The distribution of risk and density-dependent mortality in the galls of Eurosta solidaginis, the goldenrod gall fly

ABSTRACT.

• 1 This paper explores the net effect of a suite of mortality factors on a sedentary prey, the larvae of the goldenrod gall fly, Eurosta solidaginis Fitch (Diptera: Tephritidae).
• 2 Mortality is caused by unknown factors early in larval development, two species of parasitoid wasp (Hymenoptera: Eurytomidae), an inquiline beetle larva (Coleoptera: Mordellidae), and during the winter months downy woodpeckers Picoides pubescens (L.).
• 3 Distribution of mortality among galls relative to prey (gall) distribution was measured and discussed with respect to the distribution of relative risk of predation.
• 4 Galls are by and large contagiously distributed among quadrats, and mortality is distributed in a comparable pattern to that of galls.
• 5 The pattern of mortality on Eurosta larvae is neither density-dependent nor aggregated independently of gall distribution. Persistence in the system is probably a result of a combination of other factors such as adult mortality and early larval death which may have intergenerational density-dependent effects, and the linkage of locally unstable sub-populations via migration.

     

The influence of host plant variation and intraspecific competition on oviposition preference and offspring performance in the host races of Eurosta solidaginis

1. A series of experiments was conducted to measure the impact of plant genotype, plant growth rate, and intraspecific competition on the oviposition preference and offspring performance of the host races of Eurosta solidaginis (Diptera: Tephritidae), a fly that forms galls on Solidago altissima and Solidago gigantea (Asteraceae). Previous research has shown that both host races prefer to oviposit on their own host plant where survival is much higher than on the alternate host plant. In this study, neither host race showed any relationship between oviposition preference and offspring performance in choosing among plants of their natal host species. 2. The larval survival of both host races differed among plant genotypes when each host race oviposited on its natal host species. In one experiment, altissima host race females showed a preference among plant genotypes that was not correlated with offspring performance on those genotypes. In all other experiments, neither the altissima nor gigantea host race demonstrated a preference for specific host plant genotypes. 3. Eurosta solidaginis had a preference for ovipositing on rapidly growing ramets in all experiments, however larval survival was not correlated with ramet growth rate at the time of oviposition. 4. Eurosta solidaginis suffered high mortality from intraspecific competition in the early larval stage. There was little evidence, however, that females avoided ovipositing on ramets that had been attacked previously. This led to an aggregated distribution of eggs among ramets and strong intraspecific competition. 5. There was no interaction among plant genotype, plant growth rate, or intraspecific competition in determining oviposition preference or offspring performance.     

The effects of temperature and season on the O2 consumption of third-instar larvae of the goldenrod gall fly (Eurosta solidaginis)

Abstract. Third-instar larvae of the goldenrod gall fly ( Eurosta solidaginis Fitch) live inside ball galls on goldenrod plants from summer to the following spring.Because galls are highly exposed to the weather, larvae experience substantial variations in body temperature.This study documents the oxygen consumption of gall fly larvae with regard to the effects of ambient temperature, seasonal conditioning, and prior exposure to subzero temperature.The body mass of larvae doubles between the late summer and the autumn; it subsequently undergoes a modest decline by early winter.The O₂, consumption of field-acclimatized larvae increases with ambient temperature, especially between 0 and 10°C (Q₁₀= 2.6-3.4).The thermal sensitivity of metabolism declines at higher ambient temperatures, most notably during the autumn/early winter.After exposure to 15°C for 1 week, autumn and early winter larvae maintain much lower rates of O₂ consumption than do late summer specimens.Prior exposure to -5°C for 24 h did not influence the O₂ consumption of larvae.Low thermal sensitivity of O₂ consumption, especially at higher ambient temperatures, is an energy-sparing mechanism during seasonal inactivity.Indeed, the persistence of this metabolic pattern in larvae exposed to 15°C suggests that they have entered a state of diapause.     

Sequential radiation of unrelated organisms: the gall fly Eurosta solidaginis and the tumbling flower beetle Mordellistena convicta

Host shifts and the formation of insect-host races are likely common processes in the speciation of herbivorous insects. The interactions of goldenrods Solidago (Compositae), the gall fly Eurosta solidaginis (Diptera: Tephritidae) and the beetle Mordellistena convicta (Coleoptera: Mordellidae) provide behavioural, ecological and genetic evidence of host races that may represent incipient species forming via sympatric speciation. We summarize evidence for Eurosta host races and show that M. convicta has radiated from goldenrod stems to Eurosta galls to form host-part races and, having exploited the galler's host shift, has begun to differentiate into host races within galls. Thus, host-race formation has occurred in two interacting, but unrelated organisms representing two trophic levels, resulting in 'sequential radiation' (escalation of biodiversity up the trophic system). Distributions of host races and their behavioural isolating mechanisms suggest sympatric differentiation. Such differentiation suggests host-race formation and subsequent speciation may be an important source of biodiversity.     

Gall insects can avoid and alter indirect plant defenses

Parasitic species can dramatically alter host traits. Some of these parasite-induced changes can be considered adaptive manipulations that benefit the parasites. Gall-inducing insects are parasites well known for their ability to alter host-plant morphology and physiology, including the distribution of plant defensive compounds. Here it was investigated whether gall-inducing species alter indirect plant defenses, involving the release of volatile compounds that are attractive to foraging natural enemies. Using field and factorial laboratory experiments, volatile production by goldenrod (Solidago altissima) plants was examined in response to attack by two gall-inducing species, the tephritid fly Eurosta solidaginis and the gelechiid moth Gnorimoschema gallaesolidaginis, as well as the meadow spittlebug, Philaenus spumarius, and the generalist caterpillar Heliothis virescens. Heliothis virescens elicited strong indirect defensive responses from S. altissima, but the gall-inducing species and spittlebugs did not. More significantly, infestation by E. solidaginis appeared to suppress volatile responses to subsequent attack by the generalist caterpillar. The extensive control that E. solidaginis apparently exerts over host-plant defense responses may reduce the predation risk for the gall inducer and the subsequent herbivore, and could influence community-level dynamics, including the distribution of herbivorous insect species associated with S. altissima parasitized by E. solidaginis.     

Host‐race formation: promoted by phenology,constrained by heritability

Host‐race formation is promoted by genetic trade‐offs in the ability of herbivores to use alternate hosts, including trade‐offs due to differential timing of host‐plant availability. We examined the role of phenology in limiting host‐plant use in the goldenrod gall fly (Eurosta solidaginis) by determining: (1) whether phenology limits alternate host use, leading to a trade‐off that could cause divergent selection on Eurosta emergence time and (2) whether Eurosta has the genetic capacity to respond to such selection in the face of existing environmental variation. Experiments demonstrated that oviposition and gall induction on the alternate host, Solidago canadensis, were the highest on young plants, whereas the highest levels of gall induction on the normal host, Solidago gigantea, occurred on intermediate‐age plants. These findings indicate a phenological trade‐off for host‐plant use that sets up the possibility of divergent selection on emergence time. Heritability, estimated by parent–offspring regression, indicated that host‐race formation is impeded by the amount of genetic variation, relative to environmental, for emergence time.     

Temperature acclimation and seasonal responses by enzymes in cold-hardy gall insects

Changes in the activity of over 20 enzymes of intermediary metabolism in 15°C or ?4°C acclimated goldenrod gall moth (Epiblema scudderiana) and gall fly (Eurosta solidaginis) larvae were measured. Increased activities of glyco-genolytic and hexose monophosphate shunt enzymes in cold-acclimated Epiblema scudderiana suggest a role for coarse control in the conversion of glycogen reserves into glycerol cryoprotectant synthesis. In Eurosta solidaginis, high glycogen phosphorylase activity with decreased activities of glycolytic enzymes may account in part for the temperature-dependent switch from glycerol to sorbitol synthesis in these larvae upon cold acclimation. Isoelectric focusing analyses of five enzymes in overwintering Epiblema scudderiana revealed transient mid-winter changes in the isoelectric points of phosphofructokinase and pyruvate kinase, suggesting seasonal changes in the phosphorylation state of these enzymes. A distinct developmental pattern of aldolase isozymes suggests a role for a new isozyme during overwintering or upon spring emergence. Regulation of metabolism by changes in enzyme activities is indicated for both larvae. © 1995 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

板栗芽内化学物质与抗栗瘿蜂的关系

测定了不同栗瘿蜂抗性的板栗芽内化学物质。结果表明:栗芽内含水量、总糖、还原糖、蛋白质、花色素甙、邻苯二酚分别与栗树虫瘿百分率有明显的负相关性;氨基酸、淀粉、类黄酮、没食子酸含量与栗树受害率间无明显相关性。     

The role of sesquiterpene lactones and phenolics in the chemical defence of the chicory plant

Amounts of the sesquiterpene lactones and the major phenolics were determined in the chicory plant at different times during the growing season. The levels of the sesquiterpene lactones (lactucin, lactupicrin and 8-deoxylactucin) and the hydroxycoumarin cichoriin were found to be highest in the most actively growing regions of the plant. In two-choice and no-choice feeding experiments with borosilicate discs, 8-deoxylactucin, lactupicrin and cichoriin significantly reduced feeding of Schistocerca gregaria at levels comparable to those present in the plant. Cichoriin was still significantly antifeedant at 0.006% dry wt, while aesculin, aesculetin and the caffeic acid ester, chicoric acid were inactive. We conclude that the three sesquiterpene lactones secreted in the latex provide a significant barrier to herbivory in chicory, although the phenolics and notably cichoriin also protect the plant from insect feeding.     

The influence of oviposition phenology on survival in host races of Eurosta solidaginis

Phenological differences between host plants can contribute to allochronic isolation of host races of phytophagous insects. Host races of the gallmaking fly, Eurosta solidaginis, that live on different species of goldenrod (Solidago altissima and S. gigantea) exhibit different emergence phenologies. These differences could result from adaptation to corresponding phenological differences between the hosts in periods of optimal suitability for gall formation and survival to adulthood. In order to test this, some flies of each host race were allowed to emerge naturally while the emergence times of others were manipulated to correspond to the emergence and oviposition periods of the other host race. Percent gall formation and survival to adulthood were examined for three oviposition periods: the peak time of emergence and oviposition of the earlier-emerging host race (that from S. gigantea), that of the later-emerging host race (that from S. altissima), and a week after the peak emergence of the host race from S. altissima. Flies of both host races were allowed to ovipuncture plants of the appropriate species during each of these periods. Plant relative growth rates were measured during each of these periods. The experiment was repeated twice over a two-year period. Relative growth rates of both host species were highest during the earliest oviposition period (the period during which the host race from S. gigantea normally emerges). Percent gall formation was significantly correlated with plant relative growth rate, but the coefficient of determination was low. In both years of the study, percent gall formation of both host races was highest during the earliest oviposition period (the period during which the host race from S. gigantea normally oviposits). Likewise, percent survival to adulthood in both host races was highest during the earliest oviposition period. There was no significant effect of oviposition period on the percent of larval death due to parasitism by Eurytoma gigantea or predation by Mordellistena unicolor. These results suggest that the host race from S. altissima does not emerge at the time that its host is optimally suited for gall formation or survival to adulthood. Therefore, differences in emergence phenologies do not appear to be due to corresponding phenological differences between the host species in suitability for gall formation or survival to adulthood.     

The pattern,rate, and range of within‐patch movement of a stem‐galling fly

1. Information on the movement of insects is critical to understanding the spatial spread, dynamics, and genetic structure of their populations, as well as their interactions with other species. With this in mind, the movement behaviour of the stem‐galling fly Eurosta solidaginis Fitch (Diptera: Tephritidae) was investigated. 2. Fluorescent‐marked adults were released at a single location within pure patches of the host plant, tall goldenrod Solidago altissima, and their distributions censused repeatedly throughout the day. 3. Following their release, male and female flies redistributed themselves in a manner that was well described by a simple‐diffusion model. The diffusion rate was independent of fly density and time since flies were released. 4. Female flies dispersed at a significantly faster rate, and therefore farther on average, than males. Based on the diffusion model, it was estimated that at 2.5–3.0 h post release, males and females had a median dispersal distance of only 2.0 and 2.5 m respectively. Furthermore, 95% of the males were estimated to have dispersed no more than 5.9 m, and females no more than 6.4 m. 5. Post‐release censuses suggested that flies were most active during mid morning, disappeared from the site at a rate of 10–15% per hour (most likely due to mortality), and survived for less than 2 days. Based on the rate of spread, diel activity, and liberal estimates of longevity in the field, 50% of the ovipositing females were predicted to have had a maximum lifetime range of movement within a patch of hosts of ≤ 51 m (95% were expected to have been limited to ≤ 130 m). 6. These data are used to assess whether the absence of a positive correlation between host‐plant preference and offspring performance in this system could be due to the limited scale of dispersal of this species relative to the spatial scale at which its oviposition behaviour has been studied.     

Variation in selection pressures on the goldenrod gall fly and the competitive interactions of its natural enemies

Summary Larvae of the tephritid fly Eurosta solidaginis induce ball-shaped galls on the stem of tall goldenrod, Solidago altissima. Survival probability depends on gall size; in small galls the larva is vulnerable to parasitoid oviposition, whereas larvae in large galls are more frequently eaten by avian predators. Fly populations from 20 natural old fields in central Pennsylvania were monitored in 1983 and 1984 to examine the distribution of the selection intensity imposed by natural enemies, the parasitoids Eurytoma gigantea and E. obtusiventris, the inquiline Mordellistena unicolor, and the predatory birds Dendrocopus pubescens and Parus atricapillus. Mordellistena and E. obtusiventris are able to attack galls of all diameters while E. gigantea and the predatory birds preferentially assaulted small and large diameter galls, respectively. Eurosta in intermediate sized galls had the highest survivorship, hence selection had a stabilizing component. However, parasitoid attack was more frequent than bird attack, and the two did not exactly balance, thus there was also a directional component. The mean directional selection intensity on gall size was 0.21 standard deviations of the mean, indicating that larger gall size was favored. Interactions among the insect members of the Eurosta natural enemy guild are complex and frequent.     

Effects of manipulation of plant carbon nutrient balance on tall goldenrod resistance to a gallmaking herbivore

Summary Ramets from six Solidago altissima clones of known resistance to the stem gallmaker Eurosta solidaginis were grown with and without supplemental nutrients. In a greenhouse experiment, mated female Eurosta were allowed to oviposit in ramets that were subsequently grown through flowering and then harvested to determine biomass allocation. Supplemental nutrients increased plant biomass but did not affect resistance to this gallmaking herbivore. This result does not conform to the plant carbon/nutrient balance hypothesis which predicts that enhanced mineral nutrition will indirectly cause a reduction in carbon-based defensive chemistry. Our results indicate a strong genetic basis to ball gallmaker resistance since modification of host phenotype did not influence susceptibility. We suggest that evaluating the degree of genotypic or environmental control of plant resistance will be especially helpful in clarifying the patterns of defensive chemical responses.     

The effects of drought on the<Emphasis Type=Italic> Solidago altissima</Emphasis>-<Emphasis Type=Italic>Eurosta solidaginis</Emphasis>-natural enemy complex: population dynamics,local extirpations,and measures of selection intensity on gall size

Environmental catastrophes, such as severe drought, can reduce host-plant quality and/or abundance, which in turn decrease levels of herbivore populations. Such changes in herbivore populations affect populations of their natural enemies. As part of a long-term field experiment (1983–1991), galls of Eurosta solidaginis from 16 fields in central Pennsylvania were systematically collected from goldenrod ramets. Galls were dissected to compare the occurrence of E. solidaginis mortality caused by its natural enemies in 2 drought years (1988, 1991) with 5 pre-drought years (1983–1987) and 2 post-drought years (1989–1990). Gall diameters were significantly smaller in both drought years and early larval death significantly decreased E. solidaginis survivorship in the first drought year. Of the natural enemies, the parasitoid wasp Eurytoma gigantea caused significant selection for larger gall size in all pre-drought years, the 1991 drought, and both post-drought years, due to its differential attack of smaller galls. In spite of drought-induced small gall size in 1988, there was negligible selection on gall size by natural enemies. However, populations of E. solidaginis did suffer local extirpations at nine of the 16 fields during the first drought year and population recoveries of the gall inducer and natural enemies varied among fields in the post-drought years. As a consequence of reduced herbivore abundance in drought and post-drought years, some natural-enemy populations were absent. Drought therefore drastically reduced the abundance of E. solidaginis and natural enemies resulting in slow recoveries to pre-drought numbers. Received: 16 April 1998 / Accepted: 4 August 1998     

Taxonomy, attack strategies and host relations in flowerhead Tephritidae: a review

Abstract. 1. Host relations of Palaearctic flowerhead-inhabiting tephritids (Diptera: Tephritidae) are reviewed in terms of the interaction between type of attack strategy and flowerhead size.
2. Three types of attack strategy are recognized, each associated with a particular phase of Compositae flowerhead development. These strategies are characteristic of a tribe or subfamily, viz the Tephritini (Tephritinae), Terelliini (Tephritinae) and Myopitinae.
3. Tephritini species show the most generalized feeding method, and this enables them to attack both large and very small flowerheads. In contrast, the more specialized requirements of members of the Terelliini and Myopitinae apparently restricts these groups to plant taxa with large flowerheads. As a result, over the whole range of Compositae flowerhead sizes, there exists a positive relationship between flowerhead size and the diversity of associated tephritids.
4. The occurrence of stem-feeding tephritids, and differences between a coevolutionary and functional (colonization) explanation for tephritid host-relations are discussed.     

Phytohormones in the formation of crown gall tumors

Crown gall tumors were initiated in a variety of plant species by infection with Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain B6 and the concomitant changes in the tissue levels of phytohormones, mainly indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) and cytokinins, were analyzed. A comparison was made of these hormones with those produced by virulent and avirulent strains of the bacterium in liquid culture and with those of bacteria-free crown gall callus cultures. Specific radioimmunoassays were employed for hormone determinations. An assay for the quantitation of femto-mol amounts of isopentenyladenosine and related cytokinins was newly developed and is described in detail. The results can be summarized as follows: Virulence in strain B 6 is associated with the ability to release trans-zeatin and increased amounts of IAA into the surrounding environment. In many, but not all plants analyzed, the development of crown gall tumors is also associated with a sharp rise in the levels of trans-zeatin-type zytokinins and IAA (e.g., Euphorbia lathyris, Catharanthus roseus). Crown gall calli growing on hormone-free media varied greatly in their cytokinin levels. In a culture of Nicotiana tabacum, both trans-zeatin and isopentenyladenine or related cytokinins were not detected. Thus, tumor growth cannot be explained on the basis of elevated levels of IAA and/or cytokinins alone.Abbreviations ABA abscisic acid - GC-MS gas chromatography-mass spectroscopy - HPLC high pressure liquid chromatography - IAA indole-3-acetic acid - RIA radioimmunoassay - TLC thin layer chromatography Part 19 in the series Use of immunoassay in plant science     

Plant tolerance and resistance in food webs: community-level predictions and evolutionary implications

While evolutionary ecologists emphasize different ways in which plants can evolutionarily respond to herbivory, such as resistance or tolerance, community ecology has lagged in its understanding of how these different plant traits can influence interactions, abundance, composition, and diversity within more complex food webs. In this paper, we present a series of models comparing community level outcomes when plants either resist or tolerate herbivory. We show that resistance and tolerance can lead to very different outcomes. A particularly important result is that resistant species should often coexist locally with other, less resistant competitors, whereas tolerant species should not be able to coexist locally with less tolerant competitors, although priority effects allow them to coexist regionally. We also use these models to suggest some insights into the evolution of these traits within more complex communities. We emphasize how understanding the differential effects of plant tolerance and resistance in food webs provides greater appreciation of a variety of empirical patterns that heretofore have appeared enigmatic. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Plant water stress and gall formation (Cecidomyiidae: Asphondylia spp.) on creosote bush

Abstract. 1. Populations of creosote bush ( Larrea tridentata (DC) Coville), were studied in Arizona to determine whether associated gallformers (Cecidomyiidae: Asphondylia spp.) were more abundant on water-stressed or nonstressed plants. Gall densities were measured along a steep elevational gradient that extended from mesic, higher elevations to lower elevations in the desert; and in the Grand Canyon where severely water-stressed and relatively unstressed plants occurred adjacently. At the Grand Canyon site, the responses of creosote bush to water stress were also studied.
2. The number and densities of Asphondylia species increased both at lower elevations and locally on water-stressed plants in the Grand Canyon, indicating that climatic and local conditions influence gallformer abundance in the same way.
3. Five of the eight Asphondylia species studied at the Grand Canyon site were more abundant on stressed plants, two species were more abundant on nonstressed plants and one species showed no preference for either plant type.
4. Densities of most species on stressed plants were positively correlated with the number of meristematic terminals per branch, which were more numerous on stressed plants, due to a bushier architecture. Flower gallformers were more abundant on nonstressed plants, which produced more flowers. Gall densities did not correlate with chemistry measurements, although these parameters also varied with level of stress.
5. These results suggest that gallforming species respond variably to plant stress, even within a closely-related lineage, and that there are effects of stress on plants, including architectural changes, that may be more important to herbivores than biochemical effects emphasized by White (1984) and others.