Analysis of responder cell-cell interactions in the syngeneic mixed leukocyte response

In a previous study we identified the target antigens on stimulator cells in the murine syngeneic mixed leukocyte response (MLR) as self Ia molecules. The experiments reported here utilized analysis of log-log cell number-response titration slopes to study the responder T-cell population in the syngeneic MLR. The data indicated that in the peripheral lymphoid population at least two cell populations interact to produce a murine syngeneic MLR. One of these cell types appeared to be a member of an Lyt 2- subset, another a member of an Lyt 2+ subset. A potential third cell type, which was detected in the presence of (PMA)-induced EL4 supernatants, was found in the thymus, an organ that did not appear to contain either of the other two subsets. Experiments with adult thymectomized and neonatal mice suggested that the cell populations involved in the syngeneic MLR were mature T cells and were not an early differentiation state of T lymphocytes whose ability to be stimulated by Ia antigens alone was a transient event.     

Effect of L-ornithine on proliferative and cytotoxic T-cell responses in allogeneic and syngeneic mixed leukocyte cultures

The effect of L-ornithine on cytotoxic and proliferative responses in mixed leukocyte cultures has been analyzed. The activation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) was strongly inhibited when 9 X 10(-3) M L-ornithine was added at the initiation of the cultures. The CTL precursor cells were not completely and irreversibly inactivated, however, since the cells generated normal cytotoxic activity if resuspended after 6 days in fresh culture medium together with a fresh set of stimulator cells. Experiments in microcultures with nylon-wool-nonadherent T-cell-enriched spleen cells as responder cells and "plastic adherent cells" as stimulator cells revealed that the cytotoxic responses were almost completely suppressed if ornithine was added within the first 20 hr but were only partially suppressed if ornithine was added after 48 hr. Also, ornithine had only a mild suppressive effect on proliferative responses in allogeneic and syngeneic mixed leukocyte cultures. The strong suppressive effect of the cytotoxic response was therefore not explained by a general toxic effect of L-ornithine on the responding cells in the culture. The addition of interleukin 2 (IL-2)-containing EL-4 supernatants did not prevent but rather enhanced the suppressive effect of L-ornithine. This indicated that the inhibitory effect was not (exclusively) expressed at the level of the IL-2-producing helper T cells. Since activated macrophages have been reported to secrete arginase, it appears that L-ornithine may be part of a regulatory circuit that selectively regulates the development of cytotoxic effector T cells.     

The proliferative response of cloned Peyer's patch switch T cells to syngeneic and allogeneic stimuli

We previously defined a concanavalin A (Con A)-induced cloned T cell population in Peyer's patches (PP) that causes sIgM-bearing B cells to switch to sIgA-bearing B cells. In the present study we show that such IgA-specific switch T cells proliferate when exposed to syngeneic stimulator cells, i.e., the switch T cells are autoreactive. Detailed study of this phenomenon disclosed that both B cells and macrophages were capable of causing switch T cell proliferation, and in both cases, stimulation was enhanced by preactivation of the stimulator cells with lipopolysaccharide (LPS). In addition, fresh T cells can act as stimulators, but only if preactivated with Con A. Finally, it was clearly shown in blocking studies with the use of various antibodies directed at class II MHC specificities that class II MHC antigens were the stimulatory determinants. These studies suggest that IgA-specific switch T cells arise in PP as a result of autologous cell-cell interactions with activated (antigen-stimulated) B cells, macrophages, or T cells.     

Il-4 is an endogenous T cell growth factor during the immune response to a syngeneic retrovirus-induced tumor

The relative contributions of IL-2 and IL-4 during the immune response to the retrovirus-induced tumor, FBL, were examined. Both proliferative and cytolytic responses to FBL were measured and compared to similar responses to minor histocompatibility Ag. The addition of alpha IL-2 partially inhibited FBL-stimulated proliferation of purified L3T4+ T cells and nearly completely inhibited the response of Lyt-2+ T cells, whereas alpha IL-4 partially inhibited the proliferative response of the L3T4+ subset but had no effect on the response of the Lyt-2+ subset. The addition of exogenous IL-4 augmented the proliferative response of both subsets. Therefore, IL-4 is an endogenous growth factor for FBL-induced specific proliferation of the L3T4+ and not the Lyt-2+ population, but both subpopulations can respond to IL-4. Similar examination of anti-FBL CTL responses revealed that alpha IL-2, but not alpha IL-4, inhibited FBL-specific Lyt-2+ CTL generation. However, exogenous IL-4 partially replaced the L3T4+ Th cell activity necessary for optimal Lyt-2+ FBL-specific CTL generation. Therefore, IL-4 is not required but can participate in the CTL response. The role of IL-4 during the immune response of B6 mice to minor histocompatibility Ag disparate BALB.B cells was analyzed. alpha IL-4 had no detectable effect on the proliferative or cytolytic response to BALB.B cells, suggesting that endogenous IL-4 does not have a significant role in these responses. The extent of involvement of endogenous IL-4 in the T cell responses to retrovirus-induced tumor Ag and minor histocompatibility Ag presumably reflects the nature of the stimulating Ag, and detection of an IL-4 response may correlate with induction of an antibody response. Thus, the immunizing Ag and/or host B cell repetoire may influence which subsets of L3T4+ Th cells are activated during priming in vivo.     

The T cell repertoire to a multideterminant antigen. Clonal heterogeneity of the T cell response, variation between syngeneic individuals, and in vitro selection of T cell specificities.

The specificity of lysozyme-induced T cell proliferative responses by individual B10.A mice was compared by using a panel of three peptides. A surprising degree of variation in the focus of the responses was observed among individual animals, both in the newly isolated lymph node cell populations and in long term T cell lines. The responses to each determinant after hen egg-white lysozyme immunization were not equal and in examining the mice as a group some determinants tended to be dominant. However, despite each animal favoring a restricted number of determinants, the responding T cell populations were still highly heterogeneous. The data suggest that many determinants are involved in the response to the whole Ag. The role of one or more dominant determinants can be overestimated because the degree of heterogeneity in long term T cell lines appears to be less than in freshly obtained lymph node cells, indicating that a process of in vitro selection occurs. We observed that the T cells responsive to one peptide, 46-61, appeared to have a selective advantage in vitro culture.     

Antigen-induced suppression of the proliferative response of T cell clones

Proliferation of Ag-specific T cell clones can be inhibited by the addition of high concentrations of Ag at the beginning of culture. Under these conditions the cells produce lymphokines and express high affinity IL-2R but fail to divide, even after the addition of exogenous IL-2. This state results from restimulation of the cells with Ag-Ia molecule complexes approximately 20 h after initiation of culture. It can be prevented by addition of either an anti-Ia or an anti-L3T4 mAb at that time, but not by cyclosporin A, and mimicked in cultures containing low concentrations of antigen by addition at that time of high Ag concentrations or normal stimulatory concentrations of Con A. These observations suggest that restimulation of activated T cell clones 20 h after their initial stimulation prevents them from dividing.     

Immune response to Toxoplasma gondii--alteration of antigen specificity of peripheral blood leukocyte proliferative responses in acute toxoplasmosis

Ultrasonicated Toxoplasma gondii (RH strain) tachyzoite extract was chromatographed on Sephadex G-200, and one main peak (93,000 M.W.) and three small peaks (greater than 160,000 M.W., 110,000 M.W., and 20,000 M.W.) were eluted. Toxoplasma-specific proliferative T cell responses of peripheral blood leukocytes (PBL) from a patient with acute toxoplasmosis caused by accidental injection of tachyzoites of the protozoa were sequentially examined by using these fractioned antigens. As early as one week after the accidental injection of the protozoa, significant proliferative responses of PBL could be detected. The reaction of proliferative T cells was observed occurring mainly with Fr. II antigen. Then T cells began to respond to Fr. I and III in addition to Fr. II 3 weeks after the injection. Thus, expansion of antigen specificity in Toxoplasma-specific T cell responses was observed at the initial stage of acquired acute toxoplasmosis.     

Surface exclusion specificity of the TraT lipoprotein is determined by single alterations in a five-amino-acid region of the protein

The TraT protein is a highly cell-surface-exposed lipoprotein specified by F-like plasmids that confers serum resistance and blocks the conjugative transfer of plasmids to cells bearing identical or closely related plasmids, a process known as surface exclusion. The TraT protein specified by the antibiotic-resistance plasmid R6-5 was purified to apparent homogeneity. When added to mating mixtures, TraT blocked the transfer of plasmids belonging to Surface Exclusion Group IV (Sfx IV) but had no significant effect on the transfer of plasmids belonging to other groups. Additionally, the purified protein has a protective effect on bacterial cells incubated in serum, indicating that it does not have to be located on the cell surface to mediate serum resistance. To localize regions of the protein that were responsible for surface exclusion specificity, the amino acid sequence of the TraT protein specified by CoIB2-K98 (Sfx II) was determined by cloning and sequencing of the corresponding gene. Comparison of the derived sequence with those of the F and R100-1 proteins indicated that surface exclusion specificity of TraT is determined by single alterations in a five-amino-acid region (residues 116-120). This was confirmed by segment swapping experiments in which the specificity of the R6-5 TraT protein (Sfx IV) was switched to that of the CoIB2-K98 protein (Sfx II). Our results suggest that the region defined by residues 116-120 is located on the external face of the outer membrane and interacts specifically with the donor cell in surface exclusion.     

T cell synergy in the primary MLR: proliferative kinetics, effector cell generation, and IL 2 production

A primary rat MLR was initiated, and on each of 8 consecutive days during the evolving culture, an aliquot of cells was separated into its constitutive helper/inducer (W3/25+) and suppressor/cytotoxic (OX8+) T cell subsets by a monoclonal antibody, Degalan-bead immunoadsorbent column technique. This allowed a detailed kinetic analysis of T cell proliferation, the generation of effector cells, and the production of IL 2 by each subset relative to net whole culture supernatant IL 2 activity. The primary MLR demonstrates an early period of helper/inducer cell proliferation, IL 2 production and accumulation, followed by a period of suppressor/cytotoxic cell (OX8+) proliferation and IL 2 consumption during which there are distinct waves of allospecific suppressor, followed by cytotoxic activity. If fresh T cells of the helper/inducer or suppressor/cytotoxic phenotype were preseparated and then cultured alone with irradiated allogeneic stimulator cells, proliferation was noted in both subsets despite no demonstrable IL 2 activity in cultures of the suppressor/cytotoxic cells. Finally, a suppressed primary MLR exhibited proliferative inhibition of both T cell subsets.     

Cytotoxic T cell responses to a syngeneic tumour: conditions for primary activation in vitro.

Primary cytotoxic responses of DBA/2 lymph node cells to a syngeneic tumour (the mastocytoma P815) have been generated in vitro. The development of these responses is dependent on the addition of a soluble factor (CSCS) which is produced by concanavalin A-activated spleen cells. The response is mediated by T lymphocytes, can be detected at low effector to target cell ratios and is directed against P815 tumour-associated antigens.     

Stability of a diverse immunological memory is determined by T cell population dynamics

The correlation between properties of the T cell memory pool and the two regulatory mechanisms of cell death (apoptosis) and memory entry (differentiation) is investigated mathematically. Apoptosis of T cells occurs at the end of an immune response, removing unwanted activated T cells. T cells escaping apoptosis enter the memory pool composed of T cells specific for previously encountered antigens. We find that the relative efficiencies of these two pathways determine the clonal distribution and the long-term stability of the memory pool by regulating the number of new entries. The main result presented in this paper is that immunological memory of previously encountered pathogens cannot be erased by either severe or repeat infections with a particular pathogen (the diversity of the memory pool is ensured) only if apoptosis and/or memory differentiation are regulated by population dependent processes. Furthermore, vaccination properties are improved significantly by population dependent mechanisms and our mathematical analysis reveals that the T cell population must communicate with other parts of the immune system to ensure optimal performance of immunological memory.     

LIGHT, a TNF-like molecule, costimulates T cell proliferation and is required for dendritic cell-mediated allogeneic T cell response

LIGHT is a recently identified member of the TNF superfamily and its receptors, herpesvirus entry mediator and lymphotoxin beta receptor, are found in T cells and stromal cells. In this study, we demonstrate that LIGHT is selectively expressed on immature dendritic cells (DCs) generated from human PBMCs. In contrast, LIGHT is not detectable in DCs either freshly isolated from PBMCs or rendered mature in vitro by LPS treatment. Blockade of LIGHT by its soluble receptors, lymphotoxin beta receptor-Ig or HVEM-Ig, inhibits the induction of DC-mediated primary allogeneic T cell response. Furthermore, engagement of LIGHT costimulates human T cell proliferation, amplifies the NF-kappaB signaling pathway, and preferentially induces the production of IFN-gamma, but not IL-4, in the presence of an antigenic signal. Our results suggest that LIGHT is a costimulatory molecule involved in DC-mediated cellular immune responses.     

Facing two T cell epitopes: a degree of randomness in the primary response is lost upon secondary immunization

We have analyzed the hierarchy of epitope-specific T cell populations during a primary and a secondary CD8 T cell response. MHC-peptide tetramers were used to track the in vivo kinetics of expansion of T cell populations specific for two Kd-restricted epitopes simultaneously presented by a murine tumor cell following primary or recall immunizations. Individual syngeneic mice generated remarkably different primary CTL responses, as reflected by up to 60-fold differences in the relative contribution of each peptide-specific T cell population to the overall response. In these primary immunizations, the CTL dominance was not dictated by the respective abundance of the presented epitopes. In sharp contrast, the secondary response was systematically associated with a selective expansion of the same epitope-specific population both in vitro and in vivo. In vitro experiments indicated that the extent of expansion of each epitope-specific memory population is modulated by the epitope density. We conclude that, at least for this set of epitopes, the CTL hierarchy is not controlled by the same parameters in a primary vs a secondary response.     

The induction of cytolytic T lymphocytes with specificity for p-azophenylarsonate coupled syngeneic cells.

Conditions are described for diazonium linkage of the hapten p-azophenylarsonate (Ar) to mouse lymphocytes for the purpose of induction of syngeneic cytolytic T lymphocytes. These cytolytic effector cells do not lyse target cells that are coupled with an unrelated hapten, trinitrophenyl. Cell lysis can be blocked by the addition of anti-Ar antiserum. Only those target cells that share H-2 K or D end antigens with the stimulating cell population are susceptible to lysis. Several methods were used in an attempt to demonstrate the presence of the Ar cross-reactive idiotype on CTL induced in A/J mice.     

Ia-specific mixed leukocyte reactive T cell hybridomas: analysis of their specificity by using purified class II MHC molecules in synthetic membrane system

This study was undertaken to determine the nature of the antigens recognized in allogeneic and syngeneic mixed leukocyte reactions (MLR). Specifically, we wished to determine whether Ia antigens alone were recognized by MLR-reactive T cells, or whether the specificity was determined by the corecognition of non-MHC antigens together with syngeneic or allogeneic Ia. To do this we used 11 T cell hybrids that were characterized as being specific for Iad and were tested their capacity to respond to isolated I-Ad or I-Ed that had been incorporated into liposomes and had bound to the surface of glass beads. Of nine alloreactive T cell hybrids (five I-Ad-and four I-Ed-specific), seven were shown to be responsive to the relevant isolated Ia antigen on glass beads. Also, two of two syngeneic I-Ad-specific T cell hybrids responded to I-Ad on the glass beads. One of the two alloreactive T cell hybrids that failed to respond to the relevant Ia antigen on glass beads was shown to be specific for an antigen in fetal calf serum (FCS) that was recognized in the context of the allo-Ia antigen (I-Ed), because when intact accessory cells were used, a response by this hybrid was only observed when FCS was present in the assay culture medium or when the accessory cells were pre-pulsed with FCS. The possible involvement of FCS antigens and non-Ia accessory cell antigens in the stimulation of the nine T cell hybrids that responded to isolated Ia on glass beads was evaluated. T cell hybrids that were grown and were tested in serum free medium were still capable of reacting to Ia on beads. The isolated Ia preparations used were greater than 90% pure, and their capacity to stimulate the T cell hybrids did not correlate with the degree of contamination with non-Ia proteins. We conclude from these studies that the majority of T cells that respond to allogeneic or syngeneic Ia bearing stimulator cells are specific for the Ia antigens themselves, and do not require the co-recognition of other non-Ia antigens; nor is there any requirement for Ia antigen processing for this recognition.     

Distinct proliferative T cell clonotypes are generated in response to a murine retrovirus-induced syngeneic T cell leukemia: viral gp70 antigen-specific MT4+ clones and Lyt-2+ cytolytic clones which recognize a tumor-specific cell surface antigen

After immunization of B6 mice with the syngeneic retrovirus-induced T cell leukemia/lymphoma FBL-3, two major tumor-specific proliferative T cell clonotypes were derived. T cell clones derived from long-term lines propagated by in vitro culture with irradiated tumor cells and syngeneic spleen cells were exclusively of the Lyt-2+ phenotype. Such clones were cytolytic, retained their proliferative phenotype indefinitely when expanded by repeated cycles of reactivation and rest, and recognized a tumor-specific cell surface antigen in association with class I MHC molecules. This tumor cell antigen was not present on nontransformed virus-infected cells. Class II MHC-restricted MT4+ clones specific for the viral antigen gp70 were derived from lymph node T cells of FBL-3 tumor-immune mice only by in vitro culture with purified Friend virus in the presence of syngeneic splenic APC. Once derived, however, such clones could be stimulated in the presence of FBL-3 tumor cells and syngeneic spleen cells, demonstrating the reprocessing of tumor-derived gp70 antigen by APC in the spleen cell population. In contrast, no reprocessing of the tumor cell surface antigen by splenic APC for presentation to the class I MHC-restricted T cell clones could be demonstrated. Evidence is presented that FBL-3 T leukemia/lymphoma cells function as APC for Lyt-2+ class I MHC-restricted clones, and that no concomitant recognition of Ia molecules is required to activate these clones. Both Lyt-2+ and MT4+ clones were induced to proliferate in the presence of exogenous IL2 alone, but this stimulus failed to result in significant release of immune interferon. In contrast, antigen stimulation of both clones resulted in proliferation as well as significant immune interferon release. Immune interferon production is not required for the generation of MHC-restricted cell-mediated cytolytic function.     

Generation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes in vitro. VI. Effect of cell density on response in mixed leukocyte cultures.

Reexposure of day 14 murine mixed leukocyte culture (MLC) populations to the original irradiated allogeneic stimulating spleen cells has previously been found to result in the ratpid generation of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) associated with a net increase in cultured cell number. Under the experimental conditions used, day 5 MLC cells appeared unable to respond to the allogeneic stimulus. In order to characterize further the development of the potential for anamnestic reactivity during the course of MLC, C57BL/6 spleen cells were incubated with irradiated (1000 rads) DBA/2 spleen cells (primary MLC) for up to 3 weeks. At various time intervals after the onset of the primary MLC, the surviving cells were collected and reexposed, at varying cell concentrations, to irradiated DBA/2 spleen cells (secondary MLC). At daily intervals thereafter, CTL activity was assessed using a quantitative 51Cr-release assay system. A paradoxic effect of responding cell concentration on generation of CTL activity was observed; relatively greater increase in CTL activity was observed as the concentration of responding cells was decreased over a 100-fold range. This effect was more pronounced with responding cells reexposed to antigen after primary MLC for 20 days, but was observed even with normal cells. The apparent unresponsiveness of day 5 MLC cells to alloantigen restimulation could be overcome by simple dilution of responding cells. Cytotoxic activity at the time of restimulation with antigen seems to be a major factor determining the magnitude of the secondary response. Since intact cells bearing alloantigens are required for the generation of CTL in MLC, residual cytotoxic cells reduce the effective antigenic stimulus by destroying stimulating cells. This effect of concentration of responding cells on generation of CTL in MLC complicates interpretation of experiments investigating the role of "inhibitor" and "helper" cell in cell-mediated immune responses occurring in vitro. Under optimal conditions, the highest CTL activity and the largest increase in total cell number was observed 4 days after restimulation of day 10 MLC cells. On a per cell basis, the lytic activity was up to 4 times greater than that observed at the peak of a primary response, and the number of viable cells recovered was nearly 20 times higher than that at the onset. Such secondary MLC are thus a convenient source of lymphoid cells selected primarily on the basis of proliferation induced by alloantigens.     

Mapping the fine specificity of a cytolytic T cell response to HIV-1 nef protein.

Epitope mapping of a MHC class I-restricted cytotoxic T cell response to nef, a regulatory protein of HIV, was performed with fresh PBMC from HIV-seropositive donors and target cells pulsed with a panel of overlapping peptides of the nef protein. These nef-specific CTL recognized a synthetic peptide of 10 residues derived from a nonamphipathic, highly conserved region of the nef protein in association with the HLA A3.1 molecule. Using human cell transfectants expressing mutations of the A3 molecule, we demonstrated that the amino acid at position 152 of the A3.1 molecule appears to be critical for detection of this response. Thus, rapid analysis of the epitopes of HIV proteins stimulating CTL responses can be achieved using a combination of fresh donor PBMC and target cells pulsed with synthesized peptides.