The supramolecular structure of the GPCR rhodopsin in solution and native disc membranes

Rhodopsin, the prototypical G-protein-coupled receptor, which is densely packed in the disc membranes of rod outer segments, was proposed to function as a monomer. However, a growing body of evidence indicates dimerization and oligomerization of numerous G-protein-coupled receptors, and atomic force microscopy images revealed rows of rhodopsin dimers in murine disc membranes. In this work we demonstrate by electron microscopy of negatively stained samples, blue native- and sodium dodecyl sulphate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, chemical crosslinking, and by proteolysis that native bovine rhodopsin exists mainly as dimers and higher oligomers. These results corroborate the recent findings from atomic force microscopy and molecular modeling on the supramolecular structure and packing arrangement of murine rhodopsin dimers.     

Rhodopsin Forms Nanodomains in Rod Outer Segment Disc Membranes of the Cold-Blooded Xenopus laevis

Rhodopsin forms nanoscale domains (i.e., nanodomains) in rod outer segment disc membranes from mammalian species. It is unclear whether rhodopsin arranges in a similar manner in amphibian species, which are often used as a model system to investigate the function of rhodopsin and the structure of photoreceptor cells. Moreover, since samples are routinely prepared at low temperatures, it is unclear whether lipid phase separation effects in the membrane promote the observed nanodomain organization of rhodopsin from mammalian species. Rod outer segment disc membranes prepared from the cold-blooded frog Xenopus laevis were investigated by atomic force microscopy to visualize the organization of rhodopsin in the absence of lipid phase separation effects. Atomic force microscopy revealed that rhodopsin nanodomains form similarly as that observed previously in mammalian membranes. Formation of nanodomains in ROS disc membranes is independent of lipid phase separation and conserved among vertebrates.     

Structure of the rhodopsin dimer: a working model for G-protein-coupled receptors

G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) participate in virtually all physiological processes. They constitute the largest and most structurally conserved family of signaling molecules. Several class C GPCRs have been shown to exist as dimers in their active form and growing evidence indicates that many, if not all, class A receptors also form dimers and/or higher-order oligomers. High-resolution crystal structures are available only for the detergent-solubilized light receptor rhodopsin (Rho), the archetypal class A GPCR. In addition, Rho is the only GPCR for which the presumed higher-order oligomeric state has been demonstrated, by imaging native disk membranes using atomic force microscopy (AFM). Based on these data and the X-ray structure, an atomic model of Rho dimers has been proposed, a model that is currently scrutinized in various ways. AFM has also been used to measure the forces required to unfold single Rho molecules, thereby revealing which residues are responsible for Rho's stability. Recent functional analyses of fractions from solubilized disk membranes revealed that higher-order Rho oligomers are the most active species. These and other results have enhanced our understanding of GPCR structure and function.     

Monomeric rhodopsin is sufficient for normal rhodopsin kinase (GRK1) phosphorylation and arrestin-1 binding

G-protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) oligomerization has been observed in a wide variety of experimental contexts, but the functional significance of this phenomenon at different stages of the life cycle of class A GPCRs remains to be elucidated. Rhodopsin (Rh), a prototypical class A GPCR of visual transduction, is also capable of forming dimers and higher order oligomers. The recent demonstration that Rh monomer is sufficient to activate its cognate G protein, transducin, prompted us to test whether the same monomeric state is sufficient for rhodopsin phosphorylation and arrestin-1 binding. Here we show that monomeric active rhodopsin is phosphorylated by rhodopsin kinase (GRK1) as efficiently as rhodopsin in the native disc membrane. Monomeric phosphorylated light-activated Rh (P-Rh*) in nanodiscs binds arrestin-1 essentially as well as P-Rh* in native disc membranes. We also measured the affinity of arrestin-1 for P-Rh* in nanodiscs using a fluorescence-based assay and found that arrestin-1 interacts with monomeric P-Rh* with low nanomolar affinity and 1:1 stoichiometry, as previously determined in native disc membranes. Thus, similar to transducin activation, rhodopsin phosphorylation by GRK1 and high affinity arrestin-1 binding only requires a rhodopsin monomer.     

The G protein-coupled receptor rhodopsin in the native membrane

The higher-order structure of G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) in membranes may involve dimerization and formation of even larger oligomeric complexes. Here, we have investigated the organization of the prototypical GPCR rhodopsin in its native membrane by electron and atomic force microscopy (AFM). Disc membranes from mice were isolated and observed by AFM at room temperature. In all experimental conditions, rhodopsin forms structural dimers organized in paracrystalline arrays. A semi-empirical molecular model for the rhodopsin paracrystal is presented validating our previously reported results. Finally, we compare our model with other currently available models describing the supramolecular structure of GPCRs in the membrane.     

Rhodopsin is spatially heterogeneously distributed in rod outer segment disk membranes

The visual photoreception takes place in the retina, where specialized rod and cone photoreceptor cells are located. The rod outer segments contain a stack of 500-2,000 sealed membrane disks. Rhodopsin is the visual pigment located in rod outer segment disks, it is a member of the G-protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) superfamily, an important group of membrane proteins responsible for the majority of physiological responses to stimuli such as light, hormones, peptides, etc. Alongside rhodopsin, peripherin/Rom proteins located in the disk rims are thought to be responsible for disk morphology. Here we describe the supramolecular structure of rod outer segment disk membranes and the spatial organization of rhodopsin and peripherin/Rom molecules. Using atomic force microscopy operated in physiological buffer solution, we found that rhodopsin is loosely packed in the central region of the disks, in average about 26?000 molecules covering approximately one third of the disk surface. Peripherin/Rom proteins form dense assemblies in the rim region. A protein-free lipid bilayer girdle separates the rhodopsin and peripherin/Rom domains. The described supramolecular assembly of rhodospin, peripherin/Rom and lipids in native rod outer segment disks is consistent with the functional requirements of photoreception.     

Organization of the G protein-coupled receptors rhodopsin and opsin in native membranes

G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs), which constitute the largest and structurally best conserved family of signaling molecules, are involved in virtually all physiological processes. Crystal structures are available only for the detergent-solubilized light receptor rhodopsin. In addition, this receptor is the only GPCR for which the presumed higher order oligomeric state in native membranes has been demonstrated (Fotiadis, D., Liang, Y., Filipek, S., Saperstein, D. A., Engel, A., and Palczewski, K. (2003) Nature 421, 127-128). Here, we have determined by atomic force microscopy the organization of rhodopsin in native membranes obtained from wild-type mouse photoreceptors and opsin isolated from photoreceptors of Rpe65-/- mutant mice, which do not produce the chromophore 11-cis-retinal. The higher order organization of rhodopsin was present irrespective of the support on which the membranes were adsorbed for imaging. Rhodopsin and opsin form structural dimers that are organized in paracrystalline arrays. The intradimeric contact is likely to involve helices IV and V, whereas contacts mainly between helices I and II and the cytoplasmic loop connecting helices V and VI facilitate the formation of rhodopsin dimer rows. Contacts between rows are on the extracellular side and involve helix I. This is the first semi-empirical model of a higher order structure of a GPCR in native membranes, and it has profound implications for the understanding of how this receptor interacts with partner proteins.     

A hypothesis for GPCR activation

Growing evidence that rhodopsin (RD) and related G protein-coupled receptors form functional dimers/oligomers, followed by direct proof (using atomic force microscopy) that in the retina disc membrane RD associates into a paracrystalline network of rows of dimers, need models of the RD-transducin (Gt) complex that would envision an optimal RD dimer/oligomer able to satisfy all well-documented interactions with Gt. Of the models proposed so far, only a few refer to RD dimers and only one of them proposes a complex of Gt with an RD oligomer (Filipek S, Krzyko KA, Fotiadis D, Liang Y, Saperstein DA, Engel, A, Palczewski K Photochem Photobiol Sci 3: 628–638, 2004). This paper puts forward a hypothesis on another arrangement of RD monomers into the reported network of rows of dimers. Arguments for the compatibility of this set-up with interactions and activation of RD in the complex with Gt, in particular, with the well-documented movement of transmembrane helix 6 and cytosolic loop 3, which is vital for RD activation, are provided and discussed.This revised version was published online in June 2005 with corrections to the acknowledgements.     

Three-dimensional structure of an invertebrate rhodopsin and basis for ordered alignment in the photoreceptor membrane

Invertebrate rhodopsins activate a G-protein signalling pathway in microvillar photoreceptors. In contrast to the transducin-cyclic GMP phosphodiesterase pathway found in vertebrate rods and cones, visual transduction in cephalopod (squid, octopus, cuttlefish) invertebrates is signalled via Gq and phospholipase C. Squid rhodopsin contains the conserved residues of the G-protein coupled receptor (GPCR) family, but has only 35% identity with mammalian rhodopsins. Unlike vertebrate rhodopsins, cephalopod rhodopsin is arranged in an ordered lattice in the photoreceptor membranes. This organization confers sensitivity to the plane of polarized light and also provides the optimal orientation of the linear retinal chromophores in the cylindrical microvillar membranes for light capture. Two-dimensional crystals of squid rhodopsin show a rectilinear arrangement that is likely to be related to the alignment of rhodopsins in vivo.Here, we present a three-dimensional structure of squid rhodopsin determined by cryo-electron microscopy of two-dimensional crystals. Docking the atomic structure of bovine rhodopsin into the squid density map shows that the helix packing and extracellular plug structure are conserved. In addition, there are two novel structural features revealed by our map. The linear lattice contact appears to be made by the transverse C-terminal helix lying on the cytoplasmic surface of the membrane. Also at the cytoplasmic surface, additional density may correspond to a helix 5-6 loop insertion found in most GPCRs relative to vertebrate rhodopsins. The similarity supports the conservation in structure of rhodopsins (and other G-protein-coupled receptors) from phylogenetically distant organisms. The map provides the first indication of the structural basis for rhodopsin alignment in the microvillar membrane.     

Three-dimensional electron microscopical investigation of rhodopsin molecules in the disc membrane of Frog rod outer segments

Frog rod outer segment (ROS) disc membranes are investigated by three-dimensional electron microscopy of aperiodic structures. Out of the various chemical constituents of these membranes only the visual pigment rhodopsin is examined. It is suggested that rhodopsin molecules are dumb-bell shaped and it is shown that in small areas they are not statistically arranged. Most rhodopsin molecules are tilted 26±2° away from the position normal to the membrane thus showing angles α<90° or α>90°. Within the small part of the disc membrane investigated the long rhodopsin axes lie in planes parallel to the xy-plane, the y-axis being parallel with the connecting cilium of ROS. In the membrane cut-outs reconstructed there are aggregates of five to nine rhodopsin molecules either with α>90° or α<90° only. In adjacent disc membranes all the bigger aggregates appear at the same site and with the same magnitude of α.     

Functional characterization of rhodopsin monomers and dimers in detergents

Rhodopsin (Rho) is a G protein-coupled receptor that initiates phototransduction in rod photoreceptors. High expression levels of Rho in the disc membranes of rod outer segments and the propensity of Rho to form higher oligomeric structures are evident from atomic force microscopy, transmission electron microscopy, and chemical cross-linking experiments. To explore the structural and functional properties of Rho in n-dodecyl-beta-maltoside, frequently used to purify heterologously expressed Rho and its mutants, we used gel filtration techniques, blue native gel electrophoresis, and functional assays. Here, we show that in micelles containing n-dodecyl-beta-maltoside at concentrations greater than 3 mM, Rho is present as a single monomer per detergent micelle. In contrast, in 12 mM 3-[(3-cholamidopropyl)dimethyl-ammonio]-1-propanesulfonate (CHAPS), micelles contain mostly dimeric Rho. The cognate G protein transducin (Gt) appears to have a preference for binding to the Rho dimer, and the complexes fall apart in the presence of guanosine 5'-3-O-(thio)triphosphate. Cross-linked Rho dimers release the chromophore at a slower rate than monomers and are much more resistant to heat denaturation. Both Rho(*) monomers and dimers are capable of activating Gt, and both of them are phosphorylated by Rho kinase. Rho expressed in HEK293 cells is also readily cross-linked by a bifunctional reagent. These studies provide an explanation of how detergent influences the oligomer-dimermonomer equilibrium of Rho and describe the functional characterization of Rho monomers and dimers in detergent.     

A link between rhodopsin and disc membrane cyclic nucleotide phosphodiesterase. Action spectrum and sensitivity to illumination.

Frog (Rana pipiens) rod outer segment disc membranes contain guanosine 3',5'-cyclic monophosphate phosphodiesterase (EC 3.1.4.1.c) which, in the presence of ATP, is stimulated 5- to 20-fold by illumination. The effectiveness of monochromatic light of different wavelengths in activating phosphodiesterase was examined. The action spectrum has a maximum of 500 nm, and the entire spectrum from 350 to 800 nm closely matches the absorption spectrum of rhodopsin, which is apparently the pigment which mediates the effects of light on phosphodiesterase activity. trans-Retinal alone does not mimic light. Half-maximal activation of the phosphodiesterase occurs with a light exposure which bleaches 1/2000 of the rhodopsins. Half-maximal activation can also be achieved by mixing 1 part of illuminated disc membranes in which the rhodopsin is bleached with 99 parts of unilluminated membranes. Regeneration of bleached rhodopsin by addition of 11-cis-retinal is illuminated disc membranes reverses the ability of these membranes to activate phosphodiesterase in unilluminated membranes. If the rhodopsin regenerated by 11-cis-retinal is illuminated again, it regains the ability to activate phosphodiesterase. These studies show that the levels of cyclic nucleotides in vetebrate rod outer segments are regulated by minute amounts of light and clearly indicate that rhodopsin is the photopigment whose state of illumination is closely linked to the enzymatic activity of disc membrane phosphodiesterase.     

Rows of ATP synthase dimers in native mitochondrial inner membranes

The ATP synthase is a nanometric rotary machine that uses a transmembrane electrochemical gradient to form ATP. The structures of most components of the ATP synthase are known, and their organization has been elucidated. However, the supramolecular assembly of ATP synthases in biological membranes remains unknown. Here we show with submolecular resolution the organization of ATP synthases in the yeast mitochondrial inner membranes. The atomic force microscopy images we have obtained show how these molecules form dimers with characteristic 15 nm distance between the axes of their rotors through stereospecific interactions of the membrane embedded portions of their stators. A different interaction surface is responsible for the formation of rows of dimers. Such an organization elucidates the role of the ATP synthase in mitochondrial morphology. Some dimers have a different morphology with 10 nm stalk-to-stalk distance, in line with ATP synthases that are accessible to IF1 inhibition. Rotation torque compensation within ATP synthase dimers stabilizes the ATP synthase structure, in particular the stator-rotor interaction.     

Functional reconstitution of rhodopsin into tubular lipid bilayers supported by nanoporous media

We report on a novel reconstitution method for G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) that yields detergent-free, single, tubular membranes in porous anodic aluminum oxide (AAO) filters at concentrations sufficient for structural studies by solid-state NMR. The tubular membranes line the inner surface of pores that traverse the filters, permitting easy removal of detergents during sample preparation as well as delivery of ligands for functional studies. Reconstitution of bovine rhodopsin into AAO filters did not interfere with rhodopsin function. Photoactivation of rhodopsin in AAO pores, monitored by UV-vis spectrophotometry, was indistinguishable from rhodopsin in unsupported unilamellar liposomes. The rhodopsin in AAO pores is G-protein binding competent as shown by a [35S]GTPgammaS binding assay. The lipid-rhodopsin interaction was investigated by 2H NMR on sn-1- or sn-2-chain perdeuterated 1-stearoyl-2-docosahexaenoyl-sn-glycero-3-phospholine as a matrix lipid. Rhodopsin incorporation increased mosaic spread of bilayer orientations and contributed to spectral density of motions with correlation times in the range of nano- to microseconds, detected as a significant reduction in spin-spin relaxation times. The change in lipid chain order parameters due to interaction with rhodopsin was insignificant.     

Monomeric G-protein-coupled receptor as a functional unit

Rhodopsin, the first purified G-protein-coupled receptor (GPCR), was characterized as a functional monomer 30 year ago, but dimerization of GPCRs recently became the new paradigm of signal transduction. It has even been claimed, on the basis of recent biophysical and biochemical studies, that this new concept could be extended to higher-order oligomerization. Here this view is challenged. The new studies of rhodopsin and other simple (class 1a) GPCRs solubilized in detergent are re-assessed and are compared to the earlier classical studies of rhodopsin and other membrane proteins solubilized in detergent. The new studies are found to strengthen rather than invalidate the conclusions of the early ones and to support a monomeric model for rhodopsin and other class 1a GPCRs. A molecular model is proposed for the functional coupling of a rhodopsin monomeric unit with a G-protein heterotrimer. This model should be valid even for GPCRs that exist as structural dimers.     

Binding and activation of rod outer segment phosphodiesterase and guanosine triphosphate binding protein by disc membranes: influence of reassociation method and divalent cations

Attempts to optimize the recovery of light-stimulated phosphodiesterase activity following reassociation of the hypotonically extractable proteins derived from retinal rod segments with hypotonically stripped disc membranes lead to the following observations: the best reassociations were obtained by mixing proteins and stripped disc membranes under hypotonic conditions and slowly increasing the salt concentration; the binding of G-protein and phosphodiesterase to stripped disc membrane occurs in less than 5 minutes and the recovery of light-stimulated phosphodiesterase activation in response to subsaturating stimulus levels requires 2-3 h to plateau. Stripped disc membranes and proteins were reassociated in 'isotonic' buffers containing KCl/NaCl, KCl/NaCl plus Mg2+, or KCl/NaCl plus Ca2+. Large fractional rhodopsin bleaches produced nearly identical light-stimulated phosphodiesterase activities in each of these samples and in the control rod outer segment membranes. Rod outer segment membranes and reassociated stripped disc membrane samples containing divalent cations showed similar phosphodiesterase activities in response to low fractional rhodopsin bleaches (e.g. less than or equal to 0.1%), however, samples devoid of divalent cations during reassociation required rhodopsin bleaches up to 10-fold larger to elicit comparable phosphodiesterase activities. These results suggest that not all phosphodiesterase and/or G-protein molecules bound to the disc membrane surface are equivalent with regard to their efficiency of activation by bleached rhodopsin and that divalent cations can modulate the distribution of G-protein and/or phosphodiesterase between these populations.     

Calorimetric studies of bovine rod outer segment disk membranes support a monomeric unit for both rhodopsin and opsin

The photoreceptor rhodopsin is a G-protein coupled receptor that has recently been proposed to exist as a dimer or higher order oligomer, in contrast to the previously described monomer, in retinal rod outer segment disk membranes. Rhodopsin exhibits considerably greater thermal stability than opsin (the bleached form of the receptor), which is reflected in an ∼15°C difference in the thermal denaturation temperatures (T_m) of rhodopsin and opsin as measured by differential scanning calorimetry. Here we use differential scanning calorimetry to investigate the effect of partial bleaching of disk membranes on the T_m of rhodopsin and of opsin in native disk membranes, as well as in cross-linked disk membranes in which rhodopsin dimers are known to be present. The T_ms of rhodopsin and opsin are expected to be perturbed if mixed oligomers are present. The T_m remained constant for rhodopsin and opsin in native disks regardless of the level of bleaching. In contrast, the T_m of cross-linked rhodopsin in disk membranes was dependent on the extent of bleaching. The energy of activation for denaturation of rhodopsin and cross-linked rhodopsin was calculated. Cross-linking rhodopsin significantly decreased the energy of activation. We conclude that in native disk membranes, rhodopsin behaves predominantly as a monomer.     

Trimers, dimers of trimers, and trimers of trimers are common building blocks of annexin a5 two-dimensional crystals

Annexin A5 is a member of a family of homologous proteins sharing the ability to bind to negatively charged phospholipid membranes in a Ca(2+)-dependent manner. Annexin A5, as well as other annexins, self-assembles into two-dimensional (2D) ordered arrays upon binding to membranes, a property that has been proposed to have functional implications. Electron microscopy and atomic force microscopy experiments have revealed that annexin A5 forms two types of 2D crystals-with either p6 or p3 symmetry-that are both based on annexin trimers. In this study, we describe three other crystal forms that coexist with the p6 crystals. All crystal forms are made of the same building blocks, namely, dimers of trimers and trimers of trimers. A mechanistic model of the formation of the annexin A5 2D crystals is proposed.     

Effect of dietary docosahexaenoic acid on rhodopsin content and packing in photoreceptor cell membranes

Docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) is enriched in photoreceptor cell membranes. DHA deficiency impairs vision due to photoreceptor cell dysfunction, which is caused, at least in part, by reduced activity of rhodopsin, the light receptor that initiates phototransduction. It is unclear how the depletion of membrane DHA impacts the structural properties of rhodopsin and, in turn, its activity. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) was used to assess the impact of DHA deficiency on membrane structure and rhodopsin organization. AFM revealed that signaling impairment in photoreceptor cells is independent of the oligomeric status of rhodopsin and causes adaptations in photoreceptor cells where the content and density of rhodopsin in the membrane is increased. Functional and structural changes caused by DHA deficiency were reversible.