Altered spectra of hypermutation in DNA repair-deficient mice

Affinity maturation of the humoral immune response is based on the ability of immunoglobulin variable genes to undergo a process of rapid and extensive somatic mutation followed by antigenic selection for antibodies with higher affinity. While the behaviour of this somatic hypermutation phenomenon has been well characterized over the last 20 years, the molecular mechanism responsible for inserting mutations has remained shrouded. To better understand this mechanism, we studied the interplay between hypermutation and other DNA associated activities such as DNA repair. There was no effect on the frequency and pattern of hypermutation in mice deficient for nucleotide excision repair, base excision repair and ataxia-telangiectasia mutated gene repair of double strand breaks. However, variable genes from mice lacking some components of mismatch repair had an increased frequency of tandem mutations and had more mutations of G and C nucleotides. These results suggest that the DNA polymerase(s) involved in the hypermutation pathway produces a unique spectra of mutations, which is then altered by mismatch repair and antigenic selection. We, also describe the differential pattern of expression of some nuclear DNA polymerases in hypermutating versus non-hypermutating B lymphocytes. The rapidly dividing germinal centre B cells expressed DNA polymerases alpha, beta, delta, epsilon and zeta, whereas the resting non-germinal centre cells did not express polymerases alpha or epsilon at detectable levels, although they did express polymerases beta, delta and zeta. The lack of expression of polymerase epsilon in the non-germinal centre cells suggests that this enzyme has a critical role in chromosomal replication but does not participate in DNA repair in these cells.     

DNA polymerase zeta （pol ζ） in higher eukaryotes

Most current knowledge about DNA polymerase zeta （pol ζ） comes from studies of the enzyme in the budding yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, where pol ζ consists of a complex of the catalytic subunit Rev3 with Rev7, which associates with Revl. Most spontaneous and induced mutagenesis in yeast is dependent on these gene products, and yeast pol can mediate translesion DNA synthesis past some adducts in DNA templates. Study of the homologous gene products in higher eukaryotes is in a relatively early stage, but additional functions for the eukaryotic proteins are already apparent. Suppression of vertebrate REV3L function not only reduces induced point mutagenesis but also causes larger-scale genome instability by raising the frequency of spontaneous chromosome translocations. Disruption of Rev3L function is tolerated in Drosophila, Arabidopsis, and in vertebrate cell lines under some conditions, but is incompatible with mouse embryonic development. Functions for REV3L and REV7（MAD2B） in higher eukaryotes have been suggested not only in translesion DNA synthesis but also in some forms of homologous recombination, repair of interstrand DNA crosslinks, somatic hypermutation of immunoglobulin genes and cell-cycle control. This review discusses recent developments in these areas.     

Codon bias and plasticity in immunoglobulins

Immunoglobulin genes experience Darwinian evolution twice. In addition to the germline evolution all genes experience, immunoglobulins are subjected, upon exposure to antigen, to somatic hypermutation. This is accompanied by selection for high affinity to the eliciting antigen and frequently results in a significant increase in the specificity of the responding population. The hypermutation mechanism displays a strong sequence specificity. Thus arises the opportunity to manipulate codon bias in a site-specific manner so as to direct hypermutation to those parts of the gene that encode the antigen-binding portions of the molecule and away from those that encode the structurally conserved regions. This segregation of mutability would clearly be advantageous; it would enhance the generation of potentially useful variants while keeping mutational loss to acceptably low levels. But it is not clear that the advantage gained would be large enough to produce a measurable effect within the background stochasticity of the evolutionary process. I have performed a pair of statistical tests to determine whether site- specific codon bias in human immunoglobulin genes is correlated with the sequence specificity of the somatic mutation mechanism. The sequence specificity of the mutator was determined by analysis of a database of published immunoglobulin intron sequences that had experienced somatic mutation but not selection. The site-specific codon bias was determined by analysis of published sequences of human germline immunoglobulin V genes. Both tests strongly suggest that evolution has acted to enhance the plasticity of immunoglobulin genes under somatic hypermutation.      

Somatic hypermutation and junctional diversification at Ig heavy chain loci in the nurse shark

We estimate there are approximately 15 IgM H chain loci in the nurse shark genome and have characterized one locus. It consists of one V, two D, and one J germline gene segments, and the constant (C) region can be distinguished from all of the others by a unique combination of restriction endonuclease sites in Cmu2. On the basis of these Cmu2 markers, 22 cDNA clones were selected from an epigonal organ cDNA library from the same individual; their C region sequences proved to be the same up to the polyadenylation site. With the identification of the corresponding germline gene segments, CDR3 from shark H chain rearrangements could be analyzed precisely, for the first time. Considerable diversity was generated by trimming and N addition at the three junctions and by varied recombination patterns of the two D gene segments. The cDNA sequences originated from independent rearrangements events, and most carried both single and contiguous substitutions. The 53 point mutations occurred with a bias for transition changes (53%), whereas the 78 tandem substitutions, mostly 2-4 bp long, do not (36%). The nature of the substitution patterns is the same as for mutants from six loci of two nurse shark L chain isotypes, showing that somatic hypermutation events are very similar at both H and L chain genes in this early vertebrate. The cis-regulatory elements targeting somatic hypermutation must have already existed in the ancestral Ig gene, before H and L chain divergence.     

In vivo and in vitro studies of immunoglobulin gene somatic hypermutation

Following antigen encounter, two distinct processes modify immunoglobulin genes. The variable region is diversified by somatic hypermutation while the constant region may be changed by class-switch recombination. Although both genetic events can occur concurrently within germinal centre B cells, there are examples of each occurring independently of the other. Here we compare the contributions of class-switch recombination and somatic hypermutation to the diversification of the serum immunoglobulin repertoire and review evidence that suggests that, despite clear differences, the two processes may share some aspects of their mechanism in common.     

Evolution of Ig DNA sequence to target specific base positions within codons for somatic hypermutation

Ig variable (V) region genes are subjected to a somatic hypermutation process as B lymphocytes participate in immune reactions to protein Ags. Although little is known regarding the mechanism of mutagenesis, a consistent hierarchy of trinucleotide target preferences is evident. Analysis of trinucleotide regional distributions predicted and we now empirically confirm the surprising finding that the framework 2 region of kappa V region genes is highly mutable despite its importance to the structural integrity and function of the Ab molecule. Interestingly, much of this mutability appears to be focused on the third codon position where synonymous substitutions are most likely to occur. We also observed a trend for high predicted mutability for codon positions 1 and 2 in complementarity-determining regions. Consequently, amino acid replacements should occur at a higher rate in complementarity-determining regions than in framework regions due to the distribution and subsequent targeting of microsequences by the mutation mechanism. Our results reveal a subtle tier of V region gene evolution in which DNA sequence has been molded to direct mutations to specific base positions within codons in a manner that minimizes damage and maximizes the benefits of the somatic hypermutation process.     

The multiple shark Ig H chain genes rearrange and hypermutate autonomously

Sharks and skates are representatives of the earliest vertebrates with an immune system based on V(D)J rearrangement. They possess a unique Ig gene organization consisting of 15 to >50 individual IgM loci, each with one VH, two DH, one JH, and one set of constant region exons. The present study attempts to understand how multiple Ig genes are regulated with respect to rearrangement initiation and to targeting during somatic hypermutation. The linkage of three single-copy IgH genes was determined, and single-cell genomic PCR studies in a neonatal animal were used to examine any relationship between relative gene position and likelihood of rearrangement. Our results show that one to three IgH genes are activated independently of linkage or allelic position and the data best fit with a probability model based on the hypothesis that V(D)J rearrangement occurs as a sequence of trials within the B cell. In the neonatal cell set, two closely related IgH, G2A, and G2B, rearranged at similar frequencies, and their membrane forms were expressed at similar levels, like in other young animals. However, older animals displayed a bias in favor of the G2A isotype, which suggests that although rearrangement at G2A and G2B was randomly initiated during primary repertoire generation, the two very similar IgM sequences appear to be differentially expressed with age and exposure to Ag. We performed genomic single-cell PCR on B cells from an immunized individual to study activation-induced cytidine deaminase targeting and found that hypermutation, like V(D)J rearrangement, occurred independently among the many shark IgH.     

Error-prone DNA repair activity during somatic hypermutation in shark B lymphocytes

Sharks are representatives of the earliest vertebrates that possess an immune system utilizing V(D)J recombination to generate Ag receptors. Their Ab repertoire diversity is based in part on a somatic hypermutation process that introduces adjacent nucleotide substitutions of 2-5 bp. We have isolated mutant nonfunctional Ig rearrangements and intronic flank sequences to characterize the nonselected, intrinsic properties of this phenomenon; changes unique to shark were observed. Duplications and deletions were associated with N additions, suggesting participation of a DNA polymerase with some degree of template independence during the repair of DNA breaks initiated by activation-induced cytidine deaminase. Other mutations were consistent with some in vitro activities of mammalian translesion DNA polymerase η: tandem base substitutions, strand slippage, and small insertions/deletions. The nature of substitution patterns shows that DNA lesions at shark Ig genes recruit DNA repair factors with a species-specific repertoire of activities. We speculate that the tandem mutations are introduced by direct sequential misinsertions and that, in shark B cells, the mispairs tend to be extended rather than proofread. Despite extensive changes undergone by some mutants, the physical range of mutational activity remained restricted to VDJ and within the first 2-kb portion of the 6.8-kb J-C intron, perhaps a self-regulating aspect of activation-induced cytidine deaminase action that is conserved in evolution.     

Patterns of Somatic Mutations in Immunoglobulin Variable Genes

The mechanism responsible for somatic mutation in the variable genes of antibodies is unknown and may differ from previously described mechanisms that produce mutation in DNA. We have analyzed 421 somatic mutations from the rearranged immunoglobulin variable genes of mice to determine if the nucleotide substitutions differ from those generated during meiosis and if the presence of nearby direct and inverted repeated sequences could template mutations around the variable gene. The results reveal a difference in the pattern of substitutions obtained from somatic mutations vs. meiotic mutations. An increased frequency of T:A to C:G transitions and a decreased frequency of mutations involving a G in the somatic mutants compared to the meiotic mutants is indicated. This suggests that the mutational processes responsible for somatic mutations in antibody genes differs from that responsible for mutation during meiosis. An analysis of the local DNA sequences revealed many direct repeats and palindromic sequences that were capable of templating some of the known mutations. Although additional factors may be involved in targeting mutations to the variable gene, mistemplating by nearby repeats may provide a mechanism for the enhancement of somatic mutation.     

Emerging links between hypermutation of antibody genes and DNA polymerases

Substantial antibody variability is created when nucleotide substitutions are introduced into immunoglobulin variable genes by a controlled process of hypermutation. Evidence points to a mechanism involving DNA repair events at sites of targeted breaks. In vertebrate cells, there are many recently identified DNA polymerases that inaccurately copy templates. Some of these are candidates for enzymes that introduce base changes during hypermutation. Recent research has focused on possible roles for DNA polymerases zeta (POLZ), eta (POLH), iota (POLI), and mu (POLM) in the process.     

Somatic hypermutation and the three R's: repair, replication and recombination

Somatic hypermutation introduces single base changes into the rearranged variable (V) regions of antigen activated B cells at a rate of approximately 1 mutation per kilobase per generation. This is nearly a million-fold higher than the typical mutation rate in a mammalian somatic cell. Rampant mutation at this level could have a devastating effect, but somatic hypermutation is accurately targeted and tightly regulated. Here, we provide an overview of immunoglobulin gene somatic hypermutation; discuss mechanisms of mutation in model organisms that may be relevant to the hypermutation mechanism; and review recent advances toward understanding the possible role(s) of DNA repair, replication, and recombination in this fascinating process.     

A/T-targeted somatic hypermutation: critique of the mainstream model

The "affinity maturation" of the humoral immune response is driven by antigen-activated somatic hypermutation (SHM) of the genes that encode antibody variable regions and the subsequent antigenic selection of mutant clones. The molecular mechanism of SHM is yet to be completely elucidated. SHM affects cytosine-guanine (C/G) and adenine-thymine (A/T) pairs with approximately equal frequency in vivo. The proposition that error-prone DNA-dependent DNA synthesis explains A/T-targeted hypermutagenesis seems to have mainstream support within the hypermutation research community at present. A major feature of SHM in vivo is that C/G hypermutation is strand unbiased, whereas A/T hypermutation is strand biased. We show that the "DNA-based polymerase error" model of A/T-targeted hypermutagenesis does not explain this important aspect of SHM.     

Mutation pattern of immunoglobulin transgenes is compatible with a model of somatic hypermutation in which targeting of the mutator is linked to the direction of DNA replication.

We have previously demonstrated that B lymphocyte specific somatic mutations are introduced into the variable regions of immunoglobulin kappa transgenes in two independent transgenic mouse lines. The frequency, distribution and nature of these mutations strongly suggest that they arose as a result of the process of somatic hypermutation, which is responsible, in part, for affinity maturation during an immune response. Unexpectedly, in these multiple copy transgenic lines, many of the transgene copies showed no evidence of somatic mutation. This paradox was addressed by determining the sequence of each transgene copy in several B cell hybridomas derived from a mouse line carrying three copies of the kappa transgene. It was found that the somatic hypermutation process in different B cells from the same mouse preferentially targets one, but not the same, transgene copy. We present a model, based on the pattern of this targeting, which links somatic hypermutation to the orientation of the Ig gene relative to the direction of DNA replication.     

Comprehensive characterization of immunoglobulin gene rearrangements in patients with chronic lymphocytic leukaemia

Previous studies have suggested a geographical pattern of immunoglobulin rearrangement in chronic lymphocytic leukaemia (CLL), which could be as a result of a genetic background or an environmental antigen. However, the characteristics of Ig rearrangements in the population from the South of France have not yet been established. Here, we studied CLL B‐cell repertoire and mutational pattern in a Southern French cohort of patients using an in‐house protocol for whole sequencing of the rearranged immunoglobulin heavy‐chain genes. Described biased usage of variable, diversity and joining genes between the mutated and unmutated groups was found in our population. However, variable gene frequencies are more in accordance with those observed in the Mediterranean patients. We found that the third complementary‐determining region (CDR) length was higher in unmutated sequences, because of bias in the diversity and joining genes usage and not due to the N diversity. Mutations found in CLL followed the features of canonical somatic hypermutation mechanism: preference of targeting for activation‐induced cytidine deaminase and polymerase motifs, base change bias for transitions and more replacement mutations occurring in CDRs than in framework regions. Surprisingly, localization of activation‐induced cytidine deaminase motifs onto the variable gene showed a preference for framework regions. The study of the characteristics at the age of diagnosis showed no difference in clinical outcome, but suggested a tendency of increased replacement and transition‐over‐transversion mutations and a longer third CDR length in older patients.     

Immune system learning and memory quantified by graphical analysis of B-lymphocyte phylogenetic trees

The immune system learns from its encounters with pathogens and memorizes its experiences. One of the mechanisms it uses for this purpose is the intra-individual evolution of antigen receptors on B lymphocytes, achieved via hypermutation and selection of antigen receptor variable region genes during an immune response. We have developed a novel method for analyzing the graphical properties of phylogenetic trees of receptor genes which have been mutated and selected during an immune response. In the study presented here, we address the artifacts introduced by experimental methods of cell collection for DNA analysis, the meaning of each parameter measured on the tree graphs, and the differences between the dynamics of the humoral immune response in different lymphoid tissues.