Comprehensive evaluation of solution nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy sample preparation for helical integral membrane proteins

The preparation of high quality samples is a critical challenge for the structural characterization of helical integral membrane proteins. Solving the structures of this diverse class of proteins by solution nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (NMR) requires that well-resolved 2D ¹H/¹⁵N chemical shift correlation spectra be obtained. Acquiring these spectra demands the production of samples with high levels of purity and excellent homogeneity throughout the sample. In addition, high yields of isotopically enriched protein and efficient purification protocols are required. We describe two robust sample preparation methods for preparing high quality, homogeneous samples of helical integral membrane proteins. These sample preparation protocols have been combined with screens for detergents and sample conditions leading to the efficient production of samples suitable for solution NMR spectroscopy. We have examined 18 helical integral membrane proteins, ranging in size from approximately 9 kDa to 29 kDa with 1–4 transmembrane helices, originating from a number of bacterial and viral genomes. 2D ¹H/¹⁵N chemical shift correlation spectra acquired for each protein demonstrate well-resolved resonances, and >90% detection of the predicted resonances. These results indicate that with proper sample preparation, high quality solution NMR spectra of helical integral membrane proteins can be obtained greatly enhancing the probability for structural characterization of these important proteins.     

Automated and assisted RNA resonance assignment using NMR chemical shift statistics

The three-dimensional structure determination of RNAs by NMR spectroscopy relies on chemical shift assignment, which still constitutes a bottleneck. In order to develop more efficient assignment strategies, we analysed relationships between sequence and ¹H and ¹³C chemical shifts. Statistics of resonances from regularly Watson–Crick base-paired RNA revealed highly characteristic chemical shift clusters. We developed two approaches using these statistics for chemical shift assignment of double-stranded RNA (dsRNA): a manual approach that yields starting points for resonance assignment and simplifies decision trees and an automated approach based on the recently introduced automated resonance assignment algorithm FLYA. Both strategies require only unlabeled RNAs and three 2D spectra for assigning the H2/C2, H5/C5, H6/C6, H8/C8 and H1′/C1′ chemical shifts. The manual approach proved to be efficient and robust when applied to the experimental data of RNAs with a size between 20 nt and 42 nt. The more advanced automated assignment approach was successfully applied to four stem-loop RNAs and a 42 nt siRNA, assigning 92–100% of the resonances from dsRNA regions correctly. This is the first automated approach for chemical shift assignment of non-exchangeable protons of RNA and their corresponding ¹³C resonances, which provides an important step toward automated structure determination of RNAs.     

HNHC: a triple resonance experiment for correlating the H2, N1(N3) and C2 resonances in adenine nucleobases of <Superscript>13</Superscript>C-, <Superscript>15</Superscript>N-labeled RNA oligonucleotides

A novel NMR pulse sequence has been developed that correlates the H2 resonances with the C2 and the N1 (N3) resonances in adenine nucleobases of ¹³C, ¹⁵N labeled oligonucleotides. The pulse scheme of the new 3D-HNHC experiment is composed of a ²J-¹⁵N-HSQC and a ¹J-¹³C-HSQC and utilizes large ²J(H2, N1(N3)) and ¹J(H2, C2) couplings. The experiment was applied to a medium-size ¹³C, ¹⁵N-labeled 36mer RNA. It is useful to resolve assignment ambiguities occurring especially in larger RNA molecules due to resonance overlap in the ¹H-dimension. Therefore, the missing link in correlating the imino H3 resonances of the uracils across the AU base pair to the H8 resonances of the adenines via the novel pulse sequence and the TROSY relayed HCCH-COSY (Simon et al. in J Biomol NMR 20:173–176 2001) is provided. Electronic supplementary material  The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Dilute spin-exchange assignment of solid-state NMR spectra of oriented proteins: Acetylcholine M2 in bilayers

The assignment of amide resonances in the two-dimensional PISEMA (Polarization Inversion with Spin Exchange at the Magic Angle) spectrum of uniformly ¹⁵N labeled M2 peptide corresponding to the channel-lining segment of the acetylcholine receptor in oriented phospholipid bilayers is described. The majority of the resonances were assigned through comparisons with spectra from selectively ¹⁵N labeled recombinant peptides and specifically ¹⁵N labeled synthetic peptides. Some resonances were assigned to specific amino acid residues by means of homonuclear ¹⁵N spin-exchange spectroscopy. A modification to the conventional spin-exchange pulse sequence that significantly shortens the length of the experiments by combining the intervals for ¹⁵ N spin-exchange and ¹H magnetization recovery is described.     

Three-dimensional solid-state NMR spectroscopy of a peptide oriented in membrane bilayers

Summary A three-dimensional ¹H chemical shift/¹H-¹⁵N dipolar coupling/¹⁵N chemical shift correlation spectrum was obtained on a sample of specifically ¹⁵N-labeled magainin peptides oriented in lipid bilayers between glass plates in a flat-coil probe. The spectrum showed complete resolution of the resonances from two labeled amide sites in all three dimensions. The three orientationally dependent frequencies associated with each resonance enabled the orientation of the peptide planes to be determined relative to the direction of the applied magnetic field. These results demonstrate the feasibility of multiple-pulse spectroscopy in a flat-coil probe, the ability to measure three spectral parameters from each site in a single experiment, and the potential for resolving among many labeled sites in oriented membrane proteins.     

HNCAN pulse sequences for sequential backbone resonance assignment across proline residues in perdeuterated proteins

A TROSY-based triple-resonance pulse scheme is described which correlates backbone ¹H and ¹⁵N chemical shifts of an amino acid residue with the ¹⁵N chemical shifts of both the sequentially preceding and following residues. The sequence employs ¹ J _NC and ² J _NC couplings in two sequential magnetization transfer steps in an `out-and-back' manner. As a result, N,N connectivities are obtained irrespective of whether the neighbouring amide nitrogens are protonated or not, which makes the experiment suitable for the assignment of proline resonances. Two different three-dimensional variants of the pulse sequence are presented which differ in sensitivity and resolution to be achieved in one of the nitrogen dimensions. The new method is demonstrated with two uniformly ²H/¹³C/¹⁵N-labelled proteins in the 30-kDa range.     

Multidimensional oriented solid-state NMR experiments enable the sequential assignment of uniformly <Superscript>15</Superscript>N labeled integral membrane proteins in magnetically aligned lipid bilayers

Oriented solid-state NMR is the most direct methodology to obtain the orientation of membrane proteins with respect to the lipid bilayer. The method consists of measuring ¹H-¹⁵N dipolar couplings (DC) and ¹⁵N anisotropic chemical shifts (CSA) for membrane proteins that are uniformly aligned with respect to the membrane bilayer. A significant advantage of this approach is that tilt and azimuthal (rotational) angles of the protein domains can be directly derived from analytical expression of DC and CSA values, or, alternatively, obtained by refining protein structures using these values as harmonic restraints in simulated annealing calculations. The Achilles’ heel of this approach is the lack of suitable experiments for sequential assignment of the amide resonances. In this Article, we present a new pulse sequence that integrates proton driven spin diffusion (PDSD) with sensitivity-enhanced PISEMA in a 3D experiment ([¹H,¹⁵N]-SE-PISEMA-PDSD). The incorporation of 2D ¹⁵N/¹⁵N spin diffusion experiments into this new 3D experiment leads to the complete and unambiguous assignment of the ¹⁵N resonances. The feasibility of this approach is demonstrated for the membrane protein sarcolipin reconstituted in magnetically aligned lipid bicelles. Taken with low electric field probe technology, this approach will propel the determination of sequential assignment as well as structure and topology of larger integral membrane proteins in aligned lipid bilayers.     

Dipolar filtered 1H-13C heteronuclear correlation spectroscopy for resonance assignment of proteins

Resonance assignment is necessary for the comprehensive structure determination of insoluble proteins by solid-state NMR spectroscopy. While various 2D and 3D correlation techniques involving ¹³C and ¹⁵N spins have been developed for this purpose, ¹H chemical shift has not been exploited sufficiently. We demonstrate the combination of the regular ¹H-¹³C heteronuclear correlation (HETCOR) experiment and a dipolar filtered HETCOR technique to obtain better resolved ¹H chemical shift spectra. The dipolar filtered experiment, MELODI-HETCOR, simplifies the ¹H spectra by suppressing the directly bonded C-H correlation peaks and retaining only the medium- and long-range cross peaks. We apply this MELODI-HETCOR technique to several amino acids and proteins with various isotopic labeling patterns. The enhanced ¹H chemical shift resolution allows the assignment of overlapping H and H resonances in Ser, identifies the ¹H chemical shift differences between neutral and cationic imidazole rings of His, and permits the assignment of residues with side chain nitrogen atoms in ubiquitin. The potential utility of this dipolar filtered HETCOR technique to resonance assignment of extensively labeled proteins is discussed.     

Multiple frequency saturation pulses reduce CEST acquisition time for quantifying conformational exchange in biomolecules

Exchange between conformational states is required for biomolecular catalysis, allostery, and folding. A variety of NMR experiments have been developed to quantify motional regimes ranging from nanoseconds to seconds. In this work, we describe an approach to speed up the acquisition of chemical exchange saturation transfer (CEST) experiments that are commonly used to probe millisecond to second conformational exchange in proteins and nucleic acids. The standard approach is to obtain CEST datasets through the acquisition of a series of 2D correlation spectra where each experiment utilizes a single saturation frequency to ¹H, ¹⁵N or ¹³C. These pseudo 3D datasets are time consuming to collect and are further lengthened by reduced signal to noise stemming from the long saturation pulse. In this article, we show how usage of a multiple frequency saturation pulse (i.e., MF-CEST) changes the nature of data collection from series to parallel, and thus decreases the total acquisition time by an integer factor corresponding to the number of frequencies in the pulse. We demonstrate the applicability of MF-CEST on a Src homology 2 (SH2) domain from phospholipase Cγ and the secondary active transport protein EmrE as model systems by collecting ¹³C methyl and ¹⁵N backbone datasets. MF-CEST can also be extended to additional sites within proteins and nucleic acids. The only notable drawback of MF-CEST as applied to backbone ¹⁵N experiments occurs when a large chemical shift difference between the major and minor populations is present (typically greater than ~?8 ppm). In these cases, ambiguity may arise between the chemical shift of the minor population and the multiple frequency saturation pulse. Nevertheless, this drawback does not occur for methyl group MF-CEST experiments or in cases where somewhat smaller chemical shift differences occur are present.     

Automated assignment of NMR chemical shifts using peak-particle dynamics simulation with the DYNASSIGN algorithm

A new algorithm, DYNASSIGN, for the automated assignment of NMR chemical shift resonances was developed in which expected cross peaks in multidimensional NMR spectra are represented by peak-particles and assignment restraints are translated into a potential energy function. Molecular dynamics simulation techniques are used to calculate a trajectory of the system of peak-particles subjected to the potential function in order to find energetically optimal configurations that correspond to correct assignments. Peak-particle dynamics-based simulated annealing was combined with the Hungarian algorithm for local optimization, and a residue-based score was introduced to distinguish between reliable assignments and “unassigned” resonances for which no reliable assignment can be established. The DYNASSIGN algorithm was implemented in the program CYANA and tested with data sets obtained from the experimental NMR data of nine small proteins. With a set of 10 commonly used NMR spectra, on average 82.5% of all backbone and side-chain ¹H, ¹³C and ¹⁵N resonances could be assigned with an average error rate of 3.5%.     

Heterologous Expression of Hen Egg White Lysozyme and Resonance Assignment of Tryptophan Side Chains in its Non-native States

A new protocol is described for the isotope (¹⁵N and ¹³C,¹⁵N) enrichment of hen egg white lysozyme. Hen egg white lysozyme and an all-Ala-mutant of this protein have been expressed in E. coli. They formed inclusion bodies from which mg quantities of the proteins were purified and prepared for NMR spectroscopic investigations. ¹H,¹³C and ¹⁵N main chain resonances of disulfide reduced and S-methylated lysozyme were assigned and its residual structure in water pH 2 was characterized by chemical shift perturbation analysis. A new NMR experiment has been developed to assign tryptophan side chain indole resonances by correlation of side chain and backbone NH resonances with the C^γ resonances of these residues. Assignment of tryptophan side chains enables further residue specific investigations on structural and dynamical properties, which are of significant interest for the understanding of non-natives states of lysozyme stabilized by hydrophobic interactions between clusters of tryptophan residues.     

15N resonance assignments of oxidized and reducedChromatium vinosum high-potential iron protein

The¹⁵N resonances in reduced and oxidizedChromatium vinosum high-potential iron protein have been assigned by use of¹H-¹H COSY spectra and¹H-¹⁵N HMQC, HMQC-COSY, and HMQC-NOESY spectra. Unambiguous assignment of 70 of 85 backbone¹⁵N resonances in the reduced protein and 62 of 85 resonances in the oxidized protein are made, as are 12 of 21 side-chain¹⁵N resonances.     

15N resonance assignments of oxidized and reducedChromatium vinosum high-potential iron protein

The¹⁵N resonances in reduced and oxidizedChromatium vinosum high-potential iron protein have been assigned by use of¹H-¹H COSY spectra and¹H-¹⁵N HMQC, HMQC-COSY, and HMQC-NOESY spectra. Unambiguous assignment of 70 of 85 backbone¹⁵N resonances in the reduced protein and 62 of 85 resonances in the oxidized protein are made, as are 12 of 21 side-chain¹⁵N resonances.     

Assessing the effects of time and spatial averaging in 15N chemical shift/15N-1H dipolar correlation solid state NMR experiments

The effect of time and spatial averaging on ¹⁵N chemical shift/¹H-¹⁵N dipolar correlation spectra, i.e., PISEMA spectra, of -helical membrane peptides and proteins is investigated. Three types of motion are considered: (a) Librational motion of the peptide planes in the -helix; (b) rotation of the helix about its long axis; and (c) wobble of the helix about a nominal tilt angle. A 2ns molecular dynamics simulation of helix D of bacteriorhodopsin is used to determine the effect of librational motion on the spectral parameters. For the time averaging, the rotation and wobble of this same helix are modelled by assuming either Gaussian motion about the respective angles or a uniform distribution of a given width. For the spatial averaging, regions of possible ¹⁵N chemical shift/¹H-¹⁵N dipolar splittings are computed for a distribution of rotations and/or tilt angles of the helix. The computed spectra show that under certain motional modes the ¹⁵N chemical shift/¹H-¹⁵N dipolar pairs for each of the residues do not form patterns which mimic helical wheel patterns. As a result, the unambiguous identification of helix tilt and helix rotation without any resonance assignments or on the basis of a single assignment may be difficult.     

A new triple-resonance experiment for the sequential assignment of backbone resonances in proteins

Summary A new protocol is described for obtaining intraresidual and sequential correlations between carbonyl carbons and amide ¹H and ¹⁵N resonances of amino acids. Frequency labeling of ¹³CO spins occurs during a period required for the ¹³C-¹⁵N polarization transfer, leading to an optimized transfer efficiency. In a four-dimensional version of the experiment, ¹³C chemical shifts are used to improve the dispersion of signals. The resonance frequencies of all backbone nuclei can be detected in a 3D variant in which cross peaks are split along two frequency axes. This pulse scheme is the equivalent of a five-dimensional experiment. The novel pulse sequences are applied to flavodoxin from Desulfovibrio vulgaris.     

Bridge over troubled proline: assignment of intrinsically disordered proteins using (HCA)CON(CAN)H and (HCA)N(CA)CO(N)H experiments concomitantly with HNCO and i(HCA)CO(CA)NH

NMR spectroscopy is by far the most versatile and information rich technique to study intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs). While NMR is able to offer residue level information on structure and dynamics, assignment of chemical shift resonances in IDPs is not a straightforward process. Consequently, numerous pulse sequences and assignment protocols have been developed during past several years, targeted especially for the assignment of IDPs, including experiments that employ H^N, H^α or ¹³C detection combined with two to six indirectly detected dimensions. Here we propose two new HN-detection based pulse sequences, (HCA)CON(CAN)H and (HCA)N(CA)CO(N)H, that provide correlations with ¹H^N(i ? 1), ¹³C′(i ? 1) and ¹⁵N(i), and ¹H^N(i + 1), ¹³C′(i) and ¹⁵N(i) frequencies, respectively. Most importantly, they offer sequential links across the proline bridges and enable filling the single proline gaps during the assignment. We show that the novel experiments can efficiently complement the information available from existing HNCO and intraresidual i(HCA)CO(CA)NH pulse sequences and their concomitant usage enabled >95 % assignment of backbone resonances in cytoplasmic tail of adenosine receptor A2A in comparison to 73 % complete assignment using the HNCO/i(HCA)CO(CA)NH data alone.     

Assignment of the 15N NMR spectra of reduced and oxidized Escherichia coli thioredoxin

As a necessary first step in the use of heteronuclear correlated spectra to obtain high resolution solution structures of the protein, assignment of the 15N NMR spectra of reduced and oxidized Escherichia coli thioredoxin (Mr 12,000) uniformly labeled with 15N has been performed. The 15N chemical shifts of backbone amide nitrogen atoms have been determined for both oxidation states of thioredoxin using 15N-1H correlated and two-dimensional heteronuclear single-quantum coherence (HSQC) TOCSY and NOESY spectra. The backbone assignments are complete, except for the proline imide nitrogen resonances and include Gly33, whose amide proton resonance is difficult to observe in homonuclear 1H spectra. The differences in the 15N chemical shift between oxidized and reduced thioredoxin, which occur mainly in the vicinity of the two active site cysteines, including residues distant in the amino acid sequence which form a hydrophobic surface close to the active site, are consistent with the differences observed for proton chemical shifts in earlier work on thioredoxin.     

A spectroscopic assignment technique for membrane proteins reconstituted in magnetically aligned bicelles

Oriented-sample NMR (OS-NMR) has emerged as a powerful tool for the structure determination of membrane proteins in their physiological environments. However, the traditional spectroscopic assignment method in OS NMR that uses the ??shotgun?? approach, though effective, is quite labor- and time-consuming as it is based on the preparation of multiple selectively labeled samples. Here we demonstrate that, by using a combination of the spin exchange under mismatched Hartmann-Hahn conditions and a recent sensitivity-enhancement REP-CP sequence, spectroscopic assignment of solid-state NMR spectra of Pf1 coat protein reconstituted in magnetically aligned bicelles can be significantly improved. This method yields a two-dimensional spin-exchanged version of the SAMPI4 spectrum correlating the ¹⁵N chemical shift and ¹⁵N?C¹H dipolar couplings, as well as spin-correlations between the (i, i?±?1) amide sites. Combining the spin-exchanged SAMPI4 spectrum with the original SAMPI4 experiment makes it possible to establish sequential assignments, and this technique is generally applicable to other uniaxially aligned membrane proteins. Inclusion of an ¹⁵N?C¹⁵N correlation spectrum into the assignment process helps establish correlations between the peaks in crowded or ambiguous spectral regions of the spin-exchanged SAMPI4 experiment. Notably, unlike the traditional method, only a uniformly labeled protein sample is required for spectroscopic assignment with perhaps only a few selectively labeled ??seed?? spectra. Simulations for the magnetization transfer between the dilute spins under mismatched Hartmann Hahn conditions for various B ₁ fields have also been performed. The results adequately describe the optimal conditions for establishing the cross peaks, thus eliminating the need for lengthy experimental optimizations.     

15N-labeled 5S RNA. Identification of uridine base pairs in Escherichia coli 5S RNA by 1H-15N multiple quantum NMR

Escherichia coli 5S RNA labeled with 15N at N3 of the uridines was isolated from the S phi-187 uracil auxotroph grown on a minimal medium supplemented with [3-15N]uracil. 1H-15N multiple quantum filtered and 2D chemical shift correlated spectra gave resonances for the uridine imino 1H-15N units whose protons were exchanging slowly with solvent. Peaks with 1H/15N shifts at 11.6/154.8, 11.7/155.0, 11.8/155.5, 12.1/155.0, and 12.2/155.0 ppm were assigned to GU interactions. Two labile high-field AU resonances at 12.6/156.8 and 12.8/157.3 ppm typical of AU pairs in a shielded environment at the end of a helix were seen. Intense AU signals were also found at 13.4/158.5 and 13.6/159.2 ppm where 1H-15N units in normal Watson-Crick pairs resonate. 1H resonances at 10.6 and 13.8 ppm were too weak, presumably because of exchange with water, to give peaks in chemical shift correlated spectra. 1H chemical shifts suggest that the resonance at 13.8 ppm represents a labile AU pair, while the resonance at 10.6 ppm is typical of a tertiary interaction between U and a tightly bound water or a phosphate residue. The NMR data are consistent with proposed secondary structures for 5S RNA.