Suppressor T cell recognition of major and minor histocompatibility alloantigens: selected suppression of MHC-directed responses by minor alloantigen Ts

The induction of suppression by i.v. administered alloantigens in the murine host was analyzed as a model of the possible effects of blood transfusion on transplant survival. The results indicated that suppressor T cells (Ts) specific for minor histocompatibility alloantigens could be readily induced by the i.v. presentation of minor alloantigen-disparate spleen cells. In contrast, similar priming with cells differing solely at the H-2 major histocompatibility complex stimulated only positive T cell immunity, with no evidence of suppression. The induction of H-2 directed Ts activity could be accomplished only by i.v. priming with major plus minor incompatible donor cells, suggesting that suppressor cell recognition of minor alloantigens may have facilitated the generation of Ts against H-2-encoded major transplantation antigens. A role for minor histocompatibility antigens in the regulation of H-2-specific immunity at the effector level was also indicated. Ts induced by i.v. pretreatment with minor antigen-disparate donor cells not only suppressed the delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) response to the relevant minor alloantigens, but also inhibited DTH against unrelated H-2 alloantigens introduced during subsequent intradermal immunization. Suppression of H-2-directed T cell reactivity was specific in that the presence of the Ts-inducing minor alloantigens was also required and occurred only when the minor and unrelated major alloantigens were presented within the same inoculum, if not on the same cell surface. The capacity of Lyt-2+Ts or Ts-derived suppressive factors specific for one set of cell surface molecules to modulate responses to an unrelated group of surface antigens does not appear to represent a general phenomenon, because similar suppression of immunity to unrelated tumor-specific transplantation antigens by minor-specific Ts was not observed. These results are discussed with respect to the possible mechanism of H-2-directed suppression and the role of the I region in Ts recognition of antigen.     

Transplantation of cultured thymic fragments. VI. H-2 recombinant donors

Athymic (nude) mice were transplanted with cultured thymic fragments from syngeneic, allogeneic, and partially allogeneic (recombinant) mice. Lymphocyte proliferation and cytotoxicity in vitro were measured to assess immunologic reconstitution. Transplanted nude mice were immunocompetent whether donor and recipient were disparate for class I, class II, or both H-2 gene types. Furthermore, allotolerance for thymic H-2 class I antigens was achieved independently of class II antigen allotolerance. Class I antigen tolerance was not broken during lymphocyte responses to unrelated alloantigens, ruling out insufficient help as the tolerance mechanism. Splenocytes, isolated from nude mice transplanted with fully allogeneic or syngeneic thymic fragments and stimulated in vitro with trinitrophenyl-modified cells, displayed H-2-restricted, hapten-specific cytotoxicity. Cytotoxic cells from allotolerant mice were restricted to either host or thymic H-2 antigens, depending on the stimulating cell haplotype. Response levels for thymic and host trinitrophenyl-modified cells were comparable. We have shown that allogeneic thymic epithelium transplanted into adult nude mice can induce allotolerance to class I and II H-2 antigens equally, and permits T lymphocyte interaction with cells bearing thymic donor or host H-2 antigens. Our results are consistent with a model wherein T lymphocyte self-receptors retain their genomic repertoire but can be selectively mutated or expanded by appropriate H-2 antigen presentation by the thymus.     

Epitopes associated with the MHC restriction site of T cells. I. Selective expression of Iat epitopes on H-2-restricted helper T cells

We previously established monoclonal antibodies (mAb) that are putatively directed to the I region of H-2k but are reactive only with T cells. Because of their specificity to the unique epitopes different from class II antigens, they are designated as anti-Iat reagents. The present study demonstrated that these anti-Iat inhibit the H-2k-restricted helper T (Th) cell function by acting on the very H-2 restriction site of both H-2k and H-2kxb F1 T cells. This was determined by both the cytotoxic treatment and blocking of antigen-primed Th cells. In the F1 Th population, only those restricted to H-2k were eliminated, leaving the H-2b-restricted Th cells uninhibited. The inhibition of the response was not due to the induction of suppressor T cells, but to the elimination of the function of radioresistant Lyt-1+,2- Th cells. Iatk epitopes were also found on an H-2k-restricted but not on H-2b-restricted Th cell clone established from the same H-2kxb F1 animal. None of the anti-Iatk were reactive with class II antigens on B cells. These results indicate that Iat epitopes are not directly encoded by the I region genes, but are associated with the H-2 restriction site of T cells, which see the self class II polymorphism. Thus, Iat epitopes are expressed clonally in high frequency on H-2k-restricted Th cells of F1, being excluded from the H-2b-restricted Th population. The relationship between Iat and T cell receptor molecules is unknown.     

Neonatal tolerance of H-2 alloantigens. II. I region dependence of tolerance expressed to K and D antigens

Third-party skin allografts were employed to test the specificity of transplantation tolerance achieved by neonatal inoculation of cells bearing H-2 alloantigens. Tolerant animals rejected with normal vigour third-party grafts expressing strong Class I alloantigens foreign to the host and to the donor of the tolerance-conferring inoculum. However, these animals rejected with exceptional vigour third-party grafts expressing weak Class II alloantigens plus the tolerated Class I alloantigen; even third-party grafts comprised of the host's own Class II antigens in conjunction with the tolerated Class I alloantigen were acutely rejected. It is proposed, but there is no direct evidence to prove, that rejection of these third-party grafts is mediated by killer T cells directed at the tolerated Class I alloantigens and that these cells are activated by the presentation of the putative tolerogen in an inappropriate I region context. Inconsistency of these data with a clonal deletion mechanism is discussed.     

Delayed-type hypersensitivity to minor histocompatibility antigens and its genetic restriction

The analysis of skin allograft survival time and the level of delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) reaction to major and minor histocompatibility antigens revealed the correlation between these parameters of the transplantation immunity. The data obtained have shown that histocompatibility in several non-H-2 antigens induces DTH reaction comparable with the reaction caused by H-2 antigens. The effector phase of DTH to non-H-2 antigens is H-2 restricted. No restriction of the afferent phase is revealed. The application of these results to the analysis of the mechanisms of the recognition of minor histocompatibility antigens in DTH is discussed.     

The role of class II MHC molecules in the activation of class I-reactive T cell hybridomas

To examine the role of Ia molecules in T cell responses to allo-class I major histocompatibility antigens, a series of allo-class I-reactive T cell hybridomas was established. Of 134 T cell hybridomas obtained from the fusion of C3H/HeJm or B10.HTT T cells stimulated with C57BL/6 splenocytes, nine T cell hybridomas were reactive to class I antigens and 126 T cell hybridomas were reactive to class II antigens. Six of the nine IL 2-producing T cell hybridomas were further analyzed: five mapped to H-2Kb and the other mapped to H-2Db. Three of these T cell hybridomas, HTB-157.7, HTB-176.10, and HTB-177.2, could react to the EL-4 cell line that expresses H-2Kb and H-2Db class I antigens but lacks class II I-Ab molecules. Furthermore, the activation of these three T cell hybridomas with C57BL/6-derived splenocytes was not blocked by either anti-I-A or anti-L3T4 antibody. In contrast, the other three T cell hybridomas, CB-127.6, CB-221.7, and HTB-102.7, failed to react with EL-4 but reacted with the LB cell line which expresses class I (H-2Kb, H-2Db) and class II (I-Ab) molecules. Although class II molecules were required for activation of the latter clones, there was no apparent I-A allele specificity, suggesting that a relatively nonpolymorphic Ia determinant was involved. The activation of the three latter T cell hybridoma clones with C57BL/6 splenocytes could be blocked completely by either anti-I-A or anti-L3T4 antibody. The data are interpreted in terms of possible T cell receptor models for recognition of class I with nonpolymorphic class II determinants.     

H-2-restricted graft-versus-host reaction: Foreign determinants and restriction elements

Nylon-wool-purified T cells from radiation chimeras cause a lethal graft-versus-host reaction (GVHR) in irradiated, bone-marrow-protected recipients only if the recipient shares a restriction element with the T-cell donor and also expresses antigens foreign to the donor. Class I molecules (H-2K and H-2D) can act as restriction elements, but restriction to class II molecules could not be demonstrated. However, class II molecules as well as H-2K and some non-H-2 determinants could serve as foreign antigens.     

Inhibition of cytolytic T lymphocyte clones reactive with Moloney leukemia virus-associated antigens by monoclonal antibodies: a direct approach to the study of H-2 restriction

H-2 restriction in cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL)-mediated lysis of syngeneic murine Moloney leukemia virus (MoLV)-induced tumor cells was studied at the clonal level by testing the inhibitory effect of monoclonal anti-H-2 antibodies on the lytic interaction between CTL clones and target cells. Large numbers of MoLV-specific CTL clones were generated by placing limiting numbers of C57BL/6 regressor (responder) spleen cells into micro-mixed leukocyte-tumor cell cultures. The clonal CTL populations thus obtained were split into 5 aliquots and tested for lytic activity in the presence (or absence) of 1 of 3 monoclonal antibodies or of an anti-whole H-2b haplotype antiserum. Two of the monoclonal antibodies were directed against H-2Db and one against H-2Kb determinants. Specificity of these reagents had been verified by demonstrating inhibition of lysis by CTL populations directed against H-2Db and H-2Kb alloantigens. In 44 of a total of 51 clones tested, results showed selective inhibition by the anti-H-2Db (and the anti-whole haplotype) reagents, and lack of inhibition by the anti-H-2Kb antibody., Of the remaining 7 clones, none was inhibited by the anti-H-2Db antibody, and 3 were inhibited by the anti-whole haplotype antiserum. These studies show that the recognition of MoLV-associated antigens by the majority of CTL clones was restricted to the H-2Db region, and that there exists limited heterogeneity in the H-2 restriction of such clones.     

Analysis of neonatally induced tolerance of H-2 alloantigens

Neonatal inoculation of mice with semi-allogeneic lymphohematopoietic cells produces a state of highly specific allograft tolerance. Phenotypically, by both in vivo and in vitro criteria, antigen-reactive cells specific for the tolerated antigens appear to be clonally deleted from intact, tolerant mice. However, a series of adoptive transfer experiments using mice rendered tolerant of variousH-2 alloantigens revealed that tolerance of Ia (class II) antigens is maintained by a different mechanism than tolerance of K/D (class I) antigens. Long-term acceptance of Ia-disparate grafts by recipients of Ia-tolerant lymphoid cells suggested that an active process (rather than passive clonal deletion) mediates and maintains this type of tolerance. No comparable success was achieved when tolerance of isolated class I or entireH-2 haplotype disparity was examined, suggesting that clonal deletion might be operative in these combinations. Modest prolongation of skin-graft survival was observed in adoptive transfer recipients of lymphoid cells from donors tolerant ofI-JECSD disparity. These data are compatible with the hypothesis that the centralI region (JE) promotes tolerance induction to associated strong IA- and D-region alloantigens by activating a suppression mechanism.With the technical assistance of Phoebe Strome.     

Monoclonal antibodies directed against major histocompatibility complex antigens bind to the surface of Treponema pallidum isolated from infected rabbits or humans

Evidence is presented for the association of class I major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens with the surface of Treponema pallidum during infection. A monoclonal antibody (IgG2a) directed against a murine H-2Kb epitope of public specificity reacted with the cell surface of T. pallidum, as assayed by the binding of protein A-colloidal gold in immunoelectron microscopy. Monoclonal antibodies directed against class I rabbit MHC antigens also reacted in immunofluorescence assays with material on the surface of rabbit-cultivated T. pallidum. In addition, impression smears of human syphilitic genital ulcers that were darkfield-positive for the presence of spirochetes were tested in immunofluorescence assays with monoclonal antibodies directed against human MHC antigens; antibody directed against HLA-ABC (class I) was reactive whereas antibody directed against HLA-DR (class II) was nonreactive. Results of the study suggest that the association of host-derived class I MHC antigens or molecular mimicry may play a role in T. pallidum evasion of host immune defenses.     

Evidence for involvement of clonal anergy in MHC class I and class II disparate skin allograft tolerance after the termination of intrathymic clonal deletion

Mechanisms of cyclophosphamide (CP)-induced tolerance to class I (D) and class II (IE) alloantigens were studied. Transplantation tolerance across H-2D plus IE Ag-barriers has been achieved when B10.Thy-1.1 (Kb,IAb,IE-,Db; Thy-1.1) mice were primed i.v. with 9 x 10(7) spleen cells plus 3 x 10(7) bone marrow cells from B10.A(5R) mice (5R; kb,IAb,IEb,Dd; Thy-1.2) and treated i.p. with 200 mg/kg of CP 2 days later. The tolerant state in the early and the late stage was confirmed by prolonged acceptance of donor-type skin grafts, and in vitro unresponsiveness to donor Ag. In the tolerant B10.Thy-1.1 mice treated with 5R cells 28 days earlier and followed by CP, intrathymic clonal deletion of V beta 11+ T cells reactive to IE-encoded antigens was observed in association with intrathymic mixed chimerism. 5R skin survived, however, even after the clonal deletion of V beta 11+ T cells terminated by 180 days after tolerance induction. V beta 11+ T cells, which reappeared in the periphery of the recipient B10.Thy-1.1 mice bearing 5R skin at this stage, were not capable of proliferating in response to receptor cross-linking with V beta 11-specific mAb. Furthermore, the CTL activity against class I (Dd) alloantigens of spleen cells from these tolerant mice was restored by the addition of IL-2 to MLC. Thus, our experiments provide direct evidence that tolerance to both class I (Dd) and class II (IEb) alloantigens by clonal allergy occurs during the termination of intrathymic clonal deletion. These results clearly show practical hierarchy of the mechanisms of transplantation tolerance.     

Analysis of the rat major histocompatibility system by Southern blot hybridization

The organization of the rat major histocompatibility complex, RT1, was studied at the DNA level by Southern blot hybridization. Genomic DNA from eight different RT1 congenic rat strains was digested by various restriction enzymes and was hybridized under stringent conditions with probes of mouse class I and class II H-2 genes. Few cross-hybridizing DNA fragments, showing no polymorphism, were seen with class II A alpha and A beta probes. The class I probes allowed for the distinction of about 8 to 19 cross-hybridizing bands, which exhibited extensive polymorphism. With the use of five RT1 recombinants, about 20% of the DNA fragments could be mapped to the RT1.A region, which codes for the ubiquitously expressed class I antigens, and about 80% to the RT1.C region-determining class I-like antigens, which are different from RT1.A antigens with respect to tissue distribution, restriction function in immune responses, and allograft rejection. The number of class I genes present in the rat genome and the possible relationship of RT1.C to H-2Qa, Tla of the mouse are discussed.     

The role of Ia molecules in the activation of T lymphocytes. II. Ia-restricted recognition of allo K/D antigens is required for class I MHC-stimulated mixed lymphocyte responses

The role of Ia molecules in the T cell proliferative response to class I (H2K/D) MHC alloantigens was examined. Proliferation in response to allo-K/D antigenic stimulation, but not to allo-Ia, was markedly inhibited by the addition of monoclonal anti-responder Ia antibodies to cultures in the absence of C. This anti-Ia blocking was observed in responses against both allelic and mutant class I antigens. Partial blocking was observed by using an anti-I-A or anti-I-E monoclonal antibody alone, whereas marked inhibition was seen with these two reagents together when the proliferating cells derived from a responder strain expressing both IA and IE gene products. Syngeneic Ia molecules appear to function as restriction elements, because they are required even in the presence of a source of exogenous second signal, phorbol myristic acetate or IL 1. The K/D-specific response required a responding cell that bears both Lyt-1 and -2 antigens, whereas responses generated to alloantigenic differences, including the I region, require only an Ly-1+ cell. The implications of these data with respect to the repertoire of the alloreactive proliferating T cell and the expression of the Lyt-2 antigen by such cells are discussed.     

Restricted recognition of H-2 subregion coded alloantigens in delayed-type hypersensitivity

Subcutaneous (sc) immunization of mice with H-2K, I, or D incompatible spleen cells induces a state of host-versus-graft (HvG) delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH). The DTH reaction is elicited by challenging the immunized mice in a hind foot with similar allogeneic spleen cells and is measured as the subsequent foot swelling. DTH effector T cells specific for H-2I-coded alloantigens, but not for H-2K/D-coded alloantigens, can be induced in a graft-versus-host (GvH) model as well. In this paper we report that under HvG as well as under GvH conditions the recognition of class II antigens by DTH effector T cells is restricted by class I molecules. Furthermore, DTH effector T cells induced by sc immunization with class I antigens appear to be restricted by class II molecules.     

Histocompatibility-2 system in wild mice. X. Frequencies of H-2 and Ia antigens in wild mice from Europe and Africa

In this study, data are presented on serologic H-2 typing of 320 wild mice collected in several parts of Europe and Egypt. The sample was typed for 39 class I (K, D) and 16 class II (Ia) antigens. The phenotype frequencies of class I and class II antigens showed high variability in their distribution among different areas, ranging from absence or presence in low frequency in one area to presence in about one-half of the mice in another area. The average phenotypic frequency of class I private antigens was 6.3%; at least 60% of class I alleles (blanks) could not be identified with the available reagents. The data suggest that there might be more than 100 alleles for each class I locus, H-2K and H-2D. The average phenotypic frequencies of Ia-1 private antigens was 10.8%. About 75% of Ia-1 alleles (blanks) could not be identified. The number of Ia-1 alleles was estimated to be in the range of 20 to 50.     

Parasite-accessory cell interactions in murine leishmaniasis. II. Leishmania donovani suppresses macrophage expression of class I and class II major histocompatibility complex gene products

In the present study, we examined the modulation of MHC class II and class I gene products on BALB/c macrophages infected with the obligate intracellular protozoan Leishmania donovani. Our findings indicated that this organism suppressed macrophage expression of both classes of MHC antigens. These effects varied somewhat, depending on whether cells were in the basal state or were stimulated with interferon-gamma. Thus, class II density on interferon-gamma-treated infected macrophages was suppressed by as much as 90%, relative to lymphokine-stimulated control cells. Induction of H-2K and H-2D by lymphokine treatment of infected macrophages was also markedly reduced. In the basal (non-lymphokine-treated) state, infected cells also showed reduced expression of H-2K and H-2D, but not I-A or I-E. The latter result was related to minimal levels of class II molecules on normal, in vitro cultured macrophages. Suppression of MHC gene products correlated with both the duration and intensity of leishmania infection and could not be overcome by increasing doses of interferon-gamma. Culture of cells under conditions of cyclooxygenase inhibition completely abolished elevated synthesis of prostaglandin E2 by infected macrophages and augmented their responsiveness to lymphokine induction of class II antigens by 60 to 80%. These results indicate that L. donovani is capable of subverting a critical macrophage accessory function required for the induction of T lymphocyte immunity. This mechanism could account, at least in part, for defective parasite-specific cell-mediated immunity seen during infections with this protozoan.     

Major histocompatibility complex-restricted augmenting T cells induced by in vitro cultivation of antigen-primed T cells. A new parallelism between suppressor and augmenting circuits

In vitro cultivation of primed T cells with antigen resulted in the induction of a regulatory T cell that nonspecifically augmented the in vitro antibody responses of H-2-compatible T and B cells. This T cell, designated as the augmenting T cell (Ta), was unable to help B cells by itself but enhanced the antibody response of B cells to several multitudes only when conventional helper T (Th) cells or cloned Th cells from the same H-2 haplotype coexisted. Ta was radioresistant and belonged to Lyt-1+, 2-, L3T4+, I-J- T cell lineage. Ta exhibited interesting H-2-restricted activities: when primed T cells from (A X B) F1 were cultured with the antigen in the presence of parent A type antigen-presenting cells, the induced Ta was able to augment the antibody response of (A x B) F1 B cells in the presence of Th cells from F1----A but not from F1----B radiation bone marrow chimeras. This indicates that the induction of Ta in an F1 T cell population is dependent on the H-2 haplotype of antigen-presenting cells during in vitro cultivation. The restriction specificity of the established Ta is, however, not directed to the class II antigen itself but to the restriction specificity of Th cells that recognize class II antigen. In support of this is the fact that the elimination of A-restricted Th cells during cultivation by treatment with anti-I-J mAb, which is known to react with H-2-restricted Th cells, resulted in failure of induction of Ta cells having the augmenting activity for the A-restricted response.     

Cyclosporine-induced tolerance in experimental organ transplantation. Evidence of diminished donor-specific cytotoxicity relative to donor-specific proliferative response

Alloreactivity of intragraft and peripheral blood lymphocytes from tolerant canine lung allograft recipients was examined. Tolerance was induced by variable periods of treatment with cyclosporine. Analysis of effector cells from lung allografts (obtained by bronchoalveolar lavage) revealed the absence of specific cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) activity and the presence of a low level of cytolytic activity detected in a lectin-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity assay. In contrast, high levels of specific CTL activity and lectin-dependent activity were detected in cell preparations from lung allografts undergoing rejection. Tolerant recipients retained normal ability to generate specific CTL activity to third party alloantigens in mixed lymphocyte cultures (MLC) but had diminished ability to generate CTL to donor alloantigens in recipient X donor MLC. Addition of exogenous interleukin 2 to these MLC was unable to restore donor-specific CTL activity. Lymphocytes from tolerant recipients were, however, capable of generating proliferative responses and lectin-dependent cytotoxicity on exposure to donor alloantigens in MLC. Evidence presented in this report suggests that the lectin-dependent cytolytic activity generated in these MLC is mediated by lymphokine-activated killer cells. Such cells are likely to be activated by interleukin 2 released in the proliferative response. The results support the proposal that the cyclosporine-induced tolerant state is characterized by the relative inability to respond against major histocompatibility complex class I antigens in contrast to class II antigens and/or minor histocompatibility antigens since MLC-induced CTL are directed, for the most part, against class I molecules.     

Tumor rejection mediated by transfection with allogeneic class I histocompatibility gene

Non-self class I histocompatibility Ag can act as strong alloantigens and be recognized as distinct targets by CTL. To study the possibility of using allograft rejection to generate tumor-specific immunity, we have introduced an allogeneic class I histocompatibility gene, the H-2Kb gene, into a k haplotype tumor, K36.16, by DNA-mediated gene transfer. The K36.16 tumor grows readily and does not confer protective immunity in AKR mice. A total of 37 H-2Kb-transfected K36.16 clones (Kb/K36.16) was isolated and studied individually. The Kb/K36.16 clones were found to differ significantly in the amount of the exogenous H-2Kb antigens expressed on their cell surface. Moreover, as a result of the transfection, the level of expression of the endogenous H-2Dk Ag was also altered when compared to that of the parental K36.16 tumor cells. All the Kb/K36.16 clones that were positive for the H-2Kb Ag were rejected by the semisyngeneic AKR mice. Moreover, some of these Kb/K36.16 clones were also rejected by syngeneic (AKR x C57BL/10)F1 mice. In consequence of immunization with the Kb/K36.16 clones, the AKR and F1 mice were able to survive a subsequent challenge of the wild-type, unmodified, parental K36.16 tumor cells. More importantly, some of these Kb/K36.16 clones demonstrated an active and specific immunotherapeutic effect, and they were able to eradicate the growth of the parental K36.16 tumor cells in AKR mice. This observation therefore reinforces the feasibility of using DNA-mediated gene transfer as a molecular approach to abrogate tumor growth.     

Histocompatibility-2 system in wild mice

Ninety-six wild mice trapped at 13 localities in the state of Texas were tested in the dye-exclusion cytotoxic test with a battery of 49 oligospecific H-2 antisera. The antisera detected 36 class I (K and D) and 10 class II (Ia) antigens. The phenotypic frequencies of private class I antigens ranged from 1 to 20%, the majority of them being in the range between 1 and 5%. At least some of the higher frequencies resulted from the presence of more than one antibody in the typing reagents, and from other factors complicating the typing. We estimate that the frequencies of most of the class I alleles among Texas wild mice are 1% or less. This estimate leads to the prediction that at least 200 alleles exist in Texas mice at theH-2K locus, and another 200 alleles exist at theH-2D locus. Frequencies of most of the class I public antigens were in excess of 20%. In the sample of 96 mice, 46 different phenotypic combinations of private class I antigens were found, and the frequency of blanks (mice unreactive with any of the antibodies to private class I antigens) was 27%. The frequencies of private class II antigens ranged from 5 to 15%. Some of the public class II antigens, in particular those controlled by theE region, occurred with frequencies of 80% or higher. The class II antigens were found in 26 phenotypic combinations. No striking linkage disequilibrium was found either between K and D antigens, or between class I and class II antigens. The polymorphism of theK, A, andD region appears to be higher than that of the corresponding regions of the human or rat major histocompatibility complex. The polymorphism of theE region is significantly lower than that of theA, K, andD regions. The polymorphism of theA region is extensive.