Immunological analysis of chick notochord and cartilage matrix development with antisera to cartilage matrix macromolecules

Transverse frozen sections from the postcephalic region of stage 9-16 chick embryos and from the wing bud region of stage 17-31 embryos were stained with antibodies to the major extracellular matrix components of cartilage. These probes included unfractionated A1 and A2 antisera to the major cartilage proteoglycan, affinity-purified purified antibodies to the proteoglycan core protein and to Type II collagen, and a monoclonal antibody to keratan sulfate. In embryos as early as stage 10, notochord stained specifically with the keratan sulfate monoclonal antibody. At this stage the notochord, as well as surrounding tissues, were negative to cartilage proteoglycan and collagen antibodies. Positive staining with the latter probes was coordinately acquired by notochord cells and their accompanying sheath around stage 15, while surrounding tissues remained negative. At this stage, the ventral region of the perispinal cord sheath exhibited light staining with the proteoglycan and keratan sulfate antibodies though failing to react to Type II collagen antibodies. Positive staining of notochord and ventral spinal cord persisted through later developmental stages. As revealed by immunofluorescence, definitive vertebral chondroblasts first emerged at approximately stage 23 and definitive limb chondroblasts at stage 25. The results are discussed in terms of the possible multiple roles of notochord in early embryogenesis.     

Ossification patterns in the tetrapod limb – conservation and divergence from morphogenetic events

Two different patterns of the condensation and chondrification of the limbs of tetrapods are known from extensive studies on their early skeletal development. These are on the one hand postaxial dominance in the sequential formation of skeletal elements in amniotes and anurans, and on the other, preaxial dominance in urodeles. The present study investigates the relative sequence of ossification in the fore‐ and hindlimbs of selected tetrapod taxa based on a literature survey in comparison to the patterns of early skeletal development, i.e. mesenchymal condensation and chondrification, representing essential steps in the late stages of tetrapod limb development. This reveals the degree of conservation and divergence of the ossification sequence from early morphogenetic events in the tetrapod limb skeleton. A step‐by‐step recapitulation of condensation and chondrification during the ossification of limbs can clearly be refuted. However, some of the deeper aspects of early skeletal patterning in the limbs, i.e. the general direction of development and sequence of digit formation are conserved, particularly in anamniotes. Amniotes show a weaker coupling of the ossification sequence in the limb skeleton with earlier condensation and chondrification events. The stronger correlation between the sequence of condensation/chondrification and ossification in the limbs of anamniotes may represent a plesiomorphic trait of tetrapods. The pattern of limb ossification across tetrapods also shows that some trends in the sequence of ossification of their limb skeleton are shared by major clades possibly representing phylogenetic signals. This review furthermore concerns the ossification sequence of the limbs of the Palaeozoic temnospondyl amphibian Apateon sp. For the first time this is described in detail and its patterns are compared with those observed in extant taxa. Apateon sp. shares preaxial dominance in limb development with extant salamanders and the specific order of ossification events in the fore‐ and hindlimb of this fossil dissorophoid is almost identical to that of some modern urodeles.     

Subepithelial type II collagen deposition during embryonic chick limb development

Summary Type II collagen is a major component of hyaline cartilage but recent studies have demonstrated the presence of this protein in a variety of interfaces that separate epithelia from mesenchyme, particularly in early stages of embryonic chick development. In the present study an immunohistochemical analysis of the distribution of type II collagen was performed on closely staged wing buds of early chick embryo. This report describes how using two different monoclonal antibodies against type II collagen and the peroxidase or fluorescence staining technique reveals that deposition of type II collagen at the ectoderm-mesenchyme interface occurs in the proximal part of the limb coincidentally with the appearance of this protein in the proximal core region, where chondrogenesis begins (stage 25). Then the staining in the subepithelial region spreads distallly with time, following the progression of the formation of cartilage rudiments. At about 7 days of development type II collagen is present under the apical ectoderm ridge and surrounds completely the wing bud underneath the epithelium. At the same time, another antibody directed against the cartilage-specific proteoglycan core protein only stains the chondrogenic central core of the limb and not the subepithelium. Although type II collagen and cartilage-specific proteoglycan are closely associated in the cartilage, the observations presented here suggest that the deposition of these proteins can be regulated independently during limb formation. The role of type II collagen at the epithelium-mesenchyme interface during limb formation is still to be determined.     

Of chicken wings and frog legs: a smorgasbord of evolutionary variation in mechanisms of tetrapod limb development

The tetrapod limb, which has served as a paradigm for the study of development and morphological evolution, is becoming a paradigm for developmental evolution as well. In its origin and diversification, the tetrapod limb has undergone a great deal of remodeling. These morphological changes and other evolutionary phenomena have produced variation in mechanisms of tetrapod limb development. Here, we review that variation in the four major clades of limbed tetrapods. Comparisons in a phylogenetic context reveal details of development and evolution that otherwise may have been unclear. Such details include apparent differences in the mechanisms of dorsal-ventral patterning and limb identity specification between mouse and chick and mechanistic novelties in amniotes, anurans, and urodeles. As we gain a better understanding of the details of limb development, further differences among taxa will be revealed. The use of appropriate comparative techniques in a phylogenetic context thus sheds light on evolutionary transitions in limb morphology and the generality of developmental models across species and is therefore important to both evolutionary and developmental biologists.     

Effect of 4-methylumbelliferyl-β-d-xyloside on collagen synthesis in chick limb bud mesenchymal cell cultures

Previous studies showed that cultures of chick limb bud mesenchymal cells plated at high density, to maximize chondrogenic expression, had a much reduced extracellular matrix around chondrocytes when exposed to 4-methyl-, umbelliferyl-β-d-xyloside. The majority of newly synthesized chondroitin sulfate chains were found in the culture medium presumably bound to the xyloside as opposed to their normal deposition on the core protein of proteoglycan. The question remained open as to whether the development of an abnormal matrix affected the synthesis of extracellular deposition of other cartilage-specific macromolecules. We have analyzed, both morphologically and biochemically, the synthesis and deposition of Type I and Type II collagen by β-d-xyloside-treated cultures of limb mesenchymal cells. While the rate of collagen synthesis per plate and its extracellular accumulation after 8 days in culture were reduced to some extent, the ratios of Type II to Type I collagen and the morphological distribution of these macromolecules were not affected by exposure to β-d-xyloside. We conclude that the expression of the cartilage-specific Type II collagen during chondrogenic differentiation is, although reduced, qualitatively not dependent on the amount of extracellular chondroitin sulfate chains attached to matrix-associated proteoglycan core protein. However, prolonged exposure of limb bud cells to xylosides leads to the formation of a chondroitin sulfate- and collagen-deficient matrix which, in turn, reduces the capacity of limb bud cells to synthesize Types I and II collagen.     

Chondrogenesis and ossification of the lissamphibian pectoral girdle

Knowledge of amphibian shoulder development is requisite for further understanding of gnathostome pectoral girdle evolution. Fish and amniotes share few pectoral girdle elements, but modern amphibians exhibit a unique combination of traits that bridge the morphological gap between these two groups. I analyzed patterns of chondrogenesis, ossification, and bone histology of the pectoral girdles of two anuran species (Xenopus laevis and Bombina orientalis) and two urodele species (Ambystoma mexicanum and Desmognathus aeneus) to provide new insight into the evolution of the tetrapod pectoral girdle. Comparisons reveal the following: 1) variation in the pattern of chondrogenesis among the anuran species analyzed correlates to variation in adult pectoral girdle morphology; 2) morphologically similar pectoral skeletons do not necessarily have similar patterns of bone histology; and 3) the urodele and anuran pectoral girdles included herein share a common morphology despite differences in patterns of chondrogenesis.     

Ancestors and homology

Current issues concerning the nature of ancestry and homology are discussed with reference to the evolutionary origin of the tetrapod limb. Homologies are argued to be complex conjectural inferences dependant upon a pre-existing phylogenetic analysisand a theoretical model of the evolutionary development of ontogenetic information. Ancestral conditions are inferred primarily from character (synapomorphy/homology) distributions within phylogeny, because of the deficiencies of palaeontological data. Recent analyses of tetrapod limb ontogeny, and the diverse, earliest morphologies known from the fossil record, are inconsistent with typological concepts such as fixed ancestral patterns or bauplans, emphasising the incompatibility of these with evolutionary continuity. The evolutionary origin of the tetrapod limb is also examined in the light of its recent discussion in developmental genetics. While this field promises to reveal more of the fundamental ontogenetic content of homology (identity), at present it is concerned mostly with the abstraction of a new set of types, rather than investigating diversity and change.     

Developmental basis of mammalian digit reduction: a case study in pigs

Digit reduction has occurred in parallel in many mammalian lineages. However, despite this pattern's prevalence, the developmental mechanisms underlying mammalian digit reduction remain controversial. We therefore undertook a study of digit development in the pig (Sus scrofa), a mammal with reduced first, second, and fifth digits. Our results indicate that from its earliest formation, the pig limb bud is significantly narrower than that of the model pentadactyl mammal, mouse. Furthermore, the cartilage condensations of the pig's reduced digits are noticeably smaller than those of their nonreduced counterparts from the time of their formation. In addition, growth rates of pig digits are comparable, as are the patterns of cell death in developing pig and mouse limbs. Taken together, results suggest that pig's first, second, and fifth digits are primarily reduced through evolutionary modifications in the early developmental patterning of their limbs. Results of this study, coupled with those from study of limb development in other mammals, suggest that although major developmental reorganizations (e.g., complete digit or limb loss) during early limb development may be selected against, it may be common for more subtle evolutionary modifications in limb development (e.g., changes in relative digit size) to occur at this time.     

Fish fingers: digit homologues in sarcopterygian fish fins

A defining feature of tetrapod evolutionary origins is the transition from fish fins to tetrapod limbs. A major change during this transition is the appearance of the autopod (hands, feet), which comprises two distinct regions, the wrist/ankle and the digits. When the autopod first appeared in Late Devonian fossil tetrapods, it was incomplete: digits evolved before the full complement of wrist/ankle bones. Early tetrapod wrists/ankles, including those with a full complement of bones, also show a sharp pattern discontinuity between proximal elements and distal elements. This suggests the presence of a discontinuity in the proximal-distal sequence of development. Such a discontinuity occurs in living urodeles, where digits form before completion of the wrist/ankle, implying developmental independence of the digits from wrist/ankle elements. We have observed comparable independent development of pectoral fin radials in the lungfish Neoceratodus (Osteichthyes: Sarcopterygii), relative to homologues of the tetrapod limb and proximal wrist elements in the main fin axis. Moreover, in the Neoceratodus fin, expression of Hoxd13 closely matches late expression patterns observed in the tetrapod autopod. This evidence suggests that Neoceratodus fin radials and tetrapod digits may be patterned by shared mechanisms distinct from those patterning the proximal fin/limb elements, and in that sense are homologous. The presence of independently developing radials in the distal part of the pectoral (and pelvic) fin may be a general feature of the Sarcopterygii.     

CAENOGENESIS,DEVELOPMENTAL VARIABILITY,AND EVOLUTION IN THE CARPUS AND TARSUS OF THE MARBLED NEWT TRITURUS MARMORATUS

In this paper, after a comparative analysis of the development of Triturus marmoratus, we explore the existence of caenogenetic events and their ontogenetic and phylogenetic consequences. The adult morphology of the Triturus marmoratus limb, in terms of number and spatial arrangement of skeletal elements, agrees with the general pattern of urodeles. The congruence in the typical pattern of adult morphology does not hint at the striking differences in embryonic development. These differences can be summarized as follows: 1) Presence of a “central axis” that develops in a distal-to-proximal direction. It originates in the basale commune giving rise to the centrale and the intermedium. Thus, there is no postaxial branching as found in Ambystoma mexicanum. 2) Again, unlike in Ambystoma mexicanum, we find a postaxial structure composed of the ulnare (fibulare)-distal carpal (tarsal) 4-metacarpal (metatarsal) 4 which is independent of the “digital arch.” 3) The (forelimb) digits, in particular, digits 1, 2, and 3, undergo disproportionate elongation. For example, the second digit, composed of a thin continuous, cartilaginous rod, becomes longer than the rest of the limb. Our study of the patterns of embryonic connectivity suggests the coexistence of three directions of growth and morphogenesis in the development of the Triturus marmoratus limb. 1) A proximo-distal one that gives rise to the preaxial axis, “primary axis,” and individual digits. 2) An anterio-posterior axis of development that gives rise to the “digital arch” and determines the number of digits. 3) A disto-proximal central axis that originates in the basale commune and sequentially generates the centrale and the intermedium. We speculate that heterochronic interspecific variation in the time of onset of limb bud formation is related to the degree of precocious digital elongation. Selection for long extremities in early larval stages, associated with functional demands for locomotion and balancing, may be the cause for the above listed changes in developmental pattern. Thus, the reported system is an example of how selection during ontogeny can result in the evolution of the developmental process.     

Developmental morphology of limb reduction in Hemiergis (Squamata: Scincidae): chondrogenesis,osteogenesis, and heterochrony

Digit loss is a common theme in tetrapod evolution that may involve changes in several developmental processes. The skink genus Hemiergis provides an ideal model to study these processes in closely related taxa: within three Western Australian Hemiergis species, digit quantity ranges between two and five. For three consecutive reproductive seasons, gravid females of Hemiergis were collected in the field and their embryos prepared for histological analysis of limb skeletal development (chondrogenesis and osteogenesis). Comparative studies of skeletal developmental morphology demonstrate that limbs with fewer than five digits do not result from a simple truncation of a putative ancestral (five-digit) developmental program. The developmental and adult morphologies in two-, three-, and four-digit Hemiergis are neither predicted nor explained by a simple model of heterochrony involving either chondrogenesis or osteogenesis. In postnatal Hemiergis, digit number and relative limb length do not correlate in a simple linear fashion. Instead, limb size and digit reduction may correlate with substrate conditions and burrowing behavior.     

An immunofluorescence study of chondrogenesis in murine mandibular ectomesenchyme

The temporal and spatial distribution of type I collagen, type II collagen, cartilage-specific proteoglycan (CSPG) and fibronectin in mouse mandible is described. CD-1 mouse embryos of 12-, 15-, and 18-day gestation were used, and matrix molecules were localized using indirect immunofluorescence. On day 12, accumulation of type II collagen, CSPG, and fibronectin within regions of condensed mesenchyme was noted. On day 15, intense staining for type II collagen and CSPG occurred. Fibronectin was less brilliant with its greatest concentration near the perichondrium. On day 18, the cartilage matrix was undergoing osseous replacement concurrent with loss of type II collagen and CSPG. Type I collagen was seen in the perichondrium, membranous bone and sub-basement membrane region in specimens of all ages. Synthesis and expression of extracellular matrix molecules reflect patterns of differentiation in mandibular mesenchyme.     

Evolution of sexual dimorphism in the digit ratio 2D:4D--relationships with body size and microhabitat use in iguanian lizards

The ratio between lengths of digit II and IV (digit ratio 2D:4D) is a morphological feature that likely affects tetrapod locomotor performances in different microhabitats. Modifications of this trait may be triggered by changes in steroids concentrations during embryo development, which might reflect direct selection acting on digit ratio or be solely a consequence of hormonal differences related for example to body size. Here we apply both conventional and phylogenetic analyses on morphological data from 25 lizard species of 3 families of Iguania (Iguanidae, Polychrotidae, and Tropiduridae), in order to verify whether selective pressures related to locomotion in different microhabitats could override the prenatal developmental cues imposed on the digit ratio 2D:4D by differences in body size between males and females. Data suggest that this trait evolved in association with ecological divergence in the species studied, despite the clear effect of body size on the digit ratio 2D:4D. The ecological associations of size-corrected digit ratios were restricted to one sex, and females of species that often use perches exhibited small digit ratios in the front limbs, which translated into larger sexual dimorphism indexes of arboreal species. The results, together with the subsequent discussion, provide outlines for further investigation about possible developmental mechanisms related to the evolution of adaptive changes in digit lengths that may have occurred during the evolution of ecological divergence in squamates.     

Developmental constraints and the evolution of vertebrate digit patterns

The skeletal makeup of the digits of 145 hands and feet from species from the four classes of tetrapod vertebrates is analysed. The analysis leads to the conclusion that developmental constraints are very influential in the evolution of vertebrate digit patterns. Furthermore, 98% of the patterns analysed fall within the specific constraints of the Stock & Bryant (1981) version of the polar coordinate model for the formation of digit patterns during development and pattern regulation. Three cases of apparently forbidden morphology are discussed in terms of the phenomenon of differential growth during development.     

Appearance and persistence of fibronectin in cartilage. Specific interaction of fibronectin with collagen type II

Binding of fibronectins (FN) to collagen types I-IV were studied using polyclonal antibodies against human and chicken FNs, proteoglycan monomers, collagen type II and monoclonal antibodies reacting with both soluble and insoluble forms of human FN. Plasma fibronectin and type II collagen were shown to interact specifically in a homologous system. Type II collagen, however, proved to be less effective in inhibition assays compared to other types of collagen. In high density cultures of chicken limb bud cells, fibronectin was first localized within the fibroblast-like cells of 4 hr cultures and an extensive extracellular filamentous network developed by the end of day 1. Fibronectin was present in the newly formed cartilage nodules although it seemed to disappear by day 6, when the proteoglycan accumulation became more intensive. Enzyme treatments (testicular hyaluronidase, chondroitinase ABC) helped to localize FN at this stage of development of chicken cartilage, in microdroplet high density cultures of human fetal chondrocytes and in articular cartilage. Fibronectin was localized only in the pericellular ring of intact human articular cartilage using monoclonal antibodies with the biotin-avidin system.     

Temporal and spatial expression of genes for cartilage extracellular matrix proteins during avian mandibular arch development

We have examined the temporal expression of genes for extracellular matrix proteins (type I collagen, type II collagen, and the cartilage specific proteoglycan core protein) during the development of the avian mandibular arch. We detected low levels of type II collagen mRNA in the mandibular arch as early as stage 15. Type II collagen mRNA remained low but increased slightly as development progressed from stage 15 to stage 25. More dramatic increases occurred after stage 25 coincident with overt chondrogenesis. In contrast, mRNA for the core protein of cartilage specific proteoglycan was not detected prior to the onset of chondrogenesis, appeared at stage 25, and increased thereafter. Type I collagen mRNA was also present as early as stage 15 and dramatically increased after stage 28/29, coincident with initiation of osteogenesis. Using in situ hybridization, we found that type II collagen mRNA became detectable in the center of the mandible around stage 24/25 coincident with the initiation of chondrogenesis. At later stages (26-32) type II collagen mRNA was localized in the cartilaginous rudiment. The pattern of hybridization observed with the proteoglycan core protein probe at later stages of development was essentially identical to that observed with the type II collagen probe. In contrast, the probe for the alpha 1 (I) collagen mRNA was localized over the perichondrium, over differentiated bone, and in areas within the mandibular arch where bone formation had been initiated.