Statistical Assessment of Variability of Terminal Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism Analysis Applied to Complex Microbial Communities

The variability of terminal restriction fragment polymorphism analysis applied to complex microbial communities was assessed statistically. Recent technological improvements were implemented in the successive steps of the procedure, resulting in a standardized procedure which provided a high level of reproducibility.Terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism (T-RFLP) analysis is a robust, high-resolution, high-throughput, rapid, and cost-effective method for studying the structures of microbial communities (3, 10). T-RFLP analysis is based on group-specific variations in the restriction patterns of molecular markers essential to all life forms (i.e., rRNA genes) or unique to a particular physiological group (e.g., ammonia-oxidizing and sulfate-reducing bacteria) which generate specific and characteristic terminal restriction fragment (T-RF) patterns from mixed fluorescently labeled amplicon pools of environmental nucleic acid extracts. This analysis has developed recently into one of the favorite techniques for the rapid assessment of the structures of bacterial communities. Refinements of the technique and data analysis have been introduced (5, 8, 11, 14, 20-22). Improvements have been made to the sampling procedure (16), to the DNA extraction and amplification steps (17, 19, 26), and to enzymatic restriction digestion (2, 6). Statistical analysis has also been improved in the treatment of the raw data and the selection of logical binning and clustering algorithms resulting, for instance, in the alignment of replicate profiles into a single consensus profile (1, 13). Finally, recent developments have been proposed for the statistical analysis of the profiles using multivariate techniques from numerical ecology (4, 7, 9, 23-25, 27).Both the resolution and reproducibility of T-RFLP analysis have already been assessed using artificially created bacterial communities (12) comprising up to 30 different clones or bacterial species. However, to the best knowledge of the authors, so far no study has been conducted to assess statistically the dissimilarities obtained in the electropherogram profiles when more complex bacterial communities from natural samples have been analyzed. The main purpose of this report is then to assess statistically the resolution and reproducibility of a standardized T-RFLP protocol, as applied to the analysis of 16S rRNA gene pools from complex communities. The statistical analysis was carried out at successive steps of the procedure, from the initial PCR amplification to the sizing of the obtained T-RFs.The samples used for this study were taken from a sequencing batch bubble column reactor inoculated with activated sludge from a municipal wastewater treatment plant and operated in such a way as to produce aerobic granular sludge able to remove carbon, nitrogen, and phosphate from an artificial wastewater sample containing acetate, ammonium, and phosphate. Samples were taken at different steps of operation of the reactor systems. The standardized protocol used in the present report is presented in detail in the supplemental material. Note that the methodology implied in the extraction of the total bacterial DNA is not discussed in the context of this work. The T-RFLP protocol was conceived on the basis of recent developments made in the protocol at various stages of the T-RFLP analysis and was implemented with optimized procedures allowing us to minimize potential biases and to ensure a high degree of reproducibility. Whenever possible, technological advances in instrumentation were included, as for instance with the application of optimized electrophoresis conditions and the use of more complex sizing standards and brighter fluorochromes. The use of relatively large and precise amounts of digested PCR fragments (200 ng per replica) also contributed to a drastic reduction of the background noise, which was usually observed to be equal to only about 10 relative fluorescence units (RFU).Numerical treatment and analysis of the data were carried out with R (R Development Core Team) and the Vegan library (18). We used asymmetric dissimilarity indices to compare T-RFLP profiles using the Jaccard formula, so that the double absence of a T-RF was not considered a resemblance between two profiles (15). The Jaccard dissimilarity was applied to binary data, i.e., the presence/absence of T-RFs. Moreover, to take into account the relative intensity of T-RF areas within each profile in the comparison, we used Ruzicka dissimilarity, which is the Jaccard index applied to quantitative data. Both dissimilarity measures range from 0 (identical profiles) to 1 (different profiles with no T-RF in common). Numerical treatment of the data was also carried out on the modified results, so as to reduce potential biases induced by the inconsistent presence of T-RFs showing very small amounts of fluorescence. T-RF signals just above the detection threshold (low signal-to-noise ratio) can be a cause of suboptimal fingerprinting reproducibility. For this reason, small-area T-RFs (<300 RFU) were suppressed when they were not present in all replicate profiles of a sample.     

Selection of Enzymes for Terminal Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism Analysis of Fungal Internally Transcribed Spacer Sequences

Terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism (TRFLP) profiling of the internally transcribed spacer (ITS) ribosomal DNA of unknown fungal communities is currently unsupported by a broad-range enzyme-choosing rationale. An in silico study of terminal fragment size distribution was therefore performed following virtual digestion (by use of a set of commercially available 135 type IIP restriction endonucleases) of all published fungal ITS sequences putatively annealing to primers ITS1 and ITS4. Different diversity measurements were used to rank primer-enzyme pairs according to the richness and evenness that they showed. Top-performing pairs were hierarchically clustered to test for data dependency. The enzyme set composed of MaeII, BfaI, and BstNI returned much better results than randomly chosen enzyme sets in computer simulations and is therefore recommended for in vitro TRFLP profiling of fungal ITSs.Terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism (TRFLP) profiling was originally developed as a means of genotyping mixed DNA samples (30) and is currently being employed in fungal community ecology studies (3, 5, 6, 7, 10, 13, 19, 22, 26, 27, 29, 33, 38), despite a number of technical and conceptual difficulties (11). Briefly, TRFLP profiling involves amplifying the DNA in pools of mixed genetic material with fluorescently labeled primers, digesting the products with restriction endonucleases, and sizing the labeled terminal fragments in a sequencer. The difference in the positions at which the different restriction enzymes cleave DNA is thought to provide enough variability for such DNA mixtures to be characterized and the contributing organisms to be identified.However, the technique is not without its problems. DNA extraction and PCR amplification biases burden most modern molecular techniques, including TRFLPs (18, 25). Additionally, concerns exist regarding the ability of the differences between primer-enzyme pairs (PEPs) to generate sufficiently different fragment sizes (2), the success of enzymatic cleavage (2), the dependency on the detection threshold of the sequencer (4), and the accuracy of DNA sizing (1). The choice of the primer pairs and restriction enzymes to be used has also been a matter of concern since the appearance of TRFLP profiling. Liu et al. (30) performed virtual digestion of all the bacterial RNA sequences in the Ribosomal Database Project database (release V) with 10 different enzymes and four primer pairs. This pioneering work showed the importance of avoiding enzymes with highly conserved target motifs, something that later became recognized as a major source of TRFLP bias (2, 14, 16, 32). Similar studies have been performed by Osborn et al. (36), Dunbar et al. (12), Engebretson and Moyer (15), and Cardinale et al. (8).The first virtual TRFLP analysis involving a database of fungal DNA sequences was performed by Edwards and Turco (14). This consisted of virtual digestion, by use of six restriction endonucleases, of 316 internally transcribed spacer (ITS) sequences belonging to a number of ectomycorrhizal genera. Avis et al. (2) found only small differences in the diversity of the TRFLPs produced in silico by three PEPs when using their own fungal ITS database, although these differences increased with sample number in iterative analysis. Recent advances using automated resources, such as REPK software (9), have allowed optimal enzyme selection for TRFLP profiling of previously defined communities of organisms. This software selects up to four restriction endonucleases capable of discriminating a desired number of sequence groups. However, this system relies on a priori information, which in real biological communities may not available.The aim of the present work was to improve selection of restriction enzymes for use in the TRFLP profiling of the ITS sequences of unknown fungal communities.     

Relative Diversity and Community Structure of Ciliates in Stream Biofilms According to Molecular and Microscopy Methods

Ciliates are an important component of aquatic ecosystems, acting as predators of bacteria and protozoa and providing nutrition for organisms at higher trophic levels. Understanding of the diversity and ecological role of ciliates in stream biofilms is limited, however. Ciliate diversity in biofilm samples from four streams subject to different impacts by human activity was assessed using microscopy and terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism (T-RFLP) analysis of 18S rRNA sequences. Analysis of 3′ and 5′ terminal fragments yielded very similar estimates of ciliate diversity. The diversity detected using microscopy was consistently lower than that suggested by T-RFLP analysis, indicating the existence of genetic diversity not apparent by morphological examination. Microscopy and T-RFLP analyses revealed similar relative trends in diversity between different streams, with the lowest level of biofilm-associated ciliate diversity found in samples from the least-impacted stream and the highest diversity in samples from moderately to highly impacted streams. Multivariate analysis provided evidence of significantly different ciliate communities in biofilm samples from different streams and seasons, particularly between a highly degraded urban stream and less impacted streams. Microscopy and T-RFLP data both suggested the existence of widely distributed, resilient biofilm-associated ciliates as well as ciliate taxa restricted to sites with particular environmental conditions, with cosmopolitan taxa being more abundant than those with restricted distributions. Differences between ciliate assemblages were associated with water quality characteristics typical of urban stream degradation and may be related to factors such as nutrient availability and macroinvertebrate communities. Microscopic and molecular techniques were considered to be useful complementary approaches for investigation of biofilm ciliate communities.Heterotrophic microeukaryotes such as ciliates are thought to be of considerable importance in aquatic ecosystems, as they are major predators of bacteria and constitute a nutritional resource for other protozoa, invertebrates, and probably fish larvae (9, 22, 36, 52, 62, 63, 71). In addition, protozoan bacterivory contributes to enhanced decomposition of leaf detritus—a vital nutrient resource in streams—by increasing turnover of bacterial populations through predation (57). It is not well understood, however, how ciliate diversity and community structure in streams are affected by changing environmental conditions, or how ciliate communities affect other stream biota and processes. The effects of various physical, chemical, and biological factors on freshwater protozoan communities have been considered by a number of studies, but most of these have focused upon planktonic organisms in lentic habitats (for example, see references 2, 11, and 44). However, the complex microbial communities in biofilms have been recognized as important contributors to critical ecological processes, such as auxotrophic primary production, nitrogen fixation, and nutrient cycling, and may underpin the function of stream food webs (31, 45, 61). The few studies which have investigated benthic habitats in lotic systems have found evidence of the existence of diverse communities of abundant ciliates (3, 20, 56) and shifts in community structure in response to ecophysiological parameters (30, 42, 43). With one exception, however, these investigations were based on aquatic sediments, and the organisms within epilithic biofilms have continued to receive little attention.Most studies of ciliate diversity and ecology have utilized microscopy-based methods of identification (for example, see references 3 and 56), as ciliate cells are relatively large and morphologically diverse. Such methods demand a high level of taxonomic expertise, however, and are difficult and time-consuming—for example, many ciliates are fragile and fast moving, and they often require difficult fixing and staining protocols for reliable identification. Molecular biological tools offer the possibility of more accurate and efficient methods for protozoan study and may provide a useful complement to traditional approaches (12, 18, 28, 65), yet we know of only a few molecular studies of environmental ciliate diversity (18, 20, 37). A series of recent investigations used culture-independent analysis of 18S rRNA gene sequences to reveal the existence of diverse microeukaryote communities in assorted marine, anoxic, and extreme environments (40, 48, 66, 69, 70, 72). Furthermore, a growing body of evidence suggests the existence of significant genetic diversity among various ciliate taxa which has escaped detection by microscopy (14, 18, 23, 34, 60, 64, 78), pointing to the potential for molecular techniques to generate new insights into ciliate diversity and ecology, and suggesting a need for comparison of the effectiveness of these different techniques in environmental samples.Terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism (T-RFLP) analysis provides an efficient, inexpensive, and semiquantitative means for comparing microbial molecular diversity between different samples and has been widely used to investigate bacterial communities, although only a few studies have applied T-RFLP methods to the analysis of microeukaryote diversity (6, 16, 17). In this study, ciliate diversity and community structure were investigated in biofilm samples from streams representing a range of levels of anthropogenic degradation, with the objective of testing the null hypothesis that human impacts have no effect upon this important heterotrophic component of stream ecosystems. To achieve this, ciliate-targeted PCR primers were used in conjunction with T-RFLP and multivariate statistical analyses. Additionally, ciliate diversity measures obtained using molecular techniques were compared with those derived from microscopy-based methods in order to assess the relative effectiveness of these approaches.     

Cultivation of Fastidious Bacteria by Viability Staining and Micromanipulation in a Soil Substrate Membrane System

Soil substrate membrane systems allow for microcultivation of fastidious soil bacteria as mixed microbial communities. We isolated established microcolonies from these membranes by using fluorescence viability staining and micromanipulation. This approach facilitated the recovery of diverse, novel isolates, including the recalcitrant bacterium Leifsonia xyli, a plant pathogen that has never been isolated outside the host.The majority of bacterial species have never been recovered in the laboratory (1, 14, 19, 24). In the last decade, novel cultivation approaches have successfully been used to recover “unculturables” from a diverse range of divisions (23, 25, 29). Most strategies have targeted marine environments (4, 23, 25, 32), but soil offers the potential for the investigation of vast numbers of undescribed species (20, 29). Rapid advances have been made toward culturing soil bacteria by reformulating and diluting traditional media, extending incubation times, and using alternative gelling agents (8, 21, 29).The soil substrate membrane system (SSMS) is a diffusion chamber approach that uses extracts from the soil of interest as the growth substrate, thereby mimicking the environment under investigation (12). The SSMS enriches for slow-growing oligophiles, a proportion of which are subsequently capable of growing on complex media (23, 25, 27, 30, 32). However, the SSMS results in mixed microbial communities, with the consequent difficulty in isolation of individual microcolonies for further characterization (10).Micromanipulation has been widely used for the isolation of specific cell morphotypes for downstream applications in molecular diagnostics or proteomics (5, 15). This simple technology offers the opportunity to select established microcolonies of a specific morphotype from the SSMS when combined with fluorescence visualization (3, 11). Here, we have combined the SSMS, fluorescence viability staining, and advanced micromanipulation for targeted isolation of viable, microcolony-forming soil bacteria.     

Functional diversity and electron donor dependence of microbial populations capable of U(VI) reduction in radionuclide-contaminated subsurface sediments

In order to elucidate the potential mechanisms of U(VI) reduction for the optimization of bioremediation strategies, the structure-function relationships of microbial communities were investigated in microcosms of subsurface materials cocontaminated with radionuclides and nitrate. A polyphasic approach was used to assess the functional diversity of microbial populations likely to catalyze electron flow under conditions proposed for in situ uranium bioremediation. The addition of ethanol and glucose as supplemental electron donors stimulated microbial nitrate and Fe(III) reduction as the predominant terminal electron-accepting processes (TEAPs). U(VI), Fe(III), and sulfate reduction overlapped in the glucose treatment, whereas U(VI) reduction was concurrent with sulfate reduction but preceded Fe(III) reduction in the ethanol treatments. Phyllosilicate clays were shown to be the major source of Fe(III) for microbial respiration by using variable-temperature Mössbauer spectroscopy. Nitrate- and Fe(III)-reducing bacteria (FeRB) were abundant throughout the shifts in TEAPs observed in biostimulated microcosms and were affiliated with the genera Geobacter, Tolumonas, Clostridium, Arthrobacter, Dechloromonas, and Pseudomonas. Up to two orders of magnitude higher counts of FeRB and enhanced U(VI) removal were observed in ethanol-amended treatments compared to the results in glucose-amended treatments. Quantification of citrate synthase (gltA) levels demonstrated a stimulation of Geobacteraceae activity during metal reduction in carbon-amended microcosms, with the highest expression observed in the glucose treatment. Phylogenetic analysis indicated that the active FeRB share high sequence identity with Geobacteraceae members cultivated from contaminated subsurface environments. Our results show that the functional diversity of populations capable of U(VI) reduction is dependent upon the choice of electron donor.Uranium contamination in subsurface environments is a widespread problem at mining and milling sites across North America, South America, and Eastern Europe (1). Uranium in the oxidized state, U(VI), is highly soluble and toxic and thus is a potential contaminant to local drinking-water supplies (46). Nitrate is often a cocontaminant with U(VI) as a result of the use of nitric acid in the processing of uranium and uranium-bearing waste (6, 45). Oxidized uranium can be immobilized in contaminated groundwater through the reduction of U(VI) to insoluble U(IV) by indirect (abiotic) and direct (enzymatic) processes catalyzed by microorganisms. Current remediation practices favor the stimulation of reductive uranium immobilization catalyzed by indigenous microbial communities along with natural attenuation and monitoring (5, 24, 40, 44, 65, 68, 69). Microbial uranium reduction activity in contaminated subsurface environments is often limited by carbon or electron donor availability (13, 24, 44, 69). Previous studies have indicated that U(VI) reduction does not proceed until nitrate is depleted (13, 16, 24, 44, 68, 69), as high nitrate concentrations inhibit the reduction of U(VI) by serving as a competing and more energetically favorable terminal electron acceptor for microorganisms (11, 16). The fate and transport of uranium in groundwater are also strongly linked through sorption and precipitation processes to the bioreduction of Fe minerals, including oxides, layer-silicate clay minerals, and sulfides (7, 23, 53).In order to appropriately design U(VI) bioremediation strategies, the potential function and phylogenetic structure of indigenous subsurface microbial communities must be further understood (24, 34, 46). Conflicting evidence has been presented on which microbial groups, Fe(III)- or sulfate-reducing bacteria (FeRB or SRB), effectively catalyze the reductive immobilization of U(VI) in the presence of amended electron donors (5, 44, 69). The addition of acetate to the subsurface at a uranium-contaminated site in Rifle, Colorado, initially stimulated FeRB within the family Geobacteraceae to reduce U(VI) (5, 65). However, with long-term acetate addition, SRB within the family Desulfobacteraceae, which are not capable of U(VI) reduction, increased in abundance and a concomitant reoxidation of U(IV) was observed (5, 65). At a uranium-contaminated site in Oak Ridge, Tennessee, in situ and laboratory-based experiments successfully employed ethanol amendments to stimulate denitrification followed by the reduction of U(VI) by indigenous microbial communities (13, 24, 44, 48, 50, 57, 68). In these studies, ethanol amendments stimulated both SRB and FeRB, with SRB likely catalyzing the reduction of U(VI). This suggests that the potential for bioremediation will be affected by the choice of electron donor amendment through effects on the functional diversity of U(VI)-reducing microbial populations. As uranium reduction is dependent on the depletion of nitrate, the microbial populations mediating nitrate reduction are also critical to the design of bioremediation strategies. Although nitrate-reducing bacteria (NRB) have been studied extensively in subsurface environments (2, 15, 19, 24, 56, 58, 70), the mechanisms controlling the in situ metabolism of NRB remain poorly understood.The dynamics of microbial populations capable of U(VI) reduction in subsurface sediments are poorly understood, and the differences in the microbial community dynamics during bioremediation have not been explored. Based on the results of previous studies (13, 44, 49, 57, 68, 69), we hypothesized that the activity of nitrate- and Fe(III)-reducing microbial populations, catalyzing the reductive immobilization of U(VI) in subsurface radionuclide-contaminated sediments, would be dependent on the choice of electron donor. The objectives of the present study were (i) to characterize structure-function relationships for microbial groups likely to catalyze or limit U(VI) reduction in radionuclide-contaminated sediments and (ii) to further develop a proxy for the metabolic activity of FeRB. Microbial activity was assessed by monitoring terminal electron-accepting processes (TEAPs), electron donor utilization, and Fe(III) mineral transformations in microcosms conducted with subsurface materials cocontaminated with high levels of U(VI) and nitrate. In parallel, microbial functional groups (i.e., NRB and FeRB) were enumerated and characterized using a combination of cultivation-dependent and -independent methods.     

Identification of Diverse Antimicrobial Resistance Determinants Carried on Bacterial,Plasmid, or Viral Metagenomes from an Activated Sludge Microbial Assemblage

Using both sequence- and function-based metagenomic approaches, multiple antibiotic resistance determinants were identified within metagenomic libraries constructed from DNA extracted from bacterial chromosomes, plasmids, or viruses within an activated sludge microbial assemblage. Metagenomic clones and a plasmid that in Escherichia coli expressed resistance to chloramphenicol, ampicillin, or kanamycin were isolated, with many cloned DNA sequences lacking any significant homology to known antibiotic resistance determinants.Activated sludge in wastewater treatment plants is an open system with a dynamic and phylogenetically diverse microbial community (2, 3, 6, 7, 10, 11). Since the activated sludge process promotes cellular interactions among diverse microorganisms, there is great potential for the lateral transfer of antibiotic resistance genes between microbes in activated sludge and in downstream environments. Several studies have previously identified antibiotic resistance determinants from wastewater communities that are carried on bacterial chromosomes (1, 4, 14) and plasmids (9, 12, 13), but to our knowledge, a simultaneous metagenomic survey of antibiotic resistance determinants from all three genetic reservoirs (i.e., chromosomes, plasmids, and viruses) has never been performed within the same environment. To achieve a more comprehensive assessment of antibiotic resistance genes in the activated sludge microbial community, this study used both function- and sequence-based metagenomic approaches to identify antibiotic resistance determinants carried on bacterial chromosomes, plasmids, or viruses within an activated sludge microbial assemblage.     

Assessment of Bias Associated with Incomplete Extraction of Microbial DNA from Soil

DNA extraction bias is a frequently cited but poorly understood limitation of molecular characterizations of environmental microbial communities. To assess the bias of a commonly used soil DNA extraction kit, we varied the cell lysis protocol and conducted multiple extractions on subsamples of clay, sand, and organic soils. DNA, as well as bacterial and fungal ribosomal gene copies as measured by quantitative PCR, continued to be isolated in successive extractions. When terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism was used, a significant shift in community composition due to extraction bias was detected for bacteria but not for fungi. Pyrosequencing indicated that the relative abundances of sequences from rarely cultivated groups such as Acidobacteria, Gemmatimonades, and Verrucomicrobia were higher in the first extraction than in the sixth but that the reverse was true for Proteobacteria and Actinobacteria. This suggests that the well-known phylum-level bacterial cultivation bias may be partially exaggerated by DNA extraction bias. We conclude that bias can be adequately reduced in many situations by pooling three successive extractions, and additional measures should be considered when divergent soil types are compared or when comprehensive community analysis is necessary.The vast majority of soil bacteria (1, 7, 27) and fungi (13, 29) cannot be cultured via traditional laboratory techniques and must be identified using molecular methods. Successful characterization of microbial communities is therefore often dependent on DNA that is extracted from the environment. However, extraction of high-quality DNA from soil can be problematic (8, 11, 22, 26). Commercial DNA extraction kits are now commonly used in the assessment of taxonomic and functional diversity, community composition, and population abundance (e.g., references 19, 21, 23, 25, and 31). Studies comparing various kits (18, 32) or comparing commercial kits to other methods (2, 10, 24) have shown that DNA yield and purity vary depending on methodology and soil type. While these comparative studies are valuable, it is still unclear to what extent these protocols yield genomic DNA representative of the microbial community found within soil.Our objective in this study was to optimize and assess the bias of a widely used commercial soil DNA extraction kit. We hypothesized that cell lysis would be enhanced and DNA would be removed from adsorption sites by conducting multiple extractions on a single sample, thereby increasing genomic DNA yield and obtaining a more complete survey of microbial taxa. This hypothesis was tested by (i) varying the extraction protocol and measuring DNA yield for three soils with differing characteristics and (ii) examining extraction bias in the genomic DNA obtained from successive extractions by using an improved method. Analytical replicates rather than biological replicates were used in order to focus strictly on variation and bias introduced through methodology, although multiple soil types were analyzed to determine whether biases detected were consistent.     

Microbial Community Structure and Denitrification in a Wetland Mitigation Bank

Wetland mitigation is implemented to replace ecosystem functions provided by wetlands; however, restoration efforts frequently fail to establish equivalent levels of ecosystem services. Delivery of microbially mediated ecosystem functions, such as denitrification, is influenced by both the structure and activity of the microbial community. The objective of this study was to compare the relationship between soil and vegetation factors and microbial community structure and function in restored and reference wetlands within a mitigation bank. Microbial community composition was assessed using terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism targeting the 16S rRNA gene (total bacteria) and the nosZ gene (denitrifiers). Comparisons of microbial function were based on potential denitrification rates. Bacterial community structures differed significantly between restored and reference wetlands; denitrifier community assemblages were similar among reference sites but highly variable among restored sites throughout the mitigation bank. Potential denitrification was highest in the reference wetland sites. These data demonstrate that wetland restoration efforts in this mitigation bank have not successfully restored denitrification and that differences in potential denitrification rates may be due to distinct microbial assemblages observed in restored and reference (natural) wetlands. Further, we have identified gradients in soil moisture and soil fertility that were associated with differences in microbial community structure. Microbial function was influenced by bacterial community composition and soil fertility. Identifying soil factors that are primary ecological drivers of soil bacterial communities, especially denitrifying populations, can potentially aid the development of predictive models for restoration of biogeochemical transformations and enhance the success of wetland restoration efforts.Wetlands provide more ecosystem services (e.g., flood control, water purification, nutrient cycling, and habitat for wildlife) per hectare than any other ecosystem (16). Riparian wetlands, in particular, are sites of intense biogeochemical activity and play an important role in improving water quality, recycling nutrients, and detoxifying chemicals (41). Changing patterns of land use over the last century have resulted in the loss of over half of the wetlands in the contiguous United States (17) and about 60% of wetlands in the Midwestern United States (82). The loss of ecosystem services through conversion of wetlands to alternative (primarily agricultural) land uses exacerbates nutrient pollution and eutrophication of downstream ecosystems (57). Declines in wetland acreage have continued despite a federal policy goal of no-net-loss of wetland acreage and function adopted in 1990 (7, 55). Wetland mitigation projects provide compensation for impacted wetlands and aim to replace the critical functions provided by wetlands. Despite decades of wetland mitigation, however, restoration efforts frequently fail to reestablish desired levels of ecosystem services. Restoration outcomes remain uncertain, and more information is necessary in order to improve monitoring and assessment of wetland development (13, 18, 50, 80).One approach to wetland compensation is through mitigation banks. These sites are areas that are restored, established, enhanced, or preserved for replacement of wetlands that will be affected by future land use change. Mitigation banks are considered “third-party” compensatory mitigation, where the permittee (e.g., developer planning to destroy a wetland) is responsible for purchasing wetland credits in acreage, but the wetland bank is established and managed by another party (24). Wetland mitigation banks have unique characteristics that distinguish them from smaller individual restoration projects (7, 69, 81). Due to their size, wetland mitigation banks are especially heterogeneous and may have a great deal of within-site variability in hydrology and nutrient status, making it challenging to implement a single restoration design. Thus, wetland mitigation banks require intense management and monitoring for improved success (7, 69, 81).Restoration efforts such as mitigation banks aim to replace chemical, physical, and biological ecosystem functions of wetlands that have been lost through anthropogenic disturbance (24). Monitoring of wetland mitigation sites has largely focused on measures of macro-scale community structure (e.g., vegetation surveys) (52) along with measures of hydrology and soil type (24). Measurement of vegetation is a common proxy for wetland performance but does not provide an accurate assessment of wetland function (6, 52). Quantitative assessment is achievable, however, for ecosystem services such as water quality improvement through nitrate removal, where well-characterized microbial mechanisms underlie denitrification processes.The link between microbial community structure and function in a restoration context is a topic of current interest (33). Relating microbial community composition and dynamics to chemical, physical, and biological variables can help to reveal important ecological drivers of microbial communities and their activities (26, 35, 42). Conserved bacterial functional genes related to specific biogeochemical transformations allow evaluation of the community structure of microbial populations directly involved in these processes (49, 60, 63, 77, 79). Assessing the diversity of microorganisms that are specifically involved in denitrification is possible through amplification of the nosZ gene, which encodes the catalytic subunit of nitrous oxide reductase, the enzyme responsible for the final step of denitrification (60, 63, 66). Phylogenetically diverse microorganisms can carry out denitrification though the majority of previously described denitrifiers belong to subphyla within the Proteobacteria (53, 56, 60, 61). Denitrification is a facultative process that occurs only under anaerobic conditions (53, 75). Complete denitrification to N₂ is more prevalent in anaerobic, saturated wetland ecosystems (14, 76), and incomplete denitrification to N₂O is the less desirable, more common endpoint of denitrification under more aerobic, drier conditions (14, 62). While the environmental factors (e.g., oxygen, carbon, nitrate, and pH) that influence bulk denitrification rates have been well characterized (31, 72), the influence of these factors on the composition of denitrifier communities, particularly in a restoration context, is unclear. Understanding the relationship between the microbial populations responsible for nitrogen transformations and easily measured environmental parameters (e.g., soil chemical and physical measures) could lead to assessment metrics that are linked directly to ecosystem functions such as denitrification and bridge the current gap in functional assessment methods (36, 60, 70).The objectives of this study were (i) to compare the microbial and plant community composition in restored wetlands to the composition in adjacent reference floodplain forest wetlands; (ii) to assess the relationship between microbial community composition (based on terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism [T-RFLP]) and potential denitrification activity throughout the mitigation bank; and (iii) to examine soil factors correlated with microbial community composition using both phylogenetic and functional gene markers. As soil environmental conditions affect microbial community structure and activity, we expected that sites where wetland hydrology and soil chemistry have been successfully restored would harbor microbial assemblages that are similar in composition and denitrification function to those observed in reference wetlands within this mitigation bank.     

Impacts of Inter- and Intralaboratory Variations on the Reproducibility of Microbial Community Analyses

With the advent of molecular biological techniques, especially next-generation sequencing and metagenomics, the number of microbial biogeography studies is rapidly increasing. However, these studies involve the synthesis of data generated by different laboratories using different protocols, chemicals, etc., all with inherent biases. The aim of this study was to assess inter- as well as intralaboratory variations in microbial community composition when standardized protocols are applied to a single soil sample. Aliquots from a homogenized soil sample from a rice field in Italy were sent to five participating laboratories. DNA was extracted by two investigators per laboratory using an identical protocol. All DNA samples were sent to one laboratory to perform DNA quantification, quantitative PCR (QPCR), and microarray and denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) analyses of methanotrophic communities. Yields, as well as purity of DNA, were significantly different between laboratories but in some cases also between investigators within the same laboratory. The differences in yield and quality of the extracted DNA were reflected in QPCR, microarray, and DGGE analysis results. Diversity indices (Shannon-Wiener, evenness, and richness) differed significantly between laboratories. The observed differences have implications for every project in which microbial communities are compared in different habitats, even if assessed within the same laboratory. To be able to make sensible comparisons leading to valid conclusions, intralaboratory variation should be assessed. Standardization of DNA extraction protocols and possible use of internal standards in interlaboratory comparisons may help in rendering a “quantifiable” bias.Microorganisms comprise a major part of total biomass and biodiversity (21, 41-43, 49). They play a critical role in biogeochemical processes and ecosystem functioning (16). However, knowledge of ecology and functioning of environmental microbial communities is still far from complete, mainly due to our inability to grow the majority of environmental microbes under laboratory conditions. The introduction of culture-independent DNA- and RNA-based techniques has led to a revolution in environmental microbiology, yielding a wealth of information on community compositions in an ever-growing range of habitats. Phylogenetic as well as functional microarrays (51) and metagenomic techniques (41, 47) enable in-depth analyses and comparison of whole microbial communities in a high-throughput manner.The collective goal of all environmental microbial ecology studies is 2-fold: (i) to obtain an overall understanding of microbial community composition, dynamics, and functioning and (ii) to identify regulating mechanisms. Reaching these goals will necessitate the integrated analyses of data generated in different laboratories and from different habitats. The first step in most if not all environmental microbial community studies is the extraction of total DNA from environmental samples in a way that reflects the in situ community composition as closely as possible. Numerous methods, protocols, and commercial kits have been developed to improve and optimize quantity and quality of extracted community DNA from a wide range of natural environments (4, 8, 28, 37, 39). However, up-to-date bias-free extraction methods are not available, especially not for complex and highly variable matrices, like soil. Beside the challenge of lysing all cells, the incomplete removal of compounds interfering with downstream processing render the development of a bias-free protocol a “mission impossible.” Assessments of the bias introduced by DNA extraction with different methods and kits on microbial community profiling revealed that a perfect protocol fitting all types of environments is not feasible (10, 17, 20, 45). However, in light of the global biodiversity debate, assessment of local and global patterns of microbial diversity and their controlling factors (19, 26) necessitates the comparison of data collected in multiple habitats and processed in different laboratories.In contrast to other scientific disciplines, intercalibration of protocols is not common practice in environmental microbiology. Interlaboratory comparisons (ring analyses) have been applied commonly in food control, veterinary, forensic, and soil studies to evaluate, for example, Salmonella diagnostic accuracy (25), virus isolation (18), enzyme-linked immmunosorbent assay methods (2), mitochondrial DNA sequencing (30), soil microbial biomass C (3), and quantitative PCR (QPCR) (11). Ring analyses assessing the reproducibility of DNA extraction and subsequent community analyses between different laboratories have not been carried out so far in environmental microbial ecology.A microbial functional guild that has been investigated intensively using molecular techniques is represented by the methanotrophs (aerobic methane-oxidizing bacteria [MOB]), which can be found in a wide variety of environments (27). The unique contribution of these bacteria to the global methane cycle has rendered the diversity and ecology of MOB hot topics for decades (9, 14, 34, 46, 48). By using methane as single source of carbon and energy, these microbes represent the only biological sink of the greenhouse gas methane under aerobic conditions (13). Aerobic MOB belong to the Gamma- and Alphaproteobacteria and the Verrucomicrobia (13, 34) and have the following features that enable linking function and identity. Assimilating methane facilitates the application of stable isotope probing of diagnostic lipids and of RNA/DNA (6, 29, 33). Besides this, the key gene in methane oxidation (for methanemonooxygenase subunit A, pmoA) reflects the phylogeny of these bacteria, facilitating a direct link between methane consumption and taxonomy. These features have made this group of microbes a model group for studies in environmental microbial ecology. Combined with the broad distribution and high environmental relevance, this group is highly suited to perform a ring analysis on reproducibility of DNA extraction and subsequent community profiling.In the present study, five independent laboratories from Norway, Finland, Netherlands, Germany, and Austria extracted DNA from the same rice field soil sample, using identical protocols and performed by two different investigators per laboratory. Subsequently, the extracted DNA was sent to one laboratory, where DNA quantification, QPCR, microarray, and denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) analyses were performed by one and the same person. The impacts of inter- as well as intralaboratory variations of DNA extraction are discussed, and recommendations for comparative studies are presented.     

Characterization of Airborne Microbial Communities at a High-Elevation Site and Their Potential To Act as Atmospheric Ice Nuclei

Bacteria and fungi are ubiquitous in the atmosphere. The diversity and abundance of airborne microbes may be strongly influenced by atmospheric conditions or even influence atmospheric conditions themselves by acting as ice nucleators. However, few comprehensive studies have described the diversity and dynamics of airborne bacteria and fungi based on culture-independent techniques. We document atmospheric microbial abundance, community composition, and ice nucleation at a high-elevation site in northwestern Colorado. We used a standard small-subunit rRNA gene Sanger sequencing approach for total microbial community analysis and a bacteria-specific 16S rRNA bar-coded pyrosequencing approach (4,864 sequences total). During the 2-week collection period, total microbial abundances were relatively constant, ranging from 9.6 × 10⁵ to 6.6 × 10⁶ cells m⁻³ of air, and the diversity and composition of the airborne microbial communities were also relatively static. Bacteria and fungi were nearly equivalent, and members of the proteobacterial groups Burkholderiales and Moraxellaceae (particularly the genus Psychrobacter) were dominant. These taxa were not always the most abundant in freshly fallen snow samples collected at this site. Although there was minimal variability in microbial abundances and composition within the atmosphere, the number of biological ice nuclei increased significantly during periods of high relative humidity. However, these changes in ice nuclei numbers were not associated with changes in the relative abundances of the most commonly studied ice-nucleating bacteria.Microbes are abundant in the atmosphere, with both cultivation-dependent and molecular approaches showing that the atmosphere harbors a diverse assemblage of bacteria and fungi, including taxa also commonly found on leaf surfaces (5, 49) and in soil habitats (30). The abundance and composition of airborne microbial communities are variable across time and space (14, 24, 27, 33, 47, 48, 69). However, the atmospheric conditions responsible for driving the observed changes in microbial abundances are unknown. The diversity of airborne microorganisms, and the factors influencing diversity levels, also remains poorly characterized. One reason for these limitations in knowledge is that until recently, culture-based microbiological methods have been the standard, and it is well-recognized that such methods capture only a small portion of the total microbial diversity (59). As demonstrated in a number of recent studies (6, 13, 22, 23, 33, 52, 59, 63, 73), advances in culture-independent techniques allow far more of the microbial diversity present in the atmosphere to be surveyed and the spatiotemporal variability in microbial communities to be examined.Microbes are often considered passive inhabitants of the atmosphere, dispersing via airborne dust particles. However, recent studies suggest that many atmospheric microbes may be metabolically active (3, 4, 64), even up to altitudes of 20,000 m (34). Some airborne microbes may alter atmospheric conditions directly by acting as cloud condensation nuclei (7, 25, 56) and/or ice nuclei (IN) (19, 41, 56, 57, 61); this hypothesis is supported by the observation that most ice nuclei in snow samples are inactivated by a 95°C heat treatment (16, 17). However, the overall contribution of airborne microbes to atmospheric processes such as ice nucleation remains unclear.The best-studied ice-nucleating microbes are gram-negative bacteria that have also been isolated from leaf surfaces, including Pseudomonas syringae, Pseudomonas fluorescens, Erwinia herbicola, Xanthomonas campestri, and Sphingomonas spp. (45). These bacteria have been cultured extensively, and their ice-nucleating activity has been traced to a membrane-bound glycoprotein (40, 42, 70). However, their specific influence on atmospheric processes remains, at this point, largely anecdotal. Less is known about the ice-nucleating activities of fungi, but a few studies have shown that fungi can be effective ice nucleators, capable of initiating ice nucleation at temperatures as high as −2°C (41, 61). At this point, all known ice-nucleating microorganisms are amenable to culture-based studies, but given that the vast majority of microorganisms have yet to be cultured, it is likely that other ice-nucleating microbes remain undiscovered.The work presented here addresses three overarching questions. (i) Are microbial abundances altered by changes in atmospheric conditions? (ii) How is the diversity and composition of airborne microbial communities influenced by changes in atmospheric conditions? (iii) Can we identify known and novel ice-nucleating microbes in the atmosphere by testing for correlations between taxa abundances and the concentrations of biological ice nuclei? To address these questions, we combined epifluorescence microscopy, tagged pyrosequencing, Sanger sequencing, and an ice nucleation assay with atmospheric measurements to characterize the microbial communities at a high-elevation research site.     

Use of Ichip for High-Throughput In Situ Cultivation of “Uncultivable” Microbial Species

One of the oldest unresolved microbiological phenomena is why only a small fraction of the diverse microbiological population grows on artificial media. The “uncultivable” microbial majority arguably represents our planet''s largest unexplored pool of biological and chemical novelty. Previously we showed that species from this pool could be grown inside diffusion chambers incubated in situ, likely because diffusion provides microorganisms with their naturally occurring growth factors. Here we utilize this approach and develop a novel high-throughput platform for parallel cultivation and isolation of previously uncultivated microbial species from a variety of environments. We have designed and tested an isolation chip (ichip) composed of several hundred miniature diffusion chambers, each inoculated with a single environmental cell. We show that microbial recovery in the ichip exceeds manyfold that afforded by standard cultivation, and the grown species are of significant phylogenetic novelty. The new method allows access to a large and diverse array of previously inaccessible microorganisms and is well suited for both fundamental and applied research.It has been known for over a century that the overwhelming majority of microbial species do not grow on synthetic media in vitro and remain unexplored (13, 32, 37, 39, 40, 43). The rRNA and metagenomics approaches demonstrated a spectacular diversity of these uncultivated species (11, 21, 25-27, 30, 36). Accessing this “missing” microbial diversity is of significant interest for both basic and applied sciences and has been recognized as one of the principal challenges for microbiology today (12, 29, 41). In recent years, technical advances in cultivation methodologies have recovered a diverse set of ecologically relevant species (1, 3, 5, 7, 15, 20, 24, 28, 33, 42). However, by and large the gap between microbial diversity in nature and that in culture collections remains unchanged, and most microbial phyla still have no cultivable representatives (25, 29). Earlier, we developed a novel method of in situ cultivation of environmental microorganisms inside diffusion chambers (15). The rationale for such an approach was that diffusion would provide cells inside the chamber with naturally occurring growth components and enable those species that grew in nature at the time of the experiment to also grow inside the diffusion chambers. Expectedly, this method yields a rate of microbial recovery many times larger than those of standard techniques. Even so, this method is laborious and does not allow an efficient, high-throughput isolation of microbial species en masse. This limits the method''s applicability, for example, in the drug discovery effort. Here we transform this methodology into a high-throughput technology platform for massively parallel cultivation of “uncultivable” species. Capitalizing on earlier microfluidics methods developed for microbial storage and screening (4, 16), we have designed and tested an isolation chip, or ichip for short, which consists of hundreds of miniature diffusion chambers. If each diffusion minichamber is loaded with a single cell, the resulting culture is monospecific. The ichip thus allows microbial growth and isolation into pure culture in one step. Here we demonstrate that cultivation of environmental microorganisms inside the ichip incubated in situ leads to a significantly increased colony count over that observed on synthetic media. Perhaps even more significantly, species grown in ichips are different from those registered in standard petri dishes and are highly novel.     

Phylogenetic Analysis Indicates Evolutionary Diversity and Environmental Segregation of Marine Podovirus DNA Polymerase Gene Sequences

The distribution of viral genotypes in the ocean and their evolutionary relatedness remain poorly constrained. This paper presents data on the genetic diversity and evolutionary relationships of 1.2-kb DNA polymerase (pol) gene fragments from podoviruses. A newly designed set of PCR primers was used to amplify DNA directly from coastal sediment and water samples collected from inlets adjacent to the Strait of Georgia, British Columbia, Canada, and from the northeastern Gulf of Mexico. Restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis of 160 cloned PCR products revealed 29 distinct operational taxonomic units (OTUs), with OTUs within a site typically being more similar than those among sites. Phylogenetic analysis of the DNA pol gene fragments demonstrated high similarity between some environmental sequences and sequences from the marine podoviruses roseophage SIO1 and cyanophage P60, while others were not closely related to sequences from cultured phages. Interrogation of the CAMERA database for sequences from metagenomics data demonstrated that the amplified sequences were representative of the diversity of podovirus pol sequences found in marine samples. Our results indicate high genetic diversity within marine podovirus communities within a small geographic region and demonstrate that the diversity of environmental polymerase gene sequences for podoviruses is far more extensive than previously recognized.Marine viruses are the most abundant (41) and diverse (2, 6) biological entities in the ocean. They affect community composition by causing the lysis of specific subsets of the microbial community (22, 28, 46, 47) and, by killing numerically dominant host taxa, may influence species evenness and richness (24, 28, 43, 50). Despite the abundance of bacteriophages in marine systems and their important roles in marine microbial composition, little is known about the distribution and diversity of specific groups of marine viruses. However, most marine bacteriophage isolates are tailed phages (3) belonging to the order Caudovirales (27), which comprises the families Myoviridae, Podoviridae, and Siphoviridae.Podoviruses are classified into several groups (e.g., T7-like, P22-like, and phi-29-like) based on genome size, genome arrangement, and shared genes and can be readily isolated from seawater (11, 16, 42, 45). Genomic analysis of roseophage SIO1 (33), cyanophage P60 (7), vibriophage VpV262 (21), and cyanophage PSSP7 (40) suggests that many of the isolates are T7-like. Despite the apparently wide distribution of podoviruses in the sea, and their potential importance as agents of microbial mortality, there has been little effort to explore their diversity.Sequence analysis of representative genes is one approach that has been used to examine the genetic diversity of specific groups of marine viruses. For example, homologues for structural genes (g20 and g23) found in T4-like phages are found in some marine myoviruses (18, 20) and have been used to examine the distribution, diversity, and evolutionary relationships among marine myoviruses (12, 14, 17, 37, 38, 49). Other studies have used DNA polymerase (pol) to examine the diversity of viruses infecting eukaryotic phytoplankton (8, 38) and have shown that phylogenies constructed with this gene are congruent with established viral taxonomy (9, 36, 37).Although it is not universally present, family A DNA pol is a good target for examining the diversity of podoviruses (4). Our study presents a newly designed set of PCR primers that amplify a longer fragment of the DNA polymerase from a much larger suite of podoviruses and shows that the diversity within marine podoviruses as revealed by DNA pol sequences is far greater than previously realized.     

A New Borrelia Species Defined by Multilocus Sequence Analysis of Housekeeping Genes

Analysis of Lyme borreliosis (LB) spirochetes, using a novel multilocus sequence analysis scheme, revealed that OspA serotype 4 strains (a rodent-associated ecotype) of Borrelia garinii were sufficiently genetically distinct from bird-associated B. garinii strains to deserve species status. We suggest that OspA serotype 4 strains be raised to species status and named Borrelia bavariensis sp. nov. The rooted phylogenetic trees provide novel insights into the evolutionary history of LB spirochetes.Multilocus sequence typing (MLST) and multilocus sequence analysis (MLSA) have been shown to be powerful and pragmatic molecular methods for typing large numbers of microbial strains for population genetics studies, delineation of species, and assignment of strains to defined bacterial species (4, 13, 27, 40, 44). To date, MLST/MLSA schemes have been applied only to a few vector-borne microbial populations (1, 6, 30, 37, 40, 41, 47).Lyme borreliosis (LB) spirochetes comprise a diverse group of zoonotic bacteria which are transmitted among vertebrate hosts by ixodid (hard) ticks. The most common agents of human LB are Borrelia burgdorferi (sensu stricto), Borrelia afzelii, Borrelia garinii, Borrelia lusitaniae, and Borrelia spielmanii (7, 8, 12, 35). To date, 15 species have been named within the group of LB spirochetes (6, 31, 32, 37, 38, 41). While several of these LB species have been delineated using whole DNA-DNA hybridization (3, 20, 33), most ecological or epidemiological studies have been using single loci (5, 9-11, 29, 34, 36, 38, 42, 51, 53). Although some of these loci have been convenient for species assignment of strains or to address particular epidemiological questions, they may be unsuitable to resolve evolutionary relationships among LB species, because it is not possible to define any outgroup. For example, both the 5S-23S intergenic spacer (5S-23S IGS) and the gene encoding the outer surface protein A (ospA) are present only in LB spirochete genomes (36, 43). The advantage of using appropriate housekeeping genes of LB group spirochetes is that phylogenetic trees can be rooted with sequences of relapsing fever spirochetes. This renders the data amenable to detailed evolutionary studies of LB spirochetes.LB group spirochetes differ remarkably in their patterns and levels of host association, which are likely to affect their population structures (22, 24, 46, 48). Of the three main Eurasian Borrelia species, B. afzelii is adapted to rodents, whereas B. valaisiana and most strains of B. garinii are maintained by birds (12, 15, 16, 23, 26, 45). However, B. garinii OspA serotype 4 strains in Europe have been shown to be transmitted by rodents (17, 18) and, therefore, constitute a distinct ecotype within B. garinii. These strains have also been associated with high pathogenicity in humans, and their finer-scale geographical distribution seems highly focal (10, 34, 52, 53).In this study, we analyzed the intra- and interspecific phylogenetic relationships of B. burgdorferi, B. afzelii, B. garinii, B. valaisiana, B. lusitaniae, B. bissettii, and B. spielmanii by means of a novel MLSA scheme based on chromosomal housekeeping genes (30, 48).     

Alignment of the c-Type Cytochrome OmcS along Pili of Geobacter sulfurreducens

Immunogold localization revealed that OmcS, a cytochrome that is required for Fe(III) oxide reduction by Geobacter sulfurreducens, was localized along the pili. The apparent spacing between OmcS molecules suggests that OmcS facilitates electron transfer from pili to Fe(III) oxides rather than promoting electron conduction along the length of the pili.There are multiple competing/complementary models for extracellular electron transfer in Fe(III)- and electrode-reducing microorganisms (8, 18, 20, 44). Which mechanisms prevail in different microorganisms or environmental conditions may greatly influence which microorganisms compete most successfully in sedimentary environments or on the surfaces of electrodes and can impact practical decisions on the best strategies to promote Fe(III) reduction for bioremediation applications (18, 19) or to enhance the power output of microbial fuel cells (18, 21).The three most commonly considered mechanisms for electron transfer to extracellular electron acceptors are (i) direct contact between redox-active proteins on the outer surfaces of the cells and the electron acceptor, (ii) electron transfer via soluble electron shuttling molecules, and (iii) the conduction of electrons along pili or other filamentous structures. Evidence for the first mechanism includes the necessity for direct cell-Fe(III) oxide contact in Geobacter species (34) and the finding that intensively studied Fe(III)- and electrode-reducing microorganisms, such as Geobacter sulfurreducens and Shewanella oneidensis MR-1, display redox-active proteins on their outer cell surfaces that could have access to extracellular electron acceptors (1, 2, 12, 15, 27, 28, 31-33). Deletion of the genes for these proteins often inhibits Fe(III) reduction (1, 4, 7, 15, 17, 28, 40) and electron transfer to electrodes (5, 7, 11, 33). In some instances, these proteins have been purified and shown to have the capacity to reduce Fe(III) and other potential electron acceptors in vitro (10, 13, 29, 38, 42, 43, 48, 49).Evidence for the second mechanism includes the ability of some microorganisms to reduce Fe(III) that they cannot directly contact, which can be associated with the accumulation of soluble substances that can promote electron shuttling (17, 22, 26, 35, 36, 47). In microbial fuel cell studies, an abundance of planktonic cells and/or the loss of current-producing capacity when the medium is replaced is consistent with the presence of an electron shuttle (3, 14, 26). Furthermore, a soluble electron shuttle is the most likely explanation for the electrochemical signatures of some microorganisms growing on an electrode surface (26, 46).Evidence for the third mechanism is more circumstantial (19). Filaments that have conductive properties have been identified in Shewanella (7) and Geobacter (41) species. To date, conductance has been measured only across the diameter of the filaments, not along the length. The evidence that the conductive filaments were involved in extracellular electron transfer in Shewanella was the finding that deletion of the genes for the c-type cytochromes OmcA and MtrC, which are necessary for extracellular electron transfer, resulted in nonconductive filaments, suggesting that the cytochromes were associated with the filaments (7). However, subsequent studies specifically designed to localize these cytochromes revealed that, although the cytochromes were extracellular, they were attached to the cells or in the exopolymeric matrix and not aligned along the pili (24, 25, 30, 40, 43). Subsequent reviews of electron transfer to Fe(III) in Shewanella oneidensis (44, 45) appear to have dropped the nanowire concept and focused on the first and second mechanisms.Geobacter sulfurreducens has a number of c-type cytochromes (15, 28) and multicopper proteins (12, 27) that have been demonstrated or proposed to be on the outer cell surface and are essential for extracellular electron transfer. Immunolocalization and proteolysis studies demonstrated that the cytochrome OmcB, which is essential for optimal Fe(III) reduction (15) and highly expressed during growth on electrodes (33), is embedded in the outer membrane (39), whereas the multicopper protein OmpB, which is also required for Fe(III) oxide reduction (27), is exposed on the outer cell surface (39).OmcS is one of the most abundant cytochromes that can readily be sheared from the outer surfaces of G. sulfurreducens cells (28). It is essential for the reduction of Fe(III) oxide (28) and for electron transfer to electrodes under some conditions (11). Therefore, the localization of this important protein was further investigated.     

Hollow-Fiber Membrane Chamber as a Device for In Situ Environmental Cultivation

A hollow-fiber membrane chamber (HFMC) was developed as an in situ cultivation device for environmental microorganisms. The HFMC system consists of 48 to 96 pieces of porous hollow-fiber membrane connected with injectors. The system allows rapid exchange of chemical compounds, thereby simulating a natural environment. Comparative analysis through the cultivation of three types of environmental samples was performed using this newly designed device and a conventional agar-based petri dish. The results show that the ratios of novel phylotypes in isolates, species-level diversities, and cultivabilities in HFMC-based cultivation are higher than those in an agar-based petri dish for all three samples, suggesting that the new in situ cultivation device is effective for cultivation of various environmental microorganisms.Although highly diverse untapped microbial consortia exist in natural environments, it is generally recognized that most microorganisms are not readily cultivable in the laboratory (1, 17). Recent advances in culture-independent molecular approaches, based on rRNA or genomic approaches that can estimate microbial composition and function, have considerably improved knowledge of microbial ecosystems (7, 11, 29, 32). However, cultivation-based approaches are still necessary for comprehensive elucidation of the physiology and ecology of these organisms and for their biotechnological applications. Recently, several attempts have been made to address these issues (19, 24). Modification of growth conditions based on conventional methods, such as controlling the substrate composition and concentration, the gelling reagent, trace additives such as signaling molecules, and the length of cultivation, has improved isolation efficiencies of rarely cultivated phyla and increased the diversity of isolates (3, 4, 6, 9, 14, 15, 26, 28, 30). Newly developed cultivation methods such as high-throughput methods have brought success with uncultivated microorganisms and improved cultivation capabilities (5, 8, 20, 22, 35). Additionally, development and use of a diffusion chamber to enable the exchange of chemical compounds during cultivation have demonstrated the importance of in situ environmental conditions for the isolation of environmental microorganisms (2, 16). Among them, a concept based on “environmental simulation” is likely to be generally effective for cultivation of environmental microorganisms because various factors that are unknown but necessary for recovery and growth can be provided to the microorganisms (10). However, very few methods have been developed that are applicable to cultivation of microorganisms under in situ environmental conditions. Consequently, it is still important to develop a new cultivation device that is particularly suitable for pure cultivation under in situ environmental conditions while maintaining simple operation. For this study, we designed a new cultivation device, called the hollow-fiber membrane chamber (HFMC), which can provide in situ environmental and liquid culture conditions while maintaining a microliter- to milliliter-scale volume of each chamber. We evaluated the effect of the new device, especially for cultivation under in situ environmental conditions, on cultivation of samples from several different environments.