two most N-terminal domains (RBD12) bind with nanomolar affinity to an RNA stem-loop containing the consensus sequence UCCCGA in the loop. We have determined the solution structure of nucleolin RBD12 in its free form and have studied its interaction with a 22 nt RNA stem-loop using multidimensional NMR spectroscopy. The two RBDs adopt the expected beta alpha beta beta alpha beta fold, but the position of the beta 2 strand in both domains differs from what was predicted from sequence alignments. RBD1 and RBD2 are significantly different from each others and this is likely important in their sequence specific recognition of the RNA. RBD1 has a longer alpha-helix 1 and a shorter beta 2-beta 3 loop than RBD2, and differs from most other RBDs in these respects. The two RBDs are separated by a 12 amino acid flexible linker and do not interact with one another in the free protein. This linker becomes ordered when RBD12 binds to the RNA. Analysis of the observed NOEs between the protein and the RNA indicates that both RBDs interact with the RNA loop via their beta-sheet. Each domain binds residues on one side of the loop; specifically, RBD2 contacts the 5' side and RBD1 contacts the 3'.     

Asymmetric structure of five and six membered DNA hairpin loops

The tertiary structure of nucleic acid hairpins was elucidated by means of the accessibility of the single-strand-specific nuclease from mung bean. This molecular probe has proven especially useful in determining details of the structural arrangement of the nucleotides within a loop. In this study 3'-labeling is introduced to complement previously used 5'-labeling in order to assess and to exclude possible artifacts of the method. Both labeling procedures result in mutually consistent cleavage patterns. Therefore, methodological artifacts can be excluded and the potential of the nuclease as structural probe is increased. DNA hairpins with five and six membered loops reveal an asymmetric loop structure with a sharp bend of the phosphate-ribose backbone between the second and third nucleotide on the 3'-side of a loop. These hairpin structures differ from smaller loops with 3 or 4 members, which reveal this type of bend between the first and second 3' nucleotide, and resemble with respect to the asymmetry anticodon loops of tRNA.Abbreviations The hairpin oligonucleotides are indicated by hp hairpin followed by the loop sequence, starting at the 5'-end, in parenthesis; d for deoxy is omitted for clarity