Phenomenon Of Pseudomutagenesis: Experiments with Modifiers of Cell Metabolism in Human Lymphocytes

The term pseudomutagens is suggested for factors that increase the spontaneous mutation level not by induction of DNA molecule changes but as a result of inhibition of the repair of spontaneous pre-mutation lesions. The expected regularities of pseudomutagen effects, which are suitable as criteria for their identification, are considered. The experimental results on the effects of six modifiers of cell metabolism in human lymphocytes are analyzed. Four of the modifiers (5-fluorodeoxyuridine, sodium cyanide, sodium fluoride and monoiodoacetic acid) behaved as pseudomutagens according to all the criteria applied. 2,4-Dinitrophenol proved to be a true mutagen. Adenosine diphosphate revealed unusual properties: it inhibited the repair of spontaneous lesions but decreased the frequency of structural mutations induced by radiation. The significance of the phenomenon of the pseudomutagenesis for the problem of environmental mutagens/carcinogens is discussed.     

The Origin of Spontaneous Mutation in SACCHAROMYCES CEREVISIAE

Characterization of two antimutator loci in yeast shows that both are members of the same mutagenic repair system known to be responsible for almost all induced mutation (Lawrence and Christensen 1976, 1979a,b; Prakash 1976). One of the these newly isolated antimutator mutations is an allele of rev3 (Lemontt 1971b). Two other alleles of rev3 were tested and were also found to be antimutators. Double mutants carrying rev3 and mutator mutations of rad3, rad51 or rad18 are like rev3 single mutants with respect to spontaneous mutation rate, supporting the hypothesis (Hastings, Quah and von Borstel 1976) that many mutators in yeast act by channelling spontaneous lesions from accurate to mutagenic repair. However, the enhanced mutation rate seen in a radiation-resistant mutator mutant mut1 is not dependent on REV3, but is dependent on another gene designated ANT1. An additive effect on the reduction in spontaneous mutation, seen in the ant1 rev3 double-mutant strain, leads to the conclusion that at least 90% of spontaneous mutations seen in the wild type are caused by mutagenic repair of spontaneous lesions.     

Bulge defects do not destabilize negatively supercoiled DNA

The conformational properties of DNA lesions such as extrahelical bulges are presumed to be essential for recognition of defects in DNA structure by a cell's genomic repair machinery. Efficient recognition and repair of lesions by DNA-repair systems occurs despite the wide range of normal heterogeneities in DNA structure, including features such as sequence-dependent bends. The effects of global negative supercoiling on the structure of DNA lesions have been largely unexplored. We have investigated the behavior of several plasmid DNAs containing bulge defects with up to five extrahelical adenine residues. Using two-dimensional agarose-gel electrophoresis, we show that there is no spontaneous cooperative unwinding of these bulge loci up to native levels of negative supercoiling (sigma = -0.055) under our conditions.     

A superfamily of protein tags: ubiquitin,SUMO and related modifiers

The biological functions of many proteins are altered by their covalent attachment to polypeptide modifiers. The best-known example of this type of modification is ubiquitination. Ubiquitin has a well-documented role in targeting proteins for degradation by the proteasome, but additional effects of protein ubiquitination are now being uncovered. Furthermore, multiple polypeptides that are distinct from, but related to, ubiquitin are also enzymatically coupled to target macromolecules, and these ubiquitin-like proteins participate in diverse biological processes such as DNA repair, autophagy and signal transduction.     

The effect of oxidative metabolism on spontaneous Pol zeta-dependent translesion synthesis in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

DNA lesions can stall or block high-fidelity polymerases, thus inhibiting replication. To bypass such lesions, low-fidelity translesion synthesis (TLS) polymerases can be used to insert a nucleotide across from the lesion or extend from a lesion:base mispair. When DNA repair is compromised in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, spontaneous DNA lesions can lead to a novel mutational event in which a frameshift is accompanied by one or more base pair substitutions. These "complex frameshifts" are dependent upon the TLS polymerase Pol zeta, and provide a mutational signature for mutagenic Pol zeta-dependent activity. In the current study, we have found that a specific subset of the Pol zeta-dependent mutational events requires oxidative metabolism. These results suggest that translesion bypass of spontaneously oxidized DNA bases can be a significant source of mutagenesis in repair compromised cells.     

Lethal and potentially lethal lesions induced by radiation--a unified repair model

A model of radiation action is described which unifies several of the major existing concepts which have been applied to cell killing. Called the lethal and potentially lethal (LPL) model, it combines the ideas of lesion interaction, irreparable lesions caused by single tracks, linear lesion fixation, lesion repair via first-order kinetics, and binary misrepair. Two different kinds of lesions are hypothesized: irreparable (lethal) and repairable (potentially lethal) lesions. They are tentatively being identified with DNA double-strand breaks of different severity. Two processes compete for depletion of the potentially lethal lesions: correct repair following first-order kinetics, and misrepair following second-order kinetics. Fixation of these lesions can also occur. The model applies presently only to plateau (stationary)-phase cells. Radiobiological phenomena described include effects of low dose rate, high LET, and repair kinetics as measured with repair inhibitors such as hypertonic solution and beta-arabinofuranosyladenine (beta-araA). One consequence of the model is that repair of sublethal damage and the slow component of the repair of potentially lethal damage are two manifestations of the same repair process. Hypertonic treatment fixes a completely new class of lesions which normally repair correctly. Another consequence of the model is that the initial slope of the survival curve depends on the amount of time available for repair after irradiation. The "dose-rate factor" occurring in several linear-quadratic formulations is shown to emerge when appropriate low-dose and long-repair-time approximations are made.     

Cytostatic, cytotoxic and mutagenic effects of voacristine, an indole alkaloid in wild-type and repair-deficient yeasts

Voacristine, an indole alkaloid isolated from the leaves of Ervatamia coronaria (Stapf.) (Apocynaceae) has dose-dependent cytostatic and cytotoxic effects on cultures of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. These inhibitory effects take place only in growing cells. Among the different repair-deficient mutants examined, a mutant defective in excision-resynthesis repair pathway (rad3-e5) was found to be the most sensitive to such a toxic effect. The mutant rad52-1 blocked in the DNA strand break repair pathway showed an intermediary sensitivity to the lethal effect induced by this indole alkaloid, whereas the mutant defective in the mutagenic repair pathway (rad6-1) demonstrated practically the same sensitivity as the wild-type strain. The nuclear reversion mutation for the locus lysl-1 was induced by voacristine, whereas the mitochondrial "petite" mutation was not induced by this alkaloid. These results indicate that the lesions induced by voacristine in vivo are likely to be of the adducts type; such damage is repairable in the wild-type; the DNA strand break repair pathway plays a minor role in the repair of voacristine-induced lesions.     

Brc1-mediated rescue of Smc5/6 deficiency: requirement for multiple nucleases and a novel Rad18 function

Smc5/6 is a structural maintenance of chromosomes complex, related to the cohesin and condensin complexes. Recent studies implicate Smc5/6 as being essential for homologous recombination. Each gene is essential, but hypomorphic alleles are defective in the repair of a diverse array of lesions. A particular allele of smc6 (smc6-74) is suppressed by overexpression of Brc1, a six-BRCT domain protein that is required for DNA repair during S-phase. This suppression requires the postreplication repair (PRR) protein Rhp18 and the structure-specific endonucleases Slx1/4 and Mus81/Eme1. However, we show here that the contribution of Rhp18 is via a novel pathway that is independent of PCNA ubiquitination and PRR. Moreover, we identify Exo1 as an additional nuclease required for Brc1-mediated suppression of smc6-74, independent of mismatch repair. Further, the Apn2 endonuclease is required for the viability of smc6 mutants without extrinsic DNA damage, although this is not due to a defect in base excision repair. Several nucleotide excision repair genes are similarly shown to ensure viability of smc6 mutants. The requirement for excision factors for the viability of smc6 mutants is consistent with an inability to respond to spontaneous lesions by Smc5/6-dependent recombination.     

Methionine reduces spontaneous and alkylation-induced mutagenesis in Saccharomyces cerevisiae cells deficient in O6-methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase

The exposure of DNA to reactive intracellular metabolites is thought to be a major cause of spontaneous mutagenesis. DNA alkylation is implicated in the above process by the fact that bacterial and yeast cells lacking DNA alkylation-specific repair genes exhibit elevated spontaneous mutation rates. The origin of the intracellular alkylating molecules is not clear; however, S-adenosylmethionine (SAM) has been proposed as one source because it has a reactive methyl group known to methylate proteins and DNA. We supplemented yeast cultures with excess methionine and examined the effects of increased endogenous SAM concentration on spontaneous and alkylation-induced mutagenesis in the absence of various DNA repair pathways. Our results show that either the excess methionine, or the increased SAM produced as a result of this treatment, is able to protect yeast cells from mutagenesis, and that this effect is alkylation-damage-specific. The protective effect was observed only in the mgt1 mutant deficient in the O(6)-methylguanine-DNA repair methyltransferase, but not in the wild type or other DNA repair-deficient strains, indicating that the protection is specific for O-methyl lesions. Thus, our results may lend support to the recently reported chemopreventive effect of SAM in rodents and further suggest that the observed tumor prevention by SAM may be, in part, due to its suppression of spontaneous mutagenesis in mammals. Given that a strong correlation has been established between O(6)-methylguanine and carcinogenicity, this study may offer a novel approach to preventing carcinogenesis.     

The time course of repair of ultraviolet-induced DNA damage; implications for the structural organisation of repair

Alternative molecular mechanisms can be envisaged for the cellular repair of UV-damaged DNA. In the "random collision" model, DNA damage distributed throughout the genome is recognised and repaired by a process of random collision between DNA damage and repair enzymes. The other model assumes a "processive" mechanism, whereby DNA is scanned for damage by a repair complex moving steadily along its length. These two models give different predictions concerning the time course of repair. Random collision should result in a declining rate of repair with time as the concentration of lesions in the DNA falls; but the processive model predicts a constant rate of repair until scanning is complete. We have examined the time course of DNA repair in human fibroblasts given low (generally sublethal) doses of UV light. Using 3 distinct assays, we find no sign of a constant repair rate after 4 J/m2 or less, even when the first few hours after irradiation are examined. Thus DNA repair is likely to depend on random collision. The implications of this finding for the structural organisation of repair are discussed.     

Involvement of Escherichia coli DNA polymerase IV in tolerance of cytotoxic alkylating DNA lesions in vivo

Escherichia coli PolIV, a DNA polymerase capable of catalyzing synthesis past replication-blocking DNA lesions, belongs to the most ubiquitous branch of Y-family DNA polymerases. The goal of this study is to identify spontaneous DNA damage that is bypassed specifically and accurately by PolIV in vivo. We increased the amount of spontaneous DNA lesions using mutants deficient for different DNA repair pathways and measured mutation frequency in PolIV-proficient and -deficient backgrounds. We found that PolIV performs an error-free bypass of DNA damage that accumulates in the alkA tag genetic background. This result indicates that PolIV is involved in the error-free bypass of cytotoxic alkylating DNA lesions. When the amount of cytotoxic alkylating DNA lesions is increased by the treatment with chemical alkylating agents, PolIV is required for survival in an alkA tag-proficient genetic background as well. Our study, together with the reported involvement of the mammalian PolIV homolog, Polkappa, in similar activity, indicates that Y-family DNA polymerases from the DinB branch can be added to the list of evolutionarily conserved molecular mechanisms that counteract cytotoxic effects of DNA alkylation. This activity is of major biological relevance because alkylating agents are continuously produced endogenously in all living cells and are also present in the environment.     

Five repair pathways in one context: chromatin modification during DNA repair.

The eukaryotic cell is faced with more than 10 000 various kinds of DNA lesions per day. Failure to repair such lesions can lead to mutations, genomic instability, or cell death. Therefore, cells have developed 5 major repair pathways in which different kinds of DNA damage can be detected and repaired: homologous recombination, nonhomologous end joining, nucleotide excision repair, base excision repair, and mismatch repair. However, the efficient repair of DNA damage is complicated by the fact that the genomic DNA is packaged through histone and nonhistone proteins into chromatin, a highly condensed structure that hinders DNA accessibility and its subsequent repair. Therefore, the cellular repair machinery has to circumvent this natural barrier to gain access to the damaged site in a timely manner. Repair of DNA lesions in the context of chromatin occurs with the assistance of ATP-dependent chromatin-remodeling enzymes and histone-modifying enzymes, which allow access of the necessary repair factors to the lesion. Here we review recent studies that elucidate the interplay between chromatin modifiers / remodelers and the major DNA repair pathways.     

Spontaneous mutagenesis: experimental, genetic and other factors.

Spontaneous mutations are "the net result of all that can go wrong with DNA during the life cycle of an organism" (Glickman et al., 1986). Thus, the types and amounts of spontaneous mutations produced are the resultant of all the cellular processes that are mutagenic and those that are antimutagenic. It is not widely appreciated that the types and frequencies of spontaneous mutations change markedly with subtle changes in experimental conditions. All types of mutations are produced spontaneously, i.e., base substitutions, frameshifts, insertions and deletions. However, very few papers have appeared that are devoted exclusively to the study of the mechanisms of spontaneous mutagenesis, and of the subtle experimental factors that affect the types and frequencies of spontaneous mutations. This is unfortunate because spontaneous mutagenesis appears to play a major role in evolution, aging, and carcinogenesis. This review emphasizes subtle experimental variables that markedly affect the results of a spontaneous mutation experiment. A thorough understanding of these variables eliminates the need for a theory of "directed" mutagenesis. The intrinsic instability of DNA, and the types of normal metabolic lesions that are produced in DNA that lead to mutations via errors made in replication, repair, and recombination are reviewed, as is the genetic control of spontaneous mutagenesis. As with spontaneous mutagenesis, spontaneous carcinogenesis can also be considered to be the net result of all that can go wrong with DNA during the life of an organism.     

Enhancing Survival of Mouse Oocytes Following Chemotherapy or Aging by Targeting Bax and Rad51

Background

Therapeutic approaches to preserve fertility in females undergoing cancer treatments are currently ineffective. This is partly due to limited knowledge of the molecular mechanisms that injured germ cells elicit to repair damage and survive or to abort repair and activate biochemical pathways leading to death. So far, we know that following spontaneously occurring or drug-induced DNA damage, the efficiency of DNA repair is a critical determinant of the cell''s fate. The protein encoded by the Rad51 gene is one of several components recruited for homologous recombination-dependent DNA double-strand break repair in both somatic cells and germ cells. Recently, we showed that microinjection of recombinant Rad51 into AKR/J mouse oocytes decreased the extent of spontaneous DNA double-strand breaks, suppressed apoptosis, and restored the developmental competence in AKR/J embryos. Herein we characterized the nature of chemotherapy-induced lesions in oocytes, and the associated individual components of the DNA damage sensor and repair apparatus. For comparison, we also assessed parallel spontaneous changes in aging oocytes.

Methods

Data collected were derived from: analysis of apoptosis; immunodepletion; oocyte microinjections; immunocytochemistry; immunofluorescence; and CHIP-like assays.

Results

Our data show that: (i) DNA damage in oocytes can be induced by both chemotherapy and spontaneously by the aging process; (ii) oocytes possess the machinery and capability for repairing such DNA damage; (iii) Rad51 is a critical player in the repair of both chemotherapy-induced and spontaneously-sustained DNA damage; and (iv) in response to damage, oocytes exhibit an inverse functional relationship between presence of Bax and activity of Rad51.

Conclusion/Significance

Our results establish Rad51 and/or Bax as potential candidates that can be targeted for development of individualized chemotherapeutic interventions that are effective, but minimal in toxicity. The use of Rad51 and Bax modulating compounds could offer women the opportunity to maintain fully functional germ cells despite cancer treatments or aging.     

Imbalanced Base Excision Repair Increases Spontaneous Mutation and Alkylation Sensitivity in Escherichia coli

Inappropriate expression of 3-methyladenine (3MeA) DNA glycosylases has been shown to have harmful effects on microbial and mammalian cells. To understand the underlying reasons for this phenomenon, we have determined how DNA glycosylase activity and substrate specificity modulate glycosylase effects in Escherichia coli. We compared the effects of two 3MeA DNA glycosylases with very different substrate ranges, namely, the Saccharomyces cerevisiae Mag1 and the E. coli Tag glycosylases. Both glycosylases increased spontaneous mutation, decreased cell viability, and sensitized E. coli to killing by the alkylating agent methyl methanesulfonate. However, Tag had much less harmful effects than Mag1. The difference between the two enzymes' effects may be accounted for by the fact that Tag almost exclusively excises 3MeA lesions, whereas Mag1 excises a broad range of alkylated and other purines. We infer that the DNA lesions responsible for changes in spontaneous mutation, viability, and alkylation sensitivity are abasic sites and secondary lesions resulting from processing abasic sites via the base excision repair pathway.     

Plasmid pGW16, a derivative of pKM101, increases post-UV DNA synthesis, but sensitises some strains of Escherichia coli to UV

Plasmid pKM101, which carries muc genes that are analogous in function to chromosomal umu genes, protected Escherichia coli strains AB1157 uvrB+ umuC+, JC3890 uvrB umuC+, TK702 uvrB+ umuC and TK501 uvrB umuC against ultraviolet irradiation (UV). Plasmid pGW16, a derivative of pKM101 selected for its increased spontaneous mutator effect, also gave some protection to the UmuC-deficient strains, TK702 and TK501. However, it sensitised the wild-type strain AB1157 to low, but protected against high doses of UV, whilst sensitising strain JC3890 to all UV doses tested. Even though its UV-protecting effects varied, pGW16 was shown to increase both spontaneous and UV-induced mutation in all strains. Another derivative of pKM101, plasmid pGW12, was shown to have lost all spontaneous and UV-induced mutator effects and did not affect post-UV survival. Plasmids pKM101 and pGW16 increased post-UV DNA synthesis in strains AB1157 and TK702, whereas pGW12 had no effect. Similarly, the wild-type UV-protecting plasmids R46, R446b and R124 increased post-UV DNA synthesis in strain TK501, but the non-UV-protecting plasmids R1, RP4 and R6K had no effect. These results accord with the model for error-prone DNA repair that requires umu or muc gene products for chain elongation after base insertion opposite non-coding lesions. They also suggest that the UV-sensitizing effects of pGW16 on umu+ strains can be explained in terms of overactive DNA repair resulting in lethal, rather than repaired UV-induced lesions.