Fate of transforming DNA following uptake by competent Bacillus subtilis. I. Formation and properties of the donor-recipient complex

Following uptake by competent Bacillus subtilis, transforming DNA is converted to two distinct slowly sedimenting molecular forms which possess little transforming activity (eclipse). A few minutes after uptake is initiated, a physical complex of donor and recipient DNA begins to form. The recovery of donor transforming activity following eclipse, and the appearance of recombinant activity, previously reported by Venema, Pritchard &; Venema-Schröder (1965), is shown to be due to changes occurring in the donor—recipient complex. This complex exists transiently in a form with low recombinant-type transforming activity. This transient form may be one in which the donor and recipient components are joined non-covalently. The donor-recipient complex is shown to be a heteroduplex structure in which the donor moiety has an approximate molecular weight of 750,000.     

Fate of heterospecific transforming DNA bound to Streptococcus sanguis.

The fate of 3H-labeled str-r fus-s DNA from Streptococcus pneumoniae, bound after a 1-min uptake to 14C-labeled str-s fus-r S. sanguis recipients, was followed by techniques previously developed for analyzing the fate of homospecific DNA. Heterospecific S. pneumoniae DNA was bound and formed complexes with recipient protein in a manner similar to that of homospecific DNA but transformed relatively poorly. The rate at which complexed heterospecific DNA becomes physically associated with recipient DNA, and at which donor markers are integrated into the chromosome, was slower than in the case of homospecific DNA. In addition, about half of the heterospecific donor counts initially bound in trichloracetic acid-insoluble form were gradually solubilized and released from the cell. The association of heterospecific DNA with the recipient chromosome was more unstable than that involving homospecific DNA, since only associations of the former type were largely dissociated by isolation and resedimentation. The donor DNA-containing material so dissociated had the same sedimentation properties as complexed heterospecific DNA before association, indicating that the complex of single-stranded donor DNA and recipient protein formed on uptake moves as a whole from its site of formation to synapse with the chromosome.     

Fate of Transforming Deoxyribonucleate in Bacillus subtilis

The majority of donor deoxyribonucleate (DNA) at early stages after uptake was found in a complex with a cell component which changes its buoyant behavior on equilibrium density gradients. Analysis of the recipient cell lysates, after treatment to dissociate the complex, showed about two-thirds of the donor molecules in denatured form and the rest associated with recipient DNA. Incubation of cells after DNA uptake leads to the disappearance of denatured donor DNA and to the increase of donor label associated with recipient DNA. Some characteristics of a component from intact cells or spheroplasts with affinity for denatured Bacillus subtilis DNA are described.     

An unstable donor-recipient DNA complex in transformation of Bacillus subtilis.

Summary In re-extracted DNA obtained shortly after uptake of transforming DNA by Bacillus subtilis, increased amounts of donor DNA radioactivity banding at the position of donor-recipient DNA complex (DRC) are observed in CsCl gradients, if the cells are irradiated with high doses of UV prior to reextraction of the DNA. Qualitatively, the same phenomenon is observed if lysates of transforming cells are irradiated. UV-irradiation of lysates of competent cells to which single-stranded DNA is added after lysis, does not result in linkage of this DNA to the chromosomal DNA. Two observations argue in favour of the formation of a specific labile complex between donor and resident DNA during transformation. Firstly, heterologous donor DNA from Escherichia coli, although being processed to single-stranded DNA in competent B. subtilis, does not seem to be linked to the recipient chromosome upon UV-irradiation, and secondly, the labile complex of donor and recipient DNA can be stabilized by means of treatment of the lysates of transforming cells with 4, 5¹, 8-trimethylpsoralen in conjuction with long-wave ultra violet light irradiation. This indicates that base-pairing is involved in the formation of the complex. On the basis of these results we assume that the unstable complex of donor and recipient DNA is an early intermediate in genetic recombination during transformation.     

Single-stranded regions in transforming deoxyribonucleic acid after uptake by competent Haemophilus influenzae.

About 15% of donor deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) is single stranded immediately after uptake into competent Haemophilus influenzae wild-type cells, as judged by its sensitivity to S1 endonuclease. This amount decreases to 4 to 5% by 30 min after uptake. Mutants which are defective in the covalent association of recipient and donor DNA form little or no S1 endonuclease-sensitive donor. At 17 C donor DNA taken up by the wild type contains single-stranded regions although there is no observable association, either covalent or noncovalent. The single-stranded regions are at the ends of donor DNA molecules, as judged by the unchanged sedimentation velocity after S1 endonuclease digestion. The amount of single-stranded donor remains constant at 17 C for more than 60 min after uptake, suggesting that the decrease observed at 37 C is the result of association of single-stranded ends with single-stranded regions of recipient cell DNA. Three sequential steps necessary for the integration of donor DNA into recipient DNA are proposed: the synthesis of single-stranded regions in recipient DNA, the interaction of donor DNA with recipient DNA resulting in the production of single-stranded ends on donor DNA, and the stable pairing of homologous single-stranded regions.     

Integration and Repair of Ultraviolet-Irradiated Transforming Deoxyribonucleic Acid in Haemophilus influenzae

The extent of association between donor transforming deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) and recipient DNA in Haemophilus influenzae as a function of ultraviolet (UV) dose to the transforming DNA has been measured by isopycnic analysis of lysates of (3)H-labeled recipient cells exposed to DNA labeled with (32)P and heavy isotopes. Except for doses above 15,000 ergs/mm(2), the results of these measurements are in good agreement with previous estimates made by another technique. Experiments with a mutant temperature sensitive for DNA synthesis and another mutant defective in excision of pyrimidine dimers suggest that the discrepancy between the methods of high doses results from DNA synthesis, in which portions of the associated donor DNA containing pyrimidine dimers are excised and broken down, and the components are reutilized for synthesis.Repair of UV-irradiated, transforming DNA during incubation of recipient cells is observed as an increase in transforming ability when fractions from CsCl gradients of cell lysates are assayed on excision-deficient cells. When transforming DNA containing markers of different UV sensitivities is used, repair of the UV-resistant nov marker by excision proficient cells takes place exclusively in the donor DNA that is associated with recipient DNA, and this repair is observed even in the absence of DNA synthesis. However, no repair is observed in the case of the more UV-sensitive str marker, possibly because excision events may remove a large fraction of the integrated str markers in addition to repairing a small fraction of the integrated DNA containing this marker.     

Heterospecific transformation in Bacillus subtilis: protein composition of a membrane-DNA complex containing unstable heterologous donor-recipient complex

Summary Previously it was demonstrated that, in contrast to the homologous donor-recipient complex, the unstable heterologous donor-recipient complex remains bound to the cellular membrane. To examine whether proteins known to be involved in the processing of transforming DNA in Bacillus subtilis are associated with membrane fragments which carry chromosomal DNA, a crude membrane-DNA complex was subjected to electrophoresis through a sucrose gradient. This resulted in the separation of membrane fragments associated with DNA and free membrane fragments. By means of two-dimensional gel electrophoresis several proteins, either uniquely present or considerably enriched in the purified membrane-DNA complex, were detected. Among these proteins we identified the 45 kD recE gene product, required for recombination, the 18 kD binding protein involved in the binding of transforming DNA and a 17 kD nuclease involved in the entry of transforming DNA.These results suggest that the membrane sites at which donor DNA integrates into the recipient chromosome are in the vicinity of the sites of entry of donor DNA through the membrane.Abbreviations DNAase I deoxyribonuclease I - DRC donor-recipient DNA complex - PEG polyethyleneglycol - PMSF phenylmethylsulphonylfluoride - SSC standard saline citrate - TCA trichloroacetic acid     

Characteristics of a complex formed by a nonintegrated fraction of transforming DNA and Bacillus subtilis recipient cell constituents.

Summary Nonintegrated transforming DNA was isolated from recipient cell lysates as a complex with cellular constituents (natural complex) and separated from free proteins on CsCl density gradients. Sensitivity of DNA in this complex to digestion with endonuclease S₁, liberation of denatured donor molecules by treatment of the cell lysates with phenol, as well as previously described liberation of single-stranded donor DNA by heating with detergents, pointed to the single-stranded nature of the donor DNA in the complex. About 1% of radioactive leucine or phenylalamine incorporated to cellular proteins were detected in the natural complex, with two associated enzymatic activities: one autolytic, the other endonucleolytic. The autolytic activity, known to be localized mainly in the cell wall and the endonucleolytic one, similar to the enzyme localized in cell membrane and periplasmic space of B. subtilis, suggest that donor DNA is complexed with a cell wall and/or a cell membrane fragment. Consideration of several characteristics of the natural complex: its density, protein content, and partial resistance of its DNA to DNase I, point to partial shielding of donor DNA in the cell fragment structure, and existence of a portion in a free uncovered form. Considerations on the possible role of the two enzymatic activities were based on the fact that they were not found in the complex formed by denatured DNA added to cells before lysis (reconstruction complex), and on hypotheses of their possible physioligical role.Part of the above results was presented in preliminary form at the Third European Meeting on Bacterial Transformation and Transfection, Granada, Spain, August 31–September 3, 1976     

Inactivation of transforming Bacillus subtilis deoxyribonucleic acid by monoadducts of 4,5',8-trimethylpsoralen.

4,5',8-Trimethylpsoralen (TMP) monoadducts inactive transforming deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) in Bacillus subtilis. Contrary to TMP diadducts (TMP cross-links), which severely inhibit entry of donor DNA (G. Venema and U. Canosi, Mol. Gen. Genet. 179:1--11), TMP monoadducts have only a slight effect on entry. Since reextracted TMP-monoadduct-containing transforming DNA is a differentially repaired by Uvr- and Uvr+ recipients and cross-linkable to the recipient strand in the heteroduplex recombinant DNA molecules, the monoadducts can be integrated along with the donor DNA into the recipient chromosome.     

Fate of homospecific transforming DNA bound to Streptococcus sanguis.

The fate of [3H]DNA from Streptococcus sanguis str-r43 fus-s donors in [14C]S. sanguis str-s fus-r1 recipients was studied by examining the lysates prepared from such recipients at various times after 1 min of exposure to DNA. The lysates were analyzed in CsCl and 10 to 30% sucrose gradients; fractions from the gradients were tested for biological activity and sensitivity to nucleases, subjected to various treatments and retested for nuclease sensitivity, and run on 5 to 20% neutral and alkaline sucrose gradients. The results demonstrate that donor DNA bound to S. sanguis cells in a form resistant to exogenous deoxyribonuclease is initially single stranded and complexed to recipient material. Donor DNA can be removed from the complex upon treatment of the complex with Pronase, phenol, or isoamyl alcohol-chloroform. Within the complex, donor DNA is relatively insensitive to S1 endonuclease but can regain its sensitivity by treatment with phenol. With time the complex moves as a whole to associate physically with the recipient chromosome. After a noncovalent stage of synapsis, donor material is covalently bonded to and acquires the nuclease sensitivity of recipient DNA, while donor markers regain transforming activity and become linked to resident markers.     

Fate of heterologous deoxyribonucleic acid in Bacillus subtilis.

CsCl density gradient fractionation of cell lysates was employed to follow the fate of Escherichia coli, phage T6, and non-glucosylated phage T6 deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) after uptake by competent cells of Bacillus subtilis 168 thy minus trp minus. Shortly after uptake, most of the radioactive Escherichia coli or non-glucosylated T6 DNA was found in the denatured form; the remainder of the label was associated with recipient DNA. Incubation of the cells after DNA uptake led to the disappearance of denatured donor DNA and to an increase in the amount of donor label associated with recipient DNA. These findings are analogous to those previously reported with homologous DNA. By contrast, T6 DNA, which is poorly taken up, appeared in the native form shortly after uptake and was degraded on subsequent incubation. The nature of the heterologous DNA fragments associated with recipient DNA was investigated with Escherichia coli 2-H and 3-H-labeled DNA. Association of radioactivity with recipient DNA decreased to one-fourth in the presence of excess thymidine; residual radioactivity could not be separated from recipient DNA by shearing (sonic oscillation) and/or denaturation, but was reduced by one-half in the presence of a DNA replication inhibitor. Residual radioactivity associated with donor DNA under these conditions was about 5% of that originally taken up. Excess thymidine, but not the DNA replication inhibitor, also decreased association of homologous DNA label with recipient DNA; but, even in the presence of both of these, the decrease amounted to only 60%. It is concluded that most, or all, of the Escherichia coli DNA label taken up is associated with recipient DNA in the form of mononucleotides via DNA replication.     

Mechanism of transformation in B. subtilis

Summary Transformation in B. subtilis is achieved by the uptake of donor DNA into recipient cells and the integration of part of this donor DNA into the host chromosome. The evidence presented in this report is interpreted to indicate that donor double helical DNA, on entry into host cells is rapidly membrane bound and can remain in this state for a consicerable time, perhaps even until integration. This bound DNA consists of molecules which have been reduced in size and degraded on uptake, and appear as partially single-stranded molecules. It is suggested that the donor DNA initially forms single strands which rapidly assume a partially single stranded nature by association with the host DNA or by reannealing.Host cells, by virtue of the competent state, possess temporarily, and prior to the addition of donor DNA, chromosomes with single-stranded gaps. It is likely that such gaps are larger than the single-stranded segments of donor DNA which are to be integrated. Results are described which are best explained if integration is achieved by an initial annealing between the single-stranded donor and host segments followed by their covalent linkage.     

Fate of transforming bacteriophage HP1 deoxyribonucleic acid in Haemophilus influenzae lysogens.

The biological fate of temperate phage HP1 deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) was followed after uptake by defectively lysogenic competent Haemophilus influenzae cultures. The similar inactivation kinetics of three single phage genetic markers and of their triple combination indicated a complete rather than partial destruction of about half of the adsorbed DNA molecules. Intracellular DNA breakdown products were tentatively identified by hydroxyapatite column chromatography as short single strands and extensively damaged short double strands. Integrated donor DNA (after single-strand insertion?) was still highly efficient for triple-marker co-transformation. This suggests that whole or nearly whole donor DNA molecules were integrated. Some donor DNA was never integrated but remained largely unaltered. This DNA fraction did not contain significant amounts of recipient prophage marker activity. It is concluded that it had not participated in some kind of reciprocal recombination event involving the recipient chromosome. Since very similar phage DNA marker inactivation rates were observed after adsorption by competent nonlysogenic recipients (transfection), the relationship between biological inactivation of adsorbed donor phage DNA and its integration in lysogenic recipients is not clear.     

Postreplication repair of ultraviolet-irradiated transforming deoxyribonucleic acid in Bacillus subtilis

Repair of ultraviolet-irradiated transforming deoxyriboinucleic acid (DNA) in several strains of Bacillus subtilis was studied in order to determine the effects of excision repair and postreplication repair on transformation. Two mutations that cause a Uvr- and phenotype (uvr-1 and uvr-42) were shown to have strikingly different effects on repair of ultraviolet-irradiated transforming DNA. Genetic and kinetic evidence is presented to show that integrated DNA was apparently repaired by both excision and postreplication repair in wild-type and in uvr-1 recipients, although the latter excise pyrimidine dimers very slowly. In uvr-42 mutants, which are defective in incision at pyrimidine dimers, dimer-containing DNA was integrated. Postreplication repair apparently saved uvr-42 recipient cells from the lethal effects of integrated dimers, but the recombination events accompanying postreplication repair greatly reduced the linkage between closely linked genetic markers in the donor DNA. Repair of transforming DNA in a recG recipient, which does excision repair but not postreplication repair, was nearly as efficient as in wild-type cells. However, in this recipient linkage was altered only slightly, if at all, compared with wild-type cells. The apparent reduction in size of integrated regions of ultraviolet-irradiation transforming DNA probably results mainly from postreplication repair of larger integrated regions.     

Bacterial conjugative transfer: visualization of successful mating pairs and plasmid establishment in live Escherichia coli

We used the LacO/GFP-LacI system to label and visualize the IncP beta plasmid R751 fluorescently during conjugative transfer between live donor and recipient bacteria. Comparisons of R751 in conjugative and non-conjugative conditions have allowed us to identify key localizations and movements associated with the initiation of conjugative transfer in the donor and the establishment of R751 in the recipient. A survey of successful mating pairs demonstrates that close physical contact between donor and recipient bacteria is required for DNA transfer and that regions of intimate contact can occur at any location on the donor or recipient cell membrane. The transferred DNA is positioned at the characteristic centre or quarter-cell position after conversion to a double-stranded molecule in the recipient cell. Initial duplication of plasmids often results in an asymmetric distribution of plasmid foci. Symmetric localization (either at centre or at 1/4 and 3/4 cell lengths) occurs only after a significant lag, presumably reflecting the time required to synthesize the plasmid-encoded partitioning proteins.     

The integration of donor and recipient deoxyribonucleic acid during transformation of Bacillus subtilis

1. DNA labelled with 5-bromo[(3)H]uracil was used to transform auxotrophic strains of Bacillus subtilis. 2. After various times of incubation, DNA was extracted from the transformed culture and subjected to equilibrium sedimentation in caesium chloride gradients. 3. In addition to heavy donor DNA and light recipient DNA, a component with an intermediate density was found and is believed to consist of a biological hybrid of donor and recipient. 4. The component of intermediate density was isolated and found to possess activity in transformation derived from both donor and recipient strains. 5. Denaturation of the component of intermediate density followed by centrifugation gave only one component, indicating that integration had occurred in both strands of the recipient DNA. 6. No integrated band was observed after uptake by competent cells of B. subtilis of heavy DNA prepared from Escherichia coli.     

ADP-ribosylation is involved in the integration of foreign DNA into the mammalian cell genome.

The most commonly used DNA transfection method, which employs the calcium phosphate co-precipitation of the donor DNA, involves several discrete steps (1,2). These include the uptake of the donor DNA by the recipient cells, the transport of the DNA to the nucleus, transient expression prior to integration into the host cell genome, concatenation and integration of the transfected DNA into the host cell genome and finally the stable expression of the integrated genes (2,3). Both the concatenation and the integration of the donor DNA into the host genome involve the formation and ligation of DNA strand-breaks. In the present study we demonstrate that the nuclear enzyme, adenosine diphosphoribosyl transferase (ADPRT, E.C. 2.4.2.30), which is dependent on the presence of DNA strand breaks for its activity (4,5) and necessary for the efficient ligation of DNA strand-breaks in eukaryotic cells (4,6), is required for the integration of donor DNA into the host genome. However, ADPRT activity does not influence the uptake of DNA into the cell, its episomal maintenance or replication, nor its expression either before or after integration into the host genome. These observations strongly suggest the involvement of ADPRT activity in eukaryotic DNA recombination events.     

Conditions of transformation by DNA of Neurospora crassa.

The DNA uptake and transformation of inositol-requiring recipient Neurospora strains were investigated. Exponentially growing cultures can accumulate 5-10 fold quantities of donor DNA than older ones. The rate of DNA uptake depends on the physiological state of the recipient cell, and on the molecular weight of donor DNA. The exocellular DNase activity of the recipient culture may influence the DNA uptake and the transformation process. "Young" inositol-requiring Neurospora crassa cultures can be transformed by wild type DNA reproducibly, but with low efficiency.     

Multiple interactions among the competence proteins of Bacillus subtilis

Proteins required for transformation of Bacillus subtilis and other competent bacteria are associated with the membrane or reside in the cytosol. Previous work has shown that RecA, ComGA, ComFA and SsbB are directed to the cell poles in competent cells, and that the uptake of transforming DNA occurs preferentially at the poles. We show that ComGA, ComFA, DprA (Smf), SsbB (YwpH), RecA and YjbF (CoiA) are located at the cell poles, where they appear to colocalize. Using fluorescence resonance energy transfer, we have shown that these six competent (Com) proteins reside in close proximity to one another. This conclusion was supported by the effects of com gene knockouts on the stabilities of Com proteins. Data obtained from the com gene knockout studies, as well as information from other sources, extend the list of proteins in the transformation complex to include ComEC and ComEA. Because ComGA and ComFA are membrane-associated, while DprA, SsbB, RecA and YjbF are soluble, a picture emerges of a large multiprotein polar complex, involving both cytosolic and membrane proteins. This complex mediates the binding and uptake of single-stranded DNA, the protection of this DNA from cellular nucleases and its recombination with the recipient chromosome.     

Type IV secretion: the Agrobacterium VirB/D4 and related conjugation systems

The translocation of DNA across biological membranes is an essential process for many living organisms. In bacteria, type IV secretion systems (T4SS) are used to deliver DNA as well as protein substrates from donor to target cells. The T4SS are structurally complex machines assembled from a dozen or more membrane proteins in response to environmental signals. In Gram-negative bacteria, the conjugation machines are composed of a cell envelope-spanning secretion channel and an extracellular pilus. These dynamic structures (i) direct formation of stable contacts-the mating junction-between donor and recipient cell membranes, (ii) transmit single-stranded DNA as a nucleoprotein particle, as well as protein substrates, across donor and recipient cell membranes, and (iii) mediate disassembly of the mating junction following substrate transfer. This review summarizes recent progress in our understanding of the mechanistic details of DNA trafficking with a focus on the paradigmatic Agrobacterium tumefaciens VirB/D4 T4SS and related conjugation systems.