Properties of rat liver mitochondria with intermembrane Cytochrome c.

When rat liver mitochondria were suspended in 0.15 m KCl, the cytochrome c appeared to be solubilized from the binding site on the outside of the inner membrane and trapped in the intermembrane space. When the outer membrane of these mitochondria was disrupted with digitonin at a digitonin concentration of 0.15 mg/mg of protein, the solubilized cytochrome c could be released from mitochondria along with adenylate kinase. When mitochondria were suspended in 0.15 m KCl instead of 0.33 m sucrose, the $\text{ADP}\text{O}$ ratio observed with succinate, β-hydroxybutyrate, malate + pyruvate or glutamate as substrates was little affected. A number of cycles of State 4-State 3-State 4 with ADP was observed. The respiratory control ratios, however, were decreased, particularly when glutamate was used as the substrate. Cytochrome c oxidase activity was also decreased to 55% when assayed using ascorbate + N,N,N′,N′-tetramethyl-p-phenylene-diamine (TMPD) as substrates. Suspension of mitochondria in 0.15 m KCl resulted in an enhancement of the very low NADH oxidation by intact mitochondria and a twofold enhancement of sulfite oxidation. Trapped cytochrome c in outer membrane vesicles prepared from untreated and trypsin-treated intact mitochondria was found to be readily reduced by NADH and suggests that some cytochrome b₅ is located on the inner surface of the outer membrane. The enhanced NADH oxidase could therefore reflect the ability of cytochrome c to mediate intermembrane electron transport. The enhanced sulfite oxidase activity was sensitive to cyanide inhibition and coupled to oxidative phosphorylation ($\text{ADP}\text{O}\text{< 1}$) unlike the activity of mitochondria in sucrose medium. These results suggest that free cytochrome c in the intermembrane space can mediate electron transfer between the sulfite oxidase and the inner membrane.     

THE SUBMITOCHONDRIAL LOCALIZATION OF MONOAMINE OXIDASE : An Enzymatic Marker for the Outer Membrane of Rat Liver Mitochondria

Controlled osmotic lysis (water-washing) of rat liver mitochondria results in a mixed population of small vesicles derived mainly from the outer mitochondrial membrane and of larger bodies containing a few cristae derived from the inner membrane. These elements have been separated on Ficoll and sucrose gradients. The small vesicles were rich in monoamine oxidase, and the large bodies were rich in cytochrome oxidase. Separation of the inner and outer membranes has also been accomplished by treating mitochondria with digitonin in an isotonic medium and fractionating the treated mitochondria by differential centrifugation. Treatment with low digitonin concentrations released monoamine oxidase activity from low speed mitochondrial pellets, and this release of enzymatic activity was correlated with the loss of the outer membrane as seen in the electron microscope. The low speed mitochondrial pellet contained most of the cytochrome oxidase and malate dehydrogenase activities of the intact mitochondria, while the monoamine oxidase activity could be recovered in the form of small vesicles by high speed centrifugation of the low speed supernatant. The results indicate that monoamine oxidase is found only in the outer mitochondrial membrane and that cytochrome oxidase is found only in the inner membrane. Digitonin treatment released more monoamine oxidase than cytochrome oxidase from sonic particles, thus indicating that digitonin preferentially degrades the outer mitochondrial membrane.     

The pro-apoptotic proteins, Bid and Bax, cause a limited permeabilization of the mitochondrial outer membrane that is enhanced by cytosol

During apoptosis, an important pathway leading to caspase activation involves the release of cytochrome c from the intermembrane space of mitochondria. Using a cell-free system based on Xenopus egg extracts, we examined changes in the outer mitochondrial membrane accompanying cytochrome c efflux. The pro-apoptotic proteins, Bid and Bax, as well as factors present in Xenopus egg cytosol, each induced cytochrome c release when incubated with isolated mitochondria. These factors caused a permeabilization of the outer membrane that allowed the corelease of multiple intermembrane space proteins: cytochrome c, adenylate kinase and sulfite oxidase. The efflux process is thus nonspecific. None of the cytochrome c-releasing factors caused detectable mitochondrial swelling, arguing that matrix swelling is not required for outer membrane permeability in this system. Bid and Bax caused complete release of cytochrome c but only a limited permeabilization of the outer membrane, as measured by the accessibility of inner membrane-associated respiratory complexes III and IV to exogenously added cytochrome c. However, outer membrane permeability was strikingly increased by a macromolecular cytosolic factor, termed PEF (permeability enhancing factor). We hypothesize that PEF activity could help determine whether cells can recover from mitochondrial cytochrome c release.     

Oxidation and reduction of exogenous cytochrome c by the activity of the respiratory chain.

Oxidation of exogenous NADH by isolated rat liver mitochondria is generally accepted to be mediated by endogenous cytochrome c which shuttles electrons from the outer to the inner mitochondrial membrane. More recently it has been suggested that, in the presence of added cytochrome c, NADH oxidation is carried out exclusively by the cytochrome oxidase of broken or damaged mitochondria. Here we show that electrons can be transferred in and out of intact mitochondria. It is proposed that at the contact sites between the inner and the outer membrane, a "bi-trans-membrane" electron transport chain is present. The pathway, consisting of Complex III, NADH-b5 reductase, exogenous cytochrome c and cytochrome oxidase, can channel electrons from the external face of the outer membrane to the matrix face of the inner membrane and viceversa. The activity of the pathway is strictly dependent on both the activity of the respiratory chain and mitochondrion integrity.     

Reactive oxygen species and permeability transition pore in rat liver and kidney mitoplasts

Mitochondrial permeability transition is typically characterized by Ca²⁺ and oxidative stress-induced opening of a nonselective proteinaceous membrane pore sensitive to cyclosporin A, known as the permeability transition pore (PTP). Data from our laboratory provide evidence that the PTP is formed when inner membrane proteins aggregate as a result of disulfide cross-linking caused by thiol oxidation. Here we compared the redox properties between PTP in intact mitochondria and mitoplasts. The rat liver mitoplasts retained less than 5% and 10% of the original outer membrane markers monoamine oxidase and VDAC, respectively. Kidney mitoplasts also showed a partial depletion of hexokinase. In line with the redox nature of the PTP, mitoplasts that were more susceptible to PTP opening than intact mitochondria showed higher rates of H₂O₂ generation and decreased matrix NADPH-dependent antioxidant activity. Mitoplast PTP was also sensitive to the permeability transition inducer tert-butyl hydroperoxide and to the inhibitors cyclosporin A, EGTA, ADP, dithiothreitol and catalase. Taken together, these data indicate that, in mitoplasts, PTP exhibits redox regulatory characteristics similar to those described for intact mitochondria.     

Separation of outer and inner membranes of mitochondria from the brown adipose tissue of infant rats.

Digitonin treatment and the swelling-shrinkage-sonication procedure as used to separate mitochondria membranes were applied to mitochondria from the brown adipose tissue (BAT) of infant rats. Digitonin at a concentration of 0.15 mg/mg mitochondrial protein produced disruption of the outer membrane of BAT mitochondria and a complete release of adenylate kinase. However, fragments of the outer membrane remained firmly attached to the inner membrane-matrix particles (mitoplasts) and sedimented at 10 000 g, as indicated by the activity of monoamine oxidase in the pellet. Only at 0.5 mg digitonin/mg protein did outer membrane become almost entirely separated. Oxidation of external cytochrome c by mitoplasts was only 50% of the total cytochrome oxidase at 0.5 mg digitonin/mg protein, indicating an incomplete exposure of the inner membrane to the external medium. Ultrastructural studies revealed that a large proportion of mitoplasts retained the orthodox configuration under these conditions. Outer membrane fragments obtained by the swelling-shrinkage-sonication procedure were of buoyant density corresponding to 20–30% (weight/vol) sucrose. After a 10 sec sonication of mitochondria, a relatively pure outer membrane fraction could be obtained with a yield not exceeding 20%. Longer sonication increased the yield, but also increased the degree of contamination by inner membrane fragments. Optimum conditions for the separation of outer and inner membranes from brown adipose tissue mitochondria are described.     

Improved methods to isolate and subfractionate rat liver mitochondria. Lipid composition of the inner and outer membrane

Rat liver mitochondria were isolated by a combination of differential and Percoll gradient centrifugation, resulting in a highly pure and intact preparation, as assessed by marker enzyme analysis, latency of cytochrome-c oxidase, respiratory control index and electron microscopy. Two different methods were compared for the separation of inner and outer membranes. In the swell-shrink-sonicate procedure glycerol was included resulting in the isolation of one outer membrane and two inner membrane fractions of high purity. Using digitonin a highly selective and gradual solubilization of the outer membrane could be accomplished. Analysis of the phospholipid composition of the intact mitochondria and all subfractions showed that the inner membrane was virtually devoid of phosphatidylinositol and -serine, while the outer membrane contained 23% of the total mitochondrial cardiolipin, which did not originate from inner membrane contamination and therefore is a true component of the outer membrane.     

BIOCHEMICAL AND ULTRASTRUCTURAL PROPERTIES OF A MITOCHONDRIAL INNER MEMBRANE FRACTION DEFICIENT IN OUTER MEMBRANE AND MATRIX ACTIVITIES

Treatment of the inner membrane matrix fraction of rat liver mitochondria with the nonionic detergent Lubrol WX solubilized about 70% of the total protein and 90% or more of the following matrix activities: malate dehydrogenase, glutamate dehydrogenase, and isocitrate dehydrogenase (NADP). The Lubrol-insoluble fraction was enriched in cytochromes, phospholipids, and a Mg⁺⁺-stimulated ATPase activity. Less than 2% of the total mitochondrial activity of monoamine oxidase, an outer membrane marker, or adenylate kinase, an intracristal space marker could be detected in this inner membrane fraction. Electron micrographs of negatively stained preparations showed vesicles (≤0.4 µ diameter) literally saturated on the periphery with the 90 A ATPase particles. These inner membrane vesicles, which appeared for the most part to be inverted with respect to the normal inner membrane configuration in intact mitochondria, retained the succinicoxidase portion of the electron-transport chain, an intact phosphorylation site II with a high affinity for ADP, and the capacity to accumulate Ca⁺⁺. A number of biochemical properties characteristic of intact mitochondria and the inner membrane matrix fraction, however, were either absent or markedly deficient in the inner membrane vesicles. These included stimulation of respiration by either ADP or 2,4-dinitrophenol, oligomycin-sensitive ADP-ATP exchange activity, atractyloside sensitivity of adenine nucleotide requiring reactions, and a stimulation of the Mg⁺⁺-ATPase by 2,4-dinitrophenol.     

Interaction of cytochrome c with mitochondrial proteins and cybacrone-dextran

Interaction of cytochrome c with electron carriers in intact and damaged (with destroyed outer membrane) rat liver mitochondria was studied. It was shown that the increase in ionic strength causes changes in the respiration rate of damaged mitochondria due to the reduction of the cytochrome c affinity for its binding sites in the organelles. This suggests that cytochrome c concentration in the intermembrane space of intact mitochondria is increased by salts, whereas the increase in ionic strength has a slight influence on the rates of succinate oxidase and external rotenone-insensitive NADH-oxidase of intact mitochondria. At low ionic strength values, the Michaelis constant (KM) value of external NADH-oxidase for cytochrome c exceeds by one order of magnitude that for succinate oxidase, while the maximal activity of these two systems is nearly the same. The increase in ionic strength causes an increase in the KM value for both oxidases. Interaction of cytochrome c with mitochondrial proteins was modelled by cytochrome c interaction with cibacron-dextran anions. It was concluded that the ionic strength-sensitive electrostatic interactions play a decisive role in cytochrome c binding to electron carriers in mitochondrial membranes. However, cytochrome c content and its binding parameters in intact-mitochondrial membranes prevent the latent activity of external NADH oxidase to be revealed in intact mitochondria after the increase in the ionic strength of the surrounding medium.     

THE SURFACE CHARGE OF RAT LIVER MITOCHONDRIA AND THEIR MEMBRANES : Clarification of Some Controversies Concerning Mitochondrial Structure

The surface charge of intact mitochondria and submitochondrial particles was examined by the technique of preparative free flow electrophoresis. When submitochondrial preparations obtained by a swelling-contraction procedure were examined with this technique, two fractions were observed. One of these fractions exhibited the same electrophoretic properties as intact mitochondria, which indicated that it was derived from the outer limiting membrane of the mitochondrion. This fraction was found to contain the enzymes monoamine oxidase and rotenone-insensitive NADH-cytochrome c reductase which have been reported to be localized in the outer mitochondrial membrane. The other fraction exhibited an electrophoretic mobility which was different from that of intact mitochondria, and this fraction contained enzymes characteristic of the inner membrane-matrix fraction such as soluble and particulate enzymes of the Krebs cycle. Microsomes exhibited an electrophoretic mobility which was almost identical with that of the outer mitochondrial membrane. In addition to resolving the localization of enzymes in mitochondrial membranes, these data indicate that the outer limiting membrane of the mitochondrion is the sole determinant of the surface charge of mitochondria.     

A mechanism of sulfite neurotoxicity: direct inhibition of glutamate dehydrogenase

Exposure of Neuro-2a and PC12 cells to micromolar concentrations of sulfite caused an increase in reactive oxygen species and a decrease in ATP. Likewise, the biosynthesis of ATP in intact rat brain mitochondria from the oxidation of glutamate was inhibited by micromolar sulfite. Glutamate-driven respiration increased the mitochondrial membrane potential (MMP), and this was abolished by sulfite but the MMP generated by oxidation of malate and succinate was not affected. The increased rate of production of NADH from exogenous NAD+ and glutamate added to rat brain mitochondrial extracts was inhibited by sulfite, and mitochondria preincubated with sulfite failed to reduce NAD+. Glutamate dehydrogenase (GDH) in rat brain mitochondrial extract was inhibited dose-dependently by sulfite as was the activity of a purified enzyme. An increase in the Km (glutamate) and a decrease in Vmax resulting in an attenuation in Vmax/Km (glutamate) at 100 microm sulfite suggest a mixed type of inhibition. However, uncompetitive inhibition was noted with decreases in both Km (NAD+) and Vmax, whereas Vmax/Km (NAD+) remained relatively constant. We propose that GDH is one target of action of sulfite, leading to a decrease in alpha-ketoglutarate and a diminished flux through the tricarboxylic acid cycle accompanied by a decrease in NADH through the mitochondrial electron transport chain, a decreased MMP, and a decrease in ATP synthesis. Because glutamate is a major metabolite in the brain, inhibition of GDH by sulfite could contribute to the severe phenotype of sulfite oxidase deficiency in human infants.     

The localization of cholinephosphotransferase in the outer membrane of guinea-pig lung mitochondria

The activity of cholinephosphotransferase was measured in the subcellular fractions of guinea-pig lung. The specific activity of the enzyme was highest in a fraction, intermediate in density between mitochondria and microsomes. Similar subcellular distribution patterns were observed for both cholinephosphotransferase and rotenone-insensitive NADH-cytochrome c reductase, an enzyme associated with the outer membrane of mitochondria and endoplasmic reticulum, suggesting that cholinephosphotransferase may be localized in both of these organelles. The distribution of cholinephosphotransferase activity in the subfractions of mitochondria and the intermediate fractions recovered by linear density gradient paralleled that of the mitochondrial outer membrane marker enzyme, monoamine oxidase. RNA content of a subfraction enriched in cholinephosphotransferase and monoamine oxidase was not typical to that of either rough or smooth endoplasmic reticulum. The results of this study suggest that in guinea-pig lung, cholinephosphotransferase is localized in both the outer membrane of mitochondria, and the endoplasmic reticulum.     

Biochemical studies on sub-fractions of rat liver mitochondria

Highly purified mitochondria from rat liver were separated into six sub-fractions by differential centrifugation. The sub-fractions represent a spectrum from “heavy” to “very light” mitochondria. Enzymes representative of mitochondrial compartments were assayed to see whether functional differences occurred among the various mitochondrial sub-fractions. Respiratory control and NADH oxidase activity, both of which are indicators of mitochondrial structural integrity, were also measured. An enzyme marker for endoplasmic reticulum (glucose-6-phosphatase, G-6-Pase) was also assayed. Specific activities for monoamine oxidase (outer membrane marker), cytochrome oxidase (inner membrane marker) and malate-cytochrome c reductase did not vary within experimental error in all sub-fractions; similarly, for respiratory control and NADH oxidase activity. Malate dehydrogenase, a component of malate-cytochrome c reductase is located within the matrix surrounded by the inner membrane. Specific activity of adenylate kinase (located between the outer and inner membrane) decreased markedly from the “heavy” mitochondria to the “very light” fractions. Specific activity for G-6-Pase, very low in the “heavy” fractions, increased markedly in the “light” to “very light” fractions. Isopycnic density centrifugation on a linear sucrose density gradient of each of the fractions indicated that the correlation coefficient for the sucrose concentrations at which cytochrome oxidase and G-6-Pase activities peaked was 0.995. Thus the “light” to “very light” mitochondria may represent mitochondria whose outer membrane is still contiguous with the endoplasmic reticulum. Microsomes containing the endoplasmic reticulum peaked on the gradient at a significantly lower sucrose concentration than any of the mitochondrial sub-fractions. A buoyant effect of endoplasmic reticulum still attached to any of the mitochondrial sub-fractions would be expected to lower the density of attached mitochondria and thus give rise to “light” and “very light” mitochondria.     

Protective effect of magnesium and potassium ions on the permeability of the external mitochondrial membrane

The data reported are fully consistent with the well-known observation that exogenous cytochrome c (cyto-c) molecules do not permeate through the outer membrane of mitochondria (MOM) incubated in isotonic medium (250 mM sucrose). Cyto-c is unable to accept electrons from the sulfite/cyto-c oxido-reductase (Sox) present in the intermembrane space, unless mitochondria are solubilized. Mitochondria incubated in a very high hypotonic medium (25 mM sucrose), in contrast to any expectation, continue to be not permeable to added cyto-c even if Sox and adenylate kinase are released into the medium. The succinate/exogenous cyto-c reductase activity, very low in isotonic medium, is greatly increased decreasing the osmolarity of the medium but in both cases remains insensitive to proteolysis by added trypsin. In hypotonic medium, magnesium and potassium ions have a protective effect on the release of enzymes and on the reactivity of cyto-c as electron acceptor from both sulfite and succinate; results which are consistent with the view that MOM preserves its identity and remains not permeable to exogenous cyto-c. This report strengthens the proposal, supported by previously published data that in isotonic medium the exogenous NADH/cyto-c electron transport system is catalyzed by intact mitochondria, not permeable to added cyto-c.     

Etude de l'evolution des activites des enzymes mitochondriaux de l'hepatocyte au cours du developpement du rat

Study on the evolution of mitochondrial enzyme activities in hepatocyte during rat development

Some constitutive enzymes of the three isolated fractions of mitochondria outer membrane, inner membrane and matrix, have been investigated in rat hepatocyte during a period varying from the foetal state to the 15th day after birth.

In the three mitochondrial fractions, activities of the studied enzymes present different evolutions. In the matrix, the tricarboxylic enzyme activities have already reached their normal values before birth. In the outer membrane, the NADH-cytochrome c reductase activity increases regularly, in the same way as that of the endoplasmic reticulum NADH-cytochrome c reductase. In the inner membrane, the oxygen consumption is very low before birth, then increases suddenly from the 5th to the 8th day after birth, when it reaches the normal values. The limiting factor of the respiratory chain activities is neither cytochrome oxidase nor the first dehydrogenases.     

Developmental changes in mitochondria during the transition into lactation in the mouse mammary gland. II. Membrane marker enzymes and membrane ultrastructure

The activity of cytochrome oxidase (an inner mitochondrial membrane marker) in mouse mammary gland homogenates was found to increase five- to sixfold from late pregnancy to day 8 of lactation, while that of monoamine oxidase (an outer membrane marker) increased only about 25%. The specific activity of cytochrome oxidase in the isolated mitochondria decreased slightly over the same period while the specific activity of monoamine oxidase decreased fivefold. This reflects the fact that both cytochrome oxidase and mitochondrial protein are increasing at a much greater rate than is monoamine oxidase activity. Mixing experiments preclude the possibility that the release or removal of an inhibitor or stimulator produces the changes in enzymatic activity. The cytochrome oxidase to monoamine oxidase ratio was followed throughout the pregnancy-lactation cycle in total mammary homogenates, isolated mammary parenchymal cells, and isolated mammary mitochondria. In each preparation the pattern was the same with little change in the ratio until late pregnancy; and then a three- to fourfold increase occurred and the values reached a maximum by day 8 of lactation. These experiments were interpreted as demonstrating that the observed enzymatic changes are reflective of alterations in the mitochondria of the mammary parenchymal cell population. Electron micrographs of mid-pregnant and mid-lactating mammary parenchymal cells in situ were prepared, and distinct changes in the mitochondrial morphology noted. The most significant and obvious change is the large increase in the number of inner membrane cristae and an increase in matrix density in the lactating gland cell. Therefore, both enzymatic and morphological studies support the concept of an expansion of the mitochondrial inner membrane during presecretory differentiation in the mouse mammary parenchymal cell.     

Topological probes of monoamine oxidases A and B in rat liver mitochondria: inhibition by TEMPO-substituted pargyline analogues and inactivation by proteolysis

TEMPO-substituted pargyline analogues differentially inhibit recombinant human monoamine oxidase A (MAO A) and B (MAO B) in intact yeast mitochondria, suggesting these membrane-bound enzymes are located on differing faces of the mitochondrial outer membrane [Upadhyay, A., and Edmondson, D. E. (2009) Biochemistry 48, 3928]. This approach is extended to the recombinant rat enzymes and to rat liver mitochondria. The differential specificities exhibited for human MAO A and MAO B by the m- and p-amido TEMPO pargylines are not as absolute with the rat enzymes. Similar patterns of reactivity are observed for rat MAO A and B in mitochondrial outer membrane preparations expressed in Pichia pastoris or isolated from rat liver. In intact yeast mitochondria, recombinant rat MAO B is inhibited by the pargyline analogue whereas MAO A activity shows no inhibition. Intact rat liver mitochondria exhibit an inhibition pattern opposite to that observed in yeast where MAO A is inhibited and MAO B activity is unaffected. Protease inactivation studies show specificity in that MAO A is sensitive to trypsin whereas MAO B is sensitive to β-chymotrypsin. In intact mitochondrial preparations, MAO A is readily inactivated in rat liver but not in yeast upon trypsin treatment and MAO B is readily inactivated by β-chymotrypsin in yeast but not in rat liver. These data show MAO A is oriented on the cytosolic face and MAO B is situated on the surface facing the intermembrane space of the mitochondrial outer membrane in rat liver. The differential mitochondrial outer membrane topology of MAO A and MAO B is relevant to their inhibition by drugs designed to be cardioprotectants or neuroprotectants.     

Evidence for participation of the inner membrane in the import of sulfite oxidase into the intermembrane space of liver mitochondria

Sulfite oxidase, a soluble enzyme in mitochondrial intermembrane space, was synthesized as a precursor protein larger than the authentic enzyme when rat liver RNA was translated $\text{in}\text{vitro}$ using reticulocyte lysate. When the $\text{in}\text{vitro}$ translation products were incubated with isolated rat liver mitochondria, the precursor of sulfite oxidase was converted to the size of the mature enzyme. The $\text{in}\text{vitro}$ processed mature enzyme was no longer susceptible to externally added proteases and was extractable by a hypotonic treatment of the mitochondria, suggesting its location in the intermembrane space. When mitochondria were subfractionated, most of the processing activity was recovered in the mitoplast fraction. The import-processing activity of mitochondria was inhibited by CCCP, oligomycin, or atractyloside in the presence of KCN. These results suggest that the import of sulfite oxidase into mitochondrial intermembrane space requires the participation of inner membrane.     

Effect of sulfite on the energy metabolism of mammalian tissues in correlation to sulfite oxidase activity

Mammalian tissues show significant differences in the activity of sulfite oxidase (EC 1.8.3.1) which detoxifies sulfite by oxidation to sulfate. Lung tissue and phagocytic cells such as alveolar macrophages, peritoneal macrophages, Kupffer cells and granulocytes show very low activities of sulfite oxidase. Liver tissue and hepatocytes, however, exhibit high activities of sulfite oxidase. Lung tissue and macrophages show an almost 100% decrease of the intracellular ATP levels when incubated with 1 mM sulfite at pH 6 for 30 min. In addition, the O₂ consumption of lung tissue is inhibited by 1 mM sulfite at pH 6 by more than 80%. This sulfite-induced decrease of the ATP level and of the O₂ consumption of lung tissue is enhanced between pH 6.0 and pH 7.4 with decreasing pH value of the incubation medium. In contrast, the ATP levels in liver tissue and hepatocytes are not affected by 1 mM sulfite at pH 6. The O₂ consumption of liver tissue and hepatocytes is significantly increased by sulfite due to the high activities of sulfite oxidase. Therefore, the activity of the ‘sulfite-detoxifying enzyme’ sulfite oxidase and the sensitivity of the energy metabolism to sulfite show a reciprocal relationship in the tissues and cells studied.     

Mitochondrial outer membrane permeability change and hypersensitivity to digitonin early in staurosporine-induced apoptosis

We have shown here that the apoptosis inducer staurosporine causes an early decrease in the endogenous respiration rate in intact 143B.TK(-) cells. On the other hand, the activity of cytochrome c oxidase is unchanged for the first 8 h after staurosporine treatment, as determined by oxygen consumption measurements in intact cells. The decrease in the endogenous respiration rate precedes the release of cytochrome c from mitochondria. Moreover, we have ruled out caspases, permeability transition, and protein kinase C inhibition as being responsible for the decrease in respiration rate. Furthermore, overexpression of the gene for Bcl-2 does not prevent the decrease in respiration rate. The last finding suggests that Bcl-2 acts downstream of the perturbation in respiration. The evidence of normal enzymatic activities of complex I and complex III in staurosporine-treated 143B.TK(-) osteosarcoma cells indicates that the cause of the respiration decrease is probably an alteration in the permeability of the outer mitochondrial membrane. Presumably, the voltage-dependent anion channel closes, thereby preventing ADP and oxidizable substrates from being taken up into mitochondria. This interpretation was confirmed by another surprising finding, namely that, in staurosporine-treated 143B.TK(-) cells permeabilized with digitonin at a concentration not affecting the mitochondrial membranes in naive cells, the outer mitochondrial membrane loses its integrity; this leads to a reversal of its impermeability to exogenous substrates. The loss of outer membrane integrity leads also to a massive premature release of cytochrome c from mitochondria. Most significantly, Bcl-2 overexpression prevents the staurosporine-induced hypersensitivity of the outer membrane to digitonin. Our experiments have thus revealed early changes in the outer mitochondrial membrane, which take place long before cytochrome c is released from mitochondria in intact cells.