Carnivory and resource-based niche differentiation in anuran larvae: implications for food web and experimental ecology

1.  Food webs represent the paths of material and energy flow through organisms in an ecosystem. Anuran larvae are important components of pond food webs: they are abundant, consume large quantities of food and serve as prey for many organisms. However, there are very basic uncertainties about the feeding ecology of anuran larvae; for instance, as to which trophic level they belong and whether species differ in resource use. Because anuran larvae have been employed in model systems in experimental ecology for decades, these uncertainties could lead to misinterpretation of published experiments, or inadequate designs of experiments directed at general, conceptual issues in ecology.
2.  Using ¹³C and ¹⁵N stable isotope and gut content analyses of free-ranging and enclosed tadpoles of four ranid species ( Lithobates sylvaticus , L. pipiens , L. clamitans , L. catesbeianus ) in the food webs of six wetlands, we tested the following null hypotheses: (i) that anuran larvae are strict primary consumers; (ii) that they are non-selective feeders and therefore exhibit little feeding niche differentiation; (iii) that they are opportunistic consumers and (iv) that their diet remains unchanged through ontogeny.
3.  All four species consumed and assimilated substantial amounts of animal food; bullfrog larvae, in particular, appear to be predatory. Significant feeding niche differentiation among species occurred with respect to the sources of carbon, consumption of animal matter and nutritional quality of food ingested. We further documented opportunistic feeding habits and ontogenetic shifts in diet.
4.  Collectively, these studies revealed complex trophic relationships that might require a reconsideration of the role of anuran larvae in pond food webs, as well as a reinterpretation of results of previous studies employing anuran larvae in model experimental systems.     

Feeding ecology of larval and juvenile black seabream (Acanthopagrus schlegeli) and Japanese seaperch (Lateolabrax japonicus) in Tolo Harbour, Hong Kong

Black seabream, Acanthopagrus schlegeli, and Japanese seaperch, Lateolabrax japonicus, are important commercial species in the coastal waters of western Pacific Ocean, including Japan, Korea and China. In Hong Kong, larvae and juveniles of these two species occur in bays and estuaries during late winter and spring. This study reports on the ontogenetic changes in food habits in larvae and juveniles of these species in an artificial rocky shore area. Copepods and cladocerans were the most numerous food items for black seabream. There was a shift to larger and benthic prey as the fishes grew. Japanese seaperch <2.1cm fed predominantly on copepods and cladocerans, while larger prey were added as fish size increased. Japanese seaperch >6.0cm were piscivorous. Maximum prey width increased with fish standard length and mouth gape width in both species. Overall, black seabream showed greater diet breadth than did Japanese seaperch. In black seabream, diet breadth increased with fish size. In Japanese seaperch, diet breadth increased with size for fishes <4.0cm, then decreased as the fishes became piscivorous. Prey selectivity in black seabream was determined using information on prey availability in plankton samples. In general, preference was stronger for cypris larvae, Penilia avirostris and decapod larvae than for copepods and podonids. In recent years, overfishing and environmental degradation have led to the decline of fish populations in Tolo Harbour. Absence of fishes with empty gut indicates that inner Tolo Harbour is still an important nursery area for these two commercial species.     

Early larval ontogeny of the Permo-Carboniferous temnospondyl Sclerocephalus

The early larval development of the temnospondyl Sclerocephalus sp. is analyzed, based on 38 specimens from the Lower Rotliegend (Permo-Carboniferous boundary) of the Saar-Nahe Basin (south-west Germany). The study focuses on the smallest larval specimens, which exemplify changes in both proportions and ossification patterns. In comparison with dissorophoid larvae, the skull ossifies more fully and at a much faster rate; the smallest specimens already have completely formed circumorbital bones that are sutured throughout. Sculpturing undergoes two marked changes, first from uniformly pitted to pits of variable size and regional differentiation, and finally to the origin of ridges. The palate of small larvae differs from that of larger specimens in patterns of dentition, having more teeth including a denticle field on the cultriform process. The mandible of small larvae is described for the first time, being narrower than in adults and having three dentigerous coronoid elements. The smallest specimens have poorly ossified neural arches, lack vertebral centra, and have faintly ossified humeri, femora, and very poorly developed distal elements. The posterior ribs, metapodia, and phalanges appeared after the dermal elements of the pectoral girdle, whereas the scapulocoracoid and ischium are absent throughout the larval period. Early growth and differentiation of the limbs and the ilium illustrates the developmental patterning of the appendages, which proceeded from proximal to distal. Dermal squamation is uniform in small stages, consisting of round or oval osteoderms with pronounced growth rings; in large larvae, they start to differentiate in certain body regions.     

Vulnerability of late larval and early juvenile Atlantic herring, Clupea harengus, to predation by whiting,Merlangius merlangus

Laboratory experiments investigated changes in the vulnerability of herring to predation by whiting during growth from <34 to >80mm in length, Premetamorphic herring (<50mm) failed to react to c . 50% of attacks by the predator, but this was reduced to c . 20% in postmetamorphic fish. Premetamorphic herring failing to react had c. 30% probability of survival due to unforced errors by the predator (unsuccessful attacks that did not elicit a reaction by the prey), but these errors did not occur after herring metamorphosis. The loss of the advantage of lower conspicuousness following metamorphosis was counterbalanced by increased reactivity. Antipredator benefits should increase with schooling behaviour (first evident in experiments at c . 50 mm), so predation mortality should decrease in postmetamorphic herring in the sea. Metamorphosis itself would be associated with high predation risk since conspicuousness is enhanced but reactivity and schooling behaviour are still not fully developed.     

Temperature influences swimming speed, growth and larval duration in coral reef fish larvae

The effects of temperature on growth, pelagic larval duration (PLD) and maximum swimming speed were compared in the tropical fish marine species Amphiprion melanopus, to determine how temperature change affects these three factors critical to survival in larvae. The effects of rearing temperature (25 and 28 °C) on the length of the larval period and growth were examined in conjunction with the effects of swimming temperature (reared at 25 °C, swum at 25 and 28 °C, reared at 28 °C, swum at 25 and 28 °C) on critical swimming speed (U-crit). Larvae reared at 25 °C had a 25% longer pelagic larval duration (PLD) than larvae reared at 28 °C, 12.3 (±0.3) days compared with 9 (±0.6) days at 25 °C. To offset this effect of reduced developmental rate, growth and U-crit were measured in larvae reared at 28 and 25 °C at the same absolute age (7 days after hatching (dah)) and same developmental age (7 dah at 28 °C cf. 11 dah at 25 °C), corresponding to the day before metamorphosis. Larvae reared at 25 °C were smaller than larvae reared at 28 °C at the same absolute age (7 dah at 25 °C cf. 7 dah at 28 °C), yet larger at similar developmental age (11 dah at 25 °C cf. 7 dah at 28 °C) when weight and standard length were compared. This stage-specific size increase did not result in better performance in larvae at the same developmental age, as there was no difference in U-crit in premetamorphic larvae reared at either temperature (7 dah at 28 °C c.f 11 dah at 25 °C). However, U-crit was considerably slower in 7-day-old larvae reared at 25 °C than larvae of the same absolute age (7 dah) reared at 28 °C. Swimming temperature controls demonstrated that a change in temperature immediately prior to swimming tests did not effect swimming performance for larvae reared at either temperature.A decreased in rearing temperature resulted in longer larval durations, reduced growth rates and slower swimming development in larvae. However, the magnitude of the response of each of these traits varied considerably. As such, larvae reared at the lower temperature were a larger size at metamorphosis but had poorer relative swimming capabilities. This study highlights the importance of measuring a range of ecologically relevant traits in developing larvae to properly characterise their relative condition and performance in response to environmental change.     

Effect of larval ontogeny, turbulence and light on prey attack rate and swimming activity in herring larvae

The effects of ontogeny (larval size), light and turbulence on the attack rate and swimming activity (proportion of time swimming and duration of swimming bout) of herring larvae (15-28 mm TL) have been investigated. Emphasis was put on the experimental design in order to create a set-up where the turbulence intensity distribution could be accurately measured as well as controlled in the entire experimental tank.Both larval size (ontogeny) and light had a significant positive effect on prey attack rate. Likewise, an intermediate increase in turbulence had a positive effect on prey attack rate, but this effect was dependent of light intensity and larval size.At low light (1.5 μE m² s⁻¹) intermediate turbulence increased the prey attack rate significantly for larger larvae (26 and 28 mm), while at high light (18 μE m² s⁻¹) intermediate turbulence had only a significant positive effect on the attack rate of smaller larvae 20 and 23 mm.In general, our data show a dome-shaped response of turbulence on attack rate and a U-shaped response of turbulence on swimming activity.For herring larvae >20 mm, the maximum (attack rate) and minimum (swimming activity) response of turbulence were found at intermediate turbulence intensities (energy dissipation rates between 7∗10⁻⁸ and 1∗10⁻⁶ W/kg). The highest turbulence level tested (8∗10⁻⁶ W/kg) showed only negative effects, as attack rates where at the lowest and swimming activity at the highest.Swimming activity increased with larval size or light, and decreased at intermediate turbulence. Compared to turbulent intensities under natural conditions this implies that larger herring larvae at 10 m depth have to be exposed to wind speeds of more than 17 m/s before negative effects on attack rate and swimming activity occurs.     

Habitat ecology of chironomid larvae of the Big Thicket streams

Chironomid larvae were collected from streams in the Big Thicket area of East Texas from November, 1981 to October, 1982. Primary stations were sampled monthly and secondary stations bi-annually. Samples of leaf debris, wood debris, and sand were taken from each station and the chironomid larvae occupying the substrates were analyzed.A total of 15 112 individuals including 87 species were collected. Four subfamilies of Chironomidae were represented: Tanypodinae (12 species), Diamesinae (2 species), Orthocladiinae (30 species), and Chironominae (43 species). The collections yielded a larger number of individuals and species than previous environmental studies in the Big Thicket. Twenty-two species are reported for the first time from Texas.The lowest number of individuals occupied the leaf debris with Rheotanytarsus sp. and Tanytarsus sp. 2 being dominant. The wood debris, probably the most stable of the substrates, contained the highest number of species with Tanytarsus sp. 2 being dominant. Most individuals occurred in the sandy bottom where Lopescladius sp. was dominant. Tanytarsus sp. 1 occurred in over 65 percent of the samples.The populations were generally higher during the autumn. This was probably a result of the life cycle and the effects of environmental factors. More younger instars occurred during the late summer and autumn. Also, water flow during the summer and autumn was low, providing a more stable environment, promoting chironomid population growth.     

Survival activity and penetration of the first stage larvae of Camallanus oxycephalus Ward and Magath, 1916

The survival, activity and the ability to penetrate the gut wall of the intermediate host were studied for the first stage larvae of Camallanus oxycephalus. Survival was affected by temperature and salinity. The penetration efficiency decreased in a logarithmic relationship with larval age and was more rapid at 25°C than at 20°C. Larval activity rates decreased in a linear relationship with age. Activity was shown to be the most important factor in penetration of the copepod gut wall. These processes were compared with Ancylostoma and Haemonchus larvae. A fundamental difference is believed to exist in the decline of activity rates between Camallanus and Ancylostoma and Haemonchus. This difference is related to the life cycles of the three nematodes.     

Drift ecology of western catostomid larvae with emphasis on Warner suckers, Catostomus warnerensis (Teleostei)

We studied drift ecology of Warner sucker, Catostomus warnerensis, larvae in streams of Warner Valley, Oregon in 1992 and 1993 in part to determine whether downstream transport of larvae limits juvenile recruitment. Variation in runoff for the two years was extreme, where peak discharge in 1992 was two orders of magnitude lower than peak discharge in 1993. We deployed drift nets in low-gradient stream sections that are modified by diversions. Low catches of drifting sucker larvae (zero in 1992 and two in 1993) indicate that losses into diversions were probably minimal. In 1992, we conducted in situ experiments to determine how sucker larvae behaved when exposed to high velocity current by placing individuals of various sizes in mid-channel and tracking drift responses by snorkeling. Even the smallest larvae used did not drift far (2.6 m) or for very long (0.97 min), as they resisted downstream transport by exploiting cover provided by aquatic plants and debris. We also recorded locations of larvae during a 24-hour cycle to determine whether positions occupied during the day changed at night. We found that groups were positioned closer to shore at night in 1993 than in 1992, suggesting that larvae reduced the likelihood of becoming entrained into swift current by moving away from mid-channel at night when visual orientation is impaired. These patterns of drift avoidance are different from behaviors of other western catostomid larvae, potentially because terminal lake habitat in Pleistocene basins such as the Warner Valley has been unreliable.     

Lipophorin in the larval and adult stages of Musca domestica

The major Musca domestica hemolymph lipoprotein, lipophorin, was purified from larval and from adult animals. The housefly lipophorin is composed of two apoproteins, apolipophorin I (M_r ∽ 253,000) and apolipophorin II (M_r ∽ 85,000). The lipophorin contains about 3.9% carbohydrates and reacts positively with concanavalin A. The density of larval lipophorin is equal to 1.152 g/ml and of adult lipophorin to 1.106 g/ml. The amount of lipophorin per animal increases during the larval stage, is constant during pupal stage, and suffers a great reduction at the pharate adult stage. The amount of lipophorin remains stable during the whole first gonotrophic cycle of the housefly. Lipophorin is not detected in the eggs of this insect.     

Delivery of hatching larvae to estuaries by an amphidromous river shrimp: tests of hypotheses based on larval moulting and distribution

1.  Amphidromous shrimps live and breed in freshwater rivers and streams, but their larvae require development in sea water. Larvae may hatch upstream and then drift to the sea, although in some species females have been reported to migrate to the coast before larvae are released. Here, we tested the relative importance of larval drift and female migration in Macrobrachium ohione (Decapoda: Palaemonidae) in a distributary of the Mississippi River in Louisiana, U.S.A.
2.  Newly hatched (stage-1) larvae are nonfeeding and will not moult to stage 2 (first feeding stage) without encountering salt water. A factorial experiment was conducted in the laboratory to test the effects on moulting to stage 2 of (i) time spent by stage-1 larvae in fresh water before (ii) exposure to and maintenance in water of different salinity. Larvae kept in fresh water for 1 or 3 days before a change to saline water at 6 or 10 ppt showed a greater frequency of moulting than those kept for longer (5 days) in fresh water or changed to less saline water (2 ppt). Non-moulting larvae died or were moribund within 11 days of hatching.
3.  The relative abundance of stage-1 larvae was measured with plankton tows at two locations in the river c. 150 km apart, one near the sea and one upstream. Larval abundances near the sea were significantly greater than those upstream.
4.  The results indicate that hatched larvae of M. ohione have a limited period in which to drift in fresh water before reaching water sufficiently saline to stimulate moulting to the first feeding stage. Female migrations may play an important role in delivering larvae of amphidromous species from large continental river systems in which distances to the sea are great, while larval drift alone may be sufficient in species living in short streams, like those found in many small mountainous tropical islands.     

Balancing food availability and hydrodynamic constraint: phenotypic plasticity and growth in Simulium noelleri blackfly larvae

Organisms through phenotypic plasticity can cope with multiple changed environmental conditions. Theory predicts that animals in streams and rivers should be able to balance demands of the needs to obtain food efficiently and to adjust response to hydrodynamic variability. This study examined effects of variations in food availability and current velocity on the feeding structure and growth rate of Simulium noelleri blackfly larvae. The larvae developed larger labral fans and more rays under slow current and low food regimes than in fast current and high food conditions. In both fast and slow current regimes, growth rates were higher and development periods to the final-instar stage were shorter in high food treatments. The estimated flux rates of food particles through labral fans under high food treatments for both fast and slow current regimes were higher than those under low food treatments. Although both food and current velocity appeared to have selected for flexibility of feeding structure and growth rate, food availability was a more important factor for phenotypic and developmental plasticity than current velocity. The results indicate a strong link between environmental changes in food availability and current velocity, phenotypic plasticity, and growth rate of S. noelleri. This study suggests that plasticity of ecomorphs with macroevolutionary significance may play a role in the early evolutionary stages of blackfly larvae.     

Dytiscus latissimus and D. circumcinctus (Coleoptera,Dytiscidae) larvae as predators on three case-making caddis larvae

The predacious behaviour of Dytiscus circumcinctus and D. latissimus larvae was studied experimentally. When offered different prey simultaneously, D. latissimus larvae preferred cased caddis larvae relative to mayfly nymphs and isopods, whereas in D. circumcinctus the preference order was reversed. Notonectid nymphs and tadpoles were consumed in higher numbers by D. circumcinctus than by D. latissimus larvae. D. circumcinctus larvae and instar III larvae of D. latissimus most frequently captured caddis larvae through the case wall, whereas the instar I and II larvae of D. latissimus normally attacked the thorax of the exposed larva from above the front opening of the case. Limnephilus borealis, L. nigriceps and L. rhombicus caddis larvae differed in case structure, and they were all successfully captured by D. latissimus and D. circumcinctus instar II and III larvae. Neither capture success nor ingestion efficiency varied significantly between the two Dytiscus species or between different prey species. Instar II and III D. circumcinctus larvae had shorter reaction times than those of D. latissimus. The larger L. borealis and L. rhombicus larvae were preferred by the two last Dytiscus larval instars, and the handling time of these two prey was longer than that of L. nigriceps larvae.     

Aerosol infectivity of a Baculovirus to Trichoplusia ni larvae: An alternative larval inoculation strategy for recombinant protein production

The baculovirus–insect expression system is a popular tool for recombinant protein production. The standard method for infecting insect larvae with recombinant baculovirus for protein production involves either feeding occlusion bodies or injecting budded virus into the cuticle. In this study, we showed that the recombinant Autographa californica multiple nucleopolyhedrovirus (AcMNPV) at titers >10⁸ pfu/mL efficiently infected Trichoplusia ni (T. ni) larvae through aerosol inoculation of budded virus at a pressure of 5.5 × 10⁴ Pa. The dipping T. ni larvae in virus‐containing solution efficiently infected them. These results indicate that surface contamination, either by aerosol or dipping, lead to infection via spiracles. The aerosol infection route for AcMNPV was restricted to T. ni and Plutella xylostella larvae, whereas Spodoptera litura and Helicoverpa armigera larvae were resistant to this inoculation process. The yields of the reporter proteins DsRed and EGFP from T. ni larvae following aerosol infection were nearly identical to those following oral feeding or injection. This alternative baculovirus infection strategy facilitates recombinant protein and virus production by insect larvae. © 2009 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 2009     

Characterization of a natural inducer of coral larval metamorphosis

External chemical signals used by scleractinian corals to recognize suitable substrata for larval settlement and metamorphosis were identified from crustose coralline red algae (CCA). A fragment of coral rubble with CCA induced larval metamorphosis of the scleractinian coral Pseudosiderastrea tayamai. A natural inducer and compounds that enhanced its effect in larval metamorphosis were isolated from the methanol extracts of coral rubble with CCA. A bromotyrosine derivative, 11-deoxyfistularin-3 (10^− 7 M) isolated from the CCA, induced the metamorphosis of P. tayamai larvae (27.5 ± 24.0%). In the presence of fucoxanthinol (10^− 9 M) and fucoxanthin (10^− 9 M), the percentage of metamorphosis induced by the bromotyrosine derivative was further enhanced to 87.8 ± 13.0 and 88.4 ± 17.8%, respectively. Both carotenoids are also found in the coral rubble with CCA. These results suggest that bromotyrosine derivative and carotenoids have a synergistic effect in the metamorphosis of P. tayamai larvae. The synergistic effect provides a higher selectivity for recruitment than a single-component natural inducer for recognizing suitable substrata for larval metamorphosis. Thus, the effect might offer a survival advantage for benthic marine invertebrates.     

Identification of adults and larvae in Spiochaetopterus (Polychaeta, Chaetopteridae): consequences for larval transport and recruitment

This work is based on recent studies describing new species in Spiochaetopterus (Annelida Polychaeta). New morphological features were brought to light in studies of adults from widely separate areas. A parallel study of planktonic larvae in three areas (northern Atlantic Ocean, Gulf of California, Mediterranean Sea) led to the isolation of several larval categories, each related to an already described species. The large number of species already described shows that the founder species has been subjected to an intense adaptive radiation and that in spite of the ability of larvae to disseminate, each species now inhabits only a limited geographical area. Teleplanic larvae are thus not as effective as is generally supposed in controlling the adult area. The new paradigm implies that individuals from widely separate areas belong to species other than Spiochaetopterus costarum. Although larvae of each species are capable of covering long distances, larval transport may be interrupted at various stages of the life cycle for a variety of reasons. The most powerful causes of failure are not linked to the lifespan of planktonic larvae, but rather to constraints on the ability to realize physiological functions, including fecundation. The putative cosmopolitanism of S. costarum, before new species were described, was the result of both inadequate morphological examination and the use of questionable ecological arguments linked to larval dispersal.     

Neutral theory and community ecology

I review the mathematical and biological aspects of Hubbell's (2001) neutral theory of species abundance for ecological communities, and clarify its historical connections with closely related approaches in population genetics. A selective overview of the empirical evidence for and against this theory is provided, with a special emphasis on tropical plant communities. The neutral theory predicts many of the basic patterns of biodiversity, confirming its heuristic power. The strict assumption of equivalence that defines neutrality, equivalence among individuals, finds little empirical support in general. However, a weaker assumption holds for stable communities, the equivalence of average fitness among species. One reason for the surprising success of the neutral theory is that all the theories of species coexistence satisfying the fitness equivalence assumption, including many theories of niche differentiation, generate exactly the same patterns as the neutral theory. Hubbell's neutral theory represents an important synthesis and a much needed demonstration of the pivotal role of intraspecific variability in ecology. Further improvements should lead to an explicit linking to niche‐based processes. This research programme will depend crucially on forthcoming theoretical and empirical achievements.