BCG-induced suppressor cells. I. Demonstration of a macrophage-like suppressor cell that inhibits cytotoxic T cell generation in vitro.

Spleen cells obtained from mice 5 to 40 days after infection with viable BCG organisms (BCG-spleens) were found to be unresponsive in vitro to both mitogenic and alloantigenic stimuli. Moreover, suppressor cells could be demonstrated in the spleens from these infected animals. When spleen cells from BCG-infected mice were added to either syngeneic or allogeneic normal spleen cells, the mixtures neither proliferated nor developed cytotoxic activity when cultured with alloantigen or with concanavalin A (Con A). The development of unresponsiveness post-infection paralleled the onset of suppressive activity. Spleen cells obtained from mice given heat-killed BCG were neither suppressive nor unresponsive. The suppressive activity of BCG-spleen cells was associated with an adherent, phagocytic cell that lacked membrane-associated Thy-1 antigen. Removal of this cell by passage through nylon wool columns resulted in a cell population that was no longer capable of suppression and that responded normally to alloantigen and to Con A. It would thus appear that BCG infection results in the development of a "suppressor" macrophage-like cell population within the spleen. The role of this cell type in regulation of the immune response in BCG-infected animals is as yet undefined.     

Reversal of macrophage-augmented MLR reactivity by tumor-induced splenic suppressor T cells and their soluble factor(s)

Augmenting concentrations of macrophages or their supernatants failed to reverse T-cell hyporeactivity in tumor-bearing mice (TBM). Serial passaging over nylon wool columns depleted TBM spleen cells of a mildly adherent tumor-induced suppressor cell and restored mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) reactivity to the purified TBM T-cell population. The tumor-induced suppressor cell was extensively plated to remove macrophages and characterized as a T cell by its anti-Thy 1 serum sensitivity. This suppressor T cell, when added to normal T cells, abrogated all enhancing effects caused by addition of macrophages. Suppressor T-cell inhibition was non-contact dependent, since suppressor T-cell supernatants inhibited MLR activity in T cells treated with enhancing concentrations of macrophage supernatants. Thus it appears that tumor-induced T-cell debilitation is a reversible phenomenon, mediated not by macrophages but by soluble factor(s) from a nonphagocytic, mildly adherent, suppressor T cell.     

Control of the immune reaction: T cells in immunized mice which depress the in vivo DNA synthesis response in the lymph nodes to skin painting with the contact sensitizing agent picryl chloride.

This paper describes the properties of a suppressor population in immune mice which specifically depresses DNA synthesis in vivo in normal mice. Mice were immunized by painting the skin with the contact sensitizing agent picryl chloride—an agent which causes contact sensitivity and antibody production. Five days later the regional lymph nodes or spleens were taken and injected into normal recipients which were then immunized by painting the skin with the same agent. The injection of the immune cells depressed the DNA synthesis response to picryl chloride in the regional lymph nodes when assessed 4 days later by the incorporation of radioactive iododeoxyuridine. The cells in the transferred population responsible for this depression were T cells as shown by the effect of anti-θ serum, their failure to adhere to nylon wool and antiimmunoglobulin columns and their appearance in the fraction of cells lacking receptors for C3(EAC^? cells) on resetting with sheep cells coated with antibody and complement. The cells were large and their activity was destroyed by 2500 R in vitro. Their production was prevented by treatment with cyclophosphamide before exposure to antigen but was unaffected by adult thymectomy. In these two aspects they differed from the T cells which suppress contact sensitivity which occur in mice injected with picryl sulphonic acid—an agent which causes unresponsiveness.     

Suppressor cells in the spleens of tumor-bearing mice: enrichment by centrifugation on hypaque-ficoll and characterization of the suppressor population.

Spleen cells from mice bearing methylcholanthrene-induced sarcomas or a mammary adenocarcinoma suppressed the mitogen responses of normal spleen and lymph node cells. Lymph node cells from tumor bearers had no suppressive effects. Centrifugation of spleen cells layered on Hypaque-Ficoll (specific gravity of 1.08) produced a dense fraction which pelleted and a light fraction which was retained at the Hypaque-Ficoll-medium interface. Suppressive activity was not found in either fraction of normal spleen cells. In tumor-bearer spleen cells suppressor activity was greatly enriched in the light fraction. Treatment of the suppressor fraction with anti-theta or anti-Ig serum and complement did not remove suppressor activity. However, the suppressor cells were removed by passage through nylon wool or by carbonyl iron treatment. Also, the population which adhered to plastic Petri dishes contained the suppressor cell activity.     

Lymphocyte function in experimental African trypanosomiasis. VIII. Loss of suppressor T cell function in lymph nodes

The immunosuppression that occurs in mice experimentally infected with African trypanosomiasis has been examined further. In the present study we have examined lymph node cells from Trypanosoma rhodesiense-infected C57Bl/6J mice for the ability to produce mitogen induced antigen-nonspecific suppressor T cells (Ts). Inguinal, mesenteric, and brachial lymph node cells were harvested from uninfected control mice and from mice at different periods of infection. These cells were cultured with or without concanavalin A (Con A) for 48 hr to induce Ts activity. After stimulation, the control and infected lymph node cells were passed over Sephadex G-10 columns to remove suppressor macrophages that arise during the infection from Con A-induced Ts. The column passed cells were then added to normal mouse responder spleen cells in a primary in vitro antibody response culture system with sheep erythrocytes (SRBC) as antigen. The resultant plaque-forming cell responses to SRBC indicated that Ts function was not induced in infected lymph node cell populations. However, early in the infection, a stimulatory signal was provided by both the untreated and Con A-treated infected lymph node cells, which was lost in the terminal stage. Determinations of T cell subpopulations revealed that the infected Lyt 2.2-bearing subpopulation was not significantly altered from normal controls. We conclude that T. rhodesense infected mice fail to mount normal lymph node cell antigen nonspecific Ts responses and that this loss of activity may be due to an intrinsic dysfunction in the suppressor T cell population.     

Genetic control of effector cell characteristics: con A-induced suppressor cells carry H-2 I region encoded determinants.

Activation of splenic lymphocytes with Con A leads to the formation of suppressor cells capable of interfering with the activity of several polyclonal B-cell-activating substances. Thus, these suppressor cells, or their products, most probably act directly on B cells. Suppressor cells could be recovered from the effluent cell population of nylon wool columns, and they were absent from the spleens of athymic nude mice. Furthermore, they were absent from the thymus of normal as well as cortison-treated mice. Cortisone treatment did not abolish the formation of Con A-induced suppressor cells in the spleen. Treatment of activated suppressor cells with antisera specific for distinct products of the H-2 I region revealed that they carried I-J cell surface antigens. We conclude that the suppressor cells in our test system, which unlike other Con A-induced suppressor cell populations have a direct effect on B cells, had antigenic characteristics similar to those previously described for I-J carrying suppressor cells.     

Macrophages suppress CTL generation in rat mixed leukocyte cultures.

The generation of CTL in rat MLC was actively suppressed by a cell population present in spleen cell preparations from normal rats. These suppressor cells were characterized by using a variety of cell fractionation techniques. Suppressor cells were removed by passage of spleen cells through nylon wool columns or by treatment with carbonyl iron. Suppressive activity was present in the mononuclear cell fraction of spleen cells obtained by Ficoll-Hypaque density gradient centrifugation. After velocity sedimentation at unit gravity, enrichment of suppressive activity was demonstrated in the fractions containing large cells as compared to the fractions containing small cells. Populations rich in macrophages were shown to have similar suppressive activity upon CTL induction in MLC. These studies suggest that macrophages present in normal rat spleen cell preparations account for the difficulty in generating CTL in MLC prepared with rat cells.     

Transfer of agammaglobulinemia in the chicken. I. Generation of suppressor activity by injection of bursa cells

Spleen cells from adult agammaglobulinemic (bursectomized) chickens taken 1 to 3 weeks after an injection of histocompatible bursa cells can inhibit the adoptive antibody response to B. abortus of normal spleen or bursa cells in irradiated recipients. Spleen cells from Aγ chickens not injected with bursa cells generally do not. Moreover, bursectomized chickens which have been reconstituted with spleen cells within the first week after hatching do not respond with suppressor cell formation upon bursa cell injection. This apparent “autoimmunization” with bursa cells induces suppressor T cells which are only minimally sensitive to treatment with mitomycin C or to 5000 R γ irradiation. The suppressor activity is neither induced nor potentiated by concanavalin A in vivo. It is much stronger in spleen than in thymus cells and appears to be macrophage independent and to require intact cells. The cell component which stimulates the suppressor activity is more pronounced on bursa than on spleen cells, and is at most present to a very limited extent on bone marrow, thymus, or peritoneal exudate cells. It is better represented in comparable cell numbers of Day 17 than of Day 14 embryonic bursa. The inducing cell component is present in the membrane fraction of disrupted bursa cells. Immunization with bursa cells from B locus histoincompatible chickens leads to suppressor activity against histocompatible bursa cells. Although the removal of Ig-bearing cells from bursa greatly diminishes its immunizing capacity, injection of serum IgM and IgG does not induce suppressor cells. It is suggested that tolerance to a B-cell antigen is lacking in adult Aγ chickens, resulting in an autoimmune response upon exposure to B cells. The B-cell antigen may be a cell surface-specific form of Ig, a complex of Ig and a membrane component, or a differentiation antigen which appears simultaneously with Ig during ontogeny.     

Plasmodium chabaudi: Adoptive transfer of immunity with different spleen cell populations and development of protective activity in the serum of lethally irradiated recipient mice

Groups of lethally X-irradiated NIH mice were injected with either glass wool-filtered (g.w.) immune spleen cells or nylon wool enriched immune T cells from syngeneic mice immune to Plasmodium chabaudi, or g.w. normal spleen cells. After cell recipients were infected with P. chabaudi the three groups reached similar mean peak parasitaemias on Day 11. In passive transfer tests serum obtained from mice sacrificed at this time gave little protection compared to normal serum. On Day 14 g.w. immune spleen cell recipients had subpatent infections and enriched immune T-cell recipients had a lower mean parasitaemia than g.w. normal spleen cell recipients. Serum obtained on Day 14 from g.w. immune spleen cell recipients gave better protection after passive transfer than sera from enriched immune T-cell or g.w. normal spleen cell recipients. Day 14 serum from enriched immune T-cell recipients, but not from g.w. normal spleen cell recipients, produced some initial protection after passive transfer. These results suggest that the transferred immune spleen cells contributed to the observed humoral immunity in lethally irradiated recipient mice.     

Properties of ultraviolet light-induced suppressor lymphocytes within a syngeneic tumor system

It has been reported that ultraviolet light (uv) irradiation of normal C3Hf mice generates theta-positive suppressor lymphocytes which, as assayed by adoptive transfer studies, mediates susceptibility to transplanted syngeneic uv-induced tumors. We now report that the cells with suppressor activity can be recovered and enriched for using nylon wool columns. These suppressor cells are found in the nylon nonadherent fraction. Further, while uv irradiated mice are susceptible to supporting the growth of transplanted syngeneic uv tumors long after termination of the uv exposures, adoptively transferred suppression wanes and normal mice exhibit time-dependent recovery.     

Regulation of the immune system by synthetic polynucleotides. VII. Suppression induced by pretreatment with poly A:U.

Pretreatment of mouse spleen cells with polyadenylic-polyuridylic acid complexes (poly A:U) either in vivo or in vitro 24 hr prior to addition of antigen, resulted in a substantial time dependent decrease in anti-SRBC PFC. Enhancement was observed 6 hr after poly A:U, while inhibition did not become evident until 24 hr after pretreatment. Inhibition of the PFC response appeared to result from poly A:U activation of a nylon wool adherent, T suppressor cell, capable of diminishing the response of normal spleen cells exposed to antigen on co-culture.     

Inhibition of adoptive secondary responses by lymphoid cell populations

The ability of normal and tolerant lymphoid cells to inhibit the adoptive secondary response was investigated in order to delineate the influence which the host can exert on a memory cell population as the host recovers from the effects of irradiation. LBN rats were irradiated with 500R whole body X-irradiation, reconstituted with either normal or tolerant lymphoid cells, then they were given immune spleen cells and challenged with soluble antigen (DNP-BGG). Cells capable of suppressing the adoptive secondary responses were shown to possess the following characteristics: 1) in nonimmune donors they were found in the greatest concentration in lymph nodes, followed by spleen and bone marrow and were practically absent in the thymus; 2) their numbers were not increased in donors rendered tolerant by long term treatment with deaggregated DNP-BGG plus cyclophosphamide nor in donors given large doses of DNP-BGG 48 to 72 hr before sacrifice; 3) in animals rendered tolerant by long term antigen treatment alone some enhancement of suppressor function was seen; 4) the suppressor cells could be shown among both glass wool adherent and nonadherent cells and 5) the nonantigen specific suppressor cells did not affect the kinetics of antibody formation nor the affinity of the antibody which was produced. These results are discussed in terms of the nature and source of the suppressor cell populations and their relevance to the control of secondary responses in intact animals.     

Adherent cells (macrophages?) in tumor-bearing mice suppress MLC responses

The spleens of mice bearing transplanted methylcholanthrene (MCA)-induced fibrosarcomas (MCA-1425 and MCA-1460) were shown to contain cells capable of suppressing the generation of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) in mixed leukocyte cultures (MLC). The suppressive activity was first detected 21 days after tumor transplantation. No suppression was seen with lymph node cells taken at the same time as the spleen cells. The cells responsible for the suppressive activity were adherent to nylon wool and plastic dishes and they were not lysed by anti-T-cell serum plus complement. The suppressor cells were phagocytic and were resistant to irradiation (3000 rads) in vitro. Spleen cells from tumor-bearing nude mice were as suppressive as were spleen cells from tumor-bearing conventional mice. We conclude from these findings that T cells were not involved either as inducers or as effectors of the suppression observed, although the responsible adherent cells may have exerted their effect by interacting with a T-suppressor cell population in the MLC mixtures. While spleen cells of tumor-bearing mice were suppressive when added at any time during the first 4 days of a 5-day MLC, they showed no effect on the cytotoxicity of fully differentiated CTL. Indomethacin reversed suppression, suggesting that prostaglandins may have been involved.     

Suppression of responses to cryptococcal antigen in murine cryptococcosis

Subpopulations of spleen cells responsible for responsiveness and unresponsiveness to cryptococcal antigen in vitro were identified. Lymphocytes which responded in lymphocyte transformation (LT) assays were nylon wool nonadherent and theta antigen positive. These lymphocytes required the presence of an accessory cell which could be supplied by normal peritoneal exudate cells. Spleen cells taken from mice which had been infected for 3 to 15 days were tested to determine their ability to respond to cryptococcal antigen in LT assays. A minimal response was detected at the ninth day of infection. The response of infected spleen cells was attributed to a nonadherent lymphocyte. Nonadherent spleen cells of infected animals had enhanced responses after removal of adherent cells and addition of normal peritoneal exudate cells. Suppressor cells were detected in the spleens of infected mice by the 12th day of infection and thereafter. A nonadherent suppressor cell was identified, but indirect evidence suggested that an adherent cell could also be present in infected spleens.     

CD4+ suppressor cells differentially affect the production of IFN-gamma by effector cells of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis

Spleen cells from rats that have recovered from experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) suppress the production of IFN-gamma by effector T cells of EAE in an Ag-specific manner. These postrecovery suppressor cells also inhibit EAE in vivo. Fractionation of the postrecovery suppressor spleen cells on nylon wool and OX-8 coated plates yields a nylon wool-adherent CD4+ suppressor cell population that, when cocultured with effector T cells, suppresses IFN-gamma production by these effector cells. In contrast, the nylon wool-adherent, CD4+ postrecovery suppressor cell population fails to inhibit the production of IL-2 by the effector T cells. In further experiments, the effector T cell population was depleted of CD8+ cells and cocultured with the nylon wool-adherent, CD4+ postrecovery suppressor cells, and the supernatants were assayed for IFN-gamma and IL-2. IFN-gamma production was inhibited in these cultures but IL-2 production was not inhibited. Irradiated effector T cells were cocultured with CD4+ postrecovery suppressor cells, without myelin basic protein, in an effort to determine whether the mechanism of differential lymphokine suppression involved an anti-idiotypic response against effector T cells. No IL-2 was produced, indicating that there was no CD4+ suppressor cell mediated anti-idiotypic response against effector T cells. These studies suggest that the suppressor cell is a nylon wool adherent, CD4+ T cell that functions to down-regulate EAE effector T cells by differential inhibition of lymphokine production.     

An in vitro model for induction of immunologic unresponsiveness to turkey gamma-globulin in primed mouse spleen cells, II. Antigen-specific suppressor cells.

Unresponsiveness induced to turkey γ-globulin (TGG) in cultures of TGG-primed spleen cells by incubation with high concentrations of soluble TGG (sTGG) was shown to involve a state of active suppression. Upon transfer to secondary cultures of primed spleen cells stimulated with an optimal dose of TGG-conjugated erythrocytes, such tolerant spleen cells were able to actively inhibit a secondary plaque-forming cell response to TGG in these cultures. Almost complete inhibition was observed with a tolerant cell to primed cell ratio of as low as 0.1. The suppression was antigen specific in that tolerant spleen cells which were suppressive for the secondary TGG response were unable to inhibit a primary response to sheep erythrocytes. T cells were shown to be required for the suppressor effect, in that (i) suppressor activity could be removed by complement-mediated lysis with an anti-Thy 1.2 antiserum and (ii) suppressor activity was retained in the effluent fraction after passage of suppressor spleen cells over a nylon wool column. Induction of the T-cell suppressor activity was found to be associated with a loss of T-cell helper activity within the TGG-pulsed cell population. The presence of adherent cells was not required for induction of suppressor activity. Furthermore, the suppressor effect was found to be resistant to 1000 R of γ irradiation.     

In vitro generation of suppressor cell activity: suppression of in vitro induction if cell-mediated cytotoxicity.

It was observed that when normal mouse spleen cells were cultured alone in vitro (precultured) for 3 to 7 days, these cells lost the ability to generate cell-mediated cytotoxicity (CML) during subsequent in vitro sensitization with allogeneic spleen cells, trinitrophenyl (TNP)-modified syngeneic spleen cells, or syngeneic tumor cells. These precultured cells, which were themselves unable to generate CML, were also shown in mixing experiments to suppress, actively, the generation of CML by freshly explanted spleen cells. Suppression occurred at the sensitization phase of CML, and not at the effector level; supernatants from suppressive precultured cells were not suppressive. Suppression was totally abrogated by the treatment of spleen cells with a T cell-specific rabbit anti-mouse brain serum and complement (RalphaMB+C) either before or after preculturing, suggesting that a T cell eas essential both to the generation of suppressor activity and to its expression. Suppressor activity was entirely absent in precultured nylon wool column-nonadherent spleen cells, a T cell-enriched population containing most of the RalphaMB+C-sensitive cells in the spleen. Precultured nylon column-adherent cells (T cell-depleted) did have suppressive activity, and a mixture of nylon-adherent and nylon-non-adherent cells was a suppressive after preculture as the precultured unseparated spleen. Moreover, the ability of nylon-adherent spleen cells to generate suppressive activity during preculturing was abrogated by treatment with RalphaMB+C. Thus, the "spontaneous" generation of CML-suppressive activity was dependent upon a limited subpopulation of splenic T cells isolated in the nylon column-adherent fraction. The relationship of these data to a previously described synergy between subpopulations of normal spleen in the generation of CML is discussed, and the findings related to other suppressor systems described in the literature.     

Enhancement by interferon of natural killer cell activity in mice.

Injection of mice with several interferon inducers, Newcastle Disease virus, polyinosinic-polycytidylic acid and tilorone resulted in an increase in spleen cell cytotoxicity for ⁵¹chromium-labeled mouse YAC tumor target cells in 4-hr in vitro assays. This increase in spleen cell cytotoxicity was abrogated by injection of mice with potent anti-mouse interferon globulin. Inoculation of mice with mouse interferon (but not human leucocyte or mock interferon preparations) also resulted in a marked enhancement of spleen cell cytotoxicity. The extent of enhancement of spleen cell cytotoxicity was directly proportional to the amount of interferon injected and a significant increase was observed after inoculation of as little as 10³ to 10⁴ units of interferon. An effect could be detected as soon as 1 hr after injection of interferon. The increase of spleen cell cytotoxicity after inoculation of an interferon inducer was not due to a localization and accumulation of cytotoxic cells in the spleen but reflected a general increase in cytotoxic cell activity in various lymphoid tissues (except the thymus). The splenic cytotoxic cells from interferon or interferon-inducer-injected mice had the characteristics of natural killer (NK) cells since (i) interferon enhanced spleen cell cytotoxicity in athymic (nu/nu) nude mice, (ii) classical spleen cell fractionation procedures by nylon wool columns, anti-Thy 1.2 serum plus complement, anti-Ig columns, and depletion of FcR+ rosette-forming cells, failed to remove the effector cells generated in vivo or in vitro. Therefore like NK cells, interferon-induced cytotoxic cells lack the surface markers of mature T and B lymphocytes, are not adherent, and are devoid of avid Fc receptors. Furthermore like NK cells, the spleen cells from interferon-treated mice lysed various target cells (known for their sensitivity to NK cells) without H-2 or species restriction. Incubation in vitro of normal spleen cells with interferon also resulted in an increase in cytotoxicity for YAC tumor cells. We conclude that interferon acts directly on NK cells and enhances the inherent cytotoxic activity of these cells.     

LPS regulation of the immune response: suppression of immune responses to orally administered T-independent antigen

The regulation of immune responses to gastrically administered TI antigens has been investigated, and the characterization of a regulatory cell population has been performed. Intragastric administration of TNP-haptenated homologous erythrocytes (TNP-MRBC) induced splenic IgM anti-TNP PFC responses in LPS nonresponsive C3H/HeJ mice that were higher than those in LPS-responsive C3H/HeN mice and similar to those noted in athymic (nu/nu) C3H/HeN animals. The simultaneous intragastric administration of LPS with TNP-MRBC augmented immune responses in a manner similar to that previously reported for parenterally administered LPS and antigen. Further, LPS-induced augmentation of TNP-MRBC responses was greater in athymic mice. These findings were substantiated using in vitro spleen cultures. Intragastric challenge with a 2nd TI antigen, TNP-LPS, induced approximately 8-fold higher splenic anti-TNP PFC responses in athymic C3H/HeN mice compared with those in euthymic littermates. By admixture of B and T cell populations, it was demonstrated that the host responsiveness to TNP-LPS was negatively regulated by suppressor cells. Suppressive activity resided in a Thy 1.2-bearing, irradiation-resistant, nylon wool-nonadherent cell population. These cells could be demonstrated in spleen and Peyer's patches from young or old LPS-responsive C3H/HeN mice, but not in tissues from LPS nonresponsive C3H/HeJ mice. The specificity of the regulator cells was not limited to TNP-LPS responses, since immune responsiveness to another TI antigen, TNP-dextran, was also under the control of this cell population. These studies confirm the TI nature of TNP-MRBC and indicate that immune responses to gastrically administered antigens such as TNP-LPS, TNP-dextran, and possibly TNP-MRBC are negatively regulated by a suppressor T cell population. A role for endogenous LPS in the generation of regulator cells and the effect of these cells on host responses to gut-derived antigens is discussed.     

Induction of interferon production in mouse spleen cell cultures by corynebacterium parvum.

Spleen cells of CS7BL/6 mice produced considerable amounts of interferon (IF) in vitro when tested 5 to 20 days after injection of killed Corynebacterium parvum. Interferon was also produced when C. parvum was added in vitro to spleen cell cultures of previously untreated mice. High levels were detected after 1 day of culture with some increment during subsequent days. In a number of experiments IF was also produced in untreated control cultures but only after prolonged cultivation and not after 1 day. The highest levels of IF were usually obtained when spleen cells of C. parvum-treated mice were challenged with additional C. parvum in vitro. The IF induced by C. parvum shared certain physicochemical properties with a tested immune IF and was not neutralized by an antiserum raised against a type I IF. Spleen cells of nu/nu mice and spleen cells treated by anti-θ serum plus complement did not differ from their respective controls, indicating that production of IF did not require mature T lymphocytes. Removal of B lymphocytes by nylon wool columns abolished the capacity of spleen cells to produce IF. When spleen cells were freed of adherent cells by the use of plastic surfaces, they no longer produced IF. Peritoneal exudate macrophages (PEC), which by themselves did not produce IF, in small numbers reconstituted nonadherent spleen cells. Nylon column-treated spleen cells, however, could not be restored by PEC. It is concluded that IF upon challenge with C. parvum is produced by B lymphocytes and requires the help of macrophages.