Evolution of collagen IV genes from a 54-base pair exon: A role for introns in gene evolution

The exon structure of the collagen IV gene provides a striking example for collagen evolution and the role of introns in gene evolution. Collagen IV, a major component of basement membranes, differs from the fibrillar collagens in that it contains numerous interruptions in the triple helical Gly-X-Y repeat domain. We have characterized all 47 exons in the mouse alpha 2(IV) collagen gene and find two 36-, two 45-, and one 54-bp exons as well as one 99- and three 108-bp exons encoding the Gly-X-Y repeat sequence. All these exons sizes are also found in the fibrillar collagen genes. Strikingly, of the 24 interruption sequences present in the alpha 2-chain of mouse collagen IV, 11 are encoded at the exon/intron borders of the gene, part of one interruption sequence is encoded by an exon of its own, and the remaining interruptions are encoded within the body of exons. In such "fusion exons" the Gly-X-Y encoding domain is also derived from 36-, 45-, or 54-bp sequence elements. These data support the idea that collagen IV genes evolved from a primordial 54-bp coding unit. We furthermore interpret these data to suggest that the interruption sequences in collagen IV may have evolved from introns, presumably by inactivation of splice site signals, following which intronic sequences could have been recruited into exons. We speculated that this mechanism could provide a role for introns in gene evolution in general.     

Isolation and partial characterization of the entire human pro alpha 1(II) collagen gene.

Using a cDNA probe specific for the bovine Type II procollagen, a series of overlapping genomic clones containing 45 kb of contiguous human DNA have been isolated. Sequencing of a 54 bp exon, number 29, provided direct evidence that the recombinant clones bear human Type II collagen sequences. Localization of the 5' and 3' ends of the gene indicated that the human Type II collagen gene is 30 kb in size. This value is significantly higher than that of the homologous avian gene. The segregation of a polymorphic restriction site in informative families conclusively demonstrated that the Type II gene is found in a single copy in the human haploid genome. Finally, sequencing of a triple helical domain exon has confirmed that a rearrangement leading to the fusion of two exons occurred in the pro alpha 1(I) gene, following the divergence of the fibrillar collagens.     

Complete sequence of the 23-kilobase human COL9A3 gene. Detection of Gly-X-Y triplet deletions that represent neutral variants.

We report the complete sequence of the human COL9A3 gene that encodes the alpha3 chain of heterotrimeric type IX collagen, a member of the fibril-associated collagens with interrupted triple helices family of collagenous proteins. Nucleotide sequencing defined over 23,000 base pairs (bp) of the gene and about 3000 bp of the 5'-flanking sequences. The gene contains 32 exons. The domain and exon organization of the gene is almost identical to a related gene, the human COL9A2 gene. However, exon 2 of the COL9A3 gene codes for one -Gly-X-Y- triplet less than exon 2 of the COL9A2 gene. The difference is compensated by an insertion of 9 bp coding for an additional triplet in exon 4 of the COL9A3 gene. As a result, the number of -Gly-X-Y- repeats in the third collagenous domain remains the same in both genes and ensures the formation of an in-register triple helix. In the course of screening this gene for mutations, heterozygosity for separate 9-bp deletions within the COL1 domain were identified in two kindreds. In both instances, the deletions did not co-segregate with any disease phenotype, suggesting that they were neutral variants. In contrast, similar deletions in triple helical domain of type I collagen are lethal. To study whether alpha3(IX) chains with the deletion will participate in the formation of correctly folded heterotrimeric type IX collagen, we expressed mutant alpha3 chains together with normal alpha1 and alpha2 chains in insect cells. We show here that despite the deletion, mutant alpha3 chains were secreted as heterotrimeric, triple helical molecules consisting of three alpha chains in a 1:1:1 ratio. The results suggest that the next noncollagenous domain (NC2) is capable of correcting the alignment of the alpha chains, and this ensures the formation of an in-register triple helix.     

Alpha 1 type IV collagen gene evolved differently from fibrillar collagen genes

Type IV collagen is a major structural component in basement membranes. It is considerably different from the fibrillar collagens, types I-III. For example, unlike fibrillar collagens, the triple helical domain of type IV collagen is frequently interrupted by nonhelical regions. In this report, we demonstrate several overlapping genomic clones which cover most of the mouse alpha 1(IV) chain. Electron microscopic analysis of R-loops revealed that there were at least 28 exons within 35 kilobases of the gene segment. The sizes of six exons were determined by DNA sequence analysis to be 81, 178, 134, 73, 129, and 213 base pairs. These sizes do not appear to be related to the 54-base pair coding unit which is characteristic of fibrillar collagen exons, suggesting that the alpha 1 type IV collagen gene evolved differently from the fibrillar collagen genes.     

The triple-helical domain of alpha 2(VI) collagen is encoded by 19 short exons that are multiples of 9 base pairs

We have analyzed the structure of the gene coding for the alpha 2(VI) subunit of chicken type VI collagen. The triple-helical domain of this polypeptide is encoded by 19 short exons distributed over 10 kilobase pairs of genomic DNA. These exons begin with the codon for glycine and end with the codon for the Y amino acid of the collagenous triplet Gly-X-Y. The sizes of the exons are integral multiples of 9 base pairs (bp) (27, 36, 45, 54, 63, and 90 bp), the predominant one being 63 bp. The organization of this type VI collagen gene is therefore quite different from that of the fibrillar collagen genes which have evolved by duplication of a primordial 54-bp unit. It also differs from that of the basement membrane collagen genes whose exon/intron boundaries often split the codons for amino acids.     

The type X collagen gene. Intron sequences split the 5'-untranslated region and separate the coding regions for the non-collagenous amino-terminal and triple-helical domains

Type X collagen, expressed by hypertrophic chondrocytes, consists of homotrimeric molecules with subunits that are only about one-half the size of the polypeptides of fibrillar collagens. In this report we describe for the first time the complete primary structure of type X collagen, based on cloning and sequencing of cDNA and genomic DNA. A comparison between the nucleotide sequences of the cDNA and genomic DNA clones has also allowed determination of the complete exon structure of the type X collagen gene. Our results demonstrate that the primary translation product of the chicken type X collagen mRNA is 682 amino acid residues long with a calculated molecular mass of 67,317 Da for the nonhydroxylated form. This calculated molecular mass is in excellent agreement with the observed electrophoretic mobility of cell-free translation products with both poly(A)+ RNA isolated from chondrocytes as well as RNA transcribed in vitro from a full length cDNA construct. It is also in agreement with the observed size of type X collagen polypeptides isolated from the media of cultured hypertrophic chondrocytes. Thus, our data exclude the possibility of a high molecular weight precursor form of type X collagen. Our results also confirm that the chicken type X gene has a most unusual exon structure when compared to other vertebrate collagen genes. The gene has only three exons. One exon (97 base pairs (bp)), codes for most of the 5'-untranslated region of the mRNA, a second exon (159 bp) codes for the signal peptide and a short non-triple-helical domain, while the third exon (2136 bp) contains the coding region for the entire triple-helix and a large non-triple-helical carboxyl domain.     

The exon organization of the triple-helical coding regions of the human alpha 1(VI) and alpha 2(VI) collagen genes is highly similar.

The alpha 1(VI) and alpha 2(VI) chains, two of the three constituent chains of type VI collagen, are highly similar in size and domain structure. They are encoded by single-copy genes residing in close proximity on human chromosome 21. To study the evolution of the type VI collagen genes, we have isolated and characterized genomic clones coding for the triple-helical domains of the human alpha 1(VI) and alpha 2(VI) chains, which consist of 336 and 335 amino acid residues, respectively. Nucleotide sequencing indicates that, in both genes, the exons are multiples of 9 bp in length (including 27, 36, 45, 54, 63, and 90 bp) except for those encoding for regions with triple-helical interruptions. In addition, the introns are positioned between complete codons. The most predominant exon size is 63 bp, instead of 54 bp as seen in the fibrillar collagen genes. Of particular interest is the finding that the exon structures of the alpha 1(VI) and alpha 2(VI) genes are almost identical. A significant deviation is that a segment of 30 amino acid residues is encoded by two exons of 54 and 36 bp in the alpha 1(VI) gene, but by a single exon of 90 bp in the alpha 2(VI) gene. The exon arrangement therefore provides further evidence that the two genes have evolved from tandem gene duplication. Furthermore, comparison with the previously reported gene structure of the chick alpha 2(VI) chain indicates that the exon structure for the triple-helical domain of the alpha 2(VI) collagen is strictly conserved between human and chicken.     

Completion of the intron-exon structure of the gene for human type II procollagen (COL2A1): variations in the nucleotide sequences of the alleles from three chromosomes

A new procedure for preparing cosmid libraries was used to isolate three alleles for the human gene for type II procollagen (COL2A1). Over 20,000 bp of one allele were completely sequenced and over 10,000 bp of the two other alleles were sequenced. The data located and defined 26 exons and introns of the gene not previously analyzed. The results completed the structure of the gene except for the newly discovered exon 2A that undergoes alternative splicing (Ryan et al., 1990, Trans. Ann. Meet. Orthop. Res. Soc. 15:65). As a result, it is the most completely known structure of a gene for a human fibrillar collagen. The results confirm the previous impression that exon sizes are highly conserved among the genes for the three major fibrillar collagens. Comparison of clones from the three alleles defined five neutral variations in coding sequences and seven variations in the intron that also are probably neutral variations. The normal sequences and the variations in sequences will be important for identifying different alleles and haplotypes of the gene and for the analysis of genetic mutations in the gene that cause diseases of cartilage such as chondrodysplasias and osteoarthritis.     

Genomic organization of the human COL3A1 and COL5A2 genes: COL5A2 has evolved differently than the other minor fibrillar collagen genes.

We report here on the complete structure of the human COL3A1 and COL5A2 genes. Collagens III and V, together with collagens I, II and XI make up the group of fibrillar collagens, all of which share a similar structure and function; however, despite the similar size of the major triple-helical domain, the number of exons coding for the domain differs between the genes for the major fibrillar collagens characterized so far (I, II, and III) and the minor ones (V and XI). The main triple-helical domain being encoded by 49-50 exons, including the junction exons, in the COL5A1, COL11A1 and COL11A2 genes, but by 43-44 exons in the genes for the major fibrillar collagens. Characterization of the genomic structure of the COL3A1 gene confirmed its association with the major fibrillar collagen genes, but surprisingly, the genomic organization of the COL5A2 gene was found to be similar to that of the COL3A1 gene. We also confirmed that the two genes are located in tail-to-tail orientation with an intergenic distance of approximately 22 kb. Phylogenetic analysis suggested that they have evolved from a common ancestor gene. Analysis of the genomic sequences identified a novel single nucleotide polymorphism and a novel dinucleotide repeat. These polymorphisms should be useful for linkage analysis of the Ehlers-Danlos syndrome and related disorders.     

Genomic organization of the bovine alpha-S1 casein gene.

We report the sequence of the complete bovine alpha-s1 casein gene eludicating for the first time the genomic organization of an alpha-s type casein gene. Extending over 17508 bp the gene is split into 19 exons, ranging in size from 24 bp to 385 bp. Except for the translational stop codon not a single coding triplet of the alpha-s1 reading frame is disrupted by any of the splice junctions, which all confirm to known splice consensus sequences. Nine out of 16 coding exons begin with a 'GAX' codon, specific for glutamate. Splicing of this codon from exon 10 to the preceding exon creates a major phosphorylation site. An intron-exon-intron stretch of 154 bp comprising exons 10 and 13 is found precisely duplicated. Associated with the gene, copies of 8 atriodactyla retroposons are found, 6 of which are interspersed into the sequences of the three longest introns. We discuss the possibility that three functional parts of the gene have been recruited and evolutionary conserved at a time before gene diversification gave rise to the separate evolution of alpha- and beta-type casein-genes.     

The complete intron/exon structure of Ephydatia mülleri fibrillar collagen gene suggests a mechanism for the evolution of an ancestral gene module

We have completed the analysis of a genomic clone, G238, that contains most of the coding region of the sponge COLF1 fibrillar collagen gene. The main triple helical domain is encoded by 31 exons. Except for the 5 junction exon and the two last 3 exons (126 and 18 base pairs), all these exons are related to a 54-bp unit and begin with an intact glycine codon. A good correlation can be made between this sponge gene and a vertebrate fibrillar collagen gene, revealing the high conservation of the members of this family during evolution. The reconstitution of an ancestral collagen gene can be made by considering all the exon/intron junctions of these genes. We suggest that such an ancestral gene arose from multiple duplications of a 54-bp exon and a (54 + 45)-bp module.Abbreviations used bp base pair(s) - kb kilobase(s) - C-protease the enzyme that cleaves the carboxyl-terminal propeptide     

Structural organization of a 17 KB segment of the alpha 2 collagen gene: evaluation by R loop mapping.

A recombinant phage, SpC3, containing a 17 kb genomic DNA insert representing approximately 60% of the 3' portion of the sheep collagen alpha 2 gene, was evaluated by electron microscopic R loop analysis. A minimum of 17 intervening sequences (introns) and 18 alpha 2 coding sequences (exons) were mapped. With the exception of the 850 base pair exon located at the extreme 3' end of the insert, all exons contained 250 base pairs or less. The total length of all the exons in SpC3 was 3,014 base pairs. The length distribution of the 17 introns ranged from 300 to 1600 base pairs; together, all of the introns comprised 14,070 base pairs of SpC3 DNA. Thus, the DNA region required for coding the interspersed 3 kb of alpha 2 collagen genetic information was 5.6 fold longer than the corresponding alpha 2 mRNA coding sequences.     

Complete Structural Organization of the Human α1(V) Collagen Gene (COL5A1): Divergence from the Conserved Organization of Other Characterized Fibrillar Collagen Genes

Genes that encode the vertebrate fibrillar collagen types I–III have previously been shown to share a highly conserved intron/exon organization, thought to reflect common ancestry and evolutionary pressures at the protein level. We report here the complete intron/exon organization ofCOL5A1,the human gene that encodes the α1 chain of fibrillar collagen type V. The structure ofCOL5A1is shown to be considerably diverged from the conserved structure of the genes for fibrillar collagen types I–III.COL5A1has 66 exons, which is greater than the number of exons found in the genes for collagen types I–III. The increased number of exons is partly due to the increased size of the pro-α1(V) N-propeptide, relative to the sizes of the N-propeptides of the types I–III procollagen molecules. In addition, however, the increased number of exons is due to differences in the intron/exon organization of the triple-helix coding region ofCOL5A1compared to the organization of the triple-helix coding regions of the genes for collagen types I–III. Of particular interest is the increase of 54 bp exons in this region ofCOL5A1,strongly supporting the proposal that the triple-helix coding regions of fibrillar collagen genes evolved from duplication of a 54 bp primordial genetic element. Moreover, comparison of the structure ofCOL5A1to the highly conserved structure of the genes of collagen types I–III provides insights into the probable structure of the ancestral gene that gave rise to what appears to be two classes of vertebrate fibrillar collagen genes.     

The pro alpha 2(V) collagen gene is evolutionarily related to the major fibrillar-forming collagens.

A number of overlapping cDNA clones, covering 5.2 kb of sequences which code for the human pro alpha 2(V) collagen chain, have been isolated. Analysis of the structural data have indicated a close evolutionary kinship between the pro alpha 2(V) chain and the major fibrillar collagen types. Isolation and analysis of an 8 kb genomic fragment has further supported this notion by revealing a homologous arrangement of nine triple-helical domain exons. These studies have therefore provided conclusive evidence which categorizes the Type V collagen as a member of the Group 1 molecules, or fibrillar-forming collagens.     

Cloning and characterization of an alpha 1-antitrypsin like gene 12 KB downstream of the genuine alpha 1-antitrypsin gene

Cosmid clones containing alpha 1-antitrypsin (alpha 1AT) gene sequences were observed to contain alpha 1AT-like sequences approximately 12 kb downstream of the authentic alpha 1AT gene. Restriction mapping suggested the alpha 1AT-like gene lacks promoter sequences. Cosmid clones from one library contained a truncated alpha 1AT-like gene with a deletion encompassing 1745 bp, including the whole exon IV and part of exon V. Sequencing of exon II of this truncated gene revealed a nucleotide homology of 76% but included critical mutations in the start codon (ATG - greater than ATA) and the 3' exon-intron junction. These results strongly suggest that the truncated alpha 1AT-like gene is a pseudogene, which is present at a frequency of 0.30 in the Dutch population.     

Complete primary structure of human collagen alpha 1 (V) chain

Several cDNA clones, encoding prepropeptide of human collagen alpha 1(V) chain, have been isolated. The prepropeptide (1838 amino acids length) of the alpha 1(V) chain was composed of a putative signal peptide, a large NH2-terminal noncollagenous region, a main collagenous region, and a COOH-terminal noncollagenous region. The signal peptide contained many leucine residues. The NH2-terminal noncollagenous region was much larger than those of the other collagens and had a region homologous to the COOH-terminal domain of laminin A chain, but it did not contain a cysteine-rich region that was maintained in the region of the other collagens. This region also contained probable tyrosine sulfation sites, and short collagenous sequences that were interrupted by three noncollagenous segments. The main collagenous region of the alpha 1(V) chain consisted of 338 repeats of Gly-X-Y-triplet. This region had a high degree (82%) of homology with the amino acids of the collagen alpha 1(XI) chain. The COOH-terminal noncollagenous region resembled that of the alpha 1(XI) chain, too, and 8 residues of cysteine that were important for the formation of the triple helix structure of collagens were observed. These results suggest that the alpha 1(V) chain belongs to the fibrillar collagen relative to the alpha 1(XI) chain, but codon usage of the alpha 1(V) cDNA was clearly different from those of the other fibrillar collagens including the alpha 1(XI), while it was similar to type IV collagen. This result supposes a different evolution of the alpha 1(V) gene from those of the other fibrillar collagens.