Activation of human B cells: alternate options for initial triggering and effects of nonmitogenic concentrations of anti-IgM antibodies on resting and activated cells

The monoclonal antibody 1F5, which is reactive with the CD20 (Bp 35) pan-B cell antigen, was shown to activate resting human peripheral blood B cells into the middle to late G1 phase of the cell cycle. However, in contrast to F(ab')2 fragments of polyclonal anti-mu, 1F5 synergized only weakly with B cell growth factor (BCGF) for DNA synthesis in these cells. We provide evidence that the CD20 molecule and surface immunoglobulin represent two alternative activation pathways in resting B cells. We also show that anti-immunoglobulins, during co-stimulation with BCGF, may play an important role in G1 as well as for the initial cell triggering. Thus, anti-mu in nonmitogenic concentrations was shown to provoke distinct effects on 1F5-pretreated G1 cells, as monitored by increases in cellular volumes as well as in cytoplasmic Ca2+ levels. Moreover, anti-mu could increase c-myc mRNA levels in 1F5-primed cells, implying that c-myc expression can be regulated in G1 as well as during the initial G0 to G1 transition. Partially purified human BCGF neither induced G1 entry in resting peripheral blood cells nor primed the cells for DNA synthesis. The finding that BCGF did not influence c-myc mRNA levels in resting or in activated B cells suggests that its mitogenic action does not involve the c-myc function.     

Inhibition of human B cell activation by diterpine forskolin: interference with B cell growth factor-induced G1 to S transition of the B cell cycle

We have previously demonstrated that a series of sequential steps are involved in the induction of a resting human B cell to proliferate. In this system, initial activation signals were delivered by either in vivo or in vitro stimulation, and proliferative signals were delivered by a B cell growth factor (BCGF) that was derived from a human T-T cell hybridoma. The involvement of adenosine 3',5'-monophosphate (cAMP) in regulating the growth and differentiation of lymphocytes has been of considerable interest. Diterpine forskolin has been reported to be a unique adenylate cyclase activator in membranes from mammalian tissues that results in elevations of intracytoplasmic cAMP. We have examined the effect of this drug on the progression of human B cells through their activation cycle. It was found that forskolin causes a rapid and sustained increase of cytoplasmic cAMP in purified small and large B cells. In the in vitro costimulation of small resting B cells with anti-mu plus BCGF, forskolin inhibited the proliferative response of B cells in a dose-dependent manner. This forskolin-mediated suppression of B cell proliferation was found when the drug was added to the cultures as late as 36 hr after initial stimulation. Of note is the fact that the anti-mu-induced RNA synthesis as well as cell enlargement in resting B cells was not inhibited by the addition of forskolin, whereas BCGF-induced proliferative response of activated B cells was markedly inhibited by the drug. Thus, these data demonstrate that forskolin, an agent that elevates cytoplasmic cAMP levels, has relatively little effect on early events in the human B cell cycle (G0 to G1) transition, but selectively inhibits the progression of BCGF-induced G1 to S phase transition of B cells.     

Sequential effect of a high molecular weight B cell growth factor and of interleukin 2 on activated human B cells

A high m.w. B cell growth factor (50,000 BCGF) prepared from lectin-activated human peripheral blood lymphocyte culture supernatants acts only on B cells preactivated by a first signal. This first signal can be delivered in vitro (with anti-mu antibody (Ab)) or in vivo. Upon costimulation with anti-mu Ab the 50,000 BCGF induces an early and transient proliferative response, whereas the response to interleukin 2 (IL-2) develops more progressively. To determine the respective targets of the 50,000 BCGF and of IL-2, B cells were activated with anti-mu Ab and separated according to the expression of the IL-2 receptor (cluster designation (CD)25 antigen). CD25+ B cells do not respond to the 50,000 BCGF and do not acquire this responsiveness after an additional culture with IL-2. CD25- B cells respond to the 50,000 BCGF and not to IL-2. However, when CD25- B cells are cultured for 3 days with the 50,000 BCGF they become responsive to IL-2. These results demonstrate a pathway of B cell activation based on the ordered and sequential action of anti-mu Ab, the 50,000 BCGF, and IL-2.     

Human B cell responsiveness to B cell growth factor after activation by phorbol ester and monoclonal anti-mu antibody

The effect of phorbol ester on human B cell activation was examined. Picomolar to nanomolar concentrations of phorbol ester induced a high level of proliferation in small IgM-positive B cells isolated from peripheral blood by fluorescence-activated cell sorting. The addition of optimal doses of anti-mu antibody resulted in enhanced proliferation of phorbol ester-activated B cells. The addition of B cell growth factor (BCGF) to phorbol ester-activated B cells also resulted in a dose-dependent synergistic effect and maximal enhancement on day 3. BCGF activity could be absorbed with either phorbol ester- or anti-mu-activated B cells, but not with resting B cells, thus confirming the induction of functional BCGF receptor expression. Cell proliferation was not necessary for the induction of functional BCGF receptors. Phorbol ester was a more efficient inducer of BCGF receptor expression than was anti-mu antibody; gamma-interferon treatment had no effect. BCGF enhanced transferrin receptor expression by phorbol ester-activated B cells. The results suggest that phorbol ester-activated small B cells can be used to monitor BCGF activity, and this synergistic combination may be useful in establishing BCGF-dependent B cell clones in culture.     

T cell-derived B cell growth factor(s) can induce stimulation of both resting and activated B cells

The effects of a preparation containing partially purified, EL4-derived B cell growth factor(s) (BCGF) on B cell growth and proliferation have been examined by using B lymphocyte subpopulations separated on the basis of size. BCGF was found to maintain and enhance proliferation of a significant proportion of large activated B cells. In contrast, small resting B cells required the presence of BCGF and a second stimulus such as anti-IgM antibody (anti-mu) to be induced to proliferate. This disparity was not due to a lack of an effect of BCGF on small resting B cells. A factor contained within the partially purified EL4 supernatant produced time-dependent increases in cell size and RNA content in all subpopulations. These effects were independent of possible effects due to contaminating lymphokines such as interleukin 2 (IL 2), concanavalin A (Con A), and phorbol myristate acetate (PMA). Nonmitogenic doses of lipopolysaccharide (LPS) failed to show similar effects. Our data suggest that B cells at all levels of in vivo activation are responsive to stimulation by a growth factor present in EL4 supernatant, as manifested by cell growth and RNA synthesis. This activity has not previously been described for BCGF preparations. However, because the partially purified, EL4-derived supernatant used as BCGF in these studies has not been purified to homogeneity, we cannot conclude whether the factors that induce resting B cells to increase in size are the same as the growth factors that synergize with anti-mu to induce B cell proliferation or that maintain the proliferation of activated B cells.     

Effects of cholera toxin on human B cells. Cholera toxin induces B cell surface DR expression while it inhibits anti-mu antibody-induced cell proliferation

Experiments were performed to investigate the effect of cholera toxin (CT) on human B cell function. Highly purified (greater than 98% CD20+) human peripheral blood B cells were exposed to CT in the presence or absence of anti-mu antibody. Treatment of highly purified B cells with CT stimulated enhanced expression of surface DR molecules, whereas it did not enhance expression of other B cell surface activation markers including transferrin or IL-2R. Neither the A nor the B subunits of CT by themselves enhanced the expression of surface DR Ag. In addition, 8-bromo-cAMP alone or in combination with the B subunit did not increase the expression of human B cell surface DR Ag. These findings suggest that neither elevation of cAMP nor binding to GM1 ganglioside are sufficient to stimulate this activation parameter in B cells. Associated with CT-mediated enhanced expression of MHC class II molecules we found that CT-treated B cells also served as stronger stimulators, compared with control cells, of both autologous and allogeneic MLR responses in peripheral blood T cells. Although CT stimulated early events in B cell activation, it inhibited anti-mu antibody-induced B cell thymidine incorporation by 55 to 75%. Inhibitory effects of CT were observed even when CT was added to cultures as late as 36 h after the addition of the anti-mu antibody. These results suggest that CT has both a stimulatory and inhibitory effect on human B cells and that the stimulatory effect may be mediated via a cAMP-independent mechanism.     

Selective suppressive effects of glucocorticoids on the early events in the human B cell activation process

The effect of hydrocortisone on the induction of human B cell activation and proliferation has been described. Hydrocortisone prevents the anti-mu-induced cell enlargement of small tonsillar B cells, blocks expression of the activation markers 4F2 and 5E9 induced by anti-mu, inhibits RNA synthesis of small B cells stimulated by anti-mu with or without BCGF, and suppresses B cell proliferation in response to anti-mu and BCGF or to Staphylococcus aureus Cowan I. In contrast, hydrocortisone does not affect the proliferative response of in vitro or in vivo preactivated B cells. Therefore, hydrocortisone has a selective inhibitory effect on early events in the human B cell cycle that subsequently leads to inhibition of total RNA and DNA synthesis. Possible mechanisms of this action are discussed. These studies further define the nature of glucocorticoid-induced modulation of human B cell activation and proliferation.     

Interleukin-1 and interleukin-6 synergize in preparing resting murine B cells to respond to anti-mu: correlation with c-myc expression.

We demonstrate that stimulation with interleukin (IL)-1 and IL-6 prepares high-density B cells to enter the S phase more promptly in response to subsequent stimulation with anti-mu F(ab')2. The stimulatory effect of IL-1 and IL-6 is compared to the one described for IL-4. In contrast to IL-4, preculture in IL-1 and IL-6 does not induce an increase in cell volume or in expression of class II major histocompatibility complex antigens on resting B cells. Similarly, the expression of the p55 subunit of the IL-2 receptor and of the transferrin receptor was not detected on resting B cells stimulated with IL-1 and IL-6. However, the stimulatory effect of IL-1 and IL-6 is correlated with an increased expression of c-myc proto-oncogene mRNA in resting murine B cells.     

Level of mIa expression on mitogen-stimulated murine B lymphocytes is dependent on position in cell cycle

Using correlated flow cytometric analysis of cell surface Ia antigen expression (immunofluorescence) and cell cycle phase (pulse-width of axial light extinction), we have quantitated changes in expression of mIa antigen on murine B cells during progression through cell cycle. Our results indicate that density of mIa expressed on mitogen-stimulated B cells increases fourfold to fivefold during the transition from G0 to G1. By early S phase, mIa density has decreased by fourfold to fivefold relative to peak expression. This decrease becomes more evident by late S, G2, and M phases, when an eightfold decrease in mIa antigen density is observed relative to peak levels. This decrease results in mIa antigen expression lower than that of resting, unstimulated B cells. Therefore, maximum mIa antigen expression occurs during G0 to G1 transition and in early G1, when a requirement for I region-restricted, antigen-driven T cell help for thymus-dependent, antigen-driven B cell activation has been demonstrated.     

Differential modulation of interleukin-2-and interleukin-4-mediated early activation of normal human B lymphocytes by the caspase inhibitor zVAD-fmk

Caspases are a group of cysteine-related proteases that control the process of apoptosis and may also be involved in the control of lymphocyte activation. We show here that the broad-spectrum caspase inhibitor benzyloxycarbonyl (Cbz)-Val-Ala-Asp (Ome)-fluoromethylketone (zVAD-fmk) prevents the proliferation of resting human B tonsilar lymphocytes mediated by the B cell mitogen SAC or the combination of anti-mu Ab and IL-2. zVAD-fmk inhibits IL-2-induced phosphorylation of the retinoblastoma protein, and cyclin D2 expression. However, neither the IL-2-mediated proliferation of cycling activated B cells nor that of lymphoma cells were inhibited by zVAD-fmk, suggesting that only the early steps of SAC- or IL-2-mediated B cell activation were sensitive to the inhibitory properties of zVAD-fmk. Our data also demonstrated that the inhibitory effect of zVAD-fmk was not observed when B cells were activated with IL-4 in the presence of either anti-mu Ab or anti-CD40 Ab. Thus, our results suggest that caspase activation is required for the IL-2-mediated entry of primary B lymphocytes into the cell cycle and show that caspase activation plays different roles in IL-2- and IL-4-mediated B cell proliferation.     

Cholera toxin promotes the proliferation of anti-mu antibody-prestimulated human B cells.

The predominant effect of cholera toxin (CT) on cell growth has been postulated to be inhibitory as a result of its induction of intracellular cAMP. We have recently reported that CT selectively enhances surface DR expression while it inhibits anti-mu antibody-induced B lymphocyte proliferation. In the present series of experiments we studied the effect of CT on in vitro preactivated highly purified (greater than 95% CD20+) human B cells. Cholera toxin enhanced thymidine incorporation of anti-mu antibody-preactivated but not of Staphylococcus aureus Cowan I or PMA + ionomycin-preactivated B cells. Concentrations of 100 pg/ml CT stimulated an enhancement of thymidine incorporation equivalent to that of optimal doses of BCGF. The growth factor-like effect of CT required the complete molecule, since binding of purified B subunit (B-CT) to GM1 ganglioside by itself did not reproduce the holotoxin effect. Moreover, B-CT pretreatment of anti-mu antibody-primed cells completely neutralized the holotoxin-enhancing effect. Both PGE2, a physiological agent that stimulates intracellular cAMP elevation, and the cAMP analogue, 8-bromo-cAMP, mimicked the growth-promoting effect of CT. However, the ED50 of CT required to augment proliferation in anti-mu antibody-preactivated human B cells was approximately 100 times less than the ED50 for cAMP formation. These results demonstrate a specific growth factor-like promoting effect of CT on sIg-preactivated highly purified human B cells that may be mediated at least in part through elevation in intracellular cAMP levels. Increased DR expression and stimulation of growth of sIg preactivated B cells may explain some of the adjuvant properties of CT following orally or parenterally administered antigens.     

Increased expression of the B lymphocyte receptor for transferrin is stimulated by in vivo crosslinking of cell surface IgD

Expression of a receptor for the serum protein transferrin has been shown to be a characteristic of several cell lineages and increased transferrin receptor (TFR) expression to reflect cellular activation. In vitro studies of human B lymphocytes stimulated with antibodies to IgM have demonstrated that these cells have the ability to express TFR and that increased B-cell TFR expression is seen first sometime after these cells enter the G1 phase of the cell cycle. It also has been shown that TFR expression is necessary for proliferation to occur and may be regulated by a factor produced by mitogen-activated T lymphocytes. To examine expression of TFR by activated B lymphocytes in vivo, and to determine the kinetics of induction of TFR expression, we have studied the effects of injecting mice with an affinity-purified goat antibody to mouse IgD (GaM delta) on TFR expression. This antibody previously has been shown to activate polyclonally mouse splenic B cells in vivo in a T-independent fashion. Results show that there is a small but definite quantity of TFR on resting splenocytes, at 24 hr after injection nearly all B cells but not T cells express increased amounts of TFR, TFR is increased to nearly the same extent in congenitally athymic BALB/c nu/nu mice as in their normal nu/+ littermates and therefore GaM delta-induced increased B lymphocyte TFR expression is relatively T independent, TFR expression increases as early as 3 hr after injection of 800 micrograms of GaM delta and increases steadily until it peaks 24-48 hr later, and TFR expression in GaM delta-injected mice increases concomitantly with surface Ia antigen and cell size.     

The effects of interleukin 1 on human B cell activation and proliferation

The precise role of B cell surface immunoglobulin (slg) in the activation of B cells is unclear at present. In particular, it is uncertain whether ligands interacting with the B cell slg suffice to induce proliferation, or simply induce a state of activation in which the B cell becomes responsive to growth factors made by accessory cells. We have examined the effects of two ligands, Staphylococcus aureus Cowan strain I (SAC) and antihuman mu chain (anti-mu), which interact with B cell slg on highly purified human peripheral blood and tonsillar B cells cultured at low cell concentrations. The effects on B cell proliferation of these ligands alone or in combination with highly purified interleukin 1 (IL 1) or a supernatant of a human T-T hybridoma containing a B cell growth factor (BCGF) were studied. SAC with its high cell wall content of protein A triggered maximal B cell proliferation which was not increased further by IL 1 or BCGF. High concentrations of soluble F(ab')2 fragments of goat anti-mu chain also induced significant B cell proliferation. Lower concentrations of anti-mu resulted in little or no B cell proliferation but activated the B cell to a state of responsiveness to both IL 1 and BCGF. IL 1 by itself had no effect on the proliferation of unstimulated B cells or on the proliferation of in vivo-activated B cells which responded to BCGF in vitro, but demonstrated clear synergy with low concentrations of anti-mu antibody. BCGF alone augmented the proliferation of unstimulated B cells, presumably by acting on B cells which had undergone some degree of activation in vivo. In addition, it showed marked synergy with anti-mu antibody, which resulted in proliferation similar in magnitude to that induced by SAC. This synergy was far greater than that seen between anti-mu antibody and IL 1, and the resulting proliferative response was only slightly increased by the presence of IL 1. We conclude that the importance of accessory cell factors for the initial rounds of B cell proliferation depends on the strength of the initial slg-mediated activation signal. When this is strong, the response is maximal and independent of accessory cells or accessory cell factors. When it is suboptimal, a moderate synergy is seen with IL 1 and a dramatic synergy with BCGF.     

The direct effects of interleukin 1, interleukin 2, interferon-alpha, interferon-gamma, B-cell growth factor, and a B-cell differentiation factor on resting and activated human B cells

A wide variety of cytokines have been demonstrated to affect B-cell function. However, it is unclear which of these mediators actually exert direct effects on the B cells themselves. In the present study, the direct role of interleukin (IL) 1, IL-2, Interferon-gamma, or Interferon-alpha in human B-cell activation, proliferation, or differentiation was examined and compared with the effects of a B-cell growth factor (BCGF) or a B-cell differentiation factor (BCDF). Highly purified human B lymphocytes were separated according to size into two nonoverlapping populations. The fraction of small B cells was incubated with IL-1, IL-2, Interferon-gamma, Interferon-alpha, BCGF, or BCDF, and cell size changes, RNA synthesis, DNA synthesis, or supernatant immunoglobulin (Ig) production were measured. Neither IL-1, IL-2, Interferon-alpha, Interferon-gamma, nor the BCGF induced substantial cell size changes, RNA synthesis, DNA synthesis, or Ig production by the small fraction of B lymphocytes; however, the BCDF could directly activate a proportion of resting B lymphocytes to secrete Ig. The fraction of large B cells was also incubated with these cytokines. While neither IL-1, Interferon-alpha, nor Interferon-gamma enhanced DNA synthesis or Ig production by the fraction of large B lymphocytes, DNA synthesis was augmented 23-fold by BCGF and IgG production was increased 7-fold by BCDF. Additionally, IL-2 slightly enhanced both proliferation and differentiation of large B cells but substantially less so than BCGF and BCDF; DNA synthesis was increased 4-fold, while Ig production in the presence of IL-2 was increased by approximately 50%. Thus, the most important lymphokines modulating the function of these two fractions of tonsillar lymphocytes were a BCGF and a BCDF.     

Kinetics of activation antigen expression by in vitro-stimulated human T lymphocytes

In this study a panel of monoclonal antibodies was used to investigate the kinetics of the appearance of activation-linked surface determinants as well as cytoplasmic and nuclear determinants in human T cells following lectin stimulation. Well known activation markers, such as Ia/DR, transferrin receptor, IL-2 receptor, T10, and gp24, were compared and investigated together with the T13 structure, recently found in this laboratory. T13, not demonstrable on resting T cells, could be seen within 24 hr after lectin stimulation. Kinetics of the appearance were similar to IL-2 receptor and transferrin receptor expression. Ia/DR synthesis was investigated separately for each polypeptide and the cytoplasmic invariant gamma-chain expression could be demonstrated for the first time with a gamma-chain-specific monoclonal antibody VIC-Y1. Moreover, gamma-chain synthesis seems to precede alpha- and beta-chain occurrence in human T cells. In addition, data from quantitative studies on antigenic densities are presented.     

Functional properties of two human B cell growth factor species separated by lectin affinity column

The supernatants from PHA-activated normal human T cells (conditioned medium) were fractionated by differential adsorption on Con A-Sepharose columns. The effluent contained both IL 2 activity (tested on the CTL-L2 cell line) and BCGF activity (tested on anti-mu-activated normal B-enriched cells). Absorption of such effluent on PHA-activated T cell blasts removed the IL 2 activity without affecting the BCGF activity. The eluate also displayed BCGF activity (tested on anti-mu-activated B-enriched cells) without detectable IL 2 activity. The two BCGF species isolated by this criteria synergize with semipurified IL 1 to support the anti-mu-induced proliferation of highly monocyte-depleted B cells. Both BCGF species required the presence of anti-mu Ab to support the proliferation of small B cells (at the G0 stage). However, in contrast to crude conditioned medium and to the BCGF present in the effluent, the BCGF present in the eluate was unable to induce the proliferation of unfractionated or large (at the G1 stage) B cells in the absence of anti-mu Ab. These results support the existence of two functionally different human BCGF species, differing at least in their relative sugar content and distinct from IL 2.     

Identification of a major 50-kDa molecular weight human B-cell growth factor with Tac antigen-inducing activity on B cells

A bioassay was developed using human small B cells adherent to anti-human IgM (anti-mu)-coated wells. These B cells were stimulated to proliferate by culture supernatants of concanavalin A (Con A)-activated human peripheral blood lymphocytes (Con A Sup) even in the presence of high concentrations of anti-mu coated on assay wells. Human B-cell growth factor (BCGF) activities were partially purified from Con A Sup. Preparative chromatography (Sephacryl S-200 and isoelectrofocusing) yielded a major peak of BCGF activity for B cells adherent to anti-mu-coated wells with a molecular weight of 50,000 (50 kDa) and a pI 7.6. The 50-kDa BCGF was further purified by sequential chromatography using DEAE-Sephacel, CM-Sepharose, Sephacryl S-200, CM-high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC), and hydroxyapatite (HA)-HPLC. The HA-HPLC-purified 50-kDa BCGF was free of interleukin-1 (IL-1), interleukin-2 (IL-2), and interferon activities, but could support growth of BCL1 cells, similar to BCGF-II. Neither IL-1 nor interferon-gamma had any growth-stimulating effect in our B-cell proliferation assay with or without BCGF in Iscove's synthetic assay medium. BCGF-induced proliferation of B cells adherent to anti-mu-coated wells could be markedly augmented by the simultaneous or sequential addition of recombinant human IL-2 (rIL-2). When cultured for 3 days with 50-kDa BCGF, about 40% of B cells adherent to anti-mu-coated wells expressed Tac antigen, and monoclonal anti-Tac antibody inhibited rIL-2 enhancement of proliferation of 50-kDa BCGF-preactivated B cells. In addition, 50-kDa BCGF could induce Tac antigen on an Epstein-Barr virus-transformed B-cell line (ORSON) in the presence of a suboptimal dose of phorbol myristate acetate (PMA) and also on a natural killer-like cell line (YT cells). We have therefore identified a major 50-kDa BCGF activity with Tac antigen-inducing activity that also has a synergistic effect with IL-2 on normal B-cell proliferation.     

Activation of B lymphocytes with human serum-treated zymosan

C3 fragments fixed on zymosan particles were presented to resting human B lymphocytes. The opsonized zymosan (Ops-Z) particles induced release of leukocyte migration inhibitory factor, a slight decrease in mIgD, and a slight increase in the activation marker Blast-2. The B cells did not proceed further along the pathway of activation: they did not respond to B cell growth factor (BCGF) and Ops-Z did not synergize with other activators for BCGF response either. Thus, we found that interaction between C3 fragments and CR2 initiates the activation of human B lymphocytes, but this is limited to the early phase.