Minding the gap: frequency of indels in mtDNA control region sequence data and influence on population genetic analyses

Insertions and deletions (indels) result in sequences of various lengths when homologous gene regions are compared among individuals or species. Although indels are typically phylogenetically informative, occurrence and incorporation of these characters as gaps in intraspecific population genetic data sets are rarely discussed. Moreover, the impact of gaps on estimates of fixation indices, such as F(ST), has not been reviewed. Here, I summarize the occurrence and population genetic signal of indels among 60 published studies that involved alignments of multiple sequences from the mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) control region of vertebrate taxa. Among 30 studies observing indels, an average of 12% of both variable and parsimony-informative sites were composed of these sites. There was no consistent trend between levels of population differentiation and the number of gap characters in a data block. Across all studies, the average influence on estimates of PhiST was small, explaining only an additional 1.8% of among population variance (range 0.0-8.0%). Studies most likely to observe an increase in PhiST with the inclusion of gap characters were those with < 20 variable sites, but a near equal number of studies with few variable sites did not show an increase. In contrast to studies at interspecific levels, the influence of indels for intraspecific population genetic analyses of control region DNA appears small, dependent upon total number of variable sites in the data block, and related to species-specific characteristics and the spatial distribution of mtDNA lineages that contain indels.     

Contrasting levels of genetic differentiation among populations of wolverines (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Gulo gulo</Emphasis>) from northern Canada revealed by nuclear and mitochondrial loci

Habitat loss, fragmentation, overharvest, and other anthropogenic factors have resulted in population and distribution declines for North American wolverines (Gulo gulo). Currently, wolverines east of the Hudson Bay are endangered and possibly extinct, whereas the status of wolverines throughout the remaining Holarctic is vulnerable. Three previous studies using nuclear loci have detected little to no significant structuring among wolverines sampled across northern Canada. Based on these results it has been suggested that wolverines in northern Canada represent a single, panmictic population. However, as has been shown in numerous studies, in cases of female site fidelity, it is possible to have demographically autonomous populations even with male-biased gene flow. To better assess the genetic structure of wolverines in northern Canada, we examined nine microsatellite loci and DNA sequence variation from a 200 bp fragment of the mitochondrial (mtDNA) control region for 270 wolverines from nine collecting areas representing three regions of northern Canada. In agreement with previous studies, microsatellite analyses revealed a lack of significant population substructure (F _ST=0.0004). However, analysis of molecular variance, comparisons of pairwise F _ST values and nested-clade analysis of the mtDNA data revealed considerable genetic structuring among samples of wolverines from these three regions of northern Canada. These mitochondrial data provide evidence that wolverines in Canada are genetically structured due to female philopatry. The contrasting patterns of genetic differentiation based on nuclear and mitochondrial data highlight the importance of examining both nuclear and mitochondrial loci when attempting to elucidate patterns of genetic structure.     

The impact of stocking on the genetic structure of European grayling <Emphasis Type="Italic">Thymallus thymallus</Emphasis>, Salmonidae) in two alpine rivers

The European grayling (Thymallus thymallus) is considered to be threatened in several European regions. In recent decades fishery managers have increasingly turned to stocking programs as one way to combat the negative effect that human influence has had on population densities. The present study surveyed the genetic structure of two Danube drainage populations at the Inn and Drau rivers, in Austria, on the basis of mtDNA sequences. Data were placed in the context of the phylogeographic structure of European Thymallus and thus could reveal unexpected geographical mixing due to stocking with allochthonous individuals. Our analyses revealed that regular stocking of fish not originating from their natal Rivers has left genetic traces in both systems surveyed. These traces may be classified as marginal for the Inn river and its tributaries in which 97% of the graylings investigated carried haplotypes belonging to the northern alpine lineage, corresponding to the region through which the Inn flows. In contrast, the genetic composition of the Drau population, situated in the southern Alps, has been seriously altered through the stocking of fish belonging to the northern alpine mtDNA lineage as only 62% of the fishes sampled carried haplotypes representing the native southern alpine lineage.     

Genetic divergence, phylogeography and conservation units of giant tortoises from Santa Cruz and Pinzón, Galápagos Islands

Island radiations can offer challenging systemsfor the implementation of conservation policiesbecause descendent populations may exhibitdifferent levels of adaptive divergence,reproductive isolation, and phylogeneticdistinctiveness. This seems particularly truefor the endangered Galápagos gianttortoises (Geochelone nigra), whichcomprise a lineage that radiated rapidly andconcomitantly with the evolution of thearchipelago. We used mitochondrial DNAsequences and microsatellite markers toinvestigate the genetic structure, and toreconstruct genealogical relationships and thehistory of population colonization of gianttortoises from the Islands of Santa Cruz andPinzón, including samples of a basal taxonfrom the Island of San Cristóbal.Populations displayed marked geneticdivergence, contrasting demographic histories,and deep phylogeographic structure. The patternof diversification among populations wasconsistent with geological and biogeographichistory, and to some extent, with adaptive andmorphological divergence. Results stronglyindicate the presence of a minimum of fourconservation units with long-standingevolutionary separation: two in Santa Cruz, onein Pinzón, and one in San Cristóbal. Wepropose that these findings be effectivelyintegrated with other existing data by theappropriate environmental agencies to evaluatecurrent conservation efforts and implement newstrategies aimed at protecting the integrityand diversity of giant tortoise populations.     

Polyphyly of mtDNA lineages in the Russian sturgeon, Acipenser gueldenstaedtii: forensic and evolutionary implications

Molecular species identification methods are an important component of CITES monitoring programs for trade in sturgeon and caviar. To date, obtaining molecular evidence for distinguishing caviar from four closely related Eurasian sturgeon species Acipenser baerii (Siberian sturgeon), A. gueldenstaedtii (osetra), A. persicus (Persian sturgeon), A. naccarii (Italian sturgeon) remains problematic. Using approximately 2.3 kb of mtDNA sequence data (cytochrome b, NADH5, control region), we find this to be attributable to the polyphyletic nature of these mitochondrial DNA markers in the Russian sturgeon, A. gueldenstaedtii. Two mitochondrial lineages are present within this species: one is phylogenetically affiliated with A. persicus and A. naccarii, while the other clusters with A. baerii. These findings have a direct impact on molecular testing of commercial caviar and demonstrate the necessity of using large sample sizes when constructing forensic databases. Furthermore, the results affect current taxonomic designations for these species as well as hypotheses concerning their evolutionary origins.     

Genetic consequences of Pleistocene fragmentation: Isolation, drift, and loss of diversity in rock iguanas (Cyclura)

Pleistocene fragmentation of the Great BahamaBank resulted in one large and several smallpopulations of rock iguanas (Cycluracychlura). We explore patterns of geneticvariation within and among these islandpopulations using mitochondrial sequence data(partial ND4 to tRNA^Leu) in combinationwith eight polymorphic microsatellite loci (2to 10 alleles). Genetic data support twophylogeographically distinct groups, AndrosIsland and the Exuma cays. This resultconflicts with current subspecific taxonomy inwhich three subspecies are described. Analysesof allelic data indicate that most islandpopulations are currently demographicallyindependent. Pairwise Fst values between eightisland populations range from 0.18 to 0.63, and6 of 135 individuals are misassigned in anassignment test. Population-genetic diversityis characterized using standard measures suchas number of alleles and heterozygosity (H) inaddition to a normalized Shannon-Weaver indexof diversity (D). We find genetic diversity inthe Andros Island population comparable to thatin other non-piscine animals (avg. # ofalleles = 5, avg. H = 0.56, avg. D = 0.66) while inthe Exuma cays populations these measures aremuch lower (avg. # of alleles = 2.75–1.625, avg.H = 0.43–0.17, avg. D = 0.45–0.18). These dataare used to discuss conservation managementstrategies, including prioritization andtranslocation.     

Comparative phylogeography of Nearctic and Palearctic fishes

Combining phylogeographic data from mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) of Nearctic and Palearctic freshwater and anadromous fishes, we used a comparative approach to assess the influence of historical events on evolutionary patterns and processes in regional fish faunas. Specifically, we (i) determined whether regional faunas differentially affected by Pleistocene glaciations show predictable differences in phylogeographic patterns; (ii) evaluated how processes of divergence and speciation have been influenced by such differential responses; and (iii) assessed the general contribution of phylogeographic studies to conservation issues. Comparisons among case studies revealed fundamental differences in phylogeographic patterns among regional faunas. Tree topologies were typically deeper for species from nonglaciated regions compared to northern species, whereas species with partially glaciated ranges were intermediate in their characteristics. Phylogeographic patterns were strikingly similar among southern species, whereas species in glaciated areas showed reduced concordance. The extent and locations of secondary contact among mtDNA lineages varied greatly among northern species, resulting in reduced intraspecific concordance of genetic markers for some northern species. Regression analysis of phylogeographic data for 42 species revealed significant latitudinal shifts in intraspecific genetic diversity. Both relative nucleotide diversity and estimates of evolutionary effective population size showed significant breakpoints matching the median latitude for the southern limit of the Pleistocene glaciations. Similarly, analysis of clade depth of phylogenetically distinct lineages vs. area occupied showed that evolutionary dispersal rates of species from glaciated and nonglaciated regions differed by two orders of magnitude. A negative relationship was also found between sequence divergence among sister species as a function of their median distributional latitude, indicating that recent bursts of speciation events have occurred in deglaciated habitats. Phylogeographic evidence for parallel evolution of sympatric northern species pairs in postglacial times suggested that differentiation of cospecific morphotypes may be driven by ecological release. Altogether, these results demonstrate that comparative phylogeography can be used to evaluate not only phylogeographic patterns but also evolutionary processes. As well as having significant implications for conservation programs, this approach enables new avenues of research for examining the regional, historical, and ecological factors involved in shaping intraspecific genetic diversity.     

Identity of an endangered grasshopper (Acrididae: Brachaspis): Taxonomy, molecules and conservation

Brachaspis robustus is an endangeredgrasshopper endemic to South Island, NewZealand. It is both rare and localised;occupying low altitude floodplain terraces andbraided riverbeds of the Mackenzie Basin. Thisis in stark contrast to the two other speciesin this genus (B. nivalis and B.collinus) which occupy montane habitats.Mitochondrial and nuclear sequence data wereemployed to explore genetic diversity andphylogenetic relationships of populations ofBrachaspis with a view to establishingthe status of B. robustus. Molecularevidence indicates that Brachaspisprobably radiated during the Pliocene and thatdivisions within the genus relate more tospatial distribution developed during thePleistocene than to ecology. The mitochondrial(Cytochrome oxidase I) and nuclear (ITS)sequence data indicate that Brachaspisnivalis is divided into northern and southernpopulations. The northern clade is furthersubdivided geographically. The southern cladecomprises alpine populations of B.nivalis and includes the lowland B.robustus. Additionally, it is observed thatsome morphological features previously thoughtto be specific to B. robustus also occurin members of the southern B. nivalisclade. It is suggested that the taxon B.robustus should include all of the southernBrachaspis populations. But it is arguedthat the absence of genetic evidencedistinguishing the endangered population doesnot preclude it from conservation effort. Acombination of morphological and habitatpeculiarities indicate that the survival ofB. robustus (sensu lato) isimportant to the maintenance of diversity.