Missense mutations in transmembrane domains of proteins: phenotypic propensity of polar residues for human disease

Previous experiments on the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator suggested that non-native polar residues within membrane domains can compromise protein structure/function. However, depending on context, replacement of a native residue by a non-native residue can result either in genetic disease or in benign effects (e.g., polymorphisms). Knowledge of missense mutations that frequently cause protein malfunction and subsequent disease can accordingly reveal information as to the impact of these residues in local protein environments. We exploited this concept by performing a statistical comparison of disease-causing mutations in protein membrane-spanning domains versus soluble domains. Using the Human Gene Mutation Database of 240 proteins (including 80 membrane proteins) associated with human disease, we compared the relative phenotypic propensity to cause disease of the 20 naturally occurring amino acids when removed from-or inserted into-native protein sequences. We found that in transmembrane domains (TMDs), mutations involving polar residues, and ionizable residues in particular (notably arginine), are more often associated with protein malfunction than soluble proteins. To further test the hypothesis that interhelical cross-links formed by membrane-embedded polar residues stabilize TMDs, we compared the occurrence of such residues in the TMDs of mesophilic and thermophilic prokaryotes. Results showed a significantly higher proportion of ionizable residues in thermophilic organisms, reinforcing the notion that membrane-embedded electrostatic interactions play critical roles in TMD stability.     

How different amino acid sequences determine similar protein structures: The structure and evolutionary dynamics of the globins

To determine how different amino acid sequences form similar protein structures, and how proteins adapt to mutations that change the volume of residues buried in their close-packed interiors, we have analysed and compared the atomic structures of nine different globins. The homology of the sequences in the two most distantly related molecules is only 16%.The principal determinants of three-dimensional structure of these proteins are the approximately 59 residues involved in helix to helix and helix to haem packings. Half of these residues are buried within the molecules. The observed variations in the sequence keep the side-chains of buried residues non-polar, but do not maintain their size: the mean variation of the volume among homologous amino acids is 56 ų.Changes in the volumes of buried residues are accompanied by changes in the geometry of the helix packings. The relative positions and orientations of homologous pairs of helices in the globins differ by rigid body shifts of up to 7 Å and 30 °. In order to retain functional activity these shifts are coupled so that the geometry of the residues forming the haem pocket is very similar in all the globins.We discuss the implications of these results for the mechanism of protein evolution.     

Positive and negative design in stability and thermal adaptation of natural proteins

The aim of this work is to elucidate how physical principles of protein design are reflected in natural sequences that evolved in response to the thermal conditions of the environment. Using an exactly solvable lattice model, we design sequences with selected thermal properties. Compositional analysis of designed model sequences and natural proteomes reveals a specific trend in amino acid compositions in response to the requirement of stability at elevated environmental temperature: the increase of fractions of hydrophobic and charged amino acid residues at the expense of polar ones. We show that this “from both ends of the hydrophobicity scale” trend is due to positive (to stabilize the native state) and negative (to destabilize misfolded states) components of protein design. Negative design strengthens specific repulsive non-native interactions that appear in misfolded structures. A pressure to preserve specific repulsive interactions in non-native conformations may result in correlated mutations between amino acids that are far apart in the native state but may be in contact in misfolded conformations. Such correlated mutations are indeed found in TIM barrel and other proteins.     

Nature disfavors sequences of alternating polar and non-polar amino acids: implications for amyloidogenesis

Recent experiments with combinatorial libraries of de novo proteins have demonstrated that sequences designed to contain polar and non-polar amino acid residues arranged in an alternating pattern form fibrillar structures resembling beta-amyloid. This finding prompted us to probe the distribution of alternating patterns in the sequences of natural proteins. Analysis of a database of 250,514 protein sequences (79,708,024 residues) for all possible binary patterns of polar and non-polar amino acid residues revealed that alternating patterns occur significantly less often than other patterns with similar compositions. The under-representation of alternating binary patterns in natural protein sequences, coupled with the observation that such patterns promote amyloid-like structures in de novo proteins, suggests that sequences of alternating polar and non-polar amino acids are inherently amyloidogenic and consequently have been disfavored by evolutionary selection.     

De novo protein design. II. Plasticity in sequence space.

It is generally accepted that many different protein sequences have similar folded structures, and that there is a relatively high probability that a new sequence possesses a previously observed fold. An indirect consequence of this is that protein design should define the sequence space accessible to a given structure, rather than providing a single optimized sequence. We have recently developed a new approach for protein sequence design, which optimizes the complete sequence of a protein based on the knowledge of its backbone structure, its amino acid composition and a physical energy function including van der Waals interactions, electrostatics, and environment free energy. The specificity of the designed sequence for its template backbone is imposed by keeping the amino acid composition fixed. Here, we show that our procedure converges in sequence space, albeit not to the native sequence of the protein. We observe that while polar residues are well conserved in our designed sequences, non-polar amino acids at the surface of a protein are often replaced by polar residues. The designed sequences provide a multiple alignment of sequences that all adopt the same three-dimensional fold. This alignment is used to derive a profile matrix for chicken triose phosphate isomerase, TIM. The matrix is found to recognize significantly the native sequence for TIM, as well as closely related sequences. Possible application of this approach to protein fold recognition is discussed.     

Interior and surface of monomeric proteins

The solvent-accessible surface area (As) of 46 monomeric proteins is calculated using atomic co-ordinates from high-resolution and well-refined crystal structures. The As of these proteins can be determined to within 1 to 2% and that of their individual residues to within 10 to 20%. The As values of proteins are correlated with their molecular weight (Mr) in the range 4000 to 35,000: the power law As = 6.3 M0.73 predicts protein As values to within 4% on average. The average water-accessible surface is found to be 57% non-polar, 24% polar and 19% charged, with 5% root-mean-square variations. The molecular surface buried inside the protein is 58% non-polar, 39% polar and 4% charged. The buried surface contains more uncharged polar groups (mostly peptides) than the surface that remains accessible, but many fewer charged groups. On average, 15% of residues in small proteins and 32% in larger ones may be classed as "buried residues", having less than 5% of their surface accessible to the solvent. The accessibilities of most other residues are evenly distributed in the range 5 to 50%. Although the fraction of buried residues increases with molecular weight, the amino acid compositions of the protein interior and surface show no systematic variation with molecular weight, except for small proteins that are often very rich in buried cysteines. From amino acid compositions of protein surfaces and interiors we calculate an effective coefficient of partition for each type of residue, and derive an implied set of transfer free energy values. This is compared with other sets of partition coefficients derived directly from experimental data. The extent to which groups of residues (charged, polar and non-polar) are buried within proteins correlates well with their hydrophobicity derived from amino acid transfer experiments. Within these three groups, the correlation is low.     

Phenylalanine promotes interaction of transmembrane domains via GxxxG motifs

Interactions of transmembrane helices play a crucial role in the folding and oligomerisation of integral membrane proteins. In order to uncover novel sequence motifs mediating these interactions, we randomised one face of a transmembrane helix with a set of non-polar or moderately polar amino acids. Those sequences capable of self-interaction upon integration into bacterial inner membranes were selected by means of the ToxR/POSSYCCAT system. A comparison between low/medium-affinity and high-affinity sequences reveals that high-affinity sequences are strongly enriched in phenylalanine residues that are frequently observed at the − 3 position of GxxxG motifs, thus yielding FxxGxxxG motifs. Mutation of Phe or GxxxG in selected sequences significantly reduces self-interaction of the transmembrane domains without affecting their efficiency of membrane integration. Conversely, grafting FxxGxxxG onto unrelated transmembrane domains strongly enhances their interaction. Further, we find that FxxGxxxG is significantly over-represented in transmembrane domains of bitopic membrane proteins. The same motif contributes to self-interaction of the vesicular stomatitis virus G protein transmembrane domain. We conclude that Phe stabilises membrane-spanning GxxxG motifs. This is one example of how the role of certain side-chains in helix-helix interfaces is modulated by sequence context.     

An investigation of protein subunit and domain interfaces

Protein structures were collected from the Brookhaven Database of tertiary architectures that displayed oligomeric association (24 molecules) or whose polypeptide folding revealed domains (34 proteins). The subunit and domain interfaces for these proteins were respectively examined from the following aspects: percentage water-accessible surface area buried by the respective associations, surface compositions and physical characteristics of the residues involved in the subunit and domain contacts, secondary structural state of the interface amino acids, preferred polar and non-polar interactions, spatial distribution of polar and non-polar residues on the interface surface, same residue interactions in the oligomeric contacts, and overall cross-section and shape of the contact surfaces. A general, consistent picture emerged for both the domain and subunit interfaces.     

Molecular dissection,tissue localization and Ca2+ binding of the ryanodine receptor of Caenorhabditis elegans

We investigated the possible role of residues at the Ccap position in an alpha-helix on protein stability. A set of 431 protein alpha-helices containing a C'-Gly from the Protein Data Bank (PDB) was analyzed, and the normalized frequencies for finding particular residues at the Ccap position, the average fraction of buried surface area, and the hydrogen bonding patterns of the Ccap residue side-chain were calculated. We found that on average the Ccap position is 70% buried and noted a significant correlation (R=0.8) between the relative burial of this residue and its hydrophobicity as defined by the Gibbs energy of transfer from octanol or cyclohexane to water. Ccap residues with polar side-chains are commonly involved in hydrogen bonding. The hydrogen bonding pattern is such that, the longer side-chains of Glu, Gln, Arg, Lys, His form hydrogen bonds with residues distal (>+/-4) in sequence, while the shorter side-chains of Asp, Asn, Ser, Thr exhibit hydrogen bonds with residues close in sequence (<+/-4), mainly involving backbone atoms. Experimentally we determined the thermodynamic propensities of residues at the Ccap position using the protein ubiquitin as a model system. We observed a large variation in the stability of the ubiquitin variants depending on the nature of the Ccap residue. Furthermore, the measured changes in stability of the ubiquitin variants correlate with the hydrophobicity of the Ccap residue. The experimental results, together with the statistical analysis of protein structures from the PDB, indicate that the key hydrophobic capping interactions between a helical residue (C3 or C4) and a residue outside the helix (C", C3' or C4') are frequently enhanced by the hydrophobic interactions with Ccap residues.     

Periodicity in alpha-helix lengths and C-capping preferences.

We surveyed 299 high resolution, non-homologous protein crystal structures for alpha-helix lengths and capping preferences. We find that helices show a preference to have close to an integral number of turns. Helices can be usefully subdivided into either "favoured length" with 6, 7, 10, 11, 13, 14, 17, 18, 21, 22, 24, 25, 28, 29 or 31 residues, or "disfavoured length" with 8, 9, 12, 15, 16, 19, 20, 23, 26, 27 or 30 residues. Favoured length helices have their N and C-caps on the same side of the helix so they can lie on the protein surface. There is no significant difference in amino acid preferences at the N terminus between favoured and disfavoured length helices. At the C terminus, favoured length helices prefer non-polar side-chains at C4 and polar amino acid residues at C2, while disfavoured length helices prefer non-polar amino acid residues at C2. There are strong periodic trends in the likelihood of terminating a helix with a Schellman or alphaL C-capping motif. These can be rationalised by the preference for a non-polar side-chain at C3 with these motifs, favouring placing C3 on the buried side of the helix. We suggest that algorithms aiming to predict helices or C-capping in proteins should include a weight for the helix length.     

Analyses of the general rule on residue pair frequencies in local amino acid sequences of soluble,ordered proteins

The amino acid sequences of soluble, ordered proteins with stable structures have evolved due to biological and physical requirements, thus distinguishing them from random sequences. Previous analyses have focused on extracting the features that frequently appear in protein substructures, such as α‐helix and β‐sheet, but the universal features of protein sequences have not been addressed. To clarify the differences between native protein sequences and random sequences, we analyzed 7368 soluble, ordered protein sequences, by inspecting the observed and expected occurrences of 400 amino acid pairs in local proximity, up to 10 residues along the sequence in comparison with their expected occurrence in random sequence. We found the trend that the hydrophobic residue pairs and the polar residue pairs are significantly decreased, whereas the pairs between a hydrophobic residue and a polar residue are increased. This trend was universally observed regardless of the secondary structure content but was not observed in protein sequences that include intrinsically disordered regions, indicating that it can be a general rule of protein foldability. The possible benefits of this rule are discussed from the viewpoints of protein aggregation and disorder, which are both caused by low‐complexity regions of hydrophobic or polar residues.     

On the significance of alternating patterns of polar and non-polar residues in beta-strands

A common assumption about protein sequences in beta-strands is that they have alternating patterns of polar and non-polar residues. It is thought that such patterns reflect the interior/exterior geometry of amino acid residue side-chains on a beta-sheet. Here we study the prevalence of simple hydrophobicity patterns in parallel and antiparallel beta-sheets in proteins of known structure and in the sequences of amyloidogenic proteins. The occurrence of 32 possible pentapeptide binary patterns (polar (P)/non-polar (N)) is computed in 1911 non-homologous protein structures. Despite their tendency to aggregate in experimentally designed proteins, the purely alternating hydrophobic/polar patterns (PNPNP and NPNPN) are most frequent in beta-sheets, typically occurring in antiparallel strands. The overall distribution of the pentapeptide binary patterns is significantly different in strands within parallel and antiparallel sheets. In both types of sheets, complementary patterns (where the hydrophobic and polar residues pair with one another) associate preferentially. We do not find alternating patterns to be common in amyloidogenic proteins or in short fragments involved directly in amyloid formation. However, we do note some similarities between patterns present in amyloidogenic sequences and those in parallel strands.     

Exploring the Levinthal limit in protein folding

According to the thermodynamic hypothesis, the native state of proteins is uniquely defined by their amino acid sequence. On the other hand, according to Levinthal, the native state is just a local minimum of the free energy and a given amino acid sequence, in the same thermodynamic conditions, can assume many, very different structures that are as thermodynamically stable as the native state. This is the Levinthal limit explored in this work. Using computer simulations, we compare the interactions that stabilize the native state of four different proteins with those that stabilize three non-native states of each protein and find that the nature of the interactions is very similar for all such 16 conformers. Furthermore, an enhancement of the degree of fluctuation of the non-native conformers can be explained by an insufficient relaxation to their local free energy minimum. These results favor Levinthal’s hypothesis that protein folding is a kinetic non-equilibrium process.     

Polar zippers

BACKGROUND: Certain proteins are known to form leucine zippers - alpha-helical coiled-coils in which the non-polar side chains of two leucine-rich helices intermesh. We recently presented the first evidence for a polar zipper, formed by the carboxy-terminal peptides of the eight subunits of Ascaris haemoglobin. The evidence was based on the presence of pairs of acidic residues alternating with pairs of basic residues ( + + - - ) in an amino-acid sequence that has since been shown to be incomplete. The complete sequence, derived from the haemoglobin's cDNA, now shows a self-complementary polar sequence extending along the entire length of its 24-residue carboxy-terminal peptide. RESULTS: From the complete sequence, it is clear that the eight identical subunits of the haemoglobin could be held together by an eight-stranded antiparallel beta barrel made up of the carboxy-terminal 24 residues of each of the subunits, such that each strand forms 10 salt bridges with each of its neighbours. A computer search of the protein database revealed similar, but shorter, + + - - repeats in several other proteins. It also revealed long repeats of alternating arginine and aspartate residues, and long stretches of only glutamines, or only serines, suggestive of several other kinds of polar zippers. CONCLUSION: Several proteins have amino-acid sequences that suggest the formation of polar zippers made of beta strands. These could form antiparallel pleated sheets linked together by hydrogen bonds between polar side chains both above and below the plane of the sheets. Polar zippers may be important in welding together oligomeric proteins which have subunits lacking the extensive complementary surfaces necessary for stability, or in promoting the association of functionally complementary proteins.     

The energetics of off-rotamer protein side-chain conformations

Non-rotameric ("off-rotamer") conformations are commonly observed for the side-chains of protein crystal structures. This study examines whether such conformations are real or artifactual by comparing the energetics of on and off-rotamer side-chain conformations calculated with the CHARMM energy function. Energy-based predictions of side-chain orientation are carried out by rigid-geometry mapping in the presence of the fixed protein environment for 1709 non-polar side-chains in 24 proteins for which high-resolution (2.0 A or better) structures are available. For on-rotamer conformations, 97.6 % are correctly predicted; i.e. they correspond to the absolute minima of their local side-chain energy maps (generally to within 10 degrees or less). By contrast, for the observed off-rotamer side-chain conformations, 63.8 % are predicted correctly. This difference is statistically significant (P<0.001) and suggests that while most of the observed off-rotamer conformations are real, many of the erroneously predicted ones are likely to be artifacts of the X-ray refinements. Probabilities for off-rotamer conformations of the non-polar side-chains are calculated to be 5.0-6.1 % by adaptive umbrella-sampled molecular dynamics trajectories of individual amino acid residues in vacuum and in the presence of an average protein or aqueous dielectric environment. These results correspond closely to the 5.7 % off-rotamer fraction predicted by the rigid-geometry mapping studies. Since these values are about one-half of the 10.2 % off-rotamer fraction observed in the X-ray structures, they support the conclusion that many of the latter are artifacts. In both the rigid-geometry mapping and the molecular dynamics studies, the discrepancies between the predicted and observed fractions of off-rotamer conformations are largest for leucine residues (approximately 6 % versus 16.6 %). The simulations for the isolated amino acid residues indicate that the real off-rotamer frequency of 5-6 % is consistent with the internal side-chain and local side-chain-backbone energetics and does not originate from shifts due to the protein. The present results suggest that energy-based rotation maps can be used to find side-chain positional artifacts that appear in crystal structures based on refinements in the 2 A resolution range.     

Sequence optimization for native state stability determines the evolution and folding kinetics of a small protein

Investigating the relative importance of protein stability, function, and folding kinetics in driving protein evolution has long been hindered by the fact that we can only compare modern natural proteins, the products of the very process we seek to understand, to each other, with no external references or baselines. Through a large-scale all-atom simulation of protein evolution, we have created a large diverse alignment of SH3 domain sequences which have been selected only for native state stability, with no other influencing factors. Although the average pairwise identity between computationally evolved and natural sequences is only 17%, the residue frequency distributions of the computationally evolved sequences are similar to natural SH3 sequences at 86% of the positions in the domain, suggesting that optimization for the native state structure has dominated the evolution of natural SH3 domains. Additionally, the positions which play a consistent role in the transition state of three well-characterized SH3 domains (by phi-value analysis) are structurally optimized for the native state, and vice versa. Indeed, we see a specific and significant correlation between sequence optimization for native state stability and conservation of transition state structure.     

Tolerance to the substitution of buried apolar residues by charged residues in the homologous protein structures

Occurrence and accommodation of charged amino acid residues in proteins that are structurally equivalent to buried non-polar residues in homologues have been investigated. Using a dataset of 1,852 homologous pairs of crystal structures of proteins available at 2A or better resolution, 14,024 examples of apolar residues in the structurally conserved regions replaced by charged residues in homologues have been identified. Out of 2,530 cases of buried apolar residues, 1,677 of the equivalent charged residues in homologues are exposed and the rest of the charged residues are buried. These drastic substitutions are most often observed in homologous protein pairs with low sequence identity (<30%) and in large protein domains (>300 residues). Such buried charged residues in the large proteins are often located in the interface of sub-domains or in the interface of structural repeats, Beyond 7A of residue depth of buried apolar residues, or less than 4% of solvent accessibility, almost all the substituting charged residues are buried. It is also observed that acidic sidechains have higher preference to get buried than the positively charged residues. There is a preference for buried charged residues to get accommodated in the interior by forming hydrogen bonds with another sidechain than the main chain. The sidechains interacting with a buried charged residue are most often located in the structurally conserved regions of the alignment. About 50% of the observations involving hydrogen bond between buried charged sidechain and another sidechain correspond to salt bridges. Among the buried charged residues interacting with the main chain, positively charged sidechains form hydrogen bonds commonly with main chain carbonyls while the negatively charged residues are accommodated by hydrogen bonding with the main chain amides. These carbonyls and amides are usually located in the loops that are structurally variable among homologous proteins.     

Improving computational protein design by using structure‐derived sequence profile

Designing a protein sequence that will fold into a predefined structure is of both practical and fundamental interest. Many successful, computational designs in the last decade resulted from improved understanding of hydrophobic and polar interactions between side chains of amino acid residues in stabilizing protein tertiary structures. However, the coupling between main‐chain backbone structure and local sequence has yet to be fully addressed. Here, we attempt to account for such coupling by using a sequence profile derived from the sequences of five residue fragments in a fragment library that are structurally matched to the five‐residue segments contained in a target structure. We further introduced a term to reduce low complexity regions of designed sequences. These two terms together with optimized reference states for amino‐acid residues were implemented in the RosettaDesign program. The new method, called RosettaDesign‐SR, makes a 12% increase (from 34 to 46%) in fraction of proteins whose designed sequences are more than 35% identical to wild‐type sequences. Meanwhile, it reduces 8% (from 22% to 14%) to the number of designed sequences that are not homologous to any known protein sequences according to psi‐blast. More importantly, the sequences designed by RosettaDesign‐SR have 2–3% more polar residues at the surface and core regions of proteins and these surface and core polar residues have about 4% higher sequence identity to wild‐type sequences than by RosettaDesign. Thus, the proteins designed by RosettaDesign‐SR should be less likely to aggregate and more likely to have unique structures due to more specific polar interactions. Proteins 2010. © 2010 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Prudent modeling of core polar residues in computational protein design

Hydrogen bond interactions were surveyed in a set of protein structures. Compared to surface positions, polar side-chains at core positions form a greater number of intra-molecular hydrogen bonds. Furthermore, the majority of polar side-chains at core positions form at least one hydrogen bond to main-chain atoms that are not involved in hydrogen bonds to other main-chain atoms. Based on this structural survey, hydrogen bond rules were generated for each polar amino acid for use in protein core design. In the context of protein core design, these prudent polar rules were used to eliminate from consideration polar amino acid rotamers that do not form a minimum number of hydrogen bonds. As an initial test, the core of Escherichia coli thioredoxin was selected as a design target. For this target, the prudent polar strategy resulted in a minor increase in computational complexity compared to a strategy that did not allow polar residues. Dead-end elimination was used to identify global minimum energy conformations for the prudent polar and no polar strategies. The prudent polar strategy identified a protein sequence that was thermodynamically stabilized by 2.5 kcal/mol relative to wild-type thioredoxin and 2.2 kcal/mol relative to a thioredoxin variant whose core was designed without polar residues.     

Satisfaction of hydrogen-bonding potential influences the conservation of polar sidechains

Although polar amino acids tend to be found on the surface of proteins due to their hydrophilic nature, their important roles within the core of proteins are now becoming better recognized. It has long been understood that a significant number of mainchain functions will not achieve hydrogen bond satisfaction through the formation of secondary structures; in these circumstances, it is generally buried polar residues that provide hydrogen bond satisfaction. Here, we describe an analysis of the hydrogen-bonding of polar amino acids in a set of structurally aligned protein families. This allows us not only to calculate the conservation of each polar residue but also to assess whether conservation is correlated with the hydrogen-bonding potential of polar sidechains. We show that those polar sidechains whose hydrogen-bonding potential is satisfied tend to be more conserved than their unsatisfied or nonhydrogen-bonded counterparts, particularly when buried. Interestingly, these buried and satisfied polar residues are significantly more conserved than buried hydrophobic residues. Forming hydrogen bonds to mainchain amide atoms also influences conservation, with those satisfied buried polar residues that form two hydrogen bonds to mainchain amides being significantly more conserved than those that form only one or none. These results indicate that buried polar residues whose hydrogen-bonding potential is satisfied are likely to have important roles in maintaining protein structure.