Characterizing antiprion compounds based on their binding properties to prion proteins: Implications as medical chaperones

A variety of antiprion compounds have been reported that are effective in ex vivo and in vivo treatment experiments. However, the molecular mechanisms for most of these compounds remain unknown. Here we classified antiprion mechanisms into four categories: I, specific conformational stabilization; II, nonspecific stabilization; III, aggregation; and IV, interaction with molecules other than PrP^C. To characterize antiprion compounds based on this classification, we determined their binding affinities to PrP^C using surface plasmon resonance and their binding sites on PrP^C using NMR spectroscopy. GN8 and GJP49 bound specifically to the hot spot in PrP^C, and acted as “medical chaperones” to stabilize the native conformation. Thus, mechanisms I was predominant. In contrast, quinacrine and epigallocathechin bound to PrP^C rather nonspecifically; these may stabilize the PrP^C conformation nonspecifically including the interference with the intermolecular interaction following mechanism II. Congo red and pentosan polysulfate bound to PrP^C and caused aggregation and precipitation of PrP^C, thus reducing the effective concentration of prion protein. Thus, mechanism III was appropriate. Finally, CP‐60, an edarabone derivative, did not bind to PrP^C. Thus these were classified into mechanism IV. However, their antiprion activities were not confirmed in the GT + FK system, whose details remain to be elucidated. This proposed antiprion mechanisms of diverse antiprion compounds could help to elucidate their antiprion activities and facilitate effective antiprion drug discovery.     

Antibody binding modulates the dynamics of the membrane-bound prion protein

Misfolding of the cellular prion protein (PrP^C) is associated with lethal neurodegeneration. PrP^C consists of a flexible tail (residues 23–123) and a globular domain (residues 124–231) whose C-terminal end is anchored to the cell membrane. The neurotoxic antibody POM1 and the innocuous antibody POM6 recognize the globular domain. Experimental evidence indicates that POM1 binding to PrP^C emulates the influence on PrP^C of the misfolded prion protein (PrP^Sc) while the binding of POM6 has the opposite biological response. Little is known about the potential interactions between flexible tail, globular domain, and the membrane. Here, we used atomistic simulations to investigate how these interactions are modulated by the binding of the Fab fragments of POM1 and POM6 to PrP^C and by interstitial sequence truncations to the flexible tail. The simulations show that the binding of the antibodies restricts the range of orientations of the globular domain with respect to the membrane and decreases the distance between tail and membrane. Five of the six sequence truncations influence only marginally this distance and the contact patterns between tail and globular domain. The only exception is a truncation coupled to a charge inversion mutation of four N-terminal residues, which increases the distance of the flexible tail from the membrane. The interactions of the flexible tail and globular domain are modulated differently by the two antibodies.     

DLP1‐dependent mitochondrial fragmentation and redistribution mediate prion‐associated mitochondrial dysfunction and neuronal death

Mitochondrial malfunction is a universal and critical step in the pathogenesis of many neurodegenerative diseases including prion diseases. Dynamin‐like protein 1 (DLP1) is one of the key regulators of mitochondrial fission. In this study, we investigated the role of DLP1 in mitochondrial fragmentation and dysfunction in neurons using in vitro and in vivo prion disease models. Mitochondria became fragmented and redistributed from axons to soma, correlated with increased mitochondrial DLP1 expression in murine primary neurons (N2a cells) treated with the prion peptide PrP^106–126 in vitro as well as in prion strain‐infected hamster brain in vivo. Suppression of DLP1 expression by DPL1 RNAi inhibited prion‐induced mitochondrial fragmentation and dysfunction (measured by ADP/ATP ratio, mitochondrial membrane potential, and mitochondrial integrity). We also demonstrated that DLP1 RNAi is neuroprotective against prion peptide in N2a cells as shown by improved cell viability and decreased apoptosis markers, caspase 3 induced by PrP^106–126. On the contrary, overexpression of DLP1 exacerbated mitochondrial dysfunction and cell death. Moreover, inhibition of DLP1 expression ameliorated PrP^106–126‐induced neurite loss and synaptic abnormalities (i.e., loss of dendritic spine and PSD‐95, a postsynaptic scaffolding protein as a marker of synaptic plasticity) in primary neurons, suggesting that altered DLP1 expression and mitochondrial fragmentation are upstream events that mediate PrP^106–126‐induced neuron loss and degeneration. Our findings suggest that DLP1‐dependent mitochondrial fragmentation and redistribution plays a pivotal role in PrP^Sc‐associated mitochondria dysfunction and neuron apoptosis. Inhibition of DLP1 may be a novel and effective strategy in the prevention and treatment of prion diseases.     

Prion protein with a mutant N-terminal octarepeat region undergoes cobalamin-dependent assembly into high–molecular weight complexes

The cellular prion protein (PrP^C) has a C-terminal globular domain and a disordered N-terminal region encompassing five octarepeats (ORs). Encounters between Cu(II) ions and four OR sites produce interchangeable binding geometries; however, the significance of Cu(II) binding to ORs in different combinations is unclear. To understand the impact of specific binding geometries, OR variants were designed that interact with multiple or single Cu(II) ions in specific locked coordinations. Unexpectedly, we found that one mutant produced detergent-insoluble, protease-resistant species in cells in the absence of exposure to the infectious prion protein isoform, scrapie-associated prion protein (PrP^Sc). Formation of these assemblies, visible as puncta, was reversible and dependent upon medium formulation. Cobalamin (Cbl), a dietary cofactor containing a corrin ring that coordinates a Co³⁺ ion, was identified as a key medium component, and its effect was validated by reconstitution experiments. Although we failed to find evidence that Cbl interacts with Cu-binding OR regions, we instead noted interactions of Cbl with the PrP^C C-terminal domain. We found that some interactions occurred at a binding site of planar tetrapyrrole compounds on the isolated globular domain, but others did not, and N-terminal sequences additionally had a marked effect on their presence and position. Our studies define a conditional effect of Cbl wherein a mutant OR region can act in cis to destabilize a globular domain with a wild type sequence. The unexpected intersection between the properties of PrP^Sc''s disordered region, Cbl, and conformational remodeling events may have implications for understanding sporadic prion disease that does not involve exposure to PrP^Sc.     

Transition of the prion protein from a structured cellular form (PrPC) to the infectious scrapie agent (PrPSc)

Prion diseases in mammals are caused by a conformational transition of the cellular prion protein from its native conformation (PrP^C) to a pathological isoform called “prion protein scrapie” (PrP^Sc). A molecular level of understanding of this conformational transition will be helpful in unveiling the disease etiology. Experimental structural biological techniques (NMR and X‐ray crystallography) have been used to unravel the atomic level structural information for the prion and its binding partners. More than one hundred three‐dimensional structures of the mammalian prions have been deposited in the protein databank. Structural studies on the prion protein and its structural transitions will deepen our understanding of the molecular basis of prion pathogenesis and will provide valuable guidance for future structure‐based drug discovery endeavors.     

Differential stability of the bovine prion protein upon urea unfolding

Prion diseases, or transmissible spongiform encephalopathies, are a group of infectious neurological diseases associated with the structural conversion of an endogenous protein (PrP) in the central nervous system. There are two major forms of this protein: the native and noninfectious cellular form, PrP^C; and the misfolded, infectious, and proteinase K‐resistant form, PrP^Sc. The C‐terminal domain of PrP^C is mainly α‐helical in structure, whereas PrP^Sc in known to aggregate into an assembly of β‐sheets, forming amyloid fibrils. To identify the regions of PrP^C potentially involved in the initial steps of the conversion to the infectious conformation, we have used high‐resolution NMR spectroscopy to characterize the stability and structure of bovine recombinant PrP^C (residues 121 to 230) during unfolding with the denaturant urea. Analysis of the 800 MHz ¹H NMR spectra reveals region‐specific information about the structural changes occurring upon unfolding. Our data suggest that the dissociation of the native β‐sheet of PrP^C is a primary step in the urea‐induced unfolding process, while strong hydrophobic interactions between helices α1 and α3, and between α2 and α3, stabilize these regions even at very high concentrations of urea.     

The POM Monoclonals: A Comprehensive Set of Antibodies to Non-Overlapping Prion Protein Epitopes

PrP^Sc, a misfolded and aggregated form of the cellular prion protein PrP^C, is the only defined constituent of the transmissible agent causing prion diseases. Expression of PrP^C in the host organism is necessary for prion replication and for prion neurotoxicity. Understanding prion diseases necessitates detailed structural insights into PrP^C and PrP^Sc. Towards this goal, we have developed a comprehensive collection of monoclonal antibodies denoted POM1 to POM19 and directed against many different epitopes of mouse PrP^C. Three epitopes are located within the N-terminal octarepeat region, one is situated within the central unstructured region, and four epitopes are discontinuous within the globular C-proximal domain of PrP^C. Some of these antibodies recognize epitopes that are resilient to protease digestion in PrP^Sc. Other antibodies immunoprecipitate PrP^C, but not PrP^Sc. A third group was found to immunoprecipitate both PrP isoforms. Some of the latter antibodies could be blocked with epitope-mimicking peptides, and incubation with an excess of these peptides allowed for immunochromatography of PrP^C and PrP^Sc. Amino-proximal antibodies were found to react with repetitive PrP^C epitopes, thereby vastly increasing their avidity. We have also created functional single-chain miniantibodies from selected POMs, which retained the binding characteristics despite their low molecular mass. The POM collection, thus, represents a unique set of reagents allowing for studies with a variety of techniques, including western blotting, ELISA, immunoprecipitation, conformation-dependent immunoassays, and plasmon surface plasmon resonance-based assays.     

Role of polysaccharide and lipid in lipopolysaccharide induced prion protein conversion

Conversion of native cellular prion protein (PrP^c) from an α-helical structure to a toxic and infectious β-sheet structure (PrP^Sc) is a critical step in the development of prion disease. There are some indications that the formation of PrP^Sc is preceded by a β-sheet rich PrP (PrP^β) form which is non-infectious, but is an intermediate in the formation of infectious PrP^Sc. Furthermore the presence of lipid cofactors is thought to be critical in the formation of both intermediate-PrP^β and lethal, infectious PrP^Sc. We previously discovered that the endotoxin, lipopolysaccharide (LPS), interacts with recombinant PrP^c and induces rapid conformational change to a β-sheet rich structure. This LPS induced PrP^β structure exhibits PrP^Sc-like features including proteinase K (PK) resistance and the capacity to form large oligomers and rod-like fibrils. LPS is a large, complex molecule with lipid, polysaccharide, 2-keto-3-deoxyoctonate (Kdo) and glucosamine components. To learn more about which LPS chemical constituents are critical for binding PrP^c and inducing β-sheet conversion we systematically investigated which chemical components of LPS either bind or induce PrP conversion to PrP^β. We analyzed this PrP conversion using resolution enhanced native acidic gel electrophoresis (RENAGE), tryptophan fluorescence, circular dichroism, electron microscopy and PK resistance. Our results indicate that a minimal version of LPS (called detoxified and partially de-acylated LPS or dLPS) containing a portion of the polysaccharide and a portion of the lipid component is sufficient for PrP conversion. Lipid components, alone, and saccharide components, alone, are insufficient for conversion.     

Review of studies that have used knockout mice to assess normal function of prion protein under immunological or pathophysiological stress

Deletion of cellular isoform of prion protein (PrP^C) increases neuronal predisposition to damage by modulating apoptosis and the negative consequences of oxidative stress. In vivo studies have demonstrated that PrP^C‐deficient mice are more prone to seizure, depression, and induction of epilepsy and experience extensive cerebral damage following ischemic challenge or viral infection. In addition, adenovirus‐mediated overexpression of PrP^C reduces brain damage in rat models of cerebral ischemia. In experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis, PrP^C‐deficient mice reportedly have a more aggressive disease onset and less clinical improvement during the chronic phase than wild‐type mice mice. In mice given oral dextran sulfate, PrP^C has a potential protective role against inflammatory bowel disease. PrP^C‐deficient mice demonstrate significantly greater increases in blood glucose concentrations after intraperitoneal injection of glucose than wild‐type mice. Further in vivo challenges to PrP gene‐deficient models and conditional knockout models with siRNA and in vivo administration of PrP‐ligating agents may assist in refining knowledge of the lymphoid function of PrP^C and predicting the effects of anti‐PrP treatment on the immune system. Together, these findings indicate that PrP^C may have multiple neuroprotective and anti‐inflammatory roles, which explains why this protein is so widely expressed.     

Rare Large Scale Subdomain Motions in Prion Protein can Initiate Aggregation

Abstract

The prion protein is thought to induce prion diseases by changing its conformation from the cellular form, PrP^c, into the infectious Scrapie-form, PrP^Sc. Little is known about the structural and dynamical features of this conformational change. We here introduce a novel concept that involves rare large scale motions between the subdomains βl-αl-β2 and α2-α3 in the carboxy-terminal, globular part of PrP. The interface between these two subdomains carries most pathogenic mutations known to be associated with prion diseases. Based on computational simulations as well as experimental results we propose that such a large scale motion subsequently destabilizes large parts of the cellular conformer PrP^c, thus, rendering it prone to structural rearrangements, including aggregation of now partially unfolded parts of the PrP sequence. We hypothesize that such large scale motions occur as a rare event even under equilibrium conditions and that the interaction of such partially destabilized PrP^c-conformers, which we named PrP^c*, contributes to the formation of pathogenic oligomeric species of the prion protein.     

Prion Protein Is Necessary for Latent Learning and Long-Term Memory Retention

1. The cellular prion protein, designated PrP^c, is a key molecule in the prion diseases but its physiological function remains unknown. To elucidate whether PrP^c plays some role in the central nervous system, we established a line of mice in which the PrP gene had been disrupted and subsequently conducted long-term observations.2. Performance in latent learning and passive avoidance was evaluated using water-finding and step-through tests, respectively.3. PrP ^–/– mice showed impaired performance in the water-finding test, indicating a disturbance in latent learning, at 23 weeks of age. In the step-through test, although the PrP ^–/– mice showed normal learning ability and short-term memory retention, they evidenced a significant disturbance in long-term memory retention.4. These results indicate that PrP^c is needed for certain types of learning and memory and that the loss of function of this protein may contribute to the pathogenesis of prion diseases.     

Residue-specific mobility changes in soluble oligomers of the prion protein define regions involved in aggregation

Prion (PrP) diseases are neurodegenerative diseases characterized by the formation of β-sheet rich, insoluble and protease resistant protein deposits (called PrP^Sc) that occur throughout the brain. Formation of synthetic or in vitro PrP^Sc can occur through on-pathway toxic oligomers. Similarly, toxic and infectious oligomers identified in cell and animal models of prion disease indicate that soluble oligomers are likely intermediates in the formation of insoluble PrP^Sc. Despite the critical role of prion oligomers in disease progression, little is known about their structure. In order, to obtain structural insight into prion oligomers, we generated oligomers by shaking-induced conversion of recombinant, monomeric prion protein PrP^c (spanning residues 90–231). We then obtained two-dimensional solution NMR spectra of the PrP^c monomer, a 40% converted oligomer, and a 94% converted oligomer. Heteronuclear single-quantum correlation (¹H–¹⁵N) studies revealed that, in comparison to monomeric PrP^c, the oligomer has intense amide peak signals in the N-terminal (residues 90–114) and C-terminal regions (residues 226–231). Furthermore, a core region with decreased mobility is revealed from residues ~127 to 225. Within this core oligomer region with decreased mobility, there is a pocket of increased amide peak signal corresponding to the middle of α-helix 2 and the loop between α-helices 2 and 3 in the PrP^c monomer structure. Using high-resolution solution-state NMR, this work reveals detailed and divergent residue-specific changes in soluble oligomeric models of PrP.     

Applying the tools of chemistry (mass spectrometry and covalent modification by small molecule reagents) to the detection of prions and the study of their structure

Prions are molecular pathogens, able to convert a normal cellular prion protein (PrP^C) into a prion (PrP^Sc). The information necessary for this conversion is contained in the conformation of PrP^Sc. Mass spectrometry (MS) and small-molecule covalent reactions have been used to study prions. Mass spectrometry has been used to detect and quantitate prions in the attomole range (10^?18 mole). MS-based analysis showed that both possess identical amino acid sequences, one disulfide bond, a GPI anchor, asparagine-linked sugar antennae, and unoxidized methionines. Mass spectrometry has been used to define elements of the secondary and tertiary structure of wild-type PrP^Sc and GPI-anchorless PrP^Sc. It has also been used to study the quaternary structure of the PrP^Sc multimer. Small molecule reagents react differently with the same lysine in the PrP^C conformation than in the PrP^Sc conformation. Such differences can be detected by Western blot using mAbs with lysine-containing epitopes, such as 3F4 and 6D11. This permits the detection of PrP^Sc without the need for proteinase K pretreatment and can be used to distinguish among prion strains. These results illustrate how two important chemical tools, mass spectrometry and covalent modification by small molecules, are being applied to the detection and structural study of prions. Furthermore these tools are or can be applied to the study of the other protein misfolding diseases such as Alzheimer Disease, Parkinson Disease, or ALS.     

Role of Lipid Rafts and GM1 in the Segregation and Processing of Prion Protein

The prion protein (PrP^C) is highly expressed within the nervous system. Similar to other GPI-anchored proteins, PrP^C is found in lipid rafts, membrane domains enriched in cholesterol and sphingolipids. PrP^C raft association, together with raft lipid composition, appears essential for the conversion of PrP^C into the scrapie isoform PrP^Sc, and the development of prion disease. Controversial findings were reported on the nature of PrP^C-containing rafts, as well as on the distribution of PrP^C between rafts and non-raft membranes. We investigated PrP^C/ganglioside relationships and their influence on PrP^C localization in a neuronal cellular model, cerebellar granule cells. Our findings argue that in these cells at least two PrP^C conformations coexist: in lipid rafts PrP^C is present in the native folding (α-helical), stabilized by chemico-physical condition, while it is mainly present in other membrane compartments in a PrP^Sc-like conformation. We verified, by means of antibody reactivity and circular dichroism spectroscopy, that changes in lipid raft-ganglioside content alters PrP^C conformation and interaction with lipid bilayers, without modifying PrP^C distribution or cleavage. Our data provide new insights into the cellular mechanism of prion conversion and suggest that GM1-prion protein interaction at the cell surface could play a significant role in the mechanism predisposing to pathology.     

Different antigenicities of the N‐terminal region of cellular and scrapie prion proteins

Limited information is available about conformational differences between the abnormal isoform of prion protein (PrP^Sc) and cellular prion protein (PrP^C) under native conditions. To clarify conformational differences between these two isoforms, PrP‐deficient mice were immunized with brain homogenates of normal and scrapie‐infected animals. All mice generated anti‐PrP antibodies. Peptide array analysis of these serum samples revealed a distinctive epitope of PrP^Sc consisting of QGSPGGN (PrP41–47) at the N‐terminus. This study demonstrated a conformational dissimilarity at the N‐terminus between PrP^Sc and PrP^C, a finding that may provide novel information about conformational features of PrP^Sc.     

Prion protein—Semisynthetic prion protein (PrP) variants with posttranslational modifications

Deciphering the pathophysiologic events in prion diseases is challenging, and the role of posttranslational modifications (PTMs) such as glypidation and glycosylation remains elusive due to the lack of homogeneous protein preparations. So far, experimental studies have been limited in directly analyzing the earliest events of the conformational change of cellular prion protein (PrP^C) into scrapie prion protein (PrP^Sc) that further propagates PrP^C misfolding and aggregation at the cellular membrane, the initial site of prion infection, and PrP misfolding, by a lack of suitably modified PrP variants. PTMs of PrP, especially attachment of the glycosylphosphatidylinositol (GPI) anchor, have been shown to be crucially involved in the PrP^Sc formation. To this end, semisynthesis offers a unique possibility to understand PrP behavior invitro and invivo as it provides access to defined site‐selectively modified PrP variants. This approach relies on the production and chemoselective linkage of peptide segments, amenable to chemical modifications, with recombinantly produced protein segments. In this article, advances in understanding PrP conversion using semisynthesis as a tool to obtain homogeneous posttranslationally modified PrP will be discussed.     

An insight into the thermodynamic characteristics of human thrombopoietin complexation with TN1 antibody

Human thrombopoietin (hTPO) primarily stimulates megakaryocytopoiesis and platelet production and is neutralized by the mouse TN1 antibody. The thermodynamic characteristics of TN1 antibody–hTPO complexation were analyzed by isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) using an antigen‐binding fragment (Fab) derived from the TN1 antibody (TN1‐Fab). To clarify the mechanism by which hTPO is recognized by TN1‐Fab the conformation of free TN1‐Fab was determined to a resolution of 2.0 Å using X‐ray crystallography and compared with the hTPO‐bound form of TN1‐Fab determined by a previous study. This structural comparison revealed that the conformation of TN1‐Fab does not substantially change after hTPO binding and a set of 15 water molecules is released from the antigen‐binding site (paratope) of TN1‐Fab upon hTPO complexation. Interestingly, the heat capacity change (ΔCp) measured by ITC (?1.52 ± 0.05 kJ mol^?1 K^?1) differed significantly from calculations based upon the X‐ray structure data of the hTPO‐bound and unbound forms of TN1‐Fab (?1.02 ～ 0.25 kJ mol^?1 K^?1) suggesting that hTPO undergoes an induced‐fit conformational change combined with significant desolvation upon TN1‐Fab binding. The results shed light on the structural biology associated with neutralizing antibody recognition.     

Molecular model of an alpha-helical prion protein dimer and its monomeric subunits as derived from chemical cross-linking and molecular modeling calculations

Prions are the agents of a series of lethal neurodegenerative diseases. They are composed largely, if not entirely, of the host-encoded prion protein (PrP), which can exist in the cellular isoform PrP^C and the pathological isoform PrP^Sc. The conformational change of the α-helical PrP^C into β-sheet-rich PrP^Sc is the fundamental event of prion disease. The transition of recombinant PrP from a PrP^C-like into a PrP^Sc-like conformation can be induced in vitro by submicellar concentrations of SDS. An α-helical dimer was identified that might represent either the native state of PrP^C or the first step from the monomeric PrP^C to highly aggregated PrP^Sc. In the present study, the molecular structure of these dimers was analyzed by introducing covalent cross-links using 1-ethyl-3-(3-dimethylaminopropyl) carbodiimide. Inter- and intramolecular bonds between directly neighboured amino groups and carboxy groups were generated. The bonds formed in PrP dimers of recombinant PrP (90-231) were identified by tryptic digestion and subsequent mass spectrometric analysis. Intra- and intermolecular cross-links between N-terminal glycine and three acidic amino acid side chains in the globular part of PrP were identified, showing the N-terminal amino acids (90-124) are not as flexible as known from NMR analysis. When the cross-linked sites were used as structural constraint, molecular modeling calculations yielded a structural model for PrP dimer and its monomeric subunit, including the folding of amino acids 90-124 in addition to the known structure. Molecular dynamics of the structure after release of the constraint indicated an intrinsic stability of the domain of amino acids 90-124.