Orientating peptide residues and increasing the distance between pockets to enable fitting into MHC-TCR complex determine protection against malaria

The erythrocyte binding antigen EBA-175 is a 175-kDa Plasmodium falciparum protein, which has been shown to be involved in the process of invasion of erythrocytes. It has been found that conserved peptide 1818 belonging to this protein has high red blood cell binding capacity and plays an important role in the invasion process. This peptide is neither immunogenic nor protective. Peptide 1818 analogues had some of their previously recognized critical red blood cell binding residues substituted for amino acids having similar volume or mass but different polarity to make them fit into HLA-DRbeta(1)*1101 molecules; these 1818 peptide analogues were then synthesized and inoculated into Aotus nancymaae monkeys, generating different immunogenic and/or protective immune responses. Short structures such as 3(10)-helix, classical, or distorted type-III beta-turns were found in the immunogenic and protective peptides once the secondary structure had been analyzed by NMR and its structure correlated with its immunological properties. These data suggest that peptide flexibility may lead to better fitting into immune system molecules, therefore making them excellent candidates for consideration as components of a subunit-based, multicomponent synthetic antimalarial vaccine.     

Changing ABRA protein peptide to fit into the HLA-DRbeta1*0301 molecule renders it protection-inducing

The Plasmodium falciparum acidic-basic repeat antigen represents a potential malarial vaccine candidate. One of this protein's high activity binding peptides, named 2150 ((161)KMNMLKENVDYIQKNQNLFK(180)), is conserved, non-immunogenic, and non-protection-inducing. Analogue peptides whose critical binding residues (in bold) were replaced by amino-acids having similar mass but different charge were synthesized and tested to try to modify such immunological properties. These analogues' HLA-DRbeta1* molecule binding ability were also studied in an attempt to explain their biological mechanisms and correlate binding capacity and immunological function with their three-dimensional structure determined by (1)H NMR. A 3(10) distorted helical structure was identified in protective and immunogenic peptide 24922 whilst alpha-helical structure was found for non-immunogenic, non-protective peptides having differences in alpha-helical position. The changes performed on immunogenic, protection-inducing peptide 24922 allowed it to bind specifically to the HLA-DRbeta1*0301 molecule, suggesting that these changes may lead to better interaction with the MHC Class II-peptide-TCR complex rendering it immunogenic and protective, thus suggesting a new way of developing multi-component, sub-unit-based anti-malarial vaccines.     

Protection against experimental P falciparum malaria is associated with short AMA-1 peptide analogue alpha-helical structures

Apical membrane antigen-1 (AMA-1) is an integral Plasmodium falciparum malaria parasite membrane protein. Peptides having high activity binding to human red blood cells have been identified in this protein. One of them, peptide 4325, with the amino acid sequence MIKSAFLPTGAFKADRYKSH, for which critical binding residues have already been defined (underlined), is conserved and non-immunogenic. Its critical binding residues were changed for amino acids having similar mass but different charge to change such immunological properties. These changes rendered some peptides immunogenic and protective against experimental challenge in Aotus monkeys. Three-dimensional models of peptide 4325 and its analogues, 20032 and 20034, were calculated from NMR experiments with distance geometry and restrained molecular dynamic methods. Non-immunogenic, non-protective peptide 4325 showed differences in its secondary structure with respect to protective, immunogenic peptides 20032 and 20034. Such data suggest that these modifications could have converted non-immunogenic peptides into immunogenic, protective ones, making them excellent candidates for a multi-component subunit synthetic malaria vaccine.     

Peptides inducing short-lived antibody responses against Plasmodium falciparum malaria have shorter structures and are read in a different MHC II functional register

The search for a rational method of developing an antimalarial vaccine (malaria caused by Plasmodium falciparum) consists of blocking receptor-ligand interaction. Conserved peptides derived from proteins involved in invasion and having strong red blood cell binding ability have thus been identified; immunization studies using Aotus monkeys revealed that these peptides were neither immunogenic nor protection-inducing. Some of these peptides induced long-lasting and very high antibody titers and protection when their critical red blood cell binding residues were replaced to change their immunological properties. Others induced short-lived antibodies that were not associated with inducing protection. The three-dimensional structure of the short-lived antibody-inducing peptide was determined by (1)H NMR. Their HLA-DRbeta1* molecule binding ability was also determined to ascertain the relationship among three-dimensional structure, their ability to bind to major histocompatibility complex class II molecules (MHC II), and possible short-lived antibody production. These short-lived antibody-inducing peptides were 6.8 +/- 0.5 A shorter between those residues theoretically coming into contact with pocket 1 and pocket 9 of HLA-DRbeta1* molecules to which they bind than immunogenic and protection-inducing peptides. These more compact alpha-helical structures suggest that these short-lived antibody-inducing peptides could have a structure more similar to those of native peptides than immunogenic and protective ones. Such shortening was associated with a shift in HLA-DRbeta1* molecule binding and a consequent shift in functional register reading, mainly by alleles of the same haplotype when compared with immunogenic protection-inducing HABPs, suggesting an imperfect and different conformation of the MHC II peptide-TCR complex.     

Protective cellular immunity against P. falciparum malaria merozoites is associated with a different P7 and P8 residue orientation in the MHC-peptide-TCR complex

Developing a logical and rational methodology for obtaining vaccines, especially against the main parasite causing human malaria (P. falciparum), consists of blocking receptor-ligand interactions. Conserved peptides derived from proteins involved in invasion and having high red blood cell binding ability have thus been identified. Immunization studies using Aotus monkeys have revealed that these peptides were neither immunogenic nor protection inducing. When modified in their critical binding residues, previously identified by Glycine scanning, some of these peptides were immunogenic and non-protection inducers; others induced short-lived antibodies whilst a few were both immunogenic and protection inducing. However, very few of these modified high activity binding peptides (HABPs) reproducibly induced protection without inducing antibody production, but with high cytokine liberation, suggesting that cellular mechanisms had been activated in the protection process. The three-dimensional structure of these peptides inducing protection without producing antibodies was determined by 1H-NMR. Their HLA-DRbeta1* molecule binding ability was also determined to ascertain association between their 3D structure and ability to bind to Major Histocompatibility Complex Class-II molecules (MHC-II). 1H Nuclear Magnetic Resonance analysis and structure calculations clearly showed that these modified HABPs inducing protective cellular immune responses (but not producing antibodies against malaria) adopted special structural configuration to fit into the MHC II-peptide-TCR complex. A different orientation for P7 and P8 TCR contacting residues was clearly recognized when comparing their structure with modified peptides, which induced high antibody titers and protection, suggesting that these residues are involved in activating the immune system associated with antibody production and protection.     

Immunogenicity and protectivity of Plasmodium falciparum EBA-175 peptide and its analog is associated with alpha-helical region shortening and displacement

EBA-175 protein is used as a ligand in the binding of P. falciparum to red blood cells (RBCs). Evidence shows that the conserved peptide 1779 from this protein (with high red blood cell binding ability and known critical erythrocyte binding residues) plays an important role in the invasion process. This peptide is neither immunogenic nor protective; analogs having critical residues replaced by amino acids with similar volume or mass but different polarity were synthesized and inoculated into Aotus monkeys, and elicited different immunogenic and protective responses. Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (1H-NMR) studies revealed that peptide analog 21696 (non-immunogenic and non-protective) presents a large helical fragment, that the peptide 14012 (immunogenic and non-protective) helical fragment is smaller, while the peptide 22812 (immunogenic and protective) alpha-helix is shorter in a different region and possesses greater flexibility at its N-terminus. The presence of methionine residues could affect the structural stability of peptide 22812 and ultimately its immunological response. Our results suggest a new strategy for designing a new malaria multi-component subunit-based vaccine.     

1H-NMR structures of the Plasmodium falciparum 1758 erythrocyte binding peptide analogues and protection against malaria

A conserved high activity erythrocyte binding peptide (HAEBP) derived from the 175-erythrocyte binding antigen (EBA-175), coded 1758, was synthesized and analyzed for antigenic and protective activities in Aotus monkeys, together with several of its analogues. Conformational analysis by 1H Nuclear Magnetic Resonance in TFE-solution was done for some of them, as well as the 1758 parent peptide. We show that the conserved 1758 HAEBP (being neither immunogenic nor protective) has an alpha helical structure, whilst its analogues contain beta-turn structures. The 13790 peptide (highly immunogenic and protective for some monkeys) shows a type I beta-turn structure distorted in psi(i + 1) psi(i + 2) angles, whilst immunogenic and non-protective (as well as the non-immunogenic and non-protective peptides) have type III' beta-turns. An understanding of native peptide's correlation with altered peptide three-dimensional structure and resulting immunogenicity and protective activity may lead to a more rational design of multi-antigenic, multi-stage P. falciparum subunit based malaria vaccines.     

NMR structure of Plasmodium falciparum malaria peptide correlates with protective immunity

Apical membrane antigen-1 is an integral Plasmodium falciparum malaria parasite membrane protein. High activity binding peptides (HABPs) to human red blood cells (RBCs) have been identified in this protein. One of them (peptide 4313), for which critical binding residues have already been defined, is conserved and nonimmunogenic. Its critical binding residues were changed for amino acids having similar mass but different charge to change such immunological properties; these changes generated peptide analogues. Some of these peptide analogues became immunogenic and protective in Aotus monkeys.Three-dimensional models of peptide 4313 and three analogues having different immune characteristics, were calculated from nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) experiments with distance geometry and restrained molecular dynamic methods. All peptides contained a beta-turn structure spanning amino acids 7 to 10, except randomly structured 4313. When analysing dihedral angle phi and psi values, distorted type III or III' turns were identified in the protective and/or immunogenic peptides, whilst classical type III turns were found for the nonimmunogenic nonprotective peptides. This data shows that some structural modifications may lead to induction of immunogenicity and/or protection, suggesting a new way to develop multicomponent, subunit-based malarial vaccines.     

High non-protective, long-lasting antibody levels in malaria are associated with haplotype shifting in MHC-peptide-TCR complex formation: a new mechanism for immune evasion

An effective malarial vaccine must contain multiple immunogenic, protection-inducing epitopes able to block and destroy the P. falciparum malaria parasite, the most lethal form of this disease in the world. Our strategy has consisted in using conserved peptides blocking parasite binding to red blood cells; however, these peptides are non-immunogenic and non-protection-inducing. Modifying their critical residues can make them immunogenic. Such peptides induced antibody titers (determined by immunofluorescence antibody test, IFA) and made the latter reactive (determined by Western blot) and protection inducing against experimental challenge with a highly infective Aotus monkey adapted P. falciparum strain. Modified peptides also induce highly non-protective long-lasting antibody levels. Modifications performed might allow them to bind specifically to different HLA-DRbeta purified molecules. These immunological and biological activities are associated with modifications in their three-dimensional structure as determined by (1)H-NMR. It was found that modified, high non-protective long-lasting antibody level peptides bound to HLA-DR molecules from a different haplotype (to which immunogenic, protection-inducers bind) and had 4.6 +/- 1.4 A shorter distances between residues fitting into these molecules' Pocket 1 to Pocket 9, suggesting fitting into an inappropriate HLA-DR molecule. A multi-component, subunit-based, malarial vaccine is therefore feasible if modified peptides are suitably modified for an appropriate fit into the correct HLA-DRbeta1* molecule in order to form a proper MHC-II-peptide-TCR complex.     

Fitting modified HRP-I peptide analogue 3D structure into HLA-DR molecules induces protection against Plasmodium falciparum malaria

Conserved, high-activity, red blood cell binding malaria peptide 6786, from the HRP-I protein, having a random 3D structure as determined by 1H-NMR, was non-immunogenic and non-protection inducing when used as an immunogen in Aotus monkeys. Modifications made in its amino acid sequence were thus performed to render it immunogenic and protection inducing. Non-immunogenic, non-protection inducing modified peptide 13852 presented A2-H8 and K14-L18 helix fragments. Immunogenic, non-protection inducing modified peptide 23428 presented a short, displaced helix in a different region, whilst immunogenic, protection inducing peptide 24224 had 2 displaced helical regions towards the central region giving more flexibility to its N- and C-terminals. Immunogenic and protection inducing peptides bound with high affinity to HLA-DRB1* 0301 whilst others did not bind to any HLA-DRB1* purified molecule. Structural modifications may thus lead to inducing immunogenicity and protection associated with their capacity to bind specifically to purified HLA-DRB1* molecules, suggesting a new way of developing multi-component, subunit-based malarial vaccines.     

6746 SERA peptide analogues immunogenicity and protective efficacy against malaria is associated with short alpha helix formation: malaria protection associated with peptides alpha helix shortening

Erythrocyte high activity binding peptides (HABPs) have been identified for the Plasmodium falciparum serine repeat antigen (SERA). HABP 6746, located in this protein's 50 kDa fragment had its critical binding residues replaced by amino acids having similar mass but different charge to change their immunologic properties. This peptide analogues were used to immunize Aotus monkeys that were challenged later on with a virulent P. falciparum strain to determine their protective efficacy. A shortening in alpha helix structure was found in the immunogenic and protective ones when their secondary structure was analyzed by NMR, to correlate their structure with their immunologic properties. These data, together with results from previous studies, suggest that this shortening in HABP helical configuration may lead to better fitting with immune system molecules, rendering them immunogenic and protective and therefore making them excellent candidates for consideration as components of a subunit based multicomponent synthetic vaccine against malaria.     

Shortening and modifying the 1513 MSP-1 peptide's alpha-helical region induces protection against malaria

Immunogenic and protective peptide sequences are of prime importance in the search for an anti-malarial vaccine. The MSP-1 conserved and semi-conserved sequences have been shown to contain red blood cell (RBC) membrane high affinity binding peptides (HABP). HABP 1513 sequence ((42)GYSLFQKEKMVLNEGTSGTA(61)), from this protein's N-terminal, has been shown to possess a T-epitope; however, it did not induce a humoral immune response or complete protection when evaluated in Aotus monkeys. Analogue peptides with critical binding residues replaced by amino acids with similar mass but different charge were synthesised and tested for immunogenicity and protectivity in monkey. NMR studies correlated structural behaviour with biological function. Non-immunogenic and non-protective 1513 native peptide presented a helical fragment between residues L(4) and E(14). C-terminal, 5-residue-shorter, non-immunogenic, non-protective peptide 17894 contained an alpha-helix from Q(6) to L(12) residues. Immunogenic and protective peptide 13946 presented a shorter alpha-helix between K(7) to N(13) residues. These data suggest that changing certain residues permits better peptide fit within the MHC class II-peptide-TCR complex, thus activating the immune system and inducing a protective immune response.     

Modified merozoite surface protein-1 peptides with short alpha helical regions are associated with inducing protection against malaria.

The merozoite surface protein-1 represents a prime candidate for development of a malaria vaccine. Merozoite surface protein-1 has been shown to demonstrate high-activity peptide binding to human red blood cells. One of the high-activity binding peptides, named 5501, located in the N-terminus (amino acid sequence MLNISQHQCVKKQCPQNS) of the 19-kDa molecular mass fragment of merozoite surface protein-1, is conserved, nonimmunogenic and nonprotective. Its critical binding residues were identified and replaced with amino acids of similar mass but different charge, in order to modify their immunogenic and protective characteristics. Three analogues with positive or negative immunological results were studied by nuclear magnetic resonance to correlate their three-dimensional structure with their biological functions. The studied peptides presented alpha-helical fragments, but in different peptide regions and extensions, except for randomly structured 5501. We show that altering a few amino acids induced immunogenicity and protectivity against experimental malaria and changed the peptide three-dimensional structure, suggesting a better fit with immune-system molecules.     

Alpha helix shortening in 1522 MSP-1 conserved peptide analogs is associated with immunogenicity and protection against P. falciparum malaria

1522 is a nonimmunogenic conserved high-activity binding peptide (HABP) belonging to Plasmodium falciparum MSP-1 protein N-terminal fragment. The key amino acids in binding to red blood cells (RBC) were identified and replaced by others having similar mass but different charge. Because conserved HABPs are not antigenic nor immunogenic, immunogenicity and protectivity studies were then conducted on them in the Aotus monkey. 1H-NMR studies included the lead peptide 1522 as well as the analogs 9782, 13446, 13448, and 13442 to relate their structure to biological function. All the peptides presented alpha-helical structure, with differences observed in helix location and extension. The nonprotective 1522 peptide was totally helical from the N- to the C-terminus, very similar to nonprotective 13442 and 13448 peptides whose extension was almost totally helical. The 9782 and 13446 protective peptides, however, possessed a shorter helical region where modified critical binding residues were not included. A more flexible region was generated at the C-terminus in those peptides with a shorter helical region, leading to a greater number of conformers. These data suggest that peptide flexibility results in increased interaction with immune system molecules, generating protective immunity.     

Elongating modified conserved peptides eliminates their immunogenicity and protective efficacy against P. falciparum malaria

Plasmodium falciparum malaria protein peptides were synthesised in the search for more effective routes for inducing a protective immune response against this deadly parasite and this information has been associated with such molecules' three-dimensional structure. These peptides had high red blood cell binding activity and their carboxy- and amino-terminal extremes were elongated for determining their immunogenic and protection-inducing activity against this disease in the Aotus monkey experimental model. 1H-NMR was used for analysing their three-dimensional structure; FAST ELISA, immunofluorescence antibody test, and Western blot were used for identifying their antibody inducing capacity and these previously immunised Aotus were inoculated with a highly infective P. falciparum strain to determine whether these elongated peptides were able to induce protection. This was aimed at establishing an association or correlation between long peptides' three-dimensional structure and their immunogenic and protection-inducing response in these monkeys. Peptides 20026 (25 residue), 20028 (30 residue), and 20030 (35 residues) were synthesised based on elongating the amino-terminal region of the 10022 highly immunogenic and protection-inducing modified peptide. 1H-NMR studies revealed that the first three had Classical type III beta-turn structures, different from the 20-amino acid long modified peptide 10022 which had a distorted type III beta-turn. Humoral immune response analysis showed that even when some antibodies could be generated against the parasite, none of the immunised Aotus could be protected with elongated peptides suggesting that elongating them eliminated modified peptide 10022 immunogenic and protection-inducing capacity.     

Electrostatic potential as a tool to understand interactions between malaria vaccine candidate peptides and MHC II molecules

One of the most important problems in vaccine development consists in understanding receptor–ligand interactions between Class II Major Histocompatibility Complex molecules (MHC II) and antigenic peptides involved in inducing an appropriate immune response. In this study, we used X-ray crystallography structural data provided by the HLA-DRβ1*0301–CLIP peptide interaction to compare native non-immunogenic and specifically-modified immunogenic peptides derived from the malarial SALSA protein, by analyzing molecular electrostatic potential surfaces on the most important regions of the peptide binding groove (Pockets 1, 4, 6 and 9). Important differences were found on the electrostatic potential induced by these peptides, particularly in MHC II conserved residues: Qα9, Sα53, Nα62, Nα69, Yβ30, Yβ60, Wβ61, Qβ70, Kβ71 and Vβ86, the same ones involved in establishing hydrogen bonds between Class II molecule-peptide and the recognition by T cell receptor, it correlating well with the change in their immunological properties.The results clearly suggest that modifications done on the electrostatic potential of these amino acids could favor the induction of different immune responses and therefore, their identification could allow modifying peptides a priori and in silico, so as to render them into immunogenic and protection-inducers and hence suitable components of a chemically-synthesized, multi-antigenic, minimal subunit based vaccine.     

Monosaccharides modulate HCV E2 protein-derived peptide biological properties

A hepatitis C virus E(2) protein-derived sequence was selected for studying the effect of N-glycosylation on the peptide chain's conformational structure. The results suggested that the (534)TDVF(537) motif contained in peptide 33402 ((529)WGENDTDVFVLNNTRY(544)) had a type III beta-turn, relevant in antigen recognition of polyclonal antibodies, binding to human cells, and binding to HLA DRB1 *0401 molecules. N-Glycopeptides derived from this sequence contained monosaccharides in Asn(532). N-Glycopeptides presented differences in peptide chain structure compared to non-glycosylated peptides. Peptide 33402 specifically bound to human cells, specificity becoming lost when it was N-glycosylated. N-Glycosylation decreased antigen recognition of mouse polyclonal sera against this sequence. N-Glycopeptide binding to HLA DRB1 *0401 molecules was similar to that presented by non-glycosylated peptide, indicating that N-glycosylation did not affect binding to HLA DRB1 *0401 molecules. N-Glycosylation induced changes at structural and functional level which could be relevant for modulating human cell binding properties and antibody recognition.     

HLA-DR allele reading register shifting is associated with immunity induced by SERA peptide analogues

SERA protein is a leading candidate molecule to be included in an antimalarial vaccine. Conserved high activity binding peptides (HABP) binding to red blood cells (RBC) have been identified in this protein. One of them (6762) localising in the 18-kDa C-terminal fragment was used to induce protective immunity with negative result. Critical RBC binding residues (assessed by glycine-analogue scanning) were replaced by others having the same mass, volume and surface but different polarity, rendering some of them immunogenic as assessed by antibody production against the parasite or its proteins and protection-inducing against challenge with a highly infectious Aotus monkey-adapted Plasmodium falciparum strain.A shift in binding to purified HLA-DR allelic molecules from the same haplotype and in their reading register was found, suggesting that modified molecules had adopted a different ¹H NMR 3D structure allowing a better fit into the MHCII-pept-TCR complex, thereby representing a new mechanism for inducing immune protection.     

Structural characterisation of sporozoite components for a multistage, multi-epitope, anti-malarial vaccine

A totally effective anti-malarial vaccine must contain epitopes derived from multiple proteins found in different stages of the particular parasite involved in invasion. It must therefore include sporozoite molecules able to induce protective immunity thereby blocking the parasite's access to hepatic cells; thrombospondin-related anonymous protein (TRAP) is one of them. Conserved high activity binding peptides (HABPs) attaching themselves to hepatic cells were used in immunisation studies with the highly malaria-susceptible Aotus monkey. However, they had to be modified to render them immunogenic. The changes induced in lead peptide 3D structure were analysed by correlating such substitutions with the induction of high anti-sporozoite antibody levels in the experimental monkey model. The modification induced structural changes in most modified HABPs, changing them from random-coil or distorted type III beta-turn structures to classical type III or III' beta-turn, thereby allowing a better fit into the MHC-II-peptide-TCR complex since they bound with high affinity to purified HLA-DRbeta1* molecules. These are the first (TRAP) conserved HABPs corresponding to functionally active amino acid sequences in sporozoite invasion and mobility which, when modified, were able to induce very high anti-sporozoite antibody responses, leading to suggesting them as components in the first line of defence of a fully-effective, subunit-based, multi-epitope, multi-stage, synthetic anti-malarial vaccine.