Effect of freezing and cold storage on phospholipids in developing soybean cotyledons

Freezing of plant tissue adversely affects lipid composition. Immature soybean cotyledons (Glycine max L. Merr.) var. “Harosoy 63” were frozen with liquid N₂, dry ice, or stored in a freezer (−20 C) before lipid extraction. The effects of freezing temperature, thawing rate, and cold storage on the lipid composition of frozen tissue revealed significantly higher levels of phosphatidic acid, and diminished levels of phosphatidylcholine, phosphatidylethanolamine, and N-acylphosphatidylethanolamine from the control. Regardless of freezing temperature, phosphatidic acid levels increased from 4.7 mole% to nearly 50 mole% of the total phospholipid when frozen tissues were stored 10 days at −20 C. During the same period, N-acylphosphatidylethanolamine decreased from 54.1 mole% to 6.6 mole% phospholipid. At least 8 mole% of the phosphatidic acid increase occurred during slow thawing of the frozen tissues. In autoclaved samples, phosphatidic acid, phosphatidylcholine, phosphatidylethanolamine, and N-acylphosphatidylethanolamine levels were not different from the control. Labeling of the lipid-glycerol with ³H, and fatty acids with ¹⁴C, demonstrated the degradation product was primarily phosphatidic acid. Apparently enzymic destruction of the phospholipids occurred during freezing, cold storage, and thawing.     

Freezing of water in red-osier dogwood stems in relation to cold hardiness

Studies of stem water in red-osier dogwood (Cornus stolonifera Michx.) using nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy indicated that most freezing occurs at temperatures above −30 C in cold-hardy and tender stems. Hardy and tender stems had about the same amount of unfrozen water at −40 C (0.28 gram of water per gram dry weight). When hardy stems were slowly cooled below −20 C, the temperature below which little additional freezing occurs, they survived direct immersion in liquid N₂ (−196 C). Fully hardy samples not slowly precooled to at least −15 C did not survive direct immersion in liquid N₂. The results support the hypothesis that cooling rate is an unimportant factor in tissue survival at and below temperatures where there is little freezable water.     

Studies on Freezing Injury in Plant Cells : II. Protein and Lipid Changes in the Plasma Membranes of Jerusalem Artichoke Tubers during a Lethal Freezing in Vivo

Plasma membranes were isolated from both unfrozen and frozen tissues of Jerusalem artichoke tubers (Helianthus tuberosus L.) in high purity utilizing an aqueous two-polymer phase partition system. Although the recovery of the plasma membranes was decreased significantly by freezing of tissues even at the nonlethal temperature (−5°C), the isolated plasma membrane samples were considered to be representative of the plasma membranes in situ. Freezing of the tissues at sublethal temperatures resulted in marked changes in the chemical composition of the plasma membrane. Those are losses of sterols and phosphatidylethanolamine from the plasma membranes, and a change of specific proteins with relatively high molecular weights into low molecular weight peptides. These specific proteins were designated as frost susceptible proteins. The properties of the plasma membrane ATPase seem to be not affected so much by the in vivo freezing of cells. However, inhibition of the plasma membrane ATPase by N,N′-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide (DCCD) was relatively low before and after freezing in vivo at the nonlethal temperature at −5°C, but was markedly enhanced by freezing in vivo at sublethal temperatures below −10°C. From the results, it is assumed either that the enzyme molecule was partially modified, especially at the presumed DCCD binding sites or that the DCCD had become more accessible to the enzyme as a result of increased permeability of the plasma membranes. These observed changes are discussed in connection with the mechanism of cell injury.     

Studies of Frost Hardiness in Woody Plants. II. Effect of Temperature on Hardening

The effect of temperature on hardening was studied at temperatures ranging from 0° to −20° using twigs of willow and poplar. In October and in late April when the twigs are not very frost hardy, hardening at 0° produced a considerable increase in their frost hardiness, although the effectiveness of hardening at 0° decreased with a decrease in the environmental temperature. In twigs which could withstand continuous freezing without injury, hardening at −3° to −5° was most effective in increasing the frost hardiness of the twigs. Below −20°, only negligible increase was observed either in frost hardiness or sugar content.

The rate of starch to sugar conversion differed remarkably in different twig tissues. The starch in xylem was more slowly converted to sugar than that in the cortex. The optimum temperature for converting starch into sugar during frost hardening was also found to be −3° to −5°. In addition, the greater the effectiveness of the hardening treatment, the greater the rate of conversion from starch to sugar. The frost hardiness of a twig is closely related to the sugar content of the twig, especially in the xylem.

     

Relationship between Thermal Transitions and Freezing Injury in Pea and Soybean Seeds

In an attempt to correlate freezable water with freezing injury, the thermal behavior of pea (Pisum sativum L.) and soybean (Glycine max L. Merr) seed parts at different moisture contents were compared with survival of the seeds when exposed to low temperatures. Thermal transitions between −150 and 10°C were studied using differential scanning calorimetry. In pea, reduction of germinability, after exposure of seeds to temperatures between − 18 and − 180°C, occurred at a constant moisture content (about 0.33 gram H₂O/gram dry weight) regardless of the temperature; this moisture level was above that at which freezable water was first detectable by differential scanning calorimetry (0.26 gram H₂O/gram dry weight). In contrast, damage to soybean seeds was observed at progressively lower moisture contents (from 0.33 to 0.20 gram H₂O/gram dry weight) when the temperature was decreased from −18°C to −50°C. At −18 and −30°C, moisture contents at which damage to soybean seeds was evident were above that at which freezable water was first detectable (0.23 gram H₂O/gram dry weight). However, at −50, −80, and −180°C, damage was evident even when freezable water was not detectable. The data suggest that, while the quantity of water is important in the expression of freezing injury, the presence of freezable water does not account for the damage.     

Relationship between Freezing Tolerance of Root-Tip Cells and Cold Stability of Microtubules in Rye (Secale cereale L. cv Puma)

The response of cortical microtubules to low temperature and freezing was assessed for root tips of cold-acclimated and non-acclimated winter rye (Secale cereale L. cv Puma) seedlings using indirect immunofluorescence microscopy with antitubulin antibodies. Roots cooled to 0 or −3°C were fixed for immunofluorescence microscopy at these temperatures or after an additional hour at 4°C. Typical arrays of cortical microtubules were present in root-tip cells of seedlings exposed to the cold-acclimation treatment of 4°C for 2 days. Microtubules in these cold-acclimated cells were more easily depolymerized by a 0°C treatment than microtubules in root-tip cells of nonacclimated, 22°C-grown seedlings. Microtubules were still present in some cells of both nonacclimated and cold-acclimated roots at 0 and −3°C; however, the number of microtubules in these cells was lower than in controls. Microtubules remaining during the −3°C freeze were shorter than microtubules in unfrozen control cells. Repolymerization of microtubules after both the 0 and −3°C treatments occurred within 1 h. Root tips of nonacclimated seedlings had an LT-50 of −9°C. Cold acclimation lowered this value to −14°C. Treatment of 22°C-grown seedlings for 24 h with the microtubule-stabilizing drug taxol caused a decrease in the freezing tolerance of root tips, indicated by a LT-50 of −3°C. Treatment with D-secotaxol, an analog of taxol that was less effective in stabilizing microtubules, did not alter the freezing tolerance. We interpret these data to indicate that a degree of depolymerization of microtubules is necessary for realization of maximum freezing tolerance in root-tip cells of rye.     

High Survivability of Cheese Whey-Grown Rhizobium meliloti Cells upon Exposure to Physical Stress

Whey, a by-product of the dairy industry, has been found to protect the rhizobia cells during freezing and thawing. Cells of rhizobia grown on whey sustained freezing better at −18°C than did cells grown on mannitol or sucrose. Suspensions of cells grown on whey or mannitol that were suspended in whey performed equally well at −18 and −80°C, with 94 and 100% survival, respectively. Whey-grown rhizobia in pellets withstood desiccation better than did their mannitol-grown equivalents. Rhizobia that were grown on whey and then inoculated onto commercial peat showed a survival rate of 100% after 23 weeks at −4°C. Whey-grown cells in peat performed better at various temperatures during storage, even when they were exposed to desiccation, than did mannitol-grown cells in peat. Whey, therefore, offers interesting possibilities as a Rhizobium protectant for the inoculum industry.     

Why is intracellular ice lethal? A microscopical study showing evidence of programmed cell death in cryo-exposed embryonic axes of recalcitrant seeds of Acer saccharinum

Background and Aims Conservation of the genetic diversity afforded by recalcitrant seeds is achieved by cryopreservation, in which excised embryonic axes (or, where possible, embryos) are treated and stored at temperatures lower than −180 °C using liquid nitrogen. It has previously been shown that intracellular ice forms in rapidly cooled embryonic axes of Acer saccharinum (silver maple) but this is not necessarily lethal when ice crystals are small. This study seeks to understand the nature and extent of damage from intracellular ice, and the course of recovery and regrowth in surviving tissues.Methods Embryonic axes of A. saccharinum, not subjected to dehydration or cryoprotection treatments (water content was 1·9 g H₂O g⁻¹ dry mass), were cooled to liquid nitrogen temperatures using two methods: plunging into nitrogen slush to achieve a cooling rate of 97 °C s⁻¹ or programmed cooling at 3·3 °C s⁻¹. Samples were thawed rapidly (177 °C s⁻¹) and cell structure was examined microscopically immediately, and at intervals up to 72 h in vitro. Survival was assessed after 4 weeks in vitro. Axes were processed conventionally for optical microscopy and ultrastructural examination.Key Results Immediately following thaw after cryogenic exposure, cells from axes did not show signs of damage at an ultrastructural level. Signs that cells had been damaged were apparent after several hours of in vitro culture and appeared as autophagic decomposition. In surviving tissues, dead cells were sloughed off and pockets of living cells were the origin of regrowth. In roots, regrowth occurred from the ground meristem and procambium, not the distal meristem, which became lethally damaged. Regrowth of shoots occurred from isolated pockets of surviving cells of peripheral and pith meristems. The size of these pockets may determine the possibility for, the extent of and the vigour of regrowth.Conclusions Autophagic degradation and ultimately autolysis of cells following cryo-exposure and formation of small (0·2–0·4 µm) intracellular ice crystals challenges current ideas that ice causes immediate physical damage to cells. Instead, freezing stress may induce a signal for programmed cell death (PCD). Cells that form more ice crystals during cooling have faster PCD responses.     

Osmotic factors of dehardening in cornus Florida L

The killing temperature for cortical cells from the flowering dogwood changes abruptly from −25 C to −15 C during dehardening. Cell sap concentration, minimum critical cell volume, and osmotically inactive cell volume show a progressive change during dehardening, but only cell sap concentration is correlated directly with the killing temperature, showing the same step change. There is a limit to the extent to which hardy dogwood cells can be osmotically reduced in volume. Beyond this limiting volume, the extracellular osmotically can be increased without further volume reduction. Ultimately the cell succumbs, presumably to an osmotic pressure gradient. Nonhardy cells do not exhibit this resistance to shrinkage. The ability to resist volume reduction is probably a crucial factor in the freezing resistance of dogwood cortical cells.     

Comparison of tissue preparation methods for assay of nicotinamide coenzymes

To prepare tissues for analysis of NAD⁺, NADH, NADP⁺, and NADPH, common practice is to freeze samples in liquid nitrogen, often followed by freeze-drying, before extraction in HCl or NaOH. With cucumber (Cucumis sativus L.) cotyledons, prefreezing in liquid nitrogen or slower freezing to −20°C yielded substantially lower values for NADH and NADPH than obtained from samples homogenized immediately in acid or base. Freeze-drying after freezing in liquid nitrogen generally caused even lower values of those coenzymes. We suggest that direct extraction is more likely to yield accurate results with cotyledons and other plant parts.     

Survival of Ice Nucleation-Active and Genetically Engineered Non-Ice-Nucleating Pseudomonas syringae Strains after Freezing

The survival after freezing of ice nucleation-active (INA) and genetically engineered non-INA strains of Pseudomonas syringae was compared. Each strain was applied to oat seedlings and allowed to colonize for 3 days, and the plants were subjected to various freezing temperatures. Plant leaves were harvested before and after freezing on two consecutive days, and bacterial populations were determined. Populations of the INA wild-type strain increased 15-fold in the 18 h after the oat plants incurred frost damage at −5 and −12°C. Plants colonized by the non-INA strain were undamaged at −5°C and exhibited no changes in population size after two freeze trials. As freezing temperatures were lowered (−7, −9, and −12°C), oat plants colonized by the non-INA strain suffered increased frost damage concomitant with bacterial population increases following 18 h. At −12°C, both strains behaved identically. The data show a relationship between frost damage to plants and increased bacterial population size during the following 18 h, indicating a potential competitive advantage of INA strains of P. syringae over non-INA strains in mild freezing environments.     

A novel method of natural cryoprotection : intracellular glass formation in deeply frozen populus

Correlating measurements from differential scanning calorimetry, freeze-fracture freeze-etch electron microscopy, and survival of twigs after two-step cooling experiments, we provide strong evidence that winter-hardened Populus balsamifera v. virginiana (Sarg.) resists the stresses of freezing below −28°C by amorphous solidification (glass formation) of most of its intracellular contents during slow cooling (≤5°C per hour). It is shown that other components of the intracellular medium go through glass transitions during slow cooling at about −45°C and below −70°C. This `three glass' model was then used to predict the results of differential scanning calorimetry, freeze-fracture freeze-etch electron microscopy, and biological experiments. This model is the first definitive explanation for the resistance of a woody plant to liquid N₂ temperatures even if quench cooling (1200°C per minute) begins at temperatures as high as −20°C and warming is very slow (≤5°C per hour). It is also the first time high temperature natural intracellular glass formation has been demonstrated.     

Endosperm and pericarp involvement in the supercooling of imbibed lettuce seeds

Fully hydrated lettuce (Lactuca sativa L.) seeds showed dual freezing exotherms (−9 and −18°C), even after 10 hours imbibition. Only the −9°C exotherm was observed in seeds imbibed for 20 hours, but without external nucleation, all water in the embryo supercooled. Results indicate that the endosperm acts as a barrier to ice propagation. Other experiments suggest that the pericarp may also protect the embryo under certain freezing conditions.     

Physiological and metabolic responses of winter wheat to prolonged freezing stress

Survival and cold hardiness declined gradually when cold-hardened Fredrick winter wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) was maintained at −6°C for several weeks. Moisture content of crown and root tissue did not change significantly during this period. Uptake of O₂ and accumulation of ⁸⁶Rb by root tissue declined abruptly upon exposure to −6°C, whereas a concomitant negative effect of freezing on these metabolic processes was not observed in crown tissue. Electron spin resonance spectroscopic analysis of microsomal membrane preparations from crown tissue revealed no evidence of gross changes in the physical properties of the bulk lipids even when seedlings were killed. The results provide biochemical evidence that seedling damage due to prolonged exposure to a mild freezing stress is due to disruption of key metabolic process in the root while cells within the crown remain viable.     

Formation of multiplex lamellae by equilibrium slow freezing of cortical parenchyma cells of mulberry and its possible relationship to freezing tolerance

Summary Cortical parenchyma cells of mulberry (Morus bombycis Koidz. cv. Goroji) become extremely cold hardy in winter and can tolerate equilibrium freezing below –30 °C and subsequent immersion into liquid nitrogen. We show in this ultrastructural study that, in these extremely cold hardy cortical parenchyma cells of mulberry collected in winter, initiation of freezing at –5 °C resulted in the formation of multiplex lamellae (MPL) that completely covered the area beneath the plasma membrane. The MPL were produced by fusion of pre-existing vesicular endoplasmic reticulum (ER), via a reticular ER network. The completed MPL were composed of a parallel array of sheet-like ER cisternae. This structural reorganization of the ER was completed within 10 min upon freezing at –5 °C and was quickly reversed upon thawing. The same structural reorganization of the ER was produced by osmotic dehydration of the cortical tissues with a 2.7 osmol sorbitol solution at 20 °C. Thus, the structural reorganization of the ER upon freezing was, in fact, produced by dehydration. In winter samples, the formation of MPL with the initiation of freezing completely inhibited close apposition of membranes upon deep freezing that has been reported to be a cause of freezing injury via the production of ultrastructural changes in the plasma membrane. Similar but more or less incomplete MPL were produced by freezing or osmotic dehydration in cortical parenchyma cells collected in spring and autumn, and these MPL partly inhibited close apposition of membranes. MPL were not produced in the cells of mulberry collected in summer and close apposition of membranes occurred upon deep freezing. We speculate that the formation of MPL with the initiation of freezing might play a specific role in inhibiting the close apposition of membranes due to the specific nature of the cisternal membranes and might, consequently, be responsible for the high freezing tolerance of winter cells.     

Osmotic shrinkage as a factor in freezing injury in plant tissue cultures

Haplopappus gracilis and Acer saccharum tissue culture cells are extremely sensitive to freezing injury, and exhibit a decrease in survival from 98% at −1 C to 4% at −3 C (Haplopappus) and 92% at −3 C to 13% at −5 C (Acer) when suspended in distilled H₂O, seeded at −1 C, and then cooled by 0.1 C/minute. Similar results are obtained when cells are suspended in growth medium. The extent of shrinkage of cells during freezing can be duplicated by exposure of the cells to plasmolyzing solutions of nonpenetrating substances (Δ T_f = 1.86 vm). Solutions of sucrose and glycerol that produce extensive plasmolysis cause a decrease in survival within 3 to 5 minutes at room temperature, and the higher the molality to which the cell is exposed the greater the injury. Also, the rate of rehydration of the plasmolyzed cell and of the frozen cell affects its survival, with the slower rate being more beneficial. The close correlation between the decrease in survival at subzero temperatures and the decrease in survival when cells are placed in solutions having osmolalities, which could produce the same extent of shrinkage as these killing temperatures, suggests that this shrinkage is related to freezing injury in tissue culture cells.     

Cold Acclimation in Arabidopsis thaliana

The abilities of two races of Arabidopsis thaliana L. (Heyn), Landsberg erecta and Columbia, to cold harden were examined. Landsberg, grown at 22 to 24°C, increased in freezing tolerance from an initial 50% lethal temperature (LT₅₀) of about −3°C to an LT₅₀ of about −6°C after 24 hours at 4°C; LT₅₀ values of −8 to −10°C were achieved after 8 to 9 days at 4°C. Similar increases in freezing tolerance were obtained with Columbia. In vitro translation of poly(A⁺) RNA isolated from control and cold-treated Columbia showed that low temperature induced changes in the population of translatable mRNAs. An mRNA encoding a polypeptide of about 160 kilodaltons (isoelectric point about 4.5) increased markedly after 12 to 24 h at 4°C, as did mRNAs encoding four polypeptides of about 47 kilodaltons (isoelectric points ranging from 5-5.5). Incubation of Columbia callus tissue at 4°C also resulted in increased levels of the mRNAs encoding the 160 kilodalton polypeptide and at least two of the 47 kilodalton polypeptides. In vivo labeling experiments using Columbia plants and callus tissue indicated that the 160 kilodalton polypeptide was synthesized in the cold and suggested that at least two of the 47 kilodalton polypeptides were produced. Other differences in polypeptide composition were also observed in the in vivo labeling experiments, some of which may be the result of posttranslational modifications of the 160 and 47 kilodalton polypeptides.     

Factors Influencing the Induction of Freezing Tolerance by Abscisic Acid in Cell Suspension Cultures of Bromus inermis Leyss and Medicago sativa L

A 2-gram fresh weight inoculum of bromegrass (Bromus inermis Leyss. culture BG970) cell suspension culture treated with 7.5 × 10⁻⁵ molar abscisic acid (ABA) for 7 days at 25°C survived slow cooling to −60°C. Over 80% of the cells in ABA treated cultures survived immersion in liquid N₂ after slow cooling to −40 or −60°C. In contrast, a 6-gram fresh weight inoculum only attained a hardiness level of −28°C after 5 days of ABA treatment. Ethanol (2 × 10⁻² molar) added to the culture medium at the time of ABA addition, inhibited the freezing tolerance of bromegrass cells by 25°C. A 6-gram inoculum of both control and ABA treated bromegrass cells altered the pH of the medium more than a 2-gram inoculum. ABA inhibited the increase in fresh weight of bromegrass by 20% after 4 days. Both control and ABA (10⁻⁴ molar) treated alfalfa cells (Medicago sativa L.) grown at 25°C hardened from an initial LT₅₀ of −5°C to an LT₅₀ of −23°C by the third to fifth day after subculture. Thereafter, the cells dehardened but the ABA treated cells did not deharden to the same level as the control cells. ABA inhibited the increase in fresh weight of alfalfa by 50% after 5 days.     

Freezing tolerance of citrus, spinach, and petunia leaf tissue : osmotic adjustment and sensitivity to freeze induced cellular dehydration

Seasonal variations in freezing tolerance, water content, water and osmotic potential, and levels of soluble sugars of leaves of field-grown Valencia orange (Citrus sinensis) trees were studied to determine the ability of citrus trees to cold acclimate under natural conditions. Controlled environmental studies of young potted citrus trees, spinach (Spinacia pleracea), and petunia (Petunia hybrids) were carried out to study the water relations during cold acclimation under less variable conditions. During the coolest weeks of the winter, leaf water content and osmotic potential of field-grown trees decreased about 20 to 25%, while soluble sugars increased by 100%. At the same time, freezing tolerance increased from lethal temperature for 50% (LT₅₀) of −2.8 to −3.8°C. In contrast, citrus leaves cold acclimated at a constant 10°C in growth chambers were freezing tolerant to about −6°C. The calculated freezing induced cellular dehydration at the LT₅₀ remained relatively constant for field-grown leaves throughout the year, but increased for leaves of plants cold acclimated at 10°C in a controlled environment. Spinach leaves cold acclimated at 5°C tolerated increased cellular dehydration compared to nonacclimated leaves. Cold acclimated petunia leaves increased in freezing tolerance by decreasing osmotic potential, but had no capacity to change cellular dehydration sensitivity. The result suggest that two cold acclimation mechanisms are involved in both citrus and spinach leaves and only one in petunia leaves. The common mechanism in all three species tested was a minor increase in tolerance (about −1°C) resulting from low temperature induced osmotic adjustment, and the second in citrus and spinach was a noncolligative mechanism that increased the cellular resistance to freeze hydration.     

Influence of cold acclimation on membrane injury in frozen plant tissue

Cold-acclimated twigs of Amelanchier alnifolia Nutt. released less HCN at −4.5 C than nonacclimated twigs following slow freezing to −25 C or rapid freezing to −78 C. Cold-acclimated twigs frozen slowly to −25 C released more HCN than cold-acclimated twigs frozen only to −4.5 C. Cold-acclimated twigs frozen slowly to −25 C and then rapidly to −78 C released less HCN at −4.5 C than cold-acclimated twigs frozen rapidly to −78 C. In general, K⁺ efflux and the inability to reduce triphenyl tetrazolium chloride following freezing and thawing paralleled HCN release at −4.5 C. Because low K⁺ efflux and high triphenyl tetrazolium chloride reduction are known to depend upon membrane integrity, the increased K⁺ efflux and the decreased triphenyl tetrazolium chloride reduction following freezing and thawing provide indirect evidence that HCN release at −4.5 C is a measure of membrane damage in frozen cells.