Shed NKG2D ligand boosts NK cell immunity

Ligands for natural killer (NK) cell activating receptors can be released from tumor cells and are believed to promote tumor growth by acting as decoys for effector lymphocytes. In a recent paper published in Science, Deng et al. report another scenario in which a shed form of the MULT1 mouse NKG2D ligand boosts NK cell functions.Natural killer (NK) cells are cytolytic and cytokine-producing lymphocytes of the innate immune system that participate in the control of tumor growth and microbial infections¹. NK cell effector activities are tightly controlled by a fine balance of inhibitory and activating signals delivered by surface receptors. Activating receptors can recognize two types of ligands, self-molecules encoded by the host''s own genome whose expression is upregulated upon cellular stress, or exogenous molecules produced by microbes during infection. NKG2D, one of the best characterized activating receptor expressed by NK and T cells, binds to several different ligands in human and mouse². NKG2D ligands are poorly expressed on the vast majority of normal cell surfaces, but are upregulated on tumor and virus-infected cells. In addition, NKG2D ligands can be released by both surface cleavage and exosome excretion. It has been reported that shed ligands can block tumor cell recognition by effector cells by preventing NKG2D interaction with its ligands³. However, several reports do not correlate the presence of soluble ligands with decreased NKG2D expression nor functional activities.Deng et al.⁴ focused their analysis on the NKG2D mouse ligand MULT1, which is commonly overexpressed on primary tumor cells. They first showed that MULT1-transduced fibroblast can cleave MULT1 from the plasma membrane, resulting in a released shed form in the supernatant. Shed MULT1 is of high affinity to NKG2D (∼13 nM) similar to recombinant MULT1. They further reveal the presence of shed MULT1 in the serum of mice developing spontaneous MULT1⁺ tumors. Interestingly, the authors detected a very high concentration of shed MULT1 in the sera of Apoe^−/− mice exhibiting severe atherosclerosis and liver inflammation. Given that these autoimmune injuries observed in this mouse model depend on NKG2D activity⁵, it was unlikely that shed MULT1 exert an inhibitory effect on immunity.Surprisingly, the authors further showed that mouse tumor cells engineered to release a secreted form of MULT1 (secMULT1) similar to the shed MULT1 were rejected when injected into syngenic mice. Tumor rejection is dependent on NK cells as cells grow in NK but not in CD8⁺ T cell-depleted host and requires NKG2D. Importantly, the controlled release of secMULT1 from tumors harboring inducible secMULT1 promotes tumor rejection. To rule out the possibility that tumor cell rejection was due to intrinsic modifications of tumor cells, the author monitored the rejection of a mixture of 9:1 secMULT1⁻: secMULT1⁺ tumor cells and showed an improved antitumoral effect on both secMULT1⁺ and, importantly, secMULT1⁻ tumors. In addition, direct intratumoral injection of recombinant MULT1 promotes tumor rejection. These results suggested that soluble MULT1 mobilizes or activates anti-tumor effector cells. Deng et al. further reported increased frequencies of cytotoxic and IFN-γ-secreting NK cells associated with secMULT1⁺ tumors as compared to control tumor cells. Altogether, these data suggest that a shed NKG2D ligand can promote tumor rejection by boosting NK cell effector functions.Shed MULT1 could crosslink NKG2D and thus activate NK cells. However, shed and secMULT1 are monomeric molecules similar to the recombinant MULT1 which fails to activate NK cells in vitro. Formation of multivalent structures in vivo was not detected. In addition, whereas the transmembrane form of MULT1 can activate NK cells by crosslinking NKG2D and induces NKG2D downregulation, soluble MULT1 upregulates NKG2D on the NK cell surface. This upregulation is probably due do a decreased downregulation of NKG2D surface expression because no increase in NKG2D mRNA or protein was observed. Based on these findings, the authors hypothesized that NKG2D ligands expressed on non-tumor host cell membrane continuously engage NKG2D on NK cells, leading to NKG2D downregulation and NK cell desensitization, whereas soluble MULT1 blocks these interactions to increase NK cell responsiveness (Figure 1). Along this line, NK cells from mutant mice genetically deficient for the NKG2D ligand expressed by tumor-associated myeloid cells are not desensitized.Open in a separate windowFigure 1Tumor-associated cells express NKG2DL which can desensitize NK cells. Tumor shedding of MULT1 delivers soluble MULT1 that outcompetes for NKG2D binding and prevents NK cell desensitization. Boosted NK cell functions lead to improved tumor cell rejection by other activating receptors.The induction of cell desensitization by a frequent or even constant stimulation is a very common mechanism across living objects. Regarding NK cells, another example of tuning via desensitization resides in the impact of the long lasting absence of MHC class I molecules in their environment. Indeed, NK cells are hyporesponsive in a MHC-I-deficient host⁶. There are accumulating data indicating that in the absence of engagement of inhibitory receptors for MHC class I molecules, NK cells get desensitized due to their chronic interaction with endogenous stimulating ligands⁷. Indeed, in the absence of engagement of this inhibitory pathway, NK cell activation would be unleashed⁸. This scenario is supported by a series of in vitro and in vivo experiments in which NK cells are desensitized following chronic exposure to stimulatory molecules expressed at the surface of interacting cells^9,10. Thus, the induction of MHC class I downregulation or NKG2D ligand upregulation boosts NK cell function, whereas the sustained lack of MHC class I or expression of NKG2D ligands impairs NK cell reactivity. This tuning of immune response as a function of the speed of change of the stimuli detected by lymphocytes is at the center of the recently proposed Discontinuity Theory¹¹.Finally, consistent with their findings with secMULT1 but somewhat counter-intuitively, Deng et al. also show that NKG2D receptor deficiency or blockade using anti-NKG2D monoclonal antibodies mimics the effect of soluble MULT1. Indeed, in both conditions, NK cell effector functions are boosted, resulting in improved tumor rejection. Similarly, blocking other NK activating receptors, such as NKp46, may also lead to NK cell desensitization¹². Checkpoint inhibitory receptors are revolutionizing the treatment of cancers by inhibiting the inhibitory receptors. The findings reported by Deng et al. together with earlier results propose alternative strategies of cancer treatment using antibodies that are directed against activating receptors. In the case of NKG2D, the chronic engagement of NK cells with membrane-bound NKG2D ligand affects not only NKG2D-dependent but also NKG2D-independent signaling pathways⁹. The blockade of NKG2D desensitization by antibodies directed against NKG2D should thus also boost NK cell activation via other pathways, such as antibody-dependent cell cytotoxicity. However, the precise identification of the ligand-receptor pair involved in the control of tumors by NK cells will be a limiting factor to these innovative therapeutic approaches. Indeed, antibodies against activating receptors should be designed to boost NK cell reactivity but should not block the recognition of the tumors by NK cells. Finally, as the tuning of NK cell reactivity by soluble NKG2D ligands depends on their affinity for NKG2D, the pre-clinical development of this new class of drug candidates might reveal novel pharmacokinetics and the pharmacodynamics guidelines.     

Making sense of the diverse ligand recognition by NKG2D

NKG2D recognizes multiple diverse ligands. Despite recent efforts in determining the crystal structures of NKG2D-ligand complexes, the principle governing this receptor-ligand recognition and hence the criteria for identifying unknown ligands of NKG2D remain central issues to be resolved. Here we compared the molecular recognition between NKG2D and three of the known ligands, UL16 binding protein (ULBP), MHC class I-like molecule, and retinoic acid early inducible gene as observed in the ligand-complexed crystal structures. The comparison shows that while the receptor uses a common interface region to bind the three diverse ligands, each ligand forms a distinct, but overlapping, set of hydrogen bonds, hydrophobic interactions, and salt bridges, illustrating the underlying principle of NKG2D-ligand recognition being the conservation in overall shape complementarity and binding energy while permitting variation in ligand sequence through induced fit recognition. To further test this hypothesis and to distinguish between diverse recognition and promiscuous ligand binding, four ULBP3 interface mutations, H21A, E76A, R82M, and D169A, were generated to each disrupt a single hydrogen bond or salt bridge. All mutant ULBP3 displayed reduced receptor binding, suggesting a specific, rather than promiscuous, receptor-ligand recognition. Mutants with severe loss of binding affect the receptor interactions that are mostly buried. Finally, a receptor-ligand recognition algorithm was developed to assist the identification of diverse NKG2D ligands based on evaluating the potential hydrogen bonds, hydrophobic interactions, and salt bridges at the receptor-ligand interface.     

Comparative genomic analysis of mammalian NKG2D ligand family genes provides insights into their origin and evolution

NKG2D is a major activating receptor of natural killer cells. Its ligands are major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I-like molecules whose expression is induced by cellular stresses such as infections and tumorigenesis. Humans have two families of NKG2D ligands (NKG2DL): MHC class I-related chains (MIC) encoded in the MHC and UL16-binding proteins (ULBP) encoded outside the MHC. By contrast, mice have only the latter family of ligands; instead, they have non-MHC-encoded MILL molecules that are closely related to MIC, but do not function as NKG2DL. To gain insights into the origin and evolution of MIC, ULBP, and MILL gene families, we conducted comparative genomic analysis of NKG2DL family genes in five mammalian species. In the opossum MHC, we identified a ULBP-like gene adjacent to a previously described MIC-like gene, suggesting that ULBP genes were originally encoded in the MHC. The opossum genome also contained a transcribed MILL-like gene in a region syntenic to the rodent regions encoding MILL molecules. These observations indicate that MIC-, ULBP-, and MILL-like genes emerged before the divergence of placental and marsupial mammals. Comparison of the human, cattle, rat, mouse, and opossum genomes indicates that after emigration from the MHC, ULBP genes underwent extensive duplications in each species. In mice, some of the ULBP genes appear to have been translocated telomerically on the same chromosome, forming a major cluster of existent NKG2DL genes.     

ULBP4 is a novel ligand for human NKG2D

The ULBPs are a family of MHC class I-related molecules. We have previously shown that ULBPs 1, 2, and 3 are functional ligands of the NKG2D/DAP10 receptor complex on human natural killer (NK) cells. Here, we describe a new member of the ULBP family, ULBP4, which contains predicted transmembrane and cytoplasmic domains, unlike the other ULBPs, which are GPI-linked proteins. Transduction of ULBP4 into EL4 cells confers the ability to bind recombinant NKG2D and mediates increased cytotoxic activity by human NK cells, consistent with the role of ULBPs as ligands for the NKG2D/DAP10 activating receptors. Tissue expression of ULBP4 differs from other members of the family, in that it is expressed predominantly in the skin.     

Down-regulation of the NKG2D ligand MICA by the human cytomegalovirus glycoprotein UL142

Human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) employs a variety of strategies to modify or evade the host immune response, and natural killer (NK) cells play a crucial role in controlling cytomegalovirus infections in mice and humans. Activation of NK cells through the receptor NKG2D/DAP10 leads to killing of NKG2D ligand-expressing cells. We have previously shown that HCMV is able to down-regulate the surface expression of some NKG2D ligands, ULBP1, ULBP2, and MICB via the viral glycoprotein UL16. Here, we show that the viral gene product UL142 is able to down-regulate another NKG2D ligand, MICA, leading to protection from NK cytotoxicity. UL142 is not able to affect surface expression of all MICA alleles, however, which may reflect selective pressure on the host to thwart viral immune evasion, further supporting an important role for the MICA-NKG2D interaction in immune surveillance.     

Comprehensive analysis of NKG2D ligand expression and release in leukemia: implications for NKG2D-mediated NK cell responses

Ligands of the prototypical activating NK receptor NKG2D render cancer cells susceptible to NK cell-mediated cytolysis if expressed at sufficiently high levels. However, malignant cells employ mechanisms to evade NKG2D-mediated immunosurveillance, such as NKG2D ligand (NKG2DL) shedding resulting in reduced surface expression levels. In addition, systemic downregulation of NKG2D on NK cells of cancer patients has been observed in many studies and was attributed to soluble NKG2DL (sNKG2DL), although there also are conflicting data. Likewise, relevant expression of NKG2DL in leukemia has been reported by some, but not all studies. Hence, we comprehensively studied expression, release, and function of the NKG2D ligands MHC class I chain-related molecules A and B and UL16-binding proteins 1-3 in 205 leukemia patients. Leukemia cells of most patients (75%) expressed at least one NKG2DL at the surface, and all investigated patient sera contained elevated sNKG2DL levels. Besides correlating NKG2DL levels with clinical data and outcome, we demonstrate that sNKG2DL in patient sera reduce NKG2D expression on NK cells, resulting in impaired antileukemia reactivity, which also critically depends on number and levels of surface-expressed NKG2DL. Together, we provide comprehensive data on the relevance of NKG2D/NKG2DL expression, release, and function for NK reactivity in leukemia, which exemplifies the mechanisms underlying NKG2D-mediated tumor immunosurveillance and escape.     

Selective down-regulation of the NKG2D ligand H60 by mouse cytomegalovirus m155 glycoprotein

Both human and mouse cytomegaloviruses (CMVs) encode proteins that inhibit the activation of NK cells by down-regulating cellular ligands for the activating NK cell receptor NKG2D. Up to now, three ligands for the NKG2D receptor, named RAE-1, H60, and MULT-1, have been identified in mice. The resistance of mouse strains to murine CMV (MCMV) infection is determined by their ability to generate an effective NK cell response. The MCMV gene m152, a member of the m145 gene family, down-regulates the expression of RAE-1 in order to avoid NK cell control in vivo. Here we report that the m155 gene, another member of the m145 gene family, encodes a protein that interferes with the expression of H60 on the surfaces of infected cells. Deletion of the m155 gene leads to an only partial restoration of H60 expression on the cell surface, suggesting the involvement of another, so far unknown, viral inhibitor. In spite of this, an m155 deletion mutant virus shows NK cell-dependent attenuation in vivo. The acquisition of endo-beta-N-acetylglucosaminidase H resistance and the preserved half-life of H60 in MCMV-infected cells indicate that the m155-mediated effect must take place in a compartment after H60 exits from the ERGIC-cis-Golgi compartment.     

Interaction of monocytes with NK cells upon Toll-like receptor-induced expression of the NKG2D ligand MICA

Reciprocal interactions between NK cells and dendritic cells have been shown to influence activation of NK cells, maturation, or lysis of dendritic cells and subsequent adaptive immune responses. However, little is known about the crosstalk between monocytes and NK cells and the receptors involved in this interaction. We report in this study that human monocytes, upon TLR triggering, up-regulate MHC class I-Related Chain (MIC) A, but not other ligands for the activating immunoreceptor NKG2D like MICB or UL-16 binding proteins 1-3. MICA expression was associated with CD80, MHC class I and MHC class II up-regulation, secretion of proinflammatory cytokines, and apoptosis inhibition, but was not accompanied by release of MIC molecules in soluble form. TLR-induced MICA on the monocyte cell surface was detected by autologous NK cells as revealed by NKG2D down-regulation. Although MICA expression did not render monocytes susceptible for NK cell cytotoxicity, LPS-treated monocytes stimulated IFN-gamma production of activated NK cells which was substantially dependent on MICA-NKG2D interaction. No enhanced NK cell proliferation or cytotoxicity against third-party target cells was observed after stimulation of NK cells with LPS-activated monocytes. Our data indicate that MICA-NKG2D interaction constitutes a mechanism by which monocytes and NK cells as an early source of IFN-gamma may communicate directly during an innate immune response to infections in humans.     

NKG2D discriminates diverse ligands through selectively mechano‐regulated ligand conformational changes

Stimulatory immune receptor NKG2D binds diverse ligands to elicit differential anti‐tumor and anti‐virus immune responses. Two conflicting degeneracy recognition models based on static crystal structures and in‐solution binding affinities have been considered for almost two decades. Whether and how NKG2D recognizes and discriminates diverse ligands still remain unclear. Using live‐cell‐based single‐molecule biomechanical assay, we characterized the in situ binding kinetics of NKG2D interacting with different ligands in the absence or presence of mechanical force. We found that mechanical force application selectively prolonged NKG2D interaction lifetimes with the ligands MICA and MICB, but not with ULBPs, and that force‐strengthened binding is much more pronounced for MICA than for other ligands. We also integrated steered molecular dynamics simulations and mutagenesis to reveal force‐induced rotational conformational changes of MICA, involving formation of additional hydrogen bonds on its binding interface with NKG2D, impeding MICA dissociation under force. We further provided a kinetic triggering model to reveal that force‐dependent affinity determines NKG2D ligand discrimination and its downstream NK cell activation. Together, our results demonstrate that NKG2D has a discrimination power to recognize different ligands, which depends on selective mechanical force‐induced ligand conformational changes.     

NKG2D and its ligands

NKG2D is an activating immunoreceptor, first recognized on NK cells but subsequently found on γδ T cells, CD8⁺ αβ T cells and macrophages. In NK cells, inhibitory signals are generally dominate over activating signals. However, activating signals mediated through engagement of NKG2D by its ligands on target cells can bypass signals transmitted through inhibitory NK receptors, allowing NKG2D to function as a “master-switch” in determining the activation status of NK cells. NKG2D is important for T cell and NK cell-mediated immunity to viruses and tumours, and has roles in autoimmune disease, allogeneic transplantation, and xenotransplantation. Depending upon the situation, development of strategies to either block or to enhance the interactions between NKG2D and its ligands may have important implications for human health and disease.     

Intracellular retention of the NKG2D ligand MHC class I chain-related gene A in human melanomas confers immune privilege and prevents NK cell-mediated cytotoxicity

Most tumors grow in immunocompetent hosts despite expressing NKG2D ligands (NKG2DLs) such as the MHC class I chain-related genes A and B (MICA/B). However, their participation in tumor cell evasion is still not completely understood. Here we demonstrate that several human melanomas (cell lines and freshly isolated metastases) do not express MICA on the cell surface but have intracellular deposits of this NKG2DL. Susceptibility to NK cell-mediated cytotoxicity correlated with the ratio of NKG2DLs to HLA class I molecules but not with the amounts of MICA on the cell surface of tumor cells. Transfection-mediated overexpression of MICA restored cell surface expression and resulted in an increased in vitro cytotoxicity and IFN-gamma secretion by human NK cells. In xenografted nude mice, these melanomas exhibited a delayed growth and extensive in vivo apoptosis. Retardation of tumor growth was due to NK cell-mediated antitumor activity against MICA-transfected tumors, given that this effect was not observed in NK cell-depleted mice. Also, mouse NK cells killed MICA-overexpressing melanomas in vitro. A mechanistic analysis revealed the retention of MICA in the endoplasmic reticulum, an effect that was associated with accumulation of endoH-sensitive (immature) forms of MICA, retrograde transport to the cytoplasm, and degradation by the proteasome. Our study identifies a novel strategy developed by melanoma cells to evade NK cell-mediated immune surveillance based on the intracellular sequestration of immature forms of MICA in the endoplasmic reticulum. Furthermore, this tumor immune escape strategy can be overcome by gene therapy approaches aimed at overexpressing MICA on tumor cells.     

Involvement of an NKG2D ligand H60c in epidermal dendritic T cell-mediated wound repair

Dendritic epidermal T cells (DETCs) found in mouse skin are NKG2D-positive γδ T cells involved in immune surveillance and wound repair. It is assumed that the interaction of an NKG2D receptor on DETCs and an MHC class I-like NKG2D ligand on keratinocytes activates DETCs, which then secrete cytokines promoting wound repair. However, direct evidence that DETC activation through NKG2D signaling promotes wound repair is not available. In the present study, we generated mAbs for an NKG2D ligand H60c previously suggested to be expressed specifically on skin keratinocytes. Local administration of H60c-specific mAb inhibited activation of DETCs and significantly delayed wound repair. Likewise, administration of NKG2D-specific mAb impaired wound repair to a similar extent. The delay in wound closure resulting from the blockade of the NKG2D pathway was comparable to that observed in γδ T cell-deficient mice. These results indicate that H60c/NKG2D interactions play a critical role in wound repair. Reassessment of binding affinities showed that H60c monomers bind to NKG2D with affinity (K(d) = 26 ± 3.2 nM) comparable to those of other high-affinity NKG2D ligands. H60c is transcribed not only in skin but also in tissues such as tongue and female reproductive tract known to contain epithelium-resident γδ T cells expressing invariant TCRs, suggesting a more general role for H60c in the maintenance of epithelial integrity.     

Promiscuity and the single receptor: NKG2D

NKG2D (natural-killer group 2, member D) is a powerful activating receptor expressed by natural killer (NK) cells and T cells that regulates immune responses during infection, cancer and autoimmunity. NKG2D ligands comprise a diverse array of MHC-class-I-related proteins that are upregulated by cellular stress. Why is it beneficial for the host to have so many ligands for the same receptor? In this Opinion article, we propose that although competition with viruses is the most likely evolutionary drive for this diversity, there might be other explanations.