Morphological variation among Betula nana (diploid), B. pubescens (tetraploid) and their triploid hybrids in Iceland

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Introgressive hybridization between two co-existing Betula species in Iceland, diploid dwarf birch B. nana and tetraploid downy birch B. pubescens, has been well documented. The two species are highly variable morphologically, making taxonomic delineation difficult despite stable ploidy levels. Here an analysis is made of morphological variation within each ploidy group with an aim to establishing a reliable means to distinguish the species. METHODS: Plant materials were collected from 14 woodlands in Iceland. The plants were identified based on 2n chromosome numbers. Morphological variation in species-specific characters within each ploidy group was analysed qualitatively and quantitatively. The morphological index was based on eight discrete characters, whereas the multivariate analysis was based on nine leaf variables. KEY RESULTS: Of the 461 plants examined, 9.5 % were found to be triploid hybrids. The three ploidy groups were morphologically distinguishable but their variation overlapped. The diploid, triploid and tetraploid groups had average scores of 1.3, 4.1 and 8.3, respectively, in the morphology index scale from 0 (B. nana) to 13 (B. pubescens). A linear discriminant analysis also revealed significant separation among the three ploidy groups and the model assigned 96 % and 97 % of the B. nana and B. pubescens individuals correctly. The triploid hybrids were difficult to predict since only half of them could be assigned correctly. Leaf length was the most useful variable identifying triploid hybrids. Geographical patterns within the ploidy groups could partly be explained by differences in mean July temperature. CONCLUSIONS: Hybridization between B. nana and B. pubescens is widespread in Iceland. The species can be distinguished from each other morphologically, and from the triploid hybrids. The overlapping morphological variation indicates bidirectional introgression between the two species via triploid hybrids. Iceland could be considered a birch hybrid zone, harbouring genetic variation which may be advantageous in subarctic regions.     

Reproductive patterns of Betula pendula and B. pubescens coll. along a regional altitudinal gradient in northern Sweden

The Scandinavian birches have different distribution patterns Betula pendula reaches its upper tree limit at the bottom of the valleys in the Scandes, while B pubescens ssp pubescens extends above the B pendula limit, and merges into B pubescens ssp tortuosa at higher elevations In a 6 yr study I quantified the spatial and temporal variation in the reproduction of these species along a regional altitudinal gradient Betula pendula showed a steeper altitudinal decrease of seed germinability and seed germination rate than B pubescens coll Seed weight was strongly and positively correlated with altitude for B pubescens , but not for B pendula The proportion of seeds infected by gall midges Semudobia coll, was much higher in B pendula than in B pubescens coll especially in the mountain area All birch taxa showed large annual variations in quantity and quality of seeds The sapling density was higher in B pubescens ssp pubescens stands than in B pendula and B pubescens ssp tortuosa stands in the mountains The vegetative reproduction was about three times higher for B pubescens ssp tortuosa , than for the other two birches These results indicate that the altitudinal variation in reproduction among the birch taxa mirror their present distribution patterns     

Comparative analysis of leaf trichome structure and composition of epicuticular flavonoids in Finnish birch species

The morphology, ultrastructure, density and distribution of trichomes on leaves of Betula pendula, B. pubescens ssp. pubescens, B. pubescens ssp. czerepanovii and B. nana were examined by means of light, scanning and transmission electron microscopy. The composition of flavonoids in ethanolic leaf surface extracts was analysed by high pressure liquid chromatography. All taxa examined contained both glandular and non-glandular trichomes (short and/or long hairs) but differed from each other in trichome ultrastructure, density and location on the leaf. Leaves of B. pubescens were more hairy than those of B. pendula, but the latter species had a higher density of glandular trichomes. Of the two subspecies of B. pubescens, leaves of ssp. pubescens had more short hairs on the leaf surface and four times the density of glandular trichomes of leaves of ssp. czerepanovii, whereas, in the latter subspecies, short hairs occurred largely on leaf veins, as in B. nana. The glandular trichomes were peltate glands, consisting of medullar and cortical cells, which differed structurally. Cortical cells possessed numerous small, poorly developed plastids and small vacuoles, whereas medullar cells had several large plastids with well-developed thylakoid systems and fewer vacuoles. In B. pubescens subspecies, vacuoles of the glandular cells contained osmiophilic deposits, which were probably phenolic, whereas in B. pendula, vacuoles of glandular trichomes were characterized by the presence of numerous myelin-like membranes. The composition of epicuticular flavonoids also differed among species. The two subspecies of B. pubescens and B. nana shared the same 12 compounds, but five of these occurred only in trace amounts in B. nana. Leaf surface extracts of B. pendula contained just six flavonoids, three of which occurred only in this species. In summary, the structure, density and distribution of leaf trichomes and the composition of epicuticular flavonoids represent good taxonomic markers for Finnish birch species.     

Morphological, cytogenetic, and molecular evidence for introgressive hybridization in birch.

Extensive morphological variation of tetraploid birch (Betula pubescens) in Iceland is believed to be due to gene flow from diploid dwarf birch (B. nana) by means of introgressive hybridization. A combined morphological and cytogenetic approach was used to investigate this phenomenon in two geographically separated populations of natural birch woodland in Iceland. The results not only confirmed introgressive hybridization in birch, but also revealed bidirectional gene flow between the two species via triploid interspecific hybrids. The populations showed continuous morphological variation connecting the species, but karyotypically they consisted of only three types of plants: diploids, triploids, and tetraploids. No aneuploids were found. Some of the tetraploid plants had B. pubescens morphology as expected, but most of them had intermediate characters. Most of the diploid plants were B. nana, but some were intermediates and a few had B. pubescens morphology. The triploid plants were either intermediates or they resembled one of the two species. Similar introgressive variation was observed among the diploid and triploid progeny of open-pollinated B. nana in a garden. Birch samples including field plants and artificial hybrids were further examined using a molecular method based on genomic Southern hybridization. The experiments verified introgression at the DNA level.     

HPLC analysis of leaf surface flavonoids for the preliminary classification of birch species

Flavonoid aglycones found on the surfaces of birch (Betula spp.) leaves may constitute up to 10% of the dry weight of the leaf. A facile extraction and HPLC procedure has been developed that can be used for the preliminary classification of birch species according to the patterns of their leaf surface flavonoids. The procedure involves no complex sample preparation steps, and is able to provide HPLC chromatograms from fresh leaves in less than 30 min. If necessary, leaves do not even need to be removed from the tree. Since the genus Betula is taxonomically complex and separation of different birch species can be problematic, the developed method was applied to 15 Betula species and four sub-species of Betula pendula Seven of the studied species were classified as B. pubescens and eight as B. pendula-type birches. The remaining four species did not belong to either of these two classes on account of their unique pattern of external flavonoids. The difference between the leaf surface flavonoid composition of B. pubescens and B. pendula type birch species was unambiguously clear, and the developed method could reliably distinguish between the two species. Whilst leaf surface flavonoids can be valuable chemotaxonomic markers, they classify birch species differently from morphological markers. Birch species with diploid chromosome sets did not contain any of the flavanones that were present in the leaves of other species. The close relationship between the occurrence of some flavonoid aglycones and the ploidy level of Betula species suggests that these chemotaxonomic markers may be useful both in taxonomic and phylogenetic analyses.     

Comparative phylogeography and population structure of European Betula species, with particular focus on B. pendula and B. pubescens

Aim  To compare the population genetic structures of the haplotype-sharing species Betula pendula and B. pubescens and to draw phylogeographic inferences using chloroplast DNA markers. In particular, we tested whether B. pendula and B. pubescens exhibited the same or different phylogeographic structures.
Location  Western Europe and Russia.
Methods  In this study we used both chloroplast DNA polymerase chain reaction-restriction fragment length polymorphism and microsatellites to genotype B. pendula , B. pubescens and, to a limited extent, B. nana , in 53 populations across Eurasia. A spatial amova ( samova ) was used to identify major clusters within each species.
Results  The low level of phylogeographic structure previously observed in B. pendula was confirmed, and the samova analysis retrieved only two major clusters. In contrast, seven clusters were observed in B. pubescens , although the overall level of population differentiation was similar to that of B. pendula .
Main conclusions  We detected a difference in the population genetic structure between the two species, despite extensive haplotype sharing. It is difficult to ascribe this finding to a single factor, but divergence in ecology between the two species may provide part of the explanation. For both species, the contribution of southern western populations to the recolonization after the Last Glacial Maximum seems to have been limited, and eastern and western European populations apparently had different histories.     

Quantitative analysis of polymeric proanthocyanidins in birch leaves with normal-phase HPLC

The proanthocyanidin composition and content in the leaves of nine birch species (Betula albosinensis, B. ermanii B. maximowicziana, B. nana, B. papyrifera, B. pendula, B. platyphylla, B. pubescens, and B. pubescens ssp. czerepanovii) were studied with different methods including colorimetric assay, HPLC coupled with PAD or ESI/MS and NMR. Total proanthocyanidin content was determined using the acid butanol assay. A normal phase-HPLC method was applied for the analysis of polymeric proanthocyanidins. The content of polymeric proanthocyanidins was estimated from a late eluting peak in the chromatogram. With this HPLC method, quantitative analysis of polymeric proanthocyanidins could be performed directly from leaf extracts: no additional purification or preparation steps were required. It was shown that birch leaves contained mainly polymeric proanthocyanidins with a degree of polymerisation greater than 10. Total proanthocyanidin content (expressed as dry weight) was found to vary from 44mg/g (B. papyrifera) to 145mg/g (B. nana), and polymeric proanthocyanidin content from 39mg/g (B. pendula) to 119 mg/g (B. nana).     

Introgression and phylogeography of Betula nana (diploid), B. pubescens (tetraploid) and their triploid hybrids in Iceland inferred from cpDNA haplotype variation

Aim The objective was to find direct genetic evidence supporting introgressive hybridization between tetraploid tree birch (Betula pubescens) and diploid dwarf birch (B. nana), via triploid hybrids, and to investigate an association between the introgression and phylogeographical distribution of Icelandic birch. Location Samples were collected from 463 trees in 12 woodlands in Iceland and eight locations in Norway, Sweden, Scotland and Greenland. Methods Ploidy status of individual trees was determined by chromosome counting. Variation in the chloroplast genome was assessed using polymerase chain reaction‐restriction fragment length polymorphism. The geographical distribution of the haplotypes was mapped. The haplotype variation and introgression ratios (IG) were analysed statistically. Results Thirteen haplotypes were identified among Icelandic samples. The most common haplotype (T, 49% occurrence) was present in all ploidy groups and in all woodlands. All common haplotypes were shared between the triploid group and the parental species, indicating introgressive hybridization. This was supported by the statistical analysis of IG indices and the variation components. Considerable differences existed among samples, shaped by isolation by distance and local introgression. An east–west phylogeographical distribution in Iceland was observed. Main conclusions Despite extensive introgression across species and ploidy levels, a biogeographical pattern has been observed, and this may indicate different population histories or multiple origins of Icelandic birch. The chloroplast haplotype diversity found in Iceland resembles that found in birch populations from northern Scandinavia.     

Reproductive variability and pollen limitation in three Betula taxa in northern Sweden

This 3-yr study documents large variation in pollination and seed quality in birches (Betula) in northern Sweden between taxa, high and low altitude populations, and among years Seed quality was positively correlated with pollination degree and improved by pollen supplementation in B pubescens ssp pubescens in the mountain area, indicating pollen limitation Betula pendula showed the same tendency, but less pronounced Reduced sexual reproduction of B pendula in the mountain area might more often be due to limited resources for seed maturation and defense of the seeds against predispersal seed predation In contrast, coastal populations of both species display relatively high pollination rates and supplemental pollination had no effect on seed quality, suggesting that pollen limitation is rare or absent here The mountain birch Betula pubescens ssp tortuosa showed generally lower pollination and seed quality compared with B pubescens ssp pubescens , but not compared with mountain populations of B pendula It is concluded that pollen limitation may occur in Betula , but to what extent varies with taxon, altitude and year The seed quality is also strongly affected by other factors such as infections of gall midges (Semudobia spp, Diptera Cecidomyndae) and incomplete seed maturation     

Content and Composition of Fatty Acids in Total Lipids from the Buds of Betula pubescens,B. pendula,and B. pendula var. carelica

Russian Journal of Plant Physiology - Absolute content and composition of fatty acids (FAs) in total lipids from the buds of white birch (Betula pubescens Ehrh.), silver birch (B. pendula Roth),...     

Distribution of hydrolysable tannins in the foliage of Finnish birch species

On the basis of qualitative and quantitative analysis with liquid chromatography--electrospray ionisation mass spectrometry, the foliage of dwarf birch (Betula nana L.), silver birch (B. pendula Roth) and mountain birch (B. pubescens ssp. czerepanovii (Orlova) H?met-Ahti) were found, for the first time, to contain the same individual HTs that were described earlier for white birch (B. pubescens Ehrh.). In addition, one previously unidentified ellagitannin was preliminarily identified from the leaves of white and mountain birches, being totally absent from the foliage of the other two species. There were large variations in the contents of HTs between species. Seasonal variation affected significantly the contents of some individual HTs within species, and these changes were mainly in accordance with the biosynthetic pathway of HTs. All species converted galloylglucoses (GGs) into ellagitannins (ETs), dwarf birch being the only one that's efficient ET synthesis resulted in seasonally increased contents of ETs and thereof total HTs as well. The presence of insoluble ETs as well as the absence of insoluble GGs was confirmed in all four birch species for the first time. Furthermore, the amounts of insoluble ETs per one birch leaf were found to accumulate during the growing season. These findings complemented our knowledge of the biosynthetic pathway of birch leaf HTs: from soluble GGs via soluble ETs into insoluble ETs. The possible role of HTs in the herbivore defence of these species is discussed.     

Oncopsis flavicollis (L.) associated with tree birches (Betula): a complex of biological species or a host plant utilization polymorphism?

The closely related species of leafhoppers, Oncopsis flavicollis (L.) and 0. subangulata (Sahl.), are restricted to birches, Betula pendula Roth and B. pubescens Ehrh., as host plants. Morphometric discriminant analyses of adult insects from S Wales showed O. flavicollis populations from the two Betula species to be significantly different. The best discrimination was provided by characters of the male dorsal abdominal apodemes. Analyses of such apodeme morphology in populations more widely from S Britain showed three distinct types: in western localities type 1 dominantly on B. pubescens , type 2 dominantly on B. pendula and type 3 absent; in eastern localities type 3 only on B. pendula , type 2 on both species of Betula and type 1 only on B. pubescens. Acoustic calling and courtship signals of males showed clear differences between the three apodeme types of 0. flavicollis. It is concluded that the three 0. flavicollis types, together with 0. subangulata , are distinct but very closely related biological species. Contrary to earlier suggestions, this example provides no evidence for host plant utilization polymorphisms.     

Foraging by moose on two species of birch when these occur in different proportions

The two tree-like birch species Betula pendula and B. pubescens are of medium preference to moose during winter in northern Sweden. Because these birches are abundant in many biotopes, they form a major part of the moose diet. The two birches are very similar in appearance and often occur in mixed stands. Twenty-one birch stands where B. pendula formed from 2 to 97% of the birches were investigated to determine how the relative composition of the stands affected browsing of the two species by moose. In stands composed of 60% or less of B. pendula , there was a preference for this species when regarding 1.5–3.0 m high birches, which carry the largest amount of available browse per tree. At higher proportions B. pendula was still preferred, but use was closer to availability. However, in all stands there were significantly more moose bites per tree of B. pendula than of B. pubescens . In four birch stands browsing on 1.0–1.5 m high birches was also investigated. For this height class there was still a preference for B. pendula , but the difference between the two species was less pronounced than for the 1.5–3.0 m height class.     

Changes in leaf trichomes and epicuticular flavonoids during leaf development in three birch taxa

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Changes in number of trichomes and in composition and concentrations of their exudates throughout leaf development may have important consequences for plant adaptation to abiotic and biotic factors. In the present study, seasonal changes in leaf trichomes and epicuticular flavonoid aglycones in three Finnish birch taxa (Betula pendula, B. pubescens ssp. pubescens, and B. pubescens ssp. czerepanovii) were followed. METHODS: Trichome number and ultrastructure were studied by means of light, scanning and transmission electron microscopy, while flavonoid aglycones in ethanolic leaf surface extracts were analysed by high-pressure liquid chromatography. KEY RESULTS: Density of both glandular and non-glandular trichomes decreased drastically with leaf expansion while the total number of trichomes per leaf remained constant, indicating that the final number of trichomes is established early in leaf development. Cells of glandular trichomes differentiate before those of the epidermis and produce secreted material only during the relatively short period (around 1-2 weeks) of leaf unfolding and expansion. In fully expanded leaves, glandular trichomes appeared to be at the post-secretory phase and function mainly as storage organs; they contained lipid droplets and osmiophilic material (probably phenolics). Concentrations (mg g(-1) d. wt) of surface flavonoids decreased with leaf age in all taxa. However, the changes in total amount ( microg per leaf) of flavonoids during leaf development were taxon-specific: no changes in B. pubescens ssp. czerepanovii, increase in B. pendula and in B. pubescens ssp. pubescens followed by the decline in the latter taxon. Concentrations of most of the individual leaf surface flavonoids correlated positively with the density of glandular trichomes within species, suggesting the participation of glandular trichomes in production of surface flavonoids. CONCLUSIONS: Rapid decline in the density of leaf trichomes and in the concentrations of flavonoid aglycones with leaf age suggests that the functional role of trichomes is likely to be most important at the early stages of birch leaf development.     

Effects of host-plant shift on immune and other key life-history traits of an eruptive Geometrid, Epirrita autumnata (Borkhausen)

Abstract.  1. Population density of Epirrita autumnata (Lepidoptera: Geometridae) reaches outbreak densities regularly in northernmost Scandinavia. During these outbreak years, the most abundant host species, the mountain birch ( Betula pubescens ssp. czerepanovii ), is regularly exhausted, although larvae may rescue themselves from starvation by using alternative host species.
2. In this paper, the effects of the shift of host species on the immune defence and other life-history traits of E. autumnata were investigated, and possible consequences for population dynamics were briefly discussed. Moth larvae were reared on the leaves of the main host, mountain birch, until larvae reached their third instar. After this, larvae were allocated randomly to five treatments: larvae were either allowed to finish larval stage on the mountain birch or were shifted onto four alternative host species that are typical species for the area.
3. As expected, the host species had a major effect on fitness traits: body weight, development, and survival rate of the moths. The pupal weight was lower and development rates slower on the three alternative host species, Salix myrsinifolia Salisb., Vaccinium uliginosum L., and Betula nana L., than on the main host, mountain birch.
4. The immunity was, however, the same or better on the alternative hosts than on the main host. The immunity and pupal weights were negatively related, suggesting a trade-off between body size and immunocompetence.
5. The decreased body size and fecundity of E. autumnata during outbreak years may be partly due to the shift to alternative host species whereas the host-plant species probably does not affect markedly the rate of parasitism.     

Interspecific variation in resistance of Asian, European, and North American birches (Betula spp.) to bronze birch borer (Coleoptera: Buprestidae)

Bronze birch borer (Agrilus anxius Gory) is the key pest of birches (Betula spp.) in North America, several of which have been recommended for ornamental landscapes based on anecdotal reports of borer resistance that had not been confirmed experimentally. In a 20-yr common garden experiment initiated in 1979 in Ohio, North American birch species, including paper birch (Betula papyrifera Marshall), 'Whitespire' gray birch (Betula populifolia Marshall), and river birch (Betula nigra L.), were much more resistant to bronze birch borer than species indigenous to Europe and Asia, including European white birch (Betula pendula Roth), downy birch (Betula pubescens Ehrh.), monarch birch (Betula maximowicziana Regel), and Szechuan white birch (Betula szechuanica Jansson). Within 8 yr of planting, every European white, downy, and Szechuan birch had been colonized and killed, although 100% of monarch birch had been colonized and 88% of these plants were killed after nine years. Conversely, 97% of river birch, 76% of paper birch, and 73% Whitespire gray birch were alive 20 yr after planting, and river birch showed no evidence of colonization. This pattern is consistent with biogeographic theory of plant defense: North American birch species that share a coevolutionary history with bronze birch borer were much more resistant than na?ve hosts endemic to Europe and Asia, possibly by virtue of evolution of targeted defenses. This information suggests that if bronze birch borer were introduced to Europe or Asia, it could threaten its hosts there on a continental scale. This study also exposed limitations of anecdotal observation as evidence of host plant resistance.     

The genus Betula in Greenland-Holocene history, present distribution and synecology

After its arrival in E Greenland c. 8000 C-14 years B.P. Betula nana spread rapidly to become a dominant plant. A climatic change c. 5000 B.P. almost exterminated it at more oceanic sites, whereas inland it only lost little ground. Today it is common inland in many kinds of heath and other vegetation types. When it spread to Middle W Greenland around 6500 B.P. it only took two to three centuries to become dominating in the continental inland whereas the spreading to the coastal areas began later and was more gradual. After the Holocene climatic optimum it decreased here but kept its dominating position inland, where today it is a main plant in mossy heaths on N slopes and dry, grassy communities on S slopes.
Betula glandulosa arrived in SW Greenland c. 5 700 B.P., later on in S Greenland. It is a lowarctic, oceanic plant, missing only on the outer skerries, but being common in mossy heaths all through the fjords, where it also occurs in grassland vegetation types and, at the head of the fjords, as undergrowth in the subarctic, usually 4–5 m high birch woodlands formed by B. pubescens , which did not arrive until c. 3500 B.P. The most common plant communities, in which the three Betula species occur in different parts of Greenland are summarized, partly by referring to other publications, partly by presenting six new tables of vegetation analyses, stored in the Botanical Museum or published in "grey literature". Where the species meet, hybridizing and introgression take place. Distribution maps of the three species and two hybrids are presented, and the taxonomy summarized.     

Postglacial recolonization and cpDNA variation of silver birch,Betula pendula

Chloroplast PCR-RFLP markers were used to reconstruct the history of the silver birch, Betula pendula Roth, in Europe since the last glacial maximum (LGM). In birch, fossil pollen maps do not reveal a clear chronological sequence of postglacial spread. If anything, the pollen record suggests that most of Europe was recolonized by birches as early as 10000 bp, probably from populations that remained close to the ice sheets during the LGM. The geographical distribution of haplotypes supports a scenario of early colonization. Two of the 13 haplotypes that were observed are common, representing 35% and 49% of the total sample, respectively. Although one of the common haplotypes is predominant in the NW and the other in the SE, both are present throughout most of the investigated geographical area. Rare haplotypes are geographically restricted. The distribution of the haplotypes reveals five genetic boundaries between groups of haplotypes and allows us to infer patterns of postglacial recolonization. Europe was re-occupied by two main waves of recolonization: one eastern and one western, with origins at intermediate latitudes. Populations in the Iberian Peninsula and in Italy did not take part in the postglacial recolonization of Europe.     

Fragmented environment affects birch leaf endophytes

The effect of environmental fragmentation on the species distribution and frequency of horizontally transmitted endophytic fungi in Betula pubescens and Betula pendula leaves was studied in an archipelago in southwestern Finland. The study system consisted of 14 islands, ranging in size and distance to the mainland, and five mainland sites. Endophytic fungi were grown out from surface-sterilized leaves. The frequency of endophytic fungi mainly depended on the size of the island, explaining 32-35% of the variation, and the distance to the mainland explaining 29-35% of the variation. The birch trees on the largest islands near the mainland had the highest endophyte frequencies. Fusicladium betulae, Gnomonia setacea and Melanconium betulinum were the most commonly isolated fungi. Foliar endophytes of birch trees are able to disperse to fairly fragmented areas, but their frequencies seem to depend on environmental isolation and size of the island.     

额尔齐斯河流域垂枝桦林群落结构特征与物种多样性相关分析

为阐明植物群落结构特征和物种多样性之间的相互关系,选择额尔齐斯河流域白桦林国家森林公园的天然垂枝桦(Betula pendula)纯林、垂枝桦苦杨混交林、垂枝桦白柳混交林为研究对象,分林层调查群落的基本特征参数(高度、枝下高、冠幅、胸径、盖度等),计算物种重要值、丰富度指数、多样性指数、均匀度指数,并进行典范对应分析。结果表明:(1)垂枝桦白柳混交林的乔木层树高、枝下高和灌木层的地径、盖度均最高;3种群落的草本层特征参数(除基径)均具有显著差异;垂枝桦白柳林的盖度分别比垂枝桦苦杨林和垂枝桦纯林高19.1%和51.8%。(2)3种群落的乔木层重要值最高为垂枝桦,灌木层为疏花蔷薇(Rosa laxa)、阿尔泰山楂(Crataegus altaica),草本层为莎薹草(Carex bohemica)。(3)3种群落类型中乔木层的丰富度指数R、Simpson指数、Shannon-Wiener指数和灌木层的Pielou指数、Alatalo指数呈现出相同规律,即垂枝桦白柳混交林>垂枝桦苦杨混交林>垂枝桦纯林;草本层中除Alatalo指数之外,其他指数均呈现垂枝桦纯林>垂枝桦苦杨混交林>垂枝桦白柳混交林(P>0.05)。(4)CCA排序结果表明,不同垂枝桦林群落结构特征与物种多样性关系有差异。其中,垂枝桦纯林中,对物种多样性影响最大的是乔木枝下高、灌木株高、冠幅以及草本盖度;垂枝桦苦杨混交林中,对物种多样性影响最大的是乔木高度和冠幅、灌木冠幅和草本高度;垂枝桦白柳林中,对物种多样性影响最大的是乔木胸径、灌木冠幅、盖度以及草本高度。研究表明,乔木枝下高度、灌木冠幅、草本高度是影响3种群落类型物种多样性的主要因素。