Thioflavin T interaction with amyloid fibrils as an instrument for their studying

Benzthiazole dye thioflavin T (ThT) is widely used to study the formation and structure of amyloid fibrils. Nevertheless, till now there is no common opinion concerning molecular mechanisms of ThT binding to amyloid fibrils and the reasons of dramatic increase in its fluorescence quantum yield on incorporation into amyloid fibrils. Our data prove that ThT molecules incorporate in the amyloid fibrils in the monomeric form and there is no ground to suppose the formation of ThT dimers, eximers, or micells. It was shown that the increase in the quantum yield of ThT incorporated in amyloid fibrils was caused by restriction of benzthiazole and aminobenzene rings torsion fluctuations relative to each other. The use of equilibrium microdialysis allowed determining the absorption spectrum, the number of binding modes of ThT with insulin amyloid fibrils and for each mode determining the binding constants and the number of binding sites for each mode.     

Structures for amyloid fibrils

Alzheimer's disease and Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease are the best-known examples of a group of diseases known as the amyloidoses. They are characterized by the extracellular deposition of toxic, insoluble amyloid fibrils. Knowledge of the structure of these fibrils is essential for understanding the process of pathology of the amyloidoses and for the rational design of drugs to inhibit or reverse amyloid formation. Structural models have been built using information from a wide variety of techniques, including X-ray diffraction, electron microscopy, solid state NMR and EPR. Recent advances have been made in understanding the architecture of the amyloid fibril. Here, we describe and compare postulated structural models for the mature amyloid fibril and discuss how the ordered structure of amyloid contributes to its stability.     

The association of lipids with amyloid fibrils

Amyloid formation continues to be a widely studied area because of its association with numerous diseases, such as Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s diseases. Despite a large body of work on protein aggregation and fibril formation, there are still significant gaps in our understanding of the factors that differentiate toxic amyloid formation in vivo from alternative misfolding pathways. In addition to proteins, amyloid fibrils are often associated in their cellular context with several types of molecule, including carbohydrates, polyanions, and lipids. This review focuses in particular on evidence for the presence of lipids in amyloid fibrils and the routes by which those lipids may become incorporated. Chemical analyses of fibril composition, combined with studies to probe the lipid distribution around fibrils, provide evidence that in some cases, lipids have a strong association with fibrils. In addition, amyloid fibrils formed in the presence of lipids have distinct morphologies and material properties. It is argued that lipids are an integral part of many amyloid deposits in vivo, where their presence has the potential to influence the nucleation, morphology, and mechanical properties of fibrils. The role of lipids in these structures is therefore worthy of further study.     

The parallel superpleated beta-structure as a model for amyloid fibrils of human amylin

Human amylin is a 37 amino acid residue peptide hormone whose fibrillogenesis has been correlated with type 2 diabetes. These fibrils are rope-like bundles of several 5nm diameter protofilaments. Here, we propose, as a model for the protofilament, a variant of the parallel superpleated beta-structure previously derived for amyloid filaments of the yeast prion Ure2p. In the amylin model, individual polypeptides from residues 9 to 37 have a planar S-shaped fold with three beta-strands. These serpentines are stacked in register, with a 0.47 nm axial rise and a small rotational twist per step, generating an array of three parallel beta-sheets in cross-beta conformation. The interior, the two bays sandwiched between adjacent sheets, are occupied by non-polar and by polar/uncharged residues that are predicted to form H-bonded ladders, similar to those found in beta-helical proteins. The N-terminal peptide containing a disulfide bond occupies an extraneous peripheral position in the protofilament. The left-handed twist of the beta-sheets is shown to underlie left-handed coiling of amylin protofilaments in fibrils. The model is consistent with current biophysical, biochemical and genetic data and, in particular, affords a plausible explanation for why rodent amylin does not form fibrils.     

The association of an elastase with amyloid fibrils

The fibrils of all systemic forms of amyloid (primary, AL; secondary, AA; and hereditary, AF) that had been isolated by the water extraction procedure demonstrated elastolytic enzyme activity when examined in a specific assay using tritiated elastin. The source of this fibril-bound enzyme activity was consistent with human neutrophil elastase (HNE), since it was readily extracted by high salt solutions and inhibited by an elastase-specific chloromethyl ketone inhibitor, human alpha-1-protease inhibitor or by an antibody specific for HNE. The presence of an elastase on the amyloid fibril may suggest physiologic mechanisms of amyloid precursor protein degradation.     

Physical and structural basis for polymorphism in amyloid fibrils

As our understanding of the molecular structures of amyloid fibrils has matured over the past 15 years, it has become clear that, while amyloid fibrils do have well‐defined molecular structures, their molecular structures are not uniquely determined by the amino acid sequences of their constituent peptides and proteins. Self‐propagating molecular‐level polymorphism is a common phenomenon. This article reviews current information about amyloid fibril structures, variations in molecular structures that underlie amyloid polymorphism, and physical considerations that explain the development and persistence of amyloid polymorphism. Much of this information has been obtained through solid state nuclear magnetic resonance measurements. The biological significance of amyloid polymorphism is also discussed briefly. Although this article focuses primarily on studies of fibrils formed by amyloid‐β peptides, the same principles apply to many amyloid‐forming peptides and proteins.     

Conformational stability of PrP amyloid fibrils controls their smallest possible fragment size

Fibril fragmentation is considered to be an essential step in prion replication. Recent studies have revealed a strong correlation between the incubation period to prion disease and conformational stability of synthetic prions. To gain insight into the molecular mechanism that accounts for this correlation, we proposed that the conformational stability of prion fibrils controls their intrinsic fragility or the size of the smallest possible fibrillar fragments. Using amyloid fibrils produced from full-length mammalian prion protein under three growth conditions, we found a correlation between conformational stability and the smallest possible fragment sizes. Specifically, the fibrils that were conformationally less stable were found to produce shorter pieces upon fragmentation. Site-specific denaturation experiments revealed that the fibril conformational stability was controlled by the region that acquires a cross-β-sheet structure. Using atomic force microscopy imaging, we found that fibril fragmentation occurred in both directions—perpendicular to and along the fibrillar axis. Two mechanisms of fibril fragmentation were identified: (i) fragmentation caused by small heat shock proteins, including αB-crystallin, and (ii) fragmentation due to mechanical stress arising from adhesion of the fibril to a surface. This study provides new mechanistic insight into the prion replication mechanism and offers a plausible explanation for the correlation between conformational stability of synthetic prions and incubation time to prion disease.     

Side-chain interactions determine amyloid formation by model polyglutamine peptides in molecular dynamics simulations

The pathological manifestation of nine hereditary neurodegenerative diseases is the presence within the brain of aggregates of disease-specific proteins that contain polyglutamine tracts longer than a critical length. To improve our understanding of the processes by which polyglutamine-containing proteins misfold and aggregate, we have conducted molecular dynamics simulations of the aggregation of model polyglutamine peptides. This work was accomplished by extending the PRIME model to polyglutamine. PRIME is an off-lattice, unbiased, intermediate-resolution protein model based on an amino acid representation of between three and seven united atoms, depending on the residue being modeled. The effects of hydrophobicity on the system are studied by varying the strength of the hydrophobic interaction from 12.5% to 5% of the hydrogen-bonding interaction strength. In our simulations, we observe the spontaneous formation of aggregates and annular structures that are made up of beta-sheets starting from random configurations of random coils. This result was interesting because tubular protofibrils were recently found in experiments on polyglutamine aggregation and because of Perutz's prediction that polyglutamine would form water-filled nanotubes.     

Alzheimer's amyloid fibrils: structure and assembly

Structural studies of Alzheimer's amyloid fibrils have revealed information about the structure at different levels. The amyloid-beta peptide has been examined in various solvents and conditions and this has led to a model by which a conformational switching occurs from alpha-helix or random coil, to a beta-sheet structure. Amyloid fibril assembly proceeds by a nucleation dependent pathway leading to elongation of the fibrils. Along this pathway small oligomeric intermediates and short fibrillar structures (protofibrils) have been observed. In cross-section the fibril appears to be composed of several subfibrils or protofilaments. Each of these protofilaments is composed of beta-sheet structure in which hydrogen bonding occurs along the length of the fibre and the beta-strands run perpendicular to the fibre axis. This hierarchy of structure is discussed in this review.     

Cryo-EM of amyloid fibrils and cellular aggregates

1. Download : Download high-res image (183KB)
2. Download : Download full-size image

     

Environmental conditions affect the kinetics of nucleation of amyloid fibrils and determine their morphology

To understand and tackle amyloid-related diseases, it is crucial to investigate the factors that modulate amyloid formation of proteins. Our previous studies proved that the N47A mutant of the α-spectrin SH3 (Spc-SH3) domain forms amyloid fibrils quickly under mildly acidic conditions. Here, we analyze how experimental conditions influence the kinetics of assembly and the final morphology of the fibrils. Early formation of curly fibrils occurs after a considerable conformational change of the protein and the concomitant formation of small oligomers. These processes are strongly accelerated by an increase in salt concentration and temperature, and to a lesser extent by a reduction in pH. The rate-limiting step in these events has a high activation enthalpy, which is significantly reduced by an increase in NaCl concentration. At low-to-moderate NaCl concentrations, the curly fibrils convert to straight and twisted amyloid fibrils after long incubation times, but only in the presence of soluble species in the mixture, which suggests that the curly fibrils and the twisted amyloid fibrils are diverging assembly pathways. The results suggest that the influence of environmental variables on protein solvation is crucial in determining the nucleation kinetics, the pathway of assembly, and the final fibril morphology.     

Methods for structural characterization of prefibrillar intermediates and amyloid fibrils

Protein fibrillation is first and foremost a structural phenomenon. Adequate structural investigation of the central conformational individuals of the fibrillation process is however exceedingly difficult. This is due to the nature of the process, which may be described as a dynamically evolving equilibrium between a large number of structural species. These are furthermore of highly diverging sizes and present in very uneven amounts and timeframes. Different structural methods have different strengths and limitations. These, and in particular recent advances within solution analysis of the undisturbed equilibrium using small angle X-ray scattering, are reviewed here.     

Conformational prerequisites for formation of amyloid fibrils from histones

We demonstrate that bovine core histones are natively unfolded proteins in solutions with low ionic strength due to their high net positive charge at pH 7.5. Using a variety of biophysical techniques we characterized their conformation as a function of pH and ionic strength, as well as correlating the conformation with aggregation and amyloid fibril formation. Tertiary structure was absent under all conditions except at pH 7.5 and high ionic strength. The addition of trifluoroethanol or high ionic strength induced significant alpha-helical secondary structure at pH 7.5. At low pH and high salt concentration, small-angle X-ray scattering and SEC HPLC indicate the histones are present as a hexadecamer of globular subunits. The secondary structure at low pH was independent of the ionic strength or presence of TFE, as judged by FTIR. The data indicate that histones are able to adopt five different relatively stable conformations; this conformational variability probably reflects, in part, their intrinsically disordered structure. Under most of the conditions studied the histones formed amyloid fibrils with typical morphology as seen by electron microscopy. In contrast to most aggregation/amyloidogenic systems, the kinetics of fibrillation showed an inverse dependence on histone concentration; we attribute this to partitioning to a faster pathway leading to non-fibrillar self-associated aggregates at higher protein concentrations. The rate of fibril formation was maximal at low pH, and decreased to zero by pH 10. The kinetics of fibrillation were very dependent on the ionic strength, increasing with increasing salt concentration, and showing marked dependence on the nature of the ions; interestingly Gdn.HCl increased the rate of fibrillation, although much less than NaCl. Different ions also differentially affected the rate of nucleation and the rate of fibril elongation.     

Template-directed self-assembly and growth of insulin amyloid fibrils

The formation of amyloid aggregates in tissue is a pathological feature of many neurodegenerative diseases and type II diabetes. Amyloid deposition, the process of amyloid growth by the association of individual soluble amyloid molecules with a pre-existing amyloid template (i.e., plaque), is known to be critical for amyloid formation in vivo. The requirement for a natural amyloid template, however, has made amyloid deposition study difficult and cumbersome. In the present work, we developed a novel, synthetic amyloid template by attaching amyloid seeds covalently onto an N-hydroxysuccinimide-activated surface, where insulin was chosen as a model amyloidogenic protein. According to ex situ atomic force microscopy observations, insulin monomers in solution were deposited onto the synthetic amyloid template to form fibrils, like hair growth. The fibril formation on the template occurred without lag time, and its rate was highly accelerated than in the solution. The fibrils were long, over 2 mum, and much thinner than those in the solution, which was caused by limited nucleation sites on the template surface and lack of lateral twisting between fibrils. According to our investigations using thioflavin T-induced fluorescence, birefringent Congo red binding, and circular dichroism, fibrils grown on the template were identified to be amyloids that formed through a conformational rearrangement of insulin monomers upon interaction with the template. The amyloid deposition rate followed saturation kinetics with respect to insulin concentration in the solution. The characteristics of amyloid deposition on the synthetic template were in agreement with previous studies performed with human amyloid plaques. It is demonstrated that the synthetic amyloid template can be used for the screening of inhibitors on amyloid deposition in vitro.     

Elongation kinetics of polyglutamine peptide fibrils: a quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation study

Abnormally expanded polyglutamine domains in proteins are associated with several neurodegenerative diseases, including Huntington's disease. Expansion of the polyglutamine (polyQ) domain facilitates aggregation of the affected protein, and several studies directly link aggregation to neurotoxicity. Studies of synthetic polyQ peptides have contributed substantially to our understanding of the mechanism of aggregation. In this report, polyQ fibrils were immobilized onto a sensor, and their elongation by polyQ peptides of various length and conformation was examined using quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring (QCM-D). The rate of elongation increased as the peptide length increased from 8 to 24 glutamines (Q8, Q20, and Q24). Monomer conformation affected elongation rates: insertion of a β-turn template d-Pro-Gly in the center of the peptide increased elongation rates several-fold, while insertion of Pro-Pro dramatically slowed elongation. Dissipation measurements of the QCM-D provided qualitative information about mechanical properties of the elongating fibrils. These data showed clear differences in the characteristics of the elongating aggregates, depending on the specific identity of the associating polyQ peptide. Elongation rates were sensitive to the pH and ionic strength of the buffer. Comparison of QCM-D data with those obtained by optical waveguide lightmode spectroscopy revealed that very little water was associated with the elongation of fibrils by the peptide containing d-Pro-Gly, but a significant amount of water was associated when the fibrils were elongated by Q20. Together, the data indicate that elongation of polyQ fibrils can occur without full consolidation to the fibril structure, resulting in variations to the aggregate structure during elongation.     

Probing the pressure-temperature stability of amyloid fibrils provides new insights into their molecular properties

A number of medical disorders, including Alzheimer's disease and type II diabetes, is characterised by the deposition of amyloid fibrils in tissue. The insolubility and size of the fibrils has largely precluded the determination of their structures at high resolution. Studies probing the stability of amyloid fibrils can reveal which non-covalent interactions are important in the formation and maintenance of the fibril structure. In particular, we review here the use of high hydrostatic pressure and high temperature as perturbation techniques. In general, small aggregates formed early in the assembly process can be dissociated by high pressure, but mature amyloid fibrils are highly pressure stable. This finding suggests that a temporal transition occurs during which side chain packing and hydrogen bond formation are optimised, whereas the hydrophobic effect and electrostatic interactions play a dominant role in the early stages of the aggregation. High temperatures, however, can disrupt most aggregates. Though the observed stability of amyloid fibrils is not unique to these structures, the notion that amyloid fibrils can represent the global minimum in free energy is supported by this type of investigations. Some implications regarding the nature of toxic species, associated with at least many of the amyloid disorders, and recently proposed structural models are discussed.     

Experimentally derived structural constraints for amyloid fibrils of wild-type transthyretin

Transthyretin (TTR) is a largely β-sheet serum protein responsible for transporting thyroxine and vitamin A. TTR is found in amyloid deposits of patients with senile systemic amyloidosis. TTR mutants lead to familial amyloidotic polyneuropathy and familial amyloid cardiomyopathy, with an earlier age of onset. Studies of amyloid fibrils of familial amyloidotic polyneuropathy mutant TTR suggest a structure similar to the native state with only a simple opening of a β-strand-loop-strand region exposing the two main β-sheets of the protein for fibril elongation. However, we find that the wild-type TTR sequence forms amyloid fibrils that are considerably different from the previously suggested amyloid structure. Using protease digestion with mass spectrometry, we observe the amyloid core to be primarily composed of the C-terminal region, starting around residue 50. Solid-state NMR measurements prove that TTR differs from other pathological amyloids in not having an in-register parallel β-sheet architecture. We also find that the TTR amyloid is incapable of binding thyroxine as monitored by either isothermal calorimetry or 1,8-anilinonaphthalene sulfonate competition. Taken together, our experiments are consistent with a significantly different configuration of the β-sheets compared to the previously suggested structure.     

Visualization and classification of amyloid beta supramolecular assemblies

Deposition of amyloid beta (Abeta) fibrils has been suggested to play a central role in Alzheimer's disease. In clarifying the mechanism by which fibrils form and moreover in developing new treatments for amyloidosis, direct observation is important. Focusing on the interactions with surfaces at the early stages, we studied the spontaneous formation of Abeta(1-40) fibrils on quartz slides, monitored by total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy combined with thioflavin T, an amyloid-specific fluorescence dye. Self-assembly of Abeta(1-40), accelerated by a low concentration of sodium dodecyl sulfate, produced various remarkable amyloid assemblies. Densely packed spherulitic structures with radial fibril growth were typically observed. When the packing of fibrils was coarse, extremely long fibrils often protruded from the spherulitic cores. In other cases, a large number of wormlike fibrils were formed. Transmission electron microscopy and atomic force microscopy revealed relatively short and straight fibrillar blocks associated laterally without tight interaction, leading to random-walk-like fibril growth. These results suggest that, during spontaneous fibrillation, the nucleation occurring in contact with surfaces is easily affected by environmental factors, creating various types of nuclei, and hence variations in amyloid morphology. A taxonomy of amyloid supramolecular assemblies will be useful in clarifying the structure-function relationship of amyloid fibrils.     

Non-fibrillar components of amyloid deposits mediate the self-association and tangling of amyloid fibrils

Amyloid deposits are proteinaceous extra-cellular aggregates associated with a diverse range of disease states. These deposits are composed predominantly of amyloid fibrils, the unbranched, beta-sheet rich structures that result from the misfolding and subsequent aggregation of many proteins. In addition, amyloid deposits contain a number of non-fibrillar components that interact with amyloid fibrils and are incorporated into the deposits in their native folded state. The influence of a number of the non-fibrillar components in amyloid-related diseases is well established; however, the mechanisms underlying these effects are poorly understood. Here we describe the effect of two of the most important non-fibrillar components, serum amyloid P component and apolipoprotein E, upon the solution behavior of amyloid fibrils in an in vitro model system. Using analytical ultracentrifugation, electron microscopy, and rheological measurements, we demonstrate that these non-fibrillar components cause soluble fibrils to condense into localized fibrillar aggregates with a greatly enhanced local density of fibril entanglements. These results suggest a possible mechanism for the observed role of non-fibrillar components as mediators of amyloid deposition and deposit stability.