Semi-synthetic aequorins with improved sensitivity to Ca2+ ions.

Thirty-seven coelenterazine analogues were synthesized and incorporated into apo-aequorin, yielding 30 semi-synthetic aequorins that have the capacity to emit a significant amount of light in the presence of Ca2+. The properties of resultant photoproteins were investigated. The most prominent feature of those photoproteins was the wide range in their sensitivities to Ca2+ concentration. The relative intensity of Ca2+-triggered luminescence of the photoproteins ranged from 0.01 to 190 when compared with natural aequorin (relative intensity 1.0) at pCa 6 for the cases where the relative intensity is less than 1 and at pCa 7 for the cases where the relative intensity is higher than 1. Eight of the semi-synthetic aequorins belonged to the class of e-aequorin. With two of those photoproteins, the degree of dependence of the luminescence intensity ratio I400/I465 on pCa was greater than that with e-aequorin, suggesting that these two photoproteins are possibly superior to e-aequorin in measuring Ca2+ concentration by the ratio method.     

Preparation and handling of aequorin solutions for the measurement of cellular Ca2+

Main characteristics of the various types of aequorin presently available for measuring cellular Ca2+, i.e. heterogeneous aequorin, isoaequorins, recombinant aequorin, fluorescein-labeled aequorin and semi-synthetic aequorins, are summarized. Basic techniques of preparing and handling the solutions of those aequorins for measuring Ca2+, including such techniques as concentrating aequorin solutions, freeze-drying, changing buffer composition, and the regeneration of active aequorin, are described.     

The crystal structures of semi-synthetic aequorins

The photoprotein aequorin emits light by an intramolecular reaction in the presence of a trace amount of Ca(2+). Semi-synthetic aequorins, produced by replacing the coelenterazine moiety in aequorin with the analogues of coelenterazine, show widely different sensitivities to Ca(2+). To understand the structural basis of the Ca(2+)-sensitivity, we determined the crystal structures of four semi-synthetic aequorins (cp-, i-, br- and n-aequorins) at resolutions of 1.6-1.8 A. In general, the protein structures of these semi-synthetic aequorins are almost identical to native aequorin. Of the four EF-hand domains in the molecule, EF-hand II does not bind Ca(2+), and the loop of EF-hand IV is clearly deformed. It is most likely that the binding of Ca(2+) with EF-hands I and III triggers luminescence. Although little difference was found in the overall structures of aequorins investigated, some significant differences were found in the interactions between the substituents of coelenterazine moiety and the amino acid residues in the binding pocket. The coelenterazine moieties in i-, br-, and n-aequorins have bulky 2-substitutions, which can interfere with the conformational changes of protein structure that follow the binding of Ca(2+) to aequorin. In cp-aequorin, the cyclopentylmethyl group that substitutes for the original 8-benzyl group does not interact hydrophobically with the protein part, giving the coelenterazine moiety more conformational freedom to promote the light-emitting reaction. The differences of various semi-synthetic aequorins in Ca(2+)-sensitivity and reaction rate are explained by the capability of the involved groups and structures to undergo conformational changes in response to the Ca(2+)-binding.     

Semi-synthetic aequorin. An improved tool for the measurement of calcium ion concentration.

The photoprotein aequorin isolated from the jellyfish Aequorea emits blue light in the presence of Ca2+ by an intramolecular process that involves chemical transformation of the coelenterazine moiety into coelenteramide and CO2. Because of its high sensitivity to Ca2+, aequorin has widely been used as a Ca2+ indicator in various biological systems. We have replaced the coelenterazine moiety in the protein with several synthetic coelenterazine analogues, providing semi-synthetic Ca2+-sensitive photoproteins. One of the semi-synthetic photoproteins, derived from coelenterazine analogue (II) (with an extra ethano group), showed highly promising properties for the measurement of Ca2+, namely (1) the rise time of luminescence in response to Ca2+ was shortened by approx. 4-fold compared with native aequorin and (2) the luminescence spectrum showed two peaks at 405 nm and 465 nm and the ratio of their peak heights was dependent on Ca2+ concentration in the range of pCa 5-7, thus allowing the determination of [Ca2+] directly from the ratio of two peak intensities. Coelenterazine analogue (I) (with a hydroxy group replaced by an amino group) was also incorporated into apo-aequorin, yielding a Ca2+-sensitive photoprotein, which indicates that an electrostatic interaction between the phenolate group in the coelenterazine moiety and some cationic centre in apo-aequorin is not important in native aequorin, contrary to a previous suggestion.     

Isolation and properties of various molecular forms of aequorin.

The photoprotein aequorin emits light by an intramolecular reaction when a trace of Ca2+ is added. The samples of aequorin that were purified by the conventional methods of column chromatography were separated by high-performance liquid chromatography into eight molecular forms (isoaequorins), which were designated aequorins A-H. Aequorins A, C and F were obtained in crystalline states. A wide range of properties were studied with aequorins A-F, which were essentially pure. These six isoaequorins showed relatively small differences in their spectroscopic properties, but their values of A0.1%/1 cm, 280 were found to be close to 3.0, about 10% more than the previously reported value of 2.70-2.71 that was obtained with the samples of conventionally purified aequorin. The Mr values ranged from 20,100 (aequorin F) to 22,800 (aequorin A), the luminescence activities ranged from 4.35 X 10(15) photons/mg (aequorin A) to 5.16 X 10(15) photons/mg (aequorin F), and the first-order reaction rate constants of luminescence ranged from 0.95 s-1 (aequorin A) to 1.33 s-1 (aequorin F). As regards sensitivity to Ca2+, aequorin D was the most sensitive, having a sensitivity about 0.4-0.5 pCa unit above that of the least sensitive kind (aequorin A).     

Imaging calcium dynamics in living plants using semi-synthetic recombinant aequorins

The genetic transformation of the higher plant Nicotiana plumbaginifolia to express the protein apoaequorin has recently been used as a method to measure cytosolic free calcium ([Ca2+]i) changes within intact living plants (Knight, M. R., A. K. Campbell, S. M. Smith, and A. J. Trewavas. 1991. Nature (Lond.). 352:524-526; Knight, M. R., S. M. Smith, and A. J. Trewavas. 1992. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 89:4967-4971). After treatment with the luminophore coelenterazine the calcium-activated photoprotein aequorin is formed within the cytosol of the cells of the transformed plants. Aequorin emits blue light in a dose-dependent manner upon binding free calcium (Ca2+). Thus the quantification of light emission from coelenterazine-treated transgenic plant cells provides a direct measurement of [Ca2+]i. In this paper, by using a highly sensitive photon-counting camera connected to a light microscope, we have for the first time imaged changes in [Ca2+]i in response to cold-shock, touch and wounding in different tissues of transgenic Nicotiana plants. Using this approach we have been able to observe tissue-specific [Ca2+]i responses. We also demonstrate how this method can be tailored by the use of different coelenterazine analogues which endow the resultant aequorin (termed semi-synthetic recombinant aeqorin) with different properties. By using h-coelenterazine, which renders the recombinant aequorin reporter more sensitive to Ca2+, we have been able to image relatively small changes in [Ca2+]i in response to touch and wounding: changes not detectable when standard coelenterazine is used. Reconstitution of recombinant aequorin with another coelenterazine analogue (e-coelenterazine) produces a semi-synthetic recombinant aequorin with a bimodal spectrum of luminescence emission. The ratio of luminescence at two wavelengths (421 and 477 nm) provides a simpler method for quantification of [Ca2+]i in vivo than was previously available. This approach has the benefit that no information is needed on the amount of expression, reconstitution or consumption of aequorin which is normally required for calibration with aequorin.     

Calcium-sensitive photoproteins

The recombinant Ca2+ sensitive photoprotein aequorin was the first probe used to measure specifically the Ca2+ concentration, [Ca2+], inside the intracellular organelles of intact cells. Aequorin-based methods offer several advantages: (i) targeting of the probe is extremely precise, thus permitting a selective intracellular distribution; (ii) the use of wild-type and low Ca2+-affinity aequorins allows covering a large dynamic range of [Ca2+], from 10(-7) to 10(-3)M; (iii) aequorin has a low Ca2+ buffering effect and it is nearly insensitive to changes in Mg2+ or pH; (iv) it has a high signal-to-noise ratio; (v) calibration of the results in [Ca2+] is made straightforward using a simple algorithm; and (vi) the equipment required for luminescence measurements in cell populations is simple and low-cost. On the negative side, this technique has also some disadvantages: (i) the relatively low amount of emitted light makes difficult performing single-cell imaging studies; (ii) reconstitution of aequorin with coelenterazine is necessary to generate the functional photoprotein and this procedure requires at least 1h; (iii) in the case of aequorin targeted to high Ca2+ compartments, because of the high rate of aequorin consumption at steady-state, only relatively brief experiments can be performed and, because of the steepness of the Ca2+-response curve, the calibrated [Ca2+] values may not reflect the real mean in cells or compartments with dyshomogeneous behavior; and (iv) expression of targeted aequorins requires previous transfection or infection to introduce the appropriate DNA construct, or alternatively the use of stable cell clones.     

Expression of apo-aequorin during embryonic development; how much is needed for calcium imaging?

Aequorin is a bioluminescent calcium indicator consisting of a 21 kDa protein (apo-aequorin) that is covalently linked to a lipophilic cofactor (coelenterazine). The aequorin gene can be expressed in a variety of cell lines and tissues, allowing non-invasive calcium imaging of specific cell types. In the present paper, we describe the possibilities and limitations of calcium imaging with genetically introduced apo-aequorin during embryonic development. By injecting aequorin into sea urchin, Drosophila and zebrafish eggs, we found that higher aequorin concentrations are needed in smaller eggs. Our results suggest that for measuring resting levels of free cytosolic calcium, one needs aequorin concentrations of at least 40 μM in sea urchin eggs, 2 μM in Drosophila eggs, and only 0.11 μM in zebrafish eggs. A simple assay was used to determine the absolute concentrations of expressed apo-aequorin and the percentage of aequorin formation in vivo. The use of this assay is illustrated by expression of the aequorin gene in Drosophila oocytes. These oocytes form up to 1 μM apo-aequorin. In our hands, only 0.3% of this apo-aequorin combined with coelenterazine entering from the medium to form aequorin, which was not enough for calcium imaging of the oocytes, but did allow in vivo imaging of the ovaries. From these studies, we conclude that coelenterazine entry into the cell is the rate limiting step in aequorin formation. Based on the rate of coelenterazine uptake in Drosophila, we estimate that complete conversion of 1 μM apo-aequorin would take 50 days in zebrafish eggs, 19 days in Drosophila eggs, 7 days in sea urchin eggs or 18 h in a 10 gm tissue culture cell. Our results suggest that work based on genetically introduced apo-aequorin will be most successful when large amounts of small cells can be incubated in coelenterazine. During embryonic development this would involve introducing coelenterazine into the circulatory system of late stage embryos. Calcium imaging in early stage embryos may be best done by injecting aequorin, which circumvents the slow process of coelenterazine entry.     

Subcellular analysis of Ca2+ homeostasis in primary cultures of skeletal muscle myotubes.

Specifically targeted aequorin chimeras were used for studying the dynamic changes of Ca2+ concentration in different subcellular compartments of differentiated skeletal muscle myotubes. For the cytosol, mitochondria, and nucleus, the previously described chimeric aequorins were utilized; for the sarcoplasmic reticulum (SR), a new chimera (srAEQ) was developed by fusing an aequorin mutant with low Ca2+ affinity to the resident protein calsequestrin. By using an appropriate transfection procedure, the expression of the recombinant proteins was restricted, within the culture, to the differentiated myotubes, and the correct sorting of the various chimeras was verified with immunocytochemical techniques. Single-cell analysis of cytosolic Ca2+ concentration ([Ca2+]c) with fura-2 showed that the myotubes responded, as predicted, to stimuli known to be characteristic of skeletal muscle fibers, i.e., KCl-induced depolarization, caffeine, and carbamylcholine. Using these stimuli in cultures transfected with the various aequorin chimeras, we show that: 1) the nucleoplasmic Ca2+ concentration ([Ca2+]n) closely mimics the [Ca2+]c, at rest and after stimulation, indicating a rapid equilibration of the two compartments also in this cell type; 2) on the contrary, mitochondria amplify 4-6-fold the [Ca2+]c increases; and 3) the lumenal concentration of Ca2+ within the SR ([Ca2+]sr) is much higher than in the other compartments (> 100 microM), too high to be accurately measured also with the aequorin mutant with low Ca2+ affinity. An indirect estimate of the resting value (approximately 1-2 mM) was obtained using Sr2+, a surrogate of Ca2+ which, because of the lower affinity of the photoprotein for this cation, elicits a lower rate of aequorin consumption. With Sr2+, the kinetics and amplitudes of the changes in [cation2+]sr evoked by the various stimuli could also be directly analyzed.     

Blue fluorescent protein from the calcium-sensitive photoprotein aequorin: catalytic properties for the oxidation of coelenterazine as an oxygenase

Blue fluorescent protein from the calcium-binding photoprotein aequorin (BFP-aq) is a complex of Ca2+ -bound apoaequorin and coelenteramide, and shows luminescence activity like a luciferase, catalyzing the oxidation of coelenterazine with molecular oxygen. To understand the catalytic properties of BFP-aq, various fluorescent proteins (FP-aq) have been prepared from semi-synthetic aequorin and characterized in comparison with BFP-aq. FP-aq has luciferase activity and could be regenerated into native aequorin by incubation with coelenterazine. The results from substrate specificity studies of FP-aq using various coelenterazine analogues have suggested that the oxidation of coelenterazine by BFP-aq in the luciferase reaction and the regeneration process to aequorin might involve the same catalytic site of BFP-aq.     

Cloning, expression, purification and characterization of an isotype of clytin, a calcium-binding photoprotein from the luminous hydromedusa Clytia gregarium

The cDNA for an isotype of clytin, a calcium-binding photoprotein from the luminous jellyfish Clytia gregarium, was identified and named clytin-II. The histidine-tagged apoprotein of clytin-II expressed into the periplasmic space of Escherichia coli cells was isolated by nickel chelate affinity chromatography. Recombinant clytin-II regenerated from apoprotein by incubation with coelenterazine was purified. The yield of purified clytin-II was 13 mg from 2 l of cultured cells with purity >95%. The luminescence properties of clytin-II were characterized by comparison with clytin-I and aequorin, and semi-synthetic clytin-II was also prepared. The initial luminescence intensity of clytin-II triggered by Ca(2+) was 4.5 times higher than that of clytin-I and aequorin, but the luminescence capacity was close to clytin-I and aequorin. Thus, clytin-II is a useful protein, showing high sensitivity in the signal-to-noise ratio of luminescence intensity.     

Bioluminescence of the Ca-binding photoprotein, aequorin, after histidine modification

Modification studies of the 5 histidine residues in aequorin employing site-directed mutagenesis and diethyl pyrocarbonate suggested that His¹⁶⁹ may be the site of binding of molecular oxygen in aequorin. The modification of this residue led to complete loss of activity, whereas modification of the remaining 4 histidine residues yielded mutant aequorins with varying bioluminescence activities.     

Calcium measurement in living filamentous fungi expressing codon-optimized aequorin

Calcium signalling is little understood in filamentous fungi largely because easy and routine methods for calcium measurement in living hyphae have previously been unavailable. We have developed the recombinant aequorin method for this purpose. High levels of aequorin expression were obtained in Neurospora crassa, Aspergillus niger and Aspergillus awamori by codon optimization of the aequorin gene. Three external stimuli (mechanical perturbation, hypo-osmotic shock and high external calcium) were found transiently to increase [Ca(2+)](c). Each of the calcium signatures associated with these physico-chemical treatments was unique, suggesting the involvement of three distinct calcium-mediated signal transduction pathways. The fungal calcium channel blocker KP4 inhibited the [Ca(2+)](c) responses to hypo-osmotic shock and high external calcium, but not to mechanical perturbation. The divalent cation chelator BAPTA inhibited [Ca(2+)](c) responses to mechanical perturbation and hypo-osmotic shock. The calcium agonists A23187 and cyclopiazonic acid increased [Ca(2+)](c) levels.     

Presenilin mutations linked to familial Alzheimer's disease reduce endoplasmic reticulum and Golgi apparatus calcium levels

Presenilin-1 and -2 (PS1 and PS2) mutations, the major cause of familial Alzheimer's disease (FAD), have been causally implicated in the pathogenesis of neuronal cell death through a perturbation of cellular Ca(2+) homeostasis. We have recently shown that, at variance with previous suggestions obtained in cells expressing other FAD-linked PS mutations, PS2-M239I and PS2-T122R cause a reduction and not an increase in cytosolic Ca(2+) rises induced by Ca(2+) release from stores. In this contribution we have used different cell models: human fibroblasts from controls and FAD patients, cell lines (SH-SY5Y, HeLa, HEK293, MEFs) and rat primary neurons expressing a number of PS mutations, e.g. P117L, M146L, L286V, and A246E in PS1 and M239I, T122R, and N141I in PS2. The effects of FAD-linked PS mutations on cytosolic Ca(2+) changes have been monitored either by using fura-2 or recombinant cytosolic aequorin as the probe. Independently of the cell model or the employed probe, the cytosolic Ca(2+) increases, caused by agonist stimulation or full store depletion by drug treatment, were reduced or unchanged in cells expressing the PS mutations. Using aequorins, targeted to the endoplasmic reticulum or the Golgi apparatus, we here show that FAD-linked PS mutants lower the Ca(2+) content of intracellular stores. The phenomenon was most prominent in cells expressing PS2 mutants, and was observed also in cells expressing the non-pathogenic, "loss-of-function" PS2-D366A mutation. Taken as a whole, our findings, while confirming the capability of presenilins to modify Ca(2+) homeostasis, suggest a re-evaluation of the "Ca(2+) overload" hypothesis in AD and a new working hypothesis is presented.     

Effect of calcium chelators on the Ca2+-dependent luminescence of aequorin.

The luminescence of aequorin, a useful tool for studying intracellular Ca2+, was recently found to be inhibited by the free EDTA and EGTA that are present in calcium buffers. In the present study we have examined the effect of the free forms of various chelators in the calibration of [Ca2+] with aequorin. Free EDTA and EGTA in low-ionic-strength solutions strongly inhibited the Ca2+-triggered luminescence of aequorin, causing large errors in the calibration of [Ca2+] (approx. 2 pCa units), whereas in solutions containing 150mM-KCl, errors were relatively small (0.2-0.3 pCa units). Citric acid in low-ionic-strength solutions and [(carbamoylmethyl)imino]diacetic acid in high-ionic-strength solutions showed no inhibition and did not cause detectable error in the calibration of [Ca2+], indicating that they are better chelators than EDTA and EGTA for use with aequorin.     

Halistaurin, phialidin and modified forms of aequorin as Ca2+ indicator in biological systems.

Two kinds of aequorin-type photoproteins, i.e., halistaurin and phialidin, and four kinds of modified forms of aequorin, i.e., products of acetylation, ethoxycarbonylation, fluorescamine-modification and fluorescein labelling, were prepared. The modified forms of aequorin were more sensitive to Ca2+ than was aequorin in their Ca2+-triggered luminescence reactions, whereas halistaurin and phialidin were less sensitive. The emission maxima of luminescence were all within a wavelength range 450-464 nm, except for fluorescein-labelled aequorin, which emitted yellowish light (lambda max. 520 nm). A new technique of measuring Ca2+ concentration is suggested.     

The effect of physiologically occurring cations upon aequorin light emission. Determination of the binding constants.

1. The effect of K+, Na+, Mg2+ and pH upon the rate of aequorin utilization has been investigated in the presence of Ca2+. 2. The aequorin light emission in a medium simulating the in vivo cationic conditions for barnacle muscle fibres indicates that two Ca2+ are apparently involved in this process for free calcium concentrations higher than approx. 10(-5) M. However, for free calcium concentrations lower than 10(-6) M, the intensity of light emitted by aequorin shows a steeper dependency upon [Ca2+] than the square low relationship, indicating that a third Ca2+ should be involved in the process of aequorin light emission, as it has been previously predicted (Moisescu, D.G., Ashley, C.C. and Campbell, A.K. (1975) Biochim. Biophys. Acta. 396, 133-140). 3. The inhibitory effect of physiologically occurring cations upon the aequorin light emission can be explained by the cooperative action of two cations, competing with Ca2+ for the reactive sites on aequorin. 4. At a given concentration, Na2+ was found to have a stronger inhibitory effect upon the aequoring light emission than K+. 5. The experiments indicate a strong interaction between Na+ and K+ in this inhibitory process, since for a given total concentration of monovalent cations, a mixture containing both Na+ and K+ has a larger inhibitory effect on the aequorin light response than solutions containing either Na+ or K+ alone. 6. All other interactions between K+, Na+, H+ and Mg2+ appear to be weak. 7. The reaction schemes used for the explanation of these and other published results on aequorin (Moisescu, D.G., Ashley, C.C. and Campbell, A.K. (1975) Biochim. Biophys, Acta 396, 133-140 and Blinks, J.R. (1973) Eur. J. Cardiol. 1, 135-142) are described, and the 'absolute' binding constants of all physiologically occurring cations for aequorin have been determined. 8. Based on these parameters one can make accurate quantitative predictions for the aequoring light response under a variety of ionic conditions, and this suggests that it is possible to determine absolute free calcium concentrations providing that the ionic composition of the solutions is known, and that the relative rate of aequorin utilization is higher than 0.005.     

Expression of Recombinant Aequorin as an Intracellular Calcium Reporter in the Phytopathogenic Fungus Phyllosticta ampelicida

Conidia of Phyllosticta ampelicida germinate only after they have made contact with a substratum. Previous work has shown that external free calcium must be available to the spore for germination to be initiated. Transgenic strains of P. ampelicida expressing apo-aequorin, a calcium-sensitive luminescent protein, were developed to monitor cytoplasmic free Ca(2+) ([Ca(2+)]c). Transformants were verified by PCR and Southern hybridization. Apo-aequorin production was quantified for each of 21 transformants. The transformant that emitted the most light per unit of protein was found to contain 0.59 mg apo-aequorin/g total protein. To ascertain the feasibility of aequorin-based [Ca(2+)]c quantification, [Ca(2+)]c changes were measured in mycelia during various physiologically perturbing treatments: exposure to high concentrations of external Ca(2+), hypoosmotic shock, and mechanical perturbation. This is the first report of a plant pathogenic fungus for which aequorin-based Ca(2+) measurement protocols have been developed.