Redox-regulation of protein import into chloroplasts and mitochondria: Similarities and differences

Redox signals play important roles in many developmental and metabolic processes, in particular in chloroplasts and mitochondria. Furthermore, redox reactions are crucial for protein folding via the formation of inter- or intramolecular disulfide bridges. Recently, redox signals were described to be additionally involved in regulation of protein import: in mitochondria, a disulfide relay system mediates retention of cystein-rich proteins in the intermembrane space by oxidizing them. Two essential proteins, the redox-activated receptor Mia40 and the sulfhydryl oxidase Erv1 participate in this pathway. In chloroplasts, it becomes apparent that protein import is affected by redox signals on both the outer and inner envelope: at the level of the Toc complex (translocon at the outer envelope of chloroplasts), the formation/reduction of disulfide bridges between the Toc components has a strong influence on import yield. Moreover, the stromal metabolic redox state seems to be sensed by the Tic complex (translocon at the inner envelope of chloroplasts) that is able to adjust translocation efficiency of a subgroup of redox-related preproteins accordingly. This review summarizes the current knowledge of these redox-regulatory pathways and focuses on similarities and differences between chloroplasts and mitochondria.Key words: protein import, chloroplasts, mitochondria, redox-regulation, disulfide bridges, NADP(H), Toc, Tic, Tom     

Thioredoxins and glutaredoxins as facilitators of protein folding

Thiol-disulfide oxidoreductase systems of bacterial cytoplasm and eukaryotic cytosol favor reducing conditions and protein thiol groups, while bacterial periplasm and eukaryotic endoplasmatic reticulum provide oxidizing conditions and a machinery for disulfide bond formation in the secretory pathway. Oxidoreductases of the thioredoxin fold superfamily catalyze steps in oxidative protein folding via protein-protein interactions and covalent catalysis to act as chaperones and isomerases of disulfides to generate a native fold. The active site dithiol/disulfide of thioredoxin fold proteins is CXXC where variations of the residues inside the disulfide ring are known to increase the redox potential like in protein disulfide isomerases. In the catalytic mechanism thioredoxin fold proteins bind to target proteins through conserved backbone-backbone hydrogen bonds and induce conformational changes of the target disulfide followed by nucleophilic attack by the N-terminally located low pK(a) Cys residue. This generates a mixed disulfide covalent bond which subsequently is resolved by attack from the C-terminally located Cys residue. This review will focus on two members of the thioredoxin superfamily of proteins known to be crucial for maintaining a reduced intracellular redox state, thioredoxin and glutaredoxin, and their potential functions as facilitators and regulators of protein folding and chaperone activity.     

Disulfide bridges in interleukin-8 probed using non-natural disulfide analogues: dissociation of roles in structure from function.

The structural and functional roles of the two disulfide bridges in interleukin-8 (IL-8) were addressed using IL-8 analogues with covalently modified disulfide bridges. The analogues were prepared using chemical synthesis by replacement of a cysteine for either homocysteine, penicillamine, or selenocysteine and on folding resulted in a covalently modified disulfide. Deletion of either of the two disulfide bridges by replacement of either cysteine pair with alanine resulted in loss of both structure and function. In contrast, all of the analogues with modified disulfide bridges had native tertiary fold as determined by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopic methods. Their structural similarity provided a rational basis for assessing the functional effects of the changes to the disulfide. Modification to the disulfide bridge between cysteines 9 and 50 had only a modest effect on IL-8 function. In contrast, alterations to the 7-34 disulfide bridge resulted in a dramatic reduction in biological potency. Thus, although both disulfide bridges are required for maintenance of the native tertiary fold, their role in determining IL-8 activity is distinct. We propose that 7-34 disulfide has a direct role in determining receptor binding and activation, whereas the 9-50 was not directly involved. The synthesis of non-natural disulfide analogues is a novel general approach to structure-activity relationships of disulfide bridges. The demonstration that the participation of disulfide bridges in function can be dissociated from their effects on the stability of the tertiary structure suggests that this method will lead to increased understanding of the roles of disulfide bridges in proteins.     

A comparison of the folding of two knotted proteins: YbeA and YibK

The extraordinary topology of proteins belonging to the alpha/beta-knot superfamily of proteins is unexpected, due to the apparent complexities involved in the formation of a deep trefoil knot in a polypeptide backbone. Despite this, an increasing number of knotted structures are being identified; how such proteins fold remains a mystery. Studies on the dimeric protein YibK from Haemophilus influenzae have led to the characterisation of its folding pathway in some detail. To complement research into the folding of YibK, and to address whether folding pathways are conserved for members of the alpha/beta-knot superfamily, the structurally similar knotted protein YbeA from Escherichia coli has been studied. A comprehensive thermodynamic and kinetic analysis of the folding of YbeA is presented here, and compared to that of YibK. Both fold via an intermediate state populated under equilibrium conditions that is monomeric and considerably structured. The unfolding/refolding kinetics of YbeA are simpler than those found for YibK and involve two phases attributed to the formation of a monomeric intermediate state and a dimerisation step. In contrast to YibK, a change in the rate-determining step on the unfolding pathway for YbeA is observed with a changing concentration of urea. Despite this difference, both proteins fold by a mechanism involving at least one sequential monomeric intermediate that has properties similar to that observed during the equilibrium unfolding. The rate of dimerisation observed for YbeA and YibK is very similar, as is the rate constant for formation of the kinetic monomeric intermediate that precedes dimerisation. The findings suggest that relatively slow folding and dimerisation may be common attributes of knotted proteins.     

The influence of intramolecular bridges on the dynamics of a protein folding reaction

Thirteen versions of a beta-sheet protein have been constructed, each with a single, surface-exposed disulfide bridge. A comparison of folding kinetics, in oxidizing and reducing conditions, is used to elucidate the order in which beta-strands become associated during the folding process and, hence, the relationship between topology and folding dynamics. In common with the wild-type molecule, all the proteins fold through a two-step (three state) mechanism with a rapidly formed intermediate which slowly converts to the native state. In a majority of cases, the bridge is seen to stabilize the folded state, and for five of the modified proteins, the additional stability is greater than 3 kcal/mol. Surprisingly, cross-links which connect beta-strands which are distant in sequence predominantly stabilize the rapidly formed intermediate state, suggesting that these strand-strand interactions occur in the initial stages of folding. Cross-links which stabilize local hairpins have their major influence on the second, rate-determining step leading to significant enhancements in the folding rate. We find that enhancement of the folding rate in the second, rate-limiting step is correlated with a reduction in contact order in the same way as in naturally occurring proteins of different folds. The large increases in native-state stability resulting from the insertion of disulfide bridges on the surface of beta-sheet structures have implications for enhancing the robustness of proteins by molecular engineering.     

Thermodynamics and kinetics of protein folding: an evolutionary perspective

This article appeals to an evolutionary model which postulates that primordial proteins were described by small polypeptide chains which (i) lack disulfide bridges, and (ii) display slow folding rates with multi-state kinetics, to determine relations between structural properties of proteins and their folding kinetics. We parameterize the energy landscape of proteins in terms of thermodynamic activation variables. The model studies evolutionary changes in these thermodynamic parameters, and we invoke relations between these activation variables and structural properties of the protein to predict the following correspondence between protein structure and folding kinetics. 1. Proteins with inter- and intra-chain disulfide bridges: large variability in both folding rates and stability of intermediates, multi-state kinetics. 2. Proteins which lack inter and intra-chain disulfide bridges. 2.1 Single-domain chains: fast folding rates; unstable intermediates; two-state kinetics. 2.2 Multi-domain monomers: intermediate rates; metastable intermediates; multi-state kinetics. 2.3 Multi-domain oligomers: slow rates; metastable intermediates; multi-state kinetics. The evolutionary model thus provides a kinetic characterization of one important subfamily of proteins which we describe by the following properties: Folding dynamics of single-domain proteins which lack disulfide bridges are described by two-state kinetics. Folding rate of this class of proteins is positively correlated with the thermodynamic stability of the folded state.     

Glutathione directly reduces an oxidoreductase in the endoplasmic reticulum of mammalian cells

The formation of disulfide bonds is an essential step in the folding of many glycoproteins and secretory proteins. Non-native disulfide bonds are often formed between incorrect cysteine residues, and thus the cell has dedicated a family of oxidoreductases that are thought to isomerize non-native bonds. For an oxidoreductase to be capable of performing isomerization or reduction reactions, it must be maintained in a reduced state. Here we show that most of the oxidoreductases are predominantly reduced in vivo. Following oxidative stress the oxidoreductases are quickly reduced, demonstrating that a robust reductive pathway is in place in mammalian cells. Using ERp57 as a model we show that the reductive pathway is cytosol-dependent and that the component responsible for the reduction of the oxidoreductases is the low molecular mass thiol glutathione. In addition, ERp57 is not reduced following oxidative stress when inhibitors of glutathione synthesis or glutathione reduction are added to cells. Glutathione directly reduces ERp57 at physiological concentrations in vitro, and biotinylated glutathione forms a mixed disulfide with ERp57 in microsomes. Our results demonstrate that glutathione plays a direct role in the isomerization of disulfide bonds by maintaining the mammalian oxidoreductases in a reduced state.     

Fluorometric polyethyleneglycol-peptide hybrid substrates for quantitative assay of protein disulfide isomerase

In eukaryotic cells the enzyme protein disulfide isomerase (PDI) is responsible for the formation and reshuffling of disulfide bonds in secretory proteins. The reaction carried out by PDI involves interaction with a highly complex mixture of polypeptide molecules that are in the process of folding. This means that PDI activity is typically measured in the context of a globular protein folding pathway. The absence of small, well-defined substrates for the quantitation of both oxidation and reduction reactions constitutes an inherent problem in the analysis of PDI activity. We describe a new type of substrate for PDI where two cysteine-containing oligopeptides are connected by an onameric ethylene glycol linker. We term such hybrid compounds PEGtides. The oligopeptides are each marked with a fluorescent aminobenzoic acid and a quenching nitrotyrosine group, respectively. The reversible formation of an intramolecular disulfide bond between fluorophore-containing and quencher-containing peptide segments results in a redox-dependent fluorescence signal. We find a model compound of this type to be a highly sensitive substrate for PDI both in oxidation and in reduction assays under steady state conditions. These aspects should make substrates of this type generally applicable for assaying PDI and other thiol-disulfide exchange enzymes.     

A review of protein engineering for the food industry

In this review I briefly describe the technique of protein engineering and indicate how the present state of knowledge allows proteins to be mutated to increase or decrease stability. I discuss experiments on both model proteins and those of relevance to the food industry and show how hydrophobic forces are a major driving force for folding as well as having a major role in thermostability, I also indicate the large contribution that hydrogen bonding, electrostatic interactions and, in a less well predicted way, disulfide bridges make to thermostability.     

Formation of disulfide bonds in proteins and peptides

For many proteins and peptides, disulfide bridges are prerequisite for their proper biological function. Many commercialized proteins are crosslinked by disulfide bridges that increase their resistance to destructive effects of extreme environment used in industrial processes or protect protein-based therapeutics from rapid proteolytic degradation. Manufacturing of these products must take into account oxidative refolding--a formation of native disulfide bonds by specific pairs of cysteines located throughout a sequence of linear protein. This review describes basic and practical aspects of oxidative folding that should be considered while designing and optimizing manufacturing of proteins using chemical synthesis, semi-synthesis and a recombinant expression.     

The cystine knot promotes folding and not thermodynamic stability in vascular endothelial growth factor

Cystine knots consist of three intertwined disulfide bridges and are considered major determinants of protein stability in proteins in which they occur. We questioned this function and observed that removal of individual disulfide bridges in human vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) does not reduce its thermodynamic stability but reduces its unexpected high thermal stability of 108 degrees C by up to 40 degrees C. In wild-type VEGF (deltaG(u,25)(0) = 5.1 kcal.mol(-1)), the knot is responsible for a large entropic stabilization of TdeltaS(u,25)(0) = -39.3 kcal mol(-1), which is compensated for by a deltaH(u,25)(0) of -34.2 kcal mol(-1). In the disulfide-deficient mutants, this entropic stabilization disappears, but instead of a decrease, we observe an increase in the thermodynamic stability by about 2 kcal.mol(-1). A detailed crystallographic analysis of the mutant structures suggests a role of the cystine knot motif in protein folding rather than in the stabilization of the folded state. When assuming that the sequential order of the disulfide bridge formation is conserved between VEGF and glycoprotein alpha-subunit, the crystal structure of the mutant C61A-C104A, which deviates by a root mean square deviation of more than 2.2 A from wild-type VEGF, identifies a true folding intermediate of VEGF.     

Complex of pregnancy-associated plasma protein-A and the proform of eosinophil major basic protein. Disulfide structure and carbohydrate attachment

Pregnancy-associated plasma protein-A (PAPP-A) is a metzincin superfamily metalloproteinase responsible for cleavage of insulin-like growth factor-binding protein-4, thus causing release of bound insulin-like growth factor. PAPP-A is secreted as a dimer of 400 kDa but circulates in pregnancy as a disulfide-bound 500-kDa 2:2 complex with the proform of eosinophil major basic protein (pro-MBP), recently shown to function as a proteinase inhibitor of PAPP-A. Except for PAPP-A2, PAPP-A does not share global similarity with other proteins. Three lin-notch (LNR or LIN-12) modules and five complement control protein modules (also known as SCR modules) have been identified in PAPP-A by sequence similarity with other proteins, but no data are available that allow unambiguous prediction of disulfide bonds of these modules. To establish the connectivities of cysteine residues of the PAPP-A.pro-MBP complex, biochemical analyses of peptides derived from purified protein were performed. The PAPP-A subunit contains a total of 82 cysteine residues, of which 81 have been accounted for. The pro-MBP subunit contains 12 cysteine residues, of which 10 have been accounted for. Within the 2:2 complex, PAPP-A is dimerized by a single disulfide bond; pro-MBP is dimerized by two disulfides, and each PAPP-A subunit is connected to a pro-MBP subunit by two disulfide bonds. All other disulfides are intrachain bridges. We also show that of 13 potential sites for N-linked carbohydrate substitution of the PAPP-A subunit, 11 are occupied. The large number of disulfide bonds of the PAPP-A.pro-MBP complex imposes many restraints on polypeptide folding, and knowledge of the disulfide pattern of PAPP-A will facilitate structural studies based on recombinant expression of individual, putative PAPP-A domains. Furthermore, it will allow rational experimental design of functional studies aimed at understanding the formation of the PAPP-A.pro-MBP complex, as well as the inhibitory mechanism of pro-MBP.     

Methods to identify the substrates of thiol‐disulfide oxidoreductases

The formation of a disulfide bond is a critical step in the folding of numerous secretory and membrane proteins and catalyzed in vivo. A variety of mechanisms and protein structures have evolved to catalyze oxidative protein folding. Those enzymes that directly interact with a folding protein to accelerate its oxidative folding are mostly thiol‐disulfide oxidoreductases that belong to the thioredoxin superfamily. The enzymes of this class often use a CXXC active‐site motif embedded in their thioredoxin‐like fold to promote formation, isomerization, and reduction of a disulfide bond in their target proteins. Over the past decade or so, an increasing number of substrates of the thiol‐disulfide oxidoreductases that are present in the ER of mammalian cells have been discovered, revealing that the enzymes play unexpectedly diverse physiological functions. However, functions of some of these enzymes still remain unclear due to the lack of information on their substrates. Here, we review the methods used by researchers to identify the substrates of these enzymes and provide data that show the importance of using trichloroacetic acid in sample preparation for the substrate identification, hoping to aid future studies. We particularly focus on successful studies that have uncovered physiological substrates and functions of the enzymes in the periplasm of Gram‐negative bacteria and the endoplasmic reticulum of mammalian cells. Similar approaches should be applicable to enzymes in other cellular compartments or in other organisms.     

Comparative analysis of structural properties of the C-type-lectin-like domain (CTLD)

The superfamily of proteins containing the C-type-lectin-like domain (CTLD) is a group of abundant extracellular metazoan proteins characterized by evolutionary flexibility and functional versatility. Several CTLDs are also found in parasitic prokaryotes and viruses. The 37 distinct currently available CTLD structures demonstrate significant structural conservation despite low or undetectable sequence similarity. Our aim in this study was to perform an extensive comparative analysis of all available CTLD structures to establish the most conserved structural features of the fold, and to test and extend the early analysis of Drickamer. By implication, these features should be those critical for maintenance of integrity of the fold. By analyzing CTLD structures superimposed by several methods, we have established groups of conserved structural positions involved in fold maintenance but not in ligand binding; these are consistent with the fold's known functional flexibility. In addition to the well-recognized disulfide bridges, groups of conserved residues are involved in hydrophobic interactions stabilizing the core of the fold and the long loop region, and in an alpha2-beta1-beta5 polar interaction. Evaluation of the conclusions of the structure comparison study compared with alignments of all available human, mouse and Caenorhabditis elegans CTLD sequences showed that conservation patterns are preserved throughout the whole CTLD sequence space. Our observations provide an improved understanding of CTLD structure, and will help in identification of new CTLDs and the mechanisms that drive and constrain the coevolution of the structure and function of the fold.     

Complementation of DsbA deficiency with secreted thioredoxin variants reveals the crucial role of an efficient dithiol oxidant for catalyzed protein folding in the bacterial periplasm.

The thiol/disulfide oxidoreductase DsbA is the strongest oxidant of the thioredoxin superfamily and is required for efficient disulfide bond formation in the periplasm of Escherichia coli. To determine the importance of the redox potential of the final oxidant in periplasmic protein folding, we have investigated the ability of the most reducing thiol/disulfide oxidoreductase, E.coli thioredoxin, of complementing DsbA deficiency when secreted to the periplasm. In addition, we secreted thioredoxin variants with increased redox potentials as well as the catalytic a-domain of human protein disulfide isomerase (PDI) to the periplasm. While secreted wild-type thioredoxin and the most reducing thioredoxin variant could not replace DsbA, all more oxidizing thioredoxin variants as well as the PDI a-domain could complement DsbA deficiency in a DsbB-dependent manner. There is an excellent agreement between the activity of the secreted thioredoxin variants in vivo and their ability to oxidize polypeptides fast and quantitatively in vitro. We conclude that the redox potential of the direct oxidant of folding proteins and in particular its reactivity towards reduced polypeptides are crucial for efficient oxidative protein folding in the bacterial periplasm.     

Division of labor among oxidoreductases: TMX1 preferentially acts on transmembrane polypeptides

The endoplasmic reticulum (ER) is the site of maturation for secretory and membrane proteins in eukaryotic cells. The lumen of the mammalian ER contains >20 members of the protein disulfide isomerase (PDI) superfamily, which ensure formation of the correct set of intramolecular and intermolecular disulfide bonds as crucial, rate-limiting reactions of the protein folding process. Components of the PDI superfamily may also facilitate dislocation of misfolded polypeptides across the ER membrane for ER-associated degradation (ERAD). The reasons for the high redundancy of PDI family members and the substrate features required for preferential engagement of one or the other are poorly understood. Here we show that TMX1, one of the few transmembrane members of the family, forms functional complexes with the ER lectin calnexin and preferentially intervenes during maturation of cysteine-containing, membrane-associated proteins while ignoring the same cysteine-containing ectodomains if not anchored at the ER membrane. As such, TMX1 is the first example of a topology-specific client protein redox catalyst in living cells.     

Assistance of maltose binding protein to the in vivo folding of the disulfide-rich C-terminal fragment from Plasmodium falciparum merozoite surface protein 1 expressed in Escherichia coli

The C-terminal fragment of Plasmodium falciparum merozoite surface protein 1 (F19) is a leading candidate for the development of a malaria vaccine. Successful vaccination trials on primates, immunochemistry, and structural studies have shown the importance of its native conformation for its protective role against infection. F19 is a disulfide-rich protein, and the correct pairing of its 12 half-cystines is required for the native state of the protein. F19 has been produced in the Escherichia coli periplasm, which has an oxidative environment favorable for the formation of disulfide bonds. F19 was either expressed as a fusion with the maltose binding protein (MBP) or directly addressed to the periplasm by fusing it with the MBP signal peptide. Direct expression of F19 in the periplasm led to a misfolded protein with a heterogeneous distribution of disulfide bridges. On the contrary, when produced as a fusion protein with E. coli MBP, the F19 moiety was natively folded. Indeed, after proteolysis of the fusion protein, the resulting F19 possesses the structural characteristics and the immunochemical reactivity of the analogous fragment produced either in baculovirus-infected insect cells or in yeast. These results demonstrate that the positive effect of MBP in assisting the folding of passenger proteins extends to the correct formation of disulfide bridges in vivo. Although proteins or protein fragments fused to MBP have been frequently expressed with success, our comparative study evidences for the first time the helping property of MBP in the oxidative folding of a disulfide-rich protein.     

Identification of the unstable neurophysin disulfide and localization to the hormone-binding site. Relationship to folding-unfolding pathways.

For unliganded neurophysin, the effects of reduction of a single disulfide and limited regeneration of activity following reduction have suggested metastable disulfide pairing relative to that of the neurophysin precursor. This metastability was confirmed in the present study by the demonstration of almost complete regeneration of activity from the reduced state in the presence of ligand peptides, conditions mimicking precursor folding. To assign the source of the metastability of the unliganded mature protein, the disulfide(s) most susceptible to reduction and the last to be reoxidized following complete reduction were identified. Partial reduction of the first disulfide followed by trapping of the generated thiols with [14C]iodoacetate gave a distribution of label consistent with identification of the unstable disulfide as the 10-54 bridge and rapid interchange of the Cys-10 thiol with other disulfides in the amino-terminal disulfide domain. The same thiol distribution was seen at the terminal stage of reoxidation following complete reduction, providing evidence that unfolding and folding pathways are the same at this stage. The results indicate that, in the absence of bound peptide, the state with correct pairing of the 10-54 bridge has no significant thermodynamic advantage over interchanged states of the amino-terminal domain. However, since the 10-54 bridge is located at the peptide-binding site, the correct pairing is directly stabilized by ligand peptides. Moreover, since the other three bridges of the amino domain are homologous to bridges in the carboxyl-terminal domain that do not appear to be unstable, the results allow the possibility that the 10-54 bridge, which is unique to the amino domain, destabilizes other disulfides in that domain.     

Oxidative protein folding in the plant endoplasmic reticulum

For most of the proteins synthesized in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER), disulfide bond formation accompanies protein folding in a process called oxidative folding. Oxidative folding is catalyzed by a number of enzymes, including the family of protein disulfide isomerases (PDIs), as well as other proteins that supply oxidizing equivalents to PDI family proteins, like ER oxidoreductin 1 (Ero1). Oxidative protein folding in the ER is a basic vital function, and understanding its molecular mechanism is critical for the application of plants as protein production tools. Here, I review the recent research and progress related to the enzymes involved in oxidative folding in the plant ER. Firstly, nine groups of plant PDI family proteins are introduced. Next, the enzymatic properties of plant Ero1 are described. Finally, the cooperative folding by multiple PDI family proteins and Ero1 is described.     

Removal of the conserved disulfide bridges from the scFv fragment of an antibody: effects on folding kinetics and aggregation.

Fluorescence measurements and H/2H exchange experiments monitored by mass spectrometry have been applied to investigate the influence of the conserved disulfide bridges on the folding behavior and in vitro aggregation properties of the scFv fragment of the antibody hu4D5-8. A set of four proteins, carrying none, one, or both of the disulfide bridges have been compared regarding their stabilities, folding kinetics and tendency to aggregate. The results show that refolding of all four scFvs is ultimately limited by a slow proline isomerization in the VLdomain, since the native cis -conformation of proline L95 seems to be a prerequisite for formation of the native interface. Starting from short-term denatured protein, with the proline residues in their native conformation, a kinetically trapped intermediate is populated depending on the conditions, whose rate of conversion is slower than that of the fast-folding molecules. According to deuteron protection patterns determined by mass spectrometry, those domains retaining the disulfide bridge are able to form stable native-like structure, independent of native interface formation. The disulfide-free domains, in contrast, require the native interface for sufficient stabilization. The resistance of the scFvs towards aggregation seems to be critically dependent on the presence of the disulfide bridge in the VHdomain, and thus on the ability of the VHdomain to form stable structure prior to interaction with the VLdomain. The presence of a stable VLdomain in combination with a disulfide-free VHdomain appears to further promote aggregation, indicating the involvement of structured domains in the aggregates.